Jillian Tomm School of Information Studies Mcgill University, Montreal October 2012 a Thesis Submitted to Mcgill University In
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
THE IMPRINT OF THE SCHOLAR: AN ANALYSIS OF THE PRINTED BOOKS OF MCGILL UNIVERSITY’S RAYMOND KLIBANSKY COLLECTION Jillian Tomm School of Information Studies McGill University, Montreal October 2012 A thesis submitted to McGill University in partial fulfillment of the requirements of the degree of Doctor of Philosophy © Jillian Tomm 2012 TABLE OF CONTENTS Abstract ................................................................................................................................... iv Résumé ..................................................................................................................................... v Acknowledgements ............................................................................................................... vi List of Tables ....................................................................................................................... viii List of Figures ......................................................................................................................... x Abbreviations ........................................................................................................................ xii PART I: Introduction and Orientation to the Study ....................................................... 1 Chapter 1: General Introduction and goals of the study ................................................. 1 1.1 Background to the research ....................................................................................... 3 1.2 Research framework.................................................................................................. 11 1.3 Existing work on the collection. ............................................................................. 14 Chapter 2: Literature Review I: Who is Klibansky? ...................................................... 16 2.1 Biographical sketch, with an emphasis on Klibansky’s formative years ............ 16 2.2 Summary of main research and publication areas ................................................ 36 Chapter 3: Literature Review II: Methodology in the Study of Private Libraries ...... 42 3.1 Variety in approaches to private libraries ............................................................... 42 3.2 Book history ............................................................................................................... 44 3.3 Library history ............................................................................................................ 54 3.4 Summary of useful approaches and sources from book and library history .... 61 3.5 Methods used in practice: monograph studies of individual libraries................ 62 3.6 A note on library analysis in the online environment. ......................................... 72 Chapter 4: Methodology..................................................................................................... 79 4.1 Methodological overview. ........................................................................................ 79 4.2 Procedural aspects of the catalogue data analysis ................................................. 85 4.3 Subject analysis: the OCLC Conspectus ................................................................ 96 i 4.4 Delimitations and limitations of the study ............................................................. 99 Part II: The Raymond Klibansky Collection ................................................................. 106 Chapter 5: Introduction to the collection ...................................................................... 106 5.1 Developing a special awareness of libraries ......................................................... 106 5.2 Klibansky’s general treatment of his books ......................................................... 110 5.3 The RKC in context ................................................................................................ 111 5.4 The RKC collection as studied here ..................................................................... 115 Chapter 6: Content characteristics of the Klibansky Collection ................................ 118 6.1 Broad subject coverage ........................................................................................... 118 6.2 Particularities of the classification system that affect subject distribution ...... 123 6.3 Language ................................................................................................................... 126 6.4 Main authors ............................................................................................................ 135 6.5 Philosophy & Religion: the core of the RKC ...................................................... 142 Chapter 7: Overview of publication periods ................................................................. 156 7.1 Incunables ................................................................................................................. 156 7.2 The sixteenth to eighteenth centuries ................................................................... 157 7.3 The nineteenth and twentieth centuries ............................................................... 170 Chapter 8: Provenance evidence in the Klibansky Collection – Overview .............. 192 8.1 Summary of main types of provenance evidence in the RKC .......................... 192 8.2 Ownership and gift inscriptions ............................................................................ 194 8.3 Bookplates, book labels and stamps ..................................................................... 204 8.4 Other provenance evidence groups ...................................................................... 206 Chapter 9: Clusters of Provenance Evidence in the Klibansky Collection – a first assessment ........................................................................................................................... 211 9.1 Klibansky’s ownership inscriptions ...................................................................... 211 9.2 Gifts from Klibansky’s circles. .............................................................................. 215 ii 9.3 Tributary libraries of the Klibansky Collection ................................................... 246 Chapter 10: Klibansky’s Book Organization: The Enigmatic Subgroup of Shelf- marked Books ..................................................................................................................... 254 10.1 Introduction ........................................................................................................... 254 10.2 Deciphering Klibansky’s shelf marks ................................................................. 256 10.3 Why these books? .................................................................................................. 265 10.4 The shelf marks as a reflection of Klibansky .................................................... 277 Chapter 11: Conclusions .................................................................................................. 280 11.1. The Klibansky Collection and what it has to teach ......................................... 280 11.2 Looking at the special collections through catalogue data .............................. 287 11.3 Limitations of the study and further research ................................................... 290 11.4 In summary ............................................................................................................ 291 Bibliography ........................................................................................................................ 294 A. General References................................................................................................... 294 B. Referenced and main titles by Raymond Klibansky: in chronological order. .. 313 C. Works on private libraries consulted but not cited .............................................. 318 Appendixes .......................................................................................................................... 321 Appendix I. Summary of source about Klibansky .................................................... 322 Appendix II. Fields (columns) of the RKC Data Sheet ........................................... 333 Appendix III. EndNote MARC filter used and examples of output comparison with a basic RIS filter .................................................................................................... 339 Appendix IV. Frequently occurring authors noted in Klibansky’s leisure reading .......................................................................................................................................... 347 Appendix V. Language analysis ................................................................................... 348 Appendix VI. Description of supplementary electronic material (LISTS) ............ 350 iii ABSTRACT The library of Raymond Klibansky (1905-2005), historian of philosophy, was acquired by McGill University’s Rare Books and Special Collections in 2005. This first study of the Raymond Klibansky Collection (RKC) provides an introduction to the approximately 7000-title collection in its main characteristics and research strengths; offers an aid to further research on the collection; and builds on what is known about Klibansky and his life with books. The approach to the study was developed from a review of methods proposed in current discussion of book and library history research, and from structures