Forensic Science Journal FORENSIC SCIENCE 2020;19(1):1-8 JOURNAL SINCE 2002 fsjournal.cpu.edu.tw DOI:10.6593/FSJ.202012_19(1).0001

Complex Fauna Found on Carcass in A Suicide Case in Taiwan

Wei-Lun Yan 1,2, M.S. ; Qi-Ren Chen 1, M.S. ; Chiou-Herr Yang 1*, Ph.D.

1 Department of Forensic Science, Central Police University, 56 Shuren Road, Guishan, Taoyuan, Taiwan 2 Forensic Science center, Taoyuan Police Department, 3 Xianfu Road, Taoyuan, Taoyuan, Taiwan

Received: September 21, 2020; Accepted: November 30, 2020.

Abstract

A male corpse was found in a park, located in an urban residential area in Taiwan. The insect data collected from this remain shows that there was an unusual insect fauna on the corpse for an outdoor case. There were three features for the entomology study in this forensic case. First, the fauna of the collected was more diverse than in other cases. Chrysomya rufifacies (Macquart, 1842), (Van Der Wulp, 1883), Chrysomya megacephala (Fabricius, 1794), Sarcophaga dux (Thomson, 1869) and pusio (Wiedemann, 1830) were found on the corpse. The dominant was S. nudiseta which is usually found on indoor human corpse. It was the first case of larvae of S. nudiseta and F. pusio found on outdoor human remains in Taiwan. Second, the Minimum Post-Mortem Interval (minPMI) was estimated to be about 10-14 days base on the develop- mental data of three species of , including S. nudiseta (pupae), C. megacephala (), S. dux (pupae). Third, fly artifacts were found on the body and clothes, and those tiny spots were thought to be blood splatter patterns, which puzzled the investigators and so they were not sure whther it was a suicide case. After careful examination, these spots were identified to be fly artifacts and thus solved the confusing. Distinguishing between fly artifacts and bloodstain patterns is important for the crime scene inves- tigation. It excluded the wrong information from the bloodstain-like spot (fly artifacts), allowing more attention on other evidence analysis

Keywords: forensic entomology, complex insect fauna, synthesiomyia nudiseta, fannia pusio, post-mortem interval (PMI), fly artifacts

Introduction The Calliphoridae family is known as an important forensic fly family in outdoor areas, especially for Chry- Forensic entomology has been applied to crime scene somya rufifacies (Macquart, 1842) and Chrysomya investigations, such as the time or season of death, and megacephala (Fabricius, 1794). They are usually the location of remains. Before using insect information, collected from human corpses found in suburban areas it is important to know the behaviors or life cycles of and outdoors [2-4]. They are important forensic flies in insects. Environment and human activities also influence Taiwan and have been used to estimate the time of death the colonization behavior of insects on corpses. Some in forensic cases [5]. The and Sarcophagidae species of flies can be found on both indoor and outdoor families are the common fly families found on human corpses, but some can only be found on indoor or corpses in indoor scenes and urban areas, and they usu- outdoor corpses [1-3]. ally feed on trash or leftovers of human [2,6,7]. Sarco-

*Corresponding author: Chiou-Herr Yang, Department of Forensic Science, Central Police University, No.56, Shuren Rd., Guishan Dist., Taoyuan City 333322, Taiwan (R.O.C.) Fax: 886-3-3275907 E-mail: [email protected] 2 Forensic Science Journal 2020; 19(1)

phaga dux (Thomson, 1869) is reported as an important classified as a standard 9mm cartridge case, and it was species in forensic entomology on human corpses [8]. confirmed to be fired from the pistol by comparing the Synthesiomyia nudiseta (van der Wulp, 1883) is the marks of the bottom. The warhead did not have enough only species under the Synthesiomyia (Diptera: marks for comparison. The GSR collected from the Muscidae). Some reports show that S. nudiseta is highly muzzle, rifle bolt, and the right hand of the victim was eusynanthropic and has a strong preference for dense analyzed by energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy. The human settlements, especial in urban areas [7,9]. The results showed that the GSR contained metal elements, larvae of S. nudiseta are always found indoors in human including lead (Pb), antimony (Sb) and barium (Ba). The corpses [2-4,10-14], except for one outdoor case found in same ingredients were detected from the cartridge case. Spain [14]. From those results, we speculated that the victim might This paper provides the information of complex have held the gun with his right hand to shoot himself insect fauna on the corpse in an outdoor suicide case in closely. Taiwan, which is more diverse than that of other cases. The corpse was in the initial decay period. Two The insect data collected from the remains can be used wounds were found on his head. The entrance of the for the estimation of the reasonable min-PMI and the gunshot wound was in the eyebrows and its exit was in speculation on the environment of death. the hindbrain. The warhead was found in the exit wound between the T-shirt and the head. According to the anat- Case History omy, the deceased got one shot closely by the pistol and the bullet went through from his forehead to hindbrain. In November 2017, a young male corpse was found in a park located in an urban residential area in Taoyuan, Method and Material Taiwan. The corpse was laying on the floor next to the wall of the public toilets near the corner of the park (Fig. The ambient temperature data was obtained from 1). It is an open-air space that few people notice. The the closest meteorological station in Taoyuan about 3.8 corpse was fully clothed, the head was covered with a kilometers away from the scene. The average temper- T-shirt, the body was covered with a carpet, and his legs ature during the two weeks before the case found was o o were covered with a plastic bag. A pistol was held by his 22 C [15]. In this study, 22 C is used to estimate the right hand with his thumb touching the trigger. The slide insect development time. Numerous dead blowflies were found on the right of the pistol was held back and there were two bullets on elbow inside the skin (Fig. 2). It is reasonable to believe a magazine. that dead blowflies were from the first wave of larval eclosion. The live specimens were collected randomly from the corpse by the investigators with tweezers and then killed by boiled water after back to the office. The specimens were preserved with 70% ethanol in glass bottles. There were a total of 54 specimens collected in this case.

Fig. 1 The position of the corpse at the scene (next to a public toilet).

After investigation, the corpse was soon identified through fingerprint comparison. A cartridge case was found on the ground under bushes not far from the corpse. The T-shirt that covered the head was completely undamaged. The pistol was determined to be a converted Fig. 2 Numerous dead blowflies were found on the right replica gun and it worked well. The cartridge case was elbow inside the skin of the corpse. Fauna Found on Carcass 3

The morphological examination was carried out between overlapping sequence data. The length of two with a stereomicroscope (M165C, Leica, Japan) according PCR DNA fragments was 1200 and 658 bp respectively. to the key of insect identification reported by Sukon- The COI sequences obtained were then used to compare tason et al. [16] and Velásquez et al. [17] Those speci- with the Diptera sequences from the National Center mens were separated into seven parts (Table 1). One for Biotechnology Information (NCBI) database by specimen was randomly chosen from each part for DNA Nucleotide Basic Local Alignment Search Tool (BLA identification. One millimeter of the center part of each STN) function for species identification. larva and pupa was taken and put into the Master Mix as the template for PCR amplification. A region of Results and Discussion mitochondrial cytochrome oxidase c subunit I (COI) gene was amplified using primers C1-J-1718 (5’-GG A total of five insect species were identified thro- AGGATTTGGAAATTGATTAGTTCC-3’) and ugh morphology and molecular biology. They were C. TL2-N-3014 (5’-TCCAATGCACTAATCTGCCATA rufifacies, S. nudiseta, C. megacephala, S. dux and F. TTA-3’) [18]. The other primers were LCO1490 (5’- pusio. The dominant species in the corpse was S. nudiseta. GGTCAACAAATCATAAAGATATTGG-3’) and The stage and number of the collected insects are shown HCO2198 (5’-TAAACTTCAGGGTGACCAAAAAAT in Table 1. CA-3’) [19]. The respective sites of two primer sets in C. megacephala and C. rufifacies are known as the the position of the DNA fragment were shown in Fig. 3 indicated forensic fly species for PMI estimation. They [20]. First primer set (C1-J-1718 and TL2-N-3014) was are usually the first colonizers in the body without much used to amplify DNA for species identification and found delay after the death of an . Based on the data of that it could not identify all species, so the second primer Yang et al. [22], it takes 157-179 hours (6-7 days) from set (LCO1490 and HCO2198) was added to identify F. egg hatching to pupariation and 299-322 hours (12-13 pusio and to reconfirm the identification results that were days) from egg hatching to eclosion for C. megacephala done by first primer set. at 22oC. Since dead blowflies were observed under the skin, which indicates that the second generation flies were eclosed, the reasonable minPMI value would be 12- 13 days. Based on the data of Al-Misned, the developmental time of S. dux from egg to pupariation is approximately 9-12 days at 22℃, which is preliminary estimated by the interpolation of the data of 20℃ (8-11 days) and 24℃ Fig. 3 The sites of both primer sets in the map of the COI (10-13 days) [23]. However, according to our simulation gene region. experiment, putting pork on a balcony in an urban residential area has a delay about 2 days, therefore the The Thermo Scientific Phire Tissue Direct PCR Mas- min-PMI should be 11-14 days with the delay of S. dux ter Mix (Thermo Fisher Scientific) kit was used for PCR considered. reaction and the samples were put into the solution with- The developmental time of S. nudiseta from egg out DNA extraction according to the manufacturer’s hatching to pupariation is 8-10 days according to the Iso- instructions. Automated DNA sequencing was perfor- morphen-diagram of Velásquez et al. [14] regardless of med on an ABI 3100 sequencer with the ABI PrismTM the delay in arrival time. Unfortunately, we do not have BigDyeTM Terminator Cycle Sequencing Ready Re- the data of the delay time of S. nudiseta. It was reported action Kit version 3.1 (Applied Biosystems, Foster City, as a later colonizer [24] and noticed to have similar CA, USA) according to the manufacturer’s recom- behavior to that of flesh flies [7], so the delay time should mendations for both forward and reverse DNA strands. be considered. We estimate that the minPMI of the case The DNA sequence chromatograms were edited using should be about 10-12 days if two days delay was added. BioEdit v7.2.5 [21] and ContigExpress in the Vector Two days’ delay time was assumed by observation that NTI Advance v10.3 (Invitrogen, USA) to remove the the behavior of S. nudiseta is similar to that of flesh flies. sequences of primers and to eliminate discrepancies 4 Forensic Science Journal 2020; 19(1)

Table 1 The insect samples collected from the corpse and its species identified by DNA sequencing.

Species Stage Number Length (mm) Query cover Identity (a*) Accession No. 99% JN228998.1 3rd (1197/1200) C. rufifacies 8 14-16 100% Larva 100% KY001858.1 (658/658)

100% KT272865.1 3rd (1200/1200) 4 13-14 100% Larva 100% MF695706.1 (658/658) C. megacephala 99% KT272865.1 (1199/1200) Pupa 2 9 100% 99% MF695706.1 (657/658)

100% EU627713.1 3rd (1200/1200) 29 13-16 100% Larva 100% MF695706.1 (658/658) S. nudiseta 99% EU627713.1 (1199/1200) Pupa 2 7 100% 100% KY001858.1 (658/658)

100% EF405938.1 (1200/1200) S. dux Pupa 4 8-10 100% 100% EF405938.1 (658/658)

no match no match F. pusio Pupa 5 4-6 100% 100% KY511215.1 (658/658) a*: The COI sequences obtained were used to compare with the Diptera sequences from National Center for Biotechnology Information (NCBI) database by Nucleotide Basic Local Alignment Search Tool (BLASTN) function for species identification.

Overall, based on the data of insect developmental The developmental time of C. megacephala is usu- time of S. nudiseta (pupae), C. megacephala (flies), andS. ally relatively accurate in the PMI estimation in the early dux (pupae), we concluded that the reasonable minPMI stage of outdoor decay, since they are usually the first was approximately 10-14 days. The PMI estimated by colonizers in the body without much delay after the death the police investigation is less than two weeks, probably of an animal. On the other hand, the families of Muscidae in the range of 10-11 days, which is close to this ento- and Sarcophagidae are indicator species of PMI in urban mology data. or indoor cases. Since a complex insect fauna was found Fauna Found on Carcass 5

on this corpse, we could combine the data of S. nudiseta shrubs. The body was in the initial decay period, which (pupae), C. megacephala (flies) and S. dux (pupae) for was similar to this case [25]. F. pusio might be a use- double miniPMI checking. The results show that they are ful species for forensic entomology in early death inves- close. tigation. The habits and developmental time of F. pusio From the insect dada collected, we speculat that C. need further study. megacephala family was the first colonizer to reach the In this case, many tiny spots were found on the corpse in the fresh period after the death of the deceased. body and clothes (Fig. 4). These spots were thought to be About two days later, S. nudiseta and S. dux came to the blood splatter patterns in the beginning of investigation. covered part of the corpse and gradually replaced the It is unreasonable to detect blood splatters on the blowfly, becoming the dominant species in the decay opposite side of the right hand, which was supposed to period. There were a total of five species collected in hold the gun to shoot himself. Therefore, it was difficult this study, which is much more complex than the usual for us to conclude that it was a suicide case in the early outdoor case [2,3]. The insect samples collected from stage of investigation. Further inspection revealed that the corpse showed that it had both indoor and outdoor most of these spots were within 3mm in diameter. Some as well as urban and suburban environments. It might be of the colors were light brown, which is different from because the corpse was located in both urban (residential the color of dried blood. It was found that the shapes area) and suburban (park) environments and was open- of spots to be round, irregular or tadpole-like. It lacked air and close to a building. Both indoor and outdoor directionality and seemed to be randomly distributed, so insects were attracted to the human remains. it was diffi-cult to reconstruct the source of blood [26]. S. nudiseta is known to be related to the human living After care-fully examination, these spots were confirmed environment, so S. nudiseta is considered an indicator to be fly artifacts, which might be formed by fly feces and species in indoor cases. However, the park is located regurgitation deposits. The spattered bloodstains caused in an urban residential area. In addition, the corpse was by gunshots usually have directionality and concen- covered by virous objects to form a closed environment, trated misty. To distinguish between the fly artifacts which attracted adult S. nudiseta flies to lay eggs on and bloodstain patterns is important for crime scene the corpse. Velásquez et al. [14] reported a case that the investigators, who could exclude the false information larvae of S. nudiseta appeared in an outdoor case. In from blood-like staining (fly artifacts) and collect the that case, the victim was wrapped in a blanket, and the real bloodstain patterns for analysis [27]. The fly artifacts environment was similar to our case. This report provides have shown widely different type of shapes, size and the first example of the larvae of S. nudiseta found on color depend on the fly species, diet and surfaces. It is not outside human corpses in Taiwan. From this result, we easily to be distinguished only depend on the pattern of concluded that the larvae of S. nudiseta might be found single spot [28]. The more factors should be considered, indoors or on corpses that are wrapped . like reasonable source of blood, the distribution of spots The life cycle of C. megacephala is shorter than and insect activities in the scene. Crime scene inves- S. dux and S. nudiseta. If C. megacephala have been tigators might observe blood spatters and/or fly artifacts emergence in the scene, it is difficult to predict the time at the crime scene, so distinguishing between fly artif- of death of the corpse. By using life cycle of S. dux and acts and bloodstain patterns is important. It would S. nudiseta, we could predict the time of death more prevent spending too much works on the false splattered accurately when the PMI is longer. With the development bloodstain analysis. of urbanization and human life, the application of S. nudiseta and S. dux in forensic ento-mology will become more and more important in the future. Besides, it is the first report for F. pusio found in human corpses in Taiwan. F. pusio was found in a suicide case in Brazil as well. The corpse was partially hanged on a tree in 6 Forensic Science Journal 2020; 19(1)

4a 4b

4c 4d

Fig. 4 The fly artifacts found on the right hand (4a, 4b) and on the T-shirt that covered the head (4c, 4d).

Conclusions References

There were three features in the entomological 1. Goff M-L. Comparison of insect species associated study for this forensic case. First, the fauna of insect with decomposing remains recovered inside dwel- collected from the outdoor corpse was more diverse than lings and outdoors on the island of Oahu, Hawaii. J in other cases. Second, we combined the developmental Forensic Sci 1991; 36:748-53. data of three insects, including S. nudiseta (pupae), C. 2. Kumara T-K, Disney R-HL, Abu Hassan A, Flores M, megacephala (flies), and S. dux (pupae) to estimate Tan S-H, Mohamed Z, CheSalmah M-R, Bhupinder mini-PMI. Third, fly artifacts were found on the body S. Occurrence of oriental flies associated with indoor and clothes. Those tiny spots were initially thought to and outdoor human remains in the tropical climate of be blood splatter patterns. However, after careful exa- north Malaysia. J Vector Ecol 2012; 37:62-8. mination, these spots were identified to be fly artifacts, 3. Syamsa R-A, Omar B, Ahmad F-M, Hidayatulfathi O, and the false information was excluded from blood-like Shahrom A-W. Comparative fly species composition staining. on indoor and outdoor forensic cases in Malaysia. J Forensic Leg Med 2017; 45:41-6. Acknowledgements 4. Sukontason K, Narongchai P, Kanchai C, Vichairat K, Sribanditmongkol P, et al. Forensic entomology cases The authors are very grateful to the Forensic Scie- in Thailand: a review of cases from 2000 to 2006. nce Center, Taoyuan Police Department and Criminal Parasitol Res 2007; 101:1417-23. Investigation Bureau for their assistance in the cases 5. Pai C-Y, Jien M-C, Li L-H, Cheng Y-Y, Yang C-H. Ap- study. The authors would also like to extend the gratitude plication of Forensic Entomology to Postmortem In- to Dr. Hsien-Hui Meng for his opinions on firearms and terval Determination of a Burned Human Corpse: GSR examinations. Fauna Found on Carcass 7

A Homicide Case Report from Southern Taiwan. J 16. Sukontason K, Sukontason K-L, Ngern-klun R, Formos Med Assoc 2007; 106(9):792-8. Sripakdee D. Differentiation of the third instar of 6. Ren L-P, Deng H-X, Dong S-Z, Li J-B. Survey of in- forensically important fly species in Thailand. Ann door sarcosaphagous insects. Trop Biomed 2017; Entomol Soc Am 2004; 97:1069-75. 34:284-94. 17. Velásquez Y, Magaña C, Martínez-Sánchez A, Rojo 7. Byrd JH, Castner JL. Insects of Forensic Importance. S. Diptera of forensic importance in the Iberian In: Byrd JH, Castner JL, editors. Forensic Ento- Peninsula: larval identification key. Med Vet Entomol mology: The Utility of in Legal Inve- 2010; 24:293-308. stigations. 2nd ed. Florida: CRC press, 2010; 39-126. 18. Simon C, Frati F, Beckenbach A, Crespi B, Liu H, 8. Zuha R-M, Baba M-H. Sarcophaga dux Thomson Flook P. Evolution, weighting, and phylogenetic ut- (Diptera: Sarcophagidae) recovered from wrapped ility of mitochondrial gene-sequences and a comp- body of an infant: its evidential value. Serangga ilation of conserved polymerase chain-reaction pri- 2016; 21(2):163-70. mers. Ann Entomol Soc Am 1994; 87:651-701. 9. Uribe M-N, Wolff M, Carvalho CJ-B. Synanthropy 19. Folmer O, Black M, Hoeh W, Lutz R, Vrijenhoek and ecological aspects of Muscidae (Diptera) in a R. DNA primers for amplification of mitochondrial tropical dry forest ecosystem in Colombia. Rev Bras cytochrome c oxidase subunit I fromdiversemetazoan Entomol 2010; 54:462-70. invertebrates. Mol Mar Biol Biotechnol 1994; 3(5): 10. Kavitha R, Nazni W-A, Tan T-C, Lee H-L, Azirun 294-9. M-S. Review of forensically important entomological 20. Gibson J-F, Kelso S, Jackson M-D, Kits J-H, Miranda specimens collected from human cadavers in G-F-G, Skevington J-H. Diptera-Specific Polymerase Malaysia (2005-2010). J Forensic Legal Med 2013; Chain Reaction Amplification Primers of Use in 20:480-2. Molecular Phylogenetic Research. Ann. Entomol. 11. Farrell J-F, Whittington A-E, Zalucki M-P. A review Soc. Am 2011; 104(5):976-97. of necrophagous insects colonising human and an- 21. Hall T-A. BioEdit: A user-friendly biological sequ- imal cadavers in south-east Queensland, Australia. ence alignment editor and analysis program for Win- Forensic Sci Int 2015; 257:149-54. dows 95/98/NT. Nucleic Acids Symposium Series 12. Pimsler M-L, Owings C-G, Sanford M-R, OConnor 1999; 41:95-8. B-M, Teel P-D, Mohr R-M, Tomberlin J-K. Ass- 22. Yang Y-Q, Li X-B, Shao R-Y, Lyu Z, Li H-W, Li G-P, ociation of Myianoetus muscarum (Acari: Hist- Xu L-Z, Wan L-H. Developmental times of Chry- iostomatidae) with Synthesiomyia nudiseta (Wulp) somya megacephala (Fabricius) (Diptera: Call- (Diptera: Muscidae) on human remains, J Med iphoridae) at constant temperatures and applications Entomol 2016; 53:290-5. in forensic entomology. J Forensic Sci 2016; 61:1278 13. Lo Pinto S, Giordani G, Tuccia F, Ventura F, Vanin -84. S. First records of Synthesiomyia nudiseta (Diptera: 23. Al-Misned FAM. Effect of temperature on deve- Muscidae) from forensic cases in Italy. Forensic Sci lopment and mortality of immature Sarcophaga (Lio- Int 2017; 276:e1-7. sarcophaga) dux Thomson (Diptera: Sarcophagidae). 14. Velásquez Y, Ivorra T, Grzywacz A, Martinez-San- J King Saudi Univ Agri Sci 2004; 16:53-60. chez A. Larval morphology, development and fore- 24. Tantawi T-I, El-Kady E-M, Geeenberg B, El-Ghaffar nsic importance of Synthesiomyia nudiseta (Dip- H-A. succession on exposed rabbit carr- tera: Muscidae) in Europe: a rare species or just ion in Alexandria, Egypt. J Med Entomol 1996; overlooked? Bull Entomol Res 2013; 103:98-110. 33(4):566-80. 15. Central Weather Bureau Observation Data Inquire 25. Vasconcelos S-D, Costa D-L, Oliveira D-L. Ento- System. Central Weather Bureau, Taipei, Taiwan, mological evidence in a case of a suicide victim by ROC. http://e-service.cwb.gov.tw/HistoryDataQuery/ hanging: first collaboration between entomologists index.jsp. (Accessed 4 May 2018) and forensic police in north-eastern Brazil. Aust J 8 Forensic Science Journal 2020; 19(1)

Forensic Sci 2019; 51(2):231-9. 26. Durdle A, van Oorschot RA-H, Mitchell R-J. The morphology of fecal and regurgitation artifacts deposited by the blow fly Lucilia cuprina fed a diet of human blood. J Forensic Sci 2013; 58:897-903. 27. Benecke M, Barksdale L. Distinction of bloodstain patterns from fly artifacts. Forensic Sci Int 2003; 137:152-9. 28. River D-B, McGregor A. Morphological Features of Regurgitate and Defecatory Stains Deposited by Five Species of Necrophagous Flies are Influenced by Adult Diets and Body Size. J Forensic Sci 2017; 63(1):154-61.