Periodic Report - Second Cycle Section II-Frontiers of the

1. World Heritage Property Data 's in wall 54.986 / - 0.16 ? 0.16 mile 0, section 1.541 between Eastfield 1.1 - Name of World Heritage Property Avenue and Tumulus Avenue Frontières de l’Empire romain Hadrian's Wall in wall 54.985 / - 0.144 ? 0.144 mile 1, three sections 1.546 1.2 - World Heritage Property Details between Stotts Road and Vauxhall Road State(s) Party(ies) Hadrian's Wall in wall 54.976 / - 0.102 ? 0.102  Allemagne mile 2, Byker section 1.589 of Hadrian's Wall and  Royaume-Uni de Grande Bretagne et d'Irlande du presumed site of Nord 3 at Shields Road West Type of Property Hadrian's Wall in wall 54.981 / - 0.037 ? 0.037 culturel mile 2, Walker section 1.563 of Hadrian's Wall Identification Number under the forecourt of 430ter the Fosse public house Year of inscription on the World Heritage List Hadrian's Wall in wall 54.984 / -1.55 0.238 ? 0.238 1987, 2005,2008 mile 2, Walker section of Hadrian's Wall 171m long across 1.3 - Geographic Information Table Millers Dene playing Name Coordinates Property Buffer Total Inscription field (longitude / (ha) zone (ha) year Hadrian's Wall in wall 54.978 / - 0.084 ? 0.084 latitude) (ha) mile 2, Walker section 1.573 0 / 0 ? ? ? of Hadrian's Wall near the junction of 0 / 0 ? ? ? Fossway and Shields Road Hadrian's Wall in wall 54.977 / - 0.302 ? 0.302 mile 5, sections of 1.661 Hadrian's Wall in wall 54.972 / - 0.115 ? 0.115 wall in playing field of mile 4, sections of 1.602 Rutherford School wall between Crawhall Road and Hadrian's Wall 54.979 / - 0.35 ? 0.35 Jubilee Road in wall mile 6, 1.675 length of vallum of Roman aqueduct to 55.001 / - 12.353 ? 12.353 Hadrian's Wall in Great Chesters from 2.452 grounds of St the Cawburn Cuthbert's School Hadrian's Wall and 54.991 / - 7.22 ? 7.22 Hadrian's Wall in wall 54.977 / - 0.486 ? 0.486 vallum in wall mile 8 1.721 mile 6, 1.667 from Denton to Roman fort, Benwell Blucher Hadrian's Wall in wall 54.98 / -1.681 0.341 ? 0.341 Hadrian's Wall and 54.994 / - 4.751 ? 4.751 mile 7, Benwell length vallum in wall mile 9, 1.741 of vallum of Hadrian's Blucher to Dene Wall in the grounds of House Benwell Hill Cricket Hadrian's Wall and 54.996 / - 3.016 ? 3.016 Club vallum in wall mile 10 1.762 Hadrian's Wall in wall 54.981 / -1.68 0.156 ? 0.156 from Dene House to mile 7, Scotswood Throckley Bank Top section of Hadrian's Roman fort, South 55.004 / - 3.537 ? 3.537 Wall in the grounds of Shields 1.431 Benwell Hill Cricket Club Hadrian's Wall in wall 54.988 / - 1.571 ? 1.571 mile 0, 1.533 Hadrian's Wall and 54.983 / - 0.039 ? 0.039 Roman fort, vallum in wall mile 7, 1.686 Scotswood section from Denton Road to Hadrian's Wall in wall 54.987 / - 0.215 ? 0.215 Denton Dene mile 0, two sections 1.537 of Hadrian's Wall Hadrian's Wall and 54.985 / - 0.131 ? 0.131 between Sharpe vallum in wall mile 7, 1.696 Road and The Denton section of Avenue Hadrian's Wall, Denton and Red House Roman 55.004 / - 1.83 ? 1.83 Hadrian's Wall at camp 2.191 West Denton Roman camp, 290m 55.004 / - 1.776 ? 1.776 Hadrian's Wall and 54.982 / - 0.172 ? 0.172 north west of Seldom 2.284 vallum in wall mile 7, 1.688 Seen Scotswood section of 54.98 / -2.036 81.212 ? 81.212 vallum 75m long at (Corstopitum) Roman Denton Dene station Hadrian's Wall in wall 54.982 / - 0.012 ? 0.012 Roman fort and watch 54.914 / - 7.985 ? 7.985 mile 7, Scotswood 1.684 , 800m SSW of 3.055 section of Hadrian's Amberfield Wall in garden of West Road Methodist Cardurnock milefortlet 54.913 / - 0.733 ? 0.733 Chapel (Mf 5) 3.295

Page 1 Monday, May 19, 2014 (12:41:04 PM CEST) Periodic Report - Section II-Frontiers of the Roman Empire World Heritage Centre Periodic Report - Second Cycle Section II-Frontiers of the Roman Empire

The Stangate at 54.929 / - 0.393 ? 0.393 Haltonchesters 55.01 / -2.007 12.589 ? 12.589 Crosby Lodge 2.854 Roman fort, settlement & Burrow Roman 54.656 / - 1.85 ? 1.85 Hadrian's Wall & fort 3.547 vallum between the Beckfoot Roman fort 54.826 / - 1.5 ? 1.5 field boundary east of 3.418 Haltonchesters fort & Roman fortlet 40m 54.824 / - 0.624 ? 0.624 the Fence Burn in SSW of Fields 3.422 wall mile 2 Parton Roman fort 54.572 / - 9.355 ? 9.355 Hadrian's Wall and 55.011 / - 19.035 ? 19.035 3.576 vallum between the 2.021 Fence Burn and the Cardurnock Marsh 54.923 / - 0.035 ? 0.035 track to turret 4a 3.292 Cottage in wall miles Pasture House turret 54.931 / - 0.064 ? 0.064 21 and 22 3a 3.279 Hadrian's Wall and 55.016 / - 24.867 ? 24.867 Hadrian's Wall and 54.9 / -2.952 2.872 ? 2.872 vallum between the 2.048 vallum in wall mile 66, track to Portgate Stanwix Bank to Cottage and the field Stainton boundary east of milecastle 24 in wall Ravenglass Roman 54.351 / - 0.088 ? 0.088 miles 22 and 23 fort bath-house, also 3.404 known as Walls Burn 4 54.992 / - 0.206 ? 0.206 Castle Roman temporary 2.449 camp Willowford Roman 54.988 / - 1.295 ? 1.295 temporary camp 2.587 Milestone House 54.989 / - 21.286 ? 21.286 Roman temporary 2.437 Watchclose Roman 54.934 / -2.82 1.245 ? 1.245 camp and section of temporary camp the Roman Throp Roman fortlet 54.987 / - 0.695 ? 0.695 road 2.578 Markham Cottage 54.988 / - 23.973 ? 23.973 Nowtler Hill 1 Roman 54.904 / - 1.033 ? 1.033 Roman temporary 2.459 temporary camp 2.995 camps 1 and 2, a section of the Nowtler Hill 2 Roman 54.902 / -3 0.953 ? 0.953 Stanegate Roman temporary camp road, a length of Boomby Lane 1 and 2 54.907 / - 4.242 ? 4.242 Roman road and two Roman temporary 2.986 Roman cemeteries camps Lees Hall Roman 54.985 / - 3.133 ? 3.133 Hadrian's Wall and 54.996 / - 13.143 ? 13.143 camp 2.463 vallum from Throckley 1.778 Walwick Fell Roman 55.032 / - 1.34 ? 1.34 to East Town House, temporary camp 2.179 Heddon-on-the-Wall in wall mile 11 Brown Dikes Roman 55.027 / - 1.254 ? 1.254 temporary camp 2.252 Hadrian's Wall and 54.998 / -1.8 9.864 ? 9.864 vallum from East Coesike East Roman 55.026 / - 0.616 ? 0.616 Town House, temporary camp 2.285 Heddon-on-the-Wall Coesike West Roman 55.025 / - 0.89 ? 0.89 to the A69 trunk road temporary camps 1 2.286 in wall mile 12 and 2 Hadrian's Wall and 55.005 / - 29.581 ? 29.581 Grindon School 55.022 / - 0.608 ? 0.608 vallum between the 1.856 Roman temporary 2.293 March Burn and camp Oatens Bank, Harlow Hill in wall miles Seatsides 1 Roman 54.988 / - 15.985 ? 15.985 13,14 and 15 temporary camp and 2.407 section of the Hadrian's Wall from 55.009 / - 3.324 ? 3.324 Stanegate Roman Oatens Bank, Harlow 1.889 road from the west Hill, to Whittle Dene side of the road from Watercourse in wall to the mile 16 south side of the The vallum between 55.007 / - 5.069 ? 5.069 B631 Oatens Bank, Harlow 1.889 Seatsides 2 Roman 54.992 / - 5.362 ? 5.362 Hill, and Whittle Dene temporary camp 2.388 Watercourse in wall mile 16 Bean Burn 1 Roman 54.988 / - 0.733 ? 0.733 temporary camp 2.381 Hadrian's Wall and 55.009 / - 29.438 ? 29.438 vallum between the 1.922 Bean Burn 2 Roman 54.988 / - 0.124 ? 0.124 B6309 and the B6321 temporary camp 2.384 in wall miles 16, 17 Chesters Pike Roman 54.998 / -2.46 1.367 ? 1.367 and 18 temporary camp Hadrian's Wall and 55.012 / - 21.381 ? 21.381 1 54.988 / -2.45 6.859 ? 6.859 vallum between 1.988 Roman temporary Sunnybrae at Halton camp, fortlet and Shields and section of the Haltonchesters Stanegate Roman fort in wall miles 20 and 21 Haltwhistle Burn 54.991 / - 2.024 ? 2.024 Roman temporary 2.445 camps 2 and 3 and area of cord rig cultivation

Page 2 Monday, May 19, 2014 (12:41:04 PM CEST) Periodic Report - Section II-Frontiers of the Roman Empire World Heritage Centre Periodic Report - Second Cycle Section II-Frontiers of the Roman Empire

Sunny Rigg 1 Roman 54.984 / - 1.14 ? 1.14 The vallum and early 55.021 / - 10.758 ? 10.758 temporary camp 2.477 Roman road between 2.306 the field boundary Sunny Rigg 2 Roman 54.985 / - 1.131 ? 1.131 east of turret 34a and temporary camp 2.472 the field boundary Sunny Rigg 3 Roman 54.987 / - 0.269 ? 0.269 west of milecastle 36 temporary camp 2.469 in wall miles 34, 35 Fell End Roman 54.984 / - 13.463 ? 13.463 and 36 temporary camp and 2.488 Hadrian's Wall and 55.005 / - 34.87 ? 34.87 section of the associated features 2.369 Stanegate Roman between the field road boundary west of Chapel Rigg Roman 54.982 / - 2.264 ? 2.264 turret 37a and the temporary camp 2.555 road to Steel Rigg car park in wall miles 37, Crooks Roman 54.984 / -2.57 2.214 ? 2.214 38 and 39 temporary camp The vallum and a 55 / -2.366 20.293 ? 20.293 The section of 54.983 / - 10.709 ? 10.709 British settlement Stanegate Roman 2.508 between the field road from Fell End boundary west of Roman temporary turret 37a & the road camp to the track to to Steel Rigg car Old Shield, and the park, in wall miles 37, Roman cemetery 38 & 39 adjacent to Carvoran Roman f Hadrian's Wall, 55.001 / -2.41 22.973 ? 22.973 associated features & Moss Side 1 and 2 54.935 / - 8.879 ? 8.879 a Romano-British Roman temporary 2.849 settlement between camps the road to Steel Rigg Hadrian's Wall & 55.019 / - 31.756 ? 31.756 car park & the road vallum between field 2.083 through Caw Gap in boundary east of wall miles 39 milecastle 24 & field The vallum between 54.995 / - 14.344 ? 14.344 boundary west of the the road to Steel Rigg 2.408 site of turret 25b in car park and the road wall miles 24-25 in Caw Gap in wall The Roman fort, 55.025 / - 27.572 ? 27.572 miles 39, 40 and 41 , bridge 2.143 Hadrian's Wall and 54.994 / -2.44 31.442 ? 31.442 abutments and vallum between the associated remains of road to Caw Gap and Hadrian's Wall at the Caw Burn in wall Chesters in wall mile miles 41 and 42 27 Great Chesters 54.994 / - 49.169 ? 49.169 Hadrian's Wall and 55.032 / - 29.247 ? 29.247 Roman fort and 2.463 vallum between 2.165 Hadrian's Wall Chesters and the between the Caw road to Simonburn in Burn and the track to wall miles 27, 28 and Cockmount Hill farm 29 in wall miles 42 and Hadrian's Wall and 55.037 / - 25.891 ? 25.891 43 vallum between the 2.202 Hadrian's Wall 54.99 / -2.513 4.044 ? 4.044 road to Simonburn between Walltown and the field Quarry East and boundary east of Walltown Quarry car park West in wall mile 45 in wall miles 29, 30 and 31 The vallum between 54.99 / -2.494 12.656 ? 12.656 Cockmount Hill and Hadrian's Wall and 55.033 / - 16.816 ? 16.816 Walltown Quarry vallum between the 2.242 West in wall miles 43, field boundary west of 44 and 45 's Well and the field boundary at Hadrian's Wall and 54.938 / - 38.219 ? 38.219 Brown Dikes in wall vallum between 2.861 miles 31 and 32 Baron's Dike and Birky Lane at Walby, Hadrian's Wall and 55.03 / -2.274 32.853 ? 32.853 in wall miles 60, 61 vallum between the and 62. field boundary at Brown Dikes and the Hadrian's Wall and 54.925 / - 28.822 ? 28.822 field boundary east of vallum between Birky 2.894 turret 34a in wall Lane at Walby and miles 32, 33 and 34 the east side of the M6 in wall miles 62 Hadrian's Wall and 55.025 / - 25.649 ? 25.649 and 63 associated features 2.307 between the Brown Moor Roman 55.029 / - 0.36 ? 0.36 boundary east of temporary camp 2.246 turret 34a and the Hadrian's Wall 54.972 / - 8.413 ? 8.413 field boundary west of between the road to 2.732 milecastle 36 in wall Garthside and The miles 34, 35 and 3 Centurion Inn, Walton, in wall miles 54 and 55

Page 3 Monday, May 19, 2014 (12:41:04 PM CEST) Periodic Report - Section II-Frontiers of the Roman Empire World Heritage Centre Periodic Report - Second Cycle Section II-Frontiers of the Roman Empire

The vallum between 54.97 / -2.738 12.35 ? 12.35 Hadrian's Wall and 54.977 / -2.66 26.91 ? 26.91 the road to Garthside vallum between the and the track east of field boundary west of Castlesteads in wall Coombe Crag and miles 54, 55 and 56 Banks Green Cottage and the road to Hadrian's Wall 54.969 / - 3.637 ? 3.637 Lanercost at Banks in between Eden Vale 2.758 wall miles 51 & house and the Cam Beck in wall mile 56 Hadrian's Wall and 54.972 / - 21.943 ? 21.943 vallum between 2.697 Castlesteads Roman 54.963 / - 10.903 ? 10.903 Banks Green Cottage fort and the vallum 2.763 and the road to between the track to Lanercost at Banks the east of and the road to Castlesteads fort and Garthside in wall the Cam Beck in the miles 52, 53 and 54 west Ravenglass Roman 54.35 / -3.406 2.292 ? 2.292 Hadrian's Wall 54.964 / - 4.294 ? 4.294 fort between the Cam 2.773 Beck and Newtown Beaumont motte 54.924 / - 0.166 ? 0.166 Farm in wall miles 56 castle and section of 3.019 and 57 Hadrian's Wall in wall mile 70 including The vallum between 54.958 / - 1.701 ? 1.701 turret 70a the field boundary 2.778 south east of Heads Roman signal station 54.98 / -2.606 0.09 ? 0.09 Wood and the A6071 on Mains Rigg road in wall mile 57 Eight Roman 54.978 / - 0.049 ? 0.049 Hadrian's Wall & 54.949 / - 21.377 ? 21.377 inscriptions in the 2.641 vallum from A6071 to 2.797 Roman quarry in The Cottage in the Combcrag Wood, case of the Wall, & to 350m south of the road to Oldwall, Hadrian's Wall for the vallum, in wall Written Rock of Gelt: 54.921 / - 0.036 ? 0.036 miles 57, 58 & 59 Roman quarry 2.741 Hadrian's Wall 54.944 / - 6.534 ? 6.534 inscriptions between the road to 2.828 Boothby Roman fort 54.959 / - 1.034 ? 1.034 Laversdale at Oldwall 2.713 and Baron's Dike in wall miles 59 and 60 Brampton Old Church 54.946 / - 2.047 ? 2.047 Roman fort and the 2.767 The vallum between 54.943 / - 7.201 ? 7.201 medieval Church of the road to 2.828 St Martin Laversdale at Oldwall and Baron's Dike in Hadrian's Wall vallum 54.904 / - 1.518 ? 1.518 wall miles 59 and 60 between the 2.984 dismantled railway Carvoran Roman fort 54.986 / - 23.578 ? 23.578 north of and Hadrian's Wall 2.524 Knockupworth and vallum between Cottage and the the unclassified road dismantled railway to Old Shield & the south of Boomby Gill field boundary west of in wall mile 67 the fort in wall miles 45 & Hadrian's Wall vallum 54.908 / - 5.375 ? 5.375 between the 2.992 Hadrian's Wall and 54.987 / - 8.66 ? 8.66 dismantled railway vallum between the 2.533 south of Boomby Gill field boundary west of and the field Carvoran Roman fort boundary south east and the west side of of Mill Beck in wall the B6318 road in mile 68 wall mile 46 Hadrian's Wall 54.913 / - 5.173 ? 5.173 Hadrian's Wall, 54.987 / - 58.131 ? 58.131 between Grinsdale 2.999 vallum, section of the 2.555 and the field Stanegate Roman boundary south of the road and a Roman site of St Andrew's temporary camp Church, Kirkandrews between the B6318 on Eden in wall miles road and Poltross 68 and 69 Burn in wall miles 46 and 4 Hadrian's Wall vallum 54.996 / - 3.307 ? 3.307 between Mill Beck 1.778 Roman 54.989 / - 27.012 ? 27.012 and the field fort and the section of 2.604 boundary east of Hadrian's Wall and Kirkandrews Farm in vallum between the wall mile 69 and the field boundaries east Hadrian's Wall 54.921 / - 2.78 ? 2.78 of milecastle 50 between the field 3.013 boundary to the south Hadrian's Wall and 54.984 / - 48.797 ? 48.797 of the site of St vallum between the 2.627 Andrew's Church and field boundaries east Eden Bank at of milecastle 50 and Beaumont in wall the boundary west of miles 69 and 70 Coombe Crag in wall miles 50 and 51

Page 4 Monday, May 19, 2014 (12:41:04 PM CEST) Periodic Report - Section II-Frontiers of the Roman Empire World Heritage Centre Periodic Report - Second Cycle Section II-Frontiers of the Roman Empire

Hadrian's Wall vallum 54.919 / -3.03 9.561 ? 9.561 Wolsty North tower 54.843 / - 0.073 ? 0.073 between the 13a, 500m south west 3.406 dismantled railway of Wolsty Farm, part west of Kirkandrews of the Roman frontier Farm & the defences along the dismantled railway Cumbrian coast south east of Burgh Wolsty South tower 54.838 / - 0.085 ? 0.085 by Sands in wall 13b, 200m WNW of 3.408 miles 70 & New House, part of Hadrian's Wall 54.922 / - 6.955 ? 6.955 the Roman frontier between Fulwood 3.068 defences along the House at Burgh by Cumbrian coast Sands and Burgh Bank Mill tower 15a, 54.818 / - 0.084 ? 0.084 Marsh in wall miles 250m north west of 3.425 72 and 73 Belmont House, part Drumburgh Roman 54.93 / -3.158 8.761 ? 8.761 of the Roman frontier fort and Hadrian's defences along the Wall between Burgh Cumbrian coast Marsh and Westfield Mawbray Sandpit 54.801 / - 0.091 ? 0.091 House in wall miles tower 16b, 680m 3.435 76 and 77 WSW of Hailforth, Hadrian's Wall vallum 54.935 / - 6.631 ? 6.631 part of the Roman between the 3.169 frontier defences watercourse 400m along the Cumbrian south east of Glasson coast and the access road Swarthy Hill North 54.75 / -3.446 0.063 ? 0.063 to Glendale caravan tower 20b, 460m park in wall miles 76 south west of Blue and 77 Dial, part of the Hadrian's Wall and 54.942 / - 4.723 ? 4.723 Roman frontier vallum between the 3.181 defences along the access road to Cumbrian coast Glendale caravan Brownrigg North 54.739 / -3.46 0.09 ? 0.09 park and the track tower 21b, 830m south of Kirkland north west of House in wall miles Canonby Hall, part of 77 and 78 the Roman frontier The Roman fort and 54.952 / - 4.277 ? 4.277 defences along the associated civil 3.215 Cumbrian coast settlement and a Maryport Golf Course 54.734 / - 0.063 ? 0.063 medieval tower 22a, 350m 3.472 at Bowness on north of the Cemetery Solway at the west Chapel, part of the end of Hadrian's Wall Roman frontier in wall mile 80 defences along the Silloth Golf Course 54.856 / - 0.096 ? 0.096 Cumbrian coast tower 12a, 670m 3.399 54.992 / - 26.778 ? 26.778 WNW of Blitterlees (Chesterholm) 2.371 Farm, part of the Roman forts, civil Roman frontier settlement and defences along the cemeteries, adjacent Cumbrian coast length of the Silloth Golf Course 54.851 / - 0.081 ? 0.081 Stanegate Roman tower 12b, 410m 3.402 road and two north west of milestones Heatherbank, part of Low Mire (milefortlet 54.757 / - 0.249 ? 0.249 the Roman frontier 20) 50m north of 3.436 defences along the Heather Bank, part of Cumbrian coast the Roman frontier Rise How tower 25a, 54.701 / - 0.04 ? 0.04 defences along the part of the Roman 3.512 Cumbrian coast frontier defences Sea Brows (milefortlet 54.728 / - 0.36 ? 0.36 along the Cumbrian 23), 500m south west 3.485 coast including of Bank End part of remains of prehistoric the Roman frontier burial mound and defences along the early medieval kil Cumbrian coast Dubmill Point 54.797 / - 0.6 ? 0.6 Blitterlees (milefortlet 54.86 / -3.397 0.372 ? 0.372 milefortlet 17, 560m 3.437 12), part of the WNW of Hill House, Roman frontier part of the Roman defences along the frontier defences Cumbrian coast along the Cumbrian coast Herd Hill North (tower 54.931 / - 0.07 ? 0.07 3b), 175m north east 3.287 Brownrigg milefortlet 54.736 / - 0.438 ? 0.438 of the sheep wash, 22, 800m north east 3.466 part of the Roman of the Cemetery frontier defences Chapel, part of the along the Cumbrian Roman frontier coast defences along the Cumbrian coast

Page 5 Monday, May 19, 2014 (12:41:04 PM CEST) Periodic Report - Section II-Frontiers of the Roman Empire World Heritage Centre Periodic Report - Second Cycle Section II-Frontiers of the Roman Empire

Pasture House 54.933 / - 0.549 ? 0.549 Carrawburgh Roman 55.035 / - 12.53 ? 12.53 (milefortlet 3), part of 3.272 fort & Hadrian's Wall 2.225 the Roman frontier & vallum between the defences along the field boundary east of Cumbrian coast the fort & the field boundary west of Herd Hill (milefortlet 54.926 / -3.29 0.675 ? 0.675 Coventina's Well in 4) and associated wall mil parallel banks and ditches, part of the Hadrian's Wall and 54.991 / - 11.5 ? 11.5 Roman frontier vallum and their 2.583 defences along the associated features Cumbrian coast between Poltross Burn and the River Campfield (tower 2b) 54.935 / - 1.242 ? 1.242 Irthing in wall mile 48 & associated parallel 3.265 ditches & Roman The Roman bath 54.966 / - 0.11 ? 0.11 road, 350m south house to the north 2.762 west of Campfield east of Castlesteads Farm part of Roman Roman fort in wall frontier defences mile 56 along Cumbrian coas Hadrian's Wall 54.949 / -3.2 5.456 ? 5.456 Biglands House 54.946 / - 1.716 ? 1.716 between Port (milefortlet 1) and 3.236 and Bowness-on- associated parallel Solway in wall miles ditches, part of the 78 & 79 Roman frontier Hadrian's Wall vallum 54.947 / - 7.787 ? 7.787 defences along the between the track 3.194 Cumbrian coast south of Kirkland ditches, part 54.874 / - 2.528 ? 2.528 House and Bowness- of Roman frontier 3.383 on-Solway in wall defences along miles 78 & 79 Cumbrian coast, Cardurnock (tower 54.917 / - 0.526 ? 0.526 Roman camp & road 4b) and earlier 3.295 & part of Romano- system and patrol British field road, part of the system,250m north of Roman frontier Silloth defences along the Swarthy Hill 54.757 / - 0.412 ? 0.412 Cumbrian coast milefortlet 21, 80m 3.436 Hadrian's Wall north 54.945 / - 0.102 ? 0.102 south of the Saltpans, of Kirkland House, 3.183 part of the Roman Port Carlisle in wall frontier defences mile 78 along the Cumbrian coast Knockcross Roman 54.953 / - 0.774 ? 0.774 temporary camp at 3.203 Skinburness 54.892 / - 1.066 ? 1.066 Grey Havens (milefortlet 9), part of 3.359 the Roman frontier Rudchester Roman 55.001 / - 24.445 ? 24.445 defences along the fort, associated civil 1.821 Cumbrian coast, and settlement and a earlier Roman camp section of Hadrian's Wall and vallum from Maryport (Alavna) 54.723 / - 20.763 ? 20.763 the A69 to the March Roman fort, part of 3.491 Burn in wall mile 13 the Roman frontier defences along the Hadrian's Wall and 55.012 / - 20.445 ? 20.445 Cumbrian coast, its vallum between the 1.958 associated vicus and B6321 and a length of Roman Sunnybrae at Halton road Shields, in wall miles 18 and 19 Bewcastle Roman 55.064 / - 3.907 ? 3.907 fort, high cross shaft 2.682 Hadrian's Wall 54.996 / - 32.77 ? 32.77 in St Cuthbert's between the track to 2.491 churchyard, and Bew Cockmount Hill and Castle medieval shell Walltown Quarry East castle in wall miles 43, 44 and 45 Hadrian's Wall 54.94 / -3.174 0.31 ? 0.31 between Apple Garth, Limestone Corner 55.037 / - 0.846 ? 0.846 Westfield, and the Roman temporary 2.194 dismantled railway in camp wall mile 77 Cawfields Roman 54.996 / - 1.496 ? 1.496 Hadrian's Wall 54.94 / -3.176 0.39 ? 0.39 temporary camp 2.449 between the Hadrian's Wall 54.919 / - 1.775 ? 1.775 dismantled railway between the M6 2.913 and the access road motorway and the to Glendale caravan property boundaries park in wall mile 77 to the east of Burnhead Roman 54.996 / - 5.26 ? 5.26 Houghton Road in temporary camp 2.455 wall mile 64 Twice Brewed Roman 54.995 / - 2.168 ? 2.168 Hadrian's Wall vallum 54.919 / - 0.173 ? 0.173 temporary camp 2.391 between the M6 2.907 motorway and Drawdykes Castle in wall mile 64

Page 6 Monday, May 19, 2014 (12:41:04 PM CEST) Periodic Report - Section II-Frontiers of the Roman Empire World Heritage Centre Periodic Report - Second Cycle Section II-Frontiers of the Roman Empire

Hadrian's Wall vallum 54.916 / - 3.471 ? 3.471 54.973 / - 9.151 ? 9.151 between Drawdykes 2.913 Roman fort, 2.635 Castle and associated vicus and Whiteclosegate in length of Stanegate wall mile 64 Roman road Hadrian's Wall 54.915 / -2.92 0.943 ? 0.943 Defended settlement 54.995 / - 1.038 ? 1.038 between Houghton and Roman signal 2.341 Road and Tarraby in station 410m south of wall mile 64 West Crindledikes Hadrian's Wall 54.911 / - 3.657 ? 3.657 Hadrian's Wall and 55.022 / - 23.236 ? 23.236 between Tarraby and 2.927 vallum between St 2.119 Beech Grove, Oswald's Cottages, Knowefield in wall east of Brunton Gate miles 64 and 65 and the North Tyne in wall miles 25, 26 and Hadrian's Wall vallum 54.91 / -2.924 2.678 ? 2.678 27 between the boundaries north of Housesteads fort, 55.011 / - 117.876 ? 117.876 the properties on section of Wall & 2.332 Whiteclosegate and vallum between the the field boundary field boundary west of west of Wall Knowe in milecastle 36 & the wall miles 64 and field boundary west of turret 37a in wall Hadrian's Wall and 54.904 / - 14.08 ? 14.08 miles 36 & vallum between the 2.933 field boundary west of Kirkbride Roman fort, 54.905 / - 4.466 ? 4.466 Wall Knowe and part of associated 3.201 Road vicus and length of including the Roman Roman road around, fort at Stanwix in wall 370m south east of mile 65 Whitrigg Bridge Roman quarry 55.029 / - 0.011 ? 0.011 Roman fort, Anglo- 54.968 / -1.61 1.012 ? 1.012 inscription on 2.323 Saxon cemetery, Queen's Crags, 680m motte and south east of East castle and tower keep Hotbank castle Stone circle, 55.02 / -2.353 8.146 ? 8.146 Total (ha) 1691.119 0 1691.119 defended settlement, Romano-British Comment farmstead & field we will be submitting separately revised maps and numbering system, Roman camp & group of shielings for the other two components of the property; this is a immediately south of technical clarification of the numbering of the property it is not Greenlee Lough an alteration of the boundaries Roman 55.02 / -2.638 14.52 ? 14.52 road from B6318 to 450m SW of High 1.4 - Map(s) House, Gillalees Title Date Link to Beacon signal station source and Beacon Pasture early post-medieval Frontiers of the Roman Empire, Map of the Antonine 30/06/2008 dispersed settlement Wall Hadrian's Wall vallum 54.922 / - 4.401 ? 4.401 Map of the Upper German-Raetian 29/01/2004 between West End, 3.071 Burgh By Sands and Frontiers of the Roman Empire: Hadrian's Wall. Map 1: 28/11/2011 the track to Skinburness (north) to Maryport (south) Dykesfield in wall Frontiers of the Roman Empire: Hadrian's Wall. Map 2: 28/11/2011 miles 72 and 73 Cardurnock (west) to Willowholme, Carlisle (east) Hadrian's Wall 54.901 / - 13.227 ? 13.227 Frontiers of the Roman Empire: Hadrian's Wall. Map 3: 28/11/2011 between the east end 2.978 Carlisle (west) to (east) of Davidson's Banks & road to Grinsdale & Frontiers of the Roman Empire: Hadrian's Wall. Map 4: 28/11/2011 vallum between Greenhead (west) to (east) Davidson's Banks & Frontiers of the Roman Empire: Hadrian's Wall. Map 5: 28/11/2011 dismantled railway in Walwick (west) to Heddon-on-the-Wall (east) wall miles 67 & Frontiers of the Roman Empire: Hadrian's Wall. Map 6: 28/11/2011 Burgh by Sands 54.923 / - 12.894 ? 12.894 Heddon-on-the-Wall (west) to (east) Roman fort, 3.035 Beaumont camp, Comment Burgh Castle & Hadrian's Wall from We are submitting separately more detailed maps of the boundary west of German Limes; please note this is only a clarification, there churchyard, are no changes to the boundaries of the World Heritage Beaumont to Burgh property and that these maps replace those of 29/01/04. Head in wall miles 70 and Hadrian's Wall vallum 54.921 / - 1.576 ? 1.576 1.5 - Governmental Institution Responsible for the between east side of 3.054 Property road at Burgh Head, & boundary south of  Birgitta Ringbeck Ash Tree Square, Auswärtiges Amt Burgh-by-Sands in wall miles 71 & 72 National World Heritage Focal Point

Page 7 Monday, May 19, 2014 (12:41:04 PM CEST) Periodic Report - Section II-Frontiers of the Roman Empire World Heritage Centre Periodic Report - Second Cycle Section II-Frontiers of the Roman Empire

Referat 603-9 Empire - http://www.romanfrontiers.org/ Add: Historic Scotland Multilaterale Kultur- und Medienpolitik - http://www.historic-scotland.gov.uk/  Christopher Young English Heritage 1.8 - Other designations / Conventions under which the Head of World International Advice property is protected (if applicable)  Paul Blaker Department for Culture, Media and Sport 2. Statement of Outstanding Universal Value Head of World Heritage Comment 2.1 - Statement of Outstanding Universal Value / Add Generaldirektion Kulturelles Erbe, Direktion Statement of Significance Landesarchäologie, Außenstelle Koblenz, Niederberger Höhe Comment 1, 56077 Koblenz. hessenARCHÄOLOGIE, Schloss Biebrich, 65203 Wiesbaden. Bayerisches Landesamt für The Intergovernmental Committee has proposed a draft Denkmalpflege, Hofgraben 4, 80539 München. SOUV to UNESCO and this is under discussion. Regierungspräsidium Stuttgart, Landesamt für Denkmalpflege, Berliner Str. 12, 73728 Esslingen Add Historic Scotland: Mark 2.2 - The criteria (2005 revised version) under which the Lawson, Policy Manager, Historic Scotland, Longmore House, property was inscribed Salisbury Place, Edinburgh EH9 1SH. Tel: 0131 6688600 (ii)(iii)(iv)

1.6 - Property Manager / Coordinator, Local Institution / 2.3 - Attributes expressing the Outstanding Universal Agency Value per criterion  Nigel Mills It is not possible to list the attributes until the basis of the Hadrian’s Wall Heritage Ltd Statement of Outstanding Universal Value is agreed between World Heritage and Access Director (Hadrian's Wall) the property, the World Heritage Centre and ICOMOS  Tricia Weeks 2.4 - If needed, please provide details of why the Coordinator () Statement of Outstanding Universal Value should be  Wolf Claus revised Regierungspräsidium Stuttgart, Landesamt für No previous SOUV has been agreed for this property as a Denkmalpflege whole Abteilungspräsident  Peter Henrich 2.5 - Comments, conclusions and / or recommendations Deutsche Limes Kommission related to Statement of Outstanding Universal Value Site Manager We consider that there are outstanding issues which need to  John Scott be resolved as to the character of a SOUV for a transnational The Hadrian’s Wall Trust property in which the different components have very different attributes. The standard format does not fit this situation and Comment does not produce a result which is useful for the site Remove Nigel Mills, details for Patricia Weeks, Antonine Wall managers of the individual components. World Heritage Site Co-ordinator, Historic Scotland, Longmore House, Salisbury Place, Edinburgh EH9 1SH Tel: 0131 6688600, Remove 'site manager' from entry for German 3. Factors Affecting the Property Limeskommission, add Landesamt fuer Denkmalpflege, Schloss Biebrich, 65203 Wiesbaden, 0049 6116906169, add 3.14. Other factor(s) Bayerisches Landesamt fuer Denkmalpflege, Hofgraben 4, 80539 Muenchen, 00498921140 remove the names Claus Wolf and Thomas Metz 3.14.1 - Other factor(s)

1.7 - Web Address of the Property (if existing) http://www.vindolanda.com/ http://www.hadrianswallheritage.co.uk/ http://www.magic.gov.uk/website/magic/opener.htm?startTopi c=magicall&chosenLayers=whsIndex&xygridref=370289,5562 81&startScale=849311 http://www.nationaltrust.org.uk/scripts/nthandbook.dll?ACTIO N=PROPERTY&PROPERTYID=182 http://www.limes-in- deutschland.de/limes_english.html http://www.northumberland-national- park.org.uk/VisitorGuide/Visiting/PlacestoVisit/hadrianswall.ht m http://www.english- heritage.org.uk/server/show/conProperty.77 Comment Replace number 6 with the title Upper German-Raetian Limes www.deutsche-limeskommission.de Add: Antonine Wall - http://www.antoninewall.org/ Add: Frontiers of the Roman Page 8 Monday, May 19, 2014 (12:41:04 PM CEST) Periodic Report - Section II-Frontiers of the Roman Empire World Heritage Centre Periodic Report - Second Cycle Section II-Frontiers of the Roman Empire

3.15. Factors Summary Table

3.15.1 - Factors summary table Name Impact Origin 3.1 Buildings and Development 3.1.1 Housing

3.1.2 Commercial development

3.1.3 Industrial areas

3.1.4 Major visitor accommodation and associated infrastructure

3.1.5 Interpretative and visitation facilities

3.2 Transportation Infrastructure 3.2.1 Ground transport infrastructure

3.2.2 Air transport infrastructure

3.2.3 Marine transport infrastructure

3.2.4 Effects arising from use of transportation infrastructure

3.3 Services Infrastructures 3.3.1 Water infrastructure

3.3.2 Renewable energy facilities

3.3.5 Major linear utilities

3.5 Biological resource use/modification 3.5.3 Land conversion

3.5.4 Livestock farming / grazing of domesticated animals

3.5.5 Crop production

3.5.10 Forestry /wood production

3.6 Physical resource extraction 3.6.1 Mining

3.6.2 Quarrying

3.6.4 Water (extraction)

3.7 Local conditions affecting physical fabric 3.7.6 Water (rain/water table)

3.8 Social/cultural uses of heritage 3.8.2 Society's valuing of heritage

3.8.6 Impacts of tourism / visitor / recreation

3.9 Other human activities 3.9.1 Illegal activities

3.10 Climate change and severe weather events 3.10.1 Storms

3.11 Sudden ecological or geological events 3.11.5 Erosion and siltation/ deposition

3.13 Management and institutional factors 3.13.1 Low impact research / monitoring activities

3.13.2 High impact research / monitoring activities

3.13.3 Management activities

Legend Current Potential Negative Positive Inside Outside

Page 9 Monday, May 19, 2014 (12:41:04 PM CEST) Periodic Report - Section II-Frontiers of the Roman Empire World Heritage Centre Periodic Report - Second Cycle Section II-Frontiers of the Roman Empire

3.16. Assessment of current negative factors

3.16.1 - Assessment of current negative factors Spatial scale Temporal scale Impact Management Trend response 3.1 Buildings and Development 3.1.1 Housing restricted one off or rare insignificant medium capacity static 3.1.2 Commercial development restricted one off or rare insignificant medium capacity static 3.1.3 Industrial areas restricted one off or rare insignificant medium capacity static 3.2 Transportation Infrastructure 3.2.1 Ground transport infrastructure restricted one off or rare insignificant medium capacity static 3.3 Services Infrastructures 3.3.1 Water infrastructure restricted one off or rare insignificant medium capacity static 3.3.2 Renewable energy facilities restricted one off or rare insignificant medium capacity static 3.3.5 Major linear utilities restricted one off or rare insignificant medium capacity static 3.5 Biological resource use/modification 3.5.3 Land conversion restricted intermittent or sporadic insignificant low capacity static 3.5.4 Livestock farming / grazing of restricted intermittent or sporadic insignificant medium capacity static domesticated animals 3.5.5 Crop production localised on-going minor low capacity static 3.5.10 Forestry /wood production localised on-going minor medium capacity static 3.6 Physical resource extraction 3.6.2 Quarrying restricted on-going insignificant low capacity static 3.6.4 Water (extraction) restricted one off or rare insignificant low capacity static 3.7 Local conditions affecting physical fabric 3.7.6 Water (rain/water table) restricted one off or rare insignificant low capacity static 3.8 Social/cultural uses of heritage 3.8.6 Impacts of tourism / visitor / localised on-going insignificant low capacity static recreation 3.9 Other human activities 3.9.1 Illegal activities restricted one off or rare insignificant low capacity static

Page 10 Monday, May 19, 2014 (12:41:04 PM CEST) Periodic Report - Section II-Frontiers of the Roman Empire World Heritage Centre Periodic Report - Second Cycle Section II-Frontiers of the Roman Empire

for Culture Media and Sport, after seeking the advice of 3.17. Comments, conclusions and / or English Heritage, and is normally with conditions that mitigate the effects of the works on the monument to recommendations related to factors affecting the within satisfactory limits. property Local authorities are encouraged by the Management 3.17.1 - Comments Plan to develop effective local planning policies which protect the Site and its Setting. These local plans vary across the Site, but most have separate policies which 4. Protection, Management and Monitoring of the relate to the Site itself and to the Buffer Zone, known as Property “The Setting”.

4.1. Boundaries and Buffer Zones For example Carlisle City Council’s policy E25 states “Development will not be permitted where there is an unacceptable adverse effect on the Hadrian’s Wall 4.1.1 - Buffer zone status Military Zone World Heritage Site” and is applied to the There is a buffer zone scheduled monuments which comprise the WHS.

4.1.2 - Are the boundaries of the World Heritage property Policy E26 applies to the defined setting around the adequate to maintain the property's Outstanding WHS: “Within the Buffer Zone of Hadrian’s Wall Military Universal Value? Zone World Heritage Site, as defined on the Proposals The boundaries of the World Heritage property are adequate Map, proposals for development which would have an to maintain the property's Outstanding Universal Value unacceptable adverse impact on the character and/or setting of the World Heritage Site will not be permitted. Development within or adjacent to existing settlements, 4.1.3 - Are the buffer zone(s) of the World Heritage established farmsteads or other groups of buildings will property adequate to maintain the property's Outstanding be permitted provided that 1. The proposal reflects the Universal Value? scale and character of the existing group of buildings; The buffer zones of the World Heritage property do not limit and 2. There is no adverse effect on the character and/or the ability to maintain the property's Outstanding Universal appearance of Hadrian’s Wall Military Zone World Value but they could be improved Heritage Site.

4.1.4 - Are the boundaries of the World Heritage property Policy E27 relates to areas beyond the defined buffer known? zone where major developments might still affect the The boundaries of the World Heritage property are known by character and/or setting of the WHS: “Within the outer both the management authority and local residents / visual envelope, beyond the Hadrian’s Wall Military Zone communities / landowners. World Heritage Site, proposals for major development which would have an adverse effect on the character of the World Heritage Site will not be permitted unless the 4.1.5 - Are the buffer zones of the World Heritage property need for the development outweighs the environmental known? costs.” The buffer zones of the World Heritage property are known by both the management authority and local residents / Allerdale Borough Council, Council and communities / landowners. National Park all have policies which are similarly zoned for the Site itself and its Buffer Zone. 4.1.6 - Comments, conclusions and / or recommendations related to boundaries and buffer zones of the World Comment Heritage property Rheinland-Palatinate: Denkmalschutz- und -pflegegesetz. Hesse: Gesetz zum Schutz der Kulturdenkmäler (Denkmalschutzgesetz). Baden-Württemberg: Gesetz zum 4.2. Protective Measures Schutz der Kulturdenkmale. Bayern: Bayerisches Denkmalschutzgesetz. English National Planning Policy 4.2.1 - Protective designation (legal, regulatory, Framework - March '12 (DCLG). Protection of WH in Engand contractual, planning, institutional and / or traditional) Planning Circular 07/09 (DCMS).The Town & Country Planning Act (Scotland) 1997,as amended by The Planning Rapport périodique Cycle 1 (2001-2006) section 2 etc (Scotland) Act 2006.Scottish Planning Policy (2010).See Source : Periodic Reporting Cycle 1 (2001-2006) conclusions box also Soumis le Monday, October 31, 2005  Question 6.02 4.2.2 - Is the legal framework (i.e. legislation and / or The Site is equated with those parts of the frontier which regulation) adequate for maintaining the Outstanding are protected by scheduling under the Ancient Universal Value including conditions of Integrity and / or Monuments and Archaeological Areas Act 1979 as Authenticity of the property? amended by the Heritage Act 1983. The scheduling was last revised in the late 1990’s. The boundaries of the The legal framework for the maintenance of the Outstanding protected areas are mapped and notified to the owners Universal Value including conditions of Authenticity and / or and to local authorities. The legislation restricts any Integrity of the World Heritage property provides an adequate works within these areas that may damage, destroy or or better basis for effective management and protection add to the monument unless with the benefit of scheduled monument consent. Consent is given by the Department Page 11 Monday, May 19, 2014 (12:41:04 PM CEST) Periodic Report - Section II-Frontiers of the Roman Empire World Heritage Centre Periodic Report - Second Cycle Section II-Frontiers of the Roman Empire

4.2.3 - Is the legal framework (i.e. legislation and / or o Gestion par accord contractuel entre l'Etat partie et regulation) adequate in the buffer zone for maintaining un tiers the Outstanding Universal Value including conditions of o Gestion consensuelle Integrity and / or Authenticity of the property? o Autre système de gestion en vigueur The legal framework for the maintenance of the Outstanding A large part of the central section of Hadrian’s Wall is Universal Value including conditions of Authenticity and / or owned and managed by the National Trust, which is a Integrity of the World Heritage property provides an adequate national charitable body committed to conservation of or better basis for effective management and protection both the cultural and natural heritage. The excavated remains of part of the civil settlement attached to the fort 4.2.4 - Is the legal framework (i.e. legislation and / or of Vindolanda, as well as the unexcavated fort of regulation) adequate in the area surrounding the World Carvoran, is owned and managed by the Vindolanda Heritage property and buffer zone for maintaining the Trust, a charitable trust formed for the purposes of Outstanding Universal Value including conditions of acquiring and managing the archaeological sites within its Integrity and / or Authenticity of the property? ownership and promoting research, principally through An adequate legal framework exists for the area surrounding excavation and publication. the World Heritage property and the buffer zone, but there are some deficiencies in its implementation which undermine Comment the maintenance of the Outstanding Universal Value including The property has an international steering committee, conditions of Authenticity and / or Integrity of the property scientific advisory committee and site management group. Each part of the site has its own steering committee, legal protection, and a management plan. 4.2.5 - Can the legislative framework (i.e. legislation and / or regulation) be enforced? There is acceptable capacity / resources to enforce legislation 4.3.2 - Management Documents and / or regulation in the World Heritage property but some Title Status Available Date Link to deficiencies remain source Hadrian's Wall World Heritage Site N/A Disponible 01/07/1996 - Management Plan, 07/1996 4.2.6 - Comments, conclusions and / or recommendations Hadrian's Wall World Heritage Site. N/A Disponible 01/01/1996 related to protective measures Management Plan, 1996 Additional Scottish Protective Legislation to be added at 4.2.1: Hadrian's Wall World Heritage Site. N/A Disponible 01/01/2002 Planning Advice Note 2/2011 Planning and Archaeology. Management Plan, 2002-2007 Historic Environment (Amendment) Scotland Act 2011. Comment Scottish Historic Environment Policy, December 2011. Managing Change in the Historic Environment Guidance Upper German-Raetian Limes, Management Plan 2005-2010 Notes, Historic Scotland, various dates. Supplementary (link) Upper German-Raetian Limes, Management Plan 2010- Planning Guidance for the Antonine Wall World Heritage Site, 2015 (link) Hadrian's Wall World Heritage Site - Management 2012. Plan, 2008-14 (www.-wall.org) Antonine Wall, Management Plan 2007-12 (http://www.historic- scotland.gov.uk/antonine-wall-management-plan.pdf) 4.3. Management System / Management Plan 4.3.3 - How well do the various levels of administration 4.3.1 - Management System (i.e. national / federal; regional / provincial / state; local / municipal etc.) coordinate in the management of the Rapport périodique Cycle 1 (2001-2006) section 2 World Heritage Property ? Source : Periodic Reporting Cycle 1 (2001-2006) Soumis le Monday, October 31, 2005 There is coordination between the range of administrative bodies / levels involved in the management of the property but  Question 5.02 it could be improved Un comité directeur du patrimoine mondial ou un comité de gestion similaire a été constitué pour superviser la gestion du site 4.3.4 - Is the management system / plan adequate to  Question 5.03 maintain the property's Outstanding Universal Value ? Date de constitution : 1993 The management system / plan is fully adequate to maintain Rôle : To oversee and agree the production and the property's Outstanding Universal Value implementation of the WHS Management Plan Mission : To oversee and monitor the implementation of 4.3.5 - Is the management system being implemented? the Management Plan; to establish a forum for The management system is being fully implemented and management issues; to receive project reports; to agree monitored priorities and action programmes; to monitor the condition of the WHS; to develop codes of practice for protection, 4.3.6 - Is there an annual work / action plan and is it being recording and research, access, interpretation and implemented? preservation of the WHS; to review the Management Plan Statut Juridique ou officiel : formal An annual work / action plan exists and many activities are being implemented  Question 5.05 Principales caractéristiques du système de gestion d'ensemble du site 4.3.7 - Please rate the cooperation / relationship with o Gestion par l'Etat partie World Heritage property managers / coordinators / staff of o Gestion dans le cadre d'une législation de protection the following Local communities / residents Fair Page 12 Monday, May 19, 2014 (12:41:04 PM CEST) Periodic Report - Section II-Frontiers of the Roman Empire World Heritage Centre Periodic Report - Second Cycle Section II-Frontiers of the Roman Empire

Local / Municipal authorities Fair 4.4.2 - International Assistance received from the World Indigenous peoples Not applicable Heritage Fund (USD) Landowners Fair Comment Visitors Fair not applicable Researchers Good Tourism industry Fair 4.4.3 - Is the current budget sufficient to manage the Industry Fair World Heritage property effectively? The available budget is acceptable but could be further 4.3.8 - If present, do local communities resident in or near improved to fully meet the management needs the World Heritage property and / or buffer zone have input in management decisions that maintain the 4.4.4 - Are the existing sources of funding secure and Outstanding Universal Value? likely to remain so? Local communities have some input into discussions relating The existing sources of funding are secure in the medium- to management but no direct role in management term and planning is underway to secure funding in the long- term 4.3.9 - If present, do indigenous peoples resident in or regularly using the World Heritage property and / or buffer 4.4.5 - Does the World Heritage property provide zone have input in management decisions that maintain economic benefits to local communities (e.g. income, the Outstanding Universal Value? employment)? No indigenous peoples are resident in or regularly using the There is some flow of economic benefits to local communities World Heritage property and / or buffer zone 4.4.6 - Are available resources such as equipment, 4.3.10 - Is there cooperation with industry (i.e. forestry, facilities and infrastructure sufficient to meet mining, agriculture, etc.) regarding the management of management needs? the World Heritage property, buffer zone and / or area There are some adequate equipment and facilities, but surrounding the World Heritage property and buffer deficiencies in at least one key area constrain management zone? at the World Heritage property There is contact but only some cooperation with industry regarding the management of the World Heritage property, 4.4.7 - Are resources such as equipment, facilities and buffer zone and / or area surrounding the World Heritage infrastructure adequately maintained? property and buffer zone There is basic maintenance of equipment and facilities

4.3.11 - Comments, conclusions and / or 4.4.8 - Comments, conclusion, and / or recommendations recommendations related to human resources, expertise related to finance and infrastructure and training

4.4.9 - Distribution of employees involved in managing the 4.3.12 - Please report any significant changes in the legal World Heritage property (% of total) status and / or contractual / traditional protective measures and management arrangements for the World Full-time 65% Heritage property since inscription or the last Periodic Part-time 35% report The Intergovernmental Committee has been set up 2005 and 4.4.10 - Distribution of employees involved in managing adopted in 2012. The Management Group (of site managers) the World Heritage property (% of total) was created in 2009 to provide a forum for best practice Permanent 85% exchange and to complement the work of the Bratislava Group Seasonal 15% as a scientific advisory body.

4.4. Financial and Human Resources 4.4.11 - Distribution of employees involved in managing the World Heritage property (% of total) Paid 95% 4.4.1 - Costs related to conservation, based on the Volunteer 5% average of last five years (relative percentage of the funding sources) Multilateral funding (GEF, World Bank, etc) 4.4.12 - Are available human resources adequate to International donations (NGO´s, foundations, etc) manage the World Heritage property? Governmental (National / Federal) 10% A range of human resources exist, but these are below optimum to manage the World Heritage Property. Governmental (Regional / Provincial / State) 75% Governmental (Local / Municipal) 8% 4.4.13 - Considering the management needs of the World In country donations (NGO´s, foundations, etc) 5% Heritage property, please rate the availability of Individual visitor charges (e.g. entry, parking, camping fees, etc.) 2% professionals in the following disciplines Commercial operator payments (e.g. filming permit, concessions, etc.) Research and monitoring Fair Other grants Promotion Fair Community outreach Fair

Page 13 Monday, May 19, 2014 (12:41:04 PM CEST) Periodic Report - Section II-Frontiers of the Roman Empire World Heritage Centre Periodic Report - Second Cycle Section II-Frontiers of the Roman Empire

Interpretation Fair 4.5.4 - Please provide details (i.e. authors, title, and web Education Fair link) of papers published about the World Heritage Visitor management Fair property since the last Periodic Report Conservation Fair Bibliography in Antonine Wall Management Plan 2007-12 covers publications till 2007 (http://www.historic- Administration Fair scotland.gov.uk/antonin-wall-management-plan.pdf). Risk preparedness Fair Forthcoming Management Plan 2013-18 will include updates Tourism Fair till 2012 (www.historic-scotland.gov.uk). Enforcement (custodians, police) Fair 4.5.5 - Comments, conclusions and / or recommendations 4.4.14 - Please rate the availability of training related to scientific studies and research projects opportunities for the management of the World Heritage property in the following disciplines 4.6. Education, Information and Awareness Research and monitoring Medium Building Promotion Low Community outreach Medium 4.6.1 - At how many locations is the World Heritage Interpretation Low emblem displayed at the property? Education Low In many locations and easily visible to visitors Visitor management Medium Conservation Medium 4.6.2 - Please rate the awareness and understanding of Administration Low the existence and justification for inscription of the World Risk preparedness Low Heritage property amongst the following groups Tourism Low Local communities / residents Average Enforcement (custodians, police) Low Local / Municipal authorities within or adjacent to the Average property 4.4.15 - Do the management and conservation Local Indigenous peoples Not applicable programmes at the World Heritage property help develop Local landowners Average local expertise? Visitors Average A capacity development plan or programme is in place and Tourism industry Poor partially implemented; some technical skills are being Local businesses and industries Average transferred to those managing the property locally but most of the technical work is carried out by external staff 4.6.3 - Is there a planned education and awareness programme linked to the values and management of the 4.4.16 - Comments, conclusions and / or World Heritage property? recommendations related to human resources, expertise There is a limited and ad hoc education and awareness and training programme

4.5. Scientific Studies and Research Projects 4.6.4 - What role, if any, has designation as a World Heritage property played with respect to education, 4.5.1 - Is there adequate knowledge (scientific or information and awareness building activities? traditional) about the values of the World Heritage World Heritage status has influenced education, information property to support planning, management and decision- and awareness building activities, but it could be improved making to ensure that Outstanding Universal Value is maintained? 4.6.5 - How well is the information on Outstanding Knowledge about the values of the World Heritage property is Universal Value of the property presented and sufficient for most key areas but there are gaps interpreted? The Outstanding Universal Value of the property is adequately 4.5.2 - Is there a planned programme of research at the presented and interpreted but improvements could be made property which is directed towards management needs and / or improving understanding of Outstanding 4.6.6 - Please rate the adequacy for education, Universal Value? information and awareness building of the following There is considerable research but it is not directed towards visitor facilities and services at the World Heritage management needs and / or improving understanding of property Outstanding Universal Value Visitor centre Adequate Site museum Excellent 4.5.3 - Are results from research programmes Information booths Adequate disseminated? Guided tours Adequate Research results are shared widely with the local, national Trails / routes Excellent and international audiences Information materials Adequate Transportation facilities Adequate Other Not needed

Page 14 Monday, May 19, 2014 (12:41:04 PM CEST) Periodic Report - Section II-Frontiers of the Roman Empire World Heritage Centre Periodic Report - Second Cycle Section II-Frontiers of the Roman Empire

4.6.7 - Comments, conclusions and / or recommendations 4.8.2 - Are key indicators for measuring the state of related to education, information and awareness building conservation used to monitor how the Outstanding Universal Value of the property is maintained? 4.7. Visitor Management Information on the values of the World Heritage property is sufficient to define key indicators, but this has not been done 4.7.1 - Please provide the trend in annual visitation for the last five years 4.8.3 - Please rate the level of involvement in monitoring Last year Minor Increase of the following groups Two years ago Minor Increase World Heritage managers / coordinators and staff Excellent Three years ago Minor Increase Local / Municipal authorities Average Four years ago Minor Increase Local communities Poor Five years ago Minor Increase Researchers Poor NGOs Not applicable 4.7.2 - What information sources are used to collect trend Industry Not applicable data on visitor statistics? Local indigenous peoples Not applicable Entry tickets and registries Accommodation establishments 4.8.4 - Has the State Party implemented relevant Transportation services recommendations arising from the World Heritage Visitor surveys Committee? Other Implementation is underway

4.7.3 - Visitor management documents 4.8.5 - Please provide comments relevant to the Comment implementation of recommendations from the World Visitor management policies are included in the World Heritage Committee Heritage Site Management Plans for each part of the property 4.8.6 - Comments, conclusions and / or recommendations 4.7.4 - Is there an appropriate visitor use management related to monitoring plan (e.g. specific plan) for the World Heritage property which ensures that its Outstanding Universal Value is 4.9. Identification of Priority Management Needs maintained? Visitor use of the World Heritage property is managed 4.9.1 - Please select the top 6 managements needs for the but improvements could be made property (if more than 6 are listed below) Please refer to question 5.2 4.7.5 - Does the tourism industry contribute to improving visitor experiences and maintaining the values of the World Heritage property? There is limited co-operation between those responsible for the World Heritage property and the tourism industry to present the Outstanding Universal Value and increase appreciation

4.7.6 - If fees (i.e. entry charges, permits) are collected, do they contribute to the management of the World Heritage property? The fee is collected, and makes some contribution to the management of the World Heritage property

4.7.7 - Comments, conclusions and / or recommendations related to visitor use of the World Heritage property Visitor management policies are included in the World Heritage Site Management Plans for each part of the property

4.8. Monitoring

4.8.1 - Is there a monitoring programme at the property which is directed towards management needs and / or improving understanding of Outstanding Universal Value? There is considerable monitoring but it is not directed towards management needs and / or improving understanding of Outstanding Universal Value

Page 15 Monday, May 19, 2014 (12:41:04 PM CEST) Periodic Report - Section II-Frontiers of the Roman Empire World Heritage Centre Periodic Report - Second Cycle Section II-Frontiers of the Roman Empire

5. Summary and Conclusions

5.1. Summary - Factors affecting the Property

5.1.1 - Summary - Factors affecting the Property World Heritage Actions Monitoring Timeframe Lead agency (and More info / criteria and attributes others involved) comment affected 3.5 Biological resource use/modification 3.5.3 Land ii iii iv Some types of Use available national Check against regular Ongoing Management agencies N/A conversion land conversion eg to approaches to convert monitoring plans. as set out in 1.5 and 1.6 arable, forestry or and influence land use Carry out surveys and and landowners,land development can to protect archaeology. investigations to users and communities. cause damage to the These could include establish the extent to archaeological purchase, agri- which inappropriate evidence which is the environmental land uses such as basis for justifying the schemes, or other ploughing actually criteria. Other forms of agreements with land cause damage under land conversion eg owners. different conditions. from arable to pasture can be beneficial 3.5.5 Crop ii, iii, iv crop production Use available national Check against regular Ongoing Management agencies N/A production can cause damage to approaches to convert monitoring plans. as set out in 1.5 and 1.6 the archaeological and influence land use Carry out surveys and and landowners and evidence which is the to protect archaeology. investigations to land users. basis for justifying the These could include establish the extent to criteria. purchase, agri- which inappropriate environmental land uses such as schemes, or other ploughing actually agreements with land cause damage under owners. different conditions. 3.5.10 Forestry ii, iii, iv wood Use available national Check against regular Ongoing Management agencies N/A /wood production can cause approaches to convert monitoring plans. as set out in 1.5 and 1.6 production damage to the and influence land use Carry out surveys and and landowners and archaeological to protect archaeology. investigations to land users. evidence which is the These could include establish the extent to basis for justifying the purchase, agri- which inappropriate criteria. environmental land uses such as schemes, or other replanting, felling and agreements with land wind blow actually owners. cause damage under different conditions. 3.6 Physical resource extraction 3.6.2 Quarrying ii, iii, iv quarrying Use available national Spatial planning Ongoing Management agencies This is a minor damages the approaches to prevent decisions will be as set out in 1.5 and 1.6 issue affecting less archaeological inappropriate quarrying. monitored and landowners and than 0.2% of the evidence and can These include land users. World Heritage Site damage setting which purchase, spatial is the basis for planning systems, or justifying the criteria. agreements with landowners. 3.8 Social/cultural uses of heritage 3.8.6 Impacts of ii, iii, iv visits to the site Ongoing development Condition and Ongoing Management agencies N/A tourism / without appropriate and implementation of customer surveys as set out in 1.5 and 1.6 visitor / management may robust visitor and landowners, land recreation damage the management policies, users and communities. archaeological plans and systems evidence and can damage setting which is the basis for justifying the criteria.

5.2. Summary - Management Needs

5.2.2 - Summary - Management Needs 4.6 Education, Information and Awareness Building Actions Timeframe Lead agency (and others More info / comment involved) 4.6.3 There is a Develop and implement policies, Ongoing See 1.5 and 1.6 N/A limited plans and strategies for formal and education and informal education provision. awareness programme 4.8 Monitoring

Page 16 Monday, May 19, 2014 (12:41:04 PM CEST) Periodic Report - Section II-Frontiers of the Roman Empire World Heritage Centre Periodic Report - Second Cycle Section II-Frontiers of the Roman Empire

4.8.2 Key indicators As part of management plan Phased delivery to be completed in See 1.5 and 1.6 N/A have not been iterations across the FRE, key and 2016. defined joint monitoring indicators will be developed.

Page 17 Monday, May 19, 2014 (12:41:04 PM CEST) Periodic Report - Section II-Frontiers of the Roman Empire World Heritage Centre Periodic Report - Second Cycle Section II-Frontiers of the Roman Empire

6.5 - Please provide suggestions for improvement of the 5.3. Conclusions on the State of Conservation of Periodic Reporting questionnaire the Property This form was difficult for a Transnational serial WHS to answer

5.3.1 - Current state of Authenticity 6.6 - Please rate the level of support for completing the The authenticity of the World Heritage property has been Periodic Report questionnaire from the following entities preserved UNESCO Very poor State Party Representative Good 5.3.2 - Current state of Integrity Advisory Body Very poor The integrity of the World Heritage property is intact

6.7 - How accessible was the information required to 5.3.3 - Current state of the World Heritage property’s complete the Periodic Report? Outstanding Universal Value Most of the required information was accessible The World Heritage property’s Outstanding Universal Value has been maintained. 6.8 - The Periodic Reporting process has improved the understanding of the following 5.3.4 - Current state of the property's other values Monitoring and reporting Other important cultural and / or natural values and the state of conservation of the World Heritage property are Management effectiveness predominantly intact 6.9 - Please rate the follow-up to conclusions and 5.4. Additional comments on the State of recommendations from previous Periodic Reporting Conservation of the Property exercise by the following entities UNESCO Not Applicable State Party Not Applicable 5.4.1 - Comments Site Managers Not Applicable Advisory Bodies Not Applicable 6. World Heritage Status and Conclusions on Periodic Reporting Exercise 6.10 - Summary of actions that will require formal consideration by the World Heritage Committee 6.1 - Please rate the impacts of World Heritage status of  Statement of Outstanding Universal Value / the property in relation to the following areas Statement of Significance Conservation Positive Reason for update: The Intergovernmental Research and monitoring Very positive Committee has proposed a draft SOUV to UNESCO Management effectiveness Positive and this is under discussion. Quality of life for local communities and indigenous Positive  Geographic Information Table peoples Reason for update: we will be submitting separately Recognition Positive revised maps and numbering for the other two Education Positive components of the property; this is a technical Infrastructure development Positive clarification of the numbering of the property it is not Funding for the property Positive an alteration of the boundaries International cooperation Very positive  Map(s) Reason for update: We are submitting separately Political support for conservation Positive more detailed maps of the German Limes; please Legal / Policy framework Positive note this is only a clarification, there are no changes Lobbying Positive to the boundaries of the World Heritage property and Institutional coordination Positive that these maps replace those of 29/01/04. Security Not applicable Other (please specify) Not applicable 6.11 - Comments, conclusions and / or recommendations related to the Assessment of the Periodic Reporting 6.2 - Comments, conclusions and / or recommendations exercise related to World Heritage status

6.3 - Entities involved in the preparation of this Section of the Periodic Report Governmental institution responsible for the property Site Manager/Coordinator/World Heritage property staff

6.4 - Was the Periodic Reporting questionnaire easy to use and clearly understandable? no

Page 18 Monday, May 19, 2014 (12:41:04 PM CEST) Periodic Report - Section II-Frontiers of the Roman Empire World Heritage Centre