Turning on the Taps
Utilities / Asia ex Japan 15 February 2012
China Water Sector Initiation: turning on the taps
• Water industry is entering the next phase in which tariff hikes, consolidation and new technologies will improve earnings quality • Despite slowing project growth, investors should see relief with earnings visibility improving and cash flow reaching inflection • Balancing catalysts and risks, in the new phase, our order of stock
preference is: CEI, GDI, Hyflux and BEW How do we justify our view?
1) accounts receivable risks associated than peers) given increasing with local governments’ financial recurring cash flow generated from situations, 2) companies’ financing operating projects. While project ability to win new projects, and 3) additions would be favourable, we
some water companies’ increasing prefer build-operate-transfer (BOT) Jackie Jiang emphasis on build-transfer (BT) and transfer-operate-transfer (TOT) (852) 2848 4994 [email protected] projects, which could raise earnings projects to BT ones. Medium term, volatility due to accounting treatment. government-backed companies (CEI, Dave Dai, CFA GDI and BEW) could increase their (852) 2848 4068 [email protected] Our analysis suggests that China market shares via consolidation. Everbright International (CEI) has the Gary Zhou most attractive risk-reward profile, Valuation (852) 2773 8535 [email protected] followed by Guangdong Investment CEI and Hyflux are trading currently (GDI), Hyflux, and Beijing Enterprises below their past-5-year average PERs, Water (BEW). We also like CEI’s while GDI is trading in line and BEW Investment case leading position in waste-to-energy at a premium. BEW’s valuation looks The China Water Sector has raised (WTE), which offers more attractive unjustified to us, with its earnings concerns among many investors in the returns than water projects. risks not yet priced in. past due to: 1) lumpy earnings recognition, 2) negative operating We initiate coverage with a Positive Risks cash flow, and 3) less attractive sector rating. CEI is our top pick (Buy Investment risks are a slowdown in returns than other utilities sectors [1]) given its balanced profile of solid new project construction, water (such as city gas). However, we expect earnings-growth potential and limited companies’ financing difficulties, the sector to return to investors’ radar risk exposure, along with an attractive and risks arising from increasing screens with improving earnings valuation and scope for ROE involvement in BT projects. visibility in the next industry phase. improvement (to 16% for 2013E vs. 12% for 2010). We also like GDI Key stock calls Following a decade of extensive (Outperform [2]) given its very safe New Prev. project privatisation and rising earnings profile (we forecast 88% of China Everbright International (257 HK) penetration, we believe the China GDI’s 2012 earnings to be highly Rating Buy water sector is about to enter its next predictable) and potential to acquire Target price HK$4.20 Up/downside S 28.4% stage, where new project construction new water projects. We initiate on Guangdong Investment (270 HK) in waste-water treatment may slow. Hyflux and BEW with Hold (3) and Underperform (4) ratings, Rating Outperform However, we expect earnings quality Target price HK$5.35 to improve substantially, driven by: 1) respectively. We are concerned about Up/downside S 14.8% Hyflux’s limited order growth in the continuing water tariff hikes (a CAGR Hyflux (HYF SP) of around 5% over the past four years), near term and BEW’s overly Rating Hold 2) increasing mergers and aggressive project growth at the Target price S$1.40 acquisitions, and 3) wider adoption of expense of earnings quality. Up/downside T (5.4)% new technologies (such as seawater Beijing Enterprises Water Group (371 HK) desalination and water reuse), Catalysts Rating Underperform We forecast most companies to see Target price HK$1.90 providing additional project-growth Up/downside T (11.2)% potential. Some industry risks are operating cash flow improve going forward (BEW turning positive later Source: Daiwa forecasts unlikely to disappear rapidly, however: Note: Please refer to page 3 for details.
Important disclosures, including any required research certifications, are provided on the last two pages of this report. China Water Sector 15 February 2012
How do we justify our view?