The Role of Lipid Fluidity in the Function of the Thylakoid
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
) The Role of Lipid Fluidity in the Function of the Thylakoid Membrane by Robert Curtis Ford Thesis submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the University of London, and for the Diploma of Membership of the Imperial College of Science and Technology. 1 ABSTRACT A fluorescence method for estimating the fluidity of the thyla- koid membrane was developed and compared with other more establis- hed techniques using ESR spin-label probes. The fluorescence method was found to have several advantages over the ESR spin-labelling technique in that only small quantities of sample were required (equivalent to 20 micrograms Chi.) and information on both the rate of motion as well as the static order of the lipid acyl chains could be obtained. Under physiological conditions a highly fluid lipid environment was shown to exist in the thylakoid membrane for the probe DPH with a viscosity of 0.3 poise for wobbling motions within a restricted cone of half-angle 50°. Treatments causing a reduction in lipid fluidity were found to inhibit photosynthetic electron flow between Photosystem 2 and Photosystem 1 which are organized into separate regions of the thylakoid membrane. Reduction in the fluidity of the lipid matrix was also found to restrict salt-induced changes in chlorophyll fluorescence which have been associated with lateral protein movement. The lipid matrix in stromal lamellae fractions was found to be much less ordered (order parameter, 0.38) than the granal membrane fractions (order parameter, 0.61). The differences observed were interpreted in terms of the high protein:lipid ratios in the granal fractions (1.9:1) compared to the stromal lamellae (1.2:1), and the importance of the protein:lipid ratio in the ordering of the thyla- koid lipid matrix is discussed in detail. 2 Acknowledgements I would like to thank everyone who has given help and encourage- ment to me during the last three years, and in particular I would like to thank Prof. James Barber, ray supervisor, whose enthusiasm for the study of photosynthesis has proved highly infectious. Much of this work would not have been possible without the helpful and patient instruction of Dr. David Chapman who has introduced me to the techniques of lipid extraction and analysis. I would also like to acknowledge the help of Dr. Raymond Cox at Odense University in Denmark who provided facilities and expertise for the measurement of the ESR spectra of spin-labels. Many others have contributed to this work by their constructive criticism and discussion of ideas and experiments, and in particu- lar I would like to thank Drs. Fred Chow, Yasusi Yamamoto, Paul Millner, Lars Olsen, Alison Telfer, Barry Rubin and Nigel Packham. I also acknowledge the invaluable technical support of Kathy Wilson and John De-Felice. Special thanks in particular to Alice Leeming for her help and encouragement over the last few years, and for her diligent pruf reeding. Finally I would like to thank the Science Research Council and Standard Telecommunications Laboratories Ltd. for financial support for this work. 3 Contents List of Tables 7 List of Figures 8 Symbols and Abbreviations 12 1 Introduction 14 1.1 General Introduction 14 1.2 The Two Light Reactions 16 1.3 Light-Harvesting Mechanisms: The Photosystems 18 1.4 Structure of the Chloroplast 20 1.4.1 The Thylakoid Membrane 20 1.4.2 The Envelope Membrane 22 1.5 Organization of the Electron Transport Components 23 1.5.1 Inter-System Electron Transfer Components 27 1.5.1.1 Plas toquinone 27 1.5.1.2 Primary Acceptors From PS 2 28 1.5.1.3 The Cytochromes 30 1.5.1.4 Plastocyanin 32 1.5.2 Photosystem 1 Reaction Centre: P700 33 1.5.3 Reactions on the Reducing Side of PS1 34 1.5.4 Photosystem 2 Reaction Centre: P680 37 1.5.5 Reactions on the Oxidizing Side of PS2 37 1.6 The Production of ATP 40 1.7 Lipid Composition and Structure of the Thylakoid Membrane 43 1.7.1 The Use of EPR spin-labels 49 1.8 The Effect of Temperature 51 1.9 Other Experiments on Thylakoid Membrane Fluidity 52 1.10 Summary 57 4 2 Materials and Methods 59 2.1 Plant Material 59 2.2 Chloroplast Preparations 59 2.2.1 Preparation of Class 1 Intact Chloroplasts 60 2.2.2 Preparation of Class 2 Broken Chloroplasts 61 2.2.3 Determination of Chlorophyll 61 2.3 Preparation of Thylakoid Membrane Fractions 62 2.3.1 Incubation Media 62 2.3.2 Fractionation Procedure 63 2.4 Preparation of Cholesterol-Treated Thylakoid Membranes 64 2.4.1 Determination of Cholesterol 66 2.5 Isolation and Analysis of Chloroplast Lipids 67 2.5.1 Fatty-Acid Analysis 67 2.5.2 Isolation of Chloroplast Lipids 69 2.6 Preparation of Lipid Vesicles 70 2.6.1 Chloroplast Lipids 70 2.6.2 Other Lipids 70 2.6.3 Lipid Enrichment Experiments 71 2.7 Protein Analysis 71 2.8 Electron Transport Measurements 72 2.8.1 Steady-State Electron Transport 72 2.8.2 Flash-Induced Electron Transport 73 2.9 Chlorophyll Fluorescence Measurements 76 2.9.1 Salt-Induced Chlorophyll Fluorescence Changes 76 2.9.2 Modulated Chlorophyll Fluorescence 76 2.10 ESR Measurements: Spin Labels 78 2.10.1 Measurement of First-Derivative ESR Spectra 78 2.10.2 Calculation of Rotational Correlation Times 79 5 2.10.3 Calculation of Order Parameters 80 2.11 Fluorescence Polarization Measurements 85 2.11.1 Preparation of DPH-Labelled Membranes 85 2.11.2 Steady-State Fluorescence Polarization Measurements 86 2.12 Time-Resolved Fluorescence Measurements 88 3 Results 91 3.1 Lipid Fluidity Measurements 91 3.1.1 A Fluorescent Probe: DPH 91 3.1.1.1 Fluorescence Polarization Measurements with DPH 109 3.1.1.2 Steady-State Fluorescence Polarization Measurements 110 3.1.1.3 Time-Resolved Fluorescence Depolarization Measurements 113 3.1.2 ESR Spin-Label Probes 120 3.2 Lipid Fluidity and Function 130 3.2.1 Effect of Temperature 131 3.2.2 Effect of Cholesterol 133 3.2.3 Effect of Ageing on Lipid Fluidity 151 3.3 Lateral Heterogeneity in the Thylakoid Membrane 155 3.3.1 Characterization of the Thylakoid Membrane Fractions 156 3.3.2 Fluidity Measurements of Stromal and Granal Membranes 157 3.3.3 Composition of the Stromal and Granal Fractions 166 3.3.4 Lipid Fluidity and the Temperature Sensitivity of Photo- system2 170 4 Discussion 175 4.1 Comparisons With Other Biological Membranes 175 4.2 Distribution of the Probes 185 4.3 Possible Links Between Lipid Fluidity and Lateral Diffusion 187 4.4 The Effect of Lipid Fluidity on Electron Flow 191 6 4.5 Stromal and Granal Membrane Fractions 197 4.6 Future Studies 204 5 References 208 Appendix 1 235 Appendix 2 240 List of Tables 1. Effect of temperature on photosynthetic processes in higher plants. 53 2. Effect of temperature on photosynthetic processes in algae. 55 3. Fluorescence lifetimes of DPH in thylakoid systems. 101 4. Motional parameters of DPH in thylakoid membrane systems. 119 5. Spin-label to chlorophyll ratios and order parameters in thylakoid membranes. 130 6. Order parameters in soya lipid/cholesterol vesicles. 142 7. Order parameters in cholesterol-treated thylakoid membranes. 143 8. PS 1 and PS 2 activities in pea thylakoid fractions. 156 9. DPH fluoresence polarization in pea thylakoid fractions. 159 10. Motional parameters of DPH in pea thylakoid fractions. 160 11. Levels of protein, acyl lipid and chlorophyll in pea thylakoid fractions. 168 12. Proteintlipid ratios in pea thylakoid membrane fractions. 168 13. Fatty-acid composition of pea thylakoid membrane fractions. 169 14. Comparison of the steady-state fluorescence polarization values of DPH in various biological membranes. 176 15. Comparison of the (time-resolved) motional properties of DPH in various biological membranes. 177 7 List of Figures 1. Diagrammatic representation of the light reactions of photosyn- thesis. 24 2. Two-dimensional representations of a lipid bilayer in the gel and liquid-crystalline states. 45 3. Structures of the major thylakoid acyl lipids. 48 4. Flow diagram of the fractionation procedures adopted to isolate granal and stromal membrane fragments. 65 5. Block diagram of the single-beam flash spectrophotometer. 74 6. Block diagram of the apparatus used to measure modulated chloro- phyll fluorescence from intact leaves. 77 7. Diagrammatic representations of first-derivative ESR spectra of fast and slow moving spin-labels. 84 8. Corrected excitation and emission spectra of DPH in various environments. 93 9. Corrected excitation and emission spectra of DPH in thylakoid membranes and soya-phospholipid liposomes. 94 10. Chlorophyll fluorescence excitation and emission spectra in the presence and absence of DPH. 96 11. Effect of increasing DPH levels on chlorophyll fluorescence.98 12. Fluorescence decay of DPH in thylakoid membranes. 102 13. Fluorescence decays of DPH in stromal and granal membrane fractions. 103 14. Lifetimes of DPH fluorescence in lipid-enriched thylakoid membranes. 106 15. Time-course of entry of DPH into the thylakoid membrane. 108 8 16. Fluorescence polarization values of DPH during the time-course of entry into the thylakoid membrane. Ill 17. Wavelength-dependence of the steady-state fluorescence polarization values of DPH. 112 18. Wobbling-in-cone model for the motion of DPH within a lipid bilayer (a), and the actual anisotropy decay for the probe in thylakoid membrane (b). 117 19. Total and difference fluorescence decays of DPH in the thylakoid membrane. 121 20. Total and difference fluorescence decays of DPH in DGDG vesicles. 122 21. Structures of the spin-labels used in ESR measurements of thylakoid membrane fluidity.