DOCSLIB.ORG

Predicting and Reducing Springback in Bending of an Aluminum Alloy and Selected

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Predicting and Reducing Springback in Bending of an Aluminum Alloy and Selected Predicting and Reducing Springback in Bending of an Aluminum Alloy and Selected Advanced High Strength Steels (AHSS) THESIS Presented in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Master of Science in the Graduate School of The Ohio State University By Tanmay Gupta Graduate Program in Mechanical Engineering The Ohio State University 2019 Master's Examination Committee: Taylan Altan, Advisor Jerald Brevick Copyrighted by Tanmay Gupta 2019 Abstract Sheet metal forming or stamping is the process of shaping thin sheets of metal into a complex-shaped part. Part quality, which includes forming the part shape without any defects and within the required tolerances of the desired part geometry, is of major concern in the stamping industry. Major defects in sheet metal forming are splitting, wrinkling, and springback. The demand for improved safety and increased fuel efficiency in the automotive industry has led to an increased use of the Advanced High Strength Steels (AHSS) and high strength aluminum alloys. However, these high strength materials tend to exhibit low formability and higher springback compared to the conventional mild steels due to thinner gauges and higher strength. Springback significantly affects the dimensional accuracy of stamped parts and accurate prediction of springback in high strength materials becomes a challenge and necessity in the die design stage to reduce the die-recut costs. Springback occurs after stamping operation is completed and part is unloaded from the tools as a result of the elastic recovery of the deformed material. Material model defined in the finite element simulation affects the springback predicted after unloading the tools. Current mathematical models for springback prediction are complex and require material parameters which are costly and tedious to determine. Young’s modulus is one of the most significant parameter affecting the springback prediction. However, the accurate determination of E-modulus is a challenge due to its variation with plastic strain and non-linear elastic unloading behavior ii in AHSS. This study aims to develop a pragmatic approach for accurate determination of E-modulus variation with strain using in-house 4-point bending tests combined with the inverse analysis approach using commercial finite element codes (AutoForm and DEFORM). A similar approach done using wipe bending tests is also reviewed in this study and results from both the methods are compared and applied to real production part. Use of post-stretching to reduce springback is also investigated in the latter half of the study. Post-stretching using a variable blank holder force achieved via a servo hydraulic cushion to reduce springback and residual stresses in aluminum alloy is studied both experimentally and numerically. Finally, post-stretching using concept of “stake beads” is investigated numerically using AutoForm to see the effect of geometrical design of the beads on the forming forces and springback of the part. iii Acknowledgments I would like to thank my advisor, Dr. Taylan Altan, for providing me with continuous encouragement, support and inspiration. I am also grateful to Dr. Brevick for serving as member of my thesis committee. I wish to thank the sponsors of the following research: GM, Bowman, Hyson and the other CPF member companies, as well as all of the personnel of those companies which assisted me. I also thankful to my fellow colleagues at the Center for Precision Forming (CPF) – Ali Fallahiarezoodar, David Diaz-Infante Hernandez, Advaith Narayanan, Cliff Goertemiller Berk Aykas, Hitansh Singhal, Esmeray Ustunyagiz, and, Saul Hernandez for their assistance in my work. I also greatly appreciate Ms. Linda Anastasi for her administrative support. Lastly, I would like to thank my parents, for their enormous support and love throughout my journey. iv Vita 2012................................................................High School, Delhi Public School, Faridabad 2017................................................................B.E. (Hons.) Mechanical Engineering, BITS Pilani, Goa 2017................................................................M.Sc. (Hons.) Chemistry, BITS Pilani, Goa 2017 to present ..............................................Graduate Research Associate, Center for Precision Forming, The Ohio State University Publications 1. Tanmay Gupta, Ali Fallahiarezoodar, Ethan Mclaughlin, Dr. Taylan Altan (2018), R&D Update: Reducing springback in hat-shape bending with variable BHF using a servo-hydraulic cushion, Stamping Journal March/April 2018, Pg. 16-17 2. Tanmay Gupta, Ali Fallahiarezoodar, Dr. Taylan Altan (2018), R&D Update: Reducing springback using post-stretching with stake beads, Stamping Journal May/June 2018, Pg. 20-22 3. Fallahiarezoodar, A., Gupta, T., Goertemiller, C., & Altan, T. (2019). Residual stresses and springback reduction in U-channel drawing of Al5182-O by using a servo press and a servo hydraulic cushion. Production Engineering, 1-8. v Fields of Study Major Field: Mechanical Engineering vi Table of Contents Abstract ............................................................................................................................... ii Acknowledgments.............................................................................................................. iv Vita ...................................................................................................................................... v Publications ......................................................................................................................... v Fields of Study ................................................................................................................... vi Table of Contents .............................................................................................................. vii List of Tables .................................................................................................................... xii List of Figures .................................................................................................................. xiii Chapter 1: Introduction ...................................................................................................... 1 Background ..................................................................................................................... 1 Material Properties .......................................................................................................... 2 Bending ........................................................................................................................... 4 Springback ....................................................................................................................... 6 Chapter 2: Objective and Outline ....................................................................................... 8 Chapter 3: Review on determination of material properties and formability ..................... 9 Introduction ..................................................................................................................... 9 Tensile test..................................................................................................................... 10 vii Biaxial Bulge test .......................................................................................................... 14 Combined – tensile and bulge test - method for obtaining accurate flow stress data ... 16 Frictionless dome test .................................................................................................... 17 Chapter 4: Mechanics and Springback in Bending – A literature review ......................... 21 Introduction ................................................................................................................... 21 Fundamentals of bending and springback ..................................................................... 22 Mechanical properties affecting springback ................................................................. 25 Effect of Stress-strain data and Constitutive model on springback prediction ............. 26 Isotropic Hardening (IH) ............................................................................................... 28 Kinematic Hardening (KH) ........................................................................................... 30 Combined Isotropic and Kinematic Hardening (IH+KH) ............................................. 31 Effect of E-modulus ...................................................................................................... 33 Chapter 5: Effect of E-modulus Variation on Springback, Inverse Analysis Method and The Wipe Bending Test – A Review ................................................................................ 34 Introduction ................................................................................................................... 34 Effect of E-modulus on springback prediction ............................................................. 35 Nonlinear elastic unloading behavior ............................................................................ 37 Variation of elastic unloading modulus with plastic strain ........................................... 38 Strain path dependency of elastic unloading modulus .................................................. 39 viii Inverse analysis method for determination of an apparent E-modulus ......................... 39 Review on determination of
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Sheet Metal Operations - Bending and Related Processes
    Sheet metal operations - Bending and related processes R. Chandramouli Associate Dean-Research SASTRA University, Thanjavur-613 401 Table of Contents 1.Quiz-Key ........................................ Error! Bookmark not defined. 1.Bending and related processes: 1.1 Sheet metal bending Bending of sheets and plates is widely used in forming parts such as corrugations, flanges, etc. Bending is a forming operation in which a sheet metal is subjected to bending stress thereby a flat straight sheet is made into a curved sheet. The sheet gets plastically deformed without change in thickness. Die and punch are used for bending. If a v shaped die and punch are used, the bending is called v-bending. If the sheet is bent on the edge using a wiping die it is called edge bending. In this process, one end of the sheet is held like a cantilever using a pressure pad and the other end is deformed by a punch which moves vertically down, bending the sheet. Usually, edge bending is done in order to obtain an angle of 90o. During bending of a strip, the material outward of the neutral axis is subjected to tensile stress. Material inside is subjected to compressive stress. Bend radius R is the radius of curvature of the bent sheet inside the bending. The neutral axis remains at the center of the thickness of the sheet for elastic bending. For plastic bending, however, the neutral axis shifts towards the inside of the bend. The rate of elongation of outer fibers is greater than the rate of contraction of inner fibers. Therefore, there is a thickness reduction at the bend section.
    [Show full text]
  • Design of an Electrically Powered Bending Machine
    Proceedings of the International Conference on Industrial Engineering and Operations Management Rabat, Morocco, April 11-13, 2017 Design of an electrically powered bending machine: Case of Zimbabwe Tawanda Mushiri Department of Mechanical Engineering University of Johannesburg P.O Box APK 524 Johannesburg South Africa [email protected], [email protected] Definite Shumba Department of Mechanical Engineering University of Zimbabwe P.O Box MP167 Mt Pleasant Harare Zimbabwe [email protected] Charles Mbohwa Faculty of Engineering and the Built Environment University of Johannesburg P.O Box APK 524 Johannesburg South Africa [email protected] Abstract This paper seeks to carry out design of a small scale electrically powered bending machine for a developing nation, case for Zimbabwe. The bending of metal is of great importance in the manufacture of products such as nut shelling machines and maize shelling machines. Currently being used at Company X engineering is a manual bending machine with a single operation hence this design will help to increase the number of metals being bent, an increase in the efficiency and production. The paper deals with manufacturing or bending of sheet metal by using power operated sheet bending machine. Especially discussion made the productivity analysis of manually or power operated sheet bending machine. Considering manual operation is replaced by power operated devices. It also gives information about limitation of manually operated sheet bending machine and power operated sheet bending machine. The existing machines are limited to a single operation. The aim of the research is to increase the number of bent parts and to place an adjustable table to suit the height of the user thereby reducing back pain internal injuries in the long run.
    [Show full text]
  • PRESS BRAKE CAPACITIES SPRINGBACK a True 90° Air Bend, the Tooling Must Formed Flanges and Causing Distortion
    www.e-ci.com 1 CONTENTS 2 Safety 2 Bending on a CI Press Brake 8 Press Brake Bending Capacity 9 Mild Steel Air Bend Capacity Chart 13 Bending Factors Chart 17 Punching on a Press Brake SAFETY Good safety practices and proper training of each press brake operator is mandatory. Comprehensive operator, maintenance and safety manuals provide instruction on proper procedures and safety methods and BENDING ON A CINCINNATI should be with the press brake at all times. Warning signs and a checklist PRESS BRAKE of operator safety guidelines should be placed at strategic locations on PRESS BRAKE RATING For thicker than 1/2” mild steel, it may the press brake. be necessary to increase the vee die All CINCINNATI press brakes are opening up to ten times the material Users are responsible for proper rated for maximum bending pressure, thickness to minimize cracking of the installation and continued use of or tonnage. Tonnage can then be material. To determine the vee opening point-of-operation safeguarding converted into bending capacities for a simple 90° bend, multiply the and other machine guards. This through an understanding of basic metal thickness by eight. The answer helps assure operator safety factors affecting the formability of is then rounded to the next higher 1/8” and compliance with OSHA metal. Bending factors, or “rules of figure. For example: 14ga. (.075”) x 8 requirements. thumb,” for press brake forming are = .600”. This is rounded to a 5/8” vee based on using mild steel (60,000 Each new CINCINNATI press opening. psi maximum tensile strength).
    [Show full text]
  • Springback Analysis for Warm Bending of Titanium Tube Based on Coupled Thermal-Mechanical Simulation
    materials Article Springback Analysis for Warm Bending of Titanium Tube Based on Coupled Thermal-Mechanical Simulation Guangjun Li 1,*, Zirui He 1, Jun Ma 2 , Heng Yang 2 and Heng Li 2,* 1 Chengdu Aircraft Industry (Group) Co., Ltd., Chengdu 610092, China; [email protected] 2 State Key Laboratory of Solidification Processing, School of Materials Science and Engineering, Northwestern Polytechnical University, Xi’an 710072, China; [email protected] (J.M.); [email protected] (H.Y.) * Correspondence: [email protected] (G.L.); [email protected] (H.L.) Abstract: Titanium bent tubular parts attract extensive applications, thus meeting the ever-growing demands for light weight, high reliability, and long service life, etc. To improve bending limit and forming quality, local-heat-assisted bending has been developed. However, significant springback seriously reduces the dimensional accuracy of the bent tubular parts even under elevated forming temperatures, and coupled thermal-mechanical working conditions make springback behavior more complex and difficult to control in warm bending of titanium tubular materials. In this paper, using warm bending of thin-walled commercial pure titanium tube as a case, a coupled thermal-mechanical finite element model of through-process heating-bending-unloading is constructed and verified, for predicting the springback behavior in warm bending. Based on the model, the time-dependent evolutions of springback angle and residual stress distribution during thermal-mechanical unloading are studied. In addition, the influences of forming temperature and bending angle on springback angle, thickness variation, and cross-section flattening of bent tubes are clarified. This research Citation: Li, G.; He, Z.; Ma, J.; Yang, provides a fundamental understanding of the thermal-mechanical-affected springback behavior H.; Li, H.
    [Show full text]
  • Forming Methods
    theartofpressbrake.com http://www.theartofpressbrake.com/wordpress/?page_id=1023 Forming Methods Bend Allowance, Outside Setback, Bend Deduction If you calculate these with precision, you have a better chance of bending a good part on the first try. But, to make this happen, you need to make sure every factor in the equation is what it should be, and this includes the inside bend radius . How exactly is this inside bend radius achieved? To uncover this, we must first look at the different methods of bending on a press brake: air forming, bottom bending, and coining. The Methods of bending There are three different types of bending methods used in the forming of sheet metal: “ air forming“, “Bottom Bending and “Coining. Each of these methods has a specific purpose and application. In this chapter the benefits and the inefficiencies of each will be discussed. Coining Note that there are three bending methods, not two. Bottom bending and coining often are confused for the same process, but they are not. Unlike bottoming, coining actually penetrates and thins the material. Coining is the oldest method and for the most part, no longer practiced. Why? Because of the extreme tonnages this method requires. An amount of tonnage so great that the material “flows” on a molecular level while under this extreme pressure. Coining forces the punch nose into the material, penetrating the neutral axis, figure 1. Technically, any radius may be coined, but traditionally, coining has been used to establish a dead-sharp bend. This method not only requires excessive tonnages, it also destroys the material’s integrity.
    [Show full text]
  • Acute and Hem Bending
    theartofpressbrake.com http://www.theartofpressbrake.com/wordpress/?page_id=1037 Acute and hem bending Acute Bend Angle Tools Acute bend tools are used to achieve bend angles that are greater than 90° and are the first step in hemming or seaming. Acute tooling, comes in two basic angles: 30° and 45°. Figure 1 shows an example of an acute punch and die set. Acute tooling can only be used for air forming; bottom bending and coining operations cannot be accomplished because the angle tool cannot withstand the side loading forces. Die width selection for the acute bends is the same as any other. You will be air forming so the radius is based on the 20% rule, so you simply ignore the fact that these tools are not at 90° and continue the calculations as before. True, the answers would be slightly different if the correct die angles are used in the calculations, but due to a limited selection of die widths, the angle makes little difference while making the math easy. But, ultimately you have to pick between die width A and die width B. Figure 1 The standard acute punches measure 43° and 28° and are mated to 45°and 30° dies. One major thing that does change with die angle is the minimum flange length. An acute die requires a greater minimum flange length than a standard 90° V-die. Figure 2 illustrates the differences in minimum flange length; both of the illustrations are of the same die width but with Figure 2 different die angles. Table 1 shows the minimum allowable die width to flange length for acute tooling.
    [Show full text]
  • Hemming with Pre-Bent Inner Sheet for Joining Ultra-High Strength Steel Sheets of Automobile Parts
    Journal of Manufacturing and Materials Processing Communication Hemming with Pre-Bent Inner Sheet for Joining Ultra-High Strength Steel Sheets of Automobile Parts Yohei Abe * , Wataru Ijichi, Ken-ichiro Mori and Kazuma Nakagawa Faculty of Engineering, Toyohashi University of Technology, 1-1 Tempaku-cho, Toyohashi, Aichi 441-8580, Japan; [email protected] (W.I.); [email protected] (K.-i.M.); [email protected] (K.N.) * Correspondence: [email protected]; Tel.: +81-532-44-6705 Received: 29 June 2020; Accepted: 23 July 2020; Published: 25 July 2020 Abstract: In order to join two ultra-high strength steel sheets with low ductility for automobile parts, a joining process by hemming with a pre-bent inner sheet was developed. In this joining, the pre-bent inner sheet instead of the conventional flat inner sheet was used to relax the deformation concentration of the outer sheet. Although 780 MPa steel sheets were joined without the pre-bent inner sheet, a fracture in the outer sheet occurred in joining the 980 MPa sheets due to the low ductility of the sheets. The 980 MPa and 1180 MPa sheets were successfully joined by hemming with the pre-bent inner sheet. In this process, the deformation of the upper sheet was relaxed by contacting with the inner sheet, and then the strain on the outer surface reduced. Although softening around a weld nugget occurred by heating in the conventional welded joint, work-hardening occurred in the hemmed joint. The joint strength was investigated and then the peel strength of the hemmed sheets was about a half of the welded one.
    [Show full text]
  • SHEET METAL PROCESSES BENDING Bending Is One
    SHEET METAL PROCESSES BENDING Bending is one very common sheet metal forming operation used not only to form shapes like seams, corrugations, and flanges but also to provide stiffness to the part (by increasing its moment of inertia). As a sheet metal is bent (Fig 6.1), its fibres experience a distortion such that those nearer its outside, convex surface are forced to stretch and come in tension, while the inner fibres come in compression. Somewhere, in the cross section, there is a plane which separates the tension and compression zones. This plane is parallel to the surface around which the sheet is bending, and is called neutral axis. The position of neutral axis depends on the radius and angle of bend. Further, because of the Poisson's ratio, the width of the part L in the outer region is smaller, and in the inner region it is larger, than the initial original width. Fig 6.1 Sheet metal bending. It may be noted that the bend radius is measured to the inner surface of the bent part. BEND ALLOWANCE It is the length of the neutral axis in the bend, Fig 6.1. This determines the blank length needed for a bent part. It can be approximately estimated from the relation Lb = a ( R + kt ) where, Lb = bend allowance (mm) a = bend angle (radian) R = bend radius (mm) t = thickness of sheet (mm), and k = constant, whose value may be taken as 1/3 when R < 2t, and as 1/2 when R ³ 2t. Example : A 20 mm wide and 4 mm thick C 20 steel sheet is required to be bent at 600 at bend radius 10 mm.
    [Show full text]
  • Reduce Unwanted Sheet Marking
    MARK-FREE SOLUTIONS FOR BENDING REDUCE UNWANTED SHEET MARKING Wilson Tool International offers numerous solutions to help press brake operators reduce or eliminate sheet marking during bending operations. Urethane dies, holders, pads and drapes form a protective barrier that impedes the metal-on-metal scraping that often happens during bending. The protective fabric drape is a lightweight and flexible alternative to urethane that also provides a barrier to prevent scratching. V-series dies use a rotating action that causes much less friction than typical V dies, resulting in reduced part marking. Urethane products available from Wilson Tool include: • Urethane Dies These dies greatly reduce and, in some cases, completely eliminate sheet marking on the press brake. They are available in the most common profiles from the American and European tool style collections. • Urethane Holders and Pads Wilson Tool’s urethane holders are manufactured from 6061-T6 aluminum and hold a pad of urethane for mark free and radius bending. Two pad hardness options are available: Blue/90A is most commonly used and Red/80A helps reduce tonnage in the application by approximately 20%. • Pr otective Coverings Urethane drapes provide a protective layer across the top of your standard dies to virtually eliminate sheet marking. Our standard roll of urethane is offered in two thicknesses (.015" and .030") to fit your application. Our high density urethane offering is .022" thick, lasting significantly longer than standard urethane. URETHANE DRAPES CAT. NO. DESCRIPTION DIMENSIONS COLOR 42530 Standard .015" [.4mm] x 6" [152mm] White 42531 Standard .03" [.8mm] x 6" [152mm] White 42532 High Density .022" [.6mm] x 6" [152mm] Blue See the back page for Wilson Tool’s easy to use Protective Fabric Drape option.
    [Show full text]
  • INTRODUCTION to PRESS BRAKES a Vital Piece of Shop Equipment Introduction to Press Brakes
    INTRODUCTION TO PRESS BRAKES A Vital Piece of Shop Equipment Introduction to Press Brakes Press Brakes are utilized in the forming lengths of sheet metal components. A press brake is a vital necessity to most shops with shape cutting capabilities and is one of the most sought after and misunderstood machines available for sheet metal working. Press Brakes are rated generally by their pressing capacity, or tonnage, and their overall bending length or machine width such as 175X10 (175 Tons of pressing force by 10’ of overall length). The press brake may be fitted with a wide variety of standard and custom tooling that are used to press the material into the desired form. There are two major types of press brakes available on the used market as are described below. Mechanical A motor spins a large flywheel at high speed the A mechanical press brake is a good solution for operator then engages a clutch which can be punching applications as the shock of punching activated via pneumatic, hydraulic or mechanical material is distributed much easier due to the engagement. Once the clutch is engaged the machines design. The major disadvantages to moving flywheel is mated to a crankshaft in which mechanical press brakes is that the ram must the machines ram is attached. The crankshaft complete a full cycle, or stroke, and typically then spins cycling the ram up and down. The cannot be reversed during operation. This poses advantage to this type of press brake is that the some safety concerns and operational limitations machine is electronically simpler and, due to the as well as provides for the possibility that the crankshaft action tonnages are generally 2-3X press brake can be “locked” into an over stroke the rated capacity of the press brake at the situation where the ram has traveled too far bottom of the machines stroke.
    [Show full text]
  • Analysis of Springback Variation in V Bending
    Published by : International Journal of Engineering Research & Technology (IJERT) http://www.ijert.org ISSN: 2278-0181 Vol. 5 Issue 02, February-2016 Analysis of Springback Variation in V Bending Bhav Gautam* Praveen Kumar Vaibhav Chandra Kamal Rawat B. Tech Tool Asst. Professor Asst. Professor M.Tech Tool Engineering Engineering D.I.T.E Campus II D.I.T.E Campus II D.I.T.E Campus II D.I.T.E Campus II New Delhi, India New Delhi, India New Delhi, India New Delhi, India Abstract— In order to get exact shape and size of components in the total deformation only plastic deformation is responsible sheet metal manufacturing, springback effect plays a pivotal for the exact shape and size of the components. role. Prediction of springback angle helps in determining the amount of over-bend (i.e. springback compensation) required so that exact V bend angle can be obtained in the component. In this study an attempt has been done to analyze the springback effect for simple V-bending operation performed on CRDQ (Cold Rolled Draw Quality) with thickness of sheet varying from 2.0 to 4.0 mm. In this work Hyperform software is used for simulating the springback effect in V bending operation. The main objective is to get the variation of amount of springback for different thickness of sheets keeping bending angle (600) and punch radius (2mm) constant. The results showed that the value of springback decreases with the increase in sheet thickness (from 2 mm) up till 3.3 mm. Further increase in sheet thickness, Fig.1: Graph showing the two zones in the stress-strain curve from 3.3 mm to 4.0 mm, increases the amount of springback for V-bending of CRDQ sheet.
    [Show full text]
  • “Sheet Metal Bending Machine”
    NOVATEUR PUBLICATIONS INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF INNOVATIONS IN ENGINEERING RESEARCH AND TECHNOLOGY [IJIERT] ISSN: 2394-3696 VOLUME 2, ISSUE 3, March.-2015 “SHEET METAL BENDING MACHINE” Aniruddha Kulkarni Mangesh Pawar Pravin Yadav Amit Patil Sohan Jagtap Department of Mechanical Engineering, A.I.T.R.C. Vita. Prof. Sujit Malgave Department of Mechanical Engineering, A.I.T.R.C. Vita. ABSTRACT The paper deals with manufacturing or bending of sheet metal by using power operated sheet bending machine. Especially discussion made the productivity analysis of manually or power operated sheet bending machine. Considering manual operation is replaced by power operated devices .It also gives information about limitation of manually operated sheet bending machine and power operated sheet bending machine. Key Words: Shape, Bending, Cylindrical, Automatic, Hoppers, Frame, Fabrication, Production INTRODUCTION Sheet metal fabrication plays an important role in the metal manufacturing world. Sheet metal is used in the production of materials ranging from tools, to hinges, automobiles etc. Sheet metal fabrication ranges from deep drawing, stamping, forming, and hydro forming, to high-energy-rate forming (HERF) to create desired shapes. Fascinating and elegant shapes may be folded from a single plane sheet of material without stretching, tearing or cutting, if shape rolling of sheet metal is the bending continually of the piece along a linear axis. This causes alteration of the original form of the sheet as it passes through a pathway of series of rollers. The present invention relates to plate bending machines of the type which operates with rolls. Such machines involve certain well-known difficulties in respect of bending plates into conical shape.
    [Show full text]