An International Rescue for Our Biggest Airport Departure Lounge. FEATURE
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
JUNE–JULY 2020 · VOLUME 19.5 RRP $14.95 PRINT POST APPROVAL NUMBER PP352532/00001 Superfly An international rescue for our biggest airport departure lounge. FEATURE Mixed opinion For a host of reasons, mixed-mode air conditioning systems have both their supporters and detractors. Sean McGowan explores the issues with Caimin McCabe, M.AIRAH, director at Cundall; Anthony Marklund, M.AIRAH, principal sustainability engineer at Floth; Jason Gaekwad, regional manager – building physics and sustainability at Inhabit; Lasath Lecamwasam, F.AIRAH, building services engineer at ESBS; and Andrew Pettifer, principal and NSW buildings group leader at Arup. Eco: Tell us how a mixed-mode The main differences are the control McCabe: A mixed-mode comfort ventilation strategy typically works? system for the natural ventilation – strategy works on the basis that heating is automatic or manual – and what the used when ambient conditions are cold, Lecamwasam: It is the fusion of natural ventilation openings look like – air conditioning when hot, and natural time-tested and proven good passive louvres, operable walls, etc. ventilation when ambient conditions suit design principles with the predictable to maintain acceptable thermal comfort. design and operation of mechanical AC Pettifer: When outdoor conditions systems. Correct design and operation are favourable, the building is naturally However, a critical design issue is that of such systems can significantly reduce ventilated and when they are not the natural ventilation system has to operating costs and improve user the mechanical systems operate. be designed to provide for effective enjoyment of buildings. The mode shift can be fully automatic, ventilation, as just meeting NCC/BCA with actuators used to open and close openable area will not suffice. Gaekwad: The most basic mixed-mode windows and/or louvres in the façade. system is your typical single dwelling Alternatively, in natural ventilation Marklund: A semi-automated approach – house or apartment – with operable mode occupants can be alerted, for can be to install reed switches on a windows and an air conditioning system. example using a traffic light system manually operable façade element that Occupants open the windows when mounted in the space or via personal when opened, turns off the local air it’s “nice” outside. When the dwelling technology, and they then manually conditioning zone. A weather sensor becomes uncomfortably hot or cold, open and close the natural ventilation operating a visual indicator light or app the windows are closed, and the air devices in their vicinity. can be used to encourage occupants to conditioning system is switched on. open windows. Outside of natural ventilation mode, A mixed-mode system operates very the system works as conventional air A fully automated system, for say an similarly for any other building typology. conditioning. open-plan office, would typically include 24 JUNE–JULY 2020 • ECOLIBRIUM Caimin McCabe Anthony Marklund Jason Gaekwad Lasath Lecamwasam Andrew Pettifer outdoor and indoor sensors linked to At present though, the risks to the BMS to control electrically actuated consultants through adopting mixed natural ventilation devices and the air mode makes such systems a rarity. Sadly, conditioning systems. building occupants have developed some Eco: In what applications does very expensive habits and expectations mixed-mode ventilation work best? over the past 50 years or so, and in an There are examples environment now facing extreme weather Pettifer: We tend to think in terms of school, university, events more commonly, the challenges of office spaces, and there are many commercial, retail and to implementing mixed mode have examples of mixed-mode systems in increased. commercial buildings around the world. even hospital buildings Eco: And what are some of the But it can and has been applied to other that have successfully building types such as sports facilities advantages and benefits? adopted mixed-mode and even theatres. Lecamwasam: The main advantages The main drivers are to reduce energy are reduced operational costs, user consumption and the perceived benefits There are examples of school, university, satisfaction and enhanced green to occupants – most people like the commercial, retail and even hospital credentials – if being environmentally idea of being able to open the façade, buildings that have successfully adopted friendly is a key ethos of the end users. breathe fresh air and hear the birds mixed-mode air conditioning. McCabe: Mixed mode can provide for sing. If the air outside is polluted and all you can hear is traffic noise it’s not Marklund: Mixed-mode air improved energy efficiency – assuming quite the same effect! So it works best conditioning has been successfully effective controls are in place such as in suburban or rural locations with applied to many types of buildings avoiding windows being open and air temperate climates. internationally. conditioning is on – improved indoor air quality through higher rates of When designed, installed, operated and Gaekwad: The application of mixed- outside air when natural ventilation is maintained correctly, particularly in mode ventilation is wholly dependent in operation, and improved health and on climate and outdoor environment, conjunction with an adaptive thermal comfort strategy where individuals wellbeing of occupants by providing building form and use, and indoor greater connection to outside, as well as environment. East coast cities tend have visual connection to the outdoors and are appropriately educated – and providing them greater control over their to have a mild and desirable climate environment. for the majority of the year, which allowed control over their environment has led to an “indoor/outdoor” type – international studies indicate that But it is critical that the natural of lifestyle. Mixed-mode systems can occupant satisfaction and productivity ventilation part of the mixed-mode air contribute to this design and lifestyle can be improved while significantly conditioning system be designed to philosophy. During summer in reducing air conditioning energy use, cost provide effective ventilation and not just and associated carbon emissions. Melbourne, the ambient temperature meeting NCC/BCA openable area, as this is generally within the comfort range; Lecamwasam: Mandated building will not suffice and lead to complaints. natural ventilation could be utilised to rating schemes such as NABERS and Gaekwad: If done well, mixed-mode remove heat load from, for example, Green Star could complement the densely occupied office buildings. For adoption of mixed mode very well. ventilation can provide a greater regions with a high diurnal variation in connection to the outdoors, including temperature, a night-purge system can If end user groups such as the to thermal variability and ventilation be used, where cool air is brought into Commonwealth and state governments, velocity variability. This can dramatically the building at night. retail, education, hospitality industries improve comfort, and represents a move etc., redefined lease requirements for towards a more “human centred” method McCabe: Subject to prevailing climate more environmentally friendly minimum of HVAC design. being suitable and functional usage, there service requirements for temperature are not many building types or areas and occupant comfort, then mixed However the building operation should where a mixed-mode air conditioning mode would be far widely adopted by also reflect this design philosophy when approach cannot be adopted. consultants. the HVAC system is running. JUNE–JULY 2020 • ECOLIBRIUM 25 FEATURE Eco: What types of mechanical systems work best in a mixed- MIXED MODE IN OPERATION mode ventilation strategy? McCabe: ASB HEADQUARTERS, $477 million Cooler Cleaner Schools Mixed-mode designs can program. This could see naturally work with any air conditioning systems AUCKLAND NZ ventilated schools being enabled for – the key is that effective operation is The design of ASB North Wharf in manual mixed-mode air conditioning controlled so that a space or building Auckland reflected the desire of its subject to the teachers being instructed is not being air conditioned with tenant for a world-class building that to operate them this way. the windows or vents are open. The places staff and customers at the only systems where the combination centre of the sustainability equation. SUZANNE CORY of natural ventilation needs to be carefully considered from a controls Featuring a mechanical service HIGH SCHOOL, perspective are chilled ceiling and design by Arup, the seven-storey WERRIBEE, VIC chilled beam systems, so that unwanted commercial office building maximises When designing the mechanical condensation does not occur. daylight, views and the fresh air of the services solution at the Suzanne Cory Waitemata Harbour through the use Pettifer: Chilled beams are High School, Cundall in association of a green light/red light system to problematic because you have to control with Brand Architects adopted a strong alert occupants when conditions are humidity in the building to prevent passive design approach through the favourable for windows to be opened. condensation, and that’s not easy to combination of a high-performance do in a building that is intermittently To read more about the ASB North envelope (including effective use of naturally ventilated. All-air systems Wharf, see Ecolibrium December 2013. thermal mass) as well as a