CORRECTIONAL INSTITUTION INSPECTION COMMITTEE REPORT:

REVIEW OF ASSAULT DATA FROM THE OHIO DEPARTMENT OF REHABILITATION AND CORRECTION REGARDING OHIO PRISONS

Presented and Submitted by

CIIC Staff

February 23, 2006

2

TABLE OF CONTENTS PAGE

INTRODUCTION………..……………………………………………………………………….3 SUMMARY…………………………………………………………………………………….…4

I. INMATE ON STAFF ASSAULTS…………………………………………………8

A. Total Assaults 1. January 1, 2005 to December 15, 2005 2. November 2004 through October 2005………………………………10

B. Physical Assaults ………………………………………………………………12 1. January 1, 2005 to December 15, 2005 2. Southern Ohio Correctional Facility 1997 to December 28, 2005…………………………………………………...14

C. Harassment Assaults…………………………………………………………...15 1. January 1, 2005 to December 15, 2005 2. Southern Ohio Correctional Facility 1997 to December 28, 2005…………………..……………………………….17

D. Inappropriate Physical Contact Assaults…….………………………………18 1. January 1, 2005 to December 15, 2005 2. Southern Ohio Correctional Facility 1997 through December 28, 2005……………………..…………………………….19

E. Sexual Assault…………………………………….……………………………20 1. January 1, 2005 to December 15, 2005 2. Southern Ohio Correctional Facility 1997 through December 28, 2005……………………….…………………………..22

II. INMATE ON INMATE ASSAULTS……………………………………………..23

A. Total Assaults 1. November 2004 through October 2005 2. January – June 2005………………………………………………….25 B. Physical Assaults……………………………………………………………….27 1. January through June 2005 2. Southern Ohio Correctional Facility 2001 through October 12, 2005…………………………………………………….29 C. Harassment Assaults…………………………………………………………...32 1. January through June 2005 2. Southern Ohio Correctional Facility 2001 through October 12, 2005…………………………………………………….33

D. Sexual Assaults…………………………………………………………………34 1. January through June 2005 2. Southern Ohio Correctional Facility 2001 through October 12, 2005…………………………………………………….35

3

CORRECTIONAL INSTITUTION INSPECTION COMMITTEE REPORT: REVIEW OF ASSAULT DATA FROM THE OHIO DEPARMENT OF REHABILITATION AND CORRECTION REGARDING OHIO PRISONS

INTRODUCTION:

Although assault data is included in the CIIC Biennial Report of January 2005, the data is not among the statistics regularly provided on a monthly basis. Rather, the CIIC has periodically requested and received such data compiled by the ODRC Bureau of Research.

During the CIIC meeting on January 25, 2006, three Correctional Officers addressed the Committee, including two from the Southern Ohio Correctional Facility (SOCF). Their expressed concerns included an extremely serious inmate assault on an Officer at SOCF on December 5, 2005, related concerns about the incidence of inmate on staff and inmate on inmate violence at SOCF, including the murder of the reported leader of the Aryan Brotherhood by a Muslim inmate on September 26, 2005, and concerns about further related violence.

In partial follow-up to the areas of concern, CIIC staff requested updated data on assaults in Ohio prisons from the Ohio Department of Rehabilitation and Correction’s Bureau of Research. On January 31, 2006, the following assault data was provided:

· Inmate on Inmate Assault Report (January-June 2005) with Number of Assaults by Type at Each Institution · Inmate on Staff Assault Report (Jan. 1-Dec. 15, 2005) with Number of Assaults by Type at Each Institution · Reported Institutional Inmate-on-Inmate Assaults from November 2004 through October 2005 · Reported Institutional Inmate-on-Staff Assaults from November 2004 through October 2005 · SOCF Inmate-on-Inmate Assaults by Type of Assault in Calendar Years 2001- 2005 through October 12, 2005 · SOCF Inmate-on-Staff Assaults by Type of Assault in Calendar Years 1997- 2005 through December 28, 2005

The data is reported to be the most updated versions completed by the ODRC Bureau of Research. The Bureau of Research will provide the CIIC with updated assault data as they are created or updated in the future.

Following the Summary, detailed tables and findings are provided on Inmate on Staff Assaults and Inmate on Inmate Assaults.

4

SUMMARY

TOTAL INMATE ON STAFF ASSAULTS

January 1, 2005 to December 15, 2005

o Of the 536 Inmate on Staff Assaults system-wide in the period, the Southern Ohio Correctional Facility had the largest number with 169, comprising 31.5 percent of all such assaults.

o The Ohio Reformatory for Women had the second largest number of such assaults, with 37, comprising 6.9 percent of all such assaults.

o Mansfield and Chillicothe Correctional Institutions, and the Ohio State Penitentiary had from 32 to 34 such assaults in the period.

November 2004 through October 2005

o Of the 545 Inmate on Staff Assaults system-wide in the period, the Southern Ohio Correctional Facility had the largest number with 166, an average of 14 per month.

o The Ohio Reformatory for Women had the second largest number of such assaults, with 44, comprising 3.7 percent of all such assaults.

o The Ohio State Penitentiary and Mansfield Correctional Institution had the second and third largest number of such assaults, with 37 and 34 respectively.

SOCF 1997 To December 28, 2005

o In the nine-year period, there were 1,240 total Inmate Assaults on SOCF Staff, from a low of 105 in 2001 to a high of 193 in 1997.

o The 187 such assaults in 2005, rank second highest in the nine-year period.

INMATE ON STAFF PHYSICAL ASSAULTS

January 1, 2005 to December 15, 2005

o Of the 294 Inmate on Staff Physical Assaults system-wide in the period, nearly 60 percent were Minor Injury Assaults and over 29 percent resulted in No Injury.

o There were 32 Serious Injury Physical Assaults (Assaults requiring emergency medical treatment off prison grounds), comprising 10.9 percent of the Inmate on Staff Physical Assaults.

o The Southern Ohio Correctional Facility had the largest number of Inmate on Staff Physical Assaults in the period, with 69, of which 43 were Minor Injury Assaults and 17 resulted in “No Injury.” Nine of the Inmate on Staff Physical Assaults at SOCF were “Serious.”

o The Ohio Reformatory for Women had the second highest number of assaults with 24, followed closely by the Mansfield Correctional Institution and Ohio State Penitentiary with 22 and 21 respectively.

SOCF Physical Assaults 1997 to December 28, 2005

o Inmate Physical Assaults on SOCF Staff totaled 498 in the nine-year period, and comprised 40.2 percent of all Inmate Assaults on SOCF Staff.

o Physical Assaults on SOCF Staff ranged from a low of 37 in 2000 to a high of 75 in 2005.

5

o Minor Injury Physical Assaults totaled 282, the largest subgroup of Physical Assaults on SOCF Staff, from a low of 18 in 2000 to a high of 46 in 2005.

o No Injury Physical Assaults on SOCF Staff totaled 153 in the nine-year period, the second largest subgroup of Physical Assaults, from a low of 12 in 2001 to a high of 25 in 2002.

o Serious Injury Physical Assaults on SOCF Staff totaled 62 in the nine years, the smallest sub-group of Physical Assaults on staff, from a low of two in 1998 to a high of 10 in 2003 and in 2005.

INMATE ON STAFF HARASSMENT ASSAULT

Harassment assault is defined as “throwing, expelling or otherwise causing bodily substance to come into contact with another, or throwing any other liquid or material on or at another that does not result in any physical injury to victim.”

January 1, 2005 to December 15, 2005

o There were 202 Inmate on Staff Harassment Assaults system-wide in the period. o The Southern Ohio Correctional Facility had the largest number of such assaults, with 95. o The Chillicothe Correctional Institution had the second largest number with 18, followed by the Ohio Reformatory for Women with 12.

SOCF 1997 to December 28, 2005

o In the nine-year period, there were 707 Inmate on Staff Harassment Assaults at SOCF, from the low of 53 assaults in 2001 to a high of 122 incidents in 1997.

o There were 106 such assaults in 2005, the second highest in the nine-year period.

o The 707 Staff Harassment Assaults comprise 57 percent of total assaults on SOCF.

INMATE ON STAFF INAPPROPRIATE PHYSICAL CONTACT ASSAULT

Inappropriate Physical Contact Assault is defined as “physical resistance to a direct order, or the intentional grabbing, touching of a non-sexual nature, bumping into or pushing a staff member that does not result in any physical injury to the staff member.”

January 1, 2005 to December 15, 2005

o There were 30 incidents of Inappropriate Physical Contact Assault in the period, with the largest number at the Chillicothe Correctional Institution with nine, followed by SOCF with four incidents.

SOCF 1997 to December 28, 2005

o In the nine-year period SOCF had 27 such incidents, from a low of one incident in 2004 to a high of six incidents in 1998. o There were five incidents in 2005, ranking second highest in the period.

INMATE ON STAFF SEXUAL ASSAULT

Sexual Contact Assault is “any intentional touching of an erogenous zone of a staff member by an inmate.”

January 1, 2005 to December 15, 2005

o There was no attempted or completed Inmate on Staff Sexual Assault in the period. o There were ten Sexual Contact Assaults, one each at ten prisons.

SOCF 1997 to December 28, 2005

o In the nine-year period, there was one attempted sexual assault in 2001 at SOCF. o During the period, there were seven Sexual Contact Assaults, with one each from 1997 through 2000, two in 2002, and one in 2005.

6

TOTAL INMATE ON INMATE ASSAULTS

November 2004 through October 2005

o During the period, there were 483 Inmate on Inmate Assaults system-wide, with the largest number at the Southern Ohio Correctional Facility, which had 109 assaults, an average of 9.08 per month.

o North Central Correctional Institution had the second highest number of such assaults, with 32 in the period.

January – June 2005

o During the period, there were 249 Inmate on Inmate Assaults system-wide.

o The largest number of such assaults was at the Southern Ohio Correctional Facility, with 55 in the six- month period.

o The second largest number of such assaults was at the North Central Correctional Institution with 20 such assaults in the period.

SOCF 2001 to October 12, 2005

o Total Inmate on Inmate Assaults at SOCF ranged from a low of 85 in 2004 to a high of 145 in 2002. o Assaults in the five-year period averaged 117 per year. o The number of such assaults in 2004 and 2005 are below that average, and rank as the lowest two years of the five -year period in Total Inmate on Inmate Assaults.

INMATE ON INMATE PHYSICAL ASSAULTS

January – June 2005

o In the six-month period, there were 212 Inmate on Inmate Physical Assaults system-wide, with the largest number at the Southern Ohio Correctional Facility with 31. o The Oakwood Correctional Facility had the second largest number, with 18 in the period, followed closely by North Central Correctional Institution with 17. o Five other prisons had from 13 to 16 such assaults in the period, consisting of two level three (close security) prisons, Ross and Mansfield Correctional Institutions, and three level two (medium security) prisons, Richland, Noble and Southeastern Correctional Institutions. o The level four and five (maximum and high maximum security) Ohio State Penitentiary had only three such assaults. o The level three (close security) Toledo and Lebanon, Correctional Institutions had only two such assaults, while the level three Warren and Trumbull Correctional Institutions had only four such assaults in the period.

SOCF 2001 TO October 12, 2005

o The 190 physical assaults in the five-year period ranged from a low of 28 in 2001 to a high of 49 in 2005. o The number of physical assaults increased from 2001 through 2004 by 11 in 2002 and by five in 2003, followed by a decrease of 14 in 2004 to 30, the second lowest number of such assaults in the period.

o The largest subgroup of physical assaults at SOCF were Minor Injury Physical Assaults, with a total of 106, comprising 56 percent of the 190 Physical Assaults. o Minor Injury Physical Assaults ranged from the low of 12 in 2001 to a high of 28 in 2003, with a decrease to 17 in 2004, and an increase of four in 2005.

o The second largest subgroup of physical assaults were No Injury Assaults, with 53, comprising 28 percent of all physical assaults at SOCF in the five-year period. o No Injury assaults ranged from a low of six in 2003 to a high of 22 in 2005. Such assaults increased by 14 from 2004 to 2005.

o Serious Injury Physical Assaults totaled 34 in the five years, comprising 18 percent of the total Physical Assaults. 7

o Serious Injury Physical Assaults ranged from the low of five in 2004, to a high of 10 in 2003. There were six such assaults in 2005.

INMATE ON INMATE HARASSMENT ASSAULT

January – June 2005

o The 35 Inmate on Inmate Harassment Assaults system-wide only occurred at eight prisons. o The largest number occurred at the Southern Ohio Correctional Facility, with 24 such assaults, comprising 69 percent of all such assaults in the prison system. o The Lake Erie Correctional Institution had the second largest number of such assaults, with three. Two facilities had two incidents, and four facilities had one incident in the period.

SOCF 2001 through October 12, 2005

o In the five-year period, there were 394 Inmate on Inmate Harassment Assaults at SOCF, from a low of 50 in 2005 to a high of 106 in 2002. o Such assaults decreased by 11 from 2002 to 2003, decreased by 42 in 2004, and decreased by three in 2005.

INMATE ON INMATE SEXUAL ASSAULTS

January through June 2005

o In the six-month period, there were no reports of attempted or completed sexual assault in the entire prison system. o There were only two reports of Sexual Contact Assault, (any intentional touching of an erogenous zone) in the entire prison system, one each at Madison and North Central Correctional Institutions.

o The total absence of reports on even attempted sexual assault in the entire prison system in the first six months of 2005 prompts questions and concerns about the extent to which progress has been made in: o Addressing the factors which prevent victims from reporting the victimization in the prison environment, and o Ensuring that all incidents are appropriately documented in the Sexual Assault data.

SOCF 2001 to October 12, 2005

o In the five-year period at SOCF, there were reportedly three Completed Sexual Assaults, two in 2004 and one in 2005. o There were no reports of attempted sexual assault or sexual contact assault. o Based on information relayed on February 16, 2006 by the Investigator, there have been no confirmed sexual assaults at SOCF in 2004 or 2005. There were reportedly two alleged sexual assaults in July 2005, which were determined to be consensual sexual acts.

o Based on the above, there is an apparent need to distinguish between alleged sexual assaults, investigations of such allegations, and verified incidents in the reporting system.

8

I. INMATE ON STAFF ASSAULTS A. TOTAL ASSAULTS 1. JANUARY 1, 2005 TO DECEMBER 15, 2005

Inmate on Staff Total Assaults From January 1, 2005 to December 15, 2005 by Institution

Institution Total Southern Ohio Correctional Facility 169 Ohio Reformatory for Women 37 Mansfield Correctional Institution 34 Ohio State Penitentiary 34 Chillicothe Correctional Institution 32 North Central Correctional Institution 28 Lebanon Correctional Institution 25 Belmont Correctional Institution 21 Oakwood Correctional Facility 19 Allen Correctional Institution 16 Richland Correctional Institution 15 Madison Correctional Institution 12 Correctional Reception Center 12 North Coast Correctional Treatment Facility 10 Grafton Correctional Institution 8 Lake Erie Correctional Institution 8 Ross Correctional Institution 8 Trumbull Correctional Institution 8 Warren Correctional Institution 8 Pickaway Correctional Institution 7 Noble Correctional Institution 6 Lorain Correctional Institution 5 Toledo Correctional Institution 5 Southeastern Correctional Institution 4 Corrections Medical Center 2 Montgomery Education and Pre Release Center 2 Dayton Correctional Institution 1 Franklin Pre Release Center 0 Hocking Correctional Facility 0 London Correctional Institution 0 Marion Correctional Institution 0 Northeast Pre Release Center 0

Total 536

9

o There were 536 Inmate on Staff Assaults system-wide from January 1, 2005 to December 15, 2005. o Five prisons had no such assaults: Franklin and Northeast Pre-Release Centers, Marion and London Correctional Institutions, and the Hocking Correctional Facility. o The number of assaults ranged from one at the Dayton Correctional Institution to 169 assaults at the Southern Ohio Correctional Facility, comprising 31.5 percent of all assaults. o The Ohio Reformatory for Women had the second largest number of inmate on staff assaults, with 37. The Ohio State Penitentiary and Mansfield Correctional Institution each had 34 such assaults. o The facilities with 10 or more incidents are listed below:

Facility Number Percent

Southern Ohio Correctional Facility 169 31.5%

Ohio Reformatory for Women 37 6.9 Mansfield Correctional Institution 34 6.3 Ohio State Penitentiary 34 6.3 Chillicothe Correctional Institution 32 6.0

North Central Correctional Institution 28 5.2 Lebanon Correctional Institution 25 4.7 Belmont Correctional Institution 21 3.9 Oakwood Correctional Facility 19 3.5 Allen Correctional Institution 16 3.0 Richland Correctional Institution 15 2.8 Madison Correctional Institution 12 2.2 Correctional Reception Center 12 2.2 North Coast Correctional Treatment Facility 10 1.9

(All Other Facilities Subtotal) (72) (13.4)

Total 536 100%

10

I. INMATE ON STAFF ASSAULTS A. TOTAL ASSAULTS 2. NOVEMBER 2004 THROUGH OCTOBER 2005

Inmate-on-Staff Assaults From November 2004 through October 2005 With Monthly Average and Breakdown by Institution

Institution 12-Month Total Average/Month Southern Ohio Correctional Facility 166 13.83 Ohio Reformatory for Women 44 3.67 Ohio State Penitentiary 37 3.08 Mansfield Correctional Institution 34 2.83 North Central Correctional Institution 29 2.42 Chillicothe Correctional Institution 29 2.42 Lebanon Correctional Institution 24 2.00 Oakwood Correctional Facility 22 1.83 Belmont Correctional Institution 18 1.50 Madison Correctional Institution 15 1.25 Correctional Reception Center 14 1.17 Richland Correctional Institution 13 1.08 Grafton Correctional Institution 10 0.83 Pickaway Correctional Institution 10 0.83 Allen Correctional Institution 9 0.75 Ross Correctional Institution 9 0.75 Warren Correctional Institution 9 0.75 Trumbull Correctional Institution 8 0.67 Lake Erie Correctional Institution 7 0.58 Noble Correctional Institution 6 0.50 Toledo Correctional Institution 6 0.50 Southeastern Correctional Institution 5 0.42 Lorain Correctional Institution 5 0.42 Marion Correctional Institution 5 0.42 North Coast Correctional Treatment Facility 5 0.42 Montgomery Education and Pre Release Center 3 0.25 Corrections Medical Center 1 0.08 London Correctional Institution 1 0.08 Dayton Correctional Institution 1 0.08 Franklin Pre Release Center 0 0.00 Hocking Correctional Facility 0 0.00 Northeast Pre Release Center 0 0.00

Total for All Institutions 545 (One Yr.) 45.42 (Avg. per Month)

11 o From November 2004 through October 2005, there were 545 Inmate on Staff Assaults system-wide. o There were no assaults at three prisons: Franklin Pre-Release and Northeast Pre-Release Centers, and the Hocking Correctional Facility, and only one assault each at three prisons : the Dayton and London Correctional Institutions, and Corrections Medical Center o The largest number of assaults occurred at the Southern Ohio Correctional Facility with 166 assaults in the period, an average of 14 per month. o The Ohio Reformatory for Women had the second largest number of assaults in the period, with 44, an average of four assaults per month, followed closely by the Ohio State Penitentiary and Mansfield Correctional Institution with 37 and 34 respectively. o The 12 facilities with the most incidents of inmate on staff assaults are listed below:

FACILITY NUMBER MONTHLY AVERAGE

Southern Ohio CF 166 13.83

Ohio Reformatory for Women 44 3.67 Ohio State Penitentiary 37 3.08 Mansfield CI 34 2.83

North Central CI 29 2.42 Chillicothe CI 29 2.42

Lebanon CI 24 2.00 Oakwood CF 22 1.83

Belmont CI 18 1.50 Madison CI 15 1.25 Corr Reception Center 14 1.17 Richland CI 13 1.08

(All other facilities) 100

TOTAL 545

12

I. INMATE ON STAFF ASSAULTS B. PHYSICAL ASSAULTS 1. JANUARY 1, 2005 THROUGH DECEMBER 15, 2005

Inmate on Staff Physical Assaults From January 1, 2005 Through December 15, 2005 With Breakdown By Institution and Seriousness of Assault

Institution Serious Minor No Injury Total Southern Ohio Correctional Facility 9 43 17 69 Ohio Reformatory for Women 1 12 11 24 Mansfield Correctional Institution 3 14 5 22 Ohio State Penitentiary 1 11 9 21 Oakwood Correctional Facility 6 10 2 18 Lebanon Correctional Institution 0 15 2 17 North Central Correctional Institution 1 9 6 16 Belmont Correctional Institution 1 8 4 13 Allen Correctional Institution 1 6 4 11 Correctional Reception Center 2 3 4 9 Madison Correctional Institution 1 6 2 9 Richland Correctional Institution 0 5 4 9 Warren Correctional Institution 1 6 0 7 Grafton Correctional Institution 0 5 0 5 Noble Correctional Institution 3 1 1 5 North Coast Correctional Treatment Facility 0 2 3 5 Trumbull Correctional Institution 0 4 1 5 Chillicothe Correctional Institution 0 3 1 4 Lake Erie Correctional Institution 0 4 0 4 Pickaway Correctional Institution 0 3 1 4 Ross Correctional Institution 2 0 2 4 Toledo Correctional Institution 0 3 1 4 Southeastern Correctional Institution 0 0 3 3 Corrections Medical Center 0 0 2 2 Lorain Correctional Institution 0 2 0 2 Dayton Correctional Institution 0 0 1 1 Montgomery Education and Pre Release Center 0 1 0 1 Franklin Pre Release Center 0 0 0 0 Hocking Correctional Facility 0 0 0 0 London Correctional Institution 0 0 0 0 Marion Correctional Institution 0 0 0 0 Northeast Pre Release Center 0 0 0 0

Total 32 176 86 294 Percent 10.9% 59.9% 29.3% 100%

o Serious Injury Physical Assault- an assault requiring treatment at a medical facility off prison grounds. Such injuries would include stab wounds, cut requiring stitches, concussion/severe head trauma, fractures, serious eye injuries, spinal cord or other nerve damage, severe bite wounds or serious joint sprains.

13

· There were 294 inmate on staff physical assaults system-wide from January 1, 2005 to December 15, 2005.

· Of the assaults, nearly 60 percent were “Minor,” and over 29 percent resulted in “no injury.”

· A total of 32 “Serious Injury Physical Assaults” were reported, comprising 10.9 percent of the inmate on staff physical assaults. A serious injury physical assault is an assault requiring emergency treatment at a medical facility off prison grounds. Such injuries would include stab wounds, cuts requiring stitches, concussions/severe head trauma, fractures, serious eye injuries, spinal cord or other nerve damage, severe bite wounds or serious joint sprain.

· Five prisons had no reported physical assaults: Northeast and Franklin Pre- Release Centers, London and Marion Correctional Institution, and Hocking Correctional Facility.

· The remainder ranged from a low of one assault each at the Montgomery Education and Pre-Release Center and Dayton Correctional Institution, to a high of 69 at the Southern Ohio Correctional Facility.

· The Ohio Reformatory for Women had the second highest number of assaults, with 24, followed closely by the Mansfield Correctional Institution and Ohio State Penitentiary with 22 and 21 respectively.

14

I. INMATE ON STAFF ASSAULTS B. PHYSICAL ASSAULTS 2. 1997 TO DECEMBER 28, 2005 AT SOCF

Inmate on Staff Physical Assaults at the Southern Ohio Correctional Facility With Breakdown by Year and Seriousness of Assault from 1997 to December 28, 2005

Serious Minor No Injury Physical Total Assaults Assault Total YEAR N % N % N % N % N %

1997 9 4.7% 39 20.2% 18 9.3% 66 34.2% 193 100% 1998 2 1.5% 35 25.5% 13 9.5% 50 36.5% 137 100% 1999 4 3.3% 28 23.1% 13 10.7% 45 37.2% 121 100% 2000 6 5.7% 18 17.0% 13 12.3% 37 34.9% 106 100% 2001 5 4.8% 32 30.5% 12 11.4% 49 46.7% 105 100% 2002 9 6.3% 30 21.1% 25 17.6% 64 45.1% 142 100% 2003 10 7.7% 28 21.5% 20 15.4% 58 44.6% 130 100% 2004 7 5.9% 27 22.7% 20 16.8% 54 45.4% 119 100% 2005 10 5.3% 46 24.6% 19 10.2% 75 40.1% 187 100%

TOTAL 62 5.0% 282 22.8% 153 12.3% 498 40.2% 1,240 100%

· Inmate Physical Assaults on Staff totaled 498 in the nine-year period, and comprised 40.2 percent of all inmate assaults on staff.

· Physical Assaults on staff ranged from a low of 37 in 2000 to a high of 75 in 2005.

· Minor Physical Assaults totaled 282, comprising the largest subgroup of Physical Assaults on staff. Minor Physical Assaults ranged from a low of 18 in 2000 to a high of 46 in 2005.

· No Injury Physical Assaults on Staff totaled 153 in the nine-year period, comprising the second largest group of physical assaults. They ranged from a low of 12 in 2001 to a high of 25 in 2002

· A Serious Injury Physical Assault is an assault requiring emergency treatment at a medical facility off prison grounds. Such injuries would include stab wounds, cuts requiring stitches, concussions/severe head trauma, fractures, serious eye injuries, spinal cord or other nerve damage, severe bite wounds or serious joint sprain.

· Serious Injury Physical Assaults totaled 62 in the nine-year period, and comprised the smallest sub-group of Physical Assaults on staff.

· Serious Injury Physical Assaults ranged from a low of two in 1998 to a high of 10 such assaults in 2003 and also in 2005.

15

I. INMATE ON STAFF ASSAULTS C. HARASSMENT ASSAULT 1. JANUARY 1, 2005 TO DECEMBER 15, 2005

Inmate on Staff Harassment Assaults From January 1, 2005 to December 15, 2005 With Breakdown by Institution

Institution Total Southern Ohio Correctional Facility 95 Chillicothe Correctional Institution 18 Ohio Reformatory for Women 12 North Central Correctional Institution 11 Ohio State Penitentiary 11 Mansfield Correctional Institution 10 Lebanon Correctional Institution 8 Richland Correctional Institution 5 Ross Correctional Institution 4 Allen Correctional Institution 4 Belmont Correctional Institution 4 Grafton Correctional Institution 3 Lorain Correctional Institution 3 Trumbull Correctional Institution 3 Madison Correctional Institution 2 North Coast Correctional Treatment Facility 2 Pickaway Correctional Institution 2 Correctional Reception Center 1 Lake Erie Correctional Institution 1 Oakwood Correctional Facility 1 Southeastern Correctional Institution 1 Toledo Correctional Institution 1 Montgomery Education and Pre Release Center 0 Warren Correctional Institution 0 Noble Correctional Institution 0 Corrections Medical Center 0 Dayton Correctional Institution 0 Franklin Pre Release Center 0 Hocking Correctional Facility 0 London Correctional Institution 0 Marion Correctional Institution 0 Northeast Pre Release Center 0

Total 202

*Harassment Assault- throwing, expelling or othe rwise causing bodily substance to come into contact with another, or throwing any other liquid or material on or at another that does not result in any physical injury to victim.

16

· Harassment Assault is defined as throwing, expelling or otherwise causing a bodily substance to come into contact with another, or throwing another liquid or material on or at another that does not result in any physical injury to the victim.

· There were 202 incidents of “Harassment Assault” from January 1, 2005 to December 15, 2005.

· Ten institutions had no such incidents: The three Pre-Release Centers, the Corrections Medical Center, Hocking Correctional Facility, and the Dayton, London, Marion, Noble, and Warren Correctional Institutions.

· At the remaining institutions, there was one incident each at five facilities. and the largest number of incidents was at the Southern Ohio Correctional Facility, with 95 such incidents, comprising 47 percent of all harassment assault incidents.

· The Chillicothe Correctional Institution had the second largest number of incidents of inmate on staff harassment, with 18 such incidents.

· The seven prisons with the largest number of such incidents are:

Facility Number of Incidents Percent

Southern Ohio Correctional Facility 95 47.0%

Chillicothe Correctional Institution 18 8.9

Ohio Reformatory for Women 12 5.9 North Central Correctional Institution 11 5.4 Ohio State Penitentiary 11 5.4 Mansfield Correctional Institution 10 5.0 Lebanon Correctional Institution 8 4.0

Other Facilities Subtotal 37 18.3%

Total Incidents System-Wide 202 100%

17

I. INMATE ON STAFF ASSAULT C. HARASSMENT ASSAULT 2. SOCF 1997 TO DECEMBER 28, 2005

Inmate on Staff Harassment Assaults at the Southern Ohio Correctional Facility From 1997 to December 28, 2005 With Breakdown by Year

Harassment Total Total Assaults YEAR N % N % 1997 122 63.2 193 100% 1998 80 58.4 137 100% 1999 72 59.5 121 100% 2000 66 62.3 106 100% 2001 53 50.5 105 100% 2002 74 52.1 142 100% 2003 70 53.8 130 100% 2004 64 53.8 119 100% 2005* 106 56.7 187 100%

TOTAL 707 57.0% 1,240 100%

· Harassment Assault is defined as throwing, expelling, or otherwise causing a bodily substance to come into contact with another, or throwing another liquid or material on or at another that does not result in any physical injury to the victim.

· In the nine-year period, there were 707 Inmate on Staff Harassment Assaults at the Southern Ohio Correctional Facility, ranging from the low of 53 incidents in 2001 to a high of 122 incidents in 1997. The number in 2005 with 106 incidents, ranks second highest in the nine-year period.

· The 707 Inmate on Staff Harassment Assaults in the nine-year period comprise 57 percent of the total assaults on staff.

18

I. INMATE ON STAFF ASSAULT D. INAPPROPRIATE PHYSICAL CONTACT 1. JANUARY – DECEMBER 15, 2005

Inmate on Staff Inappropriate Physical Contact Assault From January- December 15, 2005 By Institution

Institution Total Chillicothe Correctional Institution 9 Southern Ohio Correctional Facility 4 Belmont Correctional Institution 3 Lake Erie Correctional Institution 3 North Coast Correctional Treatment Facility 3 Ohio State Penitentiary 2 Ohio Reformatory for Women 1 Correctional Reception Center 1 Mansfield Correctional Institution 1 Montgomery Education and Pre Release Center 1 Pickaway Correctional Institution 1 Warren Correctional Institution 1 Oakwood Correctional Facility 0 Lebanon Correctional Institution 0 North Central Correctional Institution 0 Allen Correctional Institution 0 Madison Correctional Institution 0 Richland Correctional Institution 0 Grafton Correctional Institution 0 Noble Correctional Institution 0 Trumbull Correctional Institution 0 Ross Correctional Institution 0 Toledo Correctional Institution 0 Southeastern Correctional Institution 0 Corrections Medical Center 0 Lorain Correctional Institution 0 Dayton Correctional Institution 0 Franklin Pre Release Center 0 Hocking Correctional Facility 0 London Correctional Institution 0 Marion Correctional Institution 0 Northeast Pre Release Center 0

Total 30

· Inappropriate Physical Contact Assault is defined as physical resistance to a direct order, or the intentional grabbing, touching (of a non-sexual nature), bumping into or pushing a staff member that does not result in any physical injury to the staff member.

19

· Inappropriate Physical Contact is defined as “Physical resistance to a direct order, or the intentional grabbing, touching of a non-sexual nature, bumping into or pushing a staff member that does not result in any physical injury to the staff member. o There were 30 incidents of inappropriate physical contact by an inmate on a staff member from January 1, 2005 to December 15, 2005. o The incidents occurred at 12 prisons, ranging from one incident each at six institutions, to nine incidents at the Chillicothe Correctional Institution. The Southern Ohio Correctional Facility ranked second highest in the number of incidents, with four incidents.

I. INMATE ON STAFF ASSAULT D. INAPPROPRIATE PHYSICAL CONTACT 2. SOCF 1997 THROUGH DECEMBER 28, 2005

Inmate on Staff Inappropriate Physical Contact Assault At the Southern Ohio Correctional Facility From 1997 through December 28, 2005 With Breakdown by Year

Inappropriate Total Total Assaults YEAR N % N % 1997 4 2.1% 193 100% 1998 6 4.4% 137 100% 1999 3 2.5% 121 100% 2000 2 1.9% 106 100% 2001 2 1.9% 105 100% 2002 2 1.4% 142 100% 2003 2 1.5% 130 100% 2004 1 0.8% 119 100% 2005 5 2.7% 187 100%

TOTAL 27 2.2% 1,240 100.0%

· Inappropriate Physical Contact is defined as physical resistance to a direct order, or the intentional grabbing, touching (of a non-sexual nature) bumping into or pushing of a staff member that does not result in any physical injury to the staff member. · In the nine-year period, there were 27 incidents of inappropriate physical contact assault at the Southern Ohio Correctional Facility, ranging from the low of one incident in 2004, to a high of six incidents in 1998. There were five incidents in 2005, ranking second highest in number of such incidents. · The incidents of Inappropriate Physical Contact only comprise 2.2 percent of the total SOCF Inmate on Staff Assaults in the period. 20

I. INMATE ON STAFF ASSAULT E. SEXUAL ASSAULT 1. JANUARY – DECEMBER 15, 2005

Inmate on Staff Sexual Assault* From January - December 15, 2005 With Breakdown by Institution and by Assault Category

Institution Completed Attempted Contact Total Allen Correctional Institution 0 0 1 1 Belmont Correctional Institution 0 0 1 1 Chillicothe Correctional Institution 0 0 1 1 Correctional Reception Center 0 0 1 1 Mansfield Correctional Institution 0 0 1 1 Madison Correctional Institution 0 0 1 1 North Central Correctional Institution 0 0 1 1 Richland Correctional Institution 0 0 1 1 Southern Ohio Correctional Facility 0 0 1 1 Noble Correctional Institution 0 0 1 1 Ohio Reformatory for Women 0 0 0 0 Ohio State Penitentiary 0 0 0 0 Oakwood Correctional Facility 0 0 0 0 Lebanon Correctional Institution 0 0 0 0 Warren Correctional Institution 0 0 0 0 Grafton Correctional Institution 0 0 0 0 North Coast Correctional Treatment Fac. 0 0 0 0 Trumbull Correctional Institution 0 0 0 0 Lake Erie Correctional Institution 0 0 0 0 Pickaway Correctional Institution 0 0 0 0 Ross Correctional Institution 0 0 0 0 Toledo Correctional Institution 0 0 0 0 Southeastern Correctional Institution 0 0 0 0 Corrections Medical Center 0 0 0 0 Lorain Correctional Institution 0 0 0 0 Dayton Correctional Institution 0 0 0 0 Montgomery Education and Pre Rls. Cnt. 0 0 0 0 Franklin Pre Release Center 0 0 0 0 Hocking Correctional Facility 0 0 0 0 London Correctional Institution 0 0 0 0 Marion Correctional Institution 0 0 0 0 Northeast Pre Release Center 0 0 0 0

Total 0 0 10** 10

* Sexual Assault- non-consensual anal or vaginal penetration or oral sex forced on the staff member by the inmate. ** Sexual Contact Assault- any intentional touching of an erogenous zone of a staff member by an inmate, including the thighs, genitals, buttock, pubic region, or breast (for female staff). 21

· There were no attempted or completed sexual assaults from January 1, 2005 to December 15, 2005 in any Ohio prison.

· A total of ten Inmate on Staff Sexual Contact Assaults were reported from January 1, 2005 to December 15, 2005, with one each at ten facilities: Allen, Belmont, Chillicothe, Madison, Mansfield, North Central, Richland, and Noble Correctional Institutions, the Correctional Reception Center, and the Southern Ohio Correctional Facility.

· All such assaults were reported to be “contact” or “Sexual Contact Assaults” which is defined as “any intentional touching of an erogenous zone of a staff member by an inmate.”

22

I. INMATE ON STAFF ASSAULT E. SEXUAL ASSAULT 2. SOCF 1997 THROUGH DECEMBER 28, 2005

Inmate on Staff Sexual Assaults at the Southern Ohio Correctional Facility by Year and Type of Sexual Assault From 1997 through December 28, 2005

Completed Attempted Contact Total Sexual Assaults Total Assaults YEAR N N N N N

1997 0 0 1 1 193 1998 0 0 1 1 137 1999 0 0 1 1 121 2000 0 0 1 1 106 2001 0 1 0 1 105 2002 0 0 2 2 142 2003 0 0 0 0 130 2004 0 0 0 0 119 2005 0 0 1 1 187

TOTAL 0 1 7 8 1,240

· Sexual Assault- non-consensual anal penetration vaginal penetration or oral sex forced on the staff member by the inmate. · Sexual Contact Assault- any intentional touching of an erogenous zone of a staff member, including thighs, genitals, buttock or pubic region, or breast (for female staff). · During the nine-year period, there were eight incidents of Inmate on Staff Sexual Assault at the Southern Ohio Correctional Facility, ranging from no incidents in 2003 or 2004, to two incidents in 2002. · Of the eight incidents, all but one were incidents of “Sexual Contact Assault” (intentional touching). The one incident of Attempted Sexual Assault occurred in 2001.

23

II. INMATE ON INMATE ASSAULTS A. TOTAL ASSAULTS 1. NOVEMBER 2004 THROUGH OCTOBER 2005

Total Inmate on Inmate Assaults From November 2004 through October 2005 With Monthly Average and Breakdown by Institution

Institution 12-Month Total Average/Month Southern Ohio Correctional Facility 109 9.08 North Central Correctional Institution 32 2.67 Noble Correctional Institution 29 2.42 Southeastern Correctional Institution 28 2.33 Mansfield Correctional Institution 27 2.25 Oakwood Correctional Facility 26 2.17 Ross Correctional Institution 23 1.92 Ohio Reformatory for Women 22 1.83 Belmont Correctional Institution 20 1.67 Richland Correctional Institution 19 1.58 Madison Correctional Institution 17 1.42 Chillicothe Correctional Institution 14 1.17 Lake Erie Correctional Institution 13 1.08 Trumbull Correctional Institution 13 1.08 Allen Correctional Institution 12 1.00 Lorain Correctional Institution 11 0.92 North Coast Correctional Treatment Facility 10 0.83 Correctional Reception Center 9 0.75 Warren Correctional Institution 7 0.58 Grafton Correctional Institution 6 0.50 Lebanon Correctional Institution 6 0.50 London Correctional Institution 6 0.50 Ohio State Penitentiary 6 0.50 Pickaway Correctional Institution 5 0.42 Franklin Pre Release Center 3 0.25 Marion Correctional Institution 3 0.25 Toledo Correctional Institution 3 0.25 Corrections Medical Center 1 0.08 Hocking Correctional Facility 1 0.08 Montgomery Education and Pre Release 1 0.08 Center Northeast Pre Release Center 1 0.08 Dayton Correctional Institution 0 0.00

TOTAL FOR ALL INSTITUTIONS 483 (One Year 40.25 (Avg. per Total) Month)

24

· During the 12-month period there were 483 Inmate on Inmate Assaults system- wide.

· There were no such assaults at the Dayton Correctional Institution.

· At the remaining institutions, such assaults ranged from one each at the Northeast and Montgomery Pre-Release Centers, Hocking Correctional Facility and Corrections Medical Center, to a high of 109 at the Southern Ohio Correctional Facility.

· A monthly average of nine Inmate on Inmate Assaults occurred at the Southern Ohio Correctional Facility.

· The North Central Correctional Institution had the second highest number of Inmate on Inmate Assaults, with 32 in the 12-month period.

· The prisons with ten or more Inmate on Inmate Assaults in the 12-month period are provided below:

Facility Number of Assaults

Southern Ohio CF 109

North Central CI 32

Noble CI 29 Southeastern CI 28 Mansfield CI 27 Oakwood CF 26

Ross CI 23 Ohio Reformatory for Women 22 Belmont CI 20

Richland CI 19 Madison CI 17 Chillicothe CI 14

Lake Erie CI 13 Trumbull CI 13 Allen CI 12 Lorain CI 11 North Coast CTF 10

All Other Facilities 58

Total 483

25

II. INMATE ON INMATE ASSAULTS A. TOTAL ASSAULTS 2. JANUARY – JUNE 2005

Inmate on Inmate Assaults From January - June 2005 with Breakdown by Institution

Institution Total Southern Ohio Correctional Facility 55 North Central Correctional Institution 20 Oakwood Correctional Facility 18 Southeastern Correctional Institution 17 Noble Correctional Institution 15 Mansfield Correctional Institution 14 Richland Correctional Institution 13 Ross Correctional Institution 13 Lake Erie Correctional Institution 9 Madison Correctional Institution 9 Ohio Reformatory for Women 9 Allen Correctional Institution 7 Belmont Correctional Institution 7 Chillicothe Correctional Institution 7 North Coast Correctional Treatment Facility 5 Pickaway Correctional Institution 5 Correctional Reception Center 4 Trumbull Correctional Institution 4 Ohio State Penitentiary 3 Warren Correctional Institution 3 Franklin Pre Release Center 2 Grafton Correctional Institution 2 Lorain Correctional Institution 2 Lebanon Correctional Institution 2 London Correctional Institution 2 Toledo Correctional Institution 2 Corrections Medical Center 0 Dayton Correctional Institution 0 Hocking Correctional Facility 0 Marion Correctional Institution 0 Montgomery Education and Pre R. Center 0 Northeast Pre-Release Center 0

Total 249

26

· During the first six months in 2005, there were 249 Inmate on Inmate Assaults system-wide.

· There were no such assaults at six prisons: Corrections Medical Center, Hocking Correctional Facility, Dayton and Marion Correctional Institutions, and the Montgomery and Northeast Pre-Release Centers.

· Inmate on Inmate Assaults ranged from two each at six prisons, to a high of 55 at the Southern Ohio Correctional Facility.

· The North Central Correctional Facility ranked second highest, with 20 Inmate on Inmate Assaults in the six month period.

· The prisons with ten or more assaults in the period are listed below:

Facility Inmate on Inmate Assaults

Southern Ohio CF 55

North Central CI 20 Oakwood CF 18 Southeastern CI 17 Noble CI 15 Mansfield CI 14 Richland CI 13 Ross CI 13

(All Other Facilities) (75)

TOTAL 249

27

II. INMATE ON INMATE ASSAULTS B. PHYSICAL ASSAULTS 1. JANUARY THROUGH JUNE 2005

Inmate on Inmate Physical Assaults From January through June 2005 With Breakdown by Type and Institution

Institution Serious Minor No Total Injury Southern Ohio Correctional Facility 4 16 11 31 Oakwood Correctional Facility 0 11 7 18 North Central Correctional Institution 7 10 0 17 Southeastern Correctional Institution 6 8 2 16 Noble Correctional Institution 3 11 1 15 Mansfield Correctional Institution 8 6 0 14 Richland Correctional Institution 9 3 1 13 Ross Correctional Institution 4 8 1 13 Ohio Reformatory for Women 1 7 1 9 Madison Correctional Institution 3 4 1 8 Belmont Correctional Institution 3 2 2 7 Chillicothe Correctional Institution 0 5 1 6 Lake Erie Correctional Institution 0 6 0 6 Allen Correctional Institution 0 5 0 5 North Coast Correctional Treatment Facility 0 5 0 5 Correctional Reception Center 0 4 0 4 Pickaway Correctional Institution 3 1 0 4 Trumbull Correctional Institution 2 2 0 4 Ohio State Penitentiary 2 1 0 3 Warren Correctional Institution 1 2 0 3 Franklin Pre Release Center 0 1 1 2 Grafton Correctional Institution 1 1 0 2 Lebanon Correctional Institution 1 1 0 2 London Correctional Institution 1 1 0 2 Toledo Correctional Institution 1 1 0 2 Lorain Correctional Institution 1 0 0 1 Corrections Medical Center 0 0 0 0 Dayton Correctional Institution 0 0 0 0 Hocking Correctional Facility 0 0 0 0 Marion Correctional Institution 0 0 0 0 Montgomery Education and Pre Release 0 0 0 0 Center Northeast Pre-Release Center 0 0 0 0

Total 61 122 29 212 28

· In the six-month period, there were 212 Inmate on Inmate Physical Assaults system-wide.

· Six prisons had no assaults: Northeast and Montgomery Pre-Release Centers, Dayton and Marion Correctional Institutions, Corrections Medical Center and Hocking Correctional Facility.

· Of the 212 Inmate on Inmate Physical Assaults, 122 (58%) were categorized as “Minor” and 29 were categorized as “No Injury”.

· There were 61 “Serious” Inmate on Inmate Physical Assaults in the six- month period.

· Serious Injury Physical Assault is defined as an assault requiring treatment at a medical facility off prison grounds. Such injuries include stab wounds, cut requiring stitches, concussion/severe head trauma, fractures, serious eye injuries, spinal cord or other nerve damage, severe bite wounds or serious joint sprains.

· Serious Injury Physical Assaults ranged from zero at 12 prisons, and one each at seven prisons, to a high of nine at Richland Correctional Institution.

· Mansfield and North Central Correctional Institution ranked second and third, respectively, in the number of Serious Injury Inmate on Inmate Physical assaults. There were eight incidents at Mansfield Correctional Institution and seven at North Central Correctional Institution.

29

II. INMATE ON INMATE ASSAULTS C. PHYSICAL ASSAULTS 2. SOCF 2001 TO OCTOBER 12, 2005

Inmate on Inmate Physical Assaults at the Southern Ohio Correctional Facility from 2001 to October 12, 2005 With Breakdown by Type and Year

Serious Minor No Injury Physical Total Assaults Total YEAR N % N % N % N % N %

2001 6 5.1% 12 10.2% 10 8.5% 28 23.7% 118 100% 2002 7 4.8% 25 17.2% 7 4.8% 39 26.9% 145 100% 2003 10 7.2% 28 20.1% 6 4.3% 44 31.7% 139 100% 2004 5 5.9% 17 20.0% 8 9.4% 30 35.3% 85 100% 2005 6 6.0% 21 21.0% 22 22.0% 49 49.0% 100 100%

TOTAL 34 5.8% 106 17.5% 53 9.0% 190 32.4% 587 100%

NOTE: The Physical Total is the sum of serious, minor and non-injury physical assaults. The Total Assaults is the sum of physical, sexual and harassment assaults. The percentages refer to the percentage of total assaults, not the percentage of physical assaults.

· In the five-year period, the Total Inmate on Inmate Assaults at SOCF ranged from a low of 85 in 2004 to a high of 145 in 2002. There were 587 Total Inmate on Inmate Assaults in the five-year period, an average of 117 per year. The number of incidents in 2004 and 2005 are below that average, and rank as the lowest two years of the five-year period in terms of number of Total Inmate on Inmate Assaults.

· The following provides the data on Inmate on Inmate Total Assaults in the five- year period at SOCF:

Year Total Assaults

2001 118 2002 145 2003 139 2004 85 2005 100

TOTAL 587 30

· Inmate on Inmate Physical Assaults totaled 190 in the five-year period, ranging from a low of 28 incidents in 2001 to a high of 49 incidents in 2005.

· Data on Inmate on Inmate Physical Assaults in the five-year period is provided below:

Year Inmate on Inmate Physical Assaults

2001 28 2002 39 2003 44 2004 30 2005 49

TOTAL 190

· In 2005, the number of Physical Assaults comprises 49 percent of Total Assaults, and the largest percentage compared to the other four years in the period, when Physical Assaults comprised from 23.7 percent to 35.3 percent of Total Assaults in the year.

· The number of Physical Assaults averaged 38 per year in the period. In 2001 and in 2004 the number of Physical Assaults was below their average in the period.

· There were 106 Minor Injury Inmate on Inmate Physical Assaults at SOCF in the five-year period, ranging from a low of 12 in 2001 to a high of 28 in 2003. There was an average of 21.2 minor injury incidents per year.

· Data on the number of Minor Injury Inmate on Inmate Physical Assaults at SOCF in the five-year period is provided below:

Year Minor Injury Physical Assaults

2001 12 2002 25 2003 28 2004 17 2005 21

TOTAL 106

· There were 53 No Injury Inmate on Inmate Physical Assaults at SOCF in the five-year period, ranging from a low of six incidents in 2003 to a high of 22 incidents in 2005. SOCF averaged 10.6 such incidents per year in the period, 31

though there were only six, seven and eight incidents in 2003, 2002 and 2004 respectively.

· Data on No Injury Physical Assaults for the five year period is provided below:

Year No Injury Physical Assaults

2001 10 2002 7 2003 6 2004 8 2005 22

TOTAL 53

· A Serious Injury Physical Assault is defined as an assault requiring emergency treatment at a medical facility off prison grounds. Such injuries would include stab wounds, cuts requiring stitches, concussions/severe head trauma, fractures, serious eye injuries, spinal cord or other nerve damage, severe bite wounds or serious joint sprain.

· There were 34 Serious Injury Physical Assaults in the five-year period, ranging from a low of five incidents in 2004 to a high of 10 incidents in 2003. There was an average of 6.8 Serious Injury Physical Assaults in the five-year period. The number of such incidents is below that average in 2001, 2004 and 2005

· Data on the number of Serious Injury Physical Assaults in the five-year period is provided below:

Year Serious Injury Physical Assaults

2001 6 2002 7 2003 10 2004 5 2005 6

TOTAL 34

32

II INMATE ON INMATE ASSAULT C. HARASSMENT ASSAULTS 1. JANUARY – JUNE 2005

Inmate on Inmate Harassment Assault From January- June 2005 with Breakdown by Institution

Institution Total Southern Ohio Correctional Facility 24 Lake Erie Correctional Institution 3 Allen Correctional Institution 2 North Central Correctional Institution 2 Chillicothe Correctional Institution 1 Lorain Correctional Institution 1 Pickaway Correctional Institution 1 Southeastern Correctional Institution 1 Oakwood Correctional Facility 0 Noble Correctional Institution 0 Mansfield Correctional Institution 0 Richland Correctional Institution 0 Ross Correctional Institution 0 Ohio Reformatory for Women 0 Belmont Correctional Institution 0 Madison Correctional Institution 0 North Coast Correctional Treatment Facility 0 Correctional Reception Center 0 Trumbull Correctional Institution 0 Ohio State Penitentiary 0 Warren Correctional 0 Franklin Pre Release Center 0 Grafton Correctional Institution 0 Lebanon Correctional Institution 0 London Correctional Institution 0 Toledo Correctional Institution 0 Corrections Medical Center 0 Dayton Correctional Institution 0 Hocking Correctional Facility 0 Marion Correctional Institution 0 Montgomery Education and Pre Release Cntr 0 Northeast Ohio Correctional Center 0

Total 35

· Harassment Assault- Throwing, expelling, or otherwise causing a bodily substance to come into contact with another, or throwing an other liquid or material on or at another that does not result in any physical injury to the victim.

33

· In the first six months of 2005 there were 35 incidents of Inmate on Inmate Harassment Assault system-wide.

· The 35 incidents occurred at eight prisons, ranging from one incident each at four prisons: Southeastern, Pickaway, Lorain, and Chillicothe Correctional Institutions, to the high of 24 incidents at the Southern Ohio Correctional Facility. The number of incidents at SOCF comprises 68.6 percent of all incidents system-wide in the six-month period.

· Lake Erie Correctional Institution ranked second in the number of incidents of Inmate on Inmate Harassment Assault, but they only had three incidents in the six-month period.

II. INMATE ON INMATE ASSAULT C. HARASSMENT ASSAULTS 2. SOCF 2001 THROUGH OCTOBER 12, 2005

Inmate on Inmate Harassment Assaults At the Southern Ohio Correctional Facility from 2001 through October 12, 2005 With Breakdown by Year

Harassment Total Total Assaults YEAR N % N % 2001 90 76.3% 118 100% 2002 106 73.1% 145 100% 2003 95 68.3% 139 100% 2004 53 62.4% 85 100% 2005* 50 50.0% 100 100%

TOTAL 394 67.1% 587 100%

NOTE: The total number of all assaults (physical, sexual, harassment) is identified in the last column, Total Assaults. The percentage categories are the number of harassment assaults divided by the Total Assaults.

· Harassment Assault is defined as throwing, expelling, or otherwise causing a bodily substance to come into contact with another, or throwing an other liquid or material on or at another that does not result in any physical injury to the victim.

· In the five year period, the number of Inmate on Inmate Harassment Assaults totaled 394, ranging from a low of 50 in 2005 to a high of 106 in 2002.

· The yearly average is 78.8 incidents in the period. The number of incidents in both 2004 and 2005 is below that average. The number of incidents in 2004 and in 2005 is far below the number of incidents in 2001, 2002, and 2003. 34

II. INMATE ON INMATE ASSAULTS D. SEXUAL ASSAULT 1. JANUARY THROUGH JUNE 2005

Inmate on Inmate Sexual Assaults From January through June 2005 by Institution and Category of Sexual Assault

Institution Completed Attempted Contact Total Madison Correctional Institution 0 0 1 1 North Central Correctional Institution 0 0 1 1 Southern Ohio Correctional Facility 0 0 0 0 Oakwood Correctional Facility 0 0 0 0 Southeastern Correctional Institution 0 0 0 0 Noble Correctional Institution 0 0 0 0 Mansfield Correctional Institution 0 0 0 0 Richland Correctional Institution 0 0 0 0 Ross Correctional Institution 0 0 0 0 Ohio Reformatory for Women 0 0 0 0 Belmont Correctional Institution 0 0 0 0 Chillicothe Correctional Institution 0 0 0 0 Lake Erie Correctional Institution 0 0 0 0 Allen Correctional Institution 0 0 0 0 North Coast Correctional Treatment Facility 0 0 0 0 Correctional Reception Center 0 0 0 0 Pickaway Correctional Institution 0 0 0 0 Trumbull Correctional Institution 0 0 0 0 Ohio State Penitentiary 0 0 0 0 Warren Correctional 0 0 0 0 Franklin Pre Release Center 0 0 0 0 Grafton Correctional Institution 0 0 0 0 Lebanon Correctional Institution 0 0 0 0 London Correctional Institution 0 0 0 0 Toledo Correctional Institution 0 0 0 0 Lorain Correctional Institution 0 0 0 0 Corrections Medical Center 0 0 0 0 Dayton Correctional Institution 0 0 0 0 Hocking Correctional Facility 0 0 0 0 Marion Correctional Institution 0 0 0 0 Montgomery Education and Pre Rls. Center 0 0 0 0 Northeast Ohio Correctional Center 0 0 0 0

Total 0 0 2 2

* Sexual Assault- non-consensual anal or oral sex forced on the victim by the assailant.

** Sexual Contact Assault- any intentional touching of an erogenous zone including the thigh, genitals, buttock, pubic region of one inmates by another that is unwanted by the victim.

35

· In the six-month period from January through June 2005, there were two incidents of Inmate on Inmate Sexual Assaults, one at the Madison Correctional Institution, and one at the North Central Correctional Institution.

· Both incidents were classified as Sexual Contact Assault, “any intentional touching…” in contrast to the definition of a completed or attempted Sexual Assault.”

II. INMATE ON INMATE ASSAULT D. SEXUAL ASSAULT 2. SOCF 2001 TO OCTOBER 12, 2005

Inmate on Inmate Sexual Assaults at the Southern Ohio Correctional Facility from 2001 to October 12, 2005 With Breakdown by Year and Type of Sexual Assault

Completed Attempted Contact Sexual Total Total Assaults YEAR N N N N N

2001 0 0 0 0 118 2002 0 0 0 0 145 2003 0 0 0 0 139 2004 2 0 0 2 85 2005 1 0 0 1 100

TOTAL 3 0 0 3 587

NOTE: Sexual Assault is defined as non-consensual anal penetration or oral sex forced on the victim by the assailant.

Sexual Contact Assault is defined as any touching of an erogenous zone (including thighs, genitals, buttock or pubic region) of one inmate by another that is unwanted by the victim.

· In the five-year period, there were three Inmate on Inmate Completed Sexual Assaults, with none in 2001, 2002 and 2003, two in 2004, and one in 2005.

· The previous system-wide data is solely for the first six months of 2005, which shows no Inmate on Inmate Sexual Contacts or Assaults from January through June of 2005 at the Southern Ohio Correctional Facility.

· Contact was made with the SOCF Investigator on February 16, 2006 to seek clarification on the 2005 Sexual Assault. It was relayed that there were two alleged Sexual Assaults in July 2005, one in the restroom of the inmate dining room, and one in recreation. In both incidents, it was determined that they were consensual acts. In both incidents, the alleged victims confessed to that fact. Reportedly, the two 2004 incidents cited above were also unfounded. There is an apparent need to distinguish between allegations of Sexual Assault, investigations of such allegations, and verified incidents of Sexual Assault.