77040NCJRS.Pdf
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
<. ,~~ ~ - .', "~ .:. t) • • " \ •• ' 'a If you have issues viewing or accessing this file contact us at NCJRS.gov. " , :.,." i ".'.~.::<.' ~.. _."- . ~ ~;;'~"'./ .' \1 " National Crimina.~ Justice Reterence Service -, IJ ~ 0,,,._.. -=,. __ ----, ------ o o il " This microfich~. was produced frQm gocuments received for 0 inclusion in the NCJRS data base. Since NCJRS cannot exercise control over th~ physical condition of the'tlocuments submittedl ! .'" the individual frame quality will vary. The resolution chart on ' this frame may be used to evaluate the document quality. o () -= 1.0 >';, :; kl .. 1 11111 .25 II~II ,4 !1~1'·6 0" j' MICROCOPY RESOLUTIO~, TEST CHART NATIONAL BURF.AU OF STANOARDS-1963-A " -,.. -.. : 13'-1 f ,. v _ > _~~:;=:;w~"!~ c Microfilming procedures usea to create",this fiche comply with the standards set forth in 41CFR lOl-i1.S04. Points of view or opinions stated in this document are Ii -~r~~ ,; those of the author(s) and do not represent the official ~ . I : ' position or policies of the U. S. Department of Justice. ~ lj~ \ ,lDATE F1LMtO'; \ -/:--'"'-Y .,~;:5?f J '). ~\ - . 'j' '\ l_ J., ~~~;~~~i~:~~p':~~~~~;;~::",,1,-'·----.- ......... -...----tl~ .1>7':'/O:"g//1 " 1 Washington D. C. 20531 ,- , 1 ,-"". .- .. ~--.... -~ .... I D r \ UNITED r NATIONS Sixth United Nations Congress on the Distr. ~ l' PreventiQn :of Crirne and the Treatment o '-' GENERAL of Offenders .A/CONF.87/8 23 June 1980 Caracas, Venezuela, 25 August to 5 September 1980 ORIGINAL: ENGLISH Item 7 of the provisional agenda - ( ~I NATIONS NORMS AND GUIDE-LINES IN CRIMINAL JUSTICE: FROM ST~~{DARD~SETTING TO IMPLEMENTATION 0 ']- Working paper, prepared by the Secretariat C' 0 0 [' r ~ ~:: ~ U.S. Department of Justice Nationallnsmute of Justice Q This document has been reproduced exactly as received from the person or organization originating it. Points of view or opinions stated in this document are those of the authors and do not necessarily represent the official positiCjn or pOlicies ot'the National Institute of Justice. Permission to reproduce this esP'P'l8"'fetj material has been granted by I .' Public Domain o , ./ United Natinns o (,// II to the National Criminal Justice Reference Service (NCJRS). II Further reproduction outside of the NCJRS system requires permis- sion of the ~t owner. .. o 80-15447 r.,) / .. !! / \ - .. ---.- ---::;;--- I.' I .j 10 • c. , ,. o ') CJ t.i It I· blCJ.,RS " o i,}! . -2- ! -3... jI o (I fJ -,j 'J ..MAY 7 198\ CONTENTS CONTENTS (continued)' , o " • Q '\ ; III. GUIDE-LINES TO PROVIDE MINIHUJI·1 RULES FOR THE TREATNENT OF OFFENl)ERS TN THE COMMUNITY 0 '0 ~ • 47 - 49 19 Introduction 4 o J . c IV. GUIDE-LINES TO STRENGTijEN I]ffi§ATE GRIEVANCE a Part One. II Existing a.nd emerging Urd'.ted Nations PROCEDURES . • . • . • • . • . • . 50 ~ 51 20 norms and guil(ie-lines il~~ criminal " justice r:::· . v. GUIDE-LINES TO FACILITATE THE RETURN OF PERSONS CONVICTED OF CR)]m ABROAD TO THEIR DOMICILE TO I. EXISTING NORMS AND GUIDE-LINES ...•••.•• 5 - :1,3 6 SERVE THEIR SENTENCE • . • .• • • • • 52 _. 73 21 A. hniversal Declaration of Human Rights and the A. International initiatives 52 - 57 21 .. International Covenant on Civil and Political B, Regional co-operation and bilateral . Rights and its Optional Protocol. • • . •. 5 - 6 arrangements .• . • • . • . • . 68 22 Declaration on the Protecit;ion of All Persons r.;'" from being Subjected to Torture and Other Cruel, C. Model for United N~t~ns guide-lines 73 24 Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment 7 6 IV. CONCLUSIONS AND GENERAL RECO}®~NDATIONS . 74 26 q. Code of Conduct for Law Enforcement Officials 8 - 9 7 o ./f Part Three. Gener~1 principles for the more D. Standard MinimutnRules for the Treatment;;;of ,/I: . \\ effective implementation of United /! P rlsoners . 0 • • • Ii 0 • • .. • • '10 - 13 7 Nations norms and guide-lines in II. EMERGING NORMS AND GUIDE/-LINES l4 - 25 9 criminal justice A. Draft Convention against Torture and Other I. IMPLEMENTATION AT THE ~ATIONAL LEVEL 75 :'c",76 27 Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or o \\ \\ ~ PunishJ.!lent .•. ..' . • • 14 - 15 II. IMPLEr~NTATION AT THE EEGIONAL LEVEL ,,77 - 88 n 28 if 9 B. Draft code of medical ethics 16 18 9 A. Implementation by vyay of co-operatiqn between C. Dr~ft b8~ of principles for the protection of Governme~ts, the U~ited Nations and its affiliated all persons under any form of detention or regional institute~ in crime prevention and criminal ju~tice ; 0 0 • • • • • 0 • • • • 0 77 - 80 28 imprisonment •. • .ee • 19 21 10 D. Draft principles on eCJ.uality in the B. Implementation by Va;y of co-operation between administration of justice • • . • • • .-". • . 22 23 11 Gov~rnments ~ the United Nations regional intergovernmental organizations" and other .E. Draft gui~e-lines for expeditious and eCJ.uitable regional bodies interested in crime prevention ?' ••• handling of cr~minal cases 24 25 11 and ,criminal justice . • 0 • 0 • • • 81 - 8829 . ,,~ III. .. O'rHER INSTRUMENTS RELATINGcTO "CRIMINAL JUSTICE - ... 26 27 13 III. IMPLEMENTATION ..(1.'1' THEe ~'1'J!;i':EpJ)TATlmTAL LEVEL 89 - 9.5 32 ,. IV. CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS .."""- .•. : 28 33 i4 A. Some exi~ting impl~mentation procedures . /89 - 92 32 / Part, Two. Reconnr.ended new United Nations Bo Proposal~ for t~~ ~trengthen~ng of the A guide':"'li~es in criminal Justice impl~mentation o£:,~ i}~e Standard Minimum Rules for the "Treatment of' {Pr~soners 00 0" • • 0 • • 0 0 ~ . 93 - 95 33 I. PRIORITIES. • • • • • • Q • • 0 • • • • • • • • 34- 37 15 :! IV. CQNCLUS+ONS ANP RECO~~NDATIONS • 0 • 0 ••• 0 ••• 0 96 - 110 34 f II. GUIDE-LINES FOR THE IMPROVED SELECTION AND TRAINING OF JUDGES AND PROSECUTORS . • . • • • . • . • . " 38 - 46 (.' 17 o / • 0 0 / ... o - ..... _.... _ .....- ..... - .... -.-.--.. ~-----.--.- ... -----... .~--:==-~~...---.. " ..,...--,-----r--""!.,...,.,....-_-------r"'c ~--.---__:=I- .... .----.-_.~ __"_. -----,.-~-~_;,t'"~---,---~- ~-=~....;;::::.::::..~•. ::::::::::;::;;.:::~::::t '" \, o o -4- -5- n~[,RODUCTIOllT the selection and training of judges; (b) to provide m~n~mum rules for the treatment ot: offenders in the community; (c) to strengthen inmate grievance '. "~. ,~ .- procedures;, and (d) to facilitate the return of persons convicted of crime abroad 1. The ai;;ta~nment of a just. world((''Order is. possible conly when the ci~\i.zens of all to their domicile to serve their sentences. countries are :'assured of a jnst juridical order within the context of a just social order. An equitable soci~+ order depends as much on freedom from 4~ Part three is concerned with general principles for the more effectivei) victimization by crime as an equitable juridical order depends on freedom from implementation of United Nations norms and guide-lines in cri~inal justice at the arbitrary 9 oppressive or racist crime prevention efforts. Since ~,ts foundation, na:J;ion~,l, regional and"international levels. In.accordance w~th the . the United Nations has been dedicated to these principles. The inclusion of a recommendations of the regional preparatory meet~ngs, 7/ the Congress may w1sh topic entiti~d: I1United Nations norms and guld~linesii in the agenda of the Sixth to place emphasis on the form.ulation of general principles for more effective e, United Nations Congress on the Prevention of Crime and the Treatment of Offenders implementation at the national level. As regards the regional and the. ~~was ~ therefore 9 strongly supported by the Committee on Crime Prevention and international levels, emphasis has been placed on the need for develop~ng general Control. The Committee vieW'ed,(this topic as offering the opportunity of continuing princip1es for mor~ effective implementation which would centre on regional the long history of the devel'bpment of human rights instruments by the United and international do-operation. Nations 9 with a view toward the eventual creation of a coherent net1-Tork of human rights standards in the administration of criminal justice. 1/ The regional preparatory meetings for the Congress also placed the strongest emphasis on the topic. 2/ 2. To facilitate the consideration of the topic ~ the 1-lorking paper has been divided into three parts. Part one of the paper deals with a survey of existing and emerging~lnited Nations norms~d guide-lines in criminal justice as background material for the discussion of the following items, namely, recommended ne'VT norms and guide-lines and general principles for moi~'ef'i'eotj,ve implementation. The information given in this part smmnarizes the main features of the principal i; instruments and draft tests pertinent to criminal justice and most frequently a , C} referred to in the preparator.y meetings of the Congress. 3/ '\ t .,,", 0 o .0 3. Part two deals with recommended ne.. T United Nations guide-lines in criminal I justice. It outlines areas of priority in which the Congress may wish to p~ovide policy guidance, as recommended by the Committee on Crime Prevention and Control 4/ and endorsed by the Economic and Social Copncil 21 and the regional preparatory - meetings for the Congress. 6/ Four areas of.c0priority for guide-lines have been suggested on which the Congress may wish to focus its attention: (a) to irr~rove o 1/ "Report of the Committee on Crime Prevention and Control on its fourth sessionn ,,(E/CN. 5/536), para. 62. 2/ See A/CONF.87/BP/1-4. 3/ See also working paper for the S'ixth Congress on relevant developments in human rights bodies, prepared by the United Nations Secretariat; Human Rights, A Compilation of International Instrum~nts (United Nations Publication" Sales No. E.78.XIV.2) 1978; The United Nations and Human Rights (United Nations Publication 9 Sales No. E,,78.I.18), 1978. 4/ See E/CN.5/536, chap. I, sect. B. ~ >:::: 5/ Economic and Social Council resolution 2075 (LXII), para. 2. () u 6/ See A/CO~TF.87/BP/1-4. 7/ Ibid. l: / ..