Social Mobility of Greeks in Australia
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Social Mobility of Greeks in Australia Yiannis E. Dimitreas Thesis submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for Doctor of Philosophy Department of Social and Cultural Studies Faculty of Arts Victoria University of Technology 1995 STA THESIS 305.51308989 DIM v.l 30001004466027 Dimitreas, Yiannis E Social mobility of Greeks in Australia Detailed List of Contents Abstract v Acknowledgements vii Dedication viii Declaration ix Abbreviations x List of Figures xi List of Illustrations xiii Chanter T: INTRODUCTION 1 Chanter 2: GENERAL THEORIES AND TYPES OF MIGRATION. 19 Chapter 3: METHODOLOGY 65 Fkst Stage of Data Collection From Field Study: Qualitative Research: Formal Interview Schedule 75 Second Stage of Data Collection From Field Study: Quantitative Sample Responses 76 Third Stage of Data Collection From Field Study: Informal Conferencing: Interview 77 Identification Process 78 Strengths of the Study 84 Documentary Evidence as Data 86 Chapter 4: HELLENIC VALUES AND NATIONAL CHARACTER 89 I I Chapter 5: HELLENIC CONNECTION WITH COLONIAL AUSTRALIA 122 Chapter 6: THE CAUSES OF HELLENIC MIGRATION 148 Chapter 7: AUSTRALIA'S IMMIGRATION POLICY AND HELLENIC MIGRATION 187 Chapter 8: HOST AUSTRALIAN SOCIETY ATTITUDES TOWARDS HELLENIC SETTLEMENT: THE PRE-WHITLAM YEARS 226 Chapter 9: WHITLAM AND BEYOND 271 Chapter 10: SOCIAL MOBHJTY AND POLITICAL BEHAVIOUR OF GREEKS IN AUSTRALIA Analysis of single socio-economic variables and class status 304 Residendal Mobility 304 Occupational mobility of Greek immigrants in Australia 310 Analysis of economic variables leading to a definition of class 318 Analysis of political behavioural trends and voting preferences 328 Analysis by Multivariate Methods 338 Chanter 11: DISCUSSION AND IMPLICATIONS 343 APPENDICES 357 Appendix 1: Interview Schedule 358 Appendix 2: Social Mobility of Greeks in Australia 360 Appendix 3: Interview Questions 380 I I I Appendix 4: Anglicisation of Hellenic Names 383 Appendix 5: Occupation by Birthplace. Employed Population 384 Appendix 6: Occupational Status According to the Birthplace of Parents 385 Appendix 7: Percentage of Workforce Self-Employed and Employer 386 Appendix 8: Money Lost by Greek Fruit Growers in the Riverland 387 Appendix 9: Comparison of Greek-bom in Melbourne EGAs 388 Appendix 10: Australian MPs of Hellenic or Part Hellenic Origin 389 Appendix 11: Australians MPs of Hellenic or Part Hellenic Origin: 1995 390 BIPLIOGRAPHY- 391 IV Abstract Central to this diesis is the impact of immigration from Greece (Hellas) to Australia, particularly in terms of social mobility and political affiliation. The discussion of the theoretical framework includes an analysis of migration and social mobility, defining and placing both within socio-economic and socio- historical contexts. The interdisciplinary approach cuts across the fields of political economy, sociology, politics, law and demography. The study draws from both Weberian and Marxist traditions in order to offer the most comprehensive testing possible of the empirical analysis of the immigrant experience. As argued in Chapter 2, as a theoretical study this thesis seeks to determine the causes of present Greek-Australian social mobility and related traits, in terms of pre-migration, migration-settlement and post-migration socio-economic experience. Chapter 3 discusses the methods employed in the thesis; these include an empirical inquiry based on a questionnaire surveys, detailed personal interviews, and other primary sources for the trends and variables in social mobility such as Australian Bureau of Statistics data. To comprehend the values and cultural features which contributed to the decision to migrate, Chapter 4 examines the symbols of Hellenic national identity derived from a mythical past, including symbols and legends that have continued to shape everyday human interaction to the present. Within this framework, the dissertation outlines the outstanding features of the typologies of migration, from the pioneer settlers of the mid-to the late-Nineteenth Century through to the inter-war period. It includes biographical accounts of the "scouts" who pioneered Hellenic settlement in Australia, as well as of those who came after the initiation of chain migration from Greece. It examines in detail the socio economic development of the Hellenic Nation State, as both a cause and effect of mass out-migration fix>m Greece to America and Australia over the past cenmry. It indicates how the major factors of economic under-development and under employment forced Greeks to abandon their rural and farming communities, choosing first urbanisation then mass out-migration. It analyses Australia's history, its socio-historical development, and how its changing immigration policies affected public attitudes both before and after WWII. It focuses on the attitudes of Australian public towards the settlement of non-British migrants. The thesis argues that until multiculturalism was established, Southern Europeans experienced the closure to them of social structures, and that the general unreadiness by the host society resulted in its failure to capitalise on the skills and initiatives of Greeks from the late 1800s to tiie 1970s when multiculturalism was implemented. The chapter based on empirical investigation employed the SPSS-X statistical package to analyse data gathered from the field survey. The findings show that change of residential area in relation to economic mobility was statistically significant and that immigrants' willingness to return home was either postponed or became a merely personal matter krespective of economic gains. Occupational and accompanying economic upward mobility were found to have a statistically high relationship to party political affiliation in that length of time in Australia was seen to be influenced by employment and economic status. Finally, after considering a number of diacritical indicators relating to the forces of migration, post-migration experiences and social mobility of Greek Australians, the thesis presents reflections on the results of the research and delineates various suggestions for future research. VI Acknowledgements Many have contributed to this thesis. I wish to thank all those friends, who because of their numbers must remain anonymous, who either directiy or indirectiy gave me their assistance and valuable comments on the work as it progressed. I am indebted to my supervisors Professor Ron Adams and Professor Robert Pascoe for their consistent encouragement, patience, understanding and invaluable advice on how to survive the difficulties encountered during the research and writing of a thesis. In this context, I would especially mention my debt to Ron for helping me to appreciate more fully the power of the word. I am indebted to John Marinopoulos for his expert statistical advice. I wish to express special thanks to Meng Lim for her constant support during the writing of the thesis, to Les Terry for sharing with me some of his views and interest in areas relating to the study, and to the following people and organisations for providing me with access to material in their possession: Leon Peres, Professor Charles Price, Dr Anastasios Tamis, Dr Michael Tsounis, Eric Lloga, Dr Dorothea Warr, Johna Low, Stelios Kourbetis, Theo Sidiropoulos MLA, George Zangalis, Harry Trahanas, Dimitris Kalomoiris, George Mihelakakis, Alan Matheson, George Kallianis, George Papadopoulos, Katerina Skoutas, Joan Messaris, Effy Alexakis, Leonard Janiszewski, Panayiotis Kalantzis, Sofia Kalantzis, Yiannis Kalantzis, Evangelos Dedes, Tom Oikonomou, Stathis Raftopoulos, the Greek Orthodox Community of Melbourne and Victoria, the Greek Orthodox Community of Sydney and New South Wales, Achileas Paparsenos from the Greek General Consul of Melbourne, the Holy Archdiocese of the Greek Orthodox Church of Australia, and the Greek language newspapers Neos Kosmos (Melbourne), O Kosmos, and the Hellenic Herald (Sydney). VII Dedication I dedicate this thesis to my beloved mother Stavroula Spyrea-Dimitrea, daughter of Aikaterini Spyrea, who, not always understanding why, had faith in my endeavours, a faith which has never dimmed. Ta 5eva BeXouv ^p6vr\^a, 0eXouv Ta7rsivoai5vTi 6eXouv XaYOu TrepTraniaid Ki aerou YP^lYopoauvTi AvaOeMtt ai ApepiKif, avaOejid ai JTOXTI TTou a'areiXa TOV dv8p(07ro, Kai ^'areiXes TO pdi5il AvKaTEpivri iTTupea To go abroad requires discipline, requires humility, requires the hare's speed and the eagle's wings. Curses on America curses on cities, I send you my man and you send me a bullock! Aikaterini Spyrea VIII Declaration Statement of Authorship: Except where reference is made in the text, this thesis is my work and contains no material published elsewhere or extracted in whole or in part from a thesis presented by me for another degree or diploma. IX Abbreviations ABS -Austrahan Bureau of Statistics AIMA -Austrahan Institute of Multicultural Affairs ALP -Austrahan Labor Party AMA -Austrahan Medical Association BCN -Bilingual Consultant Network BIR -Bureau of Immigration Research (subsequentiy BIMPR) CPA -Communist Party of Austraha DIEA -Department of Immigration and Ethnic Affairs ERM -Ethnic Rights Movement GOC -Greek Orthodox Community GOCM&V -Greek Orthodox Community of Melbourne and Victoria ICEM -Inter-Govemment Committee for Migration ILO -Intemational Labour Organisation IRO -International Refugee Organisation L/LM - Lower/Lower Middle NCP -National Country Party NESB (or NES) -Non Enghsh Speaking Background NOOSR -National Office of Overseas Skills Recognition