University of California Santa Cruz the Life-Cycle Of
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA SANTA CRUZ THE LIFE-CYCLE OF FORCED MIGRATION: THE LIVES AND POLITICS OF INTERNALLY DISPLACED PEASANTS IN MEDELLIN, COLOMBIA A dissertation submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree of DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY in SOCIOLOGY with an emphasis in LATIN AMERICAN AND LATINO STUDIES and FEMINIST STUDIES by Claudia María López June 2017 The Dissertation of Claudia Maria Lopez is approved: _____________________________ Professor Steven McKay, chair _____________________________ Professor Emeritus Jonathan Fox ______________________________ Professor Miriam Greenberg __________________________________ Tyrus Miller Vice Provost and Dean of Graduate Studies Copyright © by Claudia María López 2017 Table of Contents Abstract……………………………………………………………………………….iv Dedication and Acknowledgments…………………………………………………...vi Chapter One: Introduction…………………………………………………………….1 Chapter Two: Literature Review…………………………………………………….29 Chapter Three: Methodology and Case Selection…………………………………...76 Chapter Four: Phase 1 of the Life-Cycle of Forced Migration: Displacement………98 Chapter Five: Phase 2 of the Life-Cycle of Forced Migration: Resettlement……...144 Chapter Six: Phase 3 of the Life-Cycle of Forced Migration: Integration…………190 Chapter Seven: Phase 4 of the Life-Cycle of Forced Migration: Community-Building....239 Chapter Eight: Conclusion………………………………………………………….277 References…………………………………………………………………………..291 iii Abstract The Life-Cycle of Forced Migration: The Lives and Politics of Internally Displaced Peasants in Medellín, Colombia. Claudia María López The dissertation examines the dynamics of conflict-induced internal displacement on the urban integration and citizenship of peasants in Medellín, Colombia. Using this case study of displacement in Colombia—which has the largest population of internally displaced persons in the world—my dissertation fills in a gap in the migration literature that does not adequately address internal and forced migration. It also goes beyond viewing displacement as a single event, analyzing it instead as a life-long process that constitutes what I call the Life-Cycle of Forced Migration. My broader analysis of migration links displacement, resettlement, integration, and community-building, providing a multistage understanding of the processes of citizenship and belonging. The research utilizes mixed-methods for gathering data, drawing from ethnographic interviews and surveys with rural internally displaced persons, as well as interviews with representatives of government agencies and NGOs, to answer: How does a group of migrants become non-citizens despite not crossing borders, not losing formal citizenship, and not losing national identity? I find that even after having resettled for two decades in Medellín, people still identify as “displaced” due to differential inclusion, which negatively affects their sense and practice of citizenship, a form of Segmented Citizenship. I define Segmented iv Citizenship as a new social status, within a spectrum of non-belonging, that is both inclusionary and exclusionary; where citizens have claims to formal rights, yet are limited from practicing these rights fully. I argue that Segmented Citizenship changes the displaced into Partial Citizens due to inadequate state aid and attention, stigma from state actors and the receiving community, stagnation in informal employment, segregation in informal settlements, and the displaced’s own subjective experiences with violence and trauma. However, by highlighting the lives of displaced community leaders, the thesis shows how Displaced Consciousness— a new affective awareness which results from displacement—is used as a tool for building solidarity with other displaced peasants and defending their Right to the Territory in the peripheries of the city. Ultimately, I contend that this research demonstrates the limits of integration and national citizenship, offering a more nuanced lens for examining citizenship as a spectrum, pushing us to examine belonging beyond a binary category of citizen/non- citizen; included and excluded. v Dedication and Acknowledgments If it would not have been for the support, dedication, and care of literally hundreds of amazing people, over the course of almost a decade, this project could not have been carried out and completed. I am humbled and honored to be able to sit down and reflect on all the people who have been integral to my personal and professional growth and success. I would like to first and foremost acknowledge and express my deep gratitude to the internally displaced women and men in Colombia who participated in this study. Their openness to share their stories with me has been life-changing and I am forever indebted to their time, kindness, and knowledge. The bulk of the interviews and surveys with the displaced could not have been completed without the help of my research assistant in Colombia, Carmen Rosa Jaramillo. Rosita has been and continues to be an invaluable help, as well as dear friend. Her insight and non-stop energy was key for completing data collection and interview analysis. I am always impressed with her drive and fight. The day after the failed Peace Agreement referendum in September 2016, I called Rosita and expressed my sadness, saying that I had been crying all day. Rosita scolded me, saying, “Crying?! Hija, there is no to cry, more than ever it is time to fight!” Thank you, Rosita, for showing me strength in the face of despair. Without the support of my contacts, community, and colleagues in Colombia, each stage of the research could not have happened. First off, thank you to Sandra Alvarez whose friendship and personal contacts in Colombia were critical for the initial connection with networks in Medellín. Most importantly, Sandra introduced vi me to Piedad del Carmen Morales and Andrea Juliana Gonzalez, without whom I would not have been able to enter into the activist community of Medellín. When I arrived to Medellín for the first time in 2011, I was not ready for the reality of the consequences of war in Colombia. Afro-Colombian leader, Ana Fabricia Cordoba had just been assassinated while riding on the bus heading home to the Comuna 3. At the time I was unaware that I, as a stranger and researcher, was arriving to a community in grief and fear. However, in spite of the fear, due to Piedad, an acclaimed poet and community organizer, vouching for me, I was able to enter spaces that I would never have been able to in that time. Sadly, in 2012, Piedad passed away unexpectedly. I am forever grateful to Piedad for helping facilitate contacts in Medellín that have been critical for carrying out and completion of the project. I am honored to have spent nights at Piedad’s home and in the hangouts around Medellín, talking feminism and resistance. As I prepared to enter the field in 2014, Andrea Julianna Gonzalez connected me with the Corporación Juridica, an organization that wrote a letter of support for funding and sponsorship, without even knowing me personally. When I arrived to Medellín that year, Adriana Arboleda, welcomed me and introduced me to people who would end up being the core support of my research during 2014. I met with Andrea in April and told her about the organization I was closely working with through her suggestion. I will never forget that she paused and laughed, saying, “That’s who Ana Fabricia was working with…” I got the chills. My research ended up following much of Ana Fabricia’s community work, and I found myself riding the vii same bus route that she was assassinated on. I want to acknowledge her life and recognize that her spirit has guided the research as well. To the multitude of activists, organizations, and movements in Colombia, thank you for opening the door to me and allowing me to work closely with you as a fellow organizer: Corporación Juridica, Mujeres que Crean, and La Ruta Pacifica de Mujeres, to name a few. I am especially thankful to La Mesa Interbarrial de Desconectados, who became my community and the group, as we joke, of which I have become the “International Branch.” Thank you for the continued support and friendship: Lorena Zapata, Claudia Serna, Carlos Velázquez, Jhon “Mono” Duque, Carlos Bedoya, Andres “Negro,” Don Ivan, Elizabeth “Chava” and Luz Elena Ibarra. I also want to recognize the lives of those who have passed, in particular Don Gabriel Orrego and Jairo Maya. While conducting fieldwork in 2011, I met Adriana González Gil, professor at the Universidad de Antioquia and from that point on, she has been a supportive mentor in Colombia. When I returned in 2014, Dr. González Gil offered me a space to work and present my work for feedback at the university. I want to give a special thank you to Adriana and the rest of the research team at the Instituto de Estudios Políticos in the Universidad de Antioquia, especially Sandra González Diáz. Sandra has been an amazing researcher to bounce ideas off of and has helped me situate my research within the literature in Colombia. I was able to conduct research with government administrators of different humanitarian and social work programs in Medellín, in addition to city urban viii planners. Thank you to Fundación ProAntioquia, Centro de Formación para la Paz y La Reconciliación, Medellin Solidaria, Agencia de Cooperacion e Inversion de Medellín y la Area Metropoliana (ACIMAM), Unidad Municipal de Atención y Reparación a Victimas del Conflicto Armado (UAO), Unidad de Victimas (UV), Empresas Publicas de Medellín (EPM), and Departamento Nacional de Planeación. A special thank you to Brenda Tamayo, who took special interest in the project and who has offered important insight into resettlement programs in Medellín. Lastly, to the scores of people who participated and supported the project directly and indirectly by supporting me and my family while in Colombia. To my neighbors, friends, and those who were an emotional support to myself and the family while completing international research. It would not have been possible with you. To my dissertation committee, I am so thankful for your guidance and support. Your assistance, patience, and input have been key to developing my work and skills as a researcher and academic.