Method for the Development of Gene Panels For
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
(19) & (11) EP 1 364 069 B1 (12) EUROPEAN PATENT SPECIFICATION (45) Date of publication and mention (51) Int Cl.: of the grant of the patent: C12Q 1/68 (2006.01) 22.04.2009 Bulletin 2009/17 (86) International application number: (21) Application number: 02724190.0 PCT/EP2002/002255 (22) Date of filing: 01.03.2002 (87) International publication number: WO 2002/070742 (12.09.2002 Gazette 2002/37) (54) METHOD FOR THE DEVELOPMENT OF GENE PANELS FOR DIAGNOSTIC AND THERAPEUTIC PURPOSES BASED ON THE EXPRESSION AND METHYLATOIN STATUS OF THE GENES VERFAHREN ZUR ENTWICKLUNG VON GENSÄTZEN ZU DIAGNOSTISCHEN UND THERAPEUTISCHEN ZWECKEN AUF GRUNDLAGE DES EXPRESSIONS- UND METHYLIERUNGSSTATUS DER GENE PROCEDE DE MISE AU POINT DE GROUPES D’ECHANTILLONS DE GENES A DES FINS DE DIAGNOSTIC ET DE THERAPIE QUI SONT BASES SUR L’EXPRESSION ET L’ETAT DE METHYLATION DES GENES (84) Designated Contracting States: (56) References cited: AT BE CH CY DE DK ES FI FR GB GR IE IT LI LU WO-A-00/39347 WO-A-00/44934 MC NL PT SE TR WO-A-00/70090 WO-A-01/18241 (30) Priority: 01.03.2001 US 272549 P • HERMAN J G ET AL: "INCIDENCE AND FUNCTIONAL CONSEQUENCES OF HMLH1 (43) Date of publication of application: PROMOTOR HYPERMETHYLATION IN 26.11.2003 Bulletin 2003/48 COLORECTAL CARCINOMA" PROCEEDINGS OF THE NATIONAL ACADEMY OF SCIENCES OF (73) Proprietor: Epigenomics AG USA, NATIONAL ACADEMY OF SCIENCE. 10178 Berlin (DE) WASHINGTON, US, vol. 95, June 1998 (1998-06), pages 6870-6875, XP002944676 ISSN: 0027-8424 (72) Inventors: • GUO YONGJING ET AL: "DNA methylation status • OLEK, Alexander of uPA promoter directly affects the expression 10115 Berlin (DE) of uPA in human breast cancer cells to alter their • BERLIN, Kurt invasive potential" PROCEEDINGS OF THE 14532 Stahndorf (DE) ANNUAL MEETING OF THE AMERICAN ASSOCIATION FOR CANCER RESEARCH, NEW (74) Representative: Krauss, Jan et al YORK, NY, US, vol. 42, March 2001 (2001-03), Forrester & Boehmert pages 625-626, XP002195787 ISSN: 0197-016X Pettenkoferstrasse 20-22 • WU HUA-KANG ET AL: "Transcriptional 80336 München (DE) activation of human LIM-HOX gene hLH-2 in chronic myelogenous leukemia is due to a cis- acting effect of Bcr-Abl." BIOCHEMICAL AND BIOPHYSICAL RESEARCH COMMUNICATIONS, vol. 234, no. 3, 1997, pages 742-747, XP002203941 ISSN: 0006-291X Note: Within nine months of the publication of the mention of the grant of the European patent in the European Patent Bulletin, any person may give notice to the European Patent Office of opposition to that patent, in accordance with the Implementing Regulations. Notice of opposition shall not be deemed to have been filed until the opposition fee has been paid. (Art. 99(1) European Patent Convention). EP 1 364 069 B1 Printed by Jouve, 75001 PARIS (FR) 1 EP 1 364 069 B1 2 Description protein micro-characterization for large-scale identifica- tion of proteins and their post-translational modifications; FIELD OF THE INVENTION (2) ’differential display’ proteomics for comparison of pro- tein levels with potential application in a wide range of [0001] The present invention concerns a method for 5 diseases; and (3) studies of protein-protein interactions the development of gene panels for diagnostic and ther- using techniques such as mass spectrometry or the yeast apeutic purposes. The invention further concerns gene two-hybrid system. Because it is often difficult to predict panels developed using the method of the present inven- the function of a protein based on homology to other pro- tion and their uses. teins or even their three-dimensional structure, determi- 10 nation of the components of a protein complex or of a BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION cellular structure is central in functional analysis (Pandey A et al. "Proteomics to study genes and genomes." Na- [0002] The levels of observation that have been well ture 2000 Jun 15;405(6788):837-46). studied by the methodological developments of recent [0006] Due to the complexity of higher eukaryotic cells, years in molecular biology include the gene itself, the 15 single-step characterization of a proteome is likely to be translation of genes in RNA, and the resulting proteins. difficult to achieve. Jung et al. ("Proteomics meets cell When, during the course of the development of an indi- biology: the establishment of subcellular proteomes" vidual, a gene is switched on, and how the activation and Electrophoresis 2000 Oct;21(16):3369-77) describe, that inhibition of certain genes in certain cells and tissues is advantage can be taken of the macromolecular architec- controlled, can be correlated with a high degree of prob- 20 ture of a cell, e.g., subcellular compartments, organelles, ability with the extent and the character of the methylation macromolecular structures and multiprotein complexes, of the gene or the genome. In this regard, it is reasonable to establish subcellular proteomes. to assume that pathogenic conditions are expressed in [0007] Despite the recent developments in the art, the a modified methylation pattern of individual genes or of detection of proteins that are of regulatory importance, the genome. 25 from small quantities of cells still fails because of the fact that the sensitivity of the methods used is much too low. STATE OF THE ART Indeed, in contrast to nucleic acids, proteins cannot be amplified. In addition, the method is very complex, not 1. State of the art of molecular analysis of cell phe- amenable to automation, and very expensive. In contrast, notypes 30 RNA analysis presents considerable advantages, and due to of the use of PCR it is more sensitive. Above all, [0003] The study of gene expression can be at the RNA each RNA species recognized to be important can be level or at the protein level. Both levels in principle reflect identified immediately by its sequence. important phenotypic parameters. Protein assays using [0008] Overexpression or underexpression of individ- two-dimensional gels (McFarrel method) have been 35 ual RNAs with a known sequence can usually be easily known for approximately 15 years. Using these assays, detected; however, in connection with the applications it is possible to elaborate the analysis of the chromato- discussed here, they are only valid in exceptional cases. graphic positions of several thousand proteins. Very early [0009] The method of "differential displays" at best al- on, such electropherograms were already processed or lows a semiquantitative study of expression. Expression evaluated with data processing means. In principle, the 40 products amplified by PCR are separated by gel electro- validity of the method is high, however, it is inferior to the phoresis. The validity is limited as a result of the resolu- modem methods of gene expression based on RNA anal- tion of the gel electrophoresis. In addition, the method is ysis in two regards. insufficiently sensitive and robust for use in routine diag- [0004] The global analysis of cellular proteins has re- nosis (Liang, P. and Pardee, A. B., Science 257, cently been termed proteomics and is a key area of re- 45 967-971). search that is developing in the post-genome era. Pro- [0010] Genes with high overexpression or underex- teomics uses a combination of sophisticated techniques pression are frequently identified by subtractive tech- including two-dimensional (2D) gel electrophoresis, im- niques. Here, cDNA clones of a cell or tissue species to age analysis, mass spectrometry, amino acid sequenc- be examined are plated. Against the clones, cDNA is ing, and bio-informatics to resolve comprehensively, to 50 hybridized as comparison material. Expression patterns quantify, and to characterize proteins (for reviews, see cannot be reliably prepared using this technique. Chambers G et al. "Proteomics: a new approach to the [0011] Sturtevant et al. ("Applications of differential- study of disease" J Pathol 2000 Nov;192(3):280-8; Banks display reverse transcription-PCR to molecular patho- RE et al. "Proteomics: new perspectives, new biomedical genesis and medical mycology. Clin Microbiol Rev 2000 opportunities" Lancet 2000 Nov 18;356(9243):1749-56). 55 Jul;13(3):408-27) describe the characterisation of host- [0005] Proteomics is further said to contribute greatly fungus interactions by changes in gene expression in to the understanding of gene function in the post-genomic both host and pathogen. Differential-display reverse tran- era. Proteomics can be divided into three main areas: (1) scription PCR (DDRT-PCR) is a PCR-based method that 2 3 EP 1 364 069 B1 4 allows extensive analysis of gene expression among sev- impossible to examine the gene expression or the me- eral cell populations. DDRT-PCR has been used to ad- tabolism of a cell in its totality. Chip technology for the dress biological questions in mammalian systems, in- first time provided such a possibility (Schena, M. et al., cluding cell differentiation, cell activation, cell stress, and Science 270, 467-470). identification of drug targets. In microbial pathogenesis 5 [0014] If one wishes to solve the diagnostic problem and plant pathogenesis, DDRT-PCR has allowed the of early diagnosis of tumors on the molecular level, then identification of virulence factors, genes involved in cell one is confronted, today, with an insurmountable difficul- death, and signaling genes. Further, To ("Identification ty. With very few exceptions, for most tumors, the knowl- of differential gene expression by high throughput edge of the molecular events, that is, the different muta- analysis" Comb Chem High Throughput Screen 2000 10 tions, is only fragmentary. Researchers do not know what Jun;3(3):235-41) describes the high throughput analysis to look for in medical examination material. This means of differential gene expression as a powerful tool that can it is absolutely impossible to apply the remarkable sen- be applied to many areas in molecular cell biology, in- sitivity and specificity of the polymerase chain reaction.