Vertebrate Fauna of the Graham (Pinaleno) Mountains
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
1 •■ • VERTEBRATE FAUNA OF THE GRAHAM (PINALENO) MOUNTAINS • SOUTHEAST ARIZONA Edited by W. L. Minckley TABLE OF CONTENTS ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ............................................. INTRODUCTION AND DESCRIPTION OF THE AREA ....................... ACCOUNTS OF SPECIES .......................................... 6 Fishes ................................................. 6 Amphibians and Reptiles .................................. II Birds ................................................... 28 Mammals ................................................. 50 SUMMARY AND DISCUSSION ........................................ 66 LITERATURE CITED 69 TABLES 1-3 ................................................... 76 APPENDIX A, CHECK-LISTS OF SPECIES 79 -.This1/ paper results from a summer field program of the Deportment of Zoology, Arizona State University, Tempe, Arizona 85281, and is first of a series of such reports on the fauna of selected areas in the state. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Financial assistance for this project was provided mostly by the summer session of Arizona State University. Funds from the University Research Committee and from the Sport Fishing Institute were utilized in obtaining some data on fishes. The U. S. Forest Service, Coronado National Forest, issued a special use permit for the project in 1966, and personnel in the Safford district under the direction of Arthur Maynard were exceedingly helpful and sympathetic to our work. Phil Cosper, Arizona Game and Fish Department, expedited permits for collecting in the area, and James Bruce of the same agency, provided data on trout and other fish species. Other personnel of the Game and Fish Department Regional Office in Pima, under Don Wingfield, cooperated fully. Private individuals in the vicinity, landowners, tourists, and the like, gave freely of their time and materially assisted in the study. Students who participated directly in collecting of the specimens and data reported here deserve special acknowledgement. These persons, excluding individuals participating in preparation of the report, were: William S. Brown, Mardes Clayton, Victor Cresto, Murray Itzkowitz, Arturo Jimenez G., James E. Johnson, James E. LeDuc, Norman C. Leppla, Glady L. Lytle, Harry Nickla, John N. Rinne, Peter Rothlisberg, Roger S. Siervogel, Frank Turkowski, and Larry Watt. Anthony Lewis identi- fied some bats. In addition, the following individuals provided information obtained during their independent research in the area: Thomas A. Burns, J. Neil Jensen, and David I. Rasmussen. Barbara R. Minckley and her children provided support in the field and In camp in 1966, and are gratefully acknowledged. The typing assistance of Sue Johnson and Carolyn Nickerson also was greatly appreciated. INTRODUCTION AND DESCRIPTION OF THE AREA W. L. Minckley The Graham (Pinaleno) Mountains rise abruptly to a maximum elevation of 10,713 feet above mean sea level from broad, surrounding valleys that He generally below 4,000 feet. They are the most northern of a series of isolated mountain masses that are aligned along the eastern boundary of Arizona (Heald, 1951). Between 15 June and 15 July 1966, and between 8 and 13 July 1967, field parties from the Department of Zoology, Arizona State University, made intensive surveys of the vertebrate biota of these mountains. More than 3,000 specimens were obtained, prepared in the field, and deposited in the Arizona State University Collections. These materials, plus literature records and specimens taken by staff and students from the University at other times, form the bases for this report. A permanent camp was established at the now-abandoned Marijilda Canyon Campground, at an elevation of 4,400 feet, on the eastern end of the mountain mass. From this point, parties moved around the base of the mountain, and to both higher and lower elevations. Because of the generally difficult access in the area, and time limitations, much collecting was concentrated on the eastern end and along the Swift Trail Road (Arizona Highway 366) that traverses the higher elevations to near the western end. Places where major collections were made, along Swift Trail and elsewhere, were selected to represent differing habitats and were described by Hoff- meister (1956), or may be specifically located on the following U. S. Geological Survey quadrangles: N3245-W10945/15 (Thatcher, Ariz.), N3230-W 2 10945/15 (Mt. Graham, Ariz.), N3245-W11000/15 (Jackson Mtn, Ariz.), N3230-W 11000/15 (Sierra Bonita Ranch, Ariz.), and N3245-W10930/15 (Safford, Ariz.). Hoffmeister (1956) presented a description of the terrestrial habitats of the Graham Mountains, which, along with the discussion of Arizona landscapes by Lowe (1964), was freely consulted in preparation of the following account. Details on the vegetation may be found in the work by Shreve (1919). Valleys around the Grahams include the Sulphur Springs-Aravalpa Creek valleys on the south and west, the San Simon valley on the east, and the broad Gila River valley on the north. Northwest, the Graham Range is separated by a low divide from the smaller Santa Teresa Mountains, and on the south, Stockton Pass separates the main body of the Grahams from the Greasewood Range. The major structural features, and the general physio- graphy and drainage patterns of this area were outlined before the end of Tertiary time, with only minor faulting occurring in Quaternary or Recent (Kottlowski, et al., 1965). The Sulphur Springs-Aravaipa valleys are higher in elevation than the other surrounding plains. They are vegetated, in part, by a well- developed Plains Grassland Association (Lowe, 1964). Various grasses (Bouteloua, Muhlenbergia, Stipa, Sporobolus, etc.) often form a continuous ground cover. Other parts of the plain support Desert-Grassland Associations, with sotol (Dasyliron), Yucca, beargrass (Nolina), mesquite (Prosopis luliflora), Acacia, and other, larger plants being most obvious. Parts of the valley are irrigated from pumpage of underground aquifers, and mesic- adapted plants (Populus fremonti, Salix, various sedges, etc.) live adjacent 3 to tanks and irrigation outflows. The Gila and San Simon valleys are mostly under cultivation on "flats" near the watercourses; thick stands of large, perennial grasses and sedges formerly lived in such areas (Olmstead, 1919). Terraces of the rivers, however, support extensive, monotonous stands of creosote bush (Larrea divaricata), or burrsage (Franseria), as they probably did prior to invasion by Caucasian man. Mesquite occurs, or was formerly present, on well-drained parts of the terraces along drainage channels, and fringes of cottonwood persist where water is present and where man allows the trees to remain. Abrupt transition occurs at the junction of montane bajadas and the fine-grained soils of terraces or floodplains. Acacia, mesquite, and prickly pear (Opuntia spp.), along with annual grasses and forbs, become increasingly dominant, forming a low, dense cover over rocky soils. Oaks (Quercus ), junipers (Juniperus), and pinyon pine (Pinus cembriodes), occur sparsely as low as 3,500 feet in some canyons. Above 4,500 feet these become more abundant. In fact, between 4,500 and 6,000 feet, oaks form an almost inpenetrable thicket on more arid slopes, and other deciduous trees, ash (Fraxinus), maple (Acer), walnut (Juglans), and smaller species, inhabit canyons. The conifers then become generally dominant, extending in sequence from mid-elevation species (Pinus lelophylia), through ponderosa (P. ponderosa) and limber pine (P. flexilis), to fir and spruce (Abies concoior, Pseudotsuga menziesi, and Picea engelmanni), at higher elevations. In places above 8,000 feet, open parks, densely vege- tated with perennial grasses and sedges occupy many acres of surface. Open, grassy areas also occur on the highest peaks, in association with 4 aspen (Populus tremuloides) and spruce; however, timberline conditions are not now achieved at the peaks. Distributional relations of the flora of the Graham Mountains are exceedingly complex (Shreve, 1919). The mountain is rugged, and exposure and edaphic conditions markedly dictate local species compositions. In Marijilda Canyon, for example, "pockets" of oak are present below 3,500 feet. On the other hand, an "oak zone" on the almost-vertical southwest slope of the mountain extends to about 10,000 feet on xeric rockslides and shallow soils. Aquatic habitats are few, and they are highly modified by man. The larger, persistent streams, the Gila River and Aravaipa Creek, are far from the mountain base and are not considered here. Ash, Grant, and Mari- jilda creeks, and their tributaries, comprise the permanent lotic habitats on the mountain itself. They all originate in seepage and springs of montane meadows, then accumulate additional water from the walls of steep, rocky canyons through which they pass. All the streams disappear in valley fills of their lower courses, or are diverted for irrigation into the valleys below. Lentic habitats consist of Riggs Flat Lake, and a smaller impound- ment at Snow Flat. Thermal springs occur in an "artesian belt" around the north and east sides of the mountain, and these feed a myriad of tanks and other artificial basins. Some larger bodies of water, i.e. Roper's Lake ca. seven miles south of Safford, are maintained by pumpage from subterranean waters; tanks and irrigation developments of the Sulphur Springs-Aravaipa valleys were mentioned before. Natural waters in that area include a few marshy places and one tiny spring on the Sierra Bonita Ranch.