DOCSLIB.ORG

Stem Cell Research

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Stem Cell Research Committee on Jewish Law and Standards of the Rabbinical Assembly YD 336.2002 Stem Cell Research RABBI ELLIOT N. DORFF This paper was approved by the CJLS on March 13, 2002. The answer to question 1 received a vote of fifteen in favor and one abstention (15-0-1). Voting in favor: Rabbis Kassel Abelson, Ben Zion Bergman, Elliot N. Dorff, Paul Drazen, Robert Fine, Baruch Frydman-Kohl, Susan Grossman, Alan B. Lucas, Daniel Nevins, Paul Plotkin, Joseph Prouser, Mayer Rabinowitz, Avram Israel Reisner, Joel Rembaum, and Gordon Tucker. Abstaining: Rabbi Joel Roth. The answer to question 2 received a vote of fourteen in favor, one against, and one abstention (14-1-1). Voting in favor: Rabbis Kassel Abelson, Ben Zion Bergman, Elliot N. Dorff, Paul Drazen, Robert Fine, Baruch Frydman-Kohl, Alan B. Lucas, Daniel Nevins, Paul Plotkin, Joseph Prouser, Mayer Rabinowitz, Avram Israel Reisner, Joel Rembaum, and Gordon Tucker. Voting against: Rabbi Susan Grossman. Abstaining: Rabbi Joel Roth. YNWD 1. May embryonic stem cells from frozen embryos originally created for purposes of procreation or embryonic germ cells from aborted fetuses be used for research? 2. May embryonic stem cells from embryos created specifically for research, either by combining donated sperm and eggs in a petri dish or by cloning be used for research? YXD The Current State of the Science of Stem Cells Definitions and Properties What are stem cells, and why are we interested in doing research on them? The following paragraphs that answer those questions are quoted from a document issued in May, 2000 by the Director of the National Institutes of Health entitled “Stem Cells: A Primer”:1 Stem cells are best described in the context of normal human development. Human development begins when a sperm fertilizes an egg and creates a single cell that has the potential to form an entire organism. This fertilized egg is totipotent, meaning that its potential is total. In the first hours after fertilization, this cell divides into identical toti- potent cells. This means that either one of these cells, if placed into a woman’s uterus, has the potential to develop into a fetus. In fact, identical twins develop when two totipotent cells separate and develop into two individual, genetically identical human beings. Approximately four days after fertilization and after several cycles of cell divi- sion [up to the 32-cell stage], these totipotent cells begin to specialize, forming a _________________________________________________________________________________ The Committee on Jewish Law and Standards of the Rabbinical Assembly provides guidance in matters of halakhah for the Conservative movement. The individual rabbi, however, is the authority for the interpretation and application of all matters of halakhah. hollow sphere of cells, called a blastocyst. The blastocyst has an outer layer of cells, and inside the hollow sphere there is a cluster of cells called the inner cell mass. The outer layer of cells [the “trophectoderm”] will go on to form the placenta and other supporting tissues needed for fetal development in the uterus. The inner cell mass cells will go on to form virtually all of the tissues of the human body [in a process that begins with “gastrulation” during the period between 16 and 22 days of gestation] . Although the inner cell mass cells can form virtually every type of cell found in the human body, they cannot form an organism because they are unable to give rise to the placenta and supporting tissues necessary for development in the human uterus. These inner mass cells are pluripotent – they can give rise to many types of cells but not all types of cells necessary for fetal development. Because their potential is not total, they are not totipotent and they are not embryos. In fact, if an inner cell mass cell were placed into a woman’s uterus, it would not develop into a fetus. The pluripotent stem cells undergo further specialization into stem cells that are committed to give rise to cells that have a particular function. Examples of this include blood stem cells which give rise to red blood cells, white blood cells and platelets; and skin stem cells that give rise to the various types of skin cells. [Muscle, cartilage, bone, liver, brain, and fat are other examples of adult stem cells.] These more specialized stem cells are called multipotent. Two things should be noted. First, the word “adult” as used in the phrase “adult stem cells” refers to any person after birth. Thus adult stem cells from infants can and have been used to cure leukemia in siblings, for example. Some very recent research suggests that some adult stem cells may be pluripotent. Nothing in this responsum should suggest that research on adult stem cells should be abandoned; on the contrary, every effort should be expended to use adult stem cells for as many cures as possible. It should not, however, lead us to abandon embryonic stem cell research, for that still holds out more hope to accomplish all the uses de- scribed in the next section. Second, in normal human development, embyronic stem cells create the various organs and tissues of the body and then turn off; otherwise, we would have multiple heads, legs, hearts, etc., and it is questionable whether the uterus would be able to hold a human being or give birth to one. Unlike human fetal development, scientists are interested in removing embryonic stem cells to create stem cell lines, which would theoretically multiply stem cells indefinitely — although stem cells naturally “senesce” after dividing up to 100 times. Scien- tists then want to learn how to transform stem cells into needed tissues or organs and how to stop them when they reach the desired state. In addition to embryonic stem cells, scientists are interested in embryonic germ (EG) cells. Those are cells from the gonadal ridge in the early embryo that in the process of the fetus’ development are set aside and protected from maturing. They migrate through the fetus to the ovary or testes, where they form the egg and sperm cells. If removed from the fetus and grown in culture, they behave much like embryonic stem cells. Potential Uses of Stem Cells Adult stem cells, which are normally used by the body for maintenance, have already proven useful in drug development, in treatment of diseases like osteoporosis and leukemia, and in cardiac and cartilage care. Research into further potential uses of adult stem cells in blood, skin, and other parts of the body should certainly go forward. Scientists, though, are especially interested in doing research on the cells normally used by the body for development, i.e., our embryonic stem cells (ES) and our embryonic germ cells (EG). While some adult stem cells may be pluripotent, most have been differentiated to the point that they can only produce other cells like themselves (they are only “multipotent”), with minimal ability to transform into other kinds of cells. In contrast, embryonic stem cells can and do convert into all of the tissues of the body (they are “pluripotent”). Because ES cells have this greater ability to mutate, scientists engaged in research on them hope, according to the N.I.H. document quoted above, to learn or do at least the following three things: A. Learn About the Process of Cell Specialization How do stem cells decide which tissues to become and how many to make of each type of tissue? We know that turning genes on and off is central to the process of human development, but we do not know much about how these decisions are made in the process of human development or how stem cells are turned on or off. Some of our most serious medical conditions, such as cancer and birth defects, are due to abnormal cell specialization and cell division. A better understanding of normal cell development is necessary for scientists to learn what goes wrong with cells when cancer or birth defects occur so that hopefully some day such abnormal developments can be arrested and reversed. Because of their level of differentiation, adult stem cells seem to be a much less likely source for gaining this knowledge than embryonic stem cells promise to be. Thus even if adult stem cells can ultimately be used for the other two purposes listed below, embryonic stem cell research will be necessary to accomplish this end. Furthermore, even with some preliminary results indicating that some adult stem cells may be pluripotent, embryonic stem cell research still holds out greater hope for these other two purposes as well. B. Test Drugs More Safely and Efficiently Research on pluripotent human stem cells could also dramatically change the way we develop drugs and test them for safety. New medications could be initially tested using human cell lines before testing them on human beings. I am currently serving on the National Human Resources Advisory Commission of the Department of Health and Human Services, whose mandate is to review and revise the federal guidelines for research on human subjects. Widely publicized fatal experiments that killed Jesse Gelsinger at the University of Pennsylva- nia and Ellen Roche at the Johns Hopkins Medical Center have brought to light other questionable practices used by pharmaceutical companies and academic medical centers in testing drugs. The pressures to gain reputation and money in this field are enormous, and so strict requirements to protect human subjects are necessary. On the other hand, we all have benefitted immensely from the breakthroughs in drugs during the last six decades, beginning with penicillin in 1938, and that can only happen if drugs are ultimately tested for their safety and effectiveness on human beings.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Homosexuality Rabbi Joel Roth
    EH 24.1992b HoMosEXUALITY Rabbi Joel Roth This paper wa.s approved by the CJLS on March 2.5, 1992, by a t:ote offourteen in ftwor, seven opposed, and three abstain­ inp.: (14-7-3). HJtint( in.flwor: Rabbis Stnnle_y Brnmnick, Jerome _ill. LjJstein, David _lli. 1<(:/dman, Samuel Fraint, Arnold i\1. Goodman, Reut'fTL Kimdman, Anron L. Jllaclrler, Herbert _Mandl, Lionf'l L". 1Hoses, At'ram lsr(Lel Rei,-;ner, Chaim A. Rogc~ft .Joel Roth, Jlorri,, Sh"piro, and Cemld Sirolnik tirting "gains!: Rabbis Ben Zion Bergman, £lliot N. Dorff: Rich"nl L. Fisenberg, Dov Peretz Flhins, Froward Ffandlet; Joel Rcmbaum, and Gordon Tucker. Abstaining: Rabbis Kassel Abelson, Jan Cwyl Kaufman, and _ilfrqer Rahi.nDwilz. 1he Committee on Jewish Law and Standards of' the Rabbinical 1sscmblyprovides guidance in matters of'halahhahfor the Conservative movement. The individual rabbi, however, is the (Wtlwri~yfor the interpretation nnd application r~f all mntters of'halairlwh. Part I Few topics evoke the type of visceral response that homosexuality does. Responses are often quick and definitive on both ends of the spectrum. I have been cornered by some who wonder how the question could even be on the agenda of the Law Committee. "~That is there to say about the subject from a halakhic point of view", they ask? "Putting it on the agenda validates a question which, in fact, has no validity," they claim. At the other end of the spectrum, I have been contacted by some homosexuals whose claim is equally definitive. "Halakhah has no option but to validate homosexuality as a lifestyle co-equal with heterosexuality.
    [Show full text]
  • CCAR Journal the Reform Jewish Quarterly
    CCAR Journal The Reform Jewish Quarterly Halachah and Reform Judaism Contents FROM THE EDITOR At the Gates — ohrgJc: The Redemption of Halachah . 1 A. Brian Stoller, Guest Editor ARTICLES HALACHIC THEORY What Do We Mean When We Say, “We Are Not Halachic”? . 9 Leon A. Morris Halachah in Reform Theology from Leo Baeck to Eugene B . Borowitz: Authority, Autonomy, and Covenantal Commandments . 17 Rachel Sabath Beit-Halachmi The CCAR Responsa Committee: A History . 40 Joan S. Friedman Reform Halachah and the Claim of Authority: From Theory to Practice and Back Again . 54 Mark Washofsky Is a Reform Shulchan Aruch Possible? . 74 Alona Lisitsa An Evolving Israeli Reform Judaism: The Roles of Halachah and Civil Religion as Seen in the Writings of the Israel Movement for Progressive Judaism . 92 David Ellenson and Michael Rosen Aggadic Judaism . 113 Edwin Goldberg Spring 2020 i CONTENTS Talmudic Aggadah: Illustrations, Warnings, and Counterarguments to Halachah . 120 Amy Scheinerman Halachah for Hedgehogs: Legal Interpretivism and Reform Philosophy of Halachah . 140 Benjamin C. M. Gurin The Halachic Canon as Literature: Reading for Jewish Ideas and Values . 155 Alyssa M. Gray APPLIED HALACHAH Communal Halachic Decision-Making . 174 Erica Asch Growing More Than Vegetables: A Case Study in the Use of CCAR Responsa in Planting the Tri-Faith Community Garden . 186 Deana Sussman Berezin Yoga as a Jewish Worship Practice: Chukat Hagoyim or Spiritual Innovation? . 200 Liz P. G. Hirsch and Yael Rapport Nursing in Shul: A Halachically Informed Perspective . 208 Michal Loving Can We Say Mourner’s Kaddish in Cases of Miscarriage, Stillbirth, and Nefel? . 215 Jeremy R.
    [Show full text]
  • Conservative Judaism 101: a Primer for New Members
    CONSERVATIVE JUDAISM 101© A Primer for New Members (And Practically Everyone Else!) By Ed Rudofsky © 2008, 2009, 2010, 2011 Table of Contents Page Introduction & Acknowledgements ii About the Author iii Chapter One: The Early Days 1 Chapter Two: Solomon Schechter; the Founding of The United Synagogue of America and the Rabbinical Assembly; Reconstructionism; and the Golden Age of Conservative Judaism 2 Chapter Three: The Organization and Governance of the Conservative Movement 6 Chapter Four: The Revised Standards for Congregational Practice 9 Chapter Five: The ―Gay & Lesbian Teshuvot‖ of 2006 14 Introduction – The Halakhic Process 14 Section I – Recent Historical Context for the 2006 Teshuvot 16 Section II – The 2006 Teshuvot 18 Chapter Six: Intermarriage & The Keruv/Edud Initiative 20 Introduction - The Challenge of Intermarriage 20 Section I – Contemporary Halakhah of Intermarriage 22 Section II – The Keruv/Edud Initiative & Al HaDerekh 24 Section III – The LCCJ Position 26 Epilogue: Emet Ve’Emunah & The Sacred Cluster 31 Sources 34 i Addenda: The Statement of Principles of Conservative Judaism A-1 The Sacred Cluster: The Core Values of Conservative Judaism A-48 ii Introduction & Acknowledgements Conservative Judaism 101: A Primer For New Members (And Practically Everyone Else!) originally appeared in 2008 and 2009 as a series of articles in Ha- Hodesh, the monthly Bulletin of South Huntington Jewish Center, of Melville, New York, a United Synagogue-affiliated congregation to which I have proudly belonged for nearly twenty-five (25) years. It grew out of my perception that most new members of the congregation knew little, if anything, of the history and governance of the Conservative Movement, and had virtually no context or framework within which to understand the Movement‘s current positions on such sensitive issues as the role of gay and lesbian Jews and intermarriage between Jews and non-Jews.
    [Show full text]
  • Bioethics, Sustainability, and Religious Thought
    Hillel Gray, Religious ethics, 2010 1 Introduction for the Piedmont Project. Thanks to the Piedmont Project, an undergraduate course in religious bioethics has been modified to address sustainability issues, primarily the ethics of environmental health. The course would give students an opportunity to apply ethical reasoning and comparative analysis to a series of timely topics in medical ethics and environmental health. Accordingly, the religious bioethics syllabus was expanded to cover several aspects of sustainability. Students in the course would learn about the meaning of sustainability, the connections between medical ethics and sustainability, and the reasons and mechanisms for making health care institutions more sustainable. In addition, through the Piedmont workshop and subsequent research, I have been able to appreciate and utilize religious writings on specific sustainability topics. I had originally planned for the syllabus to consider several environmental health (e.g., endocrine-disrupting chemicals) and comparative methodology (e.g., informed consent and environmental right-to-know) topics that are relevant to both medical ethics and sustainability. However, since several topics lack high-quality religious writings to support stand-alone curricular modules, such topics will be covered by lectures and class exercises. Nonetheless, the syllabus has been expanded significantly to cover sustainability at several levels. To exemplify the relationship between medical ethics and sustainability, the course shows how religious thought struggles with both individual health risks and institutional management of environmental health risks. To demonstrate the diversity of religious thinking on sustainability at the global level, the course will also focus on religious thought and programming on climate change. The course will conclude with topics in biomedical technologies (i.e., reproductive technologies and organ transplantation) that have unexplored implications for sustainability.
    [Show full text]
  • Board of Trustees Meeting 19-12-12
    Partnership Ceremonies for Same-sex Couples Contents 1 The statement by Masorti Judaism UK 2 Introduction: a consideration of values 3 A summary of the arguments of the Law Committee’s responsa on which the UK Ruling is based 4 The conclusions reached by the rabbis of Masorti Judaism UK, and their ruling 5 What a shutafut ceremony might include (a fuller discussion will follow at a later date) 6 A reflection on the meaning of welcome and inclusion Endnotes (1) This document has been kept brief for reasons of clarity, but fuller arguments are given in the endnotes (2) References in this paper to “The Law Committee” are to the Committee on Jewish Law and Standards of the Conservative Movement in the United States of America. (3) References listed at the end of this paper include links to the full texts of the Law Committee’s responsa discussed below. 1. The statement by Masorti Judaism UK This paper provides the background to the following statement issued by Masorti Judaism UK in October 2014: After much learning and discussion, the Masorti rabbis have ruled that communities may carry out ceremonies for gay and lesbian couples based on a ‘shutafut,’ or partnership, ceremony. We recognise that our movement encompasses diverse views on this important subject. Each Masorti community, together with its rabbi, will be free to decide whether to carry out these ceremonies and, if so, whether the relationships sanctified by them should be registered under English law as same- sex marriages or civil partnerships. Masorti Judaism is proud to be taking this opportunity to make Alexander House, 3 Shakespeare Road, London N3 1XE | Tel 020 8349 6650 | Fax 020 8349 2743 | [email protected] | www.masorti.org.uk Senior Rabbi: Jonathan Wittenberg | Vice-Presidents: Gillian Caplin, Chazan Jaclyn Chernett, Michael Rose | Co-Chairs: Nick Gendler, Clive Sheldon | Chief Executive: Matt Plen our communities ever more welcoming and to realise our values of inclusion, equality and diversity within the framework of halakhah (Jewish law).
    [Show full text]
  • Walking with Mitzvot Edited by Rabbi Bradley Shavit Artson Ogb Hfrs Andvhfrs Rabbi Patricia Fenton in Memory of Harold Held and Louise Held, of Blessed Memory
    The Ziegler School of Rabbinic Studies Walking with Mitzvot Edited By Rabbi Bradley Shavit Artson ogb hfrs andvhfrs Rabbi Patricia Fenton In Memory of Harold Held and Louise Held, of blessed memory The Held Foundation Melissa and Michael Bordy Joseph and Lacine Held Robert and Lisa Held Published in partnership with the United Synagogue of Conservative Judaism, the Rabbinical Assembly, the Federation of Jewish Men’s Clubs and the Women’s League for Conservative Judaism. July 2011 Dear Colleague, We are delighted to enclose your copy of Walking with Mitzvot, the fifth book in the series created for adult learners by the Ziegler School of Rabbinic Studies. Walking with Mitzvot is a series of ten learning units that make up a complete adult education course. These materials expose participants to some of the very best thinkers of Conservative Judaism, and their scholarship, passion and faith. They stimulate thought and discussion, and promote learning, while offering an impressive sampling of texts from our rich tradition, presented in the original and in English translation. The book includes a series of session suggestions to guide you in mastering the material and presenting it to your adult learners. You may select which sessions to run and which texts to use for each session, so that you may customize the course in line with the needs and goals of your own community. Many of the texts are appropriate for multiple sessions. All texts may be copied and distributed to participants, and you may download PDF versions without charge from www.walkingwith.org. We would like to express our profound thanks for the generous support of the Held Foundation, which has sponsored this project in memory of Harold Held and Louise Held.
    [Show full text]
  • THE JEWISH OBSERVER (ISSN 0021-6615) Is Published Monthly, Except July and August, by the Agudath Israel of America, S Beekman Street, New York, N.Y
    Being a ]eve is ~~~;!~ply a '";<"l' of a way of thinkin ,;!its weH!: Ever nccepr thirte~!l,. s. Thhe piled by ~1\q~i: oshe ben make hiI11,a.J!'~'i · . The~Be belief so .. co··. <Jr doubt: Basffolll.< At Rockefeller Center or The Empire State Building UMB Means Business. Commercial banking is easier now that New Yorkers have a choice. They can bank uptown or downtown at UMB Bank & Trust Company. Whether your commercial interests stretch across town or across oceans, UMB crafts its multitude of services to meet your special needs. And, there are so many services-commercial loans, domestic and international money market operations, import· export arrangements, letters of credit and many more. As we are increasing our branches, we are increasing the scope and flexibility of UMB. So, besides adding a new location, we're adding more of the finest commercial and international banking professionals to tailor our services to your business needs. Service and knowledge-it's our special combination that has made us a top choice here in New York and worldwide. Remember, banking with UMB means business. Closed on all Jewish Holidays. /ih'\ UMB BANK ~:I AND TRUST COMPANY Head Office Rockefeller Center Empire State Branch 630 Fifth Avenue 350 Fifth Avenue New York, NY 10111 New York, NY 10118 212-541-8070 212·947 ·3611 A subsidiary of Established in 1923 Depositors Now Insured United Mizrahi Bank l TD., Worldw:de Assets Up To $100,000 Israel Exceed $3 Billion Member FDIC THE JEWISH OBSERVER (ISSN 0021-6615) is published monthly, except July and August, by the Agudath Israel of America, S Beekman Street, New York, N.Y.
    [Show full text]
  • OF 17Th 2004 Gender Relationships in Marriage and Out.Pdf (1.542Mb)
    Gender Relationships In Marriage and Out Edited by Rivkah Blau Robert S. Hirt, Series Editor THE MICHAEL SCHARF PUBLICATION TRUST of the YESHIVA UNIVERSITY PRESs New York OF 17 r18 CS2ME draft 8 balancediii iii 9/2/2007 11:28:13 AM THE ORTHODOX FORUM The Orthodox Forum, initially convened by Dr. Norman Lamm, Chancellor of Yeshiva University, meets each year to consider major issues of concern to the Jewish community. Forum participants from throughout the world, including academicians in both Jewish and secular fields, rabbis,rashei yeshivah, Jewish educators, and Jewish communal professionals, gather in conference as a think tank to discuss and critique each other’s original papers, examining different aspects of a central theme. The purpose of the Forum is to create and disseminate a new and vibrant Torah literature addressing the critical issues facing Jewry today. The Orthodox Forum gratefully acknowledges the support of the Joseph J. and Bertha K. Green Memorial Fund at the Rabbi Isaac Elchanan Theological Seminary established by Morris L. Green, of blessed memory. The Orthodox Forum Series is a project of the Rabbi Isaac Elchanan Theological Seminary, an affiliate of Yeshiva University OF 17 r18 CS2ME draft 8 balancedii ii 9/2/2007 11:28:13 AM Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Orthodox Forum (17th : 2004 : New York, NY) Gender relationships in marriage and out / edited by Rivkah Blau. p. cm. – (Orthodox Forum series) ISBN 978-0-88125-971-1 1. Marriage. 2. Marriage – Religious aspects – Judaism. 3. Marriage (Jewish law) 4. Man-woman relationships – Religious aspects – Judaism. I.
    [Show full text]
  • 2006 Shevat 5766
    Table of Contents A Message from the President of NAASE Glenn Easton ................................................................................................................................ 1 EDITORS: Bernard Goldblatt, FSA Adath Jeshurun Congregation, Minnetonka, Minnesota B’reishit — The Beginning: A Message from the Editors David I. Rothenberg, FSA, ATz Bernie Goldblatt and David I. Rothenberg ............................................................................ 2 Beth Israel Congregation, Owings Mills, Maryland EDITORIAL BOARD: The Synagogue Director and Financial Development: Glenn Easton, FSA, ATz Gilbert Kleiner, FSA Old Myths and New Realities Harry Hauser Marc M. Neiwirth, FSA, ATz Amir Pilch ...................................................................................................................................... 3 Rebecca B. Holmes Allan Ross, FSA Malcolm Katz, FSA Nadine Strauss Establishing Visual Identity Guidelines for Your Congregation Robert D. Festenstein .................................................................................................................. 8 HONORARY PRESIDENT Robert E. Hill, FSA Temple Emanu-El , Providence, RI The Executive Director as an Instrument of Holiness PRESIDENT Marc M. Neiwirth .......................................................................................................................11 Glenn S. Easton, FSA, ATz Adas Israel Congregation, Washington, DC Teshuvot by the Committee on Jewish Law and Standards FIRST VICE PRESIDENT that Affect Synagogue
    [Show full text]
  • Halacha Defining Death Jewish Medical Ethics: the Brain Death Controversy in Jewish Law by Rabbi Yitzchok A
    החידון המדע הירושלמי Jerusalem Science Contest Part 3, Slides 14 thru 21 Jewish Law Decisions Halacha defining death Jewish Medical Ethics: The Brain Death Controversy in Jewish Law by Rabbi Yitzchok A. Breitowitz, 1996 Rabbi Breitowitz received his Rabbinical Ordination from the Ner Israel Rabbinical College in 1976; B.S. with honors from Johns Hopkins University; J.D (magna cum laude) from Harvard Law School in 1979; and a Doctorate in Talmudic Law from Ner Israel in 1992. He has lectured extensively throughout the US and Israel on medical, business, and family ethics. He has published numerous articles on bankruptcy, commercial law, medical ethics, family law, and halakha.In addition to being the Rabbi of the Woodside Synagogue in SIlver Spring MD, Rabbi Breitowitz is a Professor of Law at the University of Maryland. The issues that need to be decided under Jewish Law. 1. Is irreversible dysfunction of the entire brain a valid criterion of death under Jewish Law? a. If No, then, such a person is alive. b. If Yes, the following issue must be decided: 2. Are the medical tests currently utilized in establishing such a condition valid indicators of its presence under Jewish Law? a. Which Tests? b. Are the tests being utilized in the patient’s facility tests that qualify under Jewish law? Mishnah Oholot 1:6 ָאָדם ֵאינֹו ְמַטֵמא, ַעֶׁדשֵתֵצאַ נְפשֹו. ַוֲאִפּלּוְ מֻגָּיד, ַוֲאִפּלּוֵ גֹוסס. זֹוֵקק ַלִיּבּום ּופֹוֵטִר מןַ הִיּבּום, ַמֲאִכילַ ּבְתָּרּומהֵּופֹוסלַ ּבְתָּרּומה. וְכֵן ְּבֵהָּמהְ וַחָּיה ֵאָּינןְמַטְמִאין, ַעדֶׁ שֵתֵצאַ נְפָּשם. ֻהְתזּוָ רֵאשֶׁיהם, ַאףַ עִּל פיֶׁ שְמַפְרְכִּסים, ְטֵמִּאים, ְכָּגֹון זָּנֶׁב של ְלָּטָּאהֶׁשִהיא ְמַפְרָּכֶׁסת: A person does not defile [as a corpse] until he dies.
    [Show full text]
  • REVIEW What Makes a Book Orthodox? Wrestling with God And
    REVIEW What Makes a Book Orthodox? Wrestling With God and Men by Steve Greenberg Reviewed by Asher Lopatin Abstract: This review focuses on whether Wrestling With God and Men can be considered an Orthodox work. It concludes that due to a lack of confidence in Orthodoxy, the book’s dearth of Orthodox sources and its failure to utilize the halakhic system to solve the problems it raises, Wrestling will not become part of the Orthodox library. Nevertheless, Orthodoxy is open to innovation, controversy, and potentially a new attitude towards homosexuality. Biography: Rabbi Asher Lopatin is the spiritual leader of Anshe Sholom B’nai Israel Congregation, a leading Modern Orthodox synagogue in Chicago. A Rhodes Scholar and a Wexner graduate, he holds a Master of Philosophy in Medieval Arabic Thought from Oxford University, and ordination from both Rabbi Isaac Elchanan Theological Seminary of Yeshiva University and Brisk Rabbinical College. The Edah Journal 4:2 Edah Inc. © 2004 Kislev 5765 2 REVIEW What Makes a Book Orthodox? Wrestling With God and Men by Steve Greenberg (University of Wisconsin Press: 2004;304 pages) Reviewed by Asher Lopatin When Rav Moshe Feinstein, zt”l, agreed to write an Wrestling With God and Men part of the tradition of haskamahh, an approbation for a book of halakhah, Orthodox Torah—the masoret or shalshelet ha- almost invariably he would write something like: “I qabbalah—worthy of a generic haskamah of an have received with joy a new book by the author, Orthodox gadol, or just an intelligent study, similar ha-rav ha-ga’on So and So, who is a God fearing and to academic or popular non-Orthodox works on righteous man.
    [Show full text]
  • An Online Journal of Applied Jewish Thought Vol. IV: Issue 1–2 | Fall–Winter 2019–2020/ 5779–5780
    ISSN 2577–4921 Zeramim: An Online Journal of Applied Jewish Thought Vol. IV: Issue 1–2 | Fall–Winter 2019–2020/ 5779–5780 Zeramim: An Online Journal of Applied Jewish Thought Vol. IV: Issue 1–2 Fall–Winter 2019–2020 / 5779–5780 1 A LETTER FROM THE EDITORS Dear readers, We (the editors) like to read essays that raise interesting questions, and present for your consideration three such articles. Shai Cherry starts with a question raised by Abraham Joshua Heschel: how are we to understand the various Midrashic teachings that our prayers somehow strengthen or empower God? Analyzing a wide variety of texts, Shai Cherry suggests, in “The Camouflaged Ta’am (‘Motive’): Redemptive Implications of Rabbinic Theurgy,” that there is a critical messianic undercurrent to these teachings—and identifying that theme can perhaps help us to better contextualize their message. Another question: is there a common element in how we understand our own personal travails, and how we understand the travails of the People Israel generally? We often think of the Book of Job as addressed to the challenges we face as individuals. Nathan Moretto and Richard Claman, in “Reading Job (Iyyov) as a Stand-In for the People of Israel,” review, however, the curious history of how the Book of Job has been understood, by Martin Buber and others, as having a collective dimension. Lastly, the final of the Ten Commandments raises the curiosity of law that appears to try to regulate our inner thought-processes. Zachary James Silver, in “Mind Control? A Halachic and Meta- Halachic Investigation of Forbidden Thoughts” reviews how traditional commentators have struggled with this concept, and some approaches towards an answer.
    [Show full text]