Early Days in a Dundee Mill 1819-23
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Early Days in a Dundee Mill 1819-23 Extracts from the diary of William Brown, an Early Dundee Spinner edited by John Hume Dundee Abertay Historical Society Publication Number 20 - 1980 Acknowledgements The Abertay Historical Society must record its gratitude to Dr. J.R.L. Halley who was responsible for the very survival of the material for this publication. It was he who procured a typescript copy of the original manuscript of William Brown's Essays before it disappeared on the death of the owner. He presented a copy to Dundee University Library and brought it to our attention with the suggestion that it should be published. In addition, he has given us the benefit of his time and long experience in the textile industry to help us with several words and phrases whose meaning we were unable to discover in textbooks. Certain limitations have been put on this edition by the loss of Brown's own notebook. It is impossible to be completely certain whether all the punctuation, spelling and figures are his or the typist's. At several points, the editors have had to use their discretion, where the context indicated more likely alternatives than the typescript version. Even worse, his sketches of different types of machinery, not copied when the typescript was made, have now disappeared for ever. Despite these reservations, however, the Society considered that the document deserved a wider readership than those who have access to Dundee University Library and to the City of Dundee Archive and Record Centre, to which Dr. Halley has also presented a copy. We have to thank Mr. John Hume of the University of Strathclyde for undertaking the task of selection and comment. Annette M. Smith Honorary Editor Abertay Historical Society CONTENTS Page numbers Introduction 1 Preface 4 Brown's apology for his writings 5 The Mill and its Working: History of East Mill 6 General Description of East Mill 8 The Weekly Expense of Carrying on the Mill 13 Facts, Maxims etc. 16 Performance 19 Management: Notes to Managers 20 Instructions for the Undermanager 22 Letter to John Reid 29 Of Order in Management 30 Plan of Management 31 On Business 36 Copy of Letter to Messrs B. & B. 37 Disorder in Business 44 Night Spinning 45 Fire and Insurance 51 Relation with Employees: Queries Concerning Flax Spinning 55 Charity in Hands of East Mill 57 Reduction of Wages 58 Reduction of Working Hours 59 Memorandum regarding Hecklers 60 Extract from Notes to Managers 62 Improvements to East Mill: Improvements on the Mill Yard 63 On the Jakes at East Mill 65 Description of Improvements and Expenses Involved 67 67 The Steam Engine and Machinery: The Steam Engine 72 Expense of Fuel for Steam Engine 73 Account of Accident 74 Notes on Alterations 75 Imperfections in Driving Shaft 77 On the Management of the Steam Engine 80 Breaking and Scutching 83 Carding 85 Spinning 88 Visit to Leeds in 1821: Information Regarding Flax Spinning at Leeds 1821 92 92 1 INTRODUCTION Dundee has been fortunate in the personal records left by its textile pioneers. Alex J. Warden, a Dundee merchant, published in 1864 The Linen Trade Ancient & Modern which contains the best nineteenth century history of a Scottish industry, prepared from personal recollections as well as from documents. Peter Carmichael, engineering genius behind the success of Baxter Brothers, wrote an autobiography which, edited by Enid Gauldie, forms a substantial part of The Dundee Textile Industry 1790-1885 (1969). William Brown, whose Essays are published here for the first time, presented to the public his Reminiscences of Flax Spinning in 1861. Of all the substantial accounts of the early Dundee linen trade, Brown's essays have in many respects the most appeal to modern man. For Brown was not concerned with retrospective analysis, and only to a limited extent was he putting on paper the everyday trivia of a mill- manager's life. His intention in writing the essays was "to improve the author of them in the knowledge of his business and to assist him in the management of' it" and the entries have both coherence and clarity. They have as well freshness and immediacy. From them emerges a picture of a young man coming to terms with problems novel in a Dundee context, drawing inspiration from his knowledge of factory masters elsewhere, and adopting a cool, rational, scientific approach based on eighteenth century ideals. Yet his coolness is tempered by speculation, and Brown is revealed as a humane man, in no sense an exploiter of his workpeople, and sensibly rather than obsessively concerned with-profit and with innovation. William Brown was the youngest of four sons of James Brown, a pioneer of water-powered flax spinning. His father operated Trottick, Friockheim and Arrat Mills, in rural Angus, before building the steam- powered West Ward or Bell Mill in Guthrie Street, Dundee, in 1806-7. This was a pioneering enterprise, largely of fireproof construction, with a twenty-five horsepower engine driving Leeds-made machinery. 2 According to Warden, the mill cost £17,000 and "for twenty years... stood unmatched in the town". It was not, however, the first steam- powered mill in Dundee. Two small-scale mills were built in the early 1790s, but both failed. In 1798, however, a tannery in Guthrie Street was converted to a mill by George Wilkie of Achlishie, near Kirriemuir, who installed a twenty horse-power Boulton and Watt engine to drive the machinery. This became known as the East Mill, and it was taken over by the three younger Brown brothers, the eldest, Andrew, remaining with his father at West Ward. The new proprietors almost immediately ran into a depression, and the mill was closed for some months in the autumn of 1810 and the spring of 1811. They had a struggle to keep going until 1816, but after that trade picked up, and the mill remained profitable until the mid 1820s depression. William became manager of the mill in 1810. At first he had no responsibility for the commercial side of the business, and concentrated on production, which fascinated him. He was, according to Warden, the leader in making the improvements which rendered the spinning of tow a practical and commercial possibility. From the dates quoted by Warden it appears that Brown was involved in this development before 1814, and it certainly seems to have been virtually completed by the commencement of these essays. John Brown left the partnership in 1817, and it may have been the increased responsibility falling on William that stimulated him to jot down his ideas and comments. Dr. Dennis Chapman's article "William Brown of Dundee, 1791-1864: Management in a Scottish Flax Mill" published in Explorations in Entrepreneurial History in 1952, which makes extensive use of Brown's own writings, also draws together other references to Brown's life. These indicate that the concern for the well-being of his workers which unobtrusively underlies many of the essays was carried into his later life. The partnership provided schoolrooms and teachers for young workers, and a newspaper room for older people. Great pains were taken to box in machinery and to ensure proper ventilation in the mill. Seats were provided in the spinning rooms and also an early form of "Music While You Work"; the foreman played the violin as he 3 walked up and down the factory floor on his supervisory duties. In general the workers seem to have been well satisfied. Chapman quotes the views of two female employers one of whom stated to the Factory Enquiries Commission that "there cannot be better employers" and the other "that she believed Messrs Brown the finest masters in this town". According to their evidence Brown gave sick relief and also kept employment open during sickness. Writing in the early 1860s Warden commented that "although Mr. Brown has retired from his favourite trade, he is still an enthusiastic spinner, and takes delight in witnessing the onward progress of mill spinning". This observation was echoed in his obituary, which commented "never during his long life-time did his enthusiasm for his favourite trade flag or falter" (1). * * * * * * As might be expected in pieces written intermittently by a busy man, the essays contain a certain amount of duplication. In addition some of his observations are verbose, and technical comments are usually rather detailed for the general reader. The manuscript has therefore been rearranged, and summarised where appropriate to reduce it to a length suitable for publication. Neither Brown's accounts nor any sums of money he mentions have been adapted to modern usage. Readers are reminded that before decimalisation twelve pennies or pence (12d.) made one shilling (1/- or 1s.) and twenty shillings equalled one pound (£1). John R. Hume June 1979 1) Quoted by William Norrie in Dundee Celebrities (Dundee, 1873) 245. 4 PREFACE Essays on Flax-Spinning and Remarks on the Management of East Mill, Dundee (1) by William Brown, the Manager, 1819. The chief object of these essays is to improve the author of them in the knowledge of his business and to assist him in the management of it. They are meant to be composed of such circumstances, ocurrences, rules, regulations, descriptions and hints for improvements at East Mill, as may appear useful to be perused or remembered afterwards. It is evident that by means of such essays much useful information will be preserved which would otherwise be lost; and when it is considered that in the flax-spinning business nothing can be obtained from books, all from observation or enquiry only, the reading or writing of essays must be particularly useful to exercise the understanding and to refresh the memory.