Tui Motu Tui Motu
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
TuiTui MotuMotu InterIslands August 2002 Price $4 timetime toto standstand andand starestare Tui Motu InterIslands 1 editorial Electoral Shambles Contents 2 editorial his is written during the final days one at that – Genetic Engineering. The 3 letters Tbefore the 2002 Election. The speakers were thoroughly prepared and 4-6 Why is this life so full of care...? campaign has been dominated by TV both very able presenters. They listened James Hillman shouting matches, minor issues magni- to each other and answered each other. 7-9 Doing it our way: the Waitaha Trust fied by the media into major scandals, Point scoring was reduced to a mini- Katie O’Connor and constant bickering over who will mum. The audience was attentive and 10-12 Life on an Israeli kibbutz go into coalition with whom after July did not interrupt discussion. Katie O’Connor 26. There has been much noise and little 13-15 The Consistent Ethic of Life No one would have gone away from that Mary Eastham reason. Real issues have been ignored or swamped. debate without being better informed 16-17 The icons of Russia and perhaps guided to a reasoned choice Peter Stupples 18 Belting kids The major responsibility for this must on one of the outstanding issues of the Glynn Cardy fall on media coverage, particularly by election. Another supreme virtue was 19-21 Broken-ness: a questionable virtue TV One. The so-called leaders’ debates the total absence of Holmes or his ilk. John Hunt have been little better than circus 22 Ministry to Church leavers entertainment with Holmes, the ring- Significantly, although this debate took Trish McBride master, constantly interrupting and place right at the beginning of the 23 poetry: The Centre of the Circle preventing the development of any campaign, none of the national channels Joy Cowley rational discussion. thought to rebroadcast it. Even more 24 response significantly, the overseas proprietor Paul Green, Anna Holmes Presentation has been custom built chose the following week to pull the 25 Marriage and sexuality in favour of the master opportunist, plug on the local TV channel. Jack Dominian Winston Peters. Little wonder that, 26 in memoriam: Xavier Rynne fuelled by the applause of a lobotomised wo observations on the main Jim Neilan studio audience, the Peters’ Party ratings Tcontenders. Helen Clark never fails 27 Labourer in the vineyard to register her consummate political skill Pat Reid have soared. These misnamed ‘debates’ are constantly interrupted by commerc- and her mastery of detail. However, 27-29 films and books an interesting chink in her armour Mike Crowl; Kevin Burns ial breaks often featuring scare- mongering political advertisements. has appeared during the campaign. Kathleen Doherty Whenever an edge of scorn comes into 30 Crosscurrents And so, during these final days, poll her voice, you can guarantee she is on John Honoré ratings are fluctuating almost as wildly 31 Voices from the past and mindlessly as the Dow Jones index. shaky ground. It is her way of dealing Humphrey O’Leary CSsR with doubt, and she manifested it 32 postscript Over three weeks of the campaign repeatedly towards the Greens and the Tom Cloher I witnessed one really worthwhile GE issue. She knows that both her logic debate – between Green leader Jeanette and her science are vulnerable so she uses Fitzsimon and Labour Minister for the this rhetorical technique to escape facing a new series Environment, Pete Hodgson. It took up to an issue which may well haunt place in Dunedin Town Hall, ably her – and us – for many years to come. Regular extracts from a recent book chaired by an eminent barrister, Judith by Dr Jack Dominian, psychiatrist and Ablett-Kerr. It was televised in full with Bill English has reinforced his image as a commentator on marriage and human minimal breaks by local TV. There was doughty scrapper. He is never overawed relationships. adequate time for questions from the by a hostile protagonist, even Kim Hill (Let’s Make Love, Darton Longman & at her most waspish. However, I never Todd Ltd., is available from the NZ floor, which were often thoughtful and cease to be amazed that he should have distributor Catholic Supplies, Wellington) challenging. After a full hour and a half the debate was still in full swing, so TV so shamelessly hitched his pennant to coverage was simply extended to allow the Law and Order bandwagon. How the process to proceed to its natural many times during the campaign has Cover: Time to stand and stare conclusion. he trotted out the 92 percent figure? Donald Moorhead illustrates the fable of “Ninety Two percent of the electorate The Hare and the Tortoise as an introduction Why was this debate so good? First, in 1999 voted for stricter sentencing”, to the leading article on pages 4-6. there was one topic only – and a crucial he cries ad nauseam. That figure is a 2 Tui Motu InterIslands letters totally dishonest statistic – and he must or 30 years? The manner of this election which afflicts every sphere of modern know it. The 1999 vote was based on and its media presentation must, life, not just politics or media comment, a question so loaded that no court of however, make us pause and ponder. we present as our leading article a law would ever have countenanced it. reflection on the Eighth Deadly Sin. It was another version of the notorious What seems to be obscured or lost in What’s that? Read overleaf and find out! question: “Have you ceased beating the constant media-driven stampede for Read it and then apply its critique of our your wife yet?” The question was quick responses and instant answers is Western world to the way our election wilfully misleading, and therefore the any exploration of depth, any rational has been fought and presented to us by result has no value except to show how debate in search of truth, or any the media. not to word a referendum question. evidence drawn from mature experi- ence. Wisdom is displaced by pragma- You may conclude that in place of It is also evident that Mr English needs tism. Rational argument gives way to ever higher economic growth, of ever a crash course on the virtues of restor- the soundbite and the tele-opportunity. more complex assessment procedures ative justice. He could do worse than Prudence and reflection are sacrificed to to in place of exams, of new assaults on study the writings of Cardinal Joseph haste and expediency. crime, what we in New Zealand need Bernardin (see article pages 13-15). is wisdom – the wisdom to cherish You could say that this accurately and enhance the huge assets of this lections come and go. Who will reflects the instant society we live in: green and pleasant land and its richly Eremember the Holmes debates in instant food, instant comment, instant endowed and talented people. Will three months time, let alone three years closure. In response to this malaise M.H. Tougher sentencing? to the taxpayer, could never have as Catholics, as Wel-Com gave its Richard Prebble, in his call for harsher done! He has picked up her ideas and readers in the dioceses of Palmerston penalties and his courting of the is now a very fine man at peace with North and Wellington, through a fine ‘Lock’m-up-and-throw-away-the- his community. article by Cardinal Tom Williams key brigade!’ will, no doubt, attract John Miller, Christchurch Social Teachings to Guide Catholic considerable public support in our voters (July issue). increasingly fear and violence-ridden His first principle, the protection culture. Or lack of it! Hitler received letters ✍ of human life and dignity, covered like support in his campaign against issues that mainstream politics in the Jews who terrified him! New Zealand tries to largely avoid, In vivid contrast, there was a man Election coverage preferring to deal with issues affecting with a frightening moko on his face Thank you for the July issue. Quite the economy and other material things, (Tui Motu July cover). His father was a few thought-provoking articles. 0I as did John Honoré. a criminal and he had a terrible life of particularly found interesting those Brian Quin SM, Wellington abuse and did time in prison. A prime about Challenge 2000 and Kitty Tui Motu’s strategy was to offer column McKinley. candidate for Prebble’s solution! space to various parties, but the early election I think that in recent months you have But a woman with radically different date frustrated this. ideas to Richard got hold of him and been balanced in your pre-election As with all matters political and social, we really stuck with him. She has done coverage. I would, though, have aim to raise issues to help people make up for him, on a shoe-string budget, that liked to have seen something on the their minds, not make up people’s minds for which a lifetime in jail, at a huge cost principles that should guide our voting Tui Motu-InterIslands is an independent, Catholic, monthly magazine. It invites its readers to question, challenge and contribute to its discussion of spiritual and social issues in the light of gospel values, and in the interests of a more just and peaceful society. Inter-church and inter-faith dialogue is welcomed. The name Tui Motu was given by Pa Henare Tate. It literally means “stitching the islands together...”, bringing the different races and peoples and faiths together to create one Pacific people of God. Divergence of opinion is expected and will normally be Tui Motu-InterIslands published, although that does not necessarily imply editorial commitment to the viewpoint expressed.