Cold War Spy Fiction in Russian Popular Culture: from Suspi- Cion to Acceptance Via Seventeen Moments of Spring

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Cold War Spy Fiction in Russian Popular Culture: from Suspi- Cion to Acceptance Via Seventeen Moments of Spring Cold War Spy Fiction in Russian Popular Culture: From Suspi- cion to Acceptance via Seventeen Moments of Spring Erik Jens Introduction In 1972, a classified CIA document (right) describing an episode of a novel that was serialized in Komsomolskaya Pravda during January and February 1969 was filed in CIA Headquarters. The episode involved a supposed Soviet intelligence operation early in 1945, in which a “Colonel Isayev” successfully “sabotaged” negotiations OSS officer Allen Dulles was then conducting with the Germans in Bern, Switzerland. Ac- cording to the report, Isayev also met two senior Germans, “Chancellor Bruening” and “Gestapo chief Mueller.” The report writer went on to conclude the account was “in all probability a fabrication”—although the Dulles negotiation was a fact— but in the interests of caution the report’s preparer recommended it be filed in Heinrich Muel- ler’s CIA file—where it remained at least until 2008, when it was declassified.1 As it turned out, the episode was neither a real operation nor a “fabrication,” but a synopsis of an episode in a Soviet spy thriller titled Seventeen Moments of Spring, which went on to become one of the USSR’s most pop- ular and enduring television miniseries. That US intelligence analysts could mistake a work of Soviet-era spy fiction for reportable intelligence says much about the most famously, the 1973 television miniseries Seventeen opacity, to Western observers throughout the Cold War Moments of Spring.a, 2 The series, commissioned by then- and even afterward, of Soviet popular culture. The single KGB chief Yuri Andropov to burnish the reputation of most popular and venerable hero of Russian spy fiction, for nearly 50 years, has been Col. Maxim Maximovich Isaуev, known to every Russian of a certain age by his a. This essay will use the terms “Soviet” and “Russian” in- working cover name, Max Otto von Stierlitz, or simply terchangeably when discussing cultural attitudes, which had, as “Stierlitz,” the hero of several Soviet-era novels and, and retain, deep roots in the Russian motherland. The views, opinions, and findings should not be construed as asserting or implying US government endorsement of its factual statements and interpretations or representing the official positions of any component of the United States government. © Erik Jens, 2017 Studies in Intelligence Vol 61, No. 2 (Extracts, June 2017) 31 Seventeen Moments of Spring In the Soviet Union of the late 1940s and 1950s, espio- nage, as a genre of fiction, held little appeal for the Soviet The Russian literary world had reading and movie-going public. therefore, by the start of the Great War and later, abdicated the field the intelligence profession, was Soviet Espionage Fiction of espionage fiction to (primarily) hugely successful upon its broadcast Before the Cold War the English, with Rudyard Kipling premiere, and its annual broadcast leading the charge. Along with him thereafter until the 1990s remained In the Soviet Union of the late came the respective anti-German jer- a major pop culture event for Soviet 1940s and 1950s, espionage, as a emiads dressed up as popular fiction viewers. genre of fiction, held little appeal for of novelists Erskine Childers and the Soviet reading and movie-going William le Queux, who established Seventeen Moments of Spring public. This was partly a result of the spy thriller as a permanent fixture may even have played a role in the Tsarist Russia’s cultural affiliations in the English literary landscape.6 rise of Vladimir Putin. In his first job with European high society. Russian But, neither Kim, that pivotal novel following his 1991 resignation from political, cultural, and literary life of Great Game espionage, nor the the KGB, Putin, then a St. Petersburg had closely followed that of France later writings of T.E. Lawrence (who, city official, had himself featured in since the 17th century; the connec- if not the first British “political” to a local documentary reenacting, as tion strengthened throughout the don native garb, was surely the first “Stierlitz,” an iconic scene from the 19th century and persisted until the to lend a largely fictional glamour to miniseries. The episode, which also establishment of the Soviet Union the intelligence business by posing marked Putin’s “coming out” as a cut off, officially at least, most such in full regalia for the home newspa- former spy, helped launch his politi- Western influences.5 The 19th-cen- pers as “Lawrence of Arabia”) had cal career, and the subsequent decade tury European literary disdain for counterparts in or made any lasting of adoring media comparisons to fictional “spies” had therefore persist- impression on Russia or the Soviet Stierlitz helped him all the way to the ed in Russian literature and popular Union of the period. 3 Russian presidency in 2000. Vladi- attitudes far longer than it did in the The Soviet Union’s own early mir Putin, thus, like Schwarzenegger, West.a And, at the turn of the 20th history created a second, more imme- rode the coattails of a fictional perso- century, the decade-long machina- diate and visceral, source of Russian na to political leadership. tions of the sorry Dreyfus affair, cultural antipathy toward espionage perpetrated by mendacious French Yet Stierlitz, “one of the central as a genre of entertainment. By the intelligence officers, gripped Russian characters in Soviet [and present-day start of the Cold War, “intelligence” readers and helped to solidify their Russian] grassroots mythology,” in the collective Russian memory image of “intelligence” as, by defini- remains almost entirely unknown meant spies, informers, and secret tion, wicked and, at best, a necessary outside the former Soviet Union.4 For murder, from the revolution through evil.b the intelligence historian, the back- years of purges culminating in the ground and production of Seventeen Great Terror of the mid-1930s. Moments of Spring provide worth- a. One of the few 19th-century novels while glimpses into Russian popular dealing directly with spies was American: The Soviet intelligence services attitudes, informed by their national James Fenimore Cooper’s 1821 tale of also emerged from the Great Patri- history and temperament, toward Revolutionary War espionage, The Spy. otic War with few, if any, sweeping, Cooper took pains to assure the reader that ready-for-fiction espionage or coun- intelligence work as a subject of even though the hero is spying, he is still a fiction. worthy person, as good as a soldier.—Brett F. Woods, “Revolution and Literature: Cooper’s The Spy Revisited,” varsityturos. eventual exoneration amid revelations of com (accessed 3 February 2017). the French military’s anti-Semitism and other perfidy, the “Dreyfus affair” was per- b. In 1894, French intelligence officers—as haps the first media-friendly global (or at was eventually proved—framed Jewish least Europe-wide) scandal and, incidental- army captain Alfred Dreyfus for treason. ly, helped to launch the espionage genre, at Throughout his trial, conviction, and least in Western Europe, as an established imprisonment on Devil’s Island until his category of popular fiction. 32 Studies in Intelligence Vol 61, No. 2 (Extracts, June 2017) Seventeen Moments of Spring A tipping point in overcoming Soviet popular disdain for terintelligence exploits. In contrast, fictional espionage was the 1961 elevation of Vladimir the wartime American and British Semichastny to the head of the KGB. intelligence and counterintelligence services had made critical, dramatic, Japanese fleet’s location and defeat it later Russian war films have ever had and well-publicized contributions at Midway. much use for happy endings. in breaking German and Japanese ciphers and otherwise helping to Yet another primary obstacle to What few spy-protagonists ap- militarily defeat the Axis powers on the emergence of fictional hero-spies peared on page or screen in postwar the ground and at sea. Soviet intelli- was the Russian obsession with de- settings had to be free from the taint gence could boast of no comparably fense. This long predated the USSR, of Stalin-era repression. One solu- dramatic contributions to their coun- but the Soviet Union could not be tion was to make the fictional spy a try’s grinding war of attrition against portrayed, even in fiction, as an NATO officer who sees the light and German invaders. Whether for lack aggressor; its mighty military and se- defects to the party, as in the popular of imagination or opportunity, the curity forces were wholly for the peo- 1968 spy film, Oshibka Rezidenta Soviet spymasters never executed ple’s protection. But espionage, by (The Resident’s Mistake). In the grad- operations with the inherent drama definition, is something that a state ually burgeoning field of Russian spy of such British operations as Double does primarily to other states, usually fiction of the mid- and late 1960s, the Cross or Mincemeat.a on their territory. Indeed, the very hero, if not a sympathetic Westerner, name of the Stalin-era counterintelli- was likely to be placed in the Great A noteworthy exception was the gence organization, Smert’ Shpionam Patriotic War—“the only time in So- Rote Kapelle (Red Orchestra) the (English acronym, SMERSH), meant viet history when the interests of the acclaimed, if ultimately smashed, So- “death to spies.” people coincided with the interests of viet HUMINT network in Europe in the state”—or else during the Bolshe- the early 1940s. The Red Orchestra, Given all the obstacles—histori- vik Revolution.10 however, was concerned mainly with cal disdain for spying, memories of incrementally damaging German the Terror, and a lack of inspiring A tipping point in overcoming military and industrial production.7 dramatics in actual Soviet espio- Soviet popular disdain for fictional No Soviet intelligence operation that nage history—Soviet “spy” fiction espionage was the 1961 elevation of we know of saved so many Allied in the early Cold War centered less Vladimir Semichastny to the head of lives or was so valuable to eventual on traditional clandestine espio- the KGB, a post he held until 1967.
Recommended publications
  • Ecrits De L'ombre Etudes & Essais Sur Le Roman Et Le Film D'espionnage
    Belphégor Norbert Spehner Ecrits de l'ombre Etudes & essais sur le roman et le film d'espionnage Cette bibliographie de base comprend trois grandes parties : la littérature, le cinéma & la télévision et le mythe James Bond. La littérature sur Ian Fleming et son personnage fétiche est tellement abondante qu'elle mérite une partie distincte. Sauf rares exceptions portant spécifiquement et uniquement sur le genre, cette compilation ne recense pas les thèses et mémoires, ni les monographies de cinéastes comme Hitchcock et cie qui ont tourné toutes sortes de films. Elle est aussi très sélective à propos des écrivains qui, comme Graham Greene ou Joseph Conrad, ont écrit d'autres types de romans. Sommaire : 1. LITTERATURE Etudes générales et ouvrages de référence Choix d'études sur quelques auteurs 2. CINEMA & TELEVISION Etudes sur le film d'espionnage Etudes sur les Séries télévisées 3. A PROPOS DE Ian Fleming ET DE James Bond Biographies de Jan Fleming Sur James Bond 1. LITTERATURE Etudes générales et ouvrages de référence ÄCHTLER, Norman (dir.), Ikonographie des Terrors ? Formen ästhetischer Erinnerung an den Terrorismus in der Bundesrepublik 1987-2008, Heidelberg, Winter Verlag, 2010, 427 pages. AMBROSETTI, Ronald J., A Study of the Spy Genre in Recent Popular Literature, thèse de doctorat, Bowling Green State University, août 1973, 147 pages. ATKINS, John, The British Spy Novel : Styles in Treachery, London, John Calder & New York, Riverrun Press, 1984, 287 pages. BANNER, Classified Maneuvers : Spies and Nationalism in Twentieth-Century Fiction, thèse de doctorat/PhD, University of California, Los Angeles, 2001, 260 pages. BAUBE, Bruno (dir.), "L'espionnage des années 30", dans Rocambole, no 33, hiver 2005, 176 pages.
    [Show full text]
  • Npr 3.2: Nuclear-Related Trade and Cooperation
    Nuclear Developments NUCLEAR-RELATED TRADE AND COOPERATION DEVELOPMENTS FOR SELECTED STATES, JULY-OCTOBER 1995 CONTENTS OVERVIEW, 97 France, Japan, United COMMONWEALTH OF FRANCE Kingdom, and U.S., 118 INDEPENDENT STATES with ALGERIA Russia, 119 with Belgium, Canada, Germany, with Iran, 108 Russia, and United King- PRC, 99 BRAZIL dom, 141 Internal Developments, 102 CUBA ARGENTINA Belgium, Finland, and with Internal Developments, 104 with Ukraine, 154 Argentina, 99 with Brazil, 99 Belgium, Japan, United Argentina, Cuba, and Argentina, Brazil, and Brazil, Cuba, and Mexico, 99 Kingdom, and U.S., 118 Mexico, 99 Mexico, 99 Israel and United States, 99 Cuba (Juragua Plant), 104 Germany, 103 Juragua Plant Participants South Korea, 99 Japan, 119 India, Indonesia, PRC and (Brazil, France, Germany, Syria, 99 Kazakhstan, 121 Russia, 103 Italy, Russia, and United United States, 100 PRC, 133 Russia, 103 Kingdom), 104 PRC and United Kingdom, 133 United States, 103 Mexico, 105 ARMENIA Russia, 142 with BULGARIA CZECH REPUBLIC South Korea and U.S., 151 ISTC, 100 with with Ukraine, 154 Russia and Ukraine, 141 Iran, 108 ASSOCIATION OF SOUTH GEORGIA EAST ASIAN NATIONS Russia and Slovakia, 142 CAMBODIA with (ASEAN) Ukraine, 154 with IAEA, 106 Internal Developments, 100 Thailand and Vietnam, 153 EGYPT ISTC, 100 BELARUS Internal Developments, 105 CANADA GERMANY with with ESTONIA with Estonia and Ukraine, 101 Belgium, France, Germany, with Belgium, Canada, France, Iran, 101 Russia, and U.K., 141 Belarus and Ukraine, 101 Russia, and U.K., 141 ISTC, 100 Japan,
    [Show full text]
  • Communication Arts 2019 Illustration Shortlist
    Communication Arts 110 Constitution Drive Communication Arts 2019 Menlo Park, CA 94025 (650) 326-6040 Illustration Shortlist (650) 326-1648 fax Media contact: These are the finalists in our 2019 Illustration competition. Rachel Whitaker, Competition Coordinator Winners will be notified by February 8, 2019. (650) 326-6040 or e-mail [email protected] Illustrator Company Category Title Sonia Alins Advertising Japanese swimmers A.Richard Allen Editorial Beast from the East Gary Alphonso Advertising Muskoka Cold Brew Florian Althans Brotlos Verlag Books Cello Ugur Altun Books Dancing with the Rain Ugur Altun Self-Promotion Feeling Weird Pablo Amargo Purple Rain Illustrators Editorial Crime Chris Anderson Giant Ant Motion/Animation Kindness Scott Anderson Editorial Pot in Paradise Scott Anderson Self-Promotion Sorolla Daniel Anguiano Unpublished Las Trenzas Mari Araki Self-Promotion Untitled Gabe Armagost Institutional Coffee Tree Tommy Arnold Books The Girl King Juliana Aschwanden-Vilaça Unpublished Freddie Mercury Elham Ataeiazar Self-Promotion Social Justice Kimberly Au Student Work Bedtime Story Dan Augustine For Sale Krampus Dan Augustine Advertising The Sofie Show Dan Augustine Unpublished Mandrill Alexandra S. Badiu Books Freaks Alexandra S. Badiu Student Work The Goat and Her Three Kids Scott Bakal Advertising World Press Freedom Day Poster Scott Bakal Unpublished Smiling Depression Scott Bakal For Sale Plenty! Boaz Balachsan DIGITALBOAZ Advertising Cyclecity Anna and Elena Balbusso ANNA+ELENA=BALBUSSO TWINS For Sale The wall,
    [Show full text]
  • CONSIGNES Semaine Du 23 Au 27 Mars Travail À Faire Sur La
    CONSIGNES Semaine du 23 au 27 mars Travail à faire sur la thématique des films Pour suivre le cours de cette semaine voici les étapes à suivre : 1- D’abord, vous lisez attentivement la trace écrite en page 2 puis vous la recopiez dans votre cahier. 2- Ensuite, vous compléter au crayon à papier la fiche en page 3. Pour faire cela, vous devez d’abord lire toutes les phrases à trou puis lire chaque proposition et ensuite essayez de compléter les trous. 3- Pour terminer, vous faites votre autocorrection grâce au corrigé qui se trouve en page 4 1 Monday, March 23rd Objectif : Parler des films Film vocabulary I know (vocabulaire de film que je connais) : - film (UK) / movie (USA) - actor = acteur / actress = actrice - a trailer = une bande annonce - a character = un personnage 1. Different types of films - Activity 2 a 1 page 66 (read, listen and translate the film types) An action film = un film d’action / a comedy = une comédie / a drama = un drame / an adventure film = un film d’aventure / an animation film = un film d’animation = un dessin animé / a fantasy film = un film fantastique / a musical = une comédie musicale/ a spy film = un film espionnage / a horror film = un film d’horreur / a science fiction film = un film de science fiction. - Activity 2 a 2 page 66 (listen to the film critic and classify the films) Johnny English Frankenweenie The Hobbit Les Misérables The Star Wars Reborn (French) series - A comedy, - An animation - A fantasy film - a musical - the series are film, science fiction - An action film - an adventure - a drama films and and - A comedy and film - adventure films - A spy film - A horror film 2.
    [Show full text]
  • Teen Programs Spy Film Fridays
    Teen Programs Summer Kickoff June 16 6-8:30 p.m. Kick back and watch a spy spoof with us, and hear our recommendations for some great summer reads. We’ll provide the snacks and sodas. Video Game Tournament June 17 1-3 p.m. (ending time approximate) After a huge turnout for our Spring Break Smash Bros tournament, we are going to break out the Wii again Gqdhx oad every month this summer! Please register by June 16, and plan to arrive 15 minutes early to get your assigned bracket. Video Game Tournament July 15 1-3 p.m. (ending time approximate) Register by July 14, and plan to arrive 15 minutes early to get your assigned bracket. Game Night July 22 6-9 p.m. Bring your Nerf weapons and get ready for another epic war! Murder in the Library will be played, and additional game requests are welcome. Pizza Fted: Qdhe! and soda provided. Anime Night July 26 7-8:30 p.m. Meet other anime and manga fans and watch new anime Use the two outer circles on the decoder wheel below to decipher the message; together. Program and title suggestions are welcome! We will have a guest tonight who is a answer is on back page. manga/anime lover who has lived in Japan. Teen Night August 12 6-10 p.m. Have fun honing your spy skills with other masters of espionage in a darkened library! Pizza and snacks will be provided. Dress in disguise to make the most of the evening! Pizza and snacks provided.
    [Show full text]
  • Mitchell James 01.16.17.Ptx
    Case 2:15-cv-00286-JLQ Document 176-1 Filed 05/22/17 Exhibit 1 Case 2:15-cv-00286-JLQ Document 176-1 Filed 05/22/17 Page 1 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF WASHINGTON AT SPOKANE - - - SULEIMAN ABDULLAH : SALIM, MOHOMED AHMED : DOCKET NO. BEN SOUD, OBAID ULLAH : (as personal : 2:15-CV-286-JLQ representative of GUL : RAHMAN), : : Plaintiffs, : : v. : : JAMES ELMER MITCHELL : and JOHN "BRUCE" : JESSEN, : : Defendants. : - - - Monday, January 16, 2017 - - - Videotaped deposition of JAMES E. MITCHELL taken pursuant to notice, was held at the law offices of Blank Rome, 130 N. 18th Street, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19103, beginning at 10:13 AM, on the above date, before Constance S. Kent, a Registered Professional Reporter and Notary Public in and for the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. * * * MAGNA LEGAL SERVICES (866) 624-6221 www.MagnaLS.com Case 2:15-cv-00286-JLQ Document 176-1 Filed 05/22/17 Page 6 Page 8 1 NO. DESCRIPTION PAGE 1 THE VIDEOGRAPHER: We are 2 Exhibit 20 Fax, Generic Description 321 of the Process, Bates 2 now on the record. 3 DOJ OLC 1126 through 3 This begins DVD No. 1 in the 1144 4 4 deposition of James Elmer Mitchell Exhibit 21 CIA Comments on the 323 5 in the matter of Salim versus 5 Senate Select Committee James Elmer Mitchell and Bruce -- on Intelligence Report 6 6 on the Rendition, 7 John Bruce Jessen in the United Detention and 8 States District Court for the 7 Interrogation Program 8 Exhibit 22 Document, Bates USA 1629 335 9 Eastern District of Washington.
    [Show full text]
  • True and False Confessions: the Efficacy of Torture and Brutal
    Chapter 7 True and False Confessions The Efficacy of Torture and Brutal Interrogations Central to the debate on the use of “enhanced” interrogation techniques is the question of whether those techniques are effective in gaining intelligence. If the techniques are the only way to get actionable intelligence that prevents terrorist attacks, their use presents a moral dilemma for some. On the other hand, if brutality does not produce useful intelligence — that is, it is not better at getting information than other methods — the debate is moot. This chapter focuses on the effectiveness of the CIA’s enhanced interrogation technique program. There are far fewer people who defend brutal interrogations by the military. Most of the military’s mistreatment of captives was not authorized in detail at high levels, and some was entirely unauthorized. Many military captives were either foot soldiers or were entirely innocent, and had no valuable intelligence to reveal. Many of the perpetrators of abuse in the military were young interrogators with limited training and experience, or were not interrogators at all. The officials who authorized the CIA’s interrogation program have consistently maintained that it produced useful intelligence, led to the capture of terrorist suspects, disrupted terrorist attacks, and saved American lives. Vice President Dick Cheney, in a 2009 speech, stated that the enhanced interrogation of captives “prevented the violent death of thousands, if not hundreds of thousands, of innocent people.” President George W. Bush similarly stated in his memoirs that “[t]he CIA interrogation program saved lives,” and “helped break up plots to attack military and diplomatic facilities abroad, Heathrow Airport and Canary Wharf in London, and multiple targets in the United States.” John Brennan, President Obama’s recent nominee for CIA director, said, of the CIA’s program in a televised interview in 2007, “[t]here [has] been a lot of information that has come out from these interrogation procedures.
    [Show full text]
  • Botsl#5 2013 Jun 10 12:30 PM Mike Sperlinger: Seventeen Types of Ambiguity
    BoTSL#5 2013 JUN 10 12:30 PM Mike Sperlinger: SEVENTEEN TYPES OF AMBIGUITY This bulletin would like to grow up to be a New Yorker article. It was researched in complete ignorance of the Russian language, and relied on the generosity of a number of people including Sergei Kostin, Alexander Ostrogorsky, Olga Semyonova, Sergei Stafeev, and, in particular, Sophio Medoidze. All photographs of Julian Semyonov are courtesy of his daughter, Olga Semyonova. With apologies to William Empson Cover image: poster design for Seventeen Moments of Spring by Alexander Zhuravskiy. Reproduced with kind permission BoTSL#5 2013 JUN 10 12:30 PM 2 Mike Sperlinger: SEVENTEEN TYPES OF AMBIGUITY The Gestapo intercepted an encrypted message which read: “Justas, you asshole. Alex.” Only Stirlitz could figure out that he had been conferred the rank of the Hero of the Soviet Union. On February 8, 2003, Vladimir Putin awarded the Order for Merit to the Fatherland, Class III, to the actor Vyacheslav Tikhonov. It was Tikhonov’s 75th birthday. Tikhonov had enjoyed a long career on stage and in film, but no one was under any illusions for what role he was receiving this honor — the same one, in fact, for which he had received a medal as a Hero of Socialist Labor from the Soviet premier Leonid Brezhnev in 1982, which was already nine years after the fact. Tikhonov was synonymous with the role of Max Otto von Stirlitz — a.k.a.“Justas,” a.k.a. Maxim Maximovich Isaev, secret agent of Moscow Center — in the television series Seventeen Moments of Spring.
    [Show full text]
  • ACLU-RDI 6808 P.1 Page 2 1 2 January 31, 2017 3 12:19 P.M
    Page 1 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF WASHINGTON Civil Action No. 2:15-CV-286-JLQ -----------------------------------) SULEIMAN ABDULLAH SALIM, MOHAMED AHMED BEN SOUD, OBAID ULLAH (AS PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVE OF GUL RAHMAN), Plaintiffs, vs. JAMES ELMER MITCHELL and JOHN "BRUCE" JESSEN, Defendants. -----------------------------------) DEPOSITION OF OBAIDULLAH New York, New York January 31, 2017 Reported by: Linda Salzman, RPR Job No. 17896 TransPerfect Legal Solutions 212-400-8845 - [email protected] ACLU-RDI 6808 p.1 Page 2 1 2 January 31, 2017 3 12:19 p.m. 4 5 Deposition of OBAIDULLAH, the 6 witness herein, held at the offices 7 of American Civil Liberties Union, 8 125 Broad Street, New York, New 9 York, pursuant to Notice, before 10 Linda Salzman, a Notary Public of 11 the State of New York. 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 TransPerfect Legal Solutions 212-400-8845 - [email protected] ACLU-RDI 6808 p.2 Page 3 1 2 A P P E A R A N C E S: 3 4 On Behalf of Plaintiffs: 5 Gibbons, PC 6 One Gateway Center 7 Newark, New Jersey 07102-5310 8 (973) 596-4731 9 BY: LAWRENCE S. LUSTBERG, ESQ. [email protected] 10 KATE JANUKOWICZ, ESQ. 11 [email protected] 12 DANIEL MCGRADY, ESQ. [email protected] 13 - and - 14 15 AMERICAN CIVIL LIBERTIES UNION 16 125 Broad Street 17 18th Floor 18 New York, New York 10004-2400 19 BY: DROR LADIN, ESQ. [email protected] 20 21 22 23 24 (Continued) 25 TransPerfect Legal Solutions 212-400-8845 - [email protected] ACLU-RDI 6808 p.3 Page 4 1 2 A P P E A R A N C E S: (Continued) 3 4 On Behalf of Defendants: 5 BLANK ROME LLP 6 One Logan Square 7 130 North 18th Street 8 Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19103-6998 9 (215) 569-5791 10 BY: BRIAN S.
    [Show full text]
  • “THE REPORT” Viewer Information and Discussion Guide
    “THE REPORT” Viewer Information and Discussion Guide PAGE 1 ​ TABLE OF CONTENTS BACKGROUND --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- page 2 ​ ​ CHARACTER DETAILS Daniel J. Jones --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- page 3 Dianne Feinstein ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ page 4 Denis McDonough ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- page 5 John Owen Brennan ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- page 6 James Elmer Mitchell ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- page 7 Martin Heinrich --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- page 7 George Tenet ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- page 8 Sheldon Whitehouse ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- page 9 John A. Rizzo ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    [Show full text]
  • The Constitutional and Political Clash Over Detainees and the Closure of Guantanamo
    UNIVERSITY OF PITTSBURGH LAW REVIEW Vol. 74 ● Winter 2012 PRISONERS OF CONGRESS: THE CONSTITUTIONAL AND POLITICAL CLASH OVER DETAINEES AND THE CLOSURE OF GUANTANAMO David J.R. Frakt ISSN 0041-9915 (print) 1942-8405 (online) ● DOI 10.5195/lawreview.2012.195 http://lawreview.law.pitt.edu This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 United States License. This site is published by the University Library System of the University of Pittsburgh as part of its D- Scribe Digital Publishing Program and is cosponsored by the University of Pittsburgh Press. PRISONERS OF CONGRESS: THE CONSTITUTIONAL AND POLITICAL CLASH OVER DETAINEES AND THE CLOSURE OF GUANTANAMO David J.R. Frakt Table of Contents Prologue ............................................................................................................... 181 I. Introduction ................................................................................................. 183 A. A Brief Constitutional History of Guantanamo ................................... 183 1. The Bush Years (January 2002 to January 2009) ....................... 183 2. The Obama Years (January 2009 to the Present) ........................ 192 a. 2009 ................................................................................... 192 b. 2010 to the Present ............................................................. 199 II. Legislative Restrictions and Their Impact ................................................... 205 A. Restrictions on Transfer and/or Release
    [Show full text]
  • Festa Del Cinema Di Roma FESTA DEL CINEMA DI ROMA 13/23 OTTOBRE 2016
    11A Festa del Cinema di Roma FESTA DEL CINEMA DI ROMA 13/23 OTTOBRE 2016 FONDATORI PRESIDENTE Roma Capitale Piera Detassis Regione Lazio Città Metropolitana di Roma Capitale Camera di Commercio di Roma DIRETTORE GENERALE Fondazione Musica per Roma Francesca Via Istituto Luce Cinecittà S.r.l DIRETTORE ARTISTICO COLLEGIO DEI FONDATORI Antonio Monda Presidente Lorenzo Tagliavanti Presidente della Camera di Commercio di Roma COMITATO DI SELEZIONE Virginia Raggi Mario Sesti, Coordinatore Sindaca di Roma Capitale Valerio Carocci e della Città Metropolitana Alberto Crespi Giovanna Fulvi Nicola Zingaretti Richard Peña Presidente della Regione Lazio Francesco Zippel Aurelio Regina Presidente della Fondazione Musica per Roma Roberto Cicutto Presidente dell’Istituto Luce Cinecittà CONSIGLIO DI AMMINISTRAZIONE RESPONSABILE UFFICIO CINEMA Piera Detassis, Presidente Alessandra Fontemaggi Laura Delli Colli Lorenzo Tagliavanti José Ramón Dosal Noriega Roberto Cicutto COLLEGIO DEI REVISORI DEI CONTI Roberto Mengoni, Presidente Massimo Gentile, Revisore Effettivo Giovanni Sapia, Revisore Effettivo Maurizio Branco, Revisore Supplente Marco Buttarelli, Revisore Supplente A FESTA 13-23 DEL CINEMA OTTOBRE 11 DI ROMA 2016 Prodotto da Main Partner Promosso da Partner Istituzionali Con il supporto di In collaborazione con Official sponsor Partner Tecnico Eco Mobility Partner Sponsor di Servizi Media Partner Partner Culturali Sponsor2.1 Invicta institutional logo “Since” 2.1.1 Dimensions, proportions and colour references The Invicta corporate logo is made up of 2 colours, blue and red. The Invicta corporate logo must never be modified or reconstructed. FOOD PROMOTION & EVENTS MANAGEMENT 26x 8x 87x 1x 15x 31x 2x 3x 5x 3x 1x Pantone 33xCMYK Pantone RGB 2x Textile 20x Invicta red C: 0 4852x C P.
    [Show full text]