DOCSLIB.ORG

The Value of Using Local Political Online Forums to Reverse Political Disengagement

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
The Value of Using Local Political Online Forums to Reverse Political Disengagement The value of using local political online forums to reverse political disengagement. Kerill Dunne Thesis submitted for Ph.D. degree in Sociology June 2008 Department of Sociology Faculty of Arts and Human Sciences University of Surrey Guildford *> Surrey UK GU2 7XH © 2008 Kerill Dunne ProQuest Number: 11010066 All rights reserved INFORMATION TO ALL USERS The quality of this reproduction is dependent upon the quality of the copy submitted. In the unlikely event that the author did not send a com plete manuscript and there are missing pages, these will be noted. Also, if material had to be removed, a note will indicate the deletion. uest ProQuest 11010066 Published by ProQuest LLC(2018). Copyright of the Dissertation is held by the Author. All rights reserved. This work is protected against unauthorized copying under Title 17, United States C ode Microform Edition © ProQuest LLC. ProQuest LLC. 789 East Eisenhower Parkway P.O. Box 1346 Ann Arbor, Ml 48106- 1346 Abstract There has been a growing concern regarding political disengagement among citizens within liberal thin democracies. This concern has brought about calls for local political online forums to be used to support participatory and deliberative democracy online to reverse this trend. However, little empirical investigation has been conducted into what such forums can support in terms of participatory and deliberative democracy. After an extensive review of the E-Democracy literature three research questions were developed to examine the value of using online forums to reverse political disengagement. A two pronged methodological approach consisting of qualitative and two-phase quantitative methods was used to examine these research questions, and to test specific recommendations on how to build online forums. It was found that, firstly, local political online forums cannot support direct or full- participatory democracy and such forums are mainly situated within liberal thin democratic models. Secondly, forums which are placed within local government websites have a greater chance of being inactive. Finally, non-government supported forums can support a type of discussion which increases citizens’ participation in local political discussions. These results taken together mean that local political online forums will not reverse political disengagement. They do not fail because of some inherent design fault, but because political disengagement is-tied to citizens’ dislike of liberal thin democracy. 1 Table of contents 1 INTRODUCTION................................................................................................................................. ...6 1.1 A im s o f t h e s is .......................................................................................................................................................................7 1.2 S c o pe of t h e s is .................................................................................................................................................................... 9 1.3 Ch a pt e r s in b r ie f ...............................................................................................................................................................9 2 DEMOCRACY AND ITS PARTICIPATORY CAPABILITIES....................................................12 2.1 D e f in in g d e m o c r a c y .............................................................................................................. 12 2 .2 Subcategories o f d e m o c r a c y ................................................................................................................................14 2.2.1 Liberal thin democracy....1.......................................................................................................................................................................15 2.2.2 Liberal plural thin democracy...................................................................................................................................... 17 2.2.3 Unitary democracy..........................................................................................................................................................................................19 2.2.4 Direct democracy............................................................................................................................................................................................20 2.2.5 Strong Democracy .......................................................................................................................................................................................... 20 2.3 P articipation ....................................................................................................................................................................22 2.3.1 A general theory of political participation ............................................................................................................................23 2.3.2 A categorization of participation .................................................................................................................................................... 26 2 .4 Conclusion and typology 1 ................................................................................................................................... 29 3 DELIBERATION....................................................................................................................................31 3.1.1 A general view o f deliberation ...........................................................................................................................................................31 3.1.2 First category: Mixed discourses and modes of communication .......................................................................33 3.1.3 Habermas and rational deliberation............................................................................................................................................35 3.1.4 Critics of Habermas......................................................................................................................................................................................38 3.1.5 Second category: Rational deliberation redefined .........................................................................................................40 3.1.6 Third category: Non-rational, non-consensual deliberation .................................................................................. 44 3.1.7 Typology 2 .............................................................................................................................................................................................................. 47 3.2 Co n c l u s io n .................................................................................................. 49 4 LOCAL POLITICAL ONLINE FORUMS, AND REVERSING POLITICAL DISENGAGEMENT........................................................................................................................................51 4.1 P o litica l disengagement , a r e a l it y , a n d a sy m p t o m of L ib e r a l is m ...........................................51 4.1.1 Reversing disengagement - the benefits of participation & deliberation ................................................58 4.2 E -D e m o c r a c y ....................................................................................................................................................................64 4.2.1 Local political online forums ................................................................................................................................................................ 66 4.2.2 A brief history of local political online forums ...................................................................................................................72 4.3 Th e v a l u e o f u s in g o n l in e fo r u m s t o r e v e r se p o litic a l disengagement .............................76 4.3.1 Local political online forums, participation, and democratic models ........................................................... 77 4.3.2 Local political online forums and deliberation ...................................................................................................................78 4.3.3 Local government support ...................................................................................................................................................................... 81 4.4 Co n c l u s io n ......................................................................................................................................................................... 82 5 METHODOLOGY.................................................................................................................................85 5.1 F irst d e d u c t iv e methodological a p p r o a c h ............................................................................................... 87 5.1.1 Technology ..........................................................................................................................................................................................................87 5.1.2 Developing a set o f rules, objectives and promotion .............................................................................................................. 88 5.1.3 Moderation .........................................................................................................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Surrey Hotel Futures Report
    SURREY HOTEL FUTURES FINAL REPORT Prepared for: Surrey County Council June 2015 Surrey Hotel Futures Study 2015 __________________________________________________________________________________________ CONTENTS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY .................................................................................................................................. i 1. INTRODUCTION ................................................................................................................................... 1 1.1. Study Background and Brief................................................................................................... 1 1.2. Scope of the Study ................................................................................................................... 2 1.3. Methodology ............................................................................................................................. 4 2. NATIONAL HOTEL TRENDS ................................................................................................................ 6 2.1. National Hotel Performance Trends ...................................................................................... 6 2.2. National Hotel Development Trends .................................................................................... 8 3. SURREY HOTEL SUPPLY ..................................................................................................................... 19 3.1. Current Surrey Hotel Supply .................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Guildfordfringefestival.Com Guildfordfringefestival 2 3 ElcoEthis Issue Is All About Getting out and Having Fun
    Directory TheGFF 2019 press ad 127mmPepperpot wide x 160mm.pdf 1 12/04/2019 08:55 June 2019 C M 9 Y 1 0 2 CM y ul MY J 8th 2 - 2 CY 8th June CMY K Comedy Theatre Music Cabaret Opera Dance Poetry Kids’ shows Talks Spoken word and more... To nd out more please visit our website GuildfordFringeFest or contact us via social media: GuildfordFringe GuildfordFringeFestival.com GuildfordFringeFestival 2 3 elcoeThis issue is all about getting out and having fun. Kicking off the month eatres Crossword/Suduko p8/37 we have the Godalming Town Show which this Music on the move p6 year has a beach theme. No milk today p13 Why not get out your swimmers and flipflops Competition p14 and enjoy this action packed day of fun for So you want to be a vet p19 all the family. Safe and sound p21 Hold the front page as the hugely When your job is a pain p25 popular boy band Take That are coming to Godalming. They are not exactly boys Garden Cuttings p26/27 anymore but if you are a fan you can Tourist at home p29 see them on stage streamed into The Book Review p32 Godalming Borough on Saturday 8th June (p22) Cinema Listings p36 This month’s competition is the opportunity What’s On p37/40 to enjoy ales from some of the country’s top independent brewers at G Live’s 9th Beer Festival in the autumn. Turn to page 14 to win 4 tickets for you and your friends.
    [Show full text]
  • Medium Term Financial Strategy
    Medium Term Financial Strategy 2009/10 - 2012/13 GUILDFORD BOROUGH COUNCIL MEDIUM TERM FINANCIAL STRATEGY 2009/10 –2012/13 Contents Budget Analysis Page Service Units Page Number (Page Colour) Number Alphabetical list of services ii Major changes introduced in vi Business Systems 1 2009/10 (Orange) Movement in General Fund vii Community Care Services 15 budget requirement (Canary) General Fund summary - gross viii Corporate Development 33 expenditure & income (Bright Blue) General Fund summary - net ix Economic Development 47 expenditure (Peach) Analysis of service unit gross x Environmental Health & 65 expenditure for 2009/10 by type Licensing (subjective analysis) (Pink) Analysis of service unit gross xi Financial Services 79 income for 2009/10 by type (White) Analysis of total gross xii Housing Advice Services 93 expenditure and sources of (Yellow) Finance for 2009/10 General Fund revenue balance xiii Human Resources 103 and major reserve funds’ (Lilac) projections to 2012/13 Housing Revenue Account xvi Legal & Democratic 111 balance and major reserve funds’ Services projections to 2012/13 (Grey) Budget Requirement and Council xvii Leisure Services 129 Tax (Deep Green) Economic Indicators xviii Neighbourhood & Housing 145 Management (Blue) Manpower Establishment used in xix Operational Services 157 estimate preparation (Gold) Salaries and Employee Costs xx Parks & Countryside 193 (including l HRA) Services (Kiwi) Collection Fund xxi Planning Services 203 (Beige) Medium Term Financial Strategy xxii Revenue & Payments 213 framework (Deep
    [Show full text]
  • Surrey Hotel Futures
    SURREY HOTEL FUTURES FINAL REPORT Prepared for: Surrey County Council August 2015 Surrey Hotel Futures Study 2015 __________________________________________________________________________________________ CONTENTS EXECUTIVE SUMMARY .................................................................................................................................. i 1. INTRODUCTION ................................................................................................................................... 1 1.1. Study Background and Brief................................................................................................... 1 1.2. Scope of the Study ................................................................................................................... 2 1.3. Methodology ............................................................................................................................. 4 2. NATIONAL HOTEL TRENDS ................................................................................................................ 6 2.1. National Hotel Performance Trends ...................................................................................... 6 2.2. National Hotel Development Trends .................................................................................... 8 3. SURREY HOTEL SUPPLY ..................................................................................................................... 19 3.1. Current Surrey Hotel Supply .................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • International Study Centre International Foundation Year and Pre-Masters in Economics 2012/13
    International Study Centre International Foundation Year and Pre-Masters in Economics 2012/13 99% of students who completed the University of Surrey International Foundation Year were offered a place to study a Degree at the University of Surrey in 2011 The International Foundation Year at the University of Surrey offers a direct path to undergraduate study for international students who have completed high school. Combining academic modules, study skills and English language training, this programme qualifies students to meet the challenges of undergraduate degree-level study at the University. The Pre-Masters prepares international students for the demands of a taught Masters degree in Economics at the University of Surrey. The course will provide a fully supported learning environment and teaches students the language skills, study and research skills and academic knowledge required to progress to a Masters in Economics at the University. < “We are delighted that 99% of students who completed the University of Surrey Hassan Al-Khayyat – Chemical Engineering International Foundation Year were offered a place to study a Degree at the University << of Surrey in 2011” Yu Yue – International Hospitality Management <<< Dr. Peter Marshall, Alexander Danjuma Usman – Electronics and Computer Engineering Director of Student Recruitment www.surrey.ac.uk/isc 3 Discover the Discover your student life Your wellbeing Discover your 6 University of Surrey 18 The Surrey student experience 32 International Student Office, 40 International Study Centre
    [Show full text]
  • A Luxury Two Bedroom Apartment Set in Central Guildford
    A luxury two bedroom apartment set in central Guildford Cobbett Place, 10 Sydenham Road, Guildford, Surrey, GU1 £1,750 pcm plus fees apply, Unfurnished Available from 30.09.2021 • Open plan reception kitchen • Principal bedroom with fitted wardrobes • Two bathrooms (one en suite) • Private terrace • Secure underground parking for one car About this property riding and cycling are popular **VIDEO TOUR AVAILABLE ON pastimes. Spectrum, Guildford’s REQUEST** award winning leisure centre, and the Surrey Sports Park, offer a This luxury two bedroom choice of swimming pools and a apartment is modern throughout whole lot more, while the town with excellent fixtures and fittings. even boasts its own Lido. And of The apartment comprises a course, the area has an spacious and bright reception area outstanding choice of prestigious with open plan kitchen, principal golf courses just waiting to be bedroom with fitted wardrobes, played. private secure terrace and en suite shower room, second double bedroom and further family Furnishing bathroom. The property comes Unfurnished with a gated ground level parking space. The development is Local Authority located moments away from Guildford Borough Council, Guildford High Street, where you Guildford have access to the town centre, Council Tax Band = D Guildford and London Road train stations, local bus routes and Energy Performance other great local amenities. A EPC Rating = B unique opportunity to live central with private parking. Viewing All viewings will be accompanied Local Information and are strictly by prior With the Electric Theatre and the arrangement through Savills Yvonne Arnaud Theatre, a cinema Guildford Lettings Office. and a museum on the doorstep, Telephone: +44 (0) 1483 796 830.
    [Show full text]
  • Association of Independent Festivals Six-Year Report 2014
    Association of Independent Festivals Six-Year Repor t 2014 Dr Emma Webster Live Music Exchange [email protected] Executive Summary ............................................................................................ 1 Introduction ...................................................................................................... 4 The festival ‘ecology’ ....................................................................................... 6 The Association of Independent Festivals ............................................................... 6 A brief history of festivals .................................................................................... 8 Risk factors for the festival sector and examples of cancelled festivals ...................... 11 The festival market in context ............................................................................ 12 Festivals and the state – austerity and secondary ticketing ....................................... 12 Consumer confidence ................................................................................... 13 Is PRS for Music getting tough on festival promoters? .............................................. 14 Festivals and the broader music industries .......................................................... 14 The ‘Glastonbury effect’ ............................................................................... 15 Competition in and outside of the UK ................................................................ 16 Technology – social media, RFID
    [Show full text]
  • Cambridge Folk Festival
    Cambridge Folk Festival Where? Cherry Hinton Hall, Cambridge When? 28-31 July Acts include: Mavis Staples, Lucinda Williams, Christy Moore In a sentence: Long-established acoustic music celebration. More information: http://www.cambridgefolkfestival.co.uk/ Download Where? Donington Park, Derbyshire When? 10-12 June Acts include: Black Sabbath, System Of A Down, Feeder In a sentence: Hard rock heaven at a heavy metal Mecca. More information: http://www.downloadfestival.co.uk Glastonbury Where? Worthy Farm, Pilton, Somerset When? 24-26 June Acts include: Coldplay, New Order, White Stripes In a sentence: The UK's most important festival, and the one the stars beg to play at. More information: http://www.glastonburyfestivals.co.uk Green Man Where? Baskerville Hall, Hay-on-Wye When? 19-21 August Acts include: Bonnie "Prince" Billy & Matt Sweeney, Joanna Newsom, King Creosote In a sentence: Laid-back, largely acoustic festival. More information: http://www.greenmanfestival.co.uk Guilfest Where? Stoke Park, Guildford, Surrey When? 15-17 July Acts include: Paul Weller, The Pogues, Status Quo In a sentence: Family-friendly Home Counties event. More information: http://www.guilfest.co.uk Isle of Wight Where? Seaclose Park, Newport When? 10-12 June Acts include: REM, Faithless, Morrissey In a sentence: Veteran stars and newer acts mix at island festival. More information: http://www.isleofwightfestival.org Larmer Tree Where? Larmer Tree Gardens, near Shaftesbury, Dorset When? 15-17 July Acts include: Show of Hands, The Cat Empire, The Bees. Jools Holland plays two shows before the festival proper starts. In a sentence: Family-themed festival with workshops and children's events.
    [Show full text]
  • DRAFT BROCHURE As of May 2015
    DRAFT BROCHURE as of May 2015 BELLERBY GUILDFORD DRAFT BROCHURE as of May 2015 DRAFT BROCHURE as of May 2015 BELLERBY The Bellerby Apartments is an exciting new development in the heart of Surrey’s county town, bringing a dramatic and vibrant new dimension to the centre of this historic community. As part of a landmark project to bring the first Waitrose GintoU central GU1,ILD it is set to becomeFO an iconicRD destination for all residents of the Guildford area. WELCOME A striking new addition to the range of buildings in Guildford’s town centre, The Bellerby Apartments is a unique collection of just 30 exceptional apartments above a state-of-the-art Waitrose supermarket. These distinctive one and two bedroom homes combine inspired architecture with modern living, pushing the boundaries of design yet respecting the rhythm of the existing streetscape. Arranged over four storeys, with a spacious communal terrace at the centre of the building, almost every property also opens onto its own private balcony or terrace, and secure car parking is provided in the basement, with lift access throughout. Just a 5 minute walk from the town’s bustling and beautiful High Street, and 10 minutes from the station, residents are perfectly positioned to take advantage of all that Guildford has in store. DRAFT BROCHURE as of May 2015 Computer generated illustrations are for indicative purposes only DRAFT BROCHURE as of May 2015 Introducing an iconic modern masterpiece into the heart of Guildford’s historic community, the sleek profi le of The Bellerby Apartments is as unexpected as it is inspiring.
    [Show full text]
  • NUS Asks Students “Don't Do Drunk”
    The University of Surrey Students’ Union Newspaper issue 1035 www.ussu.co.uk THURSDAY 12 SEPTEMBER 2002 free The Union welcomes all students back to university with an offer they can’t refuse UNIS 35TH ANNIVERSARY A day of celebration to commemorate past and future success | page 3 Stella: £2 a pint S NEW USSU’ THE UNION HAS now started selling By Richard Watts prices. Ian Gribben, the Bars & Catering DIRECTION Stella Artois Premium Lager for (hold on manager of the union said “it’s a fantastic Non-commercial serv- to your hats) £2 a pint. All of the pumps result that has allowed us to provide the ices and student train- have been connected, some extensive the third year in a row that the Union has students with what they hopefully want. ing focus | page 6 taste-testing has been performed and the held its drinks prices, making it one of the Though people expected a premium lager reassuringly inexpensive lager is set to most competitive bar and entertainment at a premium price, we were adamant that lubricate all of your big night’s out from venues in Guildford and the surrounding the price would be £2, and £2 it is.” this point onwards. area. Stella is available in the recently The move to Stella from Kronenbourg redecorated Helyn Rose Bar and all of 1664 arose as the result of a consortium BAREARTS FESTIVAL the Union bars as well as in Chancellor’s, of Students’ Unions across the country, BUMPER BONANZA where it has already shown itself to be a supplied by NUS Services Limited Reviews of the Guilfest, V2002 and success since the summer refurbishment (NUSSL), responding to demand from Reading weekend festivals | page 14 during a week in August.
    [Show full text]
  • Guildford Draft Local Plan: Strategy and Sites Consultation 2014 Statement of Community Engagement
    Guildford Draft Local Plan: Strategy and Sites Consultation 2014 Statement of Community Engagement Prepared for Guildford Borough Council by URS, October 2014 1 Guildford Draft Local Plan: Statement of Community Engagement December 2014 Contents Introduction........................................................................................................................3 What’s the purpose of this document?.............................................................................3 How’s this document structured?.....................................................................................3 Background...................................................................................................................4 What’s a Local Plan?.......................................................................................................4 Why does Guildford need a Local Plan?.........................................................................4 What happens if we don’t have a Local Plan?..................................................................4 What other Local Plan consultations have happened in Guildford?..................................5 Overview of the consultation........................................................................................6 What was our vision for the consultation on the Draft Local Plan 2014?........................6 Who did we consult?........................................................................................................7 When did we consult?......................................................................................................9
    [Show full text]
  • Www .Stoughton-Pages.Co.Uk Bi-Monthly Magazine in Print & Online
    Local advertising and news magazine, delivered free to over 3,500 homes & local businesses. May & June 2021 Bi-monthly magazine in print & online The arts are staged for a Lemon & Passionfruit Contrasting words big comeback. Venues are Drizzle Cake. A light and Frank Scammell, vicar at beginning to look forwards zesty lemon sponge, full of Emmanuel Stoughton, chooses with more positivity. We spoke citrus flavour and glazed two pairs of contrasting words to the Yvonne Arnaud Theatre. with a crunchy drizzle icing. that sum up his lockdown. www.stoughton-pages.co.uk Welcome Issue No. 5 Dear Neighbours, there is a palpable feeling of positivity and optimism in the May & air as the lock-down restrictions start to lift. We do seem to be approaching June 2021 the new freedoms with some hesitancy at first, but it feels good, doesn’t it? The joy of meeting friends (albeit out and as the weather gets ever more limited in numbers) outdoors again, the spring like. We’re looking for others to feel Stoughton Pages delights of sitting in a pub garden with braver still and start promoting their live Local advertising and news a pint of beer and a packet of crisps! events later in the year (please do get in magazine, delivered free to over 3,500 homes. Focussed on the It’s almost worth the months of lockdown touch if you have events to promote over local community and the services just to enjoy these simple pleasures in the summer and onwards, our next issue available in the general area.
    [Show full text]