Review of the Shire of Newstead Heritage Study Precincts & Specific
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Shire of Mount Alexander Review of the Shire of Newstead Heritage Study Precincts & Specific Individual Places Vaughan, 1868. Source: Newstead Historical Society. Prepared by: Wendy Jacobs: Architect & Heritage Consultant & Dr David Rowe, Authentic Heritage Services Pty Ltd October 2011 Table of Contents Page EXECUTIVE SUMMARY i 1.0 Introduction 1.1 Aims of the Review 1 1.2 Acknowledgments 1 1.3 Project Outcomes 2 1.4 Significance Criteria & Thresholds 4 2.0 Heritage Precincts 2.1 Campbells Creek 8 2.2 Fryerstown 17 2.3 Guildford 28 2.4 Newstead 38 2.5 Vaughan 53 3.0 Specific Individual Places 64 4.0 Recommendations 4.1 Heritage Precincts 72 4.2 Individual Places Outside Precincts (removed from Revised Precincts) 73 4.3 Review of Specific Individual Places 74 5.0 Appendices 5.1 Illustrated List of All Places Within Original Precincts 77 5.2 Illustrated List of Places in the Revised Campbells Creek Precinct 5.3 Illustrated List of Places in the Revised Fryerstown Precinct 5.4 Illustrated List of Places in the Revised Guildford Precinct 5.5 Illustrated List of Places in the Revised Newstead Precincts 5.6 Illustrated List of Places in the Revised Vaughan Precinct 5.7 List of Non Significant Places in the Revised Campbells Creek Precinct 5.8 List of Non Significant Places in the Revised Fryerstown Precinct 5.9 List of Non Significant Places in the Revised Guildford Precinct 5.10 List of Non Significant Places in the Revised Newstead Precinct 5.11 List of Non Significant Places in the Revised Vaughan Precinct 5.12 Revised Heritage Citations Review of the Shire of Newstead Heritage Study & Specific Individual Places 2011 Summary Executive Summary Introduction Wendy Jacobs, Architect and Heritage Consultant, and Dr David Rowe, Authentic Heritage Services, were commissioned by the Mount Alexander Shire Council in June 2011 to undertake a review of the heritage precincts and specific individual places identified in the Heritage Study of Newstead Stage 2 (May 2004). A draft of the Review was provided to the Mount Alexander Shire in July 2011. Aims of the Review The principal aims of the Review have been to: Identify (through fieldwork) all non-significant places in the 5 heritage precincts: Campbells Creek; Fryerstown; Guildford; Newstead; and Vaughan. Provide lists of all non-significant places in the 5 heritage precincts. Review submissions received by Council in relation to heritage citations and where necessary, undertake additional research and verify and/or correct the assessments provided in the Stage 2 Study. The secondary aims of the Review have been to: Review the boundaries of the 5 heritage precincts. Where necessary, refresh the supporting documentation and statements of significance for the 5 heritage precincts. It has not been the purpose of the Review to completely re-evaluate the 5 heritage precincts, but to provide limited updated information in support of their heritage values. This Review has also not involved a re-evaluation of proposed heritage precinct policies for the Mount Alexander Planning Scheme, although some limited additional policy recommendations are provided to support the refreshed statements of significance of the precincts. Recommendations Heritage Precincts It is recommended that heritage overlays be applied to the five (5) revised heritage precincts at Campbells Creek, Fryerstown, Guildford, Newstead and Vaughan as outlined in this Review. It is recommended that the significance status for each of the following places be amended in each of the precincts: Campbells Creek . 51 Main Road – dwelling at rear of site adjacent to railway line (contributory significance). Wendy Jacobs: Architect & Heritage Consultant & Dr David Rowe: Authentic Heritage Services Pty Ltd i Review of the Shire of Newstead Heritage Study & Specific Individual Places 2011 Summary . Main Road – Avenue of Honour (local significance) (between 113 Main Rd east side & 92 Main Rd west side, & 120 Midland Hwy east side & 127 Midland Hwy west side). Fryerstown . 13 Heron Street: Treed land comprising the former National School Reserve (contributory significance). Opp. 2 High Street: Stone Bridge abutments and stone creek embankments (contributory significance). Opp. 60 High Street: Stone Bridge abutments (contributory significance). Lot 13, 26 High Street: Mine Dump (contributory significance). Opp. 32 High Street: Perseverance Mine Dump (contributory significance). 2 Market Street: Park, including Eucalyptus & Cypress Trees (contributory significance). Guildford . 1 Ballarat Street: Reserve (formerly part of Russell Square) (contributory significance). Parker Street: John Powell Reserve (formerly Russell Square) (contributory significance. Newstead . 3 Creswick Newstead Road: Dwelling (contributory significance.) . 1 Lyons Street: The Shambles (3 shops) (contributory significance). 23 Lyons Street: Dwelling (contributory significance). 25 Lyons Street: Butcher’s Shop (contributory significance). 3 Tivey Street: Dwelling (contributory significance). 8 Tivey Street: Shed (contributory significance). Vaughan . VN/01, off Greville Street: Vaughan Mineral Springs: (reserve now included in heritage precinct – no change to significance). VN/03, opp. 33 Greville Street: Chinese Burial Ground: (burial ground now included in heritage precinct – no change to significance). VN/05, Fryers Creek, Greville Street: Bridge over Fryers Creek (bridge now included in heritage precinct – no change to significance). VN/13, Tarilta Road: Tarilta Road Bridge (bridge now included in heritage precinct – no change to significance). Although it is outside of the scope of this Review to re-examine the proposed heritage precinct policies for the Mt Alexander Shire Planning Scheme, the following is recommended for the Fryerstown and Vaughan Heritage Precincts: . Consideration be given to more broadly defined policy for future building development. It could include promoting: new buildings of a range of forms and designs, and of contextually modest (single storey) scales that do not impose on or detract from the significant heritage landscape setting and/or neighbouring significant buildings; construction Wendy Jacobs: Architect & Heritage Consultant & Dr David Rowe: Authentic Heritage Services Pty Ltd ii Review of the Shire of Newstead Heritage Study & Specific Individual Places 2011 Summary materials that are not highly reflective within the landscape; recessive garaging and/or carports, and visually permeable residential front fences to 1200-1300 mm heights of designs and construction that are contemporary interpretations of front fencing in the precinct and respond to the designs of the new buildings. Consideration be given to the high archaeological potential of these precincts. As all archaeological sites are protected under the Heritage Act 1995, consent is required from Heritage Victoria to disturb them. Therefore, it is recommended that policy be prepared that reflects this legislation. Consideration could be given to the following: “Where ground disturbance uncovers archaeological evidence of 19th century gold mining and associated building activity, works should cease until notification has been made with and approval given by Heritage Victoria for works to proceed, in accordance with the Victorian Heritage Act 1995.” . Any policy or incorporated document that includes the lists of non- significant places for these places be treated differently given the high archaeological potential of these areas as set out in the statements of significance for the Vaughan and Fryerstown precincts. Exotic trees on public land and road reserves as outlined in the precinct statements of significance be identified as tree controls for each of the heritage overlays in the Schedule to the Heritage Overlay. Individual Places Outside Precincts (removed from Revised Precincts) It is recommended that individual heritage overlays apply to those places of local significance previously located within the heritage precincts (and now excluded from them). These places are: Campbells Creek Precinct . CC/80: 10A Princess. CC/82: 12 Princess Street. CC/85: 24 Princess Street. CC/86: 26 Princess Street. Fryerstown Precinct No change recommended. Guildford Precinct No change recommended. Newstead Precincts . ND/16 Pair of Dwellings: 8 Church Street . Rotunda Park, Pyrenees Highway, including ND/63 Major Mitchell Cairn and ND/64 Band Rotunda. ND/88 Williams House: 3 Wyndham Street. ND/89 Clarke House: 9 Wyndham Street. Wendy Jacobs: Architect & Heritage Consultant & Dr David Rowe: Authentic Heritage Services Pty Ltd iii Review of the Shire of Newstead Heritage Study & Specific Individual Places 2011 Summary Vaughan Precinct No change recommended. Review of Specific Individual Places As a result of the informal exhibition by the Mount Alexander Shire a number of submissions were received by the Mount Alexander Shire. Changes to places were also noted in the years since Stage 1 of the study was undertaken in 1998. 38 places were reviewed. These reviewed citations are included as Appendix 5.12. As a result of the field work 4 citations have been revised and it is recommended that 22 new citations be prepared. A concern of some submitters was the condition of building fabric. While these concerns are acknowledged, attempts were made to clarify that these issues are generally outside the recognized heritage assessment process. This is supported in the Australia ICOMOS Burra Charter and particularly the Guidelines to the Burra Charter on Cultural Significance. Economic and condition