Turkish Journal of Trauma & Emergency Surgery Ulus Travma Acil Cerrahi Derg 2009;15(2):130-134 Original Article Klinik Çal›flma Injuries from bear (Ursus thibetanus) attacks in Kashmir Kaflmir’de ay› (Ursus thibetanus) sald›r›lar›ndan kaynaklanan yaralanmalar Shafaat Rashid TAK, Gh Nabi DAR, Manzoor Ahmed HALWAI, Bashir Ahmed MIR BACKGROUND AMAÇ Strict conservation of wildlife and encroachment into its habi- Kaflmir eyaletinde vahfli yaflam›n ve vahfli yaflamsal alanlara tat have led to an increase in the number of wild animal- tecavüzün s›k› bir flekilde korunmas›, vahfli hayvan kaynakl› inflicted injuries and fatalities in Kashmir. The aim of this yaralanmalarda ve ölümlerde bir art›fla yol açm›flt›r. Bu yaz›- study was to report injuries inflicted during bear attacks and da, ay› sald›r›lar›ndan kaynaklanan yaralanmalar ve sekellerin discuss their management and sequelae. tedavisindeki düzenlemeler de¤erlendirildi. METHODS GEREÇ VE YÖNTEM A retrospective study was conducted in the Department of Ocak 2003 ile Haziran 2007 tarihleri aras›nda, Kaflmir Orthopedics Government Medical College Srinagar, Üniversitesi Srinagar Devlet T›p F a k ü l t e s i , Ortopedi ve University of Kashmir, from January 2003 to June 2007. A Travmatoloji Bölümü’nde retrospektif bir çal›flma yürütüldü; total of 254 cases (186 males, 68 females) with history of bear 54 ayl›k bir sürede, ay› sald›r›s› hikayesi bulunan toplam 254 attacks were recorded over a period of 54 months. olgu (186 erkek, 68 kad›n) kaydedildi. RESULTS BULGULAR Eighty percent of victims were attacked in the maize fields Kurbanlar›n %80’inin m›s›r tarlalar› ile elma bahçelerinde ve and apple orchards and 20% in the dense forests while collect- %20’sinin de s›k ormanl›k alanda odun toplarken veya s›¤›r ing firewood or tending to the cattle. Lacerations of the head otlat›rken sald›r›ya u¤rad›¤› ö¤renildi. Bafl-boyunda laseras- and neck and fractures of the upper limbs and facial and skull yonlar, üst ekstremite k›r›klar›, yüz ve kafatas› kemi¤i k›r›kla- bones were the striking observations. Permanent facial disfig- r› dikkat çeken gözlemlerdi. Hastalar›n ço¤undaki uzun süreli urement, hearing loss, loss of digits, residual neurodeficit, and sekeller flöyleydi: Kal›c› yüz flekil bozuklu¤u, iflitme kayb›, persistent psychological morbidity were the long-term seque- parmak kayb›, kalıcı nörolojik bozukluk ve süre¤en psikolojik lae in most of the patients. morbidite. CONCLUSION SONUÇ Wild animal-inflicted injuries are a neglected part of trauma. Vahfli hayvan kaynakl› yaralanmalar, travman›n ihmal edilen There should be a high index of suspicion when treating these bir konusudur. Altta yatan ciddi kemik veya yumuflak doku injuries, as serious underlying bone or soft-tissue damage can hasar›n›n gözden kaç›r›labilece¤i gerekçesiyle, bu yaralan- be overlooked. Management of these injuries involves all malar tedavi edilirken kuflku düzeyi yüksek tutulmal›d›r. En subspecialties of trauma to achieve the best functional out- iyi fonksiyonel sonucu elde etmek üzere, bu yaralanmalar›n c o m e . tedavisi travman›n tüm alt uzmanl›k dallar›n› kapsamaktad›r. Key Words: Animals; animal injuries; bear; facial injuries; manage- Anahtar Sözcükler: Hayvanlar; hayvan yaralamalar›; ay ›; yüz ment; outcome. yaralanmas›; tedavi; sonuç. Department of Orthopaedics, Government Medical College Srinagar, Kaflmir Üniversitesi, Srinagar Devlet T›p Koleji, University of Kashmir, Kashmir, India. Ortopedi ve Travmatoloji Bölümü, Kaflmir, Hindistan. Correspondence (‹letiflim): Shafaat Rashid Tak, M.D. Bone and Joint Surgery Hospital Barzulla Srinagar, India 19000 Srinagar, I n d i a . Tel: +091-9419005535 Fax ( F a k s ): +09 1 - 0194243730 e-m a i l ( e -p o s t a) : s h a f a a t r a s h i d @ g m a i l . c o m 130 Injuries from bear (Ursus thibetanus) attacks in Kashmir The alarming increase in the incidence of wild to June 2007 with history of injury from bear attacks animal-inflicted injuries in the recent past in were reviewed. The records of these victims were Kashmir has led to many mortalities and serious also reviewed in the Wildlife Protection Department morbidity. The steadily increasing human population of Jammu and Kashmir. The results were formulated in areas in close proximity to the jungle and the after combining the information collected from these reduction in the staple food of wild animals have two different sources. forced these dangerous predators to move into areas occupied by humans. Animal bites are encountered RESULTS frequently in trauma centers and the resulting A total of 254 cases were recorded over a period injuries range from innocuous to life-threatening.[1] of 54 months. There were 186 (71.7%) males and 68 These injuries are distinct from other injuries sus- (28.3%) females, including 16 children (Table 1). tained by humans, such as tearing, cutting, penetrat- Two hundred and three (80%) victims were attacked ing and crushing injuries combined with falls and in the maize fields and apple orchards; only 51 large animal forces causing blunt trauma.[2] These (20%) victims were attacked in the dense forests. injuries are complex and their management involves Deep lacerations to the scalp, face and trunk were a multidisciplinary approach. Many animal attacks the most common findings, affecting 163 (64%) occur in remote areas with substantial delay before patients. Upper limb (24%) and facial (19%) and notification, rescue and presentation for definitive skull bone (18%) fractures were a striking observa- care.[2] Several factors need to be considered when tion. Hearing loss, intracranial bleed and fractures of evaluating these injuries, including type of animal the ribs were seen in 12.%, 6% and 4.7% of patients, involved, specific nature and location of wounds, respectively. Avulsion of tendons and nerves of the circumstances of attack, and interval between injury forearm and hand was seen in 28% of patients. and treatment. Of great concern are direct destruc- Injuries to the eyes and external ears were less com- [1] tion of tissue and risk of infection. There should be mon (Table 2). Long-term sequelae in most of the a high index of suspicion when treating these patients were permanent facial disfigurement injuries, as serious underlying bone or soft-tissue (10.6%) (Fig. 1), loss of digits (4.3%), hearing loss damage can be overlooked. (12.5%) and stiffness of the joints (21.5%). Residual The actual incidence of these injuries is not only neurodeficit (1.9%) and persistent psychological difficult but also impossible to know, as most of the morbidity were seen in some patients (Table 3). casualties never seek medical attention. Dog bites There were two mortalities. One was due to massive are reported to constitute about 50%-90% of all ani- mal-inflicted injuries,[1-4] but in Kashmir, victims of Table 1. Sex distribution of the victims bear and leopard attacks constitute the majority of Sex No. of victims No. of children the patients requiring medical attention.[5] The vic- tims of bear attacks sustain complex fractures of the Males 186 (71.7%) 9 extremities and disfiguring injuries to the face, but Females 68 (28.3%) 7 fortunately few people die in these attacks. No reports in the literature have presented a sizable Table 2. Injury pattern series of injuries from bear attacks in Kashmir. Total number of patients 254 The aim of this paper was to report a sizable Deep lacerations to the scalp, face and trunk 163 (64%) series of bear-inflicted injuries and discuss their Upper limb fractures 61 (24%) management and complications. Lower limb fractures 8 (3%) Rib fractures 12 (4.7%) MATERIALS AND METHODS Skull fractures 46 (18%) A retrospective study was conducted in the Facial bone fractures 49 (19%) Department of Orthopedics Government Medical Intracranial hemorrhage 16 (6%) College Srinagar of the University of Kashmir. This External ear injuries 5 (2%) is one of the prestigious tertiary care trauma and Internal ear injuries 32 (12.5%) research centers of India, catering to a population of Eye evisceration 2 (0.8%) five million. The case histories of all the patients Femoral vessel injury 1 (0.4%) who presented to this institution from January 2003 Tendon and nerve avulsions 71 (28%) Cilt - Vol. 15 Say› - No. 2 131 Ulus Travma Acil Cerrahi Derg Table 3. Sequelae of injuries Number of patients 131 / 254 Disfigurement of face 27 (10.6%) Fig. 1. Severe lacera- Residual neurodeficit 5 (1.9%) tions to the face and Hearing loss 32 (12.5%) avulsion of the maxil- Stiffness of joints 54 (21.5%) la leading to perma- Loss of eye 2 (0.8%) nent disfigurement of Partial amputations of limbs 11 (4.3%) the face. intracranial hemorrhage and delayed presentation for eye was done in two patients who had complete per- definitive care; the second case did not receive the foration of globe (Fig. 3 ) . In patients with tetanus prophylaxis and medical care in a timely metacarpal fractures and tendon lacerations, stiffness manner and died later of tetanus. of hand persisted after completion of treatment. Tables 1, 2 and 3 present the sex distribution, injury The survivors were admitted and treated as per pattern and the sequelae among the survivors. the Advanced Life Trauma Support with an average follow-up of 24.5 months (5-42 months). Copious DISCUSSION irrigation and debridement of the wounds was done Among the injuries sustained by man, road traffic immediately. A combination of parenteral antibiotics accidents, fall from heights, firearm injuries, and (cephalosporin, amino glycoside and fluoro- mass disasters have been the focus of most reports. quinolone) was started and modified according to Wild animal-inflicted injuries are thought to be rare the culture sensitivity.