Arxiv:Math/0307075V1 [Math.GR] 5 Jul 2003 Quotients of a Universal
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Quotients of a Universal Locally Projective Polytope of type {5, 3, 5} ∗ Michael I. Hartley KDU College Jalan SS 22/41, Damansara Jaya Selangor, 47400, Malaysia [email protected] Dimitri Leemans D´epartement de Math´ematiques Universit´eLibre de Bruxelles C.P.216 – G´eom´etrie Boulevard du Triomphe B-1050 Bruxelles [email protected] In Memory of H. S. M. “Donald” Coxeter, 1907–2003 Abstract This article examines the universal polytope P (of type {5, 3, 5}) whose facets are dodecahedra, and whose vertex figures are hemi- icosahedra. The polytope is proven to be finite, and the structure of its group is identified. This information is used to classifiy the quo- tients of the polytope. A total of 145 quotients are found, including arXiv:math/0307075v1 [math.GR] 5 Jul 2003 69 section regular polytopes with the same facets and vertex figures as P. 1 Introduction This article may be seen in three different ways. On the one hand, it was inspired by, and solves, a problem in the theory of polytopes. A certain ∗MSC (2000): 51M20, 20F65, 52B15 1 regular polytope is proven to exist and be finite, and its quotient polytopes are discovered. Being about polytopes, it is also a paper about geometries or buildings, since (for example) every regular polytope is a thin regular geometry with a string diagram. Finally, it may also be regarded as an article about Coxeter groups. A certain quotient of a hyperbolic Coxeter group is proven to be finite, and its structure as a group is identified. The polytope studied is the universal polytope P whose facets are do- decahedra and whose vertex figures are hemi-icosahedra. This polytope is locally projective, that is, it is section regular with facets and vertex figures either spherical or projective, and not both spherical. The polytope, of type {5, 3, 5}, covers every polytope with facets and vertex figures of these types. A classification of its quotients is therefore important since it encompasses a classification of the locally projective polytopes of type {5, 3, 5} – every such polytope or its dual is a quotient of P. The automorphism group of this polytope is the quotient of the Coxeter group [5, 3, 5] = hs0,s1,s2,s3i 5 by the normal subgroup generated by all quotients of (s1s2s3) . The results of the article is expressed mainly in the language of abstract polytopes, since that is the setting which gave rise to the results, and (in the authors’ opinion) in which they seem the most significant. It is assumed from this point on that the reader is familiar with the basic concepts of abstract polytopes and their quotients. The most important reference in the theory of abstract regular polytopes is [13]. An abstract polytope is a poset satisfying certain properties that are satisfied by the face-lattices of classical polytopes, as well as honeycombs in euclidian and hyperbolic space, and other objects. The theory therefore encompasses all of the latter, as well as a rich assortment of polytopes on other spaceforms and objects for which it is difficult to define a natural topology. The locally projective polytopes fall into the latter class. A (section) regular polytope may be defined to be locally X if its minimal nonspherical sections have topological type X (see [11]). Alternatively but not equiva- lently, some authors define a locally X polytope to be one whose facets and vertex figures are either spherical or X, but not both spherical (see for ex- ample [15]). Note that the former definition subsumes the latter, and that in rank 4 the two definitions are equivalent, since all polytopes of rank2 or less are spherical. A regular polytope is one whose automorphism group acts transitively on its set of flags (that is, maximal totally ordered subsets). The most important result in the study of abstract regular polytopes is that they are in one to one correspondence with so-called string C-groups, that is groups generated by involutions s0,s1,...,sn−1 where first of all sisj = sjsi whenever i =6 j, j±1, and secondly, hsi : i ∈ Ii∩hsi : i ∈ Ji = hsi : i ∈ I ∩ Ji for any I,J ⊆{0,...,n−1}. The automorphism groups of regular polytopes 2 are always C-groups, and from any C-group the corresponding polytope may be reconstructed. Given a polytope P and a subgroup N of its automorphism group, the elements of P are partitioned into orbits {F · N : F ∈ P} by N. We may define a poset P/N on these orbits, the quotient of P by N, in a natural way, letting F · N ≤ G · N if F ≤ G (that is, F · N ≤ G · N if and only if there exists F ′ ∈ F · N and G′ ∈ G · N with F ′ ≤ G′). When P is regular, the conditions on N for which P/N is again a polytope are well-known (see [12], or Section 2D of [13]). In fact, every polytope may be written as a quotient of some regular polytope (see [4] and [5]), and the quotients of a regular polytope P are in one-to-one correspondence with conjugacy classes of so-called “semisparse” subgroups of Aut(P). Let K and L be regular polytopes. If there exists a polytope Q whose facets are of type L and whose vertex figures are of type K, then there is a universal such polytope P, denoted {L, K} (with automorphism group [L, K]), which “covers” all other such polytopes in the sense that they are quotients of P. This was shown in Theorem 2.5 of [7], and much earlier for the case when Q is regular in [14] (see Theorem 4A2 of [13]). The search for polytopes with particular facets and vertex figures therefore usually follows the following pattern. First the universal such polytope is discovered (if not already known). Secondly, the quotients of this universal polytope are sought. In [7], various results about semisparse subgroups were uncovered that facilitate this process. Let W = hs0,...,sn−1i be the group of a regular polytope P, let Hn−1 = hs0,...,sn−2i be the group of its facets, and let H0 = hs1,...,sn−1i be the group of its vertex figures. The key result from [7] that we shall use here is as follows. If the vertex figures of P have no proper quotients, then subgroups w N of W are semisparse if and only N ∩ H0Hn−1 is semisparse in Hn−1 for all conjugates N w of N in W (see Theorem 2.7 of [7]). In this article, we are interested in polytopes whose facets are dodec- ahedra, and whose vertex figures are hemi-icosahedra. If any such poly- topes exist at all, they are quotients of a universal such polytope with au- 2 2 2 2 tomorphism group W = hs0,s1,s2,s3i, satisfying s0 = s1 = s2 = s3 = 1, 5 3 5 (s0s1) = (s1s2) = (s2s3) = 1, s0s2 = s2s0, s1s3 = s3s1, s0s3 = s3s0 and 5 (s1s2s3) = 1. For the remainder of this article, W shall denote this group. It is shown in Section 2 that W is a C-group, the group of a well-defined polytope P whose facets and vertex figures are as desired. This is done by exhibiting an example of another (smaller) such polytope, which must therefore be a proper quotient of P. In Section 3, it is shown that W (and therefore P) is in fact finite, and is the direct product of two large simple groups, the Janko group J1 and the 3 projective special linear group L2(19). In Section 4, the remaining quotients are discovered and tabulated. Let H0 = hs1,s2,s3i and H3 = hs0,s1,s2i. 2 Two Quotients of P. Coxeter, in [2], discovered a self-dual locally projective polytope P′′ with 57 hemi-dodecahedral facets (it was also constructed in [16]). We shall call this polytope the 57-cell. In [6] it was shown that Coxeter’s 57-cell has ′′ ′′ ′′ ′′ ′′ no proper quotients. Its group W is generated by {s0,s1,s2,s3} with the ′′ ′′ ′′ 5 ′′ ′′ ′′ 5 relations of [5, 3, 5] and the additional relations (s0s1s2) = (s1s2s3) = 1. ′′ Moreover W is isomorphic to the simple group L2(19)(= P SL2(19)), of 2 2 order 3420 = 2 .3 .5.19. It is a quotient of W = hs0,s1,s2,s3i by the normal ′′ 5 subgroup N generated by all conjugates of (s0s1s2) . The simple group L2(19) has a permutation presentation on 20 points. Readers interested to see this permutation presentation should download this article’s “auxiliary information” available at [8]. (See also the notes at the end of Section 4.) 5 ′′ For the remainder of this article, let ω =(s0s1s2) , so that N = hhωii. The action of ω (as an automorphism) on P is to move a (base) flag Φ to the “opposite” flag of the facet contained in Φ. ′ 3 Define ν = ωs3, and let N = hhν ii be the normal subgroup of W generated by all conjugates of ν3. The group W ′ ∼= W/N ′ may be taken ′ ′ ′ ′ to be the group hs0,s1,s2,s3i whose generators satisfy all the relations of ′ ′ ′ 5 ′ ′ ′ 5 ′ 3 [5, 3, 5] as well as the additional relations (s1s2s3) = ((s0s1s2) s3) = 1. A computer algebra package [3] was used to analyse the group W ′. It was found to be isomorphic to the Janko group J1, a sporadic finite simple group of order 175560 = 23.3.5.7.11.19. It was also checked that W ′ is a C-group, ′ ′ ′ ′ ′ ′ ′ ′ that H3 = hs0,s1,s2i has order 120, that H0 = hs1,s2,s3i has order 60, and therefore that W ′ is the group of a regular polytope P′ with dodecahedral facets and hemi-icosahedral vertex figures.