Consultation Response Form Please Use This Form to Respond Or Make Representations on Local Plan Part II and Associated Consultation Documents
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Mendip Local Plan Part II: Sites & Policies – Pre-Submission Consultation Consultation Response Form Please use this form to respond or make representations on Local Plan Part II and associated consultation documents. For information or advice, please contact the Planning Policy Team by email at [email protected] or phone (0300) 303 8588. Contact Details If you have appointed somebody to act as your agent, please give their contact details. All correspondence will be sent to the agent Name: Mr and Mrs Gilburt Agent Name: Mark Reynolds Organisation (if applicable): Company Name: N/A Date completed 9/2/18 Date completed 9/2/18 Do you wish to be notified of future stages of Local Plan Part II (tick box) x x We will contact you by e-mail only unless you confirm here (tick box) Data protection – please read - The information collected as part this consultation will be processed by the Council in accordance with the Data Protection Act 1998. The purposes for collecting this data are: to assist in plan making; and to contact you, if necessary, regarding the planning consultation process. Please note that representations must be attributable to named individuals or organisations at a postal address. Representations and contact names will be published on the Mendip website but no other personal information Copies of this form are available from Council Offices and Access Points or can be downloaded from www.mendip.gov.uk/localplanpart2 . If you require this document in another format such as Braille, large print or another language then please contact us. Please use a separate form for each site or main issue you wish to make. You can also attach one contact form to a group of representations. Please make sure any separate documents include your name –so they can be clearly identified. Please return your response by 5pm Monday 12th February 2018. By post to: Planning Policy, Mendip District Council, Cannards Grave Road, Shepton Mallet, Somerset, BA4 5BT By email to: [email protected] By hand to: The Council offices in Shepton Mallet (address above). Mendip Local Plan Part II: Sites & Policies - Issues and Options Consultation For office use Details of Objection/ Comment./Representation Name /Organisation: Mark Reynolds Please indicate the document to which your representation relates (e.g. policy, paragraph Local green space designation: LGSFRO005 number, HELAA site reference ) Do you consider the Local Plan is Legally Do you consider the Local Plan is Sound 1 ? Compliant? 1 Yes No Yes No x x Do you consider it necessary to participate at examination hearings? (eg present oral Yes evidence) Please provide details below of why you consider the Local Plan is not legally compliant or is unsound. Please be as precise as possible. If you wish to support the legal compliance and soundness of the plan, please also use this box to set out your comments. 1 See our Online Guidance note on what these terms mean 2 Mendip Local Plan Part II: Sites & Policies - Issues and Options Consultation See attached statement For office use Details of Objection/ Comment./Representation Name /Organisation Please indicate the document to which your representation relates (e.g. policy, paragraph number, HELAA site reference ) Do you consider the Local Plan is Legally Do you consider the Local Plan is Sound 1 ? Compliant ? 2 Yes No Yes No Do you consider it necessary to participate at examination hearings ? (eg present oral Yes/No evidence) 2 See our Online Guidance note on what these terms mean 3 Mendip Local Plan Part II Pre-submission Consultation Local Green Space Landowner Response Form If you are the landowner of a nominated Local Green Space and wish to support or object to this nomination, please use this form to outline your reasons. An electronic version of this form is available at www.mendip.gov.uk/Localplanpart2. If you wish to comment on any other aspect of the Local Plan Part II then please participate in the public consultation on the pre-submission draft of the plan commencing 2nd January 2018. Details of the consultation and how to respond can be found on the website www.mendip.gov.uk/Localplanpart2. Please return completed forms by 5pm Monday 12th February 2018. By e-mail: [email protected] By post: Mendip District Council, Council Offices, Cannards Grave Road, Shepton Mallet, Somerset,BA4 5BT If you have any queries then please contact a Member of the Planning Policy Team on [email protected] or 0300 303 8588. Name / Mr and Mrs Gilburt (C/O Mark Reynolds) organisation: Address: Phone number: Email address: Mark Reynolds (Agent) Data protection The information collected as part this consultation will be processed by the Council in accordance with the Data Protection Act 1998. The purposes for collecting this data are: to assist in plan making; and to contact you, if necessary, regarding the planning consultation process. Please note that representations must be attributable to named individuals or organisations at a postal address. Any representation received will be published on the Council’s Website, including the respondent’s name, as it will form part of the evidence base used to inform the development of the Local Plan Part II and submitted as part of the Plan’s public examination. Name and code of nominated space: LGSFRO005 Ownership of Local Green Space (Please indicate if you or your organisation are the Mr and Mrs Gilburt landowner/leaseholder): Are you in support of or objecting to the Objecting to the designation proposals to designate this land? If you are objecting to the proposals to designate your land, what are your reasons? See attached statement If you have any queries then please contact a Member of the Planning Policy Team on [email protected] or 0300 303 8588. Representation to Mendip Local Plan Part II: Sites and Policies Pre-submission Plan For: Mr and Mrs Gilburt By: Mark Reynolds BSc (Hons) MSc MRTPI 1. RELEVANT POLICY TO WHICH THIS REPRESENTATION RELATES 1.1 This objection relates to the proposed designation of my Client’s land referred to as site LGSFRO005 – Meadows alongside the River Frome on the south side as a Local Green Space (LGS) (Fig 1). This representation challenges this designation but it also questions the validity of the policy approach as a whole. 1.2 The following sections of the representation outline the reasons for the objection to the proposed designation as a LGS. Fig 1 – Map showing the extent of Rodden Meadows (south) and surrounding context 2. THE PLANNING HISTORY OF THE RODDEN MEADOWS (SOUTH) SITE 2.1 Site LGSFRO005 did until 2015 form part of the Council’s housing land supply for the settlement of Frome. Mendip District Council’s (MDC) Housing Trajectory – 1st April 2014 included the site within the 5 year supply period from 2018/19 onwards for Frome (Fig 2). The site is known in this document as FRO 148 Garston Farm (urban greenfield). The Housing Trajectory is a key evidence base which supports the housing land supply. The full document can be found at Appendix 1. 2.2 The housing trajectory identified the site as being required to deliver 20 dwellings. 10 in 2022 and a further 10 in 2023. The Housing Trajectory forms a critical part of the final evidence base for housing land supply. It is Stage 5 in the production of the Housing and Economic Land Availability Assessment (HELAA). The site formed part of the Housing Trajectory which was published following the introduction of guidance in the NPPG on HELAA production. Fig 2 – Extract from MDC Housing Trajectory – 1st April 2014 2.3 The earlier stages of production of the HELAA include a broad identification of locations and sites at stage 1. This assessment records any physical constraints as well as any potential environmental constraints and an initial assessment of whether the site is suitable for a particular use (in this case residential) is undertaken. Stage 2 involves calculating the development potential of the site. This, the NPPG guides, should take into account the individual site characteristics and physical constraints. Stage 2 clearly advises that the potential impact including the effect upon landscape features, nature and heritage conservation will be taken into account in terms of considering the suitability of sites. Stage 4 of the process involves a full review of the sites to yield an indicative trajectory and Stage 5 requires the publication of the findings. 2.4 The key point to note is that in the case of my Client’s land for the site to be included within the housing trajectory it must have been put through the robust process outlined above in terms of testing constraints and opportunities. Only upon passing these tests could the land be included within the trajectory. The site was part of the conservation area for Frome and also an OALS at the time when the site was included within the trajectory. 2.5 The Council must therefore have concluded that the allocation of the site for 20 dwellings would be compliant with the terms of Local Plan Part 1 Policy DP2: Open Areas of Local Significance (OALS). This policy advises that ‘permission will not be granted for development which would harm the contribution to distinctive local character made by OALS’. The OALS covers a larger area than that which was proposed for development and with additional landscaping measures the conclusion that the site could be developed to an extent is supported. 2.6 Likewise at the point at which the land was put forward within the SHLAA for development the site itself had become part of the Frome Conservation Area.