Leapfrog Enterprises, Inc. Securities Litigation 03-CV-05421-Exhibits 9-13

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Leapfrog Enterprises, Inc. Securities Litigation 03-CV-05421-Exhibits 9-13 EXHIBITS 9-13 Exhibit 9 United States I EMerrill Lynch FlashNote Education & Training Services 11 February 2004 Lauren R~chFine, CFA LeapFrog Enterprises First Vice President (1) 212 449-1179 LF Delivers on 44, Yet Questions Remain; NEUTIUL Sara Gubins Assistant vice president Announces Mgmt. Changes (1) 212 449-2943 Reason for Report: 44 & FY T)3 Results Volatility Risk: I HIGH LF; $30.40; C-2-9 GAAP EPS (Dec): 2002A 50.86; 2003A 51.20; 2004E $1.43 GAAP P/E(Dec): 2002A 35.3~;2003A 25.3~;2004E 21.3~ Event LeapFrog reported a solid Q4'03, with diluted EPS of $O.7Ush, up 43.6% YoY, beating our estimate by $0.04/sh, $O.Ol/sh below consensus, and within mgmt. guidance of $0.69- S0.76Ish. For the year, EPS grew 40.4% to $1.20/sh vs. $0.86/sh last year, beating our est. by c $0.03/sh, $O.Ol/sh below consensus, and within mgrnt. guidance of $1.17-$1.25/sh. LF issued 2004 guidance, projecting 18-25% rev. growth, 21-31% net income growth and 16-26% EPS growth. In a separate release, LF announced that founder and CEO Michael Wood is stepping down as CEO and t3kng on the role of Chief Vision & Creative Officer. Tom Kalinske, LF's chairman of the board, will resume his role as CEO,Jerry Perez will join LF as president, & director Steve Fink will become chairman of the board. Conference call at 9am ET on Zll. Analysis 44 revenue grew 33.4% YoY to $331.4MM, near the high end of mgmt.'s guided range of $3 16-$334MM, and $1 SMM higher than our estimate. Based on the high accounts receivable position at year end, and high inventory levels we noted in early January at retail, we have some concern that 44 sales stole from Q1'04. Underscoring our concern about sales late in the quarter is a cash flow statement that suggests that cash and short term investments would not have grown except for the proceeds and tax benefits from stock options. US consumer sales grew 25.1 % to $273.4MM ($IOMM higher than our est), international sales grew 95.8% to S46.8MM ($2.3MM higher than our est.), and education & training sales grew 84.6% to $1 1.1 MM,(02.7MM higher than our estimate). According to LF, NF'D reported that LF was the leading manufacturer of pre-school products in the U.S. in Q4, with market share increasing from 17.5% to 27.5%, although we note that NPD does not 0 include WalMart or Toys R Us data, which in the past have represented roundly 58% of LF sales. Sell-thru at 22 US retailers (96% of LF's US sales) increased 27% for the yeat in Leappad family platforms and 33% in Leappad family software. We note that sell-through in 43 was up approximately 35%, with platform sell-through up 40% & software up 80%. This was on a relatively low dollar volume and wasn't limited to just the Leappad family, but we hope to learn more about Q4 sell-through trends on the conference call tomorrow. 44 gross margins declined 308bps vs. last year to 47.9%, 380bps below our 5 1.7% projection. Management attributed the decline to lower margins on Leapster sales, which incurred airfreight costs. Operating expense grew 14.3% in the quarter, below our expectation of 18.9% growth, driven primarily by better than expected SG&A costs and lower depreciation expense. LF noted that advertising (14.3% of sales) was impacted by increased TV ad expense, although it came in slightly below our estimate as a percentage of sales. Operating margins in Q4 were 20.6% vs. our estimate of 21.7%. In the quarter, LF had other income of $ 1.m& booked a reserve due to the KB Toys bankruptcy. The tax rate was 37.1%, yielding net income of W.2MM. up 50.4% YoY and $ I .SMM higher than our projection seeking or will seek investment banking or other Refer to important disclosures on page 3. business relationships with the companies in this report. Analyst Certification on page 2. Menill Lynch Global Securities Research & Economics Group Global Fundamental Equity Research Department LeapFrog Enterprises - 11 February 2004 For the year, revenue grew 27.Yh to $680MM, at the high growth of 24%, leading us to believe there is not much end of mgmt. guidance of $665-$683MM (and higher than downside at this level and that there is potential upside. the original guidance provided last Feb.), gross margins However, we are not yet ready to move to a more positive were 50% vs. mgmt. guidance of 51-52%, operating stance on the stock as we believe that industry dynamics margins were 16.1%, up 268bps YoY, and net income are changing, creating unceriainty for LF. In 2004, LF will grew 673% to I72.7MM. face increased competitive pressure fiom Fisher-Price as Matte1 has already announced that they are committed to Management issued 2004 guidance, projecting revenues of the space and are adding more platforms. We would note $800-$850MM, or 18-25% yearover year growth, a 50% gross margin each quarter, 34% tax rate vs. 37% in '03, net that in the past LF was able to grow margins as it benefited fiom having an innovative product in the market for income of $88-f 95MM, or 21-31% year over year growth, several years before significant competition entered the diluted EPS of Sl.39Ish-$1.51/sh, or 16-26% a~ual market. LF will not have the same kind of lead time growth. LF expects IH'04 sales to each represent prospectively, which could hurt the economics of each new approximately 10% of FY sales, with lower sales growth in the first half and higher in the second half Operating product hereafter. In addition, given that the potmtial impact on pricing due to the market share and price wars expenses are expected to grow 20-25% for the year, with between Wal-Mart and other retailers remains to be seen, growth of 10-15% in 41'04. and that we have not yet seen LF's new products for Separately, LF announced a number of management FY'04 which we look forward to learning more about at changes. Founder and CEO Michael Wood is stepping Toy Fair, it is difficult to have conviction for the upper end down as CEO to take on the role of Chief Vision & of management guidance. In addition, we do have a Creative Officer. Tom Kalinske, LF's chairman of the concern, that we hope to clarify in tomorrow's conference board since 1997, will resume his role as CEO, a position call, that late quarter sales stole from Q1 sales, as based on he held fiom 9/97 to 4/02. Jerry Perez will join LF as our channel checks in January, we have seen high levels of president. Mr. Perez was previously Executive VP of inventory at retailers and as accounts receivable represents Fisher-Price. Director Steve Fink will become chairman of an all time high of 85% of Q4 sales. the board. Mr. Fink has been a board member since 1999. He is the CEO of Lawrence Investments and is a Vice Analyst Certification Chairman of Knowledge Universe. This announcement came as a surprise and we are pleased to learn that I, Lauren Rich ~ine,hereby certify that the views although Mike Wood is stepping down as CEO, he will expressed in this research report accurately reflect my take on a new role at LeapFrog. We believe that Tom personal views about the subject securities and issuers. I Kalinske has been deeply involved in LeapFrog's business also certify that no part of my compensation was, is, or and we therefore expect that the transition should be will be, directly or indirectly, related to the specific relatively smooth. We do hope to learn more about the recommendations or view expressed in this research motivation for these changes on LF's conference call. report. Recommendation & Investment Thesis LF is trading at 25.3~'03A EPS and 21.3~our '04 estimate (which has not yet been revised for today's results). Overall, the Q4 results were strong and it is interesting to note that a year ago, LF was projecting 2003 revenue of $625-S675MM, net income of $55-62MM, and diluted EPS of S0.9ltsh-$1.02/sh. While there have been ups and downs during the year, LF delivered a solid 2003. We are pleased to see that LF has issued 2004 guidance projecting net income growth of 21-31% and EPS growth of 16-26%, although we note that given that the environment has changed, we are approaching guidance a bit more skeptically than we have in the past. We maintain our Neutral rating on the shares. If we assume the low end of '04 earnings guidance and assume the low end of EPS growth of 16%, LF is currently trading at a PEG ratio of 1.37~'04 estimates,just below the average of Manel and Hasbro of I .41x, suggesting that it is fairly valued. However, if we use the mid-range of EPS guidance, assume 20% growth over the next several years, and discount the PEG ratio to 1.3x, this yields prospective Refer to importanl disclosures on page 3. .W~enil~~ynch - LeapFrog Enterprises - 1. I ~tbruary2004 Important Disclosures LF hice Chart 10TekBwm I SB:SmgBrj, B:Bq.
Recommended publications
  • Vtech/Leapfrog Initial Submission
    Completed Acquisition by VTech Holdings Limited of LeapFrog Enterprises Inc. Initial Submission to the Competition and Markets Authority 11 October 2016 i ii Table of Contents Contents Page I. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ........................................................................................................ 2 I.1 No realistic counterfactual scenario, let alone the most likely one, is substantially more competitive than the post-Transaction outcome ..................................................................... 3 I.2 In any event, the Transaction fails to raise substantive issues even against a more typical counterfactual .......................................................................................................................... 4 I.3 Conclusion ............................................................................................................................... 9 II. THE PARTIES ....................................................................................................................... 10 II.1 VTech .................................................................................................................................... 10 II.2 LeapFrog ............................................................................................................................... 12 III. THE TRANSACTION ............................................................................................................ 14 III.1 Transaction structure ............................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Leapfrog Enterprises, Inc
    LeapFrog Enterprises, Inc. David Chan Andrew Wishner +1 (203) 747-4788 +1 (978) 835-0454 SELL [email protected] [email protected] November 29, 2011 Please read the disclaimer at the end of this report for important information Even though LeapFrog has retuned more than 33% in the Vital Statistics past month, its current stock pricing is in a contrarian trend to the rest of the industry. Our Forecast: Overvalued by 15.75% Current Price: $5.00 (of 11/29/2011) Key Investment Considerations 52-Week Range: $2.57 - $6.50 LeapFrog’s current P/E ratio is close to double any of • Market Capitalization: $310.1 mm its industry peers, and its current stock price seems to be solely predicated on investors’ belief in the P/E Ratio: 26.53 unproven potential of the company’s new LeapPad EPS: 0.18 million product. • The company has only been profitable in 50% of the years since 1990, and given its severe losses in 2006, Exhibit 1: Company Revenue (in millions) 2007 and 2008, it will need to see explosive revenue 800 growth to earn back those losses. 600 400 • LeapFrog’s retained earnings has been declining 200 since 2005, and has been negative since 2006, 0 meaning that there is technically no equity value in 2008 2009 2010 2011E 2011E the company, apart from its assets and patents. 2012E 2013E 2014E 2015E Source: Historical Data Capital IQ, Chaner Capital Estimates Contents 1.1 Company Overview 2.1 Model Drivers 3.1 Appendix 4.1 Disclaimer © 2011, David Chan and Andrew Wishner 1 1.1 Company Overview LeapFrog Enterprises (Public, NASDAQ: LF) is an educational entertainment toy company.
    [Show full text]
  • LEAPFROG ENTERPRISES, INC. (Exact Name of Registrant As Specified in Its Charter) Delaware 95-4652013 (State Or Other Jurisdiction of (I.R.S
    Fellow stockholders, We produced our first learning product in 1995, and in Since it was unwrapped 2002, sales of our learning products made us the third on Christmas day … Arianna largest company in the United States toy industry.* “ has spent countless hours with LeapFrog is one of the fastest-growing education companies, her LeapPad on her lap.Within a and one of the largest publishers of children’s books in the month she could read the stories United States — and we are just getting started. in the original book quite well. 2002 was a banner year for LeapFrog. Annual net sales At first we thought that it was exceeded $531 million, which represented more than 69% more memorization than growth over our 2001 revenues. Net income for 2002 knowledge.We were wrong … increased 349% to $43.4 million compared with $9.7 million in 2001. In July 2002, our she constantly scans the house initial public offering raised a net $115 million for the company. Our capital resources for new words to read. She also and strong financial performance have us well positioned to fund our growth going forward. spends quite a bit of time read- ing her storybooks to her dolls Having met and exceeded all of our financial goals for 2002, we are looking forward to and stuffed animals....Thank building our product offering and developing new market opportunities in 2003. you for creating a wonderfully LeapFrog products are recognized for innovation, engagement and learning efficacy in fun way for my granddaughter every category in which we compete: to learn.
    [Show full text]
  • Leapfrog Enterprises, Inc. Securities Litigation 03-CV-05421-Amended
    Case 5:03-cv-05421-RMW Document 191 Filed 01/27/2006 Page 1 of 151 1 Joseph J. Tabacco, Jr. (75484) Christopher T. Heffelfinger (118058) 2 Nicole Lavallee (165755) Julie J. Bai (227047) 3 BERMAN DEVALERIO PEASE TABACCO BURT & PUCILLO 4 425 California Street, Suite 2100 San Francisco, CA 94104-2205 5 Telephone: (415) 433-3200 Facsimile: (415) 433-6382 6 Email: [email protected] Liaison Counsel for the Class 7 Steven J. Toll (admitted pro hac vice) Elizabeth Berney (admitted pro hac vice) Matthew K. Handley (admitted pro hac vice) 8 COHEN, MILSTEIN, HAUSFELD & TOLL, P.L.L.C 9 1100 New York Avenue, N.W. West Tower, Suite 500 10 Washington, D.C. 20005 Telephone: (202) 408-4600 11 Facsimile: (202) 408-4699 Email: [email protected] 12 Lead Counsel for the Class 13 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT 14 NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA 15 ) In re LEAPFROG ENTERPRISES, INC. ) CIVIL ACTION NO. C-03-05421-RMW 16 SECURITIES LITIGATION ) ) 17 ) AMENDED CONSOLIDATED CLASS This Document Relates To: ) ACTION COMPLAINT FOR 18 ) VIOLATIONS OF FEDERAL All Actions ) SECURITIES LAWS 19 ) ) DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 [C-03-05421-RMW] AMENDED CONSOLIDATED CLASS ACTION COMPLAINT FOR VIOLATIONS OF FEDERAL SECURITIES LAWS Case 5:03-cv-05421-RMW Document 191 Filed 01/27/2006 Page 2 of 151 1 TABLE OF CONTENTS 2 INTRODUCTION ...........................................................................................................................1 3 JURISDICTION AND VENUE ....................................................................................................13
    [Show full text]
  • Protecting Pennsylvania's Investments
    刀 攀瀀 漀 爀琀 漀 昀 䄀 挀琀椀瘀椀琀椀攀猀 倀甀 爀猀甀 愀渀 琀 䄀 挀琀 㐀㐀 漀 昀 ㈀ ㄀ 䄀 渀 渀 甀 愀氀 刀 攀瀀 漀 爀琀 匀攀瀀琀攀洀 戀攀爀 ㌀ Ⰰ ㈀ ㄀㔀 倀甀 爀 倀甀 爀 Annual Report of Activities Pursuant to Act 44 of 2010 September 30, 2015 September 30, 2015 The Commonwealth of Pennsylvania has enacted legislation (Act 44 of 2010) requiring public funds to divest from companies doing business in Iran and/or Sudan that meet certain thresholds of activity. Additionally, Act 44 prohibits Pennsylvania’s public funds from purchasing securities of a company once it appears on scrutinized business activities lists, regardless of whether the funds already have direct holdings in such company. Act 44 requires that the public funds each year assemble and provide a report to the Governor, the President Pro Tempore of the Senate, the Speaker of the House of Representatives, and each member of the boards of the Pennsylvania Municipal Retirement System, the State Employees’ Retirement System, and the Public School Employees’ Retirement System. Accordingly, we have prepared this report on the activities our funds have undertaken to comply with the requirements of Act 44 during the period July 1, 2014 to June 30, 2015. This report includes: • The most recent scrutinized companies lists (Sudan and Iran). • A summary of correspondence with scrutinized companies. • All investments sold, redeemed, divested or withdrawn in compliance with Act 44, the costs and expenses of such transfers, and a determination of net gain or loss associated with such transactions executed in compliance with the Act. • A list of publicly traded securities held by the public funds.
    [Show full text]
  • Toys and Games - World
    Toys and Games - World Euromonitor International : Global Market Insight April 2009 Toys and games World List of Contents and Tables Executive Briefing................................................................................................................................................... 1 State of the Market.................................................................................................................................................... 1 Chart 1 Global Presentation Slide 1 ............................................................................................... 1 Chart 2 Global Presentation Slide 2 ............................................................................................... 1 Chart 3 Global Presentation Slide 3 ............................................................................................... 2 Chart 4 Global Presentation Slide 4 ............................................................................................... 3 Chart 5 Global Presentation Slide 5 ............................................................................................... 4 Chart 6 Global Presentation Slide 6 ............................................................................................... 5 Chart 7 Global Presentation Slide 7 ............................................................................................... 6 Chart 8 Global Presentation Slide 8 ............................................................................................... 7 Chart 9 Global Presentation
    [Show full text]
  • Feasibility of the Nintendo Ds for Teaching Problem-Based Learning in Kindergarten Through Twelfth Grade Students
    FEASIBILITY OF THE NINTENDO DS FOR TEACHING PROBLEM-BASED LEARNING IN KINDERGARTEN THROUGH TWELFTH GRADE STUDENTS _______________________________________ A Thesis presented to the Faculty of the Graduate School at the University of Missouri-Columbia _______________________________________________________ In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Master of Science _____________________________________________________ by MICHAEL LIPINSKI Dr. Otho Plummer, Thesis Supervisor August 2008 The undersigned, appointed by the dean of the Graduate School, have examined the thesis entitled Feasibility of the Nintendo DS for Teaching Problem-Based Learning in Kindergarten through Twelfth Grade Students presented by Michael Lipinski, a candidate for the degree of Masters of Science, and hereby certify that, in their opinion, it is worthy of acceptance. Professor Otho Plummer Professor William Harrison Professor Michael Hosokawa Acknowledgements First off I would like to thank my loving family for all their support over the years. If it was not for them and their sacrifices I would not be writing this page today. I would also like to thank my close friends (anyone who could be considered part of the “Como crew”), my family away from my family. They helped me laugh through the sad times, supported me through the tough times, and entertain me through the boring times. They were always willing to lend a hand and an ear and I love them all dearly for it. That goes double for my best friend and partner in crime, Mike Torpea. I would also like to thank my first advisor, my boss, and my friend Dr. Ali Hussam. I would not have even been in graduate school if not for his “gentle” pushing and the job he gave me to help pay for it.
    [Show full text]
  • (AVL) Ditest Fahrzeugdiagnose Gmbh 4621 @Pos.Com 3765 01Db‐Stell 3151 0XF8 Limited 10737 103Mm Tech 8168 1064138 Ontario Ltd
    Vendor ID Company (Decimal Format) (AVL) DiTEST Fahrzeugdiagnose GmbH 4621 @pos.com 3765 01dB‐Stell 3151 0XF8 Limited 10737 103mm Tech 8168 1064138 Ontario Ltd. O/A UNI‐TEC ELECTRONICS 8219 11 WAVE TECHNOLOGY, INC. 4375 1417188 Ontario Ltd. 4835 1C Company 5288 1MORE INC. 12048 2D Debus & Diebold Messsysteme GmbH 8539 2L international B.V. 4048 2N TELEKOMUNIKACE a.s. 7303 2‐Tel B.V. 2110 2WCOM GmbH 7343 2Wire, Inc 2248 360 Electrical, LLC 12686 360 Service Agency GmbH 12930 360fly, Inc. 11161 3Brain GmbH 9818 3C TEK CORP. 9397 3Cam Technology, Inc 1928 3Com Corporation 1286 3D CONNEXION SAM 9583 3D Imaging & Simulations Corp. (3DISC) 11190 3D INNOVATIONS, LLC 7907 3D Robotics Inc. 9900 3D Systems Corporation 10632 3D Technologies Ltd 12655 3DM Devices Inc 2982 3DRUDDER 11770 3DSP 7513 3DV Systems Ltd. 6963 3eYamaichi Electronics Co., Ltd. 8709 3i Corporation 9806 3i techs Development Corp 4263 3layer Engineering 7123 3M Canada 2200 3M CMD (Communication Markets Division) 7723 3M Cogent, Inc. 7717 3M Germany 2597 3M Home Health Systems 2166 3M Library Systems 3372 3M Scott 8463 3Pea Technologies, Inc. 3637 3Shape A/S 6303 3T B.V. 11721 4G Systems GmbH 6485 4iiii Innovations Inc. 10009 4Links Limited 10728 4MOD Technology 10244 64seconds, Inc. 12215 77 Elektronika Kft. 11175 8086 Consultancy 12657 89 North, Inc. 12070 8D TECHNOLOGIES INC. 8845 8devices 9599 90meter Solutions, Inc. 12086 A & G Souzioni Digitali 4757 A & R Cambridge Ltd. 9668 A C S Co., Ltd. 9454 A Global Partner Corporation 3689 A W Electronics, Inc. 2266 A&D Company, Limited 3516 A&E Office Machines Inc.
    [Show full text]
  • Company Vendor ID
    Vendor ID Company (Decimal Format) (AVL) DiTEST Fahrzeugdiagnose GmbH 4621 @pos.com 3765 01dB‐Stell 3151 0XF8 Limited 10737 103mm Tech 8168 1064138 Ontario Ltd. O/A UNI‐TEC ELECTRONICS 8219 11 WAVE TECHNOLOGY, INC. 4375 1417188 Ontario Ltd. 4835 1C Company 5288 1MORE INC. 12048 2D Debus & Diebold Messsysteme GmbH 8539 2L international B.V. 4048 2N TELEKOMUNIKACE a.s. 7303 2‐Tel B.V. 2110 2WCOM GmbH 7343 2Wire, Inc 2248 360 Electrical, LLC 12686 360fly, Inc. 11161 3Brain GmbH 9818 3C TEK CORP. 9397 3Cam Technology, Inc 1928 3Com Corporation 1286 3D CONNEXION SAM 9583 3D Imaging & Simulations Corp. (3DISC) 11190 3D INNOVATIONS, LLC 7907 3D Robotics Inc. 9900 3D Systems Corporation 10632 3D Technologies Ltd 12655 3DM Devices Inc 2982 3DRUDDER 11770 3DSP 7513 3DV Systems Ltd. 6963 3eYamaichi Electronics Co., Ltd. 8709 3i Corporation 9806 3i techs Development Corp 4263 3layer Engineering 7123 3M Canada 2200 3M CMD (Communication Markets Division) 7723 3M Cogent, Inc. 7717 3M Germany 2597 3M Home Health Systems 2166 3M Library Systems 3372 3M Scott 8463 3M Touch Systems 1430 3Pea Technologies, Inc. 3637 3Shape A/S 6303 3T B.V. 11721 4G Systems GmbH 6485 4iiii Innovations Inc. 10009 4Links Limited 10728 4MOD Technology 10244 64seconds, Inc. 12215 77 Elektronika Kft. 11175 8086 Consultancy 12657 89 North, Inc. 12070 8BITDO TECHNOLOGY HK LIMITED 11720 8D TECHNOLOGIES INC. 8845 8devices 9599 90meter Solutions, Inc. 12086 A & G Souzioni Digitali 4757 A & R Cambridge Ltd. 9668 A C S Co., Ltd. 9454 A Global Partner Corporation 3689 A W Electronics, Inc.
    [Show full text]
  • Division of Trading and Markets Staff DATE
    TO: File S7-19-07 FROM: Division of Trading and Markets Staff DATE: November 19, 2007 RE: Proposed Amendments to Regulation SHO On November 16, 2007, staff of the Division of Trading and Markets met with representatives of Overstock.com to discuss Overstock.com’s comment letters submitted for File S7-19-07. AGENDA Meeting with SEC on November 16, 2007 1. September 10 comment letter on proposed elimination of the Options Market Maker Exception (http://www.sec.gov/comments/s7‐19‐07/s71907‐130.pdf) o G: Grandfather Clause eliminated. o O: Options Market Maker Exception should be eliminated, not narrowed. o L: Short sellers should be required to get a firm locate before shorting. The technology exists to ensure unique locates in a fast, liquid market. o D: Fails should be disclosed promptly and completely, just like short interest data. 2. October 1 comment letter on proposed elimination of the Options Market Maker Exception (http://www.sec.gov/comments/s7‐19‐07/s71907‐303.pdf) o Liquidity is important, but not if it results in fraud. A market must have scarcity if there is to be meaningful price discovery. o The Options Market Maker Exception is regularly abused in Threshold companies. In Overstock, fraudulent married puts executed, in part, on the Chicago Stock Exchange are a vehicle for creating stock when none is available to borrow. Dishonest market participants have been claiming a market making exception in OTC equity derivatives (e.g., FLEX options) in order to naked short OSTK. Overstock is not alone; at least 16 other Threshold companies have the same trading patterns.
    [Show full text]