(Y)OUR CENTRAL
www.yourcitycentre.com
@YourCityCentre YourCityCentre YourCityCentre
Glasgow City Centre District Regeneration Frameworks Central District - Final Draft Report May 2019 Central District Regeneration Framework as defined in Glasgow City Centre Strategy 2014-2019 Project Team Contents
1 Introduction 06 Central Projects 24 Client - Glasgow City Council Lead designer, strategy Local consultant, Local designer 2 (Y)our Updated Mobility 36 3 (Y)our Great Streets & Spaces 66 4 (Y)our Great Buildings 100
Connectivity, spatial Property market Socio-economic Community animation, 5 (Y)our Vibrant Central 124 economics consultants regeneration consultants engagement 6 Transforming (Y)our Central 152 7 Planning Policy 168 Gerry Grams 8 Action Plan 178
Smart city consultants Strategic city design Engineering advice Cost consultants adviser
© Crown Copyright and database right 2015. All rights reserved. OS Licence No. 100023379. You are not permitted to copy, sub-license or sell any of this data to third parties in any form. 07/03/2015 (Y)OUR CENTRAL (Y)OUR CENTRAL INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION Introduction The Assignment (Y)our Ideas
As the name suggests the area defined as the Central The urban grid of Glasgow is the recurring feature The City Centre Strategy and Action Plan 2014-19 This District Regeneration Framework has been District Regeneration Framework (DRF) in the of this DRF area, that binds together a wide variety sets out a vision and objectives for central Glasgow prepared in collaboration with a wide array of Glasgow City Centre Strategy is at the heart of the of character areas, each with its own and defines nine city centre Districts; one of which is stakeholders and consultees. Ideas and opinions city and the wider city region. Indeed the area distinctiveness. There is the urban intensity of Broomielaw. A Regeneration Framework is to be have been shared by Glaswegians and visitors to the captures the essence of central Glasgow. The Scotland’s biggest city in the area around two of prepared for each District. city. Engagement and consultation has been strongly defined urban street grid, the two major the three busiest rail stations in the country. Here conducted on-street, online, in public exhibitions, terminus rail stations, the riverfront, the principal Glasgow has a big city feel. George Square, The pilot Framework was prepared for Sauchiehall + design workshops and via social media. streets including Buchanan Street, Argyle Street and ostensibly Scotland’s ‘national square’, is Garnethill and was completed and published in Sauchiehall Street and civic squares such as George Glasgow’s main civic space; an anchor point for 2016. The next four Districts are: Broomielaw, St. Participants have included residents, businesses, Square are all synonymous with Glasgow. In most celebration, protest and remembrance and much Enoch, Central and Blythswood. The last four District land and building owners / occupiers, developers people’s mental map of Glasgow the area between more. Fronting the square the splendour of the City Regeneration Frameworks will be for the Merchant and investors, local and national agencies, Council and around Glasgow Central and Queen Street Chambers confirms this place as the civic heart of City, Learning Quarter, Townhead and Cowcaddens. departments, elected members, charities, voluntary organisations and tourists. Stations is the city centre. Glasgow. Each District Regeneration Framework will guide The area covered in this Central District The sparkle and vitality of Buchanan Street is the physical, social and economic regeneration and may The findings from this, and associated District Regeneration Framework is the most ‘complete’ and spine of Glasgow’s shopping experience, with two inform Supplementary Planning Guidance (Local Regeneration Framework engagement work is intensive piece of the city centre. The planned grid large malls at either end. Beyond these pivot points Development Frameworks and/or Strategic recorded in greater detail in a companion report sweeping up Blythswood Hill still characterises this in the ‘Golden Z’ are Argyle Street and Sauchiehall Development Frameworks as defined in the City titled (Y)our City Centre Community Engagement area. As Glasgow flourished following the Street. Both streets face significant challenges in this Development Plan 2017). dated May 2018. Enlightenment and throughout the Industrial age, era of internet retail and, for Sauchiehall Street, these (Y)our Ideas have informed and shaped the the city centre expanded westward rapidly across issues are compounded following devastating fires recommendations and projects emerging through this area and we still enjoy the rich urban at Glasgow School of Art. (Y)our Central District Regeneration Framework. architectural heritage in the contemporary cityscape. Beyond the Art School this DRF area also The relationship between Glasgow and its river is encompasses the Gallery of Modern Art, the Royal considered more specifically in the Broomielaw and Concert Hall and numerous cultural venues. In the St. Enoch DRFs. The proposals for this District have to Merchant City the narrower streets and lanes have be integrated with emerging ideas in these other been revitalised with bars, restaurants and culture. DRFs so that the relationship between the River Upon Blythswood Hill the Georgian grid retains a Clyde and the city centre is far more positive. quieter ambience, whilst towards the River Clyde the modern offices of the International Financial Within this portion of central Glasgow is some of Services District edge towards the waterfront. Glasgow’s most elaborate urban architecture, and set piece civic spaces. George Square is the natural So, evidently, this part of the city centre is crucial to civic gathering space in the city. Royal Exchange Sq., the city’s economic, cultural, social and civic health Nelson Mandela Sq. and Blythswood Sq. provide and future prosperity. further evidence of Glasgow’s historic grandeur. The ‘Golden Z’ of Sauchiehall Street / Buchanan Street / Preparing this Framework has been a collaborative, Argyle Street has long been the spine for Glasgow’s collective effort involving many people with a stake retail and commercial core. and interest in Glasgow City Centre and the Central DRF area. For this reason this project is underscored Glasgow is a city of perpetual change. The transitions by this collective effort, expertise and energy.... from religious centre to seat of learning to a city of merchants to the hyper-intense Industrial Glasgow to the present day has left a significant legacy, not (Y)our City Centre, (Y)our Central district least in this part of the city centre. This city’s motto is “Let Glasgow Flourish”. If Glasgow This District Regeneration Framework outlines a is to flourish in the 21st Century the city centre will vision, projects and an action plan to refocus the have to be at the vanguard of wider regeneration, Central district of Glasgow in the next ten years. It with Central district at the fulcrum; right at the heart overlaps with adjacent DRFs, notably Broomielaw, St. of (Y)our Future City Centre. Enoch, Blythswood and Sauchiehall / Garnethill. It is intended to align with these DRFs, and in combination set out a framework for adapting Glasgow to the changing demands of contemporary city life as it faces local and international challenges.
6 7 (Y)OUR CENTRAL (Y)OUR CENTRAL INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION (Y)our Central District Boundaries Purpose and structure of this Report
The boundaries for the (Y)our Central District The area encompasses two major rail stations PURPOSE OF THIS REPORT STRUCTURE OF THIS REPORT Regeneration Framework are defined in the Glasgow (Central and Queen Street), Argyle Street low level City Centre Strategy and Action Plan 2014-19. The station, two Subway stations and is served by The principal purpose of this District Regeneration This DRF considers the role the Central District has to Framework encompasses an area from the north most bus routes in the city. The main retail streets Framework (DRF) is to guide forthcoming physical, play in the wider renewal of Glasgow city centre. The bank of the River Clyde in the south to Killermount of the ‘Golden Z’ of Buchanan St., Argyle St. and social and economic regeneration and development regeneration of Glasgow City Centre and the River Street / Renfrew Street in the north, and from Pitt Sauchiehall St., national cultural institutions, major in the area of the city centre designated by the City Clyde corridor should be considered national priority Street / Douglas Street / Brown Street in the west to office districts and areas of regeneration are all Centre Strategy 2014-19 as the Central district. projects and the Central DRF area has a pivotal role Stockwell Street / Glassford Street / George Square included within this highly diverse district. in both (albeit the elements pertaining to the River and North Hanover Street in the east. The City Centre Strategy states that each DRF will Corridor are covered in greater detail in the The full extent of this Framework area is 104 contribute to Supplementary Planning Guidance. accompanying Broomielaw and St. Enoch DRFs). The The Central District is characterised by a south facing hectares. The City Development Plan (2017) confirms that Framework assesses the significant challenges and slope from the riverside up to the ridge of two opportunities that will continue to define Glasgow drumlins; Blythswood Hill with the eponymous Local Development Frameworks (LDF) will be produced for each of the 9 districts identified in the city centre’s environmental, spatial, economic and Square at its summit, and Garnethill with Renfrew social performance. It confirms overarching Street and Glasgow School of Art near its peak. City Centre Strategy, and that a Strategic Development Framework (SDF) will be prepared objectives that must be met if Glasgow is to covering the entire city centre and all 9 districts. compete as a leading European city, and reinforces the importance of the city centre as the engine for It is therefore intended that this DRF will contribute the city region’s economic, cultural, civic and to the planning policy for this District of Glasgow’s environmental health. It outlines fundamental city centre. It is anticipated that the Planning Policy principles to ensure Glasgow has a sustainable, chapter and other planning related elements of each resilient and vibrant city centre that is remarkable, DRF should be incorporated as Supplementary attractive and convivial. Guidance within an SDF or LDF, subject to it being consistent with the City Development Plan and In support of these principles and to help deliver the planning authority approval, and then be considered overarching objectives for (Y)our City Centre this a material consideration in planning matters report sets out a Framework of Projects within the affecting the Central DRF area. Central district and an associated Action Plan to help prioritise implementation. It also outlines additional This DRF should be read in conjunction with the City planning policy specific to the Central district. Development Plan (2017) and the City Centre Strategy 2014-19 and their respective successor The (Y)our Central Projects are outlined within five documents. It should also be read in conjunction themes; with the City Centre Strategic Development (Y)our updated mobility Framework which is to be prepared in line with guidance set out in the City Development Plan (Y)our great streets and spaces (2017). (Y)our great buildings (Y)our vibrant Central Transforming (Y)our Central Each project is described and cross referred to the objectives that it aligns with. The Action Plan suggests priorities, project leadership and inputs, early actions and sequence of tasks towards implementing each project co-ordinated within the overall DRF. This Action Plan is therefore the principal point of reference in monitoring and co-ordinating delivery of the (Y)our Central District Regeneration Framework. It is incumbent on project delivery lead and partners to undertake project risk assessments at the commencement and during the implementation of each project, in view of circumstances at that time.
8 9 (Y)OUR CENTRAL (Y)OUR CENTRAL INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION
Policy Context
Glasgow City Development Plan 2017 Glasgow City Region: City Deal Glasgow Economic Strategy 2016-2023
The City Development Plan was adopted in March Glasgow City Council and seven neighbouring local The Central DRF objectives fit well with the Glasgow other leisure/entertainment facilities. The district 2017 and is the new statutory Local Development authorities in the city region and Clyde Valley have Economic Strategy 2016-2023 (November 2016) and includes George Square, the city’s major civic space Plan for Glasgow, comprising two overarching secured one of the UK’s largest City Deals. the fundamental aim to make ‘Glasgow the most and key visitor/ cultural attractions such as The policies (the Placemaking Principle and Sustainable productive major city economy in the UK’. The Glasgow Royal Concert Hall, Cineworld Cinema, The Spatial Strategy) and ten policies supported by The Glasgow City Region City Deal will fund major current Economic Strategy outlines 10 themes; Lighthouse, Gallery of Modern Art, the Pavilion supplementary guidance. infrastructure projects; create thousands of new jobs Theatre and on its periphery, the Glasgow School of and assist thousands of unemployed people back to 1. Raising health Art Macintosh building, the Glasgow Film Theatre This Central DRF promotes design excellence and work; improve public transport and connectivity; 2. Skills for all and O2 ABC music venue. The area accommodates low-carbon place-making to deliver a mixed use city drive business innovation and growth and generate key public transportation infrastructure hubs - the centre district characterised by a diverse economy billions of pounds of private sector investment. 3. A fairer Glasgow two main railway stations Central Station and Queen and community, in a high density walkable The City Deal will support the local area to achieve Street Station, Argyle Street Station, Buchanan Street neighbourhood with excellent public transport and 4. Supporting key sectors and St Enoch subway stations, and numerous great public spaces. its shared long-term vision for the local economy through four key areas of focus: 5. Innovation/high value employment principal bus routes. It is therefore aligned with the CDP Key Aims and • Improved infrastructure 6. Smart infrastructure investment By floorspace in Central District office use is in the Strategic Outcomes to create; majority, but only just at 52% and retail use increases • a healthy, high quality place • Growth in Life Sciences 7. Housing mix including an increase in city centre to its highest market share at 28% of floorspace in population this core city centre district. Hospitality / leisure • a compact city form that supports sustainable • Supporting Business Innovation (11%) followed by residential (4%) and a marginal 8. Supporting enterprise development • Tackling unemployment amount of miscellaneous stock make up the balance 9. Linking education & employment opportunities of floorspace in Central District. Ryden’s property • a vibrant place with a growing economy There is a £1.13 billion fund to support the delivery market analysis report (2017) indicated that the • a thriving and sustainable place to live and work of improved infrastructure including an improved 10. Increasing population & retaining talent new-build office pipeline in Central District is transport network across Glasgow and the Clyde modest. The retail core is clearly regionally • a connected place to move around and do Valley, key development and regeneration sites and The City and Central district will only realise its dominant and tightening around Buchanan Street, business in improved public transport. There are two aspects potential, however, if more innovation is with a potential step-change in the pipeline when that are of specific relevance to Central; encouraged, the business base grows, skills the Buchanan Galleries extension is developed. • a green place which is resilient, accessible and provision is better linked with the needs of the local attractive City Centre Enabling Infrastructure Integrated Public economy and longstanding health issues are Realm Programme – the ‘Avenues’ project tackled. The aim of the Placemaking Principle policy CDP 1 is to “improve the quality of development taking place £115m fund for a programme of improvement works in Glasgow by promoting a design-led approach.” which will upgrade and enhance the look and feel of This policy also supports city centre living in this Glasgow city centre by delivering a network of Central District: Today location, outlining planning requirements which can avenues and public realm investment, which will The Central district provides the focus for Glasgow align with the Central DRF objectives. support the city centre economy and help increase city centre’s retail, commercial, business cultural and footfall. entertainment/leisure uses. The District is bounded Waterfront and West End Innovation Quarter to the north by Renfrew Street, the Broomielaw/ Clyde Street and the River Clyde to the south and The investment in this part of the City Deal project Stockwell Street/Glassford St/North Hanover Street (£114m) will increase economic growth by to the east. It overlaps with and includes part of the continuing the regeneration of the Clyde Waterfront Blythswood and Broomielaw districts to the west as an attractive urban quarter. and the St Enoch district to the south-east. Central DRF area should benefit from City Deal The area includes the ‘Style Mile’ formed along funded enhancement to public realm (Avenues) and Buchanan Street from Buchanan Galleries investment on the Waterfront. southwards to Princes Square and accommodates the St Enoch Shopping Centre, major hotels and
10 11 (Y)OUR CENTRAL (Y)OUR CENTRAL INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION
Central District: Future Distinctive Economic In an increasingly globalised competitive economy, Every attempt must be made to ensure that the The District Regeneration Framework projects Development Role major cities in the UK and Europe are competing to City Centre continues to build on to its relative proposed in and around Central District also all attract investments, talent and tourists that are all competitive edge in terms of retail, food/drink, include opportunities to experiment and test Central District has a very distinctive role to play in formidable drivers of economic growth. The race to affordable housing for different occupiers, students, innovative solutions (e.g. data sharing, logistics, the future wider economic renewal of Glasgow city attract visitors – business tourists, vacationers, city researchers and creatives, who are also driving its tele-commuting and digital technology). The centre. The Central District Regeneration breakers - means cities compete to host major vitality. Therefore, there will also be opportunities to CDRF makes room for a new mix of retail outlets, Framework (CDRF) has evolved from Getting events. Whether it be events for the public (e.g. promote an appropriate choice of new housing in a offices, business space and residential units that Ahead of Change: Glasgow City Centre Strategy Commonwealth Games 2014, European range of affordable tenures as part of mixed use are both pleasant to use and live in and 2014-19 with the particular emphasis on: Championships 2018) or for the business world investment in Central. The housing would target a ecologically efficient. Innovative environment • shop & play- to maintain Glasgow’s position as (research conferences, trade shows), all are catalysts wide range of occupiers including singles/couples, projects can serve as a showcase for the the best destination to shop and play outside for economic growth, drivers of regional downsizers, families and include car free housing by widespread adoption of best practices for buildings London; visit & enjoy- to be the most prominent development and marketing opportunities that help increasing active accessibility. and ‘eco-districts’ that include for example boost the city’s visibility and shape its image. fostering the adoption of the new building heating leisure and business tourism destination; work & The interests of everyone – local business owners, create - to be the biggest job generator in networks, networked energy infrastructure and Therefore, the CDRF aims to play a crucial role by the increasing resident population and highly standards. Therefore, Glasgow City Centre will be Scotland; invest & build- to remain a top ten ensuring that Buchanan Street maintains its expectant visitors–have to be taken into account in investment location in Europe. a place of experimentation, an opportunity for competitive position as a very successful shopping the CDRF. The night-time economy will look to companies looking to innovate and test new • The CDRF objectives fit well with the Glasgow street for visitors and Glaswegians that meets the move away from a focus on younger people. It is solutions. Economic Strategy 2016-2023 (November highest European standards located in what is a hoped by 2022, 40% of people using the city 2016) and the aim to make ‘Glasgow the most lively and even more popular city quarter. centre at night will be aged over 40 and that 40% Overall the CDRF ambition is for balancing all the productive major city economy in the UK’. of operating businesses at this time will be shops. factors and to ensure that Central District is a There will be an increase in opportunities for more Encouraging a larger variety of retailers and fundamental element in the wider ‘Glasgow • The objectives of the CDRF fit well and experiential stores, using the advancement of new attractions to stay open late will broaden people’s package’ offered to investors, businesses, support the ten Glasgow Economic Strategy technologies, such as augmented and virtual choices of things to do after dark. A more employees, families and students when they are themes and the opportunities to promote key reality providing shoppers with unforgettable integrated night time strategy would also benefit considering Glasgow among other competitive sectors identified in the Glasgow Economic experiences and more choice of eating/drinking from investment in intramodality and a seamless locations. Strategy (see table below) facilities. George Square will be a lively and passenger travel experience between and around important destination. The aim is to encourage the Central District transport system’s two main rail Central District Regeneration Framework & Fit with shoppers to keep on visiting with ever-more and subway stations/ hubs. the Glasgow Economic Strategy 2016-2023 Sectors competitive offer to meet the challenges of the future retail landscape. This will be reinforced by Central District can be a more ‘equal place’ with a Glasgow Economic Strategy (2-16- Central exploring the possibility of establishing new focus on attracting an even wider mix of income, 23) Sectors Focus pedestrian routes through the St. Enoch Centre gender and ethnicity with different options for together with a new event square. socialising, not just mainstream drinking venues and Digital Technology with great public art as an inspiring aspect to the The CDRF also looks to continue to improve the Finance & Business Services public space. City Centre’s economic attractiveness, financial Creative Industries competitiveness, infrastructure design and social and environmental cohesion. There is a significant Low Carbon and growing business / financial sector presence Health & Life Sciences in Central District with the recent completion of some signature developments (G1, 110 Queen Engineering, Design & Advanced Street, SSE) and the retrofitting and upgrading of Manufacturing other historic building stock for office use. The Tourism & Events CDRF aims to continue this trend to add to the street level mix of uses that include retail / leisure / Higher & Further Education food and drink. The overall objective is to accelerate the existing diversity of uses by bringing vacant upper floor spaces into use for residential, creative local enterprise and innovative uses. In a related way, the CDR also looks to promote links with the existing creative industries and advanced design & manufacturing cluster located elsewhere in the City Centre.
12 13 (Y)OUR CENTRAL (Y)OUR CENTRAL INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION
14 15 Overview of (Y)our possible projects
16 17 © Crown Copyright (Y)our Central Engagement Issues & Ideas
Through a series of workshops, presentations, site visits and digital tools, (Y)our Central engagement generated numerous issues and ideas. A detailed record of the community and stakeholder engagement has been prepared as a separate document. This page summarises the diversity of comments and discussions raised in considering this district.
18 19 © Crown Copyright (Y)our Central analysis overview Bus Station dislocated from core city centre
Central district has much that is quintessential and synonymous with Glasgow city centre; major shopping streets, busy national train and bus termini, Shopping mall megastructure large offices, significant cultural venues and lively nightlife. disrupts street network It is characterised by the urban grid and fantastic, though occasionally threatened or under appreciated, built heritage. As with the rest of the city centre districts on the riverfront it largely turns Limited greenspace in its back on the River Clyde. district is not publicly Many of the streets are dominated by traffic; cars and accessible buses. Where pedestrian and cycle accessibility has been prioritised and implemented well it is has had demonstrable benefits. Buchanan Street has many positive attributes and demonstrates the impacts enhanced public realm can have. Major public square is poor quality space Other set-piece spaces, including George Street and the north bank of the river fall below the standard befitting such urban assets. These spaces have become dominated by traffic and undermined as people places. There is a chronic lack of greenspace in the Central area, and that provided by George Square or the riverside is of a poor quality. The Central area is enlivened by footfall during the day due to significant destinations (notably two Busy car traffic major rail stations). However the quality of through city centre Successful pedestrian street pedestrian environments is sub-optimal. surrounded by historic buildings The Central DRF area is the most ‘complete’ piece of the city centre which already creates a strong image for Glasgow. However there is significant room for improvement to create an even more welcoming environment for Glaswegians and visitors. There is tremendous scope to add value, to enhance the quality of experience of citylife and benefit from the amazing assets, notably the built heritage, the river Public parks spaces and the mix of activities already located in the heart of Scotland’s largest city. Listed building A