This Front Matter is brought to you for free and open access by the Student Journals at Case Western Reserve University School of Law Scholarly Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Canada-United States Law Journal by an authorized administrator of Case Western Reserve University School of Law Scholarly Commons. Canada- United States Law Journal

VOLUME 10 1985

PROCEEDINGS OF THE CANADA-UNITED STATES LAW INSTITUTE CONFERENCE

THE LEGAL ASPECTS OF SECTORAL INTEGRATION BETWEEN THE UNITED STATES AND CANADA

Cleveland, Ohio April 19-21, 1985

List of Conference Participants ...... i Preface Professor Henry T King, Jr ...... iii Introduction Professor Sidney Picker, Jr ...... vii Introduction and Conference Opening Professor Henry T. King, Jr ...... An Overview of the Prospects for Sectoral Integration: The View From Canada The Honorable Donald S. Macdonald ...... 3 An Overview of the Prospects for Sectoral Integration: The View from The United States William S. M erkin ...... 13 Discussion Following the Remarks of The Honorable Donald S. Macdonald and Mr. Merkin . 19 Canada-U.S. Trade Options: A View from the Canadian Side W. A. Dymond ...... 27 Reducing Barriers to Trade in Nontraded Goods and Services Fred Thompson ...... 35 Discussion Following the Remarks of Mr. Dymond and Professor Thompson ...... 51 The Relevance of the EEC Experience to Additional Prospective Sectoral Integration Between Canada and the United States H ans Sm it ...... 53 Discussion Following the Remarks of Professor Smit ...... 61 The Relevance of the AutoPact to Other Sectoral Arrangements Philip H. Trezise ...... 63 The Relevance of the AutoPact for Other Sectoral Arrangements Simon S. Reisman ...... 75 Discussion Following the Remarks of Mr. Trezise and Mr. Reisman ...... 85 The Case Against United States-Canada Free Trade M el Watkins ...... 89 Discussion Following the Remarks of Professor Watkins ...... 97 External U.S. Commitments Affecting Possible Additional Products for Sectoral Integration (paper) Donald . deKieffer ...... 101 External U.S. Commitments Affecting Possible Additional Products for Sectoral Integration (remarks) Donald E. deKieffer ...... 107 The Framework and Process of Canada-United States Trade Liberalization (paper) Frank Stone ...... 111 External Commitments of Canada Affecting Possible Additional Sectoral Integration (remarks) Frank Stone ...... 119 Discussion Following the Remarks of Mr. deKieffer and Mr. Stone ...... 127 Macroeconomic Perspectives of Canada-U.S. Trade Agreements Carl Beigie ...... 131 Discussion Following the Remarks of M r. Beigie ...... 137 The Impact of U.S. Federal Laws on Sectoral Integration Peter 0. Suchman ...... 141 Trade Laws: A Canadian Perspective Robert E. Latimer ...... 157 Discussion Following the Remarks of Mr. Suchman and Mr. Latimer ...... 165 The Role of State and Provincial Governments in Canada-U.S. Sectoral Integration (paper) Earl H. Fry ...... 169 The Role of Subnational Governments in Sectoral Integration (remarks) Earl H. Fry ...... 189 Federalism and Foreign Economic Relations John Quinn ...... 197 Discussion Following the Remarks of Professor Fry and Professor Quinn ...... 221 The Case for a U.S.-Canada Free Trade Agreement (paper) Alan Win. Wolff ...... 225 Observations on the Implementation of a U.S.-Canadian Free Trade Agreement (remarks) Alan Wm. Wolff ...... 235 Implementation of Sectoral Integration Frank Stone ...... 245 Discussion Following the Remarks of Mr. Wolff and Mr. Stone ...... 251 Closing Remarks and Discussion ProfessorHenry T. King, Jr ...... 255

Speakers and Participants

at the Canada-United States Law Institute Conference on

The Legal Aspects of Sectoral Integration Between the United States and Canada

Clive Allen Northern Telecom Mississauga, Ontario John Armstrong Dofasco, Inc. Hamilton, Ontario Shelly Battram Reynolds, Beeby, Magnuson, Kenney, Fora & Grubba Detroit, MI Carl Beigie Dominion Securities Pitfield, Ltd. Toronto, Ontario Dorinda Dallmeyer Univ. of Georgia Law School Athens, GA Donald deKieffer Pillsbury, Madison & Sutro Washington, D.C. L. H. Diggs Royal Bank of Canada Ottawa, Ontario Jerome Doyle Canadian Council of Furniture Mfrs. Ottawa, Ontario William Dymond Dept. External Affairs Ottawa, Ontario William Enouen Mead Corp. Dayton, OH William Eppling American Institute of Steel Construction Washington, D.C. Prof. Asim Erdilek Dept. Economics Case Western Reserve Cleveland, OH Ivan Feltham Canadian General Electric Toronto, Ontario Jon Fried Dept. External Affairs Ottawa, Canada Prof. Earl Fry Brigham Young Univ. Provo, UT Dean Ernest Gellhorn Case Western Reserve School of Law Cleveland, OH Graham Gibb Canadian Chemical Producers Assoc. Ottawa, Ontario Marcus Gleisser Plain Dealer Cleveland, OH Prof. Win. C. Graham Univ. Toronto Law School Toronto, Ontario Richard Gwyn Toronto Star Ottawa, Ontario Dan Hall Firestone Tire & Rubber Akron, OH Sydney Harris Canadian Consulate Cleveland, OH Fred Harrison Financial Post Washington, D.C. JoAnn Heflernan Gowling & Henderson Ottawa, Ontario Prof. Robert Hudec Univ. Minnesota Law School Minneapolis, MN Raymond E. Hunziker General Electric Cleveland, OH Richard Kendon Novacor Chemicals, Ltd. Calgary, Alberta Keith Kennedy SOHIO Cleveland, OH Judd Kessler Porter, Wright, Morris & Arthur Washington, D.C. Kenneth Kumm 3M Corporation St. Paul, MN CANADA-UNITED STATES LAW JOURNAL [V/ol. 10:i 1985]

Prof. Henry T. King, Jr. Case Wastern Reserve School of Law Cleveland, OH Robert Latimer formerly Dept. External Affairs Ottawa, Ontario Prof. Virginia Leary Univ. of Buffalo (SUNY) Buffalo, NY Douglas Lewis Dept. Regional & Industrial Expansion Ottawa, Ontario Prof. Andreas F. Lowenfeld N.Y. University Law School New York, NY Stephen Lyons Borg Warner Corp. Parkersburg, WV Rosemary McCaney Kanchar International Toronto, Ontario Donald S. Macdonald McCarthy & McCarthy Toronto, Ontario David G. Meany Case Western Reserve School of Law Cleveland, OH William Merkin Office U.S. Trade Representative Washington, D.C. Roy C. Megargel General Tire International Akron, OH Prof. Sidney Picker, Jr. Case Western Reserve School of Law Cleveland, OH Beth Pritchard S.C. Johnson & Sons Racine, WI Prof. John Quinn Osgoode Hall Law School Downsview, Ontario Marke J. Raines Stikeman Elliott Toronto, Ontario Simon Reisman Reisman & Grandy Ottawa, Ontario Prof. Jack Roberts Univ. Western Ontario Law School London, Ontario Daniel Roseman Canadian Chamber of Commerce Ottawa, Ontario Jacques S. Roy Minister (Economics) Canadian Embassy Washington, D.C. Allen Sears Dow Chemical Canada Sarnia, Ontario Kurt Shaffrath Firestone Tire & Rubber Akron, OH David Sloan Attorney-at-Law Royal Oak, MI Prof. Hans Smit Columbia University School of Law New York, NY. Yvon Soucy Bombardier Montreal, Quebec Don Stanley U.S. Dept. Commerce Cleveland, OH Frank Stone Institute for Research on Public Policy Ottawa, Ontario Peter Suchman Sharretts, Paley, Carter & Blauvelt Washington, D.C. Prof. Fred Thompson Columbia University New York, NY Philip Trezise Brookings Institution Washington, D.C. Prof. Mel Watkins Univ. of Toronto Toronto, Ontario Alan Wm. Wolff Verner, Liipfert, Bernhard Washington, D.C. McPherson & Hand Sanford Yosowitz Alcan Aluminum Cleveland, OH Tobey Zettler American Trade Consul U.S. Commercial Service Toronto, Ontario

Table of Contents