INDEX of the Legislative Assembly of

DEBATES and PROCEEDINGS

40-41 Elizabeth II

Third Session - Thirty-Fifth Legislature which opened the 5th of December, 1991 and prorogued the 25th of November, 1992

Volume XLI

Printedby theOffice OUHn ofthe 's Printer,Province of Menitoba TABLE OF CONTENTS

Legislative Assembly of Manitoba

STANDING AND SPECIAL COMMITTEES

Third Session • Thirty-Fifth Legislature

Table of Contents ...... 1

List of Members ...... 11 Legislative Assembly ...... Ill

Introduction ...... IV

Member/Subject Index ...... 1 Appendices

Appendix A: Oral Questions...... 194

Appendix B: Members of Executive Council...... 226

Appendix C: Standing and Special Committees ...... 228 MANITOBA LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY Thirty-Fifth Legislature

Members, Constituencies and Political Affiliation

NAME CONSTITUENCY PARTY. ALCOCK, Reg Osborne Liberal ASHTON, Steve Thompson NDP BARRETT, Becky Wellington NDP CARR, James (resigned January27, 1992) Crescentwood Liberal CARSTAIRS, Sharon River Heights Liberal CERILLI, Marianne Radisson NDP CHEEMA, Guizar The Maples Liberal CHOMIAK, Dave Kildonan NDP CONNERY, Edward (resigned June 23, 1992) Portage Ia Prairie PC CUMMINGS, Glen, Hon. Ste. Rose PC DACQUAY, Louise Seine River PC DERKACH, Leonard, Hon. Roblin-Russell PC DEWAR, Gregory Selkirk NDP DOER, Gary Concordia NDP DOWNEY, James, Hon. Arthur-Virden PC DRIEDGER, Albert, Hon. Steinbach PC DUCHARME, Gerry, Hon. Riel PC EDWARDS, Paul St. James Liberal ENNS, Harry, Hon. Lakeside PC ERNST, Jim, Hon. Charleswood PC EVANS, Clif Interlake NDP EVANS, Leonard S. Brandon East NDP FILMON, Gary, Hon. Tuxedo PC FINDLAY, Glen, Hon. Springfield PC FRIESEN, Jean Wolseley NDP GAUDRY, Neil St. Boniface Liberal GILLESHAMMER, Harold, Hon. Minnedosa PC HARPER, Elijah Rupertsland NDP HELWER, Edward R. Gimli PC HICKES, George Point Douglas NDP LAMOUREUX, Kevin Inkster Liberal LATHLIN, Oscar The Pas NDP LAURENDEAU, Marcel St. Norbert PC MALOWAY, Jim Elmwood NDP MANNESS, Clayton, Hon. Morris PC MARTINDALE, Doug Burrows NDP McALPINE, Gerry Sturgeon Creek PC McCRAE, James, Hon. Brandon West PC MciNTOSH, Linda, Hon. Assiniboia PC MITCHELSON, Bonnie, Hon. River East PC NEUFELD, Harold, Hon. Rossmere PC ORCHARD, Donald, Hon. Pembina PC PENNER, Jack Emerson PC PLOHMAN, John Dauphin NDP PRAZNIK, Darren, Hon. Lac du Bonnet PC REID, Daryl Transcona NDP REIMER, Jack Niakwa PC RENDER, Shirley St. Vital PC ROCAN, Denis, Hon. Gladstone PC ROSE, Bob Turtle Mountain PC SANTOS, Conrad Broadway NDP STEFANSON, Eric Kirkfield Park PC STORIE, Jerry Flin Flon NDP SVEINSON, Ben La Verendrye PC VODREY, Rosemary, Hon. FortGarry PC WASYLYCIA - LEIS, Judy St. Johns NDP WOWCHUK, Rosann Swan River NDP

II LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY

Lieutenant-Governor of Manitoba ...... Hon. George Johnson, M.D.

Speaker of the Legislative Assembly ...... Hon. Denis C. Rocan, M.L.A.

Deputy Speaker and Chairman Committees of the Whole House ...... Mrs. Louise Dacquay, M.L.A.

Deputy Chairman of Committees of the Whole House ...... Mr. Marcel Laurendeau, M.L.A.

Government House Leader ...... Hon. Clayton Manness, M.L.A.

Opposition House Leader ...... Mr. Steve Ashton, M.L.A.

Second Opposition House Leader ...... Mr. Reg Alcock, M.L.A.

Government Whip ...... Mr. Edward Helwer, M.L.A.

Opposition Whip ...... Mr. George Hickes, M.L.A.

Second Opposition Whip ...... Mr. Kevin Lamoureux, M.L.A.

Clerk of the Legislative Assembly ...... Mr. W. H. Remnant

Deputy Clerk of the Legislative Assembly ...... Ms. Beverley Bosiak

Clerks of Committees ...... Ms. Patricia Chaychuk-Fitzpatrick

...... Ms. Bonnie Greschuk

Legislative Counsel ...... Ms. Shirley Strutt

Sergeant-at-Arms ...... Mr. Dennis Gray

Chief of Hansard Services ...... Mrs. Suzanne L. Dion

Hansard Indexer ...... Ms. Brenda L. Walker

Il l INTRODUCTION

The Hansard Index is designed to provide easy access to topics discussed in the Legislative Assembly. For this reason it corresponds to the text of the Manitoba Hansard.

FORMAT

The Index is in two sections: (1) Member/Subject Index, and (2) Appendices.

Mem ber/Subject Index: Main entry in this section is a subject heading which may be subdivided. Following the main entry are secondary headings, "see" and "see also" references, and a listing of individuals who spoke on that subject.

Appendices: Included in this section is a complete list of Oral Questions by department, Members of Executive Council, and Chairpersons of Standing and Special Committees.

FILING ARRANGEMENT

The basic filing principle is alphabetical, letter by letter.

The sequence is as follows: a) numbers are filed at the beginning of the alphabet, if they are the first character in the filing element. b) initials separated by punctuation, abbreviations, acronyms without interior punctuation are filed at the beginning of their alphabetic group.

ABBREVIATIONS

1 r ...... First Reading 0/C ...... Order-in-Council

2r ...... Second Reading P/0 ...... Point of Order

3r ...... Third Reading R/R ...... Read and Received

Arndt...... Amendment RIA ...... Royal Assent

C/W ...... Committee of the Whole R/S ...... Report Stage

(M) ...... Motion S.P...... Session Paper

T.P ...... Tabled Paper

IV Hansard Index

55 Pl us program Ablnoch/ PreschoolProgram - Cont. Funding restoration Meeting request Ducharme 1258, 1711; Santos 1258, 1711 Downey 1761 ; Filmon 3418; Indexing Hickes 1761 , 3418 Ducharme 2020, 3989; Gaudry 2020; See also Petitions Santos 3989 Abl tl bi·Prlce-Pine Fall s A. E. McKenzie Co. Ltd. De-inking plant Auditor's Report, 1990,19 91 (S.P. 41 ) Cummings 4207-8; Edwards 4207 Downey 551 Employee-owned proposal Doer 1754;Filmon 1754 Feasibility study ACCESS program s Doer 1754-5, 2103-4; Downey 2200-1 ; Funding, federal Filmon17 54-5, 21 03-4;Storie 2200 Lathlin 686;Stefanson 686-7 Financial status Funding reductions Doer 21 02- 3; Filmon 2103 Friesen 3169; Vodrey 3169-70 Licencing process Government action Carstairs 3954-5; Cummings 3955 Doer 4570; Filmon 4570-1 Mediation process Government commitment Carstairs 3954; Cummings 3954 Lathlin 687; Stefanson 687 Premier's discussions Aboriginal Centre Doer 4569-70; Film on 4570 Funding See also Aboriginal women Downey 1609, 3956; Hickes 1609, 3956 Governmentcommitment ACR E Downey 3316-7; Hickes 3316-7 See Association for a Clean Rural Environment Aboriginal Child and Family Services AIDS Candlel ight Mem orial Independent review Barrett4740; Gilleshammer 4740 See Nonpolitical statements Internal review AIDS education projects Barrett4739-40; Gilleshammer 4740 Public inquiry Funding Carstairs 3790-1 ; Gilleshammer 3790-1 Orchard 4598-9; Wasylycia-Leis 4598-9 Aboriginal Issues AIDS prevention programs Education/trainingopportunities Street Links funding Ernst 4571 ; Friesen 4571 Orchard 3648-9; Wasylycia-Leis 3648-9 Governmentcommitment Downey 3955; Hickes3955 Abl nochl Preschool Program See also Ministerial statements Closure Downey 1498; Hickes 1498 Aboriginal Justice Comm ission Correspondence (T.P. 36) See Private Members'Business-Resolutions Hickes 1609 Funding Aboriginal Justice Initiatives (Supply) Downey 1417-8, 1609, 1761; Edwards 5188-91; Lathlin 5178-87; Hickes 1417-8, 1609, 1761 McCrae 5178-90

1 Hansard Index

Aboriginal Justice Inquiry Report Adm inistration of Oaths of Office, an Act Courtservices, Northern respecting the (8111 1) Downey 1369; Harper 1368-9; McCrae 1368-9 1r Filmon 11 Recommendations Chomiak 3039; Doer552- 3, 5167-9; Advertising, misl eadi ng Downey 553, 5168-9; Filmon 3039; Consumer protection Lathlin 20, 224-5; McCrae 20-1, 224-5, 552-3 Edwards 124-6; McCrae 126; Mcintosh 125 See also Justice, Departmentof (Supply)-Public Employment advertisement (T.P. 2) Inquiry into the Administration of Justice and Edwards 125 AboriginalPeople Affirm ative action Aboriginal justice system Co-ordinator Government position Cerilli 443 0; Praznik 4430 Lathlin 553; McCrae 553-4 See also Multicultural legislation See also Petitions Agricultural Industry Aboriginal sel f-governm ent Diversification Governmentposition Findlay 1424, 4990; Gaudry 1424; Johnson 9-1 0 Johnson 4-5; Wowchuk 4990 Financial assistance Findlay 54-5, 728-9; Plohman 54-5, 728-9 Aboriginal wom en Net farm income ACCESS program Manness 3894; Plohman 3893- 4 Barrett10 52; Downey10 52 See also NorthAmerican Free Trade Agreement; Program accessibility Vegetable producing industry Barrett10 51-2; Downey 1052 Agricul tural laboratories Access Awareness Week, National Privatization See Nonpolitical statements Findlay 3985-6; Plohman 3985 See also specific laboratories Accreditation, Professional, and Technical See Private Members'Business-Resolutions Agricul tural land Acid Rain Abatem ent Program Conservation methods Findlay 2307; Gaudry 2306-7 See Energy andMines, Departmentof (Supply) Education supportlevy Derkach 2306; Downey 2354; Address for Papers Wowchuk 2306, 23 54 Public Health Amendment Act Sustainable development Legal opinion Findlay 23 07; Gaudry 23 07 Wasylycia-Leis 73 2; Taxation not acceptedManness 732; Derkach 2305-6; Plohman 23 05; transferred to Private Members' Business Wowchuk 2306 See also Private Members'Business Clarification Derkach 2466 Adjournm ent motion Reassessments Manness 5493 Downey 2354; Wowchuk2353-4

2 Hansard Index

Agriculturalland - Cont. Agriculture, Departmentof (Supply) - Cont. Right of appeal Salaries Downey 2353; Wowchuk 2353 Findlay 3912-3; Gaudry 3912-3; Plohman 391 3 Agricultural Ministers' meeting Veterinary ServicesBranch Agenda Findlay 3795-3804; Gaudry 3801 -2; Findlay 3894; Plohman 3894 Plohman 3795-3804 Income Insurance and SupportProgram Agriculture, Department of Administration Findlay 401 1-2; Plohman 4010-2 Annua1Report,1991 (S.P.49) Net Income StabilizationAccount Findlay 684 Findlay 4012-3; Plohman 4012 Red Meat Forum Federal-Provincial Agreement Terms of reference (T.P. 116) Soil ConservationAgreement Findlay 3795 Findlay 4009-10; Plohman 4009-10 Soils and Crops Branch Manitoba Agricultural Credit Corporation Budget Administration Findlay 1423; Gaudry 1423 Findlay 3740-50; Gaudry 3748-50; Supplementary information Plohman 37 40-8 1992-93 Estimates (T.P. 84) Allowance for Doubtful Accounts Findlay 3084 Findlay 3750-1 ; Gaudry 3750-1 ; Supply management programs (T.P. 10) Plohman 3750 Plohman 404 Manitoba Crop Insurance Corporation Visions for the 1990's (T.P. 1 09) Administration Findlay 3587 Connery 3695-3700; Gaudry 3693-5; Findlay 3593-3611 , 3682-3705, 3731 -7; Agriculture, Department of (Supply) Plohman 3593-361 1 , 3681-93, 3700-5, Administration and Finance 3731-7 Executive Support Big Game Damage Compensation Findlay 3592-3; Gaudry 3592-3; Findlay 3739-40; Wowchuk 3739-40 Plohman 3592-3 Gross Revenue Insurance Plan Minister's salary Findlay 3738-9; Gaudry3739; Plohman 3738 Plohman 401 3 Premiums Agricultural Development and Marketing Division Findlay 3737-8; Gaudry 3737-8 Animal Industry Branch Opening remarks Findlay 3751 -7; Gaudry 3751, 3755; Findlay 3585-9 Plohman 3751 -4, 3757; Wowchuk 3755-7 Response Marketing Branch Gaudry 3591-2; Plohman 3589-91 Connery 3919; Findlay 391 4-23; Policy and Economic Division Gaudry 3920-1 ; Penner 3921 -3; Administration Plohman 3914-9 Findlay 4000-7; Gaudry 4007; Soils and Crops Branch Plohman 4000-7 Connery 3906-1 1; Findlay3804-1 3, 3901 -1 2; Agricultural Research Gaudry 3810-2; Plohman 3804-10, 3901 -6; grant Wowchuk 3812-3 Findlay 4008-9; Plohman 4007-8 Technical Servicesand Training Branch Manitoba Farm Mediation Board Agricultural Societies Findlay 4009; Gaudry 4009; Plohman 4009 Findlay 391 3-4; Plohman 391 3-4 Regional Agricultural ServicesDivision

3 Hansard Index

Agriculture, Department of (Supply) - Cont. Alcock, Reg - Cont. Agricultural Crown Lands Branch Executive Administration Findlay 3994-4000; Plohman 3994-4000 3188,3260-3, 3297- 3301 Central Region Grants 4014-5 Findlay 3993-4; Plohman 3993 Keewatin Community College 3816 NorthwestRegion Literacy Office401 5-7 Findlay 3992; Gaudry 3993; Plohman 3992-3 Post-Secondary Career Development 3939-41' 4013-4 Agriculture, Standing Comm ittee on Program Analysis,Co-ordination and Support 1st Report 3302-5,351 9-25,3623-6, 36 29-31 ' 3705-9 Rose 4272-3 Red River Community College 3757-63 Special Skills Training 4017-20 Air ambulance service Student Financial Assistance Correspondence(T .P. 4) 3819-26,3830, 3923- 8 Driedger 218 Student Financial Assistance Appeal Board See also MinisterialStatements 3938-9 Workforce2000 Alco Rural Developm ent Bond Corporation 4020-3 See Ministerial statements Universities Grants Commission 40 23-6, 40 74-5 Family Services,Department of (Supply) ALCOCK, Reg (Osborne, UB) Administration and Finance Budget debate Agency Relations Bureau 1893-5 1445-53 Children's Advocate 181 9-27 City of Amendment, Municipal Policy and Planning 1884-9 Amendment and Consequential Amendments Income Security and Regional Operations Act (Bill 45) Income Maintenance Programs 2r 1 124-5 1907-8,19 46-55 Consumer and Corporate Affairs, Department of Regional Operations 1960 (Supply) Opening remarks Consumer Affairs Response 181 0-4 Consumers' Bureau 4613-20 Finance, Departmentof (Supply) Corporate Affairs 5206-5210 Regulations 4621-2 Administrationand Finance Economic Innovation and Technology Council Act Minister's salary 5211 (Bi11 9) Government Services, Department of (Supply) 2r 636-8;3r 5309-1 0 5066-9 Education and Training,Department of (Supply) Industry,Trade and Tourism (Supply) Administration and Finance Administrationand Finance Minister's salary 40 91 -2 Grant Assistance-Facultyof Management Expenditures Related to Capital 483 4-5 - Acquisition/Construction of Physical Assets Minister'ssalary 4855-6 4085-6 Strategic Planning 4828-31 Capital Grants Industry and Trade Division Universities 4090-1 Financial Programs4849 Post-Secondary, Adult and Continuing Education Industry and Training Sectoral development 4838,4845-6 Assiniboine Community College 3774-7 Opening remarks Education and Training Assistance 3816-7 Response 4822-3

4 Hansard Index

Alcock, Reg - Cont. Alcock, Reg - Cont. Strategic Development Initiative Division Investment 265 Administration 4850-2 Prairie provinces' co-operation201 8-9 Tourism Division Private sectorinvestment 341 7-8 Administration 4853 Provincial comparisons 331 8 Interim Appropriation Act, 1992 (Bill 67) Research and development 3983-4 C/W16 89-90, 171 8-34 Retail trade sector 2594-5 Manitoba Hydro Amendment Act (Bill 1 0) Education and Training, Department of 2r 992-4 Underspending 975 Ministerial statements Education, post-secondary Canadian Women's Curling Championship Funding 1182 Response10 48 Tuition fee increases 1182 Manitoba Hydro Savings Bonds Federal Trade Tribunal Response 2572, 4427-8 Manitoba cabinetmakers 2512-3, 3170,41 02 Post-Secondary Student SupportProgram First Ministers' Conference Status Indians Government agenda 264-5 Response 4569 Free Trade Agreement World Curling championships Employment creation statistics 3646 Response 1771 Governmentsupport 3583 Nonpolitical statements Impact industrial production 3583 Mount Manitoba climbing team 2799-80 Labour adjustment strategy 364 7 National Missing Children's Week 3794-5 NorthAmerican Free Trade Agreement National Social Work Week 879-80 Cultural industries19 13-4 Vimy Ridge anniversary 1920 Departmentalreview Oral questions Tabling request 1914 Budget Labour standards 1716 Employment retraining programs 405-6 Water sales 1775-6, 2877-8 Student Aid 975 Poverty rate Budget-Federal Manitoba statistics 331 7-8 Education, post-secondary 729 Provincial deficit National Science Council 730 Clarification 687 Student Aid 730 Increase 687 Children's Advocate Retail sales tax Reporting process1228 Statistics 3789 Civil service Retail trade sector Staff layoffs 1115-6 Statistics discrepancy 5265-6 Voluntary incentive program 1115 Seven Oaks Centre for Youth Communications initiative Closure 1227 Research and development funding 3894 Telecommunicationslaboratory Community colleges Government discussions 3894-5 Enrolment 406 Tourism promotion campaign Economic growth Tender process2849 -50 Building permits 2795-6 University of Manitoba Employment statistics 31 40-1 , 3788 Student foodbank 975 Full-time employment decline 2578, 2992 -3 Orders for Return Government policy performance Vision Fund (No. 2) 478 2690, 2849, 2991 Points of Order Housing starts 2747 P/0 by Manness respectingpreviously asked

5 Hansard Index

Alcock, Reg - Cont. Alcoholism Foundation of Manitoba - Cont. questions 2992; Alcock2992; Ashton 2992; Supplementaryinformation ruled out of order 2992 1992-93 Estimates (T.P. 75) P/0 by Plohman respecting responses to Orchard 2871 questions (Supply) 3431; Alcock3431 ; See also Health, Departmentof (Supply) Ashton 3431 -2; Downey 3431 ; Praznik 3432; ruled out of order (Dacquay) 3432 Allona, Elllana Private Members' Business See Nonpolitical statements Address for Papers Winnipeg Regional Housing Authority (2) Allowance for Losses and Expenditures Maintenance contracts, 1990-91 4187 Incurred by Crown Corporations and Orders for Return other Provincial Entitles (Supply) Winnipeg Regional Housing Authority (1) Doer 5056-8; Manness 5056-8 Maintenance costs,19 90-91 4187 Resolutions Altona Volunteer Fire Department Accreditation,Professional and Technical 2503-4 See Nonpolitical statements Core Area Initiative 1114540-1 Manitoba/Russiaagreement 3082 AmusementsAmendment Act (8111 42) North American Free Trade Agreement 1 r Praznik 595; 2r Ashton 511 8-22; 499-501 Lamoureux 745-6; Praznik 641-3; Provincial Auditor's Amendment Act (Bill 92) referred to Standing Committee on 2r 5162 Industrial Relations; RIS Praznik 5332; Social Allowances Amendment and Consequential 3r Ashton 5418-20; RIA 5491 Amendments Act (Bill 70) 2r 4774-9 Animal HusbandryAmendm ent Act (8111 12) Special Operating Agencies Financing 1 r Findlay 170; 2r Carstairs 528-9; Authority Act (Bill 96) Enns 486-8; Findlay 485-6, 3870; 2r5008-9 Plohman 2488-93,3869-70; Wowchuk 3557-60; Statute Law Amendment (Taxation) Act,19 92 referred to Standing Committee on Agriculture; (Bill 94) RIS Findlay 5219; 3r Plohman 5227-9; RIA 5491 2r 5003-4; C/W5238, 5248-9 Tabled papers Anlshl naabe Child and Family Services Retail sales Funding formula StatisticsCanada information (T.P. 195) 5265 Carstairs52-3; Gilleshammer 52-3 Tax Appeals Commission Act (Bill 95) 2r 5005; C/W5255 Anti-racism co-ordinator Throne speech debate Hiring process 241 -7 Lamoureux 1612; Mitchelson 1612 University of Manitoba Amendment Act (Bill 25) 1 r 466-7; 2r 780-1 Apprenticeshiptr aining Urgent Public Importance, Mattersof Correspondence (T.P. 44,45) Economic crisis 417-9,2884 Reid 1715 Apprenticeshiptraining Al cohol ism Foundation of Manitoba First-aid certificate,mandatory Annua1 Report,1991 (S.P. 93) Praznik 1715; Reid 1714 Orchard 2685 See also Labour, Departmentof (Supply)

6 Hansard Index

Appropriation Act, 1992 (8111 1 03) Ashton, Steve - Cont. 1 r Manness 5476; 2r 5476; C/W5476; Franchises Act (Bill 18) 3r Carstairs 5482-4; Doer 5478-82; 2r 2836-9 Filmon 5484-90;RIA 5493 Health Care Records Act (Bill 36) 2r 4490-3 Ashern, Manitoba Health, Department of (Supply) Alternatewater source Administration and Finance Cummings 4986-7; C. Evans 4986 Minister's salary 3241 -5 Environmental concerns Health Services Cummings 4986;C. Evans 4986 Administration Ground water contamination 3007-9, 3015-7, 3094-5, 3101-5, 3107 Cummings 2877; C. Evans 2877 Health Services Insurance Amendment Act (Bill 51) Soil/watertesting 2r 4156-8 C. Evans 4986; Cummings 4986 Highway TrafficAmendment Act (Bill 15) 2r 3871 -2 ASHTON, Steve (Thompson, NDP) Highways and TransportationDepartment Amusements Amendment Act (Bill 42) Amendment Act (Bill 14) 2r 5119-22; 3r 5418-20 2r 2760-8 Budget debate Highways and Transportation, Departmentof 131 2-5, 1330-4 (Supply) -Manitoba Enabling Vote (Supply) Operations and Maintenance 5055-6 District Offices4637-41 City of WinnipegAmendment, Municipal Internal Reform, Workforce Adjustmentand Amendment and Consequential Amendments General Salary Increases (Supply) Act (Bill 45) 5061 2r 1137-45, 1981 -2 Jury Amendment Act (Bill 46) Civil Service Commission (Supply) 2r 646-7 431 2-22 Labour, Departmentof (Supply) Opening remarks Labour Programs Response 4311-2 Apprenticeship and Training 4214-8 Consumer Protection Amendment Act (4) (Bill 61) Conciliation and Mediation 4218-23 2r 3970 Employment Standards4227-8 Denturists Amendment Act (Bill 6) Labour Adjustment 4228-30 2r 829-31 Worker Advisor Office 4226-7 Economic Innovation and Technology Council Act Workplace Safety and Health 4223-5 (Bi119) Opening remarks 2r 697-704 Response 421 0-2 Education and Training, Department of (Supply) Labour Relations Amendment Act (Bill 85) Post-Secondary, Adult and Continuing Education 2r 5149-57; 3r 5459-67 and Training Law Enforcement Review Amendment Act (Bill 87) Keewatin Community College 3777-84, 381 3-6 2r 4748 Program Analysis 3451 -4 Law Society Amendment Act (Bill 74) Farm Income Assurance Plans Amendment Act 2r 41 84 (Bill 43) Liquor Control Amendment Act (2) (Bill 91) 2r 3966-9 2r 3855-8 Farm Practices Protection and Consequential Lodge Operators and Outfitters Licensing and Amendments Act (Bill 82) Consequential Amendments Act (Bill 22) 2r 4890-1 2r 771 -6

7 Hansard Index

Ashton, Steve - Cont. Ashton, Steve - Cont. Manitoba Advisory Council on the Status of Women Amendments3988 Amendment Act (Bill 5) Health care system 2r 560-7 Diagnostic services Manitoba Hydro Amendment Act (Bill 1 0) Privatization 4741 2r 674-82 Essential servicesagreement 341 7 Ministerial statements Reform Air ambulance service Consultations 4741 Response 21 8-9 Health care system, Northern Northern Flood Agreement Transportation fee 878, 2356 Response 2871-2 Highway construction program Thompson, Manitoba NorthernManitoba 41 04 Downtown revitalization Labour College of Canada Response 1614 Scholarship 3416-7 Nonpolitical statements Labour laws Greece independence 1662-3 Worker protection 3270 Inter-Universities North Labour movement 20th anniversary 1 057-8 Government participation3271 R.D. Parker Collegiate Manitoba Liquor Control Commission KnottsBerry Farm Heritage Music Festival Senior salary levels 474 2598 Mystery Lake School Division Westray, NovaScotia mine accident 3176 Funding 2309 Oral questions Meeting request 2309 Borden Company Ltd. Northern Manitoba Closure 1055 Employment creation strategy 5409-1 0 Budget RCMP services Civil servicelayoffs 1182-3 Municipal costs 2357 CKND Television strike Repap Manitoba Inc. Government advertisingpolicy 1162-3, 1611 Employment creation strategy 754-5 Unfair labourpractices 16 1 0-1 Woodlandsdivision CN Rail Job security 1327-8 Bayline upgrade 4305 Retail trade Civil servants Sunday shopping 3854 Senior salary levels 473-4 Social assistance Civil Service Commission Off-reservestatus Indians 2596 Political interference57, 1n-8 Thicket Portage, Manitoba Disabled employees All-weather road 4305 Employment standards 3988 Train derailment report4305 Rehabilitation/vocational services3988 Thompson General Hospital Economic growth Mammography/chemotherapyservices 41 03-4 Northernprograms 407 Unemployed Help Centre Wage levels 1 054-5 Funding reinstatement 341 7 Education and Training, Department of Unemployment rate, youth Hiring authority 178 Governmentstrategy 4507 Employment creation strategy Program funding 5114-5 Northernprograms 1328 Unionization Employment Standards Act Government criteria 3270

8 Hansard Index

Ashton, Steve - Cont. Ashton, Steve - Cont. Pension Benefits Amendment Act (Bill 76) P/0 by MblQnrespecting word "honesty" 1181 ; 2r 5015-7; 3r 5420-2 Members cautioned 1181 Pension Plan Acts Amendment Act (Bill 1 00) P/0 by A§!llimrespecting relevancy of 2r 5011 debate (Filmon) 1466; Petitions Member cautioned 1466 Aboriginal Justice System P/0 by� respecting word "coward" 1174; ruled in order 1316 (Orchard) 1467; withdrawn 1467 Fight Back Against Child Abuse campaign P/0 by � respecting brevity ofquestions 1701 ; ruled in order 1909 and answers 1708; Points of Order Members cautioned 1708 P/0 by Mb1Qnrespecting brevity of questions P/0 by� respecting words "I am going to and answers 51; recommend rabies shots" (Orchard) 1775; Members cautioned 51 Manness 1775; ruled out of order 1775; P/0 by Mb1Qnrespecting dealing with matter Members cautioned 1775 raised 51; P/0 by Aib!Qnrespecting admissibility of Members cautioned 51 amendment 1830-1 ; P/0 by � respecting dealing with matter taken under advisement (Laurendeau) 1831 ; raised 59; P/0 by Aib!Qnrespecting closing debate 2346-7; Members cautioned 59 Lamoureux 2348; Manness 2347; Reid 2347-8; P/0 by Mb1Qnrespecting dealing with matter taken under advisement 2348; raised 223; Lamoureux 223; Praznik 223; Speaker's ruling 4495-6 Members cautioned 223 P/0 by Aib!Qn respecting words "space cadet" P/0 by MIJlQnrespecting brevity of questions (Filmon) 2460; and answers 270; ruled out of order 2460; Members cautioned 270 Members cautioned 2460 P/0 by MIJlQnrespecting brevity of questions P/0 by Mbl2nrespecting imputation of motives and answers 290; (Filmon) 3038; Manness 3039; Members cautioned 290 taken under advisement 3039; P/0 by� respecting unparliamentary ruled out of order 4436; language (McCrae) 333; Members cautioned 4436 withdrawn 333 P/0 by� respecting words "an obligation P/0 by MIJlQnrespecting words "R everend to tell the truth"(Orchard ) 3089; Blackjack from Burrows" (Connery) 452; ruled out oforder 3089 withdrawn 452 P/0 by Ashton respecting words "false information" P/0 by� respecting brevity of question (Orchard) 31 06; and answers 688; Members cautioned (R eimer) 31 06 Members cautioned (Dacquay) 688 P/0 by� respecting brevity ofquestions P/0 by� respecting brevity of questions and answers 3323; and answers 757; Members cautioned 3323 Members cautioned (Dacquay) 757 P/0 by &btQnrespecting members reading from P/0 by� respectingChair's assumption prepared text 3437; Enns 3437-8; Member has risen on a point of order 531 ; ruled out of order (Dacquay) 3438 taken under advisement (Dacquay) 531 ; Ruling challenged 3438; ruled in order 827 Sustained 3438 P/0 by � respecting relevancy of P/0 by� respecting brevity of questions and debate 1 066; Praznik 1 066; answers 4433; Members cautioned (Dacquay) 1066 Members cautioned 4433

9 Hansard Index

Ashton, Steve - Cont. Ashton, Steve - Cont. P/0 by Laurendeau respecting words "false Act (Bill 52) information" (Ashton) 3017; 2r 3832 ruling challenged 3018; Throne speech debate sustained 3034 212-7, 229-32 P/0 by Manness respecting imputation of motives University of Manitoba Amendment Act (Bill 25) (Cheema) 1260; Ashton 1260-1 ; 2r 789-90, 906-7 Lamoureux 1260; Urgent Public Importance, Mattersof ruled out of order 1261 Goods and services tax P/0 by Mannessrespecting previously asked Harmonization 408-9 questions 2992; Alcock 2992; Ashton 2992; Rural Development, Minister of ruled out of order 2992 School board interference 4552-3 P/0 by Mannessrespecting question anticipating Winnipeg Bible College and Theological Seminary debate (Carstairs) 3043; Ashton 3043-4; Incorporation Amendment Act (Bill 97) question rephrased 3044 2r5028 P/0 by Plohman respecting responses to questions (Supply) 3431 ; Alcock 3431 ; Asslnlbola Downs Ashton 3431-2; Downey 3431 ; Praznik 3432; Status ruled out of order (Dacquay) 3432 P/0 by �respecting supplementary C. Evans 130; Stefanson 130-1 questions 269; Ashton 269; Winter harness racing ruled out of order 269 C. Evans 130; Stefanson 130 Privilege, Matters of Legislative Building security 4437 Assl nlbol ne Memorial Curling Cl ub Private Members' Business See Nonpolitical statements Address for Papers Public Health Amendment Act Asslnlbolne River Diversion Legal opinion 2494-7 Employment creation Resolutions Cerilli 3169; Enos 31 69 Education, distance 4656-9 Environmental assessment-Federal Government contracts, issuing of 3840 Cerilli 2463-4; Cummings 2464; Manitoba/Russia agreement 3077-80 Doer 3577 -8; Downey 3577-8 Medicare, preservation of 3728-30 FederaVProvincial review Postal rate increase, rural newspapers 659-60 Cummings 926; Driedger 926; C. Evans 926 Real Property AmendmentAct (Bill 7) Irrigation purposes 2r529-35 Cerilli 3168-9; Enos 3168-9 Salvation Army Grace General Hospital Jurisdiction Incorporation Amendment Act (Bill 39) Cerilli 2464; Cummings 2464 2r 1641-4; 3r 3831 Reportstatus Social Allowances Amendment and Consequential Cerilli 3271-2; Enos 3271 -2 Amendments Act (Bill 70) Treaty land entitlements 2r 4901 -9; 3r 5379-82 Cerilli 2464; Cummings 2464 Tabled papers See also Pembina Valley Water Co-operative Labour disputes CKND Television Proposal regarding union activities (T.P. 35) Associated CountryWomen of the World 1610 Day The Pas Health Complex Incorporation Amendment See Nonpolitical statements

10 Hansard Index

Association for a Cl ean Rural Environment Barrett, Becky- Cont. Environment Act violation Child and Family Support Cummings 1778; Gaudry 1778 2329-33, 2388-95, 2398-2402 Pesticide container disposal Family Conciliation 2443-5 Cummings 1778; Gaudry 1777-8 Family Dispute Services244 7-52 Review Seven Oaks Centre for Youth Cummings 1778; Gaudry 1778 Child Day Care 2048-57 BFI Waste Systems Income Security and Regional Operations Landfill site Central Directorate 1898 Cummings 1114; Edwards 1113-4 Income Maintenance Programs 1899-1907 Income Supplement Programs 1955-9 Ball review provisions, changes to Regional Operations 1959-60, 2046-7 See Private Members'Business-Resolutions Opening remarks Response 1808-1 0 Barrett, Becky(W ell ington) Registration and Licensing Bee-Keepers Repeal Act (Bill 11) Residential Care Licensing18 97-8 2r 904-5 Vital Statistics18 96-7 Budget debate Rehabilitation and Community Living 1283-9 Administration 2136-43 Child and Family Services Amendment Act Community Living and VocationRehabilitation (Bi11 64) Adult Services21 78-9 2r 2476-88; 3r 5371 -5 Children's Special Services217 9-87, 2189-91 City of Winnipeg Amendment, Municipal Manitoba Developmental Centre 2226-9 Amendment and Consequential Amendments Special Employment Programs Act (Bi11 45) Employability Enhancement 2240-3 2r 1 125-31 Human Resources OpportunityCentre 2232 Consumer Protection Amendment Act (Bill 54) Partnerswith Youth 2327-8 2r 1650-1 Youth Programs 2234-8 Consumer Protection Amendment Act (4) (Bill 61) Franchises Act (Bill 18) 2r 3544 2r 4487-9 Economic Innovation and Technology Council Act Health Services Insurance Amendment Act (Bill 51) (Bi11 9) 2r 4493-5 2r839-45 Homesteads, Marital Property Amendment and Family Maintenance Amendment Act (Bill 89) Consequential Amendments Act (Bill 88) 2r 4586; 3r 5327-8 2r 4585; 3r 5327 Family Services,Department of (Supply) Law Reform (Miscellaneous Amendments) Act Administration and Finance (Bill 72) Agency Relations Bureau 1890-3 2r 3340-5 Children's Advocate 1814-9, 1878-9 Lodge Operators and OutfittersLicensing and Executive Support18 14 Consequential AmendmentsAct (Bill 22) Information Systems 1895 2r997-1002 InternalAudit 1889-90 Manitoba Advisory Council on the Status of Women Minister's salary 2454 Amendment Act (Bill 5) Policy and Planning 1879-84 2r 576-82;3r 5319-21 Social Services Advisory Committee18 79 Ministerial Statements Child and Family Services Domestic Violence Community Advisory Administration 2328-9 Committee

11 Hansard Index

Barrett, Becky - Cont. Barrett, Becky - Cont. Response 15 Curriculum committee 3900 International Women's Day Domestic violence Response 1046 Education/preventionprograms 4884 Nonpolitical statements Governmentprograms 18 AIDS Candlelight Memorial 3371-2 Pedlar Reportrecommendations 4884-5 InternationalWomen 's Day 1022 Employability Enhancement Programs Manitoba athletic achievements 1499 Funding 2250 National Access Awareness Week 3990-1 Independent Living Program National Social Work Week 879 Accommodation selection4505 Optometry AmendmentAct (Bill 81 ) Case review 4505-6 2r 3876-7 Lindenview Residence Oral Oqestions Funding decrease 4099 Aboriginal Child and Family Services Manitoba Tax Assistance Office Independent review 4740 Closure 620-1 Internal review 4739-40 Manitoba Telephone System Aboriginal women Call Management System 270 ACCESS program 1052 Pedlar Commission Program accessibility1 051-2 Recommendations 18, 1761 -2 Bill 70 Service de Conseiller Impact on women 2676 Funding 3957-8 Broadway House Suche Report Alternate facility 137 4 Governmentresponse 3989 Closure 1374 Recommendations 2880 Employees' status 137 4 Workingcommittee 2880 Child and Family Services University of Manitoba Resources 2015 Student safety 1761 -2 Response time 2014 Women's issues Child day care Government initiatives 3676 Centre licensing 358 Pension BenefitsAmendment Act (Bill 76) Fee schedule 1607 2r 5012-5; 3r 5386-8 Funding,federal 359 Petitions Funding formula 358 Criminal CodeAmendments Government policy 1607 1489; ruled in order 1652 National strategy Fight Back Against Child Abuse campaign Governmentsupport 725-6 462; ruled in order 510 Child day care centres 551 ; ruled in order 595 Private centres 594; ruled in order (Dacquay) 617 Government support2597 684;ruled in order (Dacquay) 723 Child day care workers 722; ruled in order (Dacquay) 749 Salary enhancementgrants 2596-7 791 ; ruled in order 81 8 Child development initiative 870; ruled in order 965 Per capita policy 3170-1 965; ruled in order 1013 Child poverty 1013; ruled in order 1041-2 Federal Minister's statements 31 70 11 08;ruled in order 1155 Children's Advocate 1316; ruled in order 1365 Mandate 2880 1365; ruled in order 1415 Children's residential facilities 1604; ruled in order 1653

12 Hansard Index

Barrett, Becky- Cont. Barrett, Becky - Cont. 1701 ; ruled in order 1752 90-6 1770; ruled in order 191 0 Urgent Public Importance,Matters of 201 2; ruled in order 21 01 Domestic violence 27-8, 39-31 2192; ruled in order 2245 See also Privilege, Matters of 2868; ruled in order 2984 3162; ruled in order 3265 Bear, Elsie 331 3; ruled in order 3360 See Nonpoliticalstatements 3842; ruled in order 3891 3950; ruled in order 3978 Bee-Keepers Repeal Act (BIII 11) 4160; ruled in order 4199 1 r Findlay 170; 2r Barrett 904-5; Points of Order Carstairs 527-8; Findlay 483-5; P/0 by McCrae respecting word "cowardly" Plohman 713-20; Santos847 -8; (Barrett) 2287; Wowchuk 845-7;referred to Standing ruled out of order (Dacquay) 2287; Committeeon Agriculture; Members cautioned 2288 R!SFindlay 5218-9; 3r 5227; RIA5491 Private Members' Business Address for Papers BeerIndu stry Public Health Amendment Act U.S. aluminum containers Legal opinion 2285-8 Cerllli 1115; Cummings 1115 Resolutions Bail review provisions, changes to 3947-8 Beverage Container Act (Bill 50) Daycare, rural 3886-7 1 r Carstairs 618; 2r Carstairs 1 006-8; Environmental Youth Corps 4365-6 Lamoureux 1741-2 Reproductive health 201 0-1 Violence, education against 1149-51 Beverage containers Women, violence against 4027-9 Deposit system Privilege,Matters of Carstairs 1421 -1 ; Almon 1421-2 Wellington, Member for Misrepresentation of facts Blll 70 Carstairs 594; Amendments remarks withdrawn (Barrett) 594 Gilleshammer 2799,3674; Resolutions Martindale 2799, 3674 Domestic violence-free zone,Manitoba Cost savings 1071-7,3878 Carstairs 21 08- 9; Gilleshammer 21 09 Salvation Army Grace General Hospital Financial impact study request Incorporation Amendment Act (Bill 39) Doer 4298-9; Downey4300; 2r 1961 Gilleshammer 4299 Social Allowances Amendment and Consequential Impact on women Amendments Act (Bill 70) Barrett3676; Mitchelson 3676 2r 51 34-7 Justification Status of Women (Supply) Gilleshammer 41 03; Martindale41 03 Advisory Council on the Status of Women 4414,4419-20 Blll 86/87 Opening remarks Adjudication process Response 4406-8 Edwards 5269; McCrae 5269 Women's Directorate 4410-4,4420-1 Consultations Throne speech debate Edwards5268-9; McCrae 5269-70

13 Hansard Index

Bill86/87- Cont. Bills - Cont. Withdrawal Amendment Act (Bill 53) Chomiak 5266-7; McCrae 5266-7 Dental Association Amendment Act (Bill 80) Denturists Amendment Act (Bill 6) Blll 87 Economic Innovation and Technology Council Correspondence (T.P. 196) Act (Bill 9) Chomiak 5266 Environment Amendment Act (Bill 49) Environmental Bill of Rights (Bill 2) Bill C-20 Family Maintenance Amendment Act (Bill 89) Extension Farm Income Assurance Plans Amendment Act Doer 685-6; Filmon 685-6 (Bi1143) Government position Farm Practices Protection and Consequential Filmon 221-2; Wasylycia-Leis 221 -2 Amendments Act (Bill 82) Legal opinion Franchises Act (Bill 18) Filmon 222; Wasylycia-Leis 222 Garnishment Amendment Act (Bill 8) Health Care Directives Act (Bill 16) Bill C-22 Health Care Directives and Consequential Extension Amendments Act (Bill 73) Doer 5262-3; Filmon 5262-4 Health Care Records Act (Bill 36) Health Services Insurance Amendment Act Bills (Bill 51) See specificBills Health Services Insurance Amendment and Administration of Oaths of Office, an Act Consequential Amendments Act (Bill 75) respecting the (Bill 1) Highway TrafficAmendment Act (Bill 15) Amusements Amendment Act (Bill 42) Highway TrafficAmendment Act (2) (Bill 63) Animal HusbandryAmendment Act (Bill 12) Highway TrafficAmendment Act (3) (Bill 83) Appropriation Act, 1992 (Bill 1 03) Highways and TransportationDepartment Bee-Keepers Repeal Act (Bill 11) Amendment Act (Bill 14) Beverage Container Act (Bill 50) Highways Protection and Consequential Business PracticesAmendment Act (Bill 27) Amendments Act (Bill 79) Business Practices Amendment Act (2) (Bill 62) Homesteads, Marital Property Amendment and Child and Family Services Amendment Act Consequential Amendments Act (Bill 88) (Bill64) Human Rights Code Amendment Act (Bill 40) Child and Family Services Amendment Act (2) Immigration Consultants Registry Act (Bill 32) (Bill 66) Interim Appropriation Act, 1992 (Bill 67) City of Winnipeg Amendment Act (Bill 30) Interpretation Amendment Act (Bill 3) City of Winnipeg Amendment Act (2) (Bill 35) Jury Amendment Act (Bill 46) City of Winnipeg Amendment Act (3) (Bill 78) Labour Relations Amendment Act (Bill 85) City of Winnipeg Amendment, Municipal Law Enforcement Review Amendment Act Amendment and Consequential Amendments (Bill 87) Act (Bill 45) Law Reform (Miscellaneous Amendments) Act Constitutional Referendum Act (Bill 26) (Bill 72) Consumer Protection Amendment Act (Bill 54) Law Society Amendment Act (Bill 74) Consumer Protection Amendment Act (2) Liquor Control Amendment Act (Bill 77) (Bill 57) Liquor Control Amendment Act (2) (Bill 91) Consumer Protection Amendment Act (4) Loan Act, 1992 (Bill 1 02) (Bill 61) Lodge Operators and Outfitters Licensing Dangerous GoodsHandling and Transportation and Consequential Amendments Act (Bill 22)

14 Hansard Index

Bills- Cont. Bills- Cont. Manitoba Advisory Council on the Status of (Bill 94) Women Amendment Act (Bill 5) SurveysAmendment Act (Bill 34) Manitoba Evidence Amendment Act (Bill 38) Tax Appeals Commission Act (Bill 95) Manitoba Hydro Amendment Act (Bill 1 0) The Pas Health Complex Incorporation Manitoba Multiculturalism Act (Bill 98) Amendment Act (Bill 52) ManitobaTelephone Amendment Act (Bill41) University of Manitoba Amendment Act (Bill 25) Mental Health Amendment Act (Bill 93) Vacations with Pay Amendment Act (Bill 33) Milk Prices Review Amendment Act (Bill44) Winnipeg Bible College andTheological Municipal Amendment Act (Bill 31) Seminary Incorporation Amendment Act Municipal Assessment Amendment Act (Bill 20) (Bill 97) Municipal Assessment Amendment Act (2) Workers Compensation Amendment Act (2) (Bill 99) (Bill 55) Municipal Council Conflict of Interest Amendment Act (Bill 29) Board of Review Optometry Amendment Act (Bill 81) Patient Records Access and Confidentiality Act Chaulk, Robert (Bill 17) Chomiak 624; McCrae 624 Pension Benefits Amendment Act (Bill 76) Governmentrepresentation Pension Plan Acts Amendment Act (Bill 1 00) Chomiak 624; McCrae 624 Personal PropertySecurity Amendment Act See also Justice, Department of (Supply)-Public (Bill4 8) Prosecutions PettyTrespasses Amendment Act (Bill47) Post-Adoption Registry Act (Bill 24 ) Borden Company Ltd. PrivateTraining Accountability Act (Bill 23) Closure Provincial Auditor's Amendment Act (Bill 92) Ashton 1 055; Stefanson 1 055 Provincial Park Lands Amendment Act (Bill 21) Labour adjustment strategy Provincial Police Amendment and Consequential Amendments Act (Bill 86) Hickes 1776; Stefanson 1776-7 Public Health Amendment Act (2) (Bill 56) PublicTrustee Amendment,Trustee Amendment Border Crossings magazine and Child and Family Services Amendment See Nonpolitical statements Act (Bill 68) Real PropertyAmendment Act (Bill 7) Brandon General Hospital ResidentialTenancies Amendment Act (Bill 65) ResidentialTenancies Amendment Act (2) Budget reduction (Bill 84) l. Evans 602; Orchard 602-3 Retirement Plan Beneficiaries Act (Bill 71) Funding Salvation Army Grace General Hospital l. Evans 1773 -4,308 8-9; Incorporation Amendment Act (Bill 39) Orchard 1774, 30 88-9 Seven Oaks General Hospital Incorporation labour adjustment strategy Amendment Act (Bill 90) l. Evans 1774; Orchard 1775 Social Allowances Amendment and Palliative care unit Consequential Amendments Act (Bill 70) L. Evans 1165; Orchard 1165 Special Operating Agencies Financing Servicereduction Authority Act (Bill 96) L. Evans 560, 603, 3089; Statute Law Amendment Act, 1992 (Bill 1 01) Orchard 560, 603, 3089 Statute Law Amendment (T axation) Act, 1992 See also Petitions

15 Hansard Index

Brandon Mental Health Centre Budget - Cont. Replacement facility Downey 924; Manness 924; Plohman 923-4 Cheema 3415; Orchard 3415-6 Economic growth Manness 921; Storie 921 Brandon School of Psychiatric Nursing Education/training Closure Doer 920; Manness 920 Dewar 1758; Orchard 1758 Education, post-secondary Doer 1109; Filmon 1109; Manness 1109 Brandon University Employment creation strategy Annual Financial Report, 1991 (S.P. 23 ) Doer 401, 919-20, 1 013-4; L. Evans 1325; Derkach 352 Filmon 1014-5; Manness 402, 920, 921-2, 1325-6; Storie 921 Breast cancer Employment retraining programs Government initiatives Alcock 405-6; Man ness 406 Orchard 291; Wasylycia-Leis 291 Fiscal Stabilization Fund See also Ministerial statements Carstairs 1178; Manness 1178 Impact Bristol Aerospace Ltd. The Pas, Manitoba Chemical burning Lathlin 752; Manness 752 Cummings 824; Dewar 824 Introduction date Environmental concerns Doer 354; Filmon 354 Cummings 824; Dewar 824 Revenue sources Cleanup costs Manness 921; Storie 921 Cummings 4281; Dewar 4281 Student Aid Pipeline Alcock 975; Vodrey975 Boundary review Unemployment rate forecast Cummings 4281 ; Dewar 4281 Doer 920; Manness 920 Environmental concerns Cummings 4281; Dewar 4281 Budget address Waste rocket fuel burning Manness 1166-73 Cummings 1607; Edwards 1607 Waste rocket fuel disposal Budget debate Cummings 1608; Edwards 1607-8 Alcock 1445-53; Ashton 1312-5, 1330-4; Barrett12 83-9; Carstairs 1237-47; Broadway House Cerilli 1293 -9; Cheema 1305- 12; Alternate facility Chomiak 1377-85; Connery 1334-42; Barrett137 4; Gilleshammer 1374 Cummings 1277-83 ; Doer118 3-92; Closure Downey 1348-55; Ducharme 1205-12; Barrett13 74; Gilleshammer 1374 Edwards 1270-7; C. Evans 1453 -5; Employees' status L. Evans 1198-1205; Filmon 1478-86; Barrett13 74; Gilleshammer 1374 Gaudry 1390-1400; Harper 1406-10; Lamoureux 1342-8; Lathlin 1355-9; Budget Laurendeau 141 0-4,142 5-6; Civi�rvice layoffs Manness 1439-45;Martindale 1433-9; Ashton 1182-3; Praznik 1182-3 McAlpine 1263-70; Mcintosh 1299-1305; Construction industry Mitchelson 1385-90; Neufeld 1359-64, 1375-7; L. Evans 1326; Manness 1326 Orchard 1218-20, 1233-7; Penner 1400-6; Crop insurance Reimer 1192-8; Rose 1289-93; Santos 1426-33;

16 Hansard Index

Budget debate - Cont. CKND Television strike - Cont. Stefanson 1455-60; Storie 1460-3, 1475-7; Unfair labour practices Wasylycia-Leis 1212-8 Ashton 161 01; Praznik 1611

Budget-Federal CMEC Education, post-secondary See Council of Ministers of Education, Canada Alcock 729; Manness 729-30 Employment creation strategy CN Rail Doer 723; Filmon 723 Bayline upgrade Finance Minister's position Ashton 4305; Driedger 4305 Carstairs726-7; Manness 726-7 Job relocations Impact cultural programs Driedger 51; Reid 51 Friesen 799-800; Mitchelson 799-800 Layoffs National Science Council Doer 2458-60; Driedger 52; Filmon 2459-61; Alcock 730; Filmon 730 Reid 52, 2460-1 Student Aid Producer car drop off Alcock 730; Vodrey 730 Driedger 2257; Wowchuk 2257 See also PrivateMembers' Business-Resolutions Business Practices Act Restitution CRISP program Maloway 626, 692; Mcintosh 626, 692 Funding Filmon 1324-5; Lamoureux 1324 Business Practices Amendment Act See also Social assistance (BIII 27) 1 r Cheema 467; 2r Cheema 1 006; CT Scanning Committee Maloway 4153-5; Reimer 2067 -9; See Ministerial statements Sveinson 2564-5 Canada Health Act Business Practices Amendment Act (2) Tray fee regulation (BIII 62) Cheema 2255-6; Orchard2255-6 1 r Mcintosh 117 4-5; 2r Cheema 3970-1; Maloway 3544-50;Mcintosh 1975-6; referred Canada-Manitoba Enabling Vote (Supply) to Standing Committee on Economic Ashton 5055-6; Doer 5055; McCrae 5055-6 Development; RISMcintosh 5307; 3r 5315; RIA 5492 Canada Pension Plan Business relocations Benefit increase Governmentdiscussions Ducharme 1711 ; Santos1711 Filmon 3849; Storie 3849 Canada-u.s. trade deficit CFB Shllo Impact labour force Continuation Man ness 1177; Storie 1177 L. Evans 691; Stefanson 691 Canadian Airlines International CKND Television strike Centralization Government advertising policy Driedger 2577; Reid 2577 Ashton 1162-3, 1611 ; Filmon 1163; Employment creation strategy Praznik 1162-3, 1611 Driedger 2578; Reid 2577-8

17 Hansard Index

Canadian AirlinesInternatio nal - Cont. CARSTAIRS, Sharon (River Heights, LIB) Reservationoffice Animal HusbandryAmendment Act (Bill 12) layoffs 2r528-9 Driedger 2577; Reid 2577 Appropriation Act, 1992 (Bill 1 03) 3r5482-4 Canadian Centre for DiseaseControl Bee-Keepers Repeal Act (Bill 11) Start date 2r527-8 Doer 724-5; Filmon 724-5 Beverage Container Act (Bill 50) 1r 618; 2r 1006-8 Capital Supply Budget debate 1237-47 See Supply, Capital Child and Family Services Amendment Act (Bill64) CareerStart program 2r 5123-7; 3r 5370-1 Centralized administration Child and Family Services Amendment Act (2) l. Evans 1180; Gilleshammer 1180 (Bill 66) Funding 1 r 1717; 2r 2839-40 L. Evans 1180, 2107, 2874; Condolence, Motions of Gilleshammer 1180, 2874; Einarson, Henry John 612-3 Manness 21 07 Hillhouse, Thomas Paterson 608 Funding restoration Witney, Charles H. 605-6 l. Evans 973, 1326; Manness 973; ConstitutionalReferendum Act (Bill 26) Gilleshammer 1326 1r468 Status report Education and Training, Department of (Supply) l. Evans 2875; Gilleshammer 2875 Administration and Finance Administration and Professional Certification CARR, Jim (Crescentwood, LIB) 2725-7 Resigned January 27, 1992 Financial Services271 8-9 Nonpolitical statements Management Information Services 2720-1 Hanukkah 26-7 Personnel Services271 5 International Human Rights Day 132 Planning, Research and Policy Co-ordination Oral questions 2629-35 Conawapa dam project Bureau de !'education francaise Contractvalidity 225-6 Division administration 31 34-5 Expenditures-Manitoba Hydro 130 Financial Support-Schools Expenditures-Ontario Hydro 129-30 School Grants and Other Assistance legal opinion request 267 2823-4, 2899-2902, 2958-9, 2963 Postponement 129 Teachers' Retirement Allowances 2965 Public Utilities Board Opening remarks Review 268 Response 2549-53 Renegotiation 361 Program Development and SupportServices Surplus power268 Child Care and Development 3122-4 Tabled papers Curriculum Services 2967-75 Conawapa dam project Distance Education and Technology 3126-7 Order in Council-Ontario(T .P. 5) 226 Manitoba Schoolfor the Deaf 3032-3 Throne speech debate Native Education 2977-9 379-83 Student SupportProgram 31 30-2

18 Hansard Index

Carstalrs, Sharon - Cont. Carstalrs, Sharon - Cont. Executive Council (Supply) Multilateral discussions Management and Administration Response 2248-9, 2844-5, 3362-3, 4595-6 1544-8, 1584, 1589-90, 1593-4, 1598-9, 1601-3 Constitutional process proposal Opening remarks Response12 22-3 Response 1535-8 First Ministers' Conference Family Services, Department of (Supply) Response 1705-6 Administrationand Finance International Women's Day Minister's salary 2454-6 Response 1046-7 Child and Family Services Linnet (International) agreement Child and Family Support Computer mapping system 2334-8, 2385-8, 2395-8 Response 512-3 Family Conciliation 2446-7 Natural Lands and Special Places Workbook Family Dispute Services2452-3 Response 3844 Seven Oaks Centre for Youth 2440-3 Seniors Month Child Day Care 2057-64 Response 5402 Rehabilitation and Community Living Social assistance Administration 2143-52 Off-reserve Status Indians Community Living and VocationRehabilitation Response 3671 Children's Special Services21 87-9 Thompson, Manitoba Manitoba Developmental Centre 2229-30 Downtown revitalization Special Employment Programs Response 1614 Employability Enhancement 2243 Western Governors' Association Conference Human Resources Opportunity Centre2233-4 Response 5262 Youth Programs2238-40 Western Premiers' Conference Grievance, Matterof Response 3409-1 0 Rural Development, Minister of Women, violence against School board interference National day of remembrance Carstairs 4555-9 Response 14 Health Care Directives and Consequential Municipal Assessment Amendment Act (Bill 20) Amendments Act (Bill 73) 2r 3562-3, 3861 -3 2r 4292-6 Nonpolitical statements Interim Appropriation Act, 1992 (Bill 67) Manitoba's 122nd birthday3276-7 C/W16 79-82 Marriage congratulations20 84 Liquor Control Amendment Act (2) (Bill 91) National Missing Children's Week 3794 2r 3859-62 Petr, Jacqueline Manitoba Advisory Council on the Status of Women Olympic competitor, ice dancing 477 Amendment Act (Bill 5) Pockar, Brian 2r525 Canadian figure skating champion, death of Manitoba Hydro Amendment Act (Bill 1 0) 2801 2r 3550-6 Roblin, Senator Duff Manitoba Multiculturalism Act (Bill 98) Retirement 4887-8 2r 4514-21 Saint Patrick's Day 1329 Ministerial statements Ukraine independence 26 Aboriginal issues Westray, NovaScotia mine accident 3324 National meeting Oral questions Response 919 Abitibi- Price-Pine Falls Constitutional meeting Licensing process 3954-5

19 Hansard Index

Carstalrs, Sharon - Cont. Carstalrs, Sharon - Cont. Mediation process 3954 Multilateral discussions 822-3 Aboriginal Child and Family Services National standards4599-600 Public inquiry 3790-1 News briefing request4277-8 Anishinaabe Child and Family Services Notwithstandingclause 4164-5 Funding formula 52-3 Public hearings 4739,5405 Beverage containers Referendum823, 3088,4098-9, 4203 Deposit system 1421-2 Renegotiation 4883-4 Bill 70 Senate reform 3087-8,4202 Cost savings 2108-9 Spending powers 5405 Budget Dutch elm disease Fiscal Stabilization Fund 1178 Government position 799 Budget-Federal Research and development funding 5408 Finance Minister's position 726-7 Economic growth Charter of Rights and Freedoms Employment creation strategy 174,727 Governmentsupport 1468-9 Forecast justification 1178-9 Child and Family Services Governmentstrategy 289 Accountability 3269 Education and Training,Department of Communication process2015-6 Underspending 922 Child day care Education, post-secondary Special needs children 4988 Accessibility 2462 Child day care centres Education system Funding formula 1050 Administrative costs2793 Restraining orders,enforcement 2352-3 Curriculum development 2793-2 Staff layoffs 1051 Exceptional student programs funding 3848 Subsidized space allocation 1051 Grade 10 curriculum changes 4571-2 Children's Advocate School closures Reportingprocess 1257,2016,3270 Guideline review 2592 Community-based health care system Student achievement levels 2848-9 Tax relief program 4431 Transportationpolicy review 2592 Community colleges Vocational programs funding 3848 Accessibility 2852 Employability Enhancement Programs Employment training initiatives 2079 Funding 2252-3 Enrolment 2851-2 Employment retraining programs Student appeal process 559-60 Funding 621-2 Conawapa dam project Governmentcommitment 2461 Justification 2508 Family life education Legal opinion request 518 Compulsory curriculum 3321 Public UtilitiesBoard Family Services,Department of Review 518,2508-9 Internal review 3270 Renegotiation 794 Review Constitutional proposal Aboriginal agencies, relations with 4880-1 Aboriginal representation 873 Finance Ministers' meeting Areas of agreement 4276-7 Labour adjustment strategy 222 Bilateral discussions-Quebec872-3 Social programs 222-3 Delegation of powers 4203 First Ministers' Conference Government position 4738-9 Education and training initiative 290,1494 Multiculturalism 5405-6 Government agenda 290,1493

20 Hansard Index

Csrstslrs, Shsron - Cont. Csrsts/rs, Shsron - Cont. Forestry industry Provincial revenues Sustainable development 972-3 Additional sources 622 Foster care RCMP services Parental training program 31 43-4 Falcon Beach detachment 2357 Standards review 31 44 RCMP uniforms Goods and services tax Government position 1568 Harmonization 402, 599 Red River Community College Reporttabling request 599-600 Nursing curriculum 161 0 Government Services, Department of Repap Manitoba Inc. Leasing Branch Benefits to Manitoba 752-3 Information tabling request 1321-2 Bunker tank relocation 794-5 Green Team program Employment creation strategy 757, 1017 Justification 5270 Environmental inspection794 Gross Revenue Insurance Program Expenditures 756 Marketing boards 295 Financial status 1016-7 Health care system Renegotiation 753-4 Health Smart Card 3679-80 Restraining orders, enforcement of Reform Departmentalco-ordination 2353 Bridge funding 3367-8 Rural Development, Minister of Continuing care 4430-1 School board interference 4546-8 Implementation plans 19 School Division Boundary Review Information release 19 Cancellation 1369-70 Monitoring process3366-7, 3412-3, 3532-3 Commitment 2592-3 Public awareness campaign 5112-3 Impact Francophonegovernance 1370 U.S. residents, services to 19-20 Schooldivisions Waiting list review 3533 Funding formula 1164-5 Health, Department of Information delivery 3675-6 Underspending 922 Seven Oaks Centre for Youth Highway Construction Program, National Closures 1257 Funding commitment, Federal 1708-9 Length of stay 4303-4 Funding commitment, Provincial 1709 Social assistance Independent Living Program Abuse rate 174 Cost effectiveness 4502 Employment training programs 174 Statistics4501 Food allowance 2988-9, 3043 Labour Force Development Agreement Provincial tax credit 356-7 National standards 5170 Special needs 357 Manitoba Liquor Control Commission Social assistance-students Fetal alcohol syndrome warnings3043-4 Categorization 1755-6 Midwifery Regulation changes 1756 Government initiatives 2687-8 Student Aid Nopiming Provincial Park Appeal process2876 Wildernessstatus 972 Application statistics 2875 Port of Churchill Emergency assistance2462 Future status 4984-5 Funding 2875 Shipment statistics 4984 Unemployment, youth Provincial deficit Government strategy Increase 922 470-1, 2078, 2196-7, 2252

21 Hansard Index

Carstalrs, Sharon - Cont. Carstalrs, Sharon - Cont. Pension Benefits Amendment Act (Bill 76) Carstairs 594; 2r 4747-8 remarks withdrawn (Barrett) 594 Petitions Resolutions Children's Advocate Domestic violence-free zone, Manitoba 1068-71 2684; ruled in order 2789 Riel, Louis 2789; ruled in order 2841 Role in development ofManitoba 3654-6 2841;ruled in order 2868 Social Allowances Amendment and Consequential 2984; ruled in order 3035 Amendments Act (Bill 70) 3264; ruled in order 331 3 2r 3863-5; 3r 5378-9 331 3; ruled in order 3360 Status of Women (Supply) 3529; ruled in order 3574 Advisory Council on the Status of Women 3842; ruled in order 3950-1 441 4-9 41 60; ruled in order 41 98 Opening remarks 4272; ruled in order 4297-8 Response 4408-10 4297; ruled in order 4426-7 Women's Directorate 4416-20, 4423-4 4426; ruled in order 4497 Tabled papers 5401; Conawapa dam project Dutch elm disease program funding Legal opinion-liberal (T.P. 13) 518 791 ; ruled in order 819 Keystone Agricultural Producers Points ofOrder Correspondence (T.P. 121) 3862 P/0 by Carstairs respecting words "completely Repap Manitoba Inc. honest" (Manness) 754; Globe and Mail article (T.P. 24) 1017 Members cautioned(D acquay) 754 Statement of claim-Quean's Bench (T.P. 20) P/0 by Carstairs respecting past precedent 2585; 794 taken under advisement 2585; Throne speech debate Speaker's ruling 2882 133-43 P/0 by Mannessrespecting supplementary Urgent Public Importance, Matters of questions 125; Carstairs 125; Martindale12 5; Domestic violence 33-4 Members cautioned 125 Economic crisis 423-5 P/0 by Manness respecting question anticipating Goods and services tax debate (Carstairs) 3043; Ashton 3043-4; Harmonization 408 question rephrased 3044 Rural Development, Minister of Post-Adoption Registry Act (Bill 24) School board interference 4552 1r397 Private Members' Business Centre Culture! Franco-Manltobaln Address for Papers Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 11) Public Health Amendment Act Mitchelson 169 Legal opinion 957-8 Resolutions CERILLI, Marianne (Radisson, NDP) Constitutionalreferendum for Canada 2902-5 Budget debate Education, distance4659-61 1293-9 Voter's list, permanent 2782-3 Culture, Heritage and Citizenship, Department of Private Training Accountability Act (Bill 23) (Supply) 1r398 Administration and Finance Privilege, Mattersof Executive Support4689-91 Wellington, Member for Citizenship Misrepresentation of facts Immigration Policy and Planning

22 Hansard Index

Cerllll, Marianne - Cont. Cerllll, Marianne - Cont. 4857-64, 4926-41 4949-51 Beer industry ' Multiculturalism U.S. aluminum containers 1115 Multicultural Secretariat 5039-47 Civil Service Commission Dangerous Goods Handling and Transportation Affirmative Action co-ordinator 4430 Amendment Act (Bill 53) Conawapa dam project 3r5325-6 Public Utilities Board Economic Innovation andTechnology Council Act Referral 872 (Bill 9) Dauphin Lake 2r887-90 Environmental concerns3651 Environment Amendment Act (Bill 49) Domtar site 2r4578-50 Cleanup 293-4 Environment, Departmentof (Supply) Soil testing costs 4204-5 Administration and Finance Earth Summit Planning and Innovation 5095-7 Communications with the Premier 4276 Environmental Management Endangered spaces Environmental Operations 5101-6 Site selection criteria 3987 Environmental Bill of Rights (Bill 2) Tall grass prairie program 1658, 3987 1r 169-70 Environment, Department of Environmental Innovations Fund(S upply) Work order enforcement 556 5075-80, 5090-2 Foreign domestic workers Human Rights Code Amendment Act (Bill 40) Investigations 2895-6 1r353 Foreign Domestic Workers' program Labour Relations Amendment Act (Bill 85) Government access 3534 2r5023-5 Government position 1 021-2 Manitoba Multiculturalism Act (Bill 98) Labour law coverage 3533 2r 5164-5;RIS 5397 -8; 3r 5429-31 Minister's consultations3534 Manitoba Telephone AmendmentAct (Bill 41) Immigration policy 1r 353 Governmentrecommendations 4879 Ministerial statements Refugee claimants 4880 Immigrant Credentials,Working Group on Lakes and rivers Executive Summary Copper sulphate buildup 2016-7 Response 1252 Manitoba Grants Advisory Council Nonpolitical statements Review 4601 Citizenship awards 197 4 Manitoba Intercultural Council Earth Day 2468 Review 4577 International Day for the Elimination of Multicultural legislation Racial Discrimination Affirmative Action, impact on 4429-30 1474 Amendments4601 InternationalHuman Rights Day 132 .. Consultations 4503 Oral questions Justification 4504 Assiniboine River diversion Multicultural Resource Centre Employment creation 31 69 Closure 124 Environmental assessment, Federal 2463-4 Education resources12 4 Irrigation purposes 3168-9 Multicultural Secretariat Jurisdiction 2464 Activities 3956 Report status 3271 -2 Hiring policy 58 Treaty land entitlements 2464 Political influence5267-8

23 Hansard Index

Cer/111, Msr/snne - Cont. Cer/111, Msr/snne - Cont. Report tabling request 3956-7 1108; ruled in order 1156 Oak Hammock ConservationCentre 1604; ruled in order 1653 Ducks Unlimited complex 2080-1 Pointsof Order Environmental assessments 269 P/0 by Mannessrespecting preambles to Oral Government credibility 269 Questions (Cerilli) 2463; Oak Hammock Marsh development Members cautioned2463 Government withdrawal 4275-6 Private Members' Business Sewage treatment 191 4-5 Address for Papers Ozone Depleting Substances Act Public Health Amendment Act Enforcement795 Legal opinion 3564-5 Pesticide usage Resolutions Biologicalalternatives 4987-8 Domestic violence-free zone, Manitoba Environmental licensing 4987 1106-7,3878 Malathion 4988 Tabled papers Prime Oil Company Domtar site Work order extension 556 Correspondence (T.P. 7) 293 Race relations policy Ducks Unlimited Education system 1494 1992 calendar (T.P. 6) 269 Programs funding 1495 Foreign domesticworkers Recycling, glass 795 Correspondence (T.P. 122) 3896 Contract consultations2746 Throne speech debate Recycling,newspaper 795 151-7 Sewage lagoon-Oak Point Environmental concerns 2796-7 Channel Area Loggers Ltd. Environmental impact assessment 2797 Annua1 Report,1991 (S.P. 53) Public hearings 2797 Downey 791 Tender process Review 2746 Charterof Rights and Freedoms Waste oil disposal Governmentsupport Reporttabling request4550 Carstairs14 68-9; Filmon 1468-9 Soil contamination 4550 Water and waste water management CHEEMA, Guizar (The Maples, LIB) Certificateprogram 3044-5 Budget debate Water and Waste Water School 1305-12 Government support2994, 3044 Business PracticesAmendment Act (Bill 27) Western Canadian Wildlife Services 1r467 ;2r 1006 Oak Hammock Marsh report268 Business Practices AmendmentAct (Bill 62) Petitions 2r 3970-1 Criminal Codeamendments Child and Family ServicesAmendment Act 1248; ruled in order 1317 (Bill 64) 1365; ruled in order 1416 2r 3972-7 1770; ruled in order 1909 Consumer and Corporate Affairs, Department of 1965; ruled in order 2012-3 (Supply) 2349; ruled in order 2457 Administration and Finance Dutch elm disease program funding Minister's salary 4623 2192; ruled in order 2296 Consumer Affairs Fight Back Against Child Abuse campaign Consumers' Bureau 4607-8, 461 0-3

24 Hansard Index

Cheema, Guizar - Cont. Cheema, Guizar - Cont. Opening remarks Insured Benefits Response 4442 Salaries 3217-21 Consumer Protection Amendment Act (4) LotteriesFunded Programs 2r3970 Health Policy Evaluation and Research Culture, Heritage and Citizenship, Department of Initiative (Supply) 3233-5 Administration and Finance Opening remarks Executive Support4685-8 Response 1517-23 Dental Association Amendment Act (Bill 80) Provincial Mental Health Services 2r3962-3 Administration DenturistsAmendment Act (Bill 6) 2696,2700-4, 2711 -4,2804, 2808-1 4 2r 801 -2 Health ServicesInsurance Amendment Act (Bill 51 ) Health Care Direct ives Act (Bill 16) 1 r 618; 2r 1008-11 1 r 398; 2r 1 002-3 Health Services Insurance Amendment and Health Care Directives and Consequential Consequential AmendmentsAct (Bill 75) Amendments Act (Bill 73 ) 2r 4590-1 2r4389-92 Housing, Departmentof (Supply) Health, Department of (Supply) Administrationand Rnance Administrationand Finance Executive Support43 72-4 Evaluation and Audit Secretariat Finance and Operations 4378-9,43 80-3 2177-8,2209-17,2313-21' 2359-74,2416-23 Opening remarks Executive support15 75-83,17 90-3,17 99, Response 43 69 1848-55,1867-73,1 929-33,1944-6,2029-31 ' Program Developmentand Support 2038- 9,21 19-29,21 67-8,2170-4 Administration 4383 Health Information Systems 2430-3 Grants and Subsidies 43 98-9 Minister's salary Research and Planning 43 85-9, 43 92 ) 3235,3237-9,3240-1 ' 3285-7,3420-2 Interim Appropriation Act, 1992 (Bill 67 Alcoholism Foundation of Manitoba 3233 2r 1664-8; C/W17 64-6 Continuing Care Programs Manitoba Multiculturalism Act (Bill 98) Administration 2668-7 4 RIS 53 98-9 Health Services Mental Health Amendment Act (Bill 93 ) Administration 2r 4889 281 5-23 ,2886, 2913- 24,2942-5, 2996-7 ' Ministerial statements 3009-1 5,3095-3101,3105-7,3177-8 Breast CancerScreening Capital Construction 3214-5 Reportof the Working Group Emergency Health and Ambulance Services Response 968-9 3213-4 CT Scanning CommitteeReport Hospital and Community Health Services Response 23 01 3178-86 Canadian Men's Curling Championship Laboratory and Imaging Services320 4-1 0 Response 1250 Health ServicesInsurance Fund 3229-30 Manitoba Centrefor Health Policy and Healthy Public Policy Evaluation Administration2437-9 Response 465-6 Health Promotion, Protection and Disease Nonpolitical statements Prevention Children's Hospital Research Foundation 2519-22,2528- 34,261 1-9 Wear Your Bear day 3961 Healthy Child Development 2655-9,2662-4 Festival of Vaisakh 21 11

25 Hansard Index

Chasms, Guizar - Cont. Chasms, Guizar - Cont. Friesen, Henry Surgery waiting lists 176-7 Medical Research Council of Canada 3046 Health SciencesCentre Holocaust Awareness Week 2750 Hip/knee replacement surgery 796-7 Philippine Heritage Week 4308-9 Home care program Winnipeg Hawks Triple "A" Bantam hockey team Licensed practical nurses' role 3898 Western Canadian Bantam Champions 5410 Human rights case Winter Olympics Governmentinvolvement 4205-6 Manitoba participants627-8 Licensed Practical Nurses Optometry Amendment Act (Bill 81 ) Educational opportunities 3898 2r 3963-4 Governmentsupport 625-6, 874-5 Oral questions Mental health care system Brandon Mental Health Centre Bed closures 4742 Replacement facility 341 5 Community-based services4742 Canada Health Act Misericordia Hospital Tray fee regulation 2255-6 Emergency ward closure 1969-70 Community-based health care system Mental health care 3039 Government initiatives 1471 Mount Carmel Clinic Government policy 1259 Cross-cultural counsellingunit 5115 Government priorities 1260-1 Multicultural legislation Licensed Practical Nurses' role 3852 Consultations 5116 Health care facilities Public health organizations Bed closures 1111-2, 1470 Funding 1259-60 Health care system Rent regulations Anesthetist manpowerreview 2201 Enforcement1659 Anesthetist shortage17 7 Legal opinion request 1659 Cataractsurgery 826 St. Boniface Hospital Deinsurance 2510-1 Bed closures 4280 Fee schedule reform 3677-8 School of Licensed Practical Nurses 3851 Hip/knee replacementsurgery 826 Urban Hospital Council Labour adjustment strategy 1471 Mental health care Multicultural policy 5115 Recommendations 3040 Out-of-province patients 2304 Misericordia Hospital review 473 Public accountability21 06-7 Reportrequest 557 Reform Patient Records Accessand Confidentiality Act Bed closures 3370 (Bill 17) Bridge funding 3371 1r 398-9 Co-ordination 3091 -2 Points of Order Deinsurance 22 P/0 by � respecting words "at least be Home care program 3370 honest" (Cheema) 23; Hospital closure 23 withdrawal requested 23 Implementation 4987 P/0 by Wasylycia-Lejsrespecting word "hypocrites" Meeting request 3167-8 (Orchard) 1785; Cheema 1785; Monitoring process4987 taken under advisement (Laurendeau) 1795; Nursing education 3851 withdrawal requested 2022; Professional training co-ordination4550-1 withdrawn (Orchard) 2022 Specialty treatments 23 Private Members' Business U.S. residents,services to 557-8 Resolutions

26 Hansard Index

Cheems, Gulzsr - Cont. Child and Family services Amendment Aboriginal Justice Commission 1554-6 Act (Bill 64) Medicare, five principles of 5358-62 1 r Gilleshammer 1320; 2r Barrett 2476-88; Residential Tenancies Amendment Act (2) (Bill 84) Carstairs 5123-7; Edwards 2n6-9; 2r4751 Gilleshammer 19n-9; Lamoureux 3972-7; Resolutions referred to Standing Committee on Riel, Louis Industrial Relations; RIS Gilleshammer 5333; Role in development of Manitoba 3667 3r Barrett 5371 -5; Carstairs 5370-1 ; Seven Oaks General Hospital Incorporation Doer 5368 -70; RIA 5492 Amendment Act (Bill 90) 2r 3880-1 Child and Family services Amendment Supply, Capital Act (2) (Bill 66) Supply, Committee of 5280-91, 5336-9 1 r Carstairs 1717; 2r Carstairs 2839-40; Tabled papers Laurendeau 3835-7; Lamoureux 3834-5 Health care system Bed closures Child day care Correspondence(T.P. 167) 4280 Centre licensing Correspondence (T.P. 188) 4987 Barrett358; Gilleshammer 358 Mental health care Fee schedule Correspondence (T.P. 69) 2809 Barrett16 07; Gilleshammer 1607 Misericordia Hospital Funding, Federal Emergency ward closure (T.P. 49) 1969 Barrett359; Gilleshammer 359 Pharrnacare Funding formula Correspondence (T.P. 79) 2996 Barrett358; Gilleshammer 358 Ultrasoundprostrate biopsies Government policy Correspondence (T.P. 80) 2996 Barrett16 06; Gilleshammer 1606 Urgent Public Importance,Matters of National strategy Economic crisis 454-6 Government support Barrett725-6; Almon 725-6 Chief Electoral Officer Special needs children Statutory Report, 1990 (S.P. 130) Carstairs 4988; Gilleshammer 4988-9 Rocan 5260 See also Family Services, Departmentof (Supply)

Child abuse Child day care centres See Domestic violence Funding formula Carstairs 1050; Gilleshammer 1050-1 Child and Family services Private centres Accountability Government support Carstairs 3269; Almon 3269 Barrett2597; Gilleshammer 2597 Communication process Restraining order enforcement Carstairs 2015-6; Gilleshammer 2015-6 Carstairs 2352-3; Gilleshammer 2352-3 Resources Staff layoffs Barrett2015; Gilleshammer 2015 Carstairs 1051; Gilleshammer 1051 Response time Subsidized space allocation Barrett201 4; Gilleshammer 2014-5 Carstairs 1051; Gilleshammer 1051 See also Aboriginal Child and Family Services; Anishinaabe Child and Family Services; Family Child day care, rural Services, Depa�ent of (Supply) See PrivateMembers' Business-Resolutions

27 Hansard Index

Child day care workers Chinesecooking wine Salary enhancement grants Alberta legislation (T.P. 51) Barrett2596 -7; Gilleshammer 2597 Hickes 2082 Sale restrictions Child development Initiative Hickes 1971, 2082-3; Mcintosh 1971 , 2082-3 Per capita policy Barrett 3170-1; Gilleshammer 31 71 CHOMIAK, Dave (KIIdonan, NDP) Budget debate Child Guidance Clinic 1377-85 Audiology program City of Winnipeg Amendment Act (2) (Bill 35) Chomiak 3172-3; Orchard 31 72-3 3r 370-3 Funding formula City of Winnipeg Amendment Act (3) (Bill 78) Chomiak 4306; Vodrey 4307 2r 51 37-8 Government position City of Winnipeg Amendment, Municipal Chomiak 3897, 3959,4307 ; Manness 3897-8; Amendment and Consequential Amendments Vodrey 3959-60,4307 Act (Bill 45) Servicereplacement 2r 1119-24 Chomiak 1261 -2; Vodrey 1261 -2 Economic Innovation and Technology Council Act (Bill 9) Child poverty 2r 985-92 Federal Minister's statements Education and Training, Department of (Supply) Barrett3170 ; Gilleshammer 31 70 Administration and Finance Governmentinitiatives Administration and Professional Certification Doer 262-3; Filmon 262-3 2721-5,2727-8 Executive Support 2553-9, 2623-4 Children's Advocate Financial Services 2718 Mandate Management Information Services271 9-20 Barrett 2880; Gilleshammer 2880 Personnel Services 2638-9,27 16-7 Reportingprocess Planning,Research and Policy Co-ordination Alcock 1228; Carstairs 1257,201 6,3270 ; 2624-9,2635-8 Gilleshammer 1228,12 57, 2016,3270 Bureau de !'education francaise See also Family Services, Department of (Supply) Division Administration31 32-3 -Administration and Finance; Petitions Financial Support-Schools Phase-In Support 2963-4 Children's Dental Health Program SchoolsGrants and Other Assistance Service reduction 2728-30,2824-36 ,2896-9, 2959-6 2 Orchard 2850; Wasylycia-Leis 2850 Teachers' Retirement Allowances2964-5 Opening remarks Children's Hospital Research Foundation Response 2545-9 See Nonpoliticalstatements Post-Secondary, Adult and Continuing Education and Training Children's residential facilities Student Financial Assistance 3935-6 Curriculum committee Program Development and Support Services Barrett3900 ; Gilleshammer 3900 Child Care and Development 31 18-22 Curriculum Services 2975-7 Childs Lake Distance Education and Technology 31 24-6 Water level Division Administration 2966-7 Enns 2466; Wowchuk 2466 Manitoba School for the Deaf 3033-4

28 Hansard Index

Chomlak, Dave - Cont. Chomlak, Dave - Cont. Native Education 2979 Bill 86/87 Student Support Program 3127-30 Withdrawal 5266-7 Garnishment Amendment Act (Bill 8) Board of Review 2r 537-8 Chaulk, Robert 624 Health Care Directives and Consequential Government representation 624 Amendments Act (Bill 73) Child Guidance Clinic 2r 4589-90 Audiology program 3172-3 Jury Amendment Act (Bill 46) Funding formula 4306 2r 647 Government position 3897, 3959, 4307 Justice, Department of (Supply) Service replacement 1261 -2 Administration and Finance City of Winnipeg Act Policy, Planning and Special Projects41 30-2 Community committee role 4099-41 00 Public Inquiry into the Administration of Domestic violence Justice and Aboriginal People Bail conditions 974 4133 Rehabilitation programs 974 Corrections Education and Training, Departmentof Administration4240 Deputy Minister Justice Salary increase 2509 Civil Legal Services 4237 Executive Support Opening remarks Salary increase 2509 Response 41 29 Education Reform, Panel on Public Prosecutions Reportrelease 3990 Board of Review Education system Salaries 4143 Child Guidance Clinic 4576 Salaries 4133-6, 4140-3 Dropout rate 2352, 2358, 2792, 3321 -2 Provincial Policing 4147-8 Funding formula 792-3, 1020, 1112-3 Law Enforcement Review Amendment Act (Bill 87) Grade 1 0 curriculum changes 4576 2r 4748-50; 3r 5414-6 Program reductions 174-5 Law Reform (Miscellaneous Amendments) Act School year length 2358 (Bi11 72) Special needs funding 876 2r 3156-61 , 3333-5 Taxation levels 175 Law Society Amendment Act (Bill 74) Hearing disorder screening 2r 41 84-5 Program funding 2575 Manitoba Evidence Amendment Act (Bill 38) Impaired driving 2r 743-5 Stayed charges review 2878 Ministerial statements Judicial system Education, multicultural Bail reviews 2879 Policy for the 1990s Charging directives 3531 -2 Response 3163-4 Public defender system 1779 Impaired drivers, victims of Two-tiered system 1780 Response 286-7 Law Enforcement Review Agency Nonpolitical statements Civilian participation4985-6 Ukraine independence 25 Racism investigations 2307-8 Yes, I Can Awards 758 Legal Aid Services Society of Manitoba Oral questions Funding 1232 Aboriginal Justice Inquiry Report Labour dispute 1495-6 Recommendations 3039 Pedlar Commission

29 Hansard Index

Chom/ak, Dave - Cont. Chomlak, Dave - Cont. Recommendation 625, 3532 2nd Report 5474 Policing servicesagreement Provincial Police Amendment and Consequential Fee-for-servicecosts 4205-6, 4278, 4737-8 Amendments Act (Bill 86) Pornography 2r 4745-7 Government policy 341 1-2 Public Trustee Amendment, Trustee Amendment RCMP services and Child and Family ServicesAmendment Act Shooting (Bill 68) Independent investigation 3039 2r 2865-7 Racism investigations Real Property Amendment Act (Bill 7) Policing services29 91 , 3038 2r 535-6 St. Vital School Division Retirement Plan Beneficiaries Act (Bill 71) Funding formula 792-3 2r3963-5 School divisions Statute Law Amendment Act, 1992 (Bill 1 01) Election postponement 600 3r 5416-7 French language division 600 Tabled papers Schools, independent Bill 87 Agreement tabling request 1422 Correspondence (T.P. 196) 5266 Funding formula 1112, 1422-3, 1469-70, 1760 Policing services agreement Schools, public Correspondence (T.P. 183, 184)4737 Enrolment decline 2021 Schools, independent Small School Rural Workshops Correspondence (T.P. 30) 1422 Cancellation 469-70 Small School Rural Workshops Personal Property Security Amendment Act Correspondence (T.P. 12) 470 (Bill 48) Throne speech debate 1 r 2855-7 345-50 Petitions Urgent Public Importance, Mattersof Criminal Code amendments Domesticviolence 35-7 1221; ruled in order 1249 Economic crisis 452-4 1316; ruled in order 1366 1701 ; ruled in order 1752 Churchill Research Range Fight Back Against Child Abuse campaign Expansion 462; ruled in order 510 Johnson 6 551 ; ruled in order 595 594; ruled in order (Dacquay) 61 7 Citizenship awards 684;ruled in order (Dacquay) 723 See Nonpoliticalstatements 722; ruled in order (Dacquay) 749 791 ; ruled in order 81 8 Citizenship Week, National 870; ruled in order 917 See Nonpoliticalstatements 91 7; ruled in order 965 1013; ruled in order 1042 City of WinnipegAmendment Act (Bill 30) PettyTrespasses Amendment Act (Bill 47) 1 r Edwards 398 2r 41 83-4 Private Members' Business City of Winnipeg Amendment Act (2) Resolutions (8111 35) Crime PreventionCouncil 860-2 1 r Ernst261 ; 2r Edwards 299-302; Ernst 296-8; Violence, education against 1 153-4 Friesen 298-9; referred to Standing Committee Privileges and Elections, Standing Committee on on Municipal Affairs; R!S Ernst 363;

30 Hansard Index

City of Winnipeg - Cont. Civil Service Commission - Cont. 3r Chomiak 370-3; Doer 373-6; Edwards 376-8; Lamoureux 55-6, 58; Ernst363-4; Friesen 364-6; Maloway 368-70; Praznik 55-6, 57, 177-8 Reid 366-8;RIA Johnson 395 Supplementary information 1992-93 Estimates (T.P. 156) City of Winnipeg Amendment Act (3) Praznik 41 61 (8111 78) Voluntary incentive program 1 r Ernst 2350 2r Chomiak 5137-8; Alcock 1115; Praznik 1115 Edwards 5138-50;Ernst 2751 -4; Friesen 5144-5; Gaudry 5141-4; Reid 5140-1 ; Civil service Commission (Supply) referred to Standing Committee on Law Ashton 4312-22; Lamoureux 4322-33; Amendments; RIS Praznik 5328; Praznik 4312-33 3r Edwards 5427-8; Opening remarks Friesen 5423-7; RIA 5492 Praznik 4310 City of Winnipeg Amendment, Municipal Response Amendment and Consequential Ashton 431 1-2; Lamoureux 4312 Amendments Act (Bill 45) Clean Environment Commission 1 r Ernst596; 2r Alcock 1 124-5; Annuru Report, 1991 (S.P. 31) Ashton 1137-45, 1981-2; Barrett 1125-31 ; Cummings 397 Chomiak 1119-24; Dewar 1995-2001 , 2087-8; Funding Doer 1033-40; Downey 2099; Edwards 1023-7; Cummings 1230-1 ; Edwards 1230-1 Ernst 643-6; L. Evans 1982-9; Friesen 2092-9; Jurisdiction Lamoureux 994-6; Maloway 1989-95; Cummings 3951-2; Doer 3951 -2 Martindale 1 027-33; Reid 1131-7; Provincial park land usage Santos 2088-92; referred to Standing Committee Cummings 969-70; Doer 969-70; on Municipal Affairs; RIS Manness 2469; Manness 970-1 3r Ernst 2474-5; Friesen 2469-74; RIA 2494

Civil servants ClearwaterLake, Manitoba Layoffs Government nursery closure Alcock 1 1 15-6; Manness 1115-6; Downey 923, 925; Enns 23, 3983; Plohman 1116; Praznik 1116 Lathlin 23, 923, 3983 Senior salary levels College Ashton 473-4; Praznik 474 Westman region positions Admission policy Downey 3645;L. Evans 3645 Derkach 357-8; Harper 357-8

Civil service Commission Committee of the Whole Affirmative action See specific Bills Comparative profile (T.P. 168) Interim Appropriation Act, 1992 (Bill 67) Praznik 43 12 Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 30) Commonwealth Day message Praznik 397 Rocan 1041 Comparative employment (T.P. 169) Praznik 4312 Communications Industry Political interference Employment statistics Ashton 57, 1n-8; Rlmon 57, 58; Ernst 4097; Storie 4097

31 Hansard Index

Communications Initiative Conswsps dam project - Cont. Research and development funding Cost projections Alcock 3894; Stefanson 3894 Downey 521 ; Edwards 521 Delays, impact of Communities Economic Development Doer 4428; Filmon 4428 Fund Economic viability Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 40) Cummings 359; Edwards 359 Downey 551 Environmental delay Cummings 359; Edwards 359 Community college governance Environmental panel Jurisdiction Inter-departmental conversion team (T.P. 97) Cummings 3952-3; Doer 3952-3; Vodrey 3299 Filmon 3953-4 Report Community colleges Cummings 4574-5; Edwards 4574-5 Accessibility Environmental review Carstairs 2852; Friesen 601 ; Vodrey 601 , 2852 Johnson 6 Alternatives Expenditures-ManitobaHydro Friesen 1755; Vodrey 1755 Carr 130; Neufeld 130 Applied Sciences courses Expenditures-Ontario Hydro Doer 1109-10; Manness 1110 Carr 129-30; Neufeld 130 Employment training initiatives Governmentposition Carstairs 2079; Vodrey 2079 Downey 2464-5; Edwards 2464 Enrolment Intervenerfunding Alcock 406; Carstairs 2851 -2; Manness 406; Cummings 4575; Edwards 4575 Vodrey 2852 Justification Funding Carstairs2508; Filmon 2508 Film on 1708; Friesen 601 , 1050, 1708, 1755; legal opinion-liberal (T.P. 13) Vodrey 601 , 1050, 1755 Carstairs 518 Funding restoration legal opinion request Friesen 874; Vodrey 874 Carr 267; Carstairs 51 8; Downey 518; Student appeal process Neufeld 267-8 Carstairs 559; Vodrey 559-60 liberal opinion See also Education and Training, Department of Governmentresponse (Supply); specific colleges Downey 2464; Edwards 2464 Manitoba Hydro Community Support Programs (Supply) Pamphlet review lotteries Funded Programs Downey 41 00-1 ; Edwards 41 00-1 Doer 5059; Manness 5059 Order in Council-Ontario (T.P. 5) Carr 226 Compton, Jim Penalty clauses See Nonpolitical statements Doer 2507; Filmon 2507 Renegotiation Conawapa dam project Doer 4428-9; Filmon4429 Contract validity Postponement Carr 225-6; Neufeld 226 Carr 129; Neufeld 129 Correspondence (T.P. 173) Power projections Doer 4428 Doer 41 62; Downey 41 62

32 Hansard Index

Conawapa dam project - Cont. Connery, Edward - Cont. Premier's discussions Budget debate Doer 2507-8; Filmon 2507-8 1334-42 Public Utilities Board Industry, Trade and Tou rism, Department of Referral (Supply) Cerilli 872; Cummings 872; Manness 872 Industry and Trade Division Review Industry Carr 268; Carstairs 518, 2508-9; Sectoral Development 4838-42 Downey 517-9, 2465; Edwards 2465; Nonpolitical statements Filmon 2509; Hickes 517-8; Neufeld 268 Manitoba Developmental Centre Renegotiation Accreditation 1424 Carr 361 ; Carstairs 794; Downey 555, 794; Rae, Don Edwards 554-5; Neufeld 361 Order of the Buffalo Hunt recipient 3681 Surplus power Wright, Amanda Carr 268; Neufeld 268 Winter fun poster contest winner 731 Sustainable development Oral questions Doer 4162-3; Downey 4163 Long Plain Indian Reserve Winnipeg Chamber of Commerce position Tree-growing contract 1114 Edwards 521-2; Filmon 522 NorthAmerican Free Trade Agreement See also Energy and Mines, Departmentof (Supply) Impact agricultural industry 1373 Older Worker Adjustment, Program for Condolence, Motions of Status report 1161-2 Portage Ia Prairie, Manitoba Einarson, Henry John Bridge inspection 3678-9 Carstairs 612-3; Doer 612; Downey 614-5; Bridge replacement 3679 Driedger 61 5; Enns 613; Filmon 61 1-2; Seafood Enterprises Association Orchard 61 3-4 Agreement 757 Hillhouse, Thomas Paterson Stephenfield reservoir Carstairs 608; Dewar 608; Doer 607; Irrigation licensing603-4 Enns 610-1 ; Filmon 606-7;Helwer 610; Vegetable producing industry McCrae 61 0; Praznik 608-10 Day haul worker program, Federal 1373 Witney, Charles H. U.S. inspections 1373 Carstairs 605-6; Doer606; Enns 606; Water rights Filmon 604-5; Storie 605 Priorities 604 Points of Order Conflict of Interest P/0 by &blQnrespecting words wReverend Declarations Blackjack from Burrowsw (Connery) 452; Resolution 20 withdrawn 452 Edwards 654 P/0 by Connery respecting words wwe are having biased chairing in this Housew 1993; CONNERY, Edward (Portage Ia Prairie, PC) taken under advisement (Dacquay) 1993; Resigned June 23, 1992 ruled out oforder 251 4 Agriculture, Departmentof (Supply) Private Members' Business Agricultural Development and Marketing Division Resolutions Marketing Branch 3919 Crime Prevention Council 862-3 Soils and Crops Branch 3906-1 1 PTH 101 safety 1083-5 Manitoba Crop Insurance Corporation Rural Development, Departmentof (Supply) Administration 3695-3700 Administration and Finance

33 Hansard Index

Connery, Edward - Cont. Constitutions/Issues - Cont. Brandon Office 3447 Notwithstanding clause Rural Economic Development Division Carstairs 41 64-5;McCrae 4164-6 Economic Development Services Public hearings Grants 3488-9 Carstairs47 39, 5405; Doer 3982; Salaries 3482-8 Downey 3982-3; Almon 4739, 5405 Infrastructure 3480-1 Referendum Throne speech debate Carstairs 823, 3088, 4098-9, 4203; 180-8 Doer 820-1, 4499-500; Downey 4098-9; Urgent Public Importance, Matter of Filmon 821 , 823-4, 3088, 4499-500; Economic crisis 450-2 McCrae 4203 Renegotiation Conservation Districts of Manitoba Carstairs 4883-4; Almon 4883-4 Annua1 Report, 1990 (S.P. 77) Senate reform Derkach 1706 Carstairs 3087-8, 4202; Almon 3087-8; Annual Report, 1991 (S.P. 114) McCrae 4202 Derkach 3981 Spending powers Carstairs 5405; Filmon 5404 Constitutional Issues Timetable Aboriginal representation Doer 4500; Almon 4501 Carstairs 873; McCrae 873 See also Ministerial statements; Private Members' All-party committee Business-Resolutions; Unity Committee report Doer 819, 3085-6; Filmon 81 9, 3085-6 Areas of agreement Constitutional Referendum Act (Bill 26) Carstairs 4276-7; McCrae 4277 1 r Carstairs 468 Bilateral negotiations- Carstairs 872-3; McCrae 872-3 Consumer and Corporate Affairs, Cultural programs, devolution of Departmentof Friesen 4506-7; Mitchelson 4506-7 Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 109) Delegation of powers Mcintosh 3643 Carstairs 4203; Doer 4095-6; Downey 4095-6; Executive support McCrae 4203 Salary increases Government position Chomiak 2509; Vodrey 2509 Carstairs 4738-9; McCrae 4738-9 Supplementary information Housing responsibility 1992-93 Estimates (T.P. 157) Ernst 1375; Martindale 1375 Mcintosh 41 99 Legal opinion request Doer 3084-5; Almon 3085 Consumer and Corporate Affairs, Multiculturalism Department of (Supply) Carstairs 5405-6; Filmon 5406 Multilateral discussions Administration and Anance Carstairs 822-3; Almon 823 Minister's salary National programs, protection of Cheema 4623; Lamoureux 4622-3; Doer 4735-7; Filmon 4735-7 Martindale4622 ; Mcintosh 4622-3 National standards Research and Planning Carstairs 4599-600; McCrae 4600-1 Gaudry444 7-8; Maloway 4443-7; News briefing request Mcintosh 4443-8 Carstairs 4277-8; McCrae 4278 Consumer Affairs

34 Hansard Index

Consumer and Corporate Affairs - Cont. Core Area Initiative Consumer's Bureau Education program Alcock 461 3-20; Cheema 4607-8, 4610-3; Ernst 1230; Friesen 1230; Vodrey 1230 Lamoureux 4609-1 0; Martindale 4459-62; Inner City Foundation Mcintosh 4459-62, 4607-20 Ernst 129; Friesen 129 Corporate Affairs Proposed projects Manitoba Securities Commission Ernst 129; Friesen 128 Martindale 4621 ;Mci ntosh 4621 Public consultations Regulations Ernst 228, 3792; Friesen 228, 3792 Alcock 4621 -2; Mcintosh 4621-2 Renewal Opening remarks Ernst 1370-1 ; Friesen 1370-1 Mcintosh 4439-41 Replacement Response Ernst 128, 3792; Friesen 128, 3791-2 Cheema 4442; Maloway 4441-2 See also Inner cityrenewal; Nonpolitical statements; Private Members' Consumer protection Business-Resolutions; Urban Affairs, Legislation Departmentof (Supply)-Urban Policy and Maloway 626; Mcintosh626 Agreement Management See also Advertising, misleading Council of Ministersof Education, Canada Consumer Protection Amendment Act Communique (T.P. 3) (Bill 54) Derkach 169 1 r Maloway 1223; 2r Barrett 1650-1 ; Maloway 1647-9 Courtof Queen's Bench Consumer Protection Amendment Act (2) Appeal screening court (Bill 57) Edwards 292-3; McCrae 292-3 1r Maloway 792; Crime Prevention Council

Consumer Protection Amendment Act (4) See PrivateMembers' Business-Resolutions (Bill 61) 1 r Mcintosh 1 175; 2r Ashton 3970; Barrett3544; Crime prevention programs Cheema 3970; Maloway 3538-44; Funding Mcintosh 1975; referred to Standing Committee Edwards 4168; McCrae 41 68-9 on Economic Development; RIS Mcintosh 5307; 3r 531 5; RIA 5491 Criminal Code Co-operative housing See Petitions See Housing, co-operative Crocus Investment Fund Co-operative Loans and Loans Guarantee Establishment Board Johnson 3 Annual Report, 1991 (S.P. 128) Stefanson 4877 Crop Insurance Big game/waterfowl damage Co-operative Promotion Board Findlay 41 01-2; Wowchuk 4101-2 Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 127) Crop adjuster salaries Stefanson4877 Findlay 227; Plohman 227

35 Hansard Index

Crop Insurance - Cont. Culture, Heritage and Citizenship - Cont See also Agriculture, Department of Supplementary information (S upply-Incom e Insurance and Support Program; 1992-93 Estimates (T .P. 171) Budget Mitchelson 4427

Cross-border shopping Culture, Heritage and Citizenship, Departmentof (Supply) Government actions Doer 1 048-9; Filmon 1049 Administration Government Services, Department of Executive Support U.S. purchase policy Cerilli 4689-91 ; Cheema 4685-8; Stefanson 5264; Storie 5264 Friesen 4668-79; Lamoureux 4679-80, Government strategy 4684-5, 4692-5; Mitchelson 4668-80, 4684-95 Filmon 5265; Stefanson 1016, 5264; Human Resource Services Storie 1015, 5264-5 Lamoureux 4695-7; Mitchelson 4695-8 Industry, Trade and Tourism, Department of Manitoba Film Classification Board Stefanson 1016; Storie 1016 Friesen 4698; Mitchelson 4698 Industry, Trade and Tourism, Department of Minister's salary (T.P. 23 ) Friesen 5050-1 ; Lamoureux 5050-1 ; Storie 1016 Mitchelson 5050-2 Citizenship Crow benefit Immigration Policy and Planning Cerilli 4857-64, 4926-41 , 4949-51 ; Government position Lamoureux 4816-7, 4941-9; Findlay 360-1 ; Plohman 360-1 Mitchelson 4816-7,4857-64, 4926-51 Payment plan Culture, Heritage and Recreation Programs Driedger 3268; Findlay 3268-9, 3578-9; ArtsBranch Plohman 3268, 3578-9 Friesen 4807-9; Lamoureux 4809-1 0; Public hearings Mitchelson 4807-1 0 Findlay 361 ; Plohman 361 Executive Administration See also Western Premiers ' Conference Friesen 4698-9, 4796-4802; Lamoureux 4700; Mitchelson 4698-9, 4795-4802 Crown Corporations Council Grants to Cultural Organizations Annual Report, 1991 (S.P. 119) Friesen 4803-6; Lamoureux 4802-3; Manness 4162 Mitchelson 4803-6 Historic Resources Crown Lands Act Friesen 4815; Lamoureux 48 14; Wildlife baiting regulations Mitchelson 481 4-5 Edwards 2308-9; Enns 2308-9 Public Library Services Friesen 4812-3; Lamoureux 481 0-2 ; Culture, Heritage and Citizenship, Mitchelson 481 1-3 Departmentof Regional Services Annua1Report, 1991 (S.P. 78) Lamoureux 4815; Mitchelson 48 15 Mitchelson 1753 Multiculturalism Community Places Programs, 1992-93 Multicultural Secretariat (T.P. 172) Cerilli 5039-47; Friesen 5047-9; Mitchelson 4427 Lamoureux 5030-9; Mitchelson 503 0-9 Hiring authority Opening remarks Filmon 1 054; Lamoureux 1054 Mitchelson 4623 -8, 4664-5

36 Hansard Index

Culture, Herltsge snd Citizenship (S upply) - Cont Cummings, Hon. Glen - Cont. Response Licensing process 3955 Friesen 4665-7; Lamoureux 4667-8 Medication process 3954 Ashern, Manitoba ¥CUMMINGS, Hon. Glen (Ste. Rose, PC) Alternate water source 4986-7 Minister of Environment} Environmental concerns 4986 Minister charged with the administration of he Manitoba Public Insurance Corporation) Ground water contamination 2877 Budget debate Soil/watertesti ng 4986 1277-83 Assiniboine River Diversion Clean Environment Commission Environmental assessment, Federal 2464 Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 31) 397 FederaVProvincial review 926 Dangerous Goods Handling and Transportation Jurisdiction 2464 Amendment Act (Bill 53) Treaty land entitlements 2464 1 r 61 9; 2r 739-40; RIS 52 19 BFI Waste Systems Landfill site 1114 Education and Training, Departmentof (Supply) Beer industry Post-Secondary, Adult and Continuing Education U.S. aluminum containers 1115 and Training Bill 49 Program Analysis, Co-ordination and Support Government strategy 3650-1 3504-7 Justification 3650 Environment Amendment Act (Bill 49) Bill 82 1 r 596; 2r 737-8; 3r 5394 Mandate 3680 Environment, Department of Bristol Aerospace Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 6) 122 Chemical burning824 Supplementary information Environmental concerns 824 1992-93 Estimates (T.P. 159) 41 99 Cleanup costs 4281 Environment, Departmentof (Supply) Pipeline Administration and Finance Boundary review 4281 Planning and Innovation 5093-7 Environmental concerns4281 Environmental Management Waste rocket fuel burning 1607 Environmental Operations 5098-5106 Waste rocket fuel disposal 1607 Environmental Innovations Fund (Supply) Clean Environment Commission 5071-80, 5090-3 Funding 1230 Manitoba Hazardous Waste Management Jurisdiction 3951 -2 Corporation Provincial park land usage 969-70 Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 1 00) 2846 Conawapa dam project Manitoba Public Insurance Corporation Economic viability 359 Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 59) 919 Environmental delay 359 Messages Environmental panel Bill 49 (S.P. 46) 596 Jurisdiction 3952-3 Bill 53 (S.P. 48) 519 Report 4574-5 Oral questions Intervenerfunding 4575 Association for a Clean Rural Environment Public Utilities Board Environment Act violation 1778 Referral 872 Pesticide container disposal 1778 Dauphin Lake Review 1778 Environmental concerns3651 Abitibi-Price-Pine Falls Domtar site De-inking plant 4207-8 Cleanup 293-4

37 Hansard Index

Cummings, Hon. Glen - Cont. Cummings, Hon. Glen - Cont. Soil testing costs 4204-5 Sewage treatment 1914-5 Ducks Unlimited headquarters Ozone Depleting Substances Act Environmental assessment-Federal 871 Enforcement 795 Funding withdrawal 871 Pesticide usage Impact tourism 871 Biologicalalternatives 4988 EarthSummit Environmental licensing 4987 Communications with the Premier 4276 Malathion 4988 Endangered spaces Prime Oil Company Tall grass prairie program 1658 Work order extension 556 Environment, Department of Pur-A-Tone hog operation Work order enforcement 556 Environmental concerns3679 Environmentalists Rafferty-Alameda dam project Minister's position 359 Environment, Minister of Furnace inspections Involvement 3272-3 Faulty heat exchangers 2512 Renegotiation 3272 Government reports Recycling, glass 795 Environment friendly products 228 Contract consultations 2746 Grand Rapids, Manitoba Recycling, newspaper 795 Environmental monitoring 41 67 Recycling programs Grand Rapids Generating Station Distributor's costs 4207 Environmental concerns331 8 Repap Manitoba Inc. Oil spill 1161 Bunker tank relocation 794-5 Stability 41 67 Environmental inspection 794 Hazardous waste Sewage lagoon-Oak Point Contaminated soil 4435-6 Environmental concerns2797 Pesticide container classification 2355 Environmental impact assessment 2797 Impaired driving Licensing process 2798 Third-partybenef its 3792-3 Public hearings 2797-8 Lakes and rivers Shoal Lake, protection of Copper sulphate buildup 201 7 Manitoba regulations 21 05-6 Manitoba Hazardous Waste Management Corp. Minister's communications 2104-5 Negotiations-A.M.of Montcalm 926 Negotiations-Ontario 2506 PCB storage site 2081 -2 Stony Mountain, Manitoba Mining operations Environmental concerns476-7, 689 Dust control 4991 Funding 690 Natural Resources, Departmentof Funding-Federal 689 Waste dumping-Winnipeg Floodway 4301 Sustainable development Nopiming Park-Forestry Government commitment 1231 Environmental mediator 21 99 Tender process Land division 2200 Review 2746 Negotiations 21 99 Waste oil disposal North American Free Trade Agreement Reporttabling request 4550 Deadline 1605 Soil contamination 4550 Government position 1605 Water and waste water management Public hearings 2791 Certificate program 3044-5 Oak Hammock Marsh Water and Waste Water School DucksUnlim ited complex 191 2-3, 2080-1 Government support2995 , 3044

38 Hansard Index

Cummings, Hon. Glen - Cont. Dscqusy, Louise - Cont. Points of Order Piche, Travis P/0 by Plohman respecting relevancy of debate 2nd place trophy, National Chess competition (Cummings) 3505; 3900-1 ruled in order (Dacquay) 3505 Petitions Private Members' Business Fight Back Against Child Abuse campaign Resolutions Barrett594; ruled in order(Dacquay) 617 Postal rate increase, rural newspapers 658-9 Barrett684; ruled in order(Dacquay) 722 Barrett722; ruled in order (Dacquay) 749 Chomiak 594; ruled in order(Dacquay) 617 Custody dispute Chomiak 684; ruled in order (Dacquay) 723 Dauphin, Manitoba Chomiak 722; ruled in order (Dacquay) 749 Gilleshammer 4435; Plohman 4434-5 Reid 617; ruled in order (Dacquay) 684 Reid 722; ruled in order(Dacquay)749 DACQUAY, Louise (Seine River, PC) Wasylycia-Leis 595; ruled in order (Dacquay) 61 7-8 Budget debate Wasylycia-Leis 684; ruled in order (Dacquay) 1431-3 722 Introduction of Guests Manitoba Heritage Federation Charleswood Junior High, Grade 9 Granting authority (Charleswood)4274 Lamoureux 3529; ruled in order (Dacquay) Desjardins, Larry 4272 Former MLA (St. Boniface) 684 Points ofOrder H.S. Paul School, Grade 5 P/0 by A§b!Qnrespecting brevity of question (Seine River) 684 and answers 688; Inwood School, Grades 7-9 Members cautioned (Dacquay) 688 (Interlake) 723 P/0 by A§b!Qnrespecting brevity ofquestions Linwood School, Grade 5 and answers 757; (Sturgeon Creek) 723, 750 Members cautioned (Dacquay) 757 Phoenix Elementary School, Grade 5 P/0 by MblQnrespecting Chair's assumption (Charleswood) 619 Member has risen on a point of order 531 ; Victor Mager School, Grade 9 taken under advisement (Dacquay) 531 ; (Riel) 619 ruled in order 827 Voyageur '92 students 41 62 P/0 by AiJmmrespecting relevancy of Law Amendments, Standing Committee on debate 1066; Praznik 1066; 1st Report 1042-4 Members cautioned (Dacquay) 1066 2nd Report3405-6 P/0 by &!Jllimrespecting members reading from 4th Report 5107-8 prepared text 3437; Enns 3437-8; Municipal Affairs, Standing Committee on ruled out of order (Dacquay) 3438 1 st Report 352 Ruling challenged 3438; 2nd Report 1653 Sustained 3438 3rd Report 2296-7 P/0 by Carstairsrespecti ng words "completely 4th Report 2349 honest" (Manness) 754; Nonpolitical statements Members cautioned (Dacquay)754 Canadian Women's Curling Championship 1056 P/0 by Connery respecting words "we are having Mcleod, Robert biased chairing in this House" 1993; Rh Award recipient 1425 taken under advisement (Dacquay) 1993; Mount Manitoba climbing team 2799, 341 9 ruled out of order 2514

39 Hansard Index

Dscqusy, Louis e - Cont. Dscqusy, Louise - Cont. P/0 by fn.o§ respecting relevancy of Private Members' Business debate 530-1 ; Resolutions Members cautioned (Dacquay)531 Core Area Initiative JJl 4538-40 P/0 by El:n§lrespecti ng relevancy of Violence, education against 1147-9 debate 370; Throne speech debate Members cautioned (Dacquay) 370 157-60 P/0 by � respecting relevancy of debate 1 032; Doer 1 032; Dakota OJibway Tribal Council Members cautioned (Dacquay) 1032 Policeforce P/0 by � respecting words "has no guts" Funding (Maloway) 1628; Harper 4602;McCrae 4602-3 Member cautioned (Dacquay) 1628 P/0 by Laurendeau respecting relevancy of Dangerous Goods Handling and debate 369; Transportation Amendment Act (Bill 53) Members cautioned (Dacquay) 369 P/0 by Laurendeau respecting relevancy of 1 r Cummings 61 9; 2r Cummings 738-40; debate (Edwards) 3062; Lamoureux 3062; Dewar 2269-72; Edwards 2272-5; referred Martindale3062; to Standing Committee on Public Utilities ruled out of order (Dacquay) 3062 and Natural Resources; RISCummings 5219; P/0 by McCrae respecting introduction of 3r Cerilli 5325-6; RIA 5491 Bills 792; Members cautioned (Dacquay) 792 Dauphin Lake P/0 by McCrae respecting word "cowardly" Environmental concerns (Barrett) 2287; Cerilli 3651 ; Cummings 3651 ruled out of order (Dacquay) 2287; Members cautioned 2288 Dauphin Lake AdvisoryCommit tee P/0 by Mcintosh respecting relevancy of debate 1991 ; Funding Members cautioned (Dacquay)19 91 Enns 3793; Plohman 3793 P/0 by Laurendeau respecting relevancy of Decentralization debate 1 027; Members cautioned (Dacquay) 1027 Brandon, Manitoba P/0 by Plohman respecting responses to L. Evans 1 053; Film on 692-3; questions (Supply) 3431 ; Alcock3431 ; Gilleshammer 1053; Lamoureux 692 Ashton 3431-2; Downey 3431 ; Praznik 3432; Government action ruled out of order (Dacquay) 3432 Dewar 3323; Downey3323 P/0 by Plohman respecting relevancy of debate Relocation statistics (Cummings) 3505; L. Evans 3645; Downey 3646, 3850-1 ; ruled in order (Dacquay) 3505 Wowchuk 3850 P/0 by � respecting sub-judice Rural civil service statistics (T.P. 120) convention 747; L. Evans 747; Wowchuk 3851 Lamoureux 747-8; Selkirk, Manitoba taken under advisement (Dacquay) 748; Derkach 2513-4, 2746; Dewar 2513-4; Speaker's ruling 2007-8 Driedger25 14 P/0 by � respecting responses to Status report questions (Supply) 3432; Derkach 3582; Plohman 1117; Praznik 1117; ruled out of order (Dacquay) 3432 Wowchuk 3582

40 Hansard Index

Decentralization (Supply) Derksch, Hon. Leonard - Cont. Decentralization Council ofMin isters of Education, Canada Derkach 4785-95; Dewar 4785-6; Communique (T.P. 3) 169 Lamoureux 4785, 4791 -3; Rose 4795; Decentralization (Supply) Wowchuk 4785-91 , 4794 Decentralization 4795-95 Opening remarks Opening remarks4782-3 Derkach 4782-3 Education, Council of Ministers Response Student financial assistance 169 Lamoureux 4784-5; Wowchuk 4783-4 Grievance, Matter of Rural Development, Minister of Deer Lodge Hospital School board interference 4559-63 Bed closures Health, Departmentof (Supply) Orchard 3322-3; Wasylycia-Leis 3322 Administration and Finance Minister'ssalary 3391 -3 Defence Infrastructure, AdvisoryGroup on Manitoba Water Services Board See Ministerial statements Annu� Report, 1991 (S.P. 88) 2515 Messages Dental Association Amendment Act Bill 20 (S.P. 129) 5000 (8111 80) Ministerial statements 1 r Orchard 2846;2r Cheema 3962-3; Rural Economic Development Initiative 2201-2 Orchard 3054-5, 3963; Wowchuk 3876; Thompson, Manitoba referred to Standing Committee on Downtown revitalization 161 3-4 Law Amendments; RIS Orchard 5220; Municipal Assessment Amendment Act (Bill 20) 3r 5233; RIA 5492 1 r Downey (Derkach) 261 ; 2r 491 -3 Municipal Board Dental Health Month Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 67) 1174 See Nonpolitical statements Nonpolitical statements Hockey championships 1662 Denturlsts Amendment Act (Bill 6) MAHA Provincial B Atoms Hockey Tournament 1 r Orchard 170; 2r Ashton 829-31 ; 1057 Cheema 801-2; Orchard 628-9; Oral questions Wasylycia-Leis 831-3; referred to Standing Agricultural land Committee on Law Amendments; Education supportlevy 2306 RIS Orchard 3961 ; 3r 5221 ; RIA 5491 Taxation 2305-6 Clarification 2466 Depo-Provera College Louis Riel Licence approval Admission policy 357-8 Orchard 291 ; Wasylycia-Leis 291 Decentralization Selkirk, Manitoba 251 3-4, 2746 DERKACH, Hon. Leonard (Roblln·Russell, Status report 3582 PC) Economic growth, rural (Minister of Education and Training) Employment creation strategy 3581 -2 (Minister of Rural Development) Education system Brandon University Curriculum development 179 Annual Financial Report, 1991 (S.P. 23) 352 Funding formula-rural schools 179-80 ConservationDistricts of Manitoba Program reductions 174-5 Annua1 Report, 1990 (S.P. 77) 1706 Taxation level 175 Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 114) 3981 Green Team program

41 Hansard Index

Derlcsch, Hon. Leonard - Cont. Derkach, Hon. Leonard - Cont. Justification 5270 Executive Administration 3466-72 Immigrant credentials Municipal Advisory and Financial Services Working group 360 Grants to Municipalities in Lieu of Taxes 3475 Municipal assessments Police Services Grants 3477 Delays 4204 Research and Systems 3479-80 Right to appeal 4204 Salaries 3473-5 NorthernManitoba Transit Grants3476-7 Employment opportunities2691 Lotteries Fu nded Programs Policing servicesagreement Grow Bonds Program 3492-4 Fee-for-servicecosts 4302 Partners with Youth 3496 Impact on Rural Manitoba 4302, 51 74 Rural Economic Development Initiatives 3494-5 Municipal costs 873-4 Municipal Board 3448-9 Regional development corporations Opening remarks3423-8 Funding 1472-3, 3582 Provincial Planning Rural economicdevelopment Salaries 3449-50, 3462-6 Government initiatives 1473 Rural Economic Development Division Minister's commitment 5404-5 Community Development Video lottery revenues 5404 Other expenditures 3491 Rural Development, Minister of Salaries 3490 School board interference4545 , 4547-8 Economic Development Services Russell, Manitoba Grants 3488-9 Dissolution 5175-6 Salaries 3481-8 Plebiscite 5176 Executive Administration 3480 Social assistance-students Infrastructure 3480-1 Reductions17 9 Universityof Manitoba The Pas, Manitoba Annual Financial Report, 1991 (S.P. 25) 352 Employment decline 2691 University of Winnipeg Universities Annual Financial Report, 1991 (S.P. 24) 352 Funding formula 173-4 Urgent Public Importance, Matter of Video lottery revenues Economic crisis 459-61 Green Team program 5267 Rural Development, Departmentof DEWAR, Gregory(Se lkirk, NDP) Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 95) 2740 Supplementary information City of Winnipeg Amendment,Muni cipal 1992-3 Estimates 2740 Amendment and Consequential Amendments Rural Development, Departmentof (Supply) Act (Bill 45) Administration and Finance 2r 1995-2001 , 2087-8 Brandon Office 3445 Condolence, Motions of Executive support Hillhouse, Thomas Paterson 608 Otherexpenditures 3444 Dangerous Goods Handling and Transportation Salaries 3444 Amendment Act (Bill 53) Finance andAdminis trative Services 3448 2r2269-72 Human Resource Management 3447 Decentralization (Supply) Expenditures Related to Capital Decentralization 4785-6 Downtown Revitalization 3491 Economic Innovation andTechnology Council Act Drought Proofing 3491 (Bill 9) Local Government Services Division 2r 978-85

42 Hansard Index

Dewar, Gregory - Cont. Dewar, Gregory - Cont. Family Services, Department of (Supply) Manitoba Telephone System Rehabilitation and Community Living Billing contract 1018 Special Employment Programs Directory contract 1613 Human Resources OpportunityCentre 2230-2 Long-distance competition 1612 GovernmentServices, Department of (Supply) Rate structure 1018 5063-6 Staff layoffs-Portage Ia Prairie 1158 Health Services Insurance Amendment Act (Bill 51) Telecommunicationsbiii-Federal 1158 2r 4265-7 Telephone directory contract 1019 Highways and Transportation, Departmentof Paddlewheel Riverboats (Supply) Lower Fort Garry trip 1918-9 Operations and Maintenance Selkirk Mental Health Centre District Offices 4636-7 Forensic unit 294, 558-9 Municipal Assessment Amendment Act (Bill 20) Selkirk School of Psychiatric Nursing 2r41 76-7 Closure postponement 1758, 4306 Natural Resources, Department of Reopening 294 Resource Programs Petitions Parks and Natural Areas Criminal Codeamendmen ts Administration 4971 -2 1248; ruled in order 1365 Nonpolitical statements 1415; Bear, Elsie Fight Back Against Child Abuse campaign Order of the BuffaloHunt recipient 1 023 1108; ruled in order 1156 Manitoba commemorative coin 1921 1415; ruled in order 1489 Manitoba's 122nd birthday 3279 1652; ruled in order 1702 Riel, Louis Human Resources OpportunityCentre Federal recognition 1117 Moratorium on closure Oral questions 2192; ruled in order2245-6 Alfred Block-Selkirk 2296; ruled in order 2505 Inspection 1423 2505; ruled in order 2571 Brandon School of Psychiatric Nursing 2571 ; ruled in order 2588 Closure 1758 2588; ruled in order 2684 Bristol Aerospace 2684; ruled in order 2740 Chemical burning824 2789; ruled in order 2841-2 Environmental concerns 824 2841 ; ruled in order 2868-9 Cleanup costs 4281 2984; ruled in order 3035 Pipeline 3035; ruled in order 3084 Boundary review 4281 3162; ruled in order 3264 Environmental concerns4281 3785; ruled in order 3842-3 Decentralization 3950; ruled in order 4094 Government action 3323 Private Members' Business Selkirk, Manitoba 2513-4 Address for Papers Health care system Public Health Amendment Act Forensic services4306 Legal opinion 3348-50 Human Resources OpportunityCentre Resolutions Closure 1371-2, 1972-3, 2108, 3092 Selkirk Psychiatric School of Nursing 2288-91 Service expansion 1371 Tabled papers Manitoba Housing Authority Riel, Louis Selkirk office 1423 Draft resolution (T.P. 26) 1117

43 Hansard Index

Dewar, Gregory - Cont. Doer, Gary - Cont. Selkirk Mental Health Centre 1539-44, 1548-53, 1548-53, 1585-93, Forensic unit 1594-1601 Correspondence (T.P. 14) 559 Opening remarks Throne speech debate Response 1530-5 336-9 Interim Appropriation Act, 1992 (Bill 67) C/W 1766-7 Disabled employees Internal Reform, Workforce Adjustment and Employment standards General Salary Increases (Supply) Ashton 3988; Gilleshammer 3988 5060-1 Rehabilitation/vocationalservices Legislative Assembly (Supply) Ashton 3988; Praznik 3988 5053 Ministerial statements Dobbie-Beaudoin committee Constitutional meeting See Unity Committee Multilateral discussions Response 2247-8, 2843-4, 3979-80, 4595 DOER, Gary(C oncordia, NDP) Constitutional process proposal Allowance for Lossesand Expenditures Incurred Response 1221-2 by Crown Corporations and other Provincial First Ministers' meeting Entities (Supply) Response 1704-5 5056-8 Linnet Graphics (International) agreement Appropriation Act, 1992 (Bill 1 03) Computer mapping system 3r 4378-82 Response 512 Budget debate Manitoba Hydro SavingsBonds 1183-92 Response 2572, 4427 Canada-Manitoba Enabling Vote (Supply) Western Governors'Association Conference 5055 Response 5261 -2 Child and Family ServicesAmendment Act (Bill 64) Western Premiers' Conference 3r 5368-70 Response 3407-9 City of Winnipeg Amendment Act (2) (Bill 35) Women, violence against 3r 373-6 National day of remembrance City of WinnipegAmendment, Municipal Response 13 Amendment and Consequential Amendments Nonpolitical statements Act (Bill 45) Fort Richmond Centurions 2r 1033-40 Manitoba high school hockey champions 1057 Community Support Programs (Supply) Holocaust Awareness Week 2749-50 LotteriesFunded Programs 5059 Manitoba Developmental Centre Condolence, Motionsof Accreditation 1424-5 Einarson, Henry John 612 Manitoba's 122nd birthday 3275-6 Hillhouse, Thomas Paterson 607 Mount Manitoba climbing team 2799 Witney, Charles H. 606 Order of Canada recipients2800-1 Economic Innovation andTechnology Council Act Roblin, Senator Duff (Bill 9) Retirement 4887 2r 808-16; 3r 5310-1 Saint Patrick's Day 1329 Emergency Expenditures (Supply) Vimy Ridge anniversary 191 9-20 5059 Oral questions Executive Council (Supply) ACCESS programs Management and Administration Governmentacti on 4570

44 Hansard Index

Doer, Gary - Cont. Doer, Gary - Cont. Premier's discussions 4569-70 Delegation ofpowers 4095-6 Abitibi-Price-Pine Falls Legal opinion request 3084-5 De-inkingplant National programs, protectionof 4735-7 Feasibility study 1754-5,21 03-4 Public hearings 3982 Employee-owned proposal 1754 Referendum 820-1 , 4499-500 Financial status 21 02-3 Timetable 4500 Aboriginal Justice Inquiry Cross-bordershopping Reportrecomme ndations552-3, 5167-9 Government actions 1048-9 Assiniboine River Diversion Ducks Unlimited headquarters Environmental assessment-Federal 35n-8 Environmental assessment-Federal 871 Bill 70 Funding withdrawal 871 Financial impact study request 4298-9 Impact tourism 870-1 Bill C-20 Drug Patent Law-Federal Extension 685-6 Government position 2589-90 Bill C-22 Earth Summit Extension 5262-3 Governmentagenda 3672 Budget Manitoba delegation 3673-4 Education, post-secondary 1109 Economic growth Education/training 920 All-party task force 1464-5 Employment creation strategy Average weekly incomes 2785-6 401 , 91 9-20, 1013-4 Employment creation strategy Introductiondate 354 353, 400-1, 2014, 2075-7, 3530, 3847, 4274 Unemployment rate forecast 920 Employment creation strategy-Federal 3530 Budget-Federal Employment statistics 3137-9, 3786, 3846 Employment creation strategy 723 Government forecast 2874 CN Rail Government initiatives 2873-4 Layoffs 2458-60 Government policy performance Canadian Centre for Disease Control 2846-8, 3845-7 Start date 724-5 Governmentpriorities 220 Child poverty Governmentstrategy 16-7, 1966-7, 201 3 Government initiatives 262-3 Government strategy-federal 3529-30 Clean Environment Commission Investment decline 2848-9 Jurisdiction 3951 -2 Manufacturing investment 2985 Provincial park land usage 969-70 National average statistics 1 175-6 Community colleges Out-migration statistics 2013-4 Applied Sciences courses 1109-1 0 Public consultations 354-5 Conawapa dam project Private sector investment2986 Delays, impact of 4428 Summit formation 5402-3 Joint environmental panel Economic summit Jurisdiction 3952-3 Implementation 2986-7 Penalty clauses 2507 Education system Renegotiations 4428-9 Funding formula 171-2 Power projections 41 62 Employment creation strategy Premier's discussions 2507-8 Government priorities 1015 Sustainable development 4162-3 Finance Ministers' meeting Constitutional proposal Government agenda 220-1 All-partycomm ittee 819, 3085-6 Free Trade Agreement

45 Hansard Index

Doer, Gary- Cont. Doer, Gary - Cont. Employment creation statistics 3036-7 Impact Crown corporations 1491 Impact on Manitoba 2573 Impact labour force 4877-9 Impact on manufacturing industry 4596-7 Impact Manitoba 2574 Labour adjustment strategy 2573 Impact supply management 4982-3 GATT negotiations Labour adjustment strategy 1491 Supply management proposal 597-8 Premier's position 4604 Goods and services tax Public hearings 1706, 2194-5, 2790-1 , 3037 Harmonization 399 Sectoral briefing 21 94 Impact manufacturing industry 400 Supply management 1606 Government, Federal Northern Flood Agreements Untendered contracts 2301-3, 2350-1 South Indian Lake GovernmentServices, Department of Legal expenses 2742-3 Leasing Branch NorthernTeleco m-Layoffs Consulting firm 1320 Governmentaction 4543-4 Director dismissal 3410 Oak Hammock Marsh development Internal audit 1255, 1655 DucksUnlim ited complex 1911-2, 3673 RCMP investigation 1254-5, 1654-5 Impact on tourism 4275 Report release 341 0-1 Port of Churchill Governmentmi nisters Grain shipments-Russian Republic 3893 Hiring authority 468-9 Rail line usage 3892-3 Health care system Shipment statistics 3892 Reform Provincial Auditor's Report Government agenda release 3164-6 Fiscal Stabilization Fund 288 Staff layoffs 1223-5 Manitoba Data Services287-8 Hudson's Bay Distribution Centre Public capital investment Employment security 2685-6 Decline 1176 Labour adjustment strategy Recession Federal-provincial co-ordination 51 08-10 Social programs 620 Macleod Stedman Recycling, glass Employment opportunities16 Contractaward criteria 2691 Head office location 17 Governmentinitia tives 2692 Manitoba Tax Assistance Office Repap Manitoba Inc. Closure 620 Aboriginal land claims 750-1 Manitoba-U.S trade deficit Cuttingarea 751 Government strategy 1 049 Employment statistics 122-3 Manufacturing industry Renegotiation 750 Shipment statistics 21 93 Technological change 123 Net income Round Table on the Environment Provincial decline 50-1 Projectreview process51 4-6 NorthAme rican Free Trade Agreement Shoal Lake, protection of Clarification 4603 Environmental review process 2506-7 Deadline 1605 Manitoba regulations 21 05 Government conditions 1706-7 Minister's communications 2104-5 Government position 1366-7, 1490, 1605 Negotiations-Ontario2506 Government study Premier's discussions 2507 Tabling request 1368 Tourism Governmentwithdrawal 4597-8 Promotion campaign

46 Hansard Index

Doer, Gary - Cont. Doer, Gary - Cont. Governmentstrate gy 331 6 Urgent Public Importance, Mattersof Statistics Economic crisis 419-21 Decline 141 6-7 U.S. visitors 331 5 Domestic violence Unity Committee report Bail conditions Legal opinion request 820 Chomiak 974; McCrae 974 Western Premiers' Conference Child abuse allegations Regional development program 3266-7 Justice Department investigation Points ofOrder Lathlin 554;McCrae 554 P/0 by �respecting word "cronies" Education/prevention programs (Filmon) 1479; Barrett4884; Mitchelson 4884 Members cautioned 1479 Government initiatives P/0 by � respecting words "my honourable Johnson 7-8 friend for Burrows has a learning disability" Government programs (Ernst) 4578; Barrett 18; Mitchelson 18 ruled out of order 4578 Pedlar Reportrecomme ndations P/0 by .E!Imrespecting relevancy of Barrett4884-5; Vodrey 4884-5 debate 1032; Doer 1032; Rehabilitation programs Members cautioned (Dacquay) 1032 Chomiak 974; McCrae 974-5 P/0 by Manness respecting withdrawal being See also Pe titions; Resolutions; Urgent Public conditional (Storie) 1225; Doer 1225; Importance, Ma tters of ruled out of order 1225 Private Members' Business Domestic VIolence Community Advisory Address for Papers Committee Public Health Amendment Act See Ministerial statements Legal opinion 2004-6 Resolutions Domtar slte Constitutional referendum for Canada 2908-1 1 Cleanup Constitutional task force 4192-3 Cerilli 293-4; Cummings 293-4 Economic Summit 5435-7, 5440-3 Correspondence (T.P. 7) Postal rate increase, rural newspapers 658-9 Cerilli 293 Social Allowances Amendment and Consequential Soil testing costs Amendments Act (Bill 70) Cerilli 4204-5; Cummings 4204-5 3r 5375-8 Statute Law Amendment (Taxation) Act, 1992 DOWNEY, Hon. James (Arthur-VIrden, PC) (Bill 94) (Minister of NorthernAffairs) C/W 5244-5; 3r 5318-9 (Minister of Rural Development) Tabled papers (Minister responsible for Native Affairs, the Manitoba Natural Resources Development Conawapa dam project Act (with respect to Channel Area Loggers Ltd. Correspondence (T.P. 173) 4428 and MooseLake Loggers Ltd.) A.E. MCK enzie Health care system reform Co. Ltd.) (Minister responsible for and charged with the Correspondence (T.P. 89) 31 65 administration of The Communities Economic The Pas Health Complex Incorporation Amendment Development Fund) Act (Bill 52) A.E. McKenzie Co. Ltd. 3r 5417 Auditor's Report, 1990, 1991 (S.P. 41 ) 551 Throne speech debate Budget debate 60-83 1348-55

47 Hansard Index

Downey, Hon. James - Cont. Downey, Hon. James - Cont. Channel Area Loggers ltd. Ministeri� statements Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 53) 791 Aboriginal issues City of Winnipeg Amendment, Municipal National meeting 917-8 Amendment and Consequential Amendments Act Alco Rural Development Bond Corporation 48-9 (Bill 45) Northern Central Hydro Electrification Agreement 2r 2099 1252-3 Communities Economic Development Fund Northern RoodAgreement (T.P. 108) Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 40) 2871 3574-5 ' Downey 551 Moose Lake Loggers Ltd. Condolence, Motions of Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 54) 791 Einarson, Henry John 614-5 Municipal Assessment Amendment Act (Bill 20) Education and Training, Departmentof (Supply) 1r 261 Post-Secondary, Adult and Continuing Education Nonpolitic� statements and Training Allona, EIIiana Program Analysis 3454-9 Energy of our Resources calendar Energy and Mines, Departmentof Manitoba artist4n Annu� Report, 1992 (S.P. 132) 5368 Bear, Elsie Manitoba Mineral Exploration Incentive Program Order of the Buffalo Hunt recipient 1023 (T.P. 181) 4731 Riel, Louis Oil activity review, 1991 (T.P. 165) 4273 Federal recognition 1118-9 Supplementary information Westray, Nova Scotia mine accident 3324 1992-93 Estimates (T.P. 112) 3671-2 Northern Affairs, Department of Energy and Mines, Departmentof (Supply) Annu� Report, 1991 (S.P. 66) 1174 Administration and Finance Supplementary information Executive Office 4722-5 1992-93 Estimates (T.P. 110) 3643 Marketing 4725-6 NorthernAffairs, Departmentof (Supply) Minister's salary 4733 Administration and Finance Energy Executive Support404 7-9 Conawapa Project Co-ordination 4728-30 Communities Economic Development Fund Energy Administration 4726-7 4050 Energy Planning 4727-8 NorthernAffa irs Fund 4049-50 Mineral Industry SupportPrograms Expenditures Related to Capital Acid Rain Abatement Program NorthernCommu nities 4105-8 Ain Flon 4732 Local Government Development Manitoba Exploration Incentive Program Programs and Operational Support 4731-2 Community Training 4051 Manitoba Potash Project 4733 Emergency Response Program4050-1 Opening remarks 471 9-20 Grants 4051 Interim Appropriation Act, 1992 (Bill 67) Recreational Director's Program 4051-3 C/W 1670-2, 1679-85 Regional Services4051 Manitoba Hydro Amendment Act (Bill 1 0) Selkirk Region 4054 1 r Neufeld (Downey) 170; 2r 482-3, 3560-2; The Pas Region 4053 RIS52 18 Native Affairs Secretariat Manitoba Hydro-ElectricBoard Aborigin� Development Programs Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 103) 3084 4066-74, 41 05 Manitoba Mineral Resources ltd. OtherExpenditures 4066 Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 85) 2350 Northern Development and Co-ordination

48 Hansard Index

Downey, .Hon. Jsmes - Cont. Downey, Hon. Jsmes - Cont. Northem Flood Agreement Liberal opinion Economic Development Governmentresponse 2464 Corporate Projects 4062 Power projections 4162 Salaries 4061 -2 Public Utilities Board Northern Aood Program 4055-61 Review 517-9, 2465 Northern Manitoba Economic Development Renegotiation 555, 794 Commission Sustainable development 41 63 Other Expenditures 4062-5 Constitutional proposal Salaries 4055 Delegation ofpowers 4095-6 Opening remarks 4037-42 Referendum 4098-9 Oral questions Decentralization Abinochi Preschool Program Government action 3323 Closure 1498 Relocation statistics 3646, 3850-1 Funding 141 7-8, 1609, 1761 Economic growth Meeting request 1761 Employment creation strategy20 14, 4097 Abitibi-Price-Pine Falls Government strategy 2013 Feasibility study 2200-1 Northern programs 407 Aboriginal Centre Out-migration statistics 2014 Funding 1609 Energy conservation Government commitment 3316-7, 3956 Funding 1231 Aboriginal issues Governmentstrategy 1231 Governmentcom mitment 3955 Goods and servicestax Aboriginal Justice Inquiry Report Harmonization 402 Court services, Northern 1369 Government, Federal Recommendations 553, 5168-9 Untendered contracts 2302-3 Aboriginal women Governmentmi nisters ACCESS program 1052 Hiring authority 469 Program accessibility 1 052 Grain exports-U.S. Agricultural land Licensing process 2593 Taxation Grand Rapids GeneratingStation Education support levy 2354 Environmental concerns 33 18 Reassessments2354 Turbine inspections 1161 Right of appeal 2353 Health care system, Northern Assiniboine River Diversion Transportationfee 878, 2356 Environmental assessment-Federal 3577-8 Highway construction program Bill 70 Northern Manitoba 41 04 Financial impact study request 4300 Highways andTransportati on, Departmentof Budget District 1 0 headquarters 2876 Crop insurance924 Human rights case Clearwater Lake, Manitoba Government involvement 4205-6 Government nursery closure 923, 925 Manitoba Hydro Civil servants Conawapa dam project Westman regional positions 3645 Pamphlet review 4100-1 Conawapa dam project Manitoba Intercultural Council Cost projections 521 Anti racism recommendations 2994 Government position 2464-5 Mining communities Legal opinion request 518 Employment retraining programs 2990

49 Hansard Index

Downey, Hon. James - Cont. Downey, Hon. James - Cont. Equity insurance 2990-1 Ashton 3431-2; Downey 3431 ; Praznik 3432; Exploration 2988 ruled out of order (Dacquay) 3432 Governmentinitiatives 2987-8 Private Members' Business Multicultural legislation Resolutions Introduction2994 Postal rate increasf:l, rural newspapers 661 Native Affairs, Minister responsible for Video lottery terminals 2644-7 Public's confidence 1418 Resolutions NorthAmer ican Free Trade Agreement Riel, Louis Election call 1656 Role in development ofManitoba 3652-4 Governmentaction 1655 Urgent Public Importance, Matter of Governmentposition 1490 Economic crisis 447-8 Impact agricultural industry 1660-1 Information tabling request 1662 DRIEDGER, Hon. Albert(S teinbach, PC) Provincial jurisdiction 1656 (Minister of Highways and Transportation) Supply management 1606 Condolence, Motions of NorthernManitoba Einarson, Henry John 61 5 Federal-Provincial agreements 24 Education and Training, Departmentof (Supply) Norway House Fishermen's Co-op Post-Secondary, Adult and Continuing Education Compensation 2877 and Training RCMP services Program Analysis, Co-ordinationand Support Municipal costs 2357 3502-4 Red Sucker Lake, Manitoba Health, Departmentof (Supply) School closure 4743 Administration and Finance Regional development corporations Minister's salary 3239-41 Funding 3851 Highway TrafficAmendmen t Act (BIII 15) Single-industry towns 1 r 220; 2r 525-6, 3876; RIS 5219 Equity insurance 1613, 2253-4 Highways and Transportation Department Social assistance Amendment Act (BIII 14) Off-reserve status indians 2596 1 r 170; 2r 488-90; RIS 5219 Tantalum Mining Corporation Highways andTransporta tion, Departmentof Contract negotiations 31 39 Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 14) 218 Employment protection 3139-40 Highway Construction programs (T.P. 1 03) 3315 The Pas, Manitoba Supplementary information Employment opportunities24, 2876 1992-93 Estimates (T.P. 104) 3315 Thompson General Hospital Highways and Transportation, Departmentof Mammography/chemotherapy services41 03-4 (Supply) Tourism industry Administration and Finance Governmentinit iatives 4097-8 Administrative Services 4468 Unemployment, youth Computer Services4470-3 Government initiatives 3368-9 Occupational Health and Safety 4473-4 Urban Aboriginal Strategy Personnel Services 4468-70 Governmentcommi tment 1608-9 Boards and Committees Wang Canada Licence Suspension Appeal Board 471 6-7 Agreement status 3649 Motor Transport Board 4712-5 Points of Order Taxicab Board 471 7-8 P/0 by Plohman respecting responses to Driver and Vehicle Licensing questions (Supply) 3431 ; Alcock 3431 ; Licensing 471 0-1

50 Hansard Index

Driedger, Hon. Albert - Cont. Driedger, Hon. Albert - Cont. Management Services4707 -1 0 Employment creation strategy 2578 Safety 471 1 Reservationoffice Transport, Safety and Regulations 4712 Layoffs 2577 Engineering and Technical Services Crowbenefit GovernmentAir and Radio Services4647-9 Payment plan 3268 Mechanical Equipment Services 4643-4 Decentralization NorthernAir ports 4644-5 Selkirk, Manitoba 2514 Traffic Engineering 4646-7 Faith Community BaptistChur ch Expenditures Related to Capital Building relocation 3852 Construction/Upgrading of Provincial Trunk Gemini Reservation System Highways Merger 1018 4718 Highway maintenance Opening remarks 4462-6 Responsibility 1472 Operations and Maintenance Highway map, provincial Bridges and Structures Exclusions 2197-8 Bridge Maintenance4629-30 Odometertampering Salaries 4628-9 Minister's opinion 3042 District Offices 4646-41 RCMP report3042 Maintenance Program 4474-82 PR 340 grading Operations and Contracts 4486 Project completion 3852 Transport Compliance463 1-6 Pembina Valley Water Co-operative Winter Roads Assiniboine River Diversion report 925 1 00 percent Provincial 4482-6 Portof Churchill Planning and Design and Land Surveys Agreement tabling request 4202 Land Surveys4643 All-partycomm ittee 224 Planning and Design 4642 Efficiency2020-1 Transportation Policy and Research Federal commitment471 4649-52, 4700-7 Future status 4984-5 Highways Protection and Consequential Governmentcommuni cations 4202 Amendments Act (Bill 79) Governmentstrategy 1263 1 r 2589; 2r 3051 -4, 4997; RIS 5394 Grain shipments 471 , 4201 Messages Manitoba representation 272 Bill 79 (S.P. 91 ) 2589 Rail line usage 3893 Ministerial statements Shipment statistics4984 Air ambulance service218 Portage Ia Prairie, Manitoba Portof Churchill Bridge inspection 3679 Rail line protection 462-3 Bridge replacement3679 Oral questions Recycling, glass Assiniboine River Diversion Contract award criteria 2691 -2 FederaVProvincial review 926 Government initiatives 2692 CN Rail Senate Transportation Committee Bayline upgrade 4305 Manitoba representation 1019 Job relocations 51 Taxicab industry Layoffs 52 Luxury cab proposal 876-7 Producer car drop off 2257 Thicket Portage, Manitoba Canadian Airlines International All-weather road 4305 Centralization2577 Train derailment report4305

51 Hansard Index

Driedger, Hon. Albert - Cont. Duchanne, Hon. Gerald - Cont. Transportationindus try 55 Plus program Rail line jurisdiction 1 019-20 Funding restoration 1258, 1711 Transportation issues Indexing 2020, 3989 Premier's involvement 52 Canada Pension Plan Trucking industry Benefit increase 171 1 All-party task force 4164 Gimli Motorsport Park Employment creation strategy 41 64 Lease renewal, Minister's role in 51 72 Employment protection 41 63-4 Government Services, Departmentof Operating authority 3789 Leasing Branch Winnipeg International Airport Consulting firm 1320 Protection 2019 Director dismissal 3410 Private Members' Business Information tabling request 1322 Resolutions Internal audit 1255 CNR jobs 1833-5 RCMP investigation 1254-5 Open Skies 3353-6 Report release 341 1 Tabled papers Health care system Air ambulance service Deinsurance 2510 Correspondence (T.P. 4) 218 Housing, seniors Throne speech debate Lounge repair-145 Powers Street 2513 143-51 Security systems 2513 Manitoba Housing Authority Drug patent law, Federal Staffing-Dauphin, Manitoba 3144 Governmentposition Manitoba Tax Assistance Office Doer 2589-90; Orchard 2590-1 Funding restoration 1711 Government strategy Pharmaceutical costs Orchard 2592; Storie 2591 -2 Impact on seniors 3371 , 3988-9 Impact on drugcosts Piney Area Seniors Group Orchard 2591 ; Storie 2591 Co-ordinator 1160 Impact on labour force St. James Seniors Group Governmentassistance 1159 Stefanson 2591 ; Storie 2591 Seniors programs DUCHARME, Hon. Gerald (Riel, PC) Funding 1258 (Minister of Government Services) Governmentcomm itment 1160, 1258 (Minister responsiblefor Seniors) Privilege, Mattersof Budget debate Legislative Building security 4438 1205-12 Private Members' Business Government Services, Department of Resolutions Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 51) 750 Core Area Initiative renewal 542-5 Government Services, Departmentof (Supply) Governmentcontracts, issuing of 3841 5062-9 Seniors' rights 2158-60 Interim Appropriation Act, 1992 (Bill 67) Resolutions C/W 1730-4 Riel, Louis Ministerial statements Role in development of Manitoba 3661 Seniors' Month 5401 Seniors' Directorate Nonpolitical statements Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 33) 466 Seniors' Month 3991 Supplementary Information Oral questions 1992-93 Estimates (T.P. 60) 2458

52 Hansard Index

Duck Mountain Earth Summit Co-Management agreements Communications with the Premier Enns 2466; Wowchuk 2466 Cerilli 4276; Cummings 4276 Governmentagenda DucksUnlimi ted Doer 3672; Filmon 3672-3 1992 calendar (T.P. 6) Manitoba delegation Cerilli269 Doer 3673-4; Filmon 3674 Headquarters Environmental assessment-Federal Eating disorders Cummings 871 ; Doer871 Treatment programs Funding withdrawal Orchard 5171 - 2; Wasylycia-Leis 5170-1 Cummings 871 ; Doer 871 Impact tourism Economic and Regional Development Cummings 871 ; Doer 870-1 Agreement Status report Dupuis, Patrice Lathlin 686; Stefanson 686 See Nonpolitical statements Economic crisis Dutch elm disease See Urgent Public Importance, Ma tters of Correspondence (T.P. 50) Enns 2080 Economic Development Board of Cabinet Funding, provincial Creation Enns 1970-1 , 2748-9; Friesen 1970-1 , 2748 Johnson 3 Funding restoration Enns 1320-1 , 2080; Ernst 519; Friesen 519, Economic Development, Standing 1320-1 ; Martindale2080 Committeeon Government position 1st Report Carstairs 799; Filmon 799 Rose 791 Multiyear planning 2nd Report Enns 1321 ; Friesen 1321 Rose 2349 Replacement tree allocation 3rd Report Enns 3677; Friesen 3677 Rose 2458 Research and development funding 4th Report Carstairs 5408; Enns 5408 Reimer 2789 Review 5th Report Enns 3677; Friesen 3677 Rose 2842 Scientific opinion tabling request 6th Report Enns 1915-6, 2080; Friesen 191 5-6 Reimer 3136 Two-percentloss limit 7th Report Enns 2852-3; Friesen 2852-3 Reimer 3643 See also Petitions 8th Report Reimer 5258 ERDA See Economic and Regional Development Economic growth Agreement All-partytas k force Doer 1464-5; Filmon 1464-6 Earth Day Anti-recession task force See Nonpolitical statements L. Evans 266; Filmon 266

53 Hansard Index

Economic growth - Cont. Economic growth - Cont. Average weekly incomes Investment decline Doer 3785-6; Filmon 3785-7 Alcock 265; Doer 2848-9; Filmon 265, 2848-9 Building permits Manufacturing industry Alcock 2795-6; Manness 2795-6 Doer 2986; L. Evans 3899; Filmon 2986; Consumer confidence Manness 3899-900 L. Evans 3898-9; Manness 3898-9 Municipal public works program Employment creation strategy L. vans 3787; Manness 2787 Carstairs 174, 727; Doer 353, 400-1 ,2014, National average statistics 2075-7, 3531 , 3847,4274 ; Downey 2014, Doer 1175-6; Manness 1175-6 4097; L. Evans 56, 131, 265; Filmon 265-6, Northernprograms 353-4, 727, 2075-7, 3531 3848, 3849-50; ' Ashton 407; Downey 407 Manness 56, 131, 174, 400-1 , 1228; Out-migration statistics Stefanson 4274-5; Storie 1228, 3849, 4097 Doer 2013-4; Downey 2014 Employment creation strategy-Federal Population statistics Doer 3530; Filmon 3530-1 L. Evans 5406-7; Manness 5406-7 Employment statistics Prairie provinces' co-operation Alcock 3140-1 , 3788; Doer 3137-9, 3786, 3846; Alcock 201 8-9; Stefanson 2018-9 Filmon 3137-9, 3140-1, 3786, 3846; Private sector investment Manness 2788-9 Alcock 341 7-8; Doer 2985; Filmon 2985, 341 8 Forecast justification Provincial comparisons Carstairs 1178-9; Manness 1178-9 Alcock 3318; L. Evans 56; Manness 57, 3318 Full-time employment decline Public consultations Alcock 2578, 2992-3; Praznik 2993; Doer 354-5;Filmon 355 Stefanson 2578 Research and development Government forecast Alcock 3983-4; Stefanson 3983-4 Doer 2874; Filmon 2874 Retail trade sector Government initiatives Alcock 2594-5;Manness 2594-5 Doer 2873-4; Filmon 2873-4 Summit formation Government policy Doer 5402-3; Filmon 5402-4 L. Evans 1756-7; Manness 1757 Wage levels Governmentpolicy performance Ashton 1 054-5; Stefanson 1054 Alcock 2690, 2849, 2991 ; Doer 2846-8, 3845-6; L. Evans 5406; Filmon 2846-8, 2849,3845-7; Economic growth, rural Manness 2690, 5406; Stefanson 2991 -2 Employment creation strategy Government priorities Derkach 3581-2; Wowchuk 3581 Doer 220; Filmon 220 Governmentinitiatives Government strategy Johnson 4 Carstairs 289; Doer 16-7, 1966-7, 2013; Government initiatives Downey 201 3; Filmon 17, 289; Derkach 1473; Johnson 4; Wowchuk 1473 L. Evans 3787-8; Manness 1229, 1966-8, Minister's commitment 3787-8; Storie 1228 Derkach 5404; Wowchuk 5404-5 Government strategy-Federal Video lottery revenues Doer 3529-30; Film on 3530 Derkach 5404; Wowchuk 5404 Housing starts Alcock 2747; Manness 2747 Economic Innovation and Technology Interprovincial migration Council Act (Bill 9) L. Evans 1757; Manness 1757 1 r Filmon 169; 2r Alcock 636-8;

54 Hansard Index

Economic Innovation - Cont. Education and Training - Cont. Ashton 697-704; Barrett 839-45; French-language education Cerilli 887-90; Chomiak 985-92; Funding (T.P. 93) Dewar 978-85; Doer 808-16; Vodrey 31 86 C. Evans 3056-9; L. Evans 759-66; Hiring authority Almon 629-31, 3059-61 ; Ashton 178; Almon 178 Friesen 939-46; Hickes 890-6; Manitoba Student Assistance Program Lathlin 693-7; Maloway 881-7; Average awards(T.P. 132) Martindale705 -13; Vodrey 3925 Plohman 802-8; Reid 816-7,833-7; Length of eligibility (T.P. 150) Storie 631-6; Wowchuk 837-9; Vodrey 4013 referred to Standing Committee on Out-of-province applicants (T. P. 151 ) Economic Development; RIS Stefanson 5307; Vodrey 4013 3r Alcock 5309-10; Doer 5310-1 ; Recipients(T.P. 124) L. Evans 5313-5; Stefanson 531 1-3; RIA 5491 Vodrey 3923 Occupations, high demand (T.P. 98) Economic Summit Vodrey 3302 Implementation Post-secondarycampus list (T.P. 115) Doer 2986-7; Almon 2987 Vodrey 381 3 See also Priva te Members' Business-Resolutions Private vocationalschools Course offerings (T.P. 139) Education, aboriginal Vodrey 3925 Post-secondary accessibility Enrolment statistics (T.P. 140) Friesen 600; Vodrey 600-1 Vodrey 3925 Foundation Learning Centre (T.P. 138) Education and Training, Departmentof Vodrey 3925 ACCESS programs (T.P. 145) Instructor qualifications (T. P. 136) Vodrey 3939 Vodrey 3925 Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 50) Truck driver training (T.P. 135) Vodrey 684 Vodrey 3925 Budgets-executive support(T.P. 64) School grants and other assistance (T.P. 85) Vodrey 2623 Vodrey 3127 Bursary and loan debts (T.P. 125) Schooltax statistics (T.P. 71 ) Vodrey 3923 Vodrey 2823 Canada student loans (T.P. 126) Schools funding, 1992/93 (T.P. 77) Vodrey 3924 Vodrey 2896 Canada student loans, part-time (T.P. 127) Special opportunity loans (T.P. 123) Vodrey 3924 Vodrey 3923 Canada student loans, repayment schedule Staffing requirements(T.P. 63) (T.P. 128) Vodrey 2623 Vodrey 3924 Student Support branch (T.P. 92) Child Care and Development branch Vodrey 31 86 Staffing summary (T.P. 82) Students, high-risk (T.P. 86) Vodrey 3033 Vodrey 3127 Education, distance Supplementary Information Firstyear university (T.P. 90) 31 86 1992-93 Estimates (T.P. 52) Eligible enrollment (T.P. 76) Vodrey 21 02 Vodrey 2896 Underspending

55 Hansard Index

Education and Training - Cont. Education and Training (Supply) - Cont. Alcock 975; Carstairs 922 ; Manness 922; Vodrey 2964-5 Vodrey 975 Opening remarks Vodrey 2538-45 Education and Training, Department of Response (Supply) Carstairs 2549-53; Chomiak 2545-9 Administration and Finance Post-Secondary, Adult and Continuing Education Administration and Professional Certification and Training Carstairs 2725-7; Chomiak 2721-5, 2727-8; Assinlboine Community College Vodrey27 21-8 Alcock 3774-7; Friesen 3768-74; Executive Support Vodrey 3768-n Chomiak 2553-9, 2623-4; Education and Training Assistance Vodrey 2553-61 , 2623-4 Alcock 3816-7; Friesen 3817-9; Financial Services Vodrey 381 6-7 Carstairs 271 8-9; Chomiak 271 8; Executive Administration Vodrey 271 8-9 Alcock 3188, 3260-3, 3297-3301 ; Management Information Services Friesen 3187, 3191-4, 3247-60, 3301 ; Carstairs 2720-1 ; Chomiak 271 9-20; Vodrey31 87-95, 3248-62, 3297-3301 Vodrey 271 9-21 Grants Minister's salary Alcock 4014-5; Vodrey 4014 Alcock 4091 -2 Keewatin Community College Personnel Services Alcock 3816; Ashton 37n-83, 3813-6; Carstairs 271 5; Chomiak 2638-9, 2716-7; Vodrey 37n-84,381 4-6 Vodrey 2638-9, 271 5-7 Literacy Office Planning, Research and Policy Co-ordination Alcock 4015-7; Vodrey 401 5-7 Carstairs 2629-35; Chomiak 2624-9, 2635-8; Post-Secondary Career Development Vodrey 2624-38 Alcock 3939-41 , 401 3-4; Bureau de !'education francaise Vodrey 3939-41 , 401 3-4 Division administration Program Analysis, Co-ordination and Support Carstairs 31 34-5; Chomiak 3132-3 Alcock 3302-5, 351 9-25, 3623-6, 3629-31 , Vodrey 3132-5 3705-9; Ashton 3451-4; Cummings 3504-7; Expenditures Related to Capital Downey 3454-9; Driedger 3502-4; Acquisition/Construction of Physical Assets Enns 3507-9;Ernst 3498-502; Alcock 4085-6; Storie 4086-90; Friesen 3305-7, 3398-3404, 3429-34, 3514-9, Vodrey 4085-90 3526-8, 3627-9, 3709-12; Hickes 361 1-8; Capital Grants Manness 3459-61 , 3496-8; Praznik 3509-13; Universities Vodrey 3302-8, 3398-3404, 3430-41 , Alcock 4090-1 ; Vodrey 4090-1 3514-28, 3615-31 , 3705-12; Financial Support-Schools Wowchuk 361 8-23 Phase-In Support Red River Community College Chomiak 2963-4; Vodrey 3964 Alcock 3757-63; Friesen 3712-9, 3757-68; School Grants and Other Assistance Lamoureux 371 9-21 ; Vodrey 371 2-20, Carstairs 2823-4, 2899-2902, 2958-9, 2963; 3757-68 Chomiak 2728-30, 2824-36, 2896-9, 2959-62; Special Skills Training Vodrey 2729-30, 2823-36, 2896-2902, Alcock 4017-20; Vodrey 4017-20 2958-63 Student Financial Assistance Teachers' Retirement Allowances Alcock 381 9-26, 3830, 3923-8; Carstairs 2965; Chomiak 2964-5; Chomiak 3935-6; Friesen 3826-30;

56 Hansard Index

Education and Training (Supply) - Cont. Education, multicultural Vodrey 381 9-30, 3923-37 See Ministerial statements Student Financial Assistance Appeal Board Alcock 3938-9;Vodrey 3938-9 Education, post-secondary Workforce 2000 Accessibility Alcock 4020-3; Vodrey 4020-3 Carstairs 2462; Friesen 874, 5407; Program Development and Support Services Vodrey874, 2462, 5407 Child Care and Development Funding Carstairs 3122-4; Chomiak 31 18-22; Alcock 1182; Manness 1182 Vodrey 31 1 8-24 Funding restoration Curriculum Services Friesen 1050; Vodrey 1050 Carstairs 2967-75; Chomiak 2975-7; Tuition fee increases Vodrey 2967-n Alcock 1182; Vodrey 1182 Distance Education and Technology See also Budget-Federal; Education and Training, Deparlment of (Supply) Carstairs 3126-7; Chomiak 3124-6; Vodrey 3124-7 Education Reform, Panel on Division Administration Reportrelease Chomiak 2966-7; Vodrey 2966-7 Chomiak 3990; Vodrey 3990 Manitoba School for the Deaf Carstairs 3032-3; Chomiak 3033-4; Education system Vodrey 3032-4 Administrative costs Native Education Carstairs 2793; Vodrey 2793 Carstairs 2977 -9; Chomiak 2979; Child Guidance Clinic Hickes 3026-32; Friesen 2981 -3, 3018-32; Chomiak 4576; Vodrey 4577 Vodrey4978-83 , 3018-32 Curriculum development Student SupportProgram Carstairs 2792-3; Derkach 179; Carstairs 3130-2; Chomiak 3127-30; Vodrey 2793; Wowchuk17 9 Vodrey 3127-32 Dropout rate Universities GrantsCommi ssion Chomiak 2352, 2358, 2792, 3321-2; Alcock 4023-6, 4074-85; Vodrey2352, 2358, 2792, 3322 Vodrey 4023-6, 4074-85 Exceptional student programs funding Carstairs 3848;Vodrey 3848 Education and Training, Deputy Minister of Funding formula Salary increase Chomiak 792-3, 1020, 1112-3; Doer 171-2; Chomiak 2509; Vodrey 2509 Filmon 171-3; Vodrey 792-3, 1020, 1112-3 Funding formula-rural schools Education and Training, Minister of Derkach 179-80; Wowchuk 179 Governmentinitiatives Resignation request Johnson 7 Filmon 57-8; Lamoureux 57 Grade 1 0 curriculum changes Carstairs 4571-2; Chomiak 4576; Education, Council of Ministers of Vodrey4572 , 4576 Student financial assistance Program reductions Derkach 169 Chomiak 174-5; Derkach 174-5 School closures Education, distance Guideline review See Priva te Members'Business-Resolutions Carstairs 2592; Vodrey 2592

57 Hansard Index

Education system - Cont. Edwards, Paul - Cont. School year length Energy Chomiak 2358; Voclrey 2359 Conawapa Project Co-ordination 4728-9 Special needs funding Energy Administration 4726 Chomiak 876 ; Voclrey 876 Mineral Industry SupportPrograms Special needs students Acid Rain Abatement Program Policy and procedural guidelines (T.P. 960 Flin Aon 4732 Vodrey 3297 Manitoba Exploration Incentive Program Student achievement levels 4731-2 Carstairs 3848-9; Vodrey 3849 Manitoba Potash Project 4732 Taxation level Opening remarks Chomiak 175; Derkach 175 Response 4721 Transportation policy review Resource Programs Carstairs 2592; Vodrey 2592 Forestry Vocational training Administration 5081 -6 Carstairs 3848; Vodrey3848 Environment Amendment Act (Bill 49) 2r 3152-6 Educational facilities Environment, Department of (Supply) St. James Seniors' Group usage Administration and Rnance Edwards 1159; Vodrey 1159 Planning and Innovation 5093-7 Environmental Management EDWARDS, Paul (St. James, LIB) Environmental Operations 5098-5106 Aboriginal Justice Initiatives (Supply) Environmental Innovations Fund(Supply) 5188-91 5074-5, 5077-80 Budget debate Family Maintenance Amendment Act (Bill 89) 1270-7 2r 4586-9 Child and Family Services Amendment Act Fi tness and Sport (Supply) (Bill 64) 521 5-7 2r 2776-9 Grievance, Matterof City of Winnipeg Amendment Act (Bill 30) Rural Development, Minister of 1r 398 School board interference 4563-4 City of Winnipeg Amendment Act (2) (Bill 35) Health Care Directives Act (Bill 16) 2r 299-302;3r 376-8 2r 4151-2 City of Winnipeg Amendment Act (3) (Bill 78) Health ServicesInsurance Amendment Act (Bill 51) 2r 5138-50; 3r 5427-8 2r 4262-3 City of Winnipeg Amendment, Municipal Highway Traffic Amendment Act (Bill 15) Amendment and Consequential Amendments 2r 849-50 Act (Bill 45) Highways and Transportation Department 2r 1023-7 Amendment Act (Bill 14) Conflict of Interest 2r 848-9 Declarations Highways and Transportation, Departmentof Resolution 20 654 (Supply) Dangerous Goods Handling and Transportation Administration and Rnance Amendment Act (Bill 53) Computer Services4471 -2 2r 2272-5 Minister's salary 471 8-9 Energy and Mines, Departmentof (Supply) Boards and Committees Administration and Finance Licence Suspension Appeal Board 4715-7 Marketing 4725-6 Motor Transport Board 471 4-5

58 Hansard Index

Edwards, Paul - Cont. Edwards, Paul - Cont. Taxicab Board 4717-8 Salaries 4143-4, 41 37-40 Driver and Vehicle Licensing Provincial Policing 4144-7 Licensing 4710-1 Law Enforcement Review Amendment Act (Bill 87) Management Services4708-9 2r 5000 Safety 471 1 Law Reform (Miscellaneous Amendments) Act Transport, Safety and Regulations471 1 (Bill 72) Engineering and Technical Services 2r 2276-7 NorthernAirports 4644 -5 Law Society Amendment Act (Bill 74) Traffic Engineering 4646-7 2r 2863-4 Opening remarks Lodge Operators and Outfitters Licensing and Response 4466-7 Consequential Amendments Act (Bill 22) Operations and Maintenance 2r 852-4 Bridges and Structures Manitoba Advisory Council on the Status of Women Bridge Maintenance 4629-30 Amendment Act (Bill 5) Maintenance Program 4478-82 2r 582 TransportComp liance3631 -2 Manitoba Evidence Amendment Act (Bill 38) Transportation Policy and Research 4704-6 2r 800-1 Highways Protection and Consequential Manitoba Hydro Act (Bill 1 0) Amendments Act (Bill 79) 2r 3061 -7 2r 4991-2 Ministerial statements Jury Amendment Act (Bill 46) Constitutional meeting 2r 647-8 Multilateral discussions Justice, Departmentof (Supply) Response 3980-1 Administration and Finance Domestic Violence Community Advisory Human Resource Services41 32 Committee Minister's salary 4259-61 Response 15 Policy, Planning and Special Projects41 30-1 Public Inquiry into the Administration of Impaired drivers, victims of Justice and Aboriginal People Response 287 41 33 National Forest Week Corrections Response 2870-1 Adult Corrections 4240-2 NorthernCentral HydroElectrification Agreement Courts Response 1254 CourtServices 4243-6 Northern Flood Agreement Regional Courts 4247 Response 2872-3, 3576 Justice Portof Churchill ConstitutionalLaw 4239-40 Rail line protection Family Law 4238-9 Response 463 Manitoba Law Reform Commission 4237-8 Municipal Council Conflict of Interest Opening remarks Amendment Act (Bill 29) Response 4129 1r467 Protection of Individual andProperty Rights Natural Resources, Departmentof (Supply) Public Trustee Administration and Finance Other Expenditures4248 Administrative Services4873-6, 4952 Salaries 4247-8 Opening remarks Public Prosecutions Response 4869 Board of Review Regional Operations

59 Hansard Index

Edwards, Paul - Cont. Edwards, Paul - Cont. HeadquarterOperations 4952-9 Minister's position 359 Nonpolitical statements Farm Lands Ownership Board International Women's Day 1022 Report production costs 228 Oral questions Garrison Diversion Project Abitibi-Price-Pine Falls Environmental impact assessment 51 73 De-inking plant 4207 Manitoba interests 5172-3 Advertising, misleading Governmentreports Consumer protection 124-6 Environmentally friendly products 228 BFI Waste Systems Hazardouswaste Landfill site 1113-4 Contaminated soil 4435-6 Bill 49 Headingley Correctional Institute Government strategy 3650-1 Psychiatric care facilities 1496-7 Justification 3650 Impaired driving Bills 86/87 Third-partybenefits 3792-3 Adjudication process 5269 Judicial system Consultations 5268-9 Courttranscription service 1656-7 Bristol Aerospace Ltd. Legal Aid Services Society of Manitoba Waste rocket fuel burning 1607 Minister's intention 1711 Waste rocket fuel disposal 1607-8 Private bar 1712, 1714 Clean Environment Commission Manitoba Hazardous Waste Management Corp. Funding 1230-1 PCB storage site 2081 -2 Co-Management agreements Manitoba Hydro Public forum 1326 Conawapa dam project Working group 1327 Pamphlet review 41 00-1 Conawapa dam project Nopiming Park-Forestry Cost projections 521 Environmental mediator 21 99 Economic viability359 Land division 2199-2200 Environmental delay 359 Negotiations 21 99 Environmental panel report457 4-5 Rafferty-Alameda dam project Governmentposition 2464 Environment, Minister of Intervenerfunding 4575 Involvement 3272-3 Liberal opinion Renegotiation 3272 Governmentresponse 2464 Recycling programs Public Utilities Board Distributor's costs 4207 Review 2465 St. James Seniors' Group Renegotiation 554-5 Governmentassistance 1159 Winnipeg Chamber of Commerce position Senate Transportation Committee 521 -2 Manitoba representation 1019 Courtof Queen's Bench Sewage lagoon-Oak Point Appeal screening court292-3 Licensing process 2797-8 Crime prevention programs Public hearings 2798 Funding 41 68 Stephenfield reservoir Crown Lands Act Irrigation licensing 601 -2 Wildlife baiting regulations 2308-9 Stony Mountain, Manitoba Educational facilities Environmental concerns 476, 689 St. James Seniors Group usage 1159 Funding 690 Environmentalists Funding-Federal 689

60 Hansard Index

Edwards, Paul - Cont. Edwards, Paul - Cont. Sustainable development 31 1-6 Government commitment 1231 Urban Affairs, Departmentof (Supply) Transportation industry Administration and Finance Rail line jurisdiction 1 019-20 Administration and Financial Services 4338 Personal Property Security Amendment Act Expenditures Related to Capital (Bill 48) Riverbank Development 4355 2r 829 Opening remarks PettyTrespasses Amendment Act (Bill 47) Response 4336-7 2r 649-50 Urban Policy and Agreement Management Points ofOrder Urgent Public Importance, Mattersof P/0 by Laurendeau respecting relevancy of Domestic violence 37-8 debate (Edwards) 3062; Lamoureux 3062; Economic crisis 444-5 Martindale 3062; ruled out of order (Dacquay) 3062 Elnarson, Henry John Private Members' Business See Condolence, Motions of Resolutions Core Area Initiative renewal 539-42 Elections Finances Act Crime Prevention Counci1 854-7 Annu� Report, 1990 (S.P. 32) PTH 101 safety 1086-7 Rocan 397 Provincial Park Lands Amendment Act (Bill 21) 2r 851 -2 Electrical Construction Journeymen Provincial Police Amendment and Consequential Examination standards Amendments Act (Bill 86) Praznik 4885-6; Wowchuk4885-6 2r 4997-5000;3r 541 3-4 Public Trustee Amendment, Trustee Amendment Emergency Expenditures (Supply) and Child and Family ServicesAmendment Act Doer 5059; Manness 5059 (Bi11 68) 2r 2277-9 Employability Enhancement Programs Statute Law Amendment (Taxation) Act, 1992 Funding (Bill 94) Barrett2250; Carstairs 2252-3; C/W 5252-3 Gilleshammer 2250-1 , 2252-3 Surveys Amendment Act (Bill 34) 2r 640-1 Employment creationstrategy Tabled Papers Governmentcomm itment Advertising, misleading Filmon 1158; Storie 1158 Employment advertisement(T.P. 2) 125 Government priorities Environmental assessments, Federal Doer 1015; Filmon 1015 Correspondence (T.P. 111) 3650 Northernprograms Judicial system Ashton 1328; Manness 1328 Courttranscription service Correspondence (T.P. 39) 1656 Employment programs Manitoba Hydro Hiring priority Conawapa pamphlet (T.P. 153) 41 00 Gilleshammer 2851 ; Martindale285 1 Stony Mountain, Manitoba Environmental concerns Employment programs, youth Correspondence (T.P. 18) 689 NorthernManitoba Throne speech debate L. Evans 2875; Gilleshammer 2875

61 Hansard Index

Employment Resources Regional Offices Enns, Hon. Harry - Cont. Closure Lodge Operators and Outfitters Licensing and L. Evans 1052-3, 1179; Gilleshammer 1053, ConsequentialAmendmen ts Act (Bill 22) 1179 1 r Enns 171 ; 2r 639-40 Manitoba Habitat Heritage Corporation Employment retraining programs Annu� Report, 1991 (S.P. 101)2985 Funding Ministerial statements Carstairs 621-2; Manness 622 National Forest Week 2869-70 Government commitment Natural Lands and Special Places Workbook Carstairs 2461 ; Vodrey 2461 -2 3843 Government initiatives Natural Resources, Department of Friesen 727-8; Vodrey 727-8 Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 68) 1249 Government strategy Forestry Friesen 4300; Vodrey 4300 Five Year Report (S.P. 87) 2458 Natural Lands and Special Places Endangered spaces Workbook (T.P. 118) 3843 Site selection criteria Supplementary information Cerilli 3987; Enns 3987 1992-93 Estimates 4594 Tall grass prairie program Natural Resources, Department of (Supply) Cerilli 1658, 3987; Cummings 1658; Administration and Finance Enns 1658, 3987 Administrative Services 4872-6, 4952 Executive Support4871 ENNS, Hon. Harry(L akeside PC) Venture Manitoba Tours Ltd. 4871-2 �Minister of Natural Resources) Opening remarks4865-8 Minister responsiblefor The Manitoba Natural esources Develo ment Act (except with Regional Operations respect to Channe rArea Loggers Ltd. and Fire Pre-Suppression Program 4962-3 Moose Lake Loggers Ltd.) ) Fire Tac Program 4963 Animal HusbandryAmendment Act (Bill 12) Headquarters Operations 4952-62 2r 486-8 Resource Programs Condolence, Motions of Fisheries Einarson, Henry John 613 Administration5088-9 Hillhouse, Thomas Paterson 610-1 Forestry Witney, Charles H. 606 Administration 5081 -6 Education and Training, Department of (Supply) Forest Protection 5087-8 Post-Secondary, Adult and Continuing Education Silviculture 5086-7 and Training Lands Program Analysis, Co-ordination and Support Crown Lands Administration 4981 3507-9 Parks and Natural Areas Environment, Departmentof (Supply) Administration 4972 Administration And Finance Management and Development 4972-4 Planning and Innovation 5095 Park Operations and Maintenance 4976 Environmental Management Program Services497 4-5 Environmental Operations 5097-8 Visitor Services4976-80 Highways and Transportation, Departmentof Water Resources (Supply) Administration 4963-6 Operations and Maintenance Water Licensingand Approvals 4967-8 Winter Roads Water Management 4968-71 1 00 percent Provincial 4485 Nonpolitical statements

62 Hansard Index

Enns, Hon. Harry - Cont. Enns, Hon. Harry - Cont. Riel, Louis Tree-growing contract 1113-4 Federal recognition 1117-8 Natural Resources, Departmentof Roblin, Senator Duff Fisheries branch-Brandon Retirement 4888 Closure 4166, 4576 Oral questions Library services 2465-6 Assiniboine River Diversion Waste disposal-Winnipeg Floodway Employment creation 31 69 4301 , 4434 Irrigation purposes 3168-9 Nopiming Provincial Park Reportstatu s 3271-2 Wildernessstatu s 972-3 Childs Lake Oak Hammock Marsh development Water level 2466 Governmentwithdrawal 4275-6 Clearwater Lake, Manitoba Stephenfield reservoir Government nursery closure 23, 3983 Irrigation licensing601 -2 Co-Management agreements Western Canadian Wildlife Service Public forum 1326-7 Oak Hammock Marsh Report269 Working group 1327 Wildlife protection Crown LandsAct Poaching 2692-3 Wildlife baiting regulations 2308-9 Points ofOrder Dauphin Lake AdvisoryComm ittee P/0 by � respecting membersreading from Funding 3793 prepared text 3437; Enns3437 -8; Duck Mountain ruled out of order (Dacquay) 3438 Co-Management agreements2466 Ruling challenged 3438; Dutch elm disease program Sustained 3438 Funding, provincial 1970-1 , 2748-9 P/0 by � respecting relevancy of Funding restoration 1320-1 , 2080 debate 530-1 ; Multiyear planning 1321 Members cautioned (Dacquay)531 Replacement tree allocation 3677 Private Members' Business Research and development funding 5408 Resolutions Review 3677 Daycare, rural 3889-90 Scientific opinion tabling request 191 5-6, 2080 Grow Bonds 3571-3 Two-percent loss limit 2852-3 Provincial Park Lands Amendment Act (Bill 21) Endangered spaces 1 r 171 ; 2r 638-9 Site selection criteria 3987 Resolutions Tall grass prairie program 1658, 3987 Riel, Louis Fisheries industry Role in development of Manitoba 3656-8 Rough fish marketing 1163-4 Supply, Capital Forestry industry Supply, Committee of 5342-58 Sustainable development 972-3 Surveys Amendment Act (Bill 34) Garrison Diversion Project 1 r 220; 2r 640 Environmental impact assessment 5173 Tabled papers Manitoba interests 51 73 Dutch elm disease (T.P. 50) 2080 Habitat enhancement program Throne speech debate Little Saskatchewan River 4166 271-8 Lake Winnipegosis Urgent Public Importance, Matter of Cormorant population control 341 6 Economic crisis 427-9 Trap net policy 1164 Venture Manitoba Tours Ltd. Long Plain Indian Reserve Auditor's Report, 1991 (S.P. 61) 1013

63 Hansard Index

Employment Standards Act Energy conservation Amendments Funding Ashton 3988; Praznik 3988 Downey 1231 ; Hickes 1231 Government strategy Energy and Mines, Departmentof Downey 1231 ; Hickes 1231 Annua1 Report, 1992 (S.P. 132) Downey 5368 Environment Amendment Act (Bill 49) Manitoba Mineral Exploration Incentive Program 1 r Cummings 596; 2r Cerilli 4578-50; (T.P. 181) Cummings 737-8; Edwards 3152-6; referred to Downey 4731 Standing Committee on Municipal Affairs; Oil activity review, 1991 (T.P. 165) RISCumm ings 5394; RIA 5491 Downey 4273 Environment, Department of Supplementary information 1992-93 Estimates (T.P. 112) Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 6) Downey 3671 -2 Cummings 122 Supplementaryinformation Energy and Mines, Departmentof 1992-93 Estimates (T.P. 159) (Supply) Cummings 41 99 Administration and Finance Work order enforcement Executive Office Cerilli 556; Cummings 556 Downey 4722-5; Hickes 4725; Storie 4721-5 Environment, Department of (Supply) Marketing Administration and Finance Downey 4725-6; Edwards 4725-6 Planning and Innovation Minister's salary Cerilli 5095-7; Cummings 5093-7; Downey 4733 Edwards 5093-4; Enns 5095 Energy Environmental Management Conawapa Project Co-ordination Environmental Operations Downey 4728-30; Edwards 4728-9; Cerilli 51 01-6; Cummings 5098-51 06; Hickes 4730 Edwards 5097-5101 ; Enns 5097-8 Energy Administration Downey 4726-7; Edwards 4726; Environmental assessments, Federal Hickes 4725-7 Correspondence (T.P. 111) Energy Planning Edwards 3650 Downey 4727-8; Hickes 4727-8 Mineral Industry SupportProgram s Environmental Bill of Rights (Bill 2) Acid Rain Abatement Program 1 r Cerilli 169-70 Rin Flon Downey 4732; Edwards 4732 Environmental Innovations Fund (Supply) Manitoba Exploration Incentive Program Cerilli 5075-80, 5090-2; Cummings 5071 -80, Downey 4731-2; Edwards 4731-2; 5090-3; Edwards 5074-5, 5077-80 Hickes 4732 Manitoba Potash Project Environmental legislation Downey 4733; Edwards 4732; Hickes 4733 Government strategy Opening remarks Cummings 3650-1 ; Edwards 3650-1 Downey 471 9-20 Justification Response Cummings 3650; Edwards 3650 Edwards 4721 ; Hickes 4720 See also Environment Amendment Act (Bi/1 49)

64 Hansard Index

Environmentalists Ernst, Hon. Jim - Cont. Minister's position Greece independence 1663 Cummings 359; Edwards 359 North Portage Development Corporation Annual Report, 1991 (T.P. 15) 61 8 ERNST, Hon. Jim (Charleswood, PC) Oral questions (Minister of Urban Affairs) Aboriginal issues (Minister of Housing) Education/training opportunities4571 City of Winnipeg Amendment Act (2) (Bill 35) Alfred Block-Selkirk 1 r 261 ; 2r 296-8; RIS 363; 3r 373-4 Inspection 1423 City of Winnipeg Amendment Act (3) (Bill 78) Bill 45 1 r 2350; 2r 2751 -4 City of Winnipeg resolution 2198 City of Winnipeg Amendment, Municipal Minister's authority 21 98 Amendment and Consequential Amendments Act Secession referendum 2198 (Bi11 45) City of Winnipeg Act 1 r 596; 2r 643-6; 3r 2474-5 Community Committee role 41 00 Education and Training, Department of (Supply) Communications industry Post-Secondary, Adult and Continuing Education Employment statistics 4097 and Training Constitutional issues Program Analysis, Co-ordination and Support Housing responsibility 1375 3498-502 Core Area Agreement Housing, Departmentof Education programs 1230 Supplementary information Inner City Foundation 129 1992-93 Estimates (T.P. 73) 2869 Proposed projects 129 Housing, Departmentof (Supply) Public consultations 228, 3792 Administration and Finance Renewal 1370-1 Executive Support4370-4 Replacement 128, 3792 Finance and Operations 4375-83 Dutch elm disease Opening remarks 4367-8 Funding restoration 519 Program Development and Support Federal Trade Tribunal Administration 4383 Manitoba cabinetmakers 2512 Client Services 4394-8 Government Services, Departmentof Grants and Subsidies 4398-40 Leasing Branch Project Management 4393-4 Internal audit 1655 Research and Planning 4383-92 RCMP investigation 1655 Transfer Payments to Manitoba Housing and Housing, co-operative Renewal Corporation Federal program 1375, 2581 , 2598 4400-3 Housing, Departmentof Interim Appropriation Act, 1992 (Bill 67) Layoffs-Brandon, Manitoba 3646 1 r 1616; 2r 1616-7; C/W 1669-70, 1685-8, Housing, Minister of 1728-30 Apology request 4882 Manitoba Housing and Renewal Corporation Housing, nonprofit Annuai Report, 1991 (S.P. 81) 1771 Government strategy 126 Messages Housing, public-PembinaHighway Bill 35 (S.P. 16) 261 Playground structure 4882 Bill 78 (S.P. 86)2350 Housing, seniors Municipal Board Lounge repair-1 45 Powers Street 2513 Headingley/Winnipeg boundary (T.P.22) 1174 Inner-city renewal programs Nonpolitical statements Funding impact 2595-6

65 Hansard Index

Ernst, Hon. Jim - Cont. Ernst, Hon. Jim - Cont. Government commitment 1229-30 Annual Report, 1991 (T.P. 19) 723 Government support 51 14 Throne speech debate Minister's position 51 13 108-1 3 Manitoba Housing Authority Urban Affairs,Department of Clarification 3900 Annual Report, 1991 (S.P. 17) 286 Employees' status 2854 Supplementary information Internalaudit 3789-90 1992-93 Estimates (T.P. 74) 2869 Layoffs 796 Urban Affairs, Department of (Supply) Parkland district 797-8 Administration and Finance Selkirk office 1423 Administration and Financial Services 4338-9 Seniors' services 2896-7 Exectuive Support4337-8 Service contracting 796 Expenditures Related to Capital Staffing 3896 Financial Assistance to the City of Winnipeg North Main Development Corporation 4354-5 Funding 51 14 Riverbank Development 4355-6 Recreation centre-Fife Street Financial Assistance to the City of Winnipeg Roof repairs 2597 UnconditionalCu rrent Programs Grant 4339-42 Rotary Pines Project Opening remarks4334-5 Funding reallocation 126 Urban Policy and Agreement Management SAFER program Core Area Renewed Agreement 4348-53 Eligibility statistics 4578 Salaries 4342-8 Public awareness 4578, 4881 Winnipeg Wards BoundariesCommi ssion Seniors' RentaiStart Supplementary Report(T.P. 43) 1706 Applications 126 Points of Order Erratum P/0 by Doer respecting words "my honourable 351 friend for Burrows has a learning disability" (Ernst) 4578; Environmental Youth Corps ruled out of order 4578 P/0 by Enmrespecting relevancy of See Priva te Members'Busi ness-Resolutions debate 370; Members cautioned (Dacquay) 370 EVANS, Cllf (Interlake, NDP) P/0 by Er:nmrespecti ng relevancy of Budget debate debate 1 032; Doer 1 032; 1453-5 Members cautioned (Dacquay) 1032 Economic Innovation and Technology Council Act P/0 by Er:nmrespec ting words "has no guts" (Bill 9) (Maloway) 1628; 2r 3056-9 Member cautioned (Dacquay) 1628 Fitness and Sport (Supply) P/0 by Martindale respecting word "stupid" 5214-7 (Ernst) 4396; Lodge Operators and Outfitters Ucensingand withdrawal requested (Laurendeau) 4396; ConsequentialAmendmen ts Act (Bill 22) withdrawn 4396 2r 3147-52 Private Members' Business Ministerial statements Resolutions Canadian Men's Curling Championship Inner city housing upgrade 4360-2 Response 1250 Manitoba/Russia agreement 3082-3 National Forest Week The Forks Renewal Corporation Response 2870

66 Hansard Index

Evans, C/lf - Cont. Evans, C/lf - Cont. Natural Lands and Special Places Workbook Natural Resources, Department of Response 3843-4 Library services 2465 World Curling championships Pembina Valley Water Co-operative Response 1n1 Assiniboine River Diversion report 925 Natural Resources, Department of (Supply) Petitions Administration and Finance Criminal Code amendments Administrative Services 4872-3 1221 ; ruled in order 1249 Executive Support 4870 Housing authorities Venture Manitoba Tours Ltd. 4871-2 Volunteer boards Opening remarks 1909; ruled in order 21 01 Response 4868-9 Private Members' Business Regional Operations Resolutions Rre Pre-Suppression Program 4962 Manitoba/Russiaagreement 3080-2 Fire Tac Program 4963 Postal rate increase, rural newspapers 656-7 Headquarters Operations 4961 -2 Provincial Park Lands Amendment Act (Bill 21) Resource Programs 2r 4182 Rsheries Social Allowances Amendment and Consequential Administration5088-9 Amendments Act (Bill 70) Forestry 2r 5025-7 Forest Protection 5087 Supply, Capital Silviculture 5086 Supply, Committee of 5341-6, 5351 -2 Parks and Natural Areas SurveysAmendment Act (Bill 34) Management and Development 4972-4 2r 4287-9 Park Operations and Maintenance 4976 Program Services4974-5 Visitor Services 4976-80 EVANS, Leonard(B randon East, NDP) Water Resources Budget debate Administration 4965-6 1198-1205 Water Management 4968-9 City of WinnipegAmendment, Municipal Nonpolitical statements Amendment and Consequential Amendments Mixed Curling Bonspiel Act (Bill 45) Manitou, Manitoba 628 2r 1982-9 Winter Olympics Economic Innovation and Technology Council Act Manitoba participants 628 (Bill 9) Winnipeg Thunder 2r 759-66; 3r 531 3-5 World Basketball League 3372 Finance, Department of (Rnance) Oral questions 5195-5206 Ashern, Manitoba Opening remarks Alternate water source 4986 Response 5193-5 Environmental concerns4986 Grievance, Matterof Ground water contamination 28n Health, Minister of Soil/water testing 4986 Performance 3374-81 Assiniboia Downs Health Care Records Act (Bill 36) Status 130 2r 2734-5 Winter harness racing 130 Health, Departmentof (Supply) Assiniboine River Diversion Administration and Rnance FederaVProvincial review 926 Executive Support 1838-47

67 Hansard Index

Evans, Leonard - Cont. Evans, Leonard - Cont. Interim Appropriation Act, 1992 (Bill 67) Employment programs 2r 1631-5; C/W 1767-8 Northern Manitoba 2875 Ministerial statements Employment Resources Regional Offices Canadian Women's Curling Championship Closure 1052-3, 1179 Response 1047-8 Rrst Ministers' Conference Defence Infrastructure, Advisory Group on Employment creation strategy 355-6 Manitoba presentation Goods and servicestax elimination 1498 Response 1318-9 Goods and services tax Social assistance Harmonization 131 Off-reserve Status Indians Habitat enhancement program Response 3671 Little Saskatchewan River 41 66 Municipal Assessment Amendment Act (Bill 20) Health care system 2r 4177-81 Cataract surgery 1661-2 Oral questions Housing, Department of Brandon General Hospital Layoffs-Brandon, Manitoba 3646 Budget reduction 602 Manufacturing industry Funding 1773-4, 3088-9 Employment statistics 406-7 Labour adjustment strategy 1774 Shipment statistics3958-9 Palliative care unit 1165 Natural Resources, Departmentof Service reduction 560, 603, 3089 Rsheries branch-Brandon Budget Closure 4166 Construction industry 1326 NorthernYouth Corps Job Program Employment creation strategy 1325 Funding restoration 973 CFB Shilo Pharmacare Continuation 691 Exclusions 51 76 CareerStartprogram Retail trade sector Centralized administration 1180 Employment statistics 131 Funding 1180, 2107, 2874 Sales decline 1497-8 Funding restoration 973, 1326 Simplot-Brandon plant Status report 2875 Governmentassistance 3959 Civil servants Modernization691 Westman region positions 3645 Social assistance Decentralization Alternative 356 Brandon, Manitoba 1053 Employment creation strategy 21 07-8, 2251-2 Relocation statistics 3645 Off-reserve status indians Economic growth 2357-8, 2466-7, 3142-3 Anti-recession task force 266 Student Temporary Employment Program Consumer confidence3898-9 Funding restoration 974 Employment creation strategy 56, 131, 265 Unemployment, youth Government policy 1756-7 Employment creation strategy2251 Government policy performance 5406 Government initiatives 3368-9 Government strategy 3787-8 Petitions Interprovincial migration 1757 Brandon General Hospital Municipal public works program 2787 2684; ruled in order 2740 Manufacturing industry 3899 2789; ruled in order 2869 Population statistics 5406-7 2868; ruled in order 2984-5 Provincial comparisons 56 3360; ruled in order 3405

68 Hansard Index

Evans, Leonard - Cont. Executive Council (Supply) 3785; ruled in order 3842 Management and Administration 3842; ruled in order 3891 Carstairs 1544-8, 1584, 1589-90, 1593-4, 3891 ; ruled in order 3950 1598-9, 1601-3; Doer 1539-44, 1548-53, 3950; ruled in order 3978 1585-93, 1594-1 601 ; Filmon 1539-53, 3978; ruled in order 4093 1584-1 603 41 98; ruled in order 4297 Opening remarks 4297; ruled in order 4497 Filmon 1526-30 4497; ruled in order 51 07 Response 5107; ruled in order 51 67 Carstairs 1535-8; Doer 1530-5 5401 ; Faith Community Baptist Church Points of Order P/0 by � respecting sub-judice Building relocation convention 747; L. Evans 747; Driedger 3852; Rose 3852 Lamoureux 747-8; Family life education taken under advisement (Dacquay) 748; Speaker's ruling 2007-8 Compulsory curriculum Private Members' Business Carstairs 3321 ; Vodrey 3321 Public Health Amendment Act Family Maintenance Amendment Act Legal opinion 4533-5 (8111 89) Provincial Auditor's Amendment Act (Bill 92) 1 r Manness 3265; 2r Barrett 4586; 2r 5162-3; em 5235 Edwards 4586-9; McCrae 4283-4; referred Public Accounts, Standing Committee on to Standing Committee on Law Amendments; 1st Report 168-9 RIS McCrae52 20; 3r Barrett 5327-8; RIA 5492 2nd Report396-7 Social Allowances Amendment and Consequential Family Services, Departmentof Amendments Act (Bill 70) Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 73) 2r 5127-34; 3r 5382-6 Gilleshammer 1490 Special Operating Agencies Financing Child abuse protocols (T.P. 59) Authority Act (Bill 96) Gilleshammer 2388 em 5256; 3r 541 2 Internal review Statute Law Amendment Act, 1992 (Bill 1 01 ) Carstairs 3270; Filmon 3270 2r 51 78 Service and Funding Agreement (T.P. 56) Statute Law Amendment (Taxation) Act, 1992 Gilleshammer 2329 (Bill 94) Supplementary Information C/W 5236-7, 5239-44, 5246-51 ; 3r 53 18 1992-93 Estimates (T.P. 32) Supply, Capital Gilleshammer 1490 Supply, Committee of 5296-8 Tabled papers Family Services, Departmentof (Supply) Social assistance Administration and Finance Off-reserve status indians (T.P. 87) 3142 Agency Relations Bureau Tax Appeals Commission Act (Bill 95) Alcock 1893-5; Barrett 1890-3; Cm 5255-6 Gilleshammer 1890-5 Throne speech debate Children's Advocate 253-9 Alcock 181 9-27; Barrett 1814-9, 1878-9; Urgent Public Importance, Mattersof Gilleshammer 181 4-26, 1878-9 Economic crisis 425-7, 2882-3 Executive Support

69 Hansard Index

Family Services (S upply) - Cont. Family Services (Supply) - Cont. Barrett 1814; Gilleshammer 1814 Alcock 181 0-4; Barrett 1808-1 0 Information systems Registration and Licensing Barrett 1895; Gllleshammer 1895 Residential Care Licensing Internal Audit Barrett18 97 -8; Gilleshammer 1897-8 Barrett18 89-90; Gilleshammer 1889-90 Vital Statistics Minister's salary Barrett 1896-7; Gilleshammer 1896-7 Barrett2454 ; Carstairs 2454-6; Rehabilitation and Community Living Gilleshammer 2456 Administration Policy and Planning Barrett21 35-43; Carstairs 2143-52·• Alcock 1884-9; Barrett 1879-84; Gilleshammer 2136-52 Gilleshammer 1879-89 Community Living and Vocational Social Services Advisory Committee Rehabilitation Barrett 1879; Gilleshammer 1879 Adult Services Child and Family Services Barrett21 78-9; Gilleshammer 21 78-9 Administration Children's Special Services Barrett2328-9; Gilleshammer 2328-9 Barrett21 79-87. 2189-91; Child and Family Support Carstairs 2187-9; Gilleshammer 2180-91 Barrett2329- 33, 2388-95, 2398-2402; Manitoba Developmental Centre Carstairs 2334-8, 2385-8, 2395-8; Barrett2226-9; Carsta irs 2229-30; Gilleshammer 2329-39, 2384-2402; Gilleshammer 2227-30 Plohman 2384-5 Special Employment Programs Family Conciliation Employability Enhancement Barrett 2443-5; Carstairs2446- 7; Barrett 2240-3; Carstairs 2243; Gilleshammer 2443-7 Gilleshammer 2240-3 Family Dispute Services Human Resources OpportunityCentre Barrett2447-52 ; Carstairs 2452-3; Barrett 2232; Carstairs2233-4 ; Gilleshammer 2447-53 Dewar 2230-2;Gilleshammer 2230-4 Seven Oaks Youth Centre Partners with Youth Barrett 2440; Carstairs 2440-3 Child Day Care Barrett 2327-8; Gilleshammer 2327-8 Barrett2048- 57; Carstairs 2057-64; Youth Programs Gilleshammer 2048-64 Barrett2234-8; Carstairs 2238-40; Income Security and Regional Operations Gilleshammer 2235-40 Central Directorate Farm Income Assurance Plans Amendment Barrett 1898; Gilleshammer 1898-9 Act (Bill 43) Income Maintenance Programs Alcock 1907-8, 1946-55; Barrett 1899-1 907; 1 r Findlay 596; 2r Ashton 3966-9; Gilleshammer 1899-1 907, 1946-55 Findlay 733-4; Gaudry 952-3; Plohman 2262-9; Income Supplement Programs referred to Standing Committee on Agriculture; Barrett 1955-9; Gilleshammer 1955-9; R!SFindlay 5219; 3r Plohman 5229-31 ; Lamoureux 1956-7 RIA 5491 Regional Operations Alcock 1960; Barrett 1959-60, 2046-7; Farm Lands Ownership Board Gilleshammer 1959-61 , 2046-7 Annual Report, 1991 (S.P. 5) Opening remarks Findlay 122 Gilleshammer 1806-8 Annual Report production costs Response Edwards 228; Mitchelson 228, 268

70 Hansard Index

Farm practices legislation Fllmon, Hon. Gary - Cont. Environmental guidelines Witney, Charles H. 604-5 Findlay 4604-5; Plohman 4604-5 Economic Innovation andTechnology Council Act Game farming (Bill 9) Findlay 4990; Wowchuk 4990 1 r 169; 2r 629-31 , 3059-61 Mandate Executive Council (Supply) Cummings 3680; Plohman 3680 Management and Administration 1539-53, 1 584-1603 Farm Practices Protection and Opening remarks 1526-30 Consequential Amendments Act (Bill 82) Messages 1 r Findlay 3036; 2r Ashton 4890-1 ; Bill 9 (S.P. 12) 169 Findlay 3324-6; Gaudry 5001 ; Plohman 4893-8; Ministerial statements Wowchuk 41 85-7, 4891 -2; referred to Standing First Ministers' meeting 1702-4 Committee on Municipal Affairs; Western Governors'Associa tion Conference RIS Findlay 5394; 3r Plohman 5411 ; RlA 5492 5260-1 Western Premier's Conference 3406-7 Fatality Inquiries Act Nonpolitical statements Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 75) Hanukkah 27 McCrae 1654 Holocaust Awareness Week 2749 Manitoba's 122nd birthday3274-5 Federal Trade Tribunal Roblin, Senator Duff Manitoba cabinetmakers Retirement 4886-7 Alcock 251 2-3, 3170, 41 02; Ernst 3512; Saint Patrick's Day 1328 Rlmon 2512, 3170; Manness 4102 Ukraine independence 25-6 University of Winnipeg Wesmen Festival of Valsakh GPAC basketball men's championship 1058 See Nonpolitical statements Vimy Ridge anniversary 1919 Oral Questions Fetal Alcohol syndrome ACCESS programs Warnings Government action 4570-1 Carstairs 3043-4; Mcintosh 3044 Premier's discussion 4570 Abinochi Preschool Program Fight Back Against Child Abuse campaign Meeting request 3418 See Petitions Abitibi-Pric�ine Falls De-inking plant Hon. Gary (Tuxedo, PC) (ALMON, Feasibility study 1754-5,21 03-4 remler) resident of Executive Council) Employee-owned proposal 1754 lnlster of Federal/Provincial Relations) Rnancial status 21 03 Administration of Oaths of Office, an Act Aboriginal Justice Inquiry Report respecting the (Bill 1 ) Recommendations 3039 1 r 11 Beverage containers Appropriation Act, 1992 (Bill 1 03) Deposit system 1421-2 3r 5484-90 Bill C-20 Budget debate Extension 685-6 1478-86 Governmentposition 221 -2 (�ndolence, Motions of Legal opinion 222 _§�narson, Henry John 61 1-2 Bill C-22 Hillhouse, Thomas Paterson 606-7 Extension 5262-4

71 Hansard Index

Fl/mon, Hon. Gsry - Cont. Fllmon, Hon. Gsry - Cont. Budget All-partycomm ittee 81 9, 3085-6 Education, post-secondary 1109 Legal opinion request 3085 Employment creation strategy 1 014-5 Multiculturalism 5406 Introduction date 354 Multilateral discussions 823 Budget-Federal National programs, protection of 4735-7 Employment creation strategy 723 Public hearings 3982-3, 4739, 5405 National Science Council 730 Referendum 821 , 823-4, 3088, 4499-500 Business relocations Renegotiation 4883-4 Government discussions 3849 Senate reform 3087-8 CKND Television strike Spending powers 5405 Government advertising policy 1163 Timetable 4501 CN Rail Cross-bordershopping Layoffs 2459-61 Governmentact ions 1049 CRISP program Government strategy 5265 Funding 1324-5 Culture, Heritage and Citizenship, Minister of Canadian Centre for Disease Control Hiring authority 1 054 Start date 724-5 Decentralization Charterof Rights and Freedoms Brandon, Manitoba 692-3 Government support 1468-9 Dutch elm disease Child and Family Services Governmentposition 799 Accountability 3269 Earth Summit Child day care Government agenda 3672-3 National strategy Manitoba delegation367 4 Government support725-6 Economic growth Child poverty All-partytask force 1464-6 Government initiatives 262-3 Anti-recession task force 266 Children's Advocate Average weekly incomes 3785-7 Reporting process 3270 Employment creation strategy Civil Service Commission 265-6, 353-4, 727, 2075-7, 3531 ' 3848, Political interference 57, 58 3849-50 Community-based health care system Employment creation strategy-Federal 3530-1 Government policy 1259 Employment statistics Government priorities 1261 3137-9, 3140-1, 3786, 3846 Community colleges Governmentforecast 287 4 Funding 1708 Governmentinitiatives 2873-4 Conawapa dam project Government policy performance Delays, impact of 4428 2846-8,2849, 3845-7 Joint environmental panel Governmentpriorities 220 Jurisdiction 3953-4 Government strategy 17, 289 Justification 2508 Government strategy-Federal 3530 Penalty clauses 2507 Investment decline 265, 2848-9 Renegotiation 4429 Manufacturing investment 2986 Premier's discussions 2507-8 Private sector investment 2985-6, 341 8 Public Utilities Board Public consultations 355 Review 2509 Summit formation 5402-4 Winnipeg Chamber of Commerce position 522 Economic summit Constitutional proposal Implementation 2987

72 Hansard Index

Fl/mon, Hon. Gary - Cont. Fl/mon, Hon. Gary - Cont. Education and Training, Departmentof Responsibility 688-9 Hiring authority 178 Labour adjustment program Education and Training, Minister of Federal/provincial co-ordination 5108-1 0 Resignation request 57-8 Funding 1325 Education system Macleod Stedman Funding formula 171-3 Employment opportunities16 Employment creation strategy Head office location 17 Governmentcommitment 1158 Manitoba Housing Authority Government priorities 1 015 Staffing-Dauphin, Manitoba 3145 Family Services, Department of Manitoba-U.S. trade deficit Internal Review 3270 Governmentstrategy 1049-50 Federal Trade Tribunal Manufacturing industry Manitoba cabinetmakers 2512-3, 3170 Employment creation strategy 1323 Finance Ministers' meeting Employment statistics 2078 Governmentagenda 221 Shipment statistics 21 94 Labour adjustment strategy 222-3 Mental health care facilities Social programs 222-3 Bed closures 4984 First Ministers' Conference Mining Community Reserve Fund Education and training initiative 290-1 , 1494 Snow Lake, Manitoba 2989-90 Employment creation strategy 355-6 Multicultural Secretariat Goods and servicestax elimination 1498 Hiring policy 58-9 Government agenda 264-5, 290, 1493-4 Net income Francophone School Governance Provincial decline 50-1 Legal opinion request 1759 NorthAmerican Free Trade Agreement Free Trade Agreement Clarification 4604 Employment creation statistics 3037 Governmentconditions 1706-7 Goods and services tax Government position 1323, 1367-8 Harmonization 599 Governmentstrategy 2853 Reporttabling request 599-600 Impact Manitoba 2574-5 Government, Federal Information tabling request 2077-8 Untendered contracts 2351 -2 Labour adjustment strategy 1491 Health care system Labour standards 1716 Reform Premier's position 4604 Government agenda release 3165-6 Public hearings 1706, 2195, 3037-8 Revenue raising proposal 127 Sectoral briefing 2194 Staff layoffs 1223-6 Withdrawal 1323 User fees 598 Northern Flood Agreements Health, Departmentof South Indian Lake External agencies funding 1325 Legal expenses27 42-4 Heritage community Northern Manitoba Granting process 2693 Employment creation strategy 5409-1 0 Highway construction program, National Oak HammockConservation Centre Funding commitment-Federal 1708-9 Environmental assessments 269 Funding commitment-Provincial 1709 Government credibility 269-70 Human Resources Opportunity Centre Oak Hammock Marsh Funding restoration 2080 Ducks Unlimited complex 1911-2, 3673 Infrastructures-Rural Pornography

73 Hansard Index

Fllmon, Hon. Gsry - Cont. Fllmon, Hon. Gsry - Cont. Government policy 341 1-2 Unemployment rate , youth Portof Churchill Governmentstra tegy 2078-9, 4507 Grain shipments690, 3273 Programs funding 51 15 Grain shipments-Russian Republic 3893 Unity Committee report Promotion3273-4 Legal opinion request 820 Rail line protection 690 Urban Aboriginal Strategy Shipment statistics 3892 Governmentaction 4571 Public capital investment Release 3418 Decline 1176-7 Urban Hospital Council Public health organizations Public participation 127 Funding 1260 Reportrequest 127 RCMP services Western Premiers' Conference Shooting Agricultural issues 341 4-5 Independent investigation 3039 Portof Churchill 3273 RCMP uniform Regional development program 3266-8 Governmentposition 1468 Points of Order Racism investigations P/0 by � respecting relevancy of Policing services2991 , 3038 debate (Filmon) 1466; Recession Member cautioned 1466 Social programs 619-20 P/0 by Mbl2n respecting words nspace cadetn Red River Community College (Filmon) 2460; Funding 1707 ruled out of order2460 ; Regional development corporations Members cautioned 2460 Funding 3850 P/0 by A!mlQnrespecting imputation of motives Repap Manitoba Inc. (Filmon) 3038; Manness 3039; Contractual obligations267 taken under advisement 3039; Employment statistics 123 ruled out of order 4436; Employment creation 267 Members cautioned 4436 Environmental assessment 267 P/0 by QQi.[respecting word ncroniesn Technological change 123-4 (Filmon) 1479; Retail trade Sunday shopping 3853 Members cautioned 1479 Round Table on the Environment P/0 by Mitchelson respecting line of questioning Projectreview process 515-7 (Supply) 4681 ; Filmon 4682-3; Lamoureux Rural Development, Minister of 4681-3; Praznik4682; School board interference 4546-8 ruled in order (Rose) 4682-3 School boards Private Members' Business Political interference4501 Resolutions School Division Boundary Review Economic Summit 5443-5 Cancellation 1369-70 Tabled papers Shoal Lake , protection of Rural Development, Minister of Environmental review process 2507 School division interference Premier's discussions 2506 Correspondence (T.P. 175) 4547 Social assistance Throne speech debate Alternative 356 386-94 Tourism promotion campaign Urgent Public Importance, Matter of Tender process 2949-50 Domestic violence 31-3

74 Hansard Index

Finance, Departmentof Fin dlay, Hon. Glen - Cont. Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 35) Soils and Crops Branch 3804-1 3, 3901-12 Manness 466 Technical Servicesand Training Branch Revenue Estimates, 1992-93 (T.P. 193) Agricultural Societies 391 3-4 Manness 5108 Salaries 3912-3 Special audit-Taxation Division (T.P. 1) Veterinary Services Branch 3795-3804 Manness 122 Federal-Provincial Agreement Soil ConservationAgr eement 4009-10 Finance, Departmentof (Supply) Income Insurance and Support Program Alcock 5206-521 0; L. Evans 5195-5206; Administration 401 1-2 Manness 5195-5210 Net Income Stabilization Account 4012-3 Administration and Finance Manitoba Agricultural Credit Corporation Minister's salary Administration 3740-50 Alcock 521 1 ; Manness 521 1-3 Allowance for Doubtful Accounts3750-1 Opening remarks Manitoba Crop Insurance Corporation Manness 5191-3 Administration 3593-361 1, 3682-3705, 3731-7 Response Big Game Damage Compensation 3739-40 L. Evans 5193-5 Gross Revenue Insurance Plan 3738-9 Premiums 3737-8 Finance Ministers' meeting Opening remarks3585-9 Government agenda Policy and Economic Division Doer 220-1 ; Filmon 221 Administration 4000-7 Labour adjustment strategy Agricultural Research Carstairs 222; Filmon 222-3 University of Manitoba grant 4008-9 Manitoba Farm Mediation Board4009 Social programs Regional Agricultural Services Division Carstairs 222-3; Filmon 222-3 Agricultural Crown Lands Branch 3994-4000 Financial Administration Act Central Region 3993-4 Northwest Region 3992 Return under Section 56(3) (S.P. 20) Animal HusbandryAmendment Act (Bill 12) Manness 286 1 r 170; 2r 485-6; RIS 5219 FINDLAY, Hon. Glen (Springfield, PC) Bee-Keepers Repeal Act {Bill 11) (Minister of Agriculture) 1 r 170; 2r 484-5; RIS 521 8-9 (Minister responsible for the administration of Farm Income Assurance Plans Amendment Act The Manitoba Telephone Act) {Bill 43) Agriculture, Departmentof 1 r 596; 2r 733-4; RIS 5219 Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 49) 684 Farm Lands Ownership Board Red Meat Forum Annua1 Report, 1991 {S.P. 5) 122 Terms of reference {T.P. 116) 3795 Farm Practices Protection and Consequential Supplementary information Amendments Act {Bill 82) 1992-93 Estimates (T.P. 84) 3084 1 r 3036; 2r 3324-6; RIS 5394 Visions for the 1990's (T.P. 1 09) 3587 Manitoba Agricultural Credit Corporation Agriculture, Departmentof (Supply) Annual Report, 1991 {S.P. 96) 2790 Administration and Finance Manitoba Crop InsuranceCorporation Executive Support 3592-3 Annua1 Report, 1991 {S.P. 121)4200 Agricultural Development and Marketing Division Correspondence (T.P. 114) 3731 Animal Industry Branch 3751 -7 Manitoba Farm Mediation Board Marketing Branch 3914-23 Annua1 Report, 1991 {S.P. 15) 261

75 Hansard Index

Findlay, Hon. Glen - Cont. Findlay, Hon. Glen - Cont. Manitoba Pork est. Southwest Manitoba 4279-80 Annua1 Report, 1991 (T.P. 160) 4200 Government position 226 Manitoba Telephone System Legal opinion request 1472 Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 97) 2790 Marketing boards 295 Messages Notification deadline 1471 Bill 43 (S.P. 44) 596 Objectives 4279 Bill 44 (S.P. 45) 596 Premium levels 227, 1262-3, 1323-4, 1472 Bill 82 (S.P. 102) 3036 Manitoba Agricultural Credit Corporation Milk Prices Review Amendment Act (Bill 44) Interest rates 1262 1 r 596; 2r 734-6; RIS 5219 Manitoba Telephone System Milk Prices Review Commission Billing contract1018 Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 4) 122 Call Management System 270 Oral questions Directory contract 1613 Agricultural industry Long-distance competition 1612-3 Diversification 1424, 4990 Rate structure 1018-9 Rnancial assistance 54-5 Staff layoffs-Portage Ia Prairie 1158 Agricultural land Telecommunications biii-Federal 1159 Conservation methods 2307 Telephone directory contract 1019 Sustainable development 2307 NorthAmerican Free Trade Agreement Agricultural Ministers' meeting Impact agricultural industry 1373 Agenda 3894 Supply management 1778-9 Agriculture, Departmentof Port of Churchill Laboratories, privatization of 3985-6 Rail line protection 1020 Soils and Crops branch Processing potato producers Budget 1423 Marketing board 3537 Bill 82 Soil Testing Laboratory Environmental guidelines 4604-5 Privatization results 3986 Game farming 4990 University of Manitoba Crop insurance Agricultural research 1424 Big game/waterfowl damage 41 01-2 Vegetable producing industry Crop adjuster salaries 227 Day haul worker program - Federal 1373 Crow benefit U.S. inspections 1373 Government position 360-1 Veterinary Drug Centre Payment plan 3268-9, 3578-9 Privatization results 3986 Public hearings 361 Western Premiers' Conference Farming industry Crow benefit 3269 Financial assistance 728-9 Wild Kingdom Zoo-Dauphin General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade Inhumane treatment of animals 4882-3 Supply management proposal Prairie Agricultural Machinery Institute 404-5, 597-8,627 Annual Report, 1991 (T.P. 17) 694 Grain exports-U.S. Licensing process 3537 Fire Safety Safari Gross Revenue Insurance Program See Priva te Members'Business-Resolutions Contract validity 1324 Coverage levels First Ministers' Conference Lentils 2794 Educationand training initiative Risk area 12 2741-2, 2744, 2795 Carstairs 290, 1494; Filmon 290-1 , 1494

76 Hansard Index

Firs t Ministers' Conference - Cont. Forest Week, National Employment creation strategy See Ministerial statements L. Evans 355-6; Film on 355-6 Goods and servicestax elimination ForestryIn dustry L. Evans 1498; Filmon 1498 Sustainable development Governmentagenda Carstairs 972-3; Enns 972-3 Alcock 264-5;Carstairs 290, 1493; Filmon 264-5,290, 14 93-4 Fort Richmond Centurions See also Ministerial statements See Nonpolitical statements Foster care Fisheries Industry Parental training program Rough fish marketing Carstairs 3143-4; Gilleshammer 3143-4 Enns 1163-4; Wowchuk 1163 Standards review See also Lake Winnipegosis Carstairs 3144; Gilleshammer 3144

Fitness and Sport(S upply) Franchises Act (8111 18) Edwards 521 5-7; C. Evans 5214-7; 1 r Maloway 870; 2r Ashton 2836-9; Stefanson 5214-7 Barrett 4487-9; Maloway 1003-6; Reid 3632-5; Reimer 1962-4; Food banks Francophone Schools Governance Increased use Legal opinion request Gilleshammer 263-4; Martindale263 Filmon 1759; Gaudry 1758-9 See also University of Manitoba Free Trade Agreement Foreign domestic workers Abrogation Correspondence(T.P. 12 2) Downey 403; Manness 3644; Cerilli 3896 Storie 403, 3643-4 Deportation intervention Employment creation statistics Lamoureux 3897; Mitchelson 3897 Alcock 3646; Doer 3036-7; Filmon 3037; Investigations Manness 3644, 3646-7; Storie 3644 Cerilli 3895-6; Mitchelson 3895-6 Governmentsupport See also Petitions Alcock 3582-3; Manness 3583-4 Impact on food processing industry Hickes 1777; Stefanson 1777 Foreign Domestic Workers' Program Impact on industrial production Governmentaccess Alcock 3583; Manness 3583 Cerilli 3534; Mitchelson 3534 Impact on Manitoba Government position Doer 2573; Stefanson 2573 Cerilli 1 021 -2; Lamoureux 1160-1 ; Impact on manufacturing industry Mitchelson 1 022, 1160-1 Doer 4596-7; Stefanson 4597 Labour law coverage Labour adjustment strategy Cerilli 3533; Praznik 3534 Alcock 3647; Doer 2573; Hickes 1777; Minister's consultations Manness 3647-8; Stet anson 1777, 2573-4 Cerilli 3534; Mitchelson 3534 Softwood lumber duty Minister's correspondence Lathlin 1113; Manness 1178; Lamoureux 3274, 3897; Mitchelson 3274, 3897 Stefanson 1113, 1177; Storie 1177

77 Hansard Index

Free Tra de Agreement-Cont. Friesen, Jean - Cont. Sea also North American Free Trade Agreement Red River Community College 371 2-9, 3763-8 Student Financial Assistance 3826-30 Freedomof Information Act Program Development and Support Services Annua1 Report, 1990 (S.P. 8) Native Education 2981 -3, 3018-26 Interim Appropriation Act, 1992 (Bill 67) Mitchelson 169 2r 1617-22;C/W 1678-9 Annual Report, 1990 (S.P. 63) Ministerial statements Rocan 1156 Constitutional meeting FRIESEN, Jean (Wolseley, NDP) Multilateral discussions Response 3362 City of Winnipeg Amendment Act (2) (Bill 35) Post-Secondary Student Support Program 2r 298-9; 3r 364-6 Status Indians City of Winnipeg Amendment Act (3) (Bill 78) Response 4568-9 2r 5144-5;3r 5423-7 Nonpolitical statements City of Winnipeg Amendment, Municipal Border Crossings magazine Amendment and Consequential Amendments Magazine of the year award 4309 Act (Bill 45) Compton, Jim 2r 2092-9; 3r 2469-74 Canada Award recipient 731 Culture, Heritage and Citizenship, Departmentof Friesen, Henry (Supply) Medical Research Council of Canada 3047 Administration Westminster United Church Executive Support4668-79 1 DOth anniversary 3373 Manitoba Film Classification Board 4698 Oral questions Minister's salary 5050-1 ACCESS programs Culture, Heritage and Recreation Programs Funding reductions 31 69 Arts Branch 4807-9 Aboriginal issues Executive Administration 4698-9, 4796-4802 Education/training opportunities4571 Grants to Cultural Organizations 4803-6 Bill 45 Historic Resources 481 5 City of Winnipeg resolution21 98 Public Library Services4812-3 Minister's authority 21 98 Multiculturalism Secession referendum 21 98 Multicultural Secretariat 5050-1 Budget-Federal Opening remarks Impact cultural program 799-800 Response 4665-7 Community colleges Economic Innovation andTech nology Council Act Accessibility 601 (Bi11 9) Alternatives 1755 2r 939-46 Funding 601 , 1050, 1708, 1755 Education, Department of (Supply) Funding restoration 874 Post-Secondary, Adult and Continuing Education Constitutional proposal and Training Cultural programs, devolution of 4506-7 Assiniboine Community College 3768-74 Core Area Agreement Education and Training Assistance 381 7-9 Education programs 1230 Executive Administration Inner City Foundation 129 3187, 3191-4, 3247-60,3301 Proposed projects 128 Program Analysis, Co-ordinationand Support Public consultations228, 3792 3305-8, 3398-3404, 3429-34, 351 4-9, 3526-8, Renewal 1370-1 3627-9,3709-12 Replacement 128, 3791 -2

78 Hansard Index

Friesen, Jean - Cont. Friesen, Jean - Cont. Dutch elm disease program Implementation 2689 Funding, provincial 1970-1 , 2748 Urban aboriginal medical program Funding restoration 519, 1320-1 Funding reduction 4571 Multiyear planning 1321 Urban Aboriginal Strategy Replacement tree allocation 3677 Government action 4571 Review 3677 Governmentcom mitment 1608 Scientific opinion tabling request 1915-6 Petitions Two-percentloss limit 2852-3 Abinochi preschool program Education, aboriginal 1701; ruled in order 1753 Post-secondary accessibility600 Criminal Codeamendments Education, post-secondary 1909; ruled in order 1965-6 Accessibility 87 4, 5407 Dutch elm disease program funding Funding restoration 1050 791 ; ruled in order 81 9 Employment retraining programs 2074; ruled in order 2192-3 Governmentinitiatives 727-8 2349; ruled in order 2457 Employment training programs 2457; ruled in order 2505 Government strategy 4300 2571 ; ruled in order 2589 Heritage community 2868; ruled in order 2984 Funding reduction 4989 3842; ruled in order 41 61 Public consultations 3584 4160; ruled in order 4198-9 Inner-city renewal programs 4272; ruled in order 4298 Funding impact 2595 4426; ruled in order 4498-9 Government commitment 1229 4566; ruled in order 4594 Labour Force Development Agreement 4735; ruled in order 4877 Governmentparticipation 51 69 5401 ; Labour forcedevelopment boards Fight Back Against Child Abuse campaign Announcement 4886 1489; ruled in order 1652-3 Manitoba Heritage Federation Private Members' Business Correspondence request 4990 Address for Papers Granting authority 3584 Public Health Amendment Act Information tabling request 3584 Legal opinion 1692-5 Meeting cancellations 2580 Resolutions Meeting requests 2355 Core Area Initiative renewal 545-7 Peer review 2356 Core Area Initiative Ill 4535-8, 4541-2 Political interference 2580 Resolutions Volunteer role 2580 Riel, Louis Property rights proposal Role in development of Manitoba 3658-61 Legal opinion request 800 Tabled papers Red River Community College Bill 45 Funding 1707 City of Winnipeg Resolution (T.P. 54) 2198 Universities Red River Community College Departmental review 2463 Course startdates (T. P. 46) 1755 Funding formula 173 Universities Levels of instruction 2463 Tuition fees (T.P. 61) 2462 Review 5407 Throne speech debate Tuition fees 2462 160-7 University Education Review Commission University of Manitoba Amendment Act (Bill 25)

79 Hansard Index

Friesen, Jean - Cont. Garrison Diversion Project 2r 781-4 Environmental impact assessment Urban Affairs, Departmentof (Supply) Edwards 5173; Enns 5173 Administration and Finance Manitoba interests Executive Support 4337-8 Edwards 5172-3; Enns 51 73 Expenditures Related to Capital Financial Assistance to the City of Winnipeg 4354-5 Gas utilities Financial Assistance to the City of Winnipeg Monthly fixed charge UnconditionalCurrent Programs Grant 4339 Maloway 227-8; Mcintosh 227-8 Opening remarks Response 4335-6 GAUDRY, Nell (St. Boniface, LIB.) Urban Policy and Agreement Management Core Area Renewed Agreement 4350-3 Agriculture, Departmentof (Supply) Administration and Finance Salaries 4342-7 Executive Support 3592-3 Urgent Public Importance, Matter of Agricultural Development and Marketing Division Manitoba Heritage Federation Animal Industry Branch 3751 , 3755 Granting authority 2583-4 Marketing Branch 3920-1 Soils and Crops Branch 381 0-2804 Friesen, Henry Technical Servicesand Training Branch See Nonpolitical statements Salaries 3912-3 Veterinary Services Branch 3801-2 FurnaceInspections Manitoba Agricultural Credit Corporation Faulty heat exchangers Administration 3749-50 Cummings 251 2; Maloway25 12 Allowance for Doubtful Accounts 3750-1 Carbon monoxide levels Manitoba Crop Insurance Corporation Maloway 251 1-2; Orchard 2512 Administration 3693-5 Condemning authority Gross Revenue Insurance Plan 3739 Maloway 21 09-10, 2254; Praznik 21 10, 2254 Premiums 3737-8 Mandatory Opening remarks Response 3591 -2 Maloway 2254; Praznik 2254 Policy and Economic Division Administration4007 GATT Manitoba Farm Mediation Board 4009 See General Agreement on Tariffs and Trades Regional Agricultural Services Division NorthwestRegion 3993 GRIP Budget debate See Gross Revenue Insurance Plan 1390-1400 City of Winnipeg Amendment Act (3) (Bill 78) GST 2r 5141-4 See Goods and Services Tax Consumer and Corporate Affairs, Department of (Supply) GarnishmentAmendment Act (Bill 8) Administration and Finance 1 r McCrae 170; 2r Chomiak 537-8; Research and Planning 4447-8 Lamoureux 538; McCrae 482 ; referred to Farm Income Assurance Plans Amendment Act Standing Committee on Law Amendments; (Bill 43) RIS Manness 3961 ; 3r 5221 ; RIA 5491 2r 952-3

80 Hansard Index

Gsudry, Nell - Cont. Gsudry, Nell - Cont. Farm Practices Protection and Consequential Northern Development and Co-ordination Amendments Act (Bill 82) Northern Rood Agreement 2r 5001 Economic Development Health, Departmentof (Supply) Corporate Projects 4062 Administration and Finance Salaries 4061 -2 Evaluation and Audit Secretariat 241 3-6 Northern Rood Program 4055-6, 4060 Milk Prices Review Amendment Act (Bill 44) Opening remarks 2r 2260-1 Response 4047 Ministerial statements Oral questions Air ambulance service 55 Plus program Response 219 Indexing 2020 Alco Rural Development Bond Corporation Associationfor a Clean Rural Environment Response 49 Environment Act violation 1778 Defence Infrastructure, Advisory Group on Pesticide container disposal 1777-8 Manitoba presentation Review 1778 Response 1319 Agricultural industry Municipal Amendment Act (Bill 31) Diversification 1424 1 r 397; 2r 908-9 Agricultural land Municipal Assessment AmendmentAct (Bill 20) Conservation methods 2306-7 2r 767 Sustainable development 2307 Nonpolitical statements Agriculture, Departmentof International Assemblyof French-language Soils and Crops branch Parliamentarians Budget 1423 3173-4 Francophone Schools Governance Manitoba commemorative coin 1921 Legal opinion request17 58-9 Manitoba's 122nd birthday3277-9 Gross Revenue Insurance Program National Safe Driving Week 24-5 Coverage levels-Risk areas 2744 Nelson Mclntrye Collegiate Hazardous waste Girls' varsity basketball team 1499 Pesticide container classification2355 Radio communautaire du Manitoba 59-60 Health, Departmentof Riel, Louis Regional operations Federal recognition 1118 St. Boniface 1916 NorthernAffairs, Departmentof (Supply) Natural Resources, Departmentof Administration and Finance Waste disposal-Winnipeg Floodway Executive Support 4047-8 4301 ' 4433-4 Communities Economic Development Fund Russell, Manitoba 4050 Dissolution 51 75 Expenditures Related to Capital Plebiscite 5176 Northern Communities 4105, 41 08 University of Manitoba Local Government Development Agricultural research 1423-4 Programs and Operational Support Private Members' Business Community Training 4051 Resolutions Grants 4051 Constitutional task force 4193-5 Regional Services4051 Education, distance 4653-4 Selkirk Region 4054 Resolutions Native Affairs Secretariat Riel, Louis Aboriginal Development Programs 4072 Role in development ofManitoba 3661-4

81 Hansard Index

Gaudry, Nell - Cont. GILLESHAMMER, Hon. Harold Rural Development, Departmentof (Supply) {Minnedosa, PC) Administration and Finance (Minister of Family Services) Brandon Office 3446 Child and Family ServicesAmendment Act Executive support (Bill 64) Other expenditures 3444 1 r 1320; 2r 19n-9; RIS 5333 Family Services, Department of Expenditures Related to Capital Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 73) 1490 Downtown Revitalization 3491 Child abuse protocols (T.P. 59) 2388 Drought Proofing 3491 Service and FundingAgr eement (T.P. 56) 2329 Local GovernmentServices Division Supplementary Information Executive Administration 3472 1992-93 Estimates (T.P. 32) 1490 Municipal Advisory and Financial Services Family Services, Department of (Supply) Grants to Municipalities in Lieu of Taxes 3475 Administration and Finance Police Services Grants 3478 Agency Relations Bureau 1890-5 Research and Systems 3479-80 Children's Advocate 181 4-26, 1878-9 Transit Grants 3476 Executive support 1814 Lotteries Funded Programs Information Systems 1895 Grow Bonds Program 3494 Internal Audit 1889-90 Partners with Youth 3496 Minister's salary 2454-6 Opening remarks Policy and Planning 1879-89 Response 3443-4 Social Services Advisory Committee 1879 Provincial Planning 3463-6 Child and Family Services Rural Economic Development Division Administration 2328-9 Community Development Child and Family Support 2329-39, 2384-2402 Otherexpenditures 3491 Family Conciliation 2443-7 Salaries 3490 Family Dispute Services2447-53 Economic Development Services Seven Oaks Youth Centre 2440-3 Child Day Care 2048-64 Grants 3488 Income Security and Regional Operations Salaries 3481 , 3488 Central Directorate 1898-9 Executive Administration 3480 Income Maintenance Programs Tabled papers 1899-1 907, 1946-55 Gross Revenue Insurance Program Income Supplement Programs 1955-9 Correspondence (T.P. 68) 2744 Regional Operations 1959-61 , 2046-7 Urgent Public Importance, Matter of Opening remarks 1806-8 Economic crisis 433-4 Registration and Licensing Residential Care Licensing 1897-8 Vital Statistics 1896-7 Gemini Reservation System Rehabilitation and Community Living Merger Administration21 36-52 Driedger 1 018; Reid 1018 Community Living and Vocation Rehabilitation Adult Services 2178-9 Children's Special Services21 80-91 General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade Manitoba Developmental Centre 2227-30 Supply management proposal Special Employment Programs Doer 597-8; Findlay 404-5, 597-8, 627; Employability Enhancement 2240-3 Plohman 404-5, 627 Human Resources OpportunityCentre 2230-4

82 Hansard Index

G/1/eshammer, Hon Harold - Cont. G/1/eshammer, Hon Harold - Cont. Partnerswith Youth 2327-8 Funding formula 1 050-1 Youth Programs 2235-40 Private centres Interim Appropriation Act, 1992 (Bill 67) Government support2597 C/W 1689 Restraining orders, enforcement of 2352-3 Messages Staff layoffs 1051 Bill 64 (S.P. 70) 1320 Subsidized space allocation 1051 Bill 70 (S.P. 76) 1654 Child day care workers Ministerial statements Salary enhancement grants 2597 Social assistance Child development initiative Off-reserve Status Indians 3670-1 Per capita policy 31 71 Nonpolitical statements Child poverty National Access Awareness Week 3991 Federal Minister's statements 31 70 National Missing Children's Week 3793-4 Children's Advocate National Social Work Week 880 Mandate 2880 Oral questions Reporting process 1228, 1257, 2016 Aboriginal Child and Family Services Children's residential facilities Independent review 4740 Curriculumcommittee 3900 Internal review 4740 Decentralization Public inquiry 3790-1 Brandon, Manitoba 1053 Anishinaabe Child and Family Services Disabled employees Funding formula 52-3 Employment standards 3988 Bill 70 Employability Enhancement Programs Amendments 2799, 3674 Funding 2250-1 , 2252-3 Cost savings 2109 Employment programs Financial impact study request 4299 Hiring priority 2851 Justification 41 03 Employment programs, youth Broadway House Northern Manitoba 2875 Alternatefaci lity 1374 Employment Resources Regional Offices Closure 1374 Closure 1 053, 1179-80 Employees' status 1374 Family Services, Departmentof CareerStartprogram Custody dispute-Dauphin4435 Centralized administration 1180 Review Funding 1180, 2874 Aboriginal agencies, relations with 4880-1 Funding restoration 1326 Food banks Status report2875 Increased use 26304 Child and Family Services Human Resources Opportunity Centre Communication process201 5-6 Closure 1371-2, 1972-3, 21 08, 3092 Resources 201 5 Service expansion 1371 -2 Response time 2014 Independent Living Program Child day care Accommodation selection 4505 Centre licensing358 Case review 4506 Fee schedule 1607 Cost effectiveness 4502 Funding - Federal 359 Statistics 4501 Funding formula 358 Inner-city recreation programs Governmentpolicy 1606-7 Governmentsupport 2851 Special needs children 4988-9 Lindenview Residence Child day care centres Funding decrease 4099, 41 69

83 Hansard Index

Gl/leshammer, Hon Harold - Cont. Gl/leshammer, Hon Harold - Cont. SARC report Throne speech debate Recommendations 3675 83-90 Service de Conseiller Glmll Motorsport Park Funding 3958 Seven Oaks Youth Centre Lease renewal, Minister's role in Closure 1227-8, 1256-7 Ducharme 5172; Maloway 51 72 Length of stay 4303-4 Glenlawn Collegiate Social assistance See Nonpolitical statements Benefit cap 1256 CRISP benefits 1256 Goods and Services Tax Common law regulation 1776 Harmonization Discrimination 1776 Carstairs 402, 599; Doer 399; Downey 402; Employment creation strategy 1255, 2251-2 L. Evans 131; Filmon 599; Employment training programs 174 Manness 131, 393-4,402-3; Food allowance 2988-9, 41 02-3 Wasylycia-Leis 598-9 Off-reserve status indians Impact manufacturing industry 2358, 2467, 2596, 2798-9, 3143-4 Doer 400; Manness 400 Provincial tax credit 356-7 Reporttabling request Rate increase 264 Carstairs 599-600; Almon 599-600 Rent appeal intervention4989 See also Urgent Public Importance, Matters of Special needs 357 Social assistance-students Government contracts Categorization 1756 See Priva te Members' Business-Resolutions Increase 171 0 Common law regulation 171 0 Governmentof Canada Reductions 179 Untendered contracts Regulation changes 1756 Doer 2301-3, 2350-1 ; Downey 2392-3; Suche Report Almon 2351-2; Manness 2302; Government response 3989-90 Stefanson 2350-1 Recommendations 2880 Working committee2880 Governmentreports Summer Challenge program Environmentally friendly products Elimination2851 Cummings 228; Edwards 228 Unemployment rate , youth Government strategy21 96-7, 2251 , 2252 Government Services, Departmentof Programs funding 51 14-5 Annual Report, 1991 (S.P. 51 ) Private Members' Business Ducharme 750 Address for Papers Leasing Branch Public Health Amendment Act Consulting firm Legal opinion 1695-7 Doer 1320; Ducharme 1320 Resolutions Director dismissal Daycare, rural 3887-8 Doer 341 0; Ducharme 3410 Domestic violence-free zone, Manitoba 3878-80 Information tabling request Social Allowances Amendment and Consequential Carstairs 1321-2; Ducharme 1322 Amendments Act (Bill 70) Internal audit 1 r 1654;2r 1979-81 ; RIS5333; 3r 5454 Doer 1255, 1655; Ducharme 1255;

84 Hansard Index

GovernmentServes - Cont. Grievance, Matters of- Cont. Ernst 1655 Rural Development, Minister of RCMP investigation School board interference Doer 1254-5, 1654-5; Ducharme 1254-5; Carstairs 4555-9; Derkach 4559-63; Ernst 1655 Edwards 4563-4 Reportrelease Women's Directorate Doer 341 0-1 ; Ducharme 3410 Civil Service investigation Lamoureux 1922-8 Government Services, Departmentof (Supply) Gross Revenue Insurance Plan Alcock 5066-9; Dewar 5063-6; Ducharme 5062-9 Contractvalidity Findlay 1324; Plohman 1324 Grain exports-U.S. Correspondence (T.P. 68) Licensing process Gaudry2744 Downey 2593; Findlay 3537; Plohman 2593, Coverage levels 3536-7 Lentils Grand Rapids Generating Station Findlay 2794; Plohman 2793-4 Risk area 12 Environmental concerns Findlay 2741 -2, 2744, 2795; Gaudry 2744; Cummings 3319; Downey 3318; Lathlin 3318-9 Manness 2741 -2; Plohman 2741 -2: Oil spill Wowchuk 2795 Cummings 1161 ; Lathlin 1161 Southwest Manitoba Stability Findlay 4279-80; Plohman 4279 Cummings 41 67; Lathlin 41 67 Government position Turbine inspections Findlay 226; Plohman 226 Downey 1161 ; Lathlin 1161 Legal opinion request Grand Rapids, Manitoba Findlay 1472; Plohman 1471 -2 Environmental monitoring Marketing boards Cummings 41 67; Lathlin 41 67 Carstairs 295; Findlay 295 Notification deadline Great-West Life AssuranceCompany Findlay 1471 ; Plohman 1471 See Nonpolitical statements Objectives Findlay 4279; Plohman 4279 Greece Premium levels See Nonpolitical statements Findlay 227, 1262-3, 1323-4, 1472; Plohman 226-7, 1262-3, 1323, 1472 Green Team program See also Agriculture, Department of (Supply) Justification Carstairs 5270; Derkach 5270 Grow Bonds See also Vide o lottery terminals See Priva te Members'Business-Resolutions

Grievance, Matters of HROC Health, Minister of See Human Resources Opportunity Centre Performance L. Evans 3374-81 Habitat enhancement program Poverty level Little Saskatchewan River Martindale3382-8 Enns 4166; L. Evans 4166

85 Hansard Index

Hamblin, Lorne and Chris Harper, Elijah - Cont. See Nonpolitical statements Dakota Ojibway Tribal Council Policeforce Handl·Transit Funding 4602 College Louis Riel Cost-sharing agreement Admission policy 357-8 Ernst 1258-9; Friesen 1258-9 Portof Churchill All-partycomm ittee224 Hanukkah Grain shipments 3273 See Nonpolitical statements Promotion 3273 Red Sucker Lake, Manitoba HARPER, Elijah (Rupertsland,NDP) School closure4742-3 Western Premiers' Conference Budget debate Portof Churchill 3273 140�1 0 Petitions Interim Appropriation Act, 1992 (Bill 67) Aboriginal Justice System 2r 1628-31 1415; ruled in order 1604 Interpretation Amendment Act (Bill 3) 3162; ruled in order 3264-5 1r 219 3978; ruled in order 4093-4 Ministerial statements Tabled papers NorthernCentral Hydro Electrification Agreement St. Boniface School Division Response 1253 Admission policy (T.P. 8) 357 Northern Flood Agreement Response 3575-6 Hay Commission Report Northern Affairs, Departmentof (Supply) Governmentresponse Administration and Finance Lamoureux 1 053; Praznik 1053 Executive Support 4048-9 Communities Economic Development Fund Hazardous waste 4050 NorthernAffairs Fund 4049-50 Contaminated soil Local Government Development Cummings 4435-6; Edwards 4435-6 Programs and Operational Support Pesticidecontai ner classification Recreational Director's Program 4053 Cummings 2355; Gaudry 2355 Selkirk Region 4054 Native Affairs Secretariat Headlngley Correctional Institute Aboriginal Development Programs Psychiatric care facilities 4069-73,4105 Edwards 1496-7; McCrae 1496-7 Northern Development and Co-ordination Northern Flood Agreement Headlngley secession Economic Development City of Winnipeg resolution Salaries 4062 Ernst 2198;Friesen 21 98 Northern Flood Program 4055-61 City of Winnipeg resolution (T.P. 54) Northern ManitobaEcon omic Development Friesen 2198 Commission Minister's authority Other Expenditures 4064-5 Ernst219 8; Friesen 21 98 Oral questions Secession referendum Aboriginal Justice Inquiry Report Ernst 2198;Friese n 21 98 Court services, Northern 1368-9 See also City of Winnipeg Amendment Act (Bill 45)

86 Hansard Index

Health AdvisoryNetwo rk Health caresys tem - Cont. Home care program Correspondence (T.P. 188) Orchard 3413; Wasylycia-Leis 3414 Cheema 4987 Reportrelease CT scanners Orchard 3413; Wasylycia-Leis 341 3 Fundraising Orchard 2303-4; Wasylycia-Leis 2303-4 Health Care Directives Act (Bill 16) Cataractsurgery 1 r Cheema 398; 2r Cheema 1 002-3; Cheema 826; L. Evans 1661-2; Edwards4151- 2; Storie 4148-51 Orchard 826, 1661 -2 De insurance Health Care Directives and Consequential Cheema 251 0-1 ; Ducharme 251 0; Amendments Act (Bill 73) Orchard 251 0-1 ; Wasylycia-Leis 2509-1 0 1 r McCrae 2075; Carstairs 4292-6; Essential services agreement Cheema 4289-92; Chomiak 4589-90; Ashton 3417; Praznik 3417 McCrae 2854-5; referred to Standing Fee schedule reform Committee on Law Amendments; Cheema 3677-8; Orchard 3678 RIS Manness 5308; 3r Martindale 5316; Forensic services RIA 5492 Dewar 4306; Orchard4306 Health care facilities Health SmartCard Carstairs 3579-80; Orchard 3579-80 Bed closures Hip/knee replacement surgery Cheema 1111-2, 1470; Cheema 826; Orchard 826 Orchard 878, 1111-2, 1466, 1470, 1492-3, Hospital bed statistics (T.P. 47) 1772-3,2017-8, 3087, 3141-2; Orchard 1928 Wasylycia-Leis 878, 1492-3, 1772-3, 2017-8, Labour adjustment strategy 3087, 3141-2 Cheema 1471 ; Orchard 1471 Funding Multicultural policy Orchard 1 181 ; W asylycia-Leis 1181 Operating budgets Cheema 51 15; Orchard 51 15-6 Out-of-province patients Orchard 3166; Wasylycia-Leis 31 66 Cheema 2304; Orchard 2304-5 See also Mental health care fa cilities; specific fa cilities Public accountability Cheema 21 06-7;Orchard 21 06-7 Health Care Records Act (Bill 36) Reform 1 r Wasylycia-Leis 1 048; 2r Ashton 4490-3; Correspondence (T.P. 89) L. Evans 2736-8; Wasylycia-Leis 2734-5 Doer 31 65 Correspondence (T.P. 94) Health care system Orchard 3184 Anesthetist manpower review Spending decision Cheema 2201 ; Orchard 1968-9, 2201 ; Orchard 1110- 1;Wa sylycia-Leis 1110-1 Wasylycia-Leis 1968-9 Staff layoffs Anesthetist shortage Doer 1223-5; Filmon 1223-6 Cheema 177; Orchard 177 Surgery waiting lists Bed closures Cheema 176-7;Orchard 176-7 Correspondence (T.P. 31) Underspending Wasylycia-Leis 1466 Orchard 1 180-1 ; Was ylycia-Leis 1180 Correspondence (T.P. 167) User fees Cheema 4280 Filmon 598; Wasylycia-Leis 598

87 Hansard Index

Health care sys tem, community-based Health caresystem, refonn - Cont. Government initiatives Home care program Cheema 1471 ; Orchard 1471 Cheema 3370; Orchard 3370-1, 3534-5, Government policy 4431-2; Wasylycia-Leis 3534-5, 443 1-2 Cheema 1259; Filmon 1259 Hospital closure Governmentpriorities Cheema 23; Orchard 23 Cheema 1260-1 ; Filmon 1261 Impact employment Licensed practical nurses' role Orchard 3366; Wasylycia-Leis 3365-6 Cheema 3852; Orchard 3852 lm plementation Tax relief program Carstairs 19; Cheema 4987; Carstairs 4431 ; Manness 4431 Orchard 19, 3364, 3366,4987 ; Wasylycia-Leis 3363-4, 3366 Health care system, Northern Information release Mammography/chemotherapy services Carstairs 19; Orchard 19 Orchard 3580-1 ; Wasylycia-Leis 3580 Meeting request Mortality rate Cheema 3167-8; Orchard 3167-8 Orchard 3090;Storie 3090 Monitoring process Transportationfee Carstairs 3366-7, 341 2-3, 3532-3; Ashton 878, 2356; Downey 2356; Cheema 4987; Orchard 3367, 3412-3, 3532-3, Orchard 878-9, 3090-1 ; Storie 3090 4987 Health care system, reform Nursing education Cheema 3851 ; Orchard 3851 Audiology services Patient protection Orchard 3680 ; Wasylycia-Leis 3680 Orchard 3364; Wasylycia-Leis 3364 Bed closures Professional training co-ordination Cheema 3370; Orchard 3323, 3370, 4572-3; Cheema 4550-1 ; Orchard 4551 Wasylycia-Leis 3323, 4572-3 Public awareness campaign Bridge funding Carstairs 51 12-3; Orchard 51 12-3 Carstairs 3367-8; Cheema 3371 ; Orchard 3368, 3371 Revenue-raising proposals Filmon 127; Wasylycia-Leis 127 Community-basedservices Orchard 3365; Wasylycia-Leis 3365 St. John's Ambulance funding Consultations Orchard 3680; Wasylycia-Leis 3680 Ashton 4741 ; Orchard 1492, 3167, 3365, 4741 Specialty treatments Wasylycia-Leis 1492, 3167, 3365 Cheema 23; Orchard 23 Continuing care U.S. residents, services to Carstairs 4430-1 ; Orchard 4430-1 Carstairs 19-20; Cheema 557-8; Co-ordination Orchard 20, 21-2, 557 -8; Cheema 3091-2; Orchard 3091 -2 Wasylycia-Leis 21 Deinsurance Waiting lists review Cheema 22; Orchard 22-3 Carstairs 3533; Orchard 3533 Government agenda Orchard 3041 -2; Wasylycia-Leis 3040-1 Health, Department of Release Annual Report, 1990 (S.P. 94) Doer 3164-6; Filmon 3165-6 Orchard 2685 Health, Minister of Capital program, 1992/93 (T.P. 197) Awareness Orchard 5278 Orchard 22; Wasylycia-Leis 22 Employee morale

88 Hansard Index

Health - Cont. Health (Supply) - Cont. Orchard 975-6; Wasylycia-Leis 975-6 Alcoholism Foundation of Manitoba External agencies Cheema 3233; Orchard 3230-3; Filmon 1325; Lamoureux 1325 Wasylycia-Leis 3230-3 Hospital insurance and health care plans Continuing Care Programs (T.P.78) Administration Orchard 291 3 Cheema 2668-74; Orchard 2665-83,2694-6; Regulation 506/88R Wasylycia-Leis 2665-8, 2679-83, 2694-5; Response to questions (T.P. 62) Wowchuk 2674-9 Orchard 2523 Health Services Staff year vacancy report (T.P. 48) Administration Orchard 1932 Ashton 3007-9, 3015-7, 3094-5, 3101-5, Ultrasoundprostrate biopsies 31 07; Cheema 281 5-23, 2886, 291 3-24, Correspondence(T.P. 80) 2942-5, 2996-7, 3009-15, 3095-3101 ' Cheema 2996 3105-7,31 77-8; Orchard281 5-23, 2886-95, Underspending 2913-58, 2996-3007, 3010-7, 3094-3101' Carstairs 922; Orchard 922 3105-17,31 77; Plohman 2924-35; Wasyiycia-Leis 2886-96,2935 -42, 2945-58, Health, Departmentof (Supply) 2997-3005, 3108-16 Administration and Finance Capital Construction Evaluation and Audit Secretariat Cheema 3214-5; Orchard 3215-7; Cheema 2177-8, 2209-17, 2313-21 , Reid 321 5-7; Wasylycia-Leis 321 6-7 2359-74, 241 6-23;Gaudry 2413-6; Emergency Health and Ambulance Services Orchard 21 78, 2204-26, 231 1 -26, 2359-84, Cheema 321 3-4; Orchard 321 3-4 241 3-27; Reid 2322-6; Hospital and CommunityHealth Services Wasylycia-Leis 2204-9, 2219-26, 2310-3, Cheema 3182-5;Orchard 3178-86; 2374-83, 241 9-20, 2423-7 Wasylycia-Leis 3178-80 Executive support Laboratory and Imaging Services Cheema 1575-83, 1790-3, 1799, 1848-55, Cheema 3204-10; Orchard 3204-13; 1867-73, 1929-33, 1944-6, 2029-31 ' 2038-9, Wasylycia-Leis 321 0-3 21 1 9-29, 2167-8, 2170-4; L. Evans 1838-47; Health Services Insurance Fund Lamoureux 2039-44;Orchard 1525-6, Cheema 3229-30;Orchard 3229-30 1564-83, 1784-1 805, 1839-78, 1928-46, Healthy Public Policy 2025-46,21 14-35, 2162-77; Reid 2044-5; Administration Wasylycia-Leis 1524-5, 1564-74, 1782-9, Cheema 2437-9; Orchard 2434-9; 1794-6, 1 799-1805, 1855-65, 1874-8, Wasylycia-Leis 2434-6, 2439 1933-43, 2025-9, 2031-7, 211 3-9, 2129-36, Health Promotion, Protection and Disease 2162-9, 21 74-7 Prevention Health Information Systems Cheema 251 9-22,2528-34, 261 1-9; Cheema 2430-3; Orchard 2438-33; Orchard 251 6-38, 2601 -9; Wasylycia-Leis 2427-30 Wasylycia-Leis 251 5-8, 2521 -8, 2534-7, Minister's salary 3296 2600-1 1 Ashton 3241-5; Cheema 3235, 3237-9, Healthy Child Development 3240-1 ,3285-7, 3420-2; Derkach 3391 -3; Cheema 2655-9, 2662-4;Orchard 261 9-23, Driedger 3239-41 ; Lamoureux 3292-6,3389; 2650-65; Wasylycia-Leis 261 9-23, 2650-5, Manness 3280-5; Orchard 3236, 3246-7, 2660-2 3287-8, 3390-1' 3422-3; Insured Benefits Wasylycia-Leis 3235-7, 3288-92, 3393-7 Salaries

89 Hansard Index

Health (Supply)- Cont. Health Services Insurance - Cont. Cheema 321 7-21 ; Orchard 321 7-28; referred to Standing Committeeon Law Wasylycia-Leis 3222-8 Amendments; RIS Manness 5308; 3r 5317; Lotteries Funded Programs RIA 5492 Health Policy Evaluation and Research Initiative Hearing disorder screening Cheema 3233-5; Orchard 3233-5 Program funding Opening remarks Chomiak 2575; Orchard 2575 Orchard 1500-1 1 , 1524 Response HELWER, Ed (Gimll, PC) Cheema 1517-23; Wasylycia-Leis 1511-7 Condolence, Motions of Provincial Mental Health Services Hillhouse, Thomas Paterson 61 0 Administration Health Services Insurance Amendment Act (Bill 51) Cheema 2696, 2700-4, 271 1-4, 2804, 2r 1742-4 2808-14; Orchard 2696-271 5, 2801-15; House Business Wasylycia-Leis 2704-1 0, 2714-5, 2801-8 Distance Education Program, First Year Health, Minister of (Res. 34) Sponsorship transfer 654 See Grievance, Matters of Municipal Amendment Act (Bill 31) Health Sciences Centre 2r 2069-71 Nonpolitical statements Bed closures Mcleod, Allan Orchard 1226-7, 191 6-7; Victoria Cross recipient 3046 Wasylycia-Leis 1226-7, 191 6-7 Oral questions Knee/hip replacement surgery Wildlife protection Cheema 796-7;Orchard 796-7 Poaching 2692-3 Operating budget Petitions Orchard 1181 , 1467; Wasylycia-Leis 1181 , Seven Oaks General Hospital 1467 3313; ruled in order 341 8-9 Operating room closure Private Members' Business Orchard 1226; Wasylycia-Leis 1226 Resolutions School of Nursing closure Orchard 4552; Wasylycia-Leis 4551-2 PTH 101 safety 1 078-81 Ukraine, Independenceof 3195-6 Health ServicesInsur ance Amendment Act Seven Oaks General Hospital Incorporation (8111 51) Amendment Act (Bill 90) 1 r Cheema 618; 2r Ashton 4156-8; 1r3529 Barrett 4493-5; Cheema 1008-1 1 ; Throne speech debate Dewar 4265-7; Edwards 4262-3; 43-7 Helwer 1742-4;Lamoureux 1011-2, 1146; Heritage community Laurendeau 3309-12; Manness 2340-2; Martindale 4267-9; Reid 4270-1 ; Funding reduction Wasylycia-Leis 4263-5 Friesen 4989; Mitchelson 4989 Granting process Health ServicesInsurance Amendment and Filmon 2693 ; Lamoureux 2576, 2693; Consequential Amendments Act (Bill 75) Mitchelson 2576 1r Orchard 2075; 2r Cheema 4590-1 ; Public consultations Orchard 3853-4; Wasylycia-Leis 4591 -3; Friesen 3584; Mitchelson 3584

90 Hansard Index

HICKES, George (Point Douglas, NDP) Hlckes, George - Cont. Economic Innovation and Technology Council Act Aboriginal issues (Bi11 9) Government commitment 3955 2r 890-6 Borden Company Ltd. Education and Training, Departmentof (Supply) Labour adjustment strategy 1777 Post-Secondary,Adult and Continuing Education Chinese cooking wine and Training Sale restrictions 1971, 2082-3 Program Analysis, Co-ordinationand Support Conawapa dam project 361 1-8 Public Utilities Board Program Development and SupportServices Review 517-8 Native Education 3026-32 Energy conservation Energy and Mines, Department of (Supply) Funding 1231 Administration and Finance Government strategy 1231 Executive Office 4725 Free Trade Agreement Energy Impact food processing industry 1777 Conawapa Project Co-ordination4730 Labour adjustment strategy 1777 Housing, seniors Energy Administration 4725-7 Energy Planning 4727-8 Lounge repair-1 45 Powers Street 2513 Security systems 2513 Mineral Industry SupportPrograms Inner city renewal programs Manitoba Exploration Incentive Program 4732 Government support51 14 Manitoba Potash Project 4733 Minister's position 51 13 Opening remarks Mount Carmel Clinic Response 4720 Cross-cultural counsellingunit 793-4, 1163 Interim Appropriation Act, 1992 (Bill 67) NativeAff airs, Minister responsible for 2r 1622-4; C/W 1682-5 Public's confidence 141 8 Liquor Control Amendment Act (Bill 77) NorthMain Development Corporation 1r2102; 2r 2569-70, 3638 Funding 51 14 Liquor Control Amendment Act (2) (Bill 91 ) Social assistance-students 2r 3858-9; 3r 5234-5 Reduction 178-9 Lodge Operators and Outfitters Licensingand Solvent abuse legislation Consequential AmendmentsAct (Bill 22) Proclamation 1971-2, 2083 2r 768-71 Urban Aboriginal Strategy Manitoba Hydro Amendment Act (Bill 1 O) Release 3418 2r 667-74 Petitions Milk Prices Review Amendment Act (Bill 44) Abinochi preschool program 2r 2258-60 1701 ; ruled in order 1753 Nonpolitical statements Aboriginal Justice System Core Area Initiative 1770; ruled in order 191 0-1 Training program graduates 1232-3 2192; ruled in order 2246 Oral questions Fight Back Against Child Abuse campaign Abinochi Preschool Program 1365; ruled in order 1415 Closure 1498 1652; ruled in order 1701 Funding 1417-8, 1609, 1761 Private Members' Business Meeting request 1761 , 341 8 Address for Papers Aboriginal Centre Public Health Amendment Act Funding 1609 Legal opinion 958-61 Government commitment 3316-7, 3956 Resolutions

91 Hansard Index

Hlckes, George - Cont. Highways and Transportation Department Aboriginal Justice Commission 1559-62 Amendment Act (8111 14) North American Free Trade Agreement 583-5 1 r Driedger 170; 2r Ashton 2760-8; Workforce 2000 912-4 Driedger 488-90; Edwards 848-9; Reid897-904 ; Social Allowances Amendment and Consequential referred to Standing Committee on Law AmendmentsAct (Bill 70) Amendments; RIS Driedger 5219; RIA 5491 2r 4766-71 Tabled papers Highways and Transportation, Abinochi Preschool Program Departmentof Correspondence (T.P. 36) 1609 Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 14) Chinese cooking wine Driedger 218 Alberta legislation(T.P. 51 ) 2082 District 1 0 headquarters Throne speech debate Downey 2876; Lathlin 2876 320-7 Highway Construction programs .(T.P. 1 03) Urgent Public Importance, Matter of Driedger 3315 Economic crisis 436-7 Supplementary information 1992-93 Estimates (T.P. 1 04) Highway construction program Driedger 331 5 Northam Manitoba Ashton 4104; Downey 41 04 Highways and Transportation, Departmentof (Supply) Highway construction program, National Administration and Finance Funding commitment - Federal Administrative Services Carstairs 1708-9; Filmon 1709 Driedger 4468; Reid 4468 Funding commitment - Provincial Computer Services Carstairs 1709; Filmon 1709 Driedger 4470-3; Edwards 4471 -2; Plohman 4472-3; Reid 4470-1 Highway maintenance Minister'ssalary Responsibility Edwards 471 8-9; Reid 471 9 Driedger 1472; Wowchuk 1472 Occupational Health and Safety See also specific highways, roads, etc. Driedger 4473-4; Reid 4473-4 Personnel Services Highway map - Provincial Driedger 4468-70; Reid 4468-70 Exclusions Boards and Committees Driedger 2197-8; Wowchuk 2197-8 Licence Suspension Appeal Board Driedger 4716-7; Edwards 471 5-7 Highway Traffic Amendment Act (8111 15) Motor Transport Board 1 r Driedger 220; 2r Ashton 3871 -2; Driedger 4712-5; Edwards 4714-5; Driedger 525-6, 3876; Edwards 849-50; Reid 471 2-4 Reid 3872-6; referred to Standing Taxicab Board Committee on Law Amendments; Driedger 4717-8; Edwards 471 7-8 RIS Driedger 52 19; 3r Reid 5226-7; RIA 5491 Driver andVehicle Licensing Licensing Highway TrafficAmendment Act (2) (8111 63) Driedger 4710-1 ; Edwards 471 0-1 1 r Reid 1156-7 Management Services Driedger 4707-1 0; Edwards 4708-9; Highway TrafficAmendment Act (3) (8111 83) Reid 4707-9 1 r Laurendeau 31 37; 2r Laurendeau 41 59 Safety

92 Hansard Index

Highways and Transportation (Supply) - Cont. Highways and Tra nsportation (Supply) - Cont. Driedger 471 1; Edwards 471 1 Reid 4649-52, 4700-4 Transport, Safety and Regulations Driedger 471 2; Edwards 471 1 Highways Protection and Consequential Engineering and Technical Services Amendments Act (Bill 79) Government Air and Radio Services 1 r Driedger 2589; 2r Driedger 3051-4,4997; Driedger 4647-8; Reid 4647-9 Edwards 4991 -2; Reid 4992-7; referred to Mechanical Equipment Services Standing Committee on Municipal Affairs; Driedger 4643-4; Reid 4643-4 RIS Driedger 5394; RIA 5492 NorthernAirports Driedger 4644-5; Edwards 4644-5; Reid 4645 Hillhouse, Thomas Paterson Traffic Engineering See Condolence, Motions of Driedger 4646-7; Edwards 4646-7; Reid 4646 Expenditures Related to Capital Holocaust Awareness Week Construction/Upgrading of Provincial Trunk See Nonpolitical statements Highways Driedger 471 8; Reid 471 8 Home care program Opening remarks Accessibility Driedger 4462-6 Orchard 1762; Santos 1762 Response Advisory committee Edwards 4466-7; Reid 4466 Orchard 623; Wasylycia-Leis 623 Operations and Maintenance Advocacy office Bridges and Structures Orchard 624 ; Wasylycia-Leis 624 Bridge Maintenance Alternative services Driedger 4629-30; Edwards 4629-30 Orchard 556-7, 31 72; Wowchuk 556-7, 3172 Salaries Correspondence (T.P. 38) Driedger 4628-9; Reid 4628-9 Wowchuk 1657 District Offices Decision-making process Ashton 4637-41 ; Dewar 4636-7; Orchard 1421 ; Wowchuk 1421 Driedger 4636-41 Employee conflictof interest Maintenance Program Orchard 141 9-20; Plohman 1419 Driedger 4474-82; Edwards 4478-82; Employee intimidation Reid 4474-8 Orchard 1420-1 ; Wowchuk 1420 Operations and Contracts Funding Driedger 4486; Reid 4486 Orchard 3414; Wasylycia-Leis 3414 Transport Compliance Government commitment Driedger 4631-6; Edwards 4631-2; Orchard 475-6; Wasylycia-Leis 474-5 Reid 4632-6 Licensed practical nurses role Winter Roads Cheema 3898; Orchard 3898 1 00 percent Provincial Privatization Driedger 4482-6; Enns 4485; Reid 4482-5 Orchard 1657; Wowchuk 1657 Planning and Design and Land Surveys Service reduction Land Surveys Orchard 556, 1419, 1420, 1657-8, 1659-60, Driedger 4643; Reid 4643 3171 ; Plohman 1419; Planning and Design Wasylycia-Leis 1659-60; Driedger 4642; Reid 4642 Wowchuk 556, 1420, 1657-8, 3171 Transportation Policy and Research Service reduction-Parkland region Driedger 4649-52, 4700-7; Edwards 4704-6; Orchard 1420; Plohman 1420

93 Hansard Index

Home careprogram - Cont. Housing, Departmentof Services, list of Brandon, Manitoba Orchard 3172; Wowchuk 3171-2 Layoffs Statistics (T.P. 107) Ernst 3646; L. Evans 3646 Wasylycia-Leis 3535 Supplementary information Whiteway, Nancy 1992-93 Estimates (T.P. 73) Orchard 623; Wasylycia-Leis 622-3 Ernst 2869 See also Health Advisory Network; Health Care system, reform Housing, Departmentof (Supply) Administration and Finance Homesteads, Marital PropertyAmendment Executive Support and Consequential Amendments Act Cheema 4372-4; Ernst 4370-4; (8111 88) Martindale 4370-2 Finance and Operations 1 r Manness 3265; 2r Barrett4585; Cheema 4378-9, 4380-3; Ernst 4375-83; Lamoureux 4585-6; McCrae 4282-3; Martindale4375-8, 4379-80 referred to Standing Committee on Law Opening remarks Amendments; R!S McCrae 5220; Ernst4367-8 3r Barrett5327; RIA 5492 Response Cheema 4369; Martindale 4368-9 House Business Program Development and Support Constitutional Referendum Act (Bill 26) Administration Sponsorship transfer Cheema 4383; Ernst 4383 Lamoureux 468 Client Services Distance Education Program, First Year Ernst 4394-8; Martindale4394-8 (Res. 34) Grants and Subsidies Sponsorship transfer Cheema 4398-9; Ernst 4398-40; Helwer 654 Martindale 4398 Manitoba Hydro Amendment Act (Bill 1 0) Project Management Sponsorship transfer Ernst 4393-4; Martindale4393-4 Manness 479 Research and Planning Municipal Assessment Amendment Act (Bill 20) Cheema 4385-9, 4392; Ernst 4383-92; Sponsorship transfer Martindale 4383-5, 4387-92 Manness 479 Transfer Payments to Manitoba Housing and Pages Renewal Corporation Rocan 11 Ernst 4400-3;Martindale 440 2-3; Votes and Proceedings Wowchuk 4400-2 Printing/perusal Housing, Inner city Rocan 11 See Priva te Members'Business-Resolutions

Housing authorities Housing, Minister of See Petitions Apology request Ernst4882 ; Martindale 4881-2 Housing, co-operative Federal program Housing, nonprofit Ernst 1375, 2581 , 2598; Governmentstrategy Martindale 1375, 2581, 2597-8 Ernst 126; Martindale 126

94 Hansard Index

Housing, public-Pembina Highway Immigration Playground structure Federal-Provincial Immigration Agreement Ernst 4882; Martindale 4882 Johnson 5 Governmentrecomme ndations Housing, seniors Cerilli 4879; Mitchelson 4879 Lounge repair-1 45 Powers Street Refugee claimants Ducharme 2513; Ernst 251 3; Hickes 2513 Cerilli 4880; Mitchelson 4880 Security systems See also Culture, Heritage and Citizenship, Ducharme 2513; Hickes 251 3 Department of (Supply)-Citizenship

Hudson's Bay Distribution Centre Immigration Consultants RegistryAct Employment security (BIII 32) Doer 2685-6; Stefanson 2685-6 1 r Lamoureux 397; 2r Lamoureux 3942-4 See also North West Company Impaireddrivers, victims of

Human ResourcesOpportun ity Centre See Ministerial statements Closure Dewar 1371-2, 1972-3, 21 08, 3091 ; Impaired driving Gilleshammer 1371-2, 1972-3, 21 08, 3092 Stayed charges review Funding restoration Chomiak 2878; McCrae 2878-9 Filmon 2080; Martindale 2080 See also Manitoba Public Insurance Corporation Service expansion Dewar 1371 ; Gilleshammer 1371 -2 See also Fa mily Services, Department of (Supply) IndependentLiving Program -Rehabilita tion and Community living; Petitions Accommodation selection Barrett 4505; Gilleshammer 4505 Human Rights Code Amendment Act Case review (BIII 40) Barrett4505-6; Gilleshammer 4506 Cost effectiveness 1rCerilli 353 Carstairs 4502; Gilleshammer 4502 Statistics Human Rights Commission Carstairs 4501 ; Gilleshammer 4501 Annua1 Report, 1990 (S.P. 39) McCrae 513 Indian Birch Reserve Governmentinvolve ment Cheema 4205-6; Downey 4205-6 Child Welfare worker ban McCrae 1055; Render 1055 Human Rights Day, International Industrial Recruitment Initiative See Nonpoliticalstatements Implementation Johnson 5 Immigrant Credentials, Working Group on Derkach 360; Santos 360 Industrial Relations, Standing Executive Summary (T.P. 29) Committee on Mitchelson 1250 1st Report See also Ministerial statements Render 5329-32

95 Hansard Index

Industry, Trade and Tourism, Infrastructures, rural Departmentof Responsibility Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 90) Film on 688-9;Wowch uk 688-9 Stefanson 2589 Economic indicators (T.P. 185) Inner city recreation programs Stefanson 4825 Government support Restructuring Gilleshammer 2851 ; Martindale 2851 Johnson 3 Inner city renewal programs Supplementary information 1992-93 Estimates (T.P. 166) Funding impact Stefanson 4273 Ernst 2595-6; Friesen 2595 Government commitment Ernst 1229; Friesen 1229 Industry, Trade and Tourism (Supply) Governmentsupport Administration and Rnance Ernst 51 14; Hickes 51 14 Minister's position Executive Support Ernst 51 13; Hickes 51 13 Stefanson 4823; Storie 4823 See also Core Area Initiative Grant Assistance-Faculty of Management Alcock 4834-5; Stefanson 4832-5; Internal Reform, Workforce Adjustment Storie 4832-4 and General Salary Increases (Supply) Minister's salary Ashton 5061 ; Doer 5060-1 ; Manness 5061 ; Alcock 4855-6; Storie4854-5 Praznik 5060-1 Strategic Planning Alcock 4828-31 ; Stefanson 4823-32; International Assembly of French-language Storie 4823-8, 4831-2 Parliamentarians Industry and Trade Division See Nonpolitical statements Business Resource Centre Stefanson 4849-50; Storie 4849-50 Interpretation Act Financial Programs Amendments Alcock 4849;Stefanson 4847-9; Lathlin 21 ; McCrae 21 Storie 4847-9 Industry Insurance Act Sectoral development Annua1 Report, 1992 (S.P. 56) Alcock 4838, 4845-6; Connery 4838-42; Mcintosh 792 Stefanson 4836-46; Storie 4835-7, 4842-5 Opening remarks Interim Appropriation Act, 1992 (Bill 67) Stefanson 481 8-20 1 r Ernst 1616; 2r Cheema 1664-8; Response Ernst 1616-7; L. Evans 1631 -5; Alcock 4822-3; Storie 4820-2 Friesen 161 7-22; Harper 1628-31 ; Strategic Development Initiative Division Hickes 1622-4; Lamoureux 1635-41 , 1664; Administration Maloway 1624-8; C/W Alcock 1689-90, Alcock 4850-2; Stefanson 4850-2 171 8-34; Carstairs 1679-82; Cheema 1764-6; Health Industry Development Initiative Doer 1766-7; Downey 1670-2, 1679-85; Stefanson 4852-3 ; Storie 4852-3 Ducharme 1730-4;Ernst 1669-70, 1685-8, Tourism Division 1728-30;L. Evans 1767-8; Friesen 1678-9; Administration Gilleshammer 1689; Hickes 1682-5; Alcock 4853; Storie 4853 Lamoureux 1670-8, 1734-40, 1762-4;

96 Hansard Index

Interim Appropriation Act - Cont. Introduction of Guests- Cont. Manness 171 8-22, 1734-40, 1766-7; Bayne, Nicholas Martindale 1685-9; Mcintosh 1688-9; High Commissioner of Great Britain Mitchelson 1673-9; Orchard 1764-5, 1768; Rocan 4543 Stefanson 1723-8; Vodrey 1689-90, 1762-4; Bemidji State University students RIS Manness 1768; 3r 1768; RIA 1768-9 Rocan 2741 Bennett, Bob Interim Supply NorthDakota Senator Rocan 3951 See Supply, Interim Bernie Wolfe School, Grades 5-6 (Radisson) Interpretation Amendment Act (Bill 3) Rocan 41 62 1 r Harper 219 Bertram E. Glavin School, Grades 5-6 (Concordia) Introduction of Guests Rocan 4569 Blake, Dave 4-H Ambassadors Program Former MLA (Minnedosa) Rocan 3672 Rocan 3872 Acadia Junior High School, Grade 9 Brown, Arnold (St. Norbert) Former MLA (Rhineland) Rocan 551 , 2985 Rocan 1165, 3844 Adult ESL Winnipeg School Division No. 1 Calvin Christian School, Grade 9 Rocan 1157 (River East) Allon, Elliana Rocan 132 Energy of our Resources calendar Canadian Forces Language School Manitoba artist (Sturgeon Creek) Rocan 468 Rocan 4162 Anderson, Harold Carter, David North Dakota Senator Speaker (Alberta Legislative Assembly) Rocan 3951 Rocan 4095 Angus McKay School, Grade 5 Century High School Patriot Jazz Ensemble (Elmwood) Bismarck, North Dakota Rocan 262 Rocan 596 Arborg Collegiate, Grade 9 Charleswood Junior High, Grade 9 (Interlake) (Charleswood) Rocan 171 Dacquay 427 4 Archwood School, Grade 6 Crestview School,Grade 5 (St. Boniface) (Assiniboia) Rocan 2350 Rocan 1490, 1604 Atlantic High School Band Dakota Collegiate (Iowa) Japanese exchange students (Seine River) Rocan 5167 Rocan 2249 Baizley, Obie Darwin School, Grade 9 Former MLA (Osborne) (Riel) Rocan 2301 Rocan 353 Banman, Bob Desjardins, Larry Former MLA (La Verendrye) Former MLA (St. Boniface) Rocan 3371 Dacquay 684

97 Hansard Index

Introduction of Guests - Cont. Introduction of Guests- Cont. Driedger, Herold (St. James) Former MLA (Niakwa) Rocan 49 Rocan 296 Gross Isle School, Grade 6 Ecole Glenwood, Grade 6 (Lakeside) (St. Vital) Rocan 1108-9 Rocan 4596 H.S. Paul School, Grade 5 Elmwood High School, English Language (Seine River) Students Dacquay 694 (Concordia) H.S. Paul School, Grade 9 Rocan 1754 (Seine River) Elmwood High School, Grade 9 Rocan 3981 (Concordia) Hanson, Orlin Rocan 1320 North Dakota Senator Elmwood High School, Grade 12 Rocan 3951 (Concordia) Harapiak, Harry Rocan 4162 Former MLA(The Pas) Elwick Community School, Grade 5 Rocan 299 (The Maples) Harapiak, Leonard Rocan 596 Former MLA (Swan River) Fall, Sir Brian Rocan 299 High Commissioner of Great Britain Hedges Junior High School, Grades 8-9 Rocan 468 (Assiniboia) Garden City Collegiate, Grade 9 Rocan 1490 (Kildonan) Hemdl, Dr. Kurt Rocan 2249, 2458 Ambassador of Austria to Canada Garden City Collegiate, Grade 11 Rocan 3981 (Kildonan) Heyes School, Grade 6 Rocan 2985 (Swan River) Garden Grove School, Grade 5 Rocan 4569 (Inkster) Immaculate Heartof Mary, Grade 5 Rocan 4499 (Burrows) George McDowell School, Grade 9 Rocan 4298 (Seine River) Inwood School, Grades 7-9 Rocan 514 (Interlake) Gnadenthal School, Grade 1-8 Dacquay 723 (Emerson) James Nisbet School, Grade 5 Rocan 3363 (Maples) Grandview School, Grades 11-12 Rocan 31 64 (Dauphin) Jefferson Junior High School, Grades 7-8 Rocan 3891-2 (Kildonan) Grant Park High School, Grade 9 Rocan 5262 (Crescentwood) John De Graff, Grades 5-6 Rocan 220, 1605, 2102 (Rossmere) Green, Sid Rocan 2846 Former MLA (Inkster) John Pritchard School, Grade 9 Rocan 541 0 (River East) Greenway School, Grade 5 Rocan 31 64

98 Hansard Index

In troduction of Guests - Cont. Introduction of Guests - Cont. Johnston, J. Frank Manitoba GovernmentEmp loyees' Association Former MLA (Sturgeon Creek) Women's Committee Rocan 1165 Rocan 2572 Joseph Wolinsky School, Grade 12 Maples Collegiate (St. Johns) (Maples) Rocan 2684 Rocan 1175 Kildonan East Regional Secondary School Margaret Park School,Grades 4-5 Grades 1 1-12(Concordia) (Kildonan) Rocan 220 Rocan 2790 Kilian, Andre Mary Porter School, Grade 5 Ambassador of the Republic ofSouth Africa (Rupertsland) Rocan 3529 Rocan 3643 Kirkness Adult Learning Centre Maxwell, Colin (Broadway) Canadian Wildlife Federation Rocan 2589, 3529, 51 08 Rocan 1966 Klassen, John Metis Senate, members of Honourary Consul ofAustria Rocan 3265-6 Rocan 3981 Miami Elementary School, Grades 5-6 Kleefeld School, Grade 8 (Morris) (Steinbach) Rocan 468 Rocan 3951 Minenko, Mark Kleefeld School, Grades 5-9 Former MLA (Seven Oaks) (Steinbach) Rocan 1232 Rocan 4095 Morden Collegiate, Grade 9 Lakehead Separate School Board Band (Pembina) (Thunder Bay, Ontario) Rocan 4428 Rocan 3981 Morden Collegiate, Grade 11 Landmark School, Grade 5 (Pembina) (La Verendrye) Rocan 4298 Rocan 3084 Mount Manitoba climbing team Leaf Rapids Education Centre, Grade 8 Rocan 2790 (Fiin Aon) Murphy, Rod Rocan 4095 MP (Churchill) Linden Meadows School, Grade 9 Rocan 15 (Tuxedo) Native Business Management Skills Program Rocan 287 (Wellington) Linwood School, Grade 5 Rocan 1966 (Sturgeon Creek) Nellie McClung Collegiate, Grade 11 Dacquay 723, 750 (Pembina) Mahugu, Njuguna Rocan 3576 High commissioner of Kenya to Canada Notre Dame de Lourdes, Grade 6 Rocan 1966 St. Basil, Portneuf, Quebec Mandrake, Ed Rocan 41 55 Former MLA (Assiniboia) Oakenwald School, Grade 5 Rocan 2350 (FortGarry) Manitoba Association for Schooling at Home Rocan 1416 Rocan 171 Onanole Elementary School, Grades 5-6

99 Hansard Index

Introduction of Guests - Cont. Introduction of Guests- Cont. (Minnedosa) Rocan 21 93 Rocan 4569 Riverside School, Grades 7-9 Paradis, Judy (La Verendrye) AIPLF Conference delegate (Maine) Rocan 870 Rocan 3084 Riverton School, Grades 4-5 Park La Salle School, Grade 5 (Interlake) (St. Norbert) Rocan 4200 Rocan 34 10 Riverview School, Grade 5 Parkdale School, Grades 5-6 (Osborne) (Fiin Aon) Rocan 4543 Rocan 41 62 Robert H. Smith School, Grade 5 Pawley, Howard (Selkirk) Former Premier (Manitoba) Rocan 4298 Rocan 596 Robert H. Smith School, Grades 5-6 Perry, Tom (Selkirk) Minister of Advanced Education, Training Rocan 3844 and Technology (British Columbia) Roseau Valley School, Grades 9 and 11 Rocan 5476 (Emerson) Phoenix Elementary School,Grade 5 Rocan 399 (Charleswood) Rosenort School, Grade 9 Dacquay 61 9 (Morris) Provencher School, Grade 9 Rocan 3844 (St. Boniface) Rossburn Elementary School,Grade 8 Rocan 2790 (Roblin-Russell) Queen Elizabeth School, Grades 8-9 Rocan 4877 (St. Boniface) Royal School, Grade 5 Rocan 2075 (Tuxedo) R.B. Russell Vocational School, Grade 12 Rocan 2741 (Point Douglas) St. AndrewsSociety of Winnipeg Rocan 171 Rocan 1771 Ralph Maybank School, Grade 5 St. George School, Grade 9 (Fort Garry) (St. Vital) Rocan 2193 Rocan 49, 171 Red River Community College St. Gerard School. Grade 5 English language students (Point Douglas) (Concordia) Rocan 3137 Rocan 41 62 Red River Community College St. John's-Ravenscourt, Grade 9 Journalism students (Fort Garry) Rocan 3266, 3410 Rocan 969, 3672 Richfield High School Choir Ste. Anne School, Grades 5-6 (Minnesota) (La Verendrye) Rocan 1048 Rocan 1464 River Heights School, Grade 9 Sandy Bay School, Grade 9 (Brandon West) (Ste. Rose) Rocan 4735 Rocan 514 River West Park School, Grade 9 Sargent Park School, Grade 9 (Charleswood) (Wellington)

100 Hansard Index

Introduction of Guests - Cont. Introduction of Guests- Cont. Rocan 1366 University of Manitoba, Student Parliament Searle, Newell (Fort Garry) Department of Agriculture (Minnesota) Rocan 51 08 Rocan 1108 University of Winnipeg, Enrichment program Shott, Kevin (Wolseley) RCMP constable Rocan 3084 Rocan 3981 University of Winnipeg, Sociology students Silver Heights Collegiate (Wolseley) Reach for the Top winners (Sturgeon Creek) Rocan 1175 Rocan 3363 Victor Mager School, Grade 9 Silver Heights Collegiate, (Riel) Student Council (Sturgeon Creek) Dacquay 619 Rocan 2985 Victor Wyatt School, Grade 4 Sisler High School (Seine River) English language students (Inkster) Rocan 1366 Rocan 3266 Villeneuve, Noble Souris Elementary School, Grade 5 MPP (Stormont, Dunas, Glengarry) (Turtle Mountain) Rocan 3137 Rocan 4543 Viscount Alexander School, Grade 9 Southwood Elementary School, Grades 7-8 (FortGarry) (Pembina) Rocan 2458, 2505, 2740-1 Rocan 51 08 Voyageur '92 students Southwood School,Grade 5 Dacquay 41 62 (Steinbach) Rocan 4162, 4543 Rocan 4499 W.B. Lewis School, Grade 5 Stewart, Fred (lac du Bonnet) Ministerof Technology, Telecommunications Rocan 15 and Research (Alberta) Warren Collegiate, Grade11 Rocan 5476 (Lakeside) Sun Valley Elementary School, Grade 5 Rocan 3529 (River East) West Branch High School Band Rocan 2572 (Iowa) Teulon Collegiate, Grade 9 Rocan 3036 (Gimli) Winkler Elementary School, Grade 5 Rocan 2301 (Pembina) Teulon Collegiate, Grade 11 Rocan 4596 (Gimli) Rocan 262 JOHNSON, Hon. George Teulon Elementary School, Grade 4 (Lieutenant-Governor of the Province of (Gimli) Manitoba) Rocan 2013 Royal Assent Treharne School, Grade 7 Amusements Amendment Act (Bill 42) (Gladstone) RIA 5491 Rocan 3643 Animal Husbandry Amendment Act (Bill 12) Tyndall Park School, Grade 4 RIA5491 (Inkster) Appropriation Act, 1992 (Bill 1 03) Rocan 4982 RIA 5493

101 Hansard Index

Johnson, Hon. George - Cont. Johnson, Hon. George - Cont. Bee-Keepers Repeal Act (Bill 11) Highways and Transportation Department RIA 5491 Amendment Act (Bi11 14) Business PracticesAmendment Act (Bill 62) RIA 5491 RIA 5492 Highways Protection and Consequential Child and Family ServicesAmendmen t Act (Bill Amendments Act (Bill 79) 64) RIA5492 RIA 5492 Homesteads, Marital property Amendment and City of Winnipeg Amendment Act (2) (Bill 35) Consequential AmendmentsAct (Bill 88) RIA 395 RIA 5492 City of Winnipeg Amendment Act (3) (Bill 78) Interim Appropriation Act, 1992 (Bill 67) RIA 5492 RIA 1768-9 City of Winnipeg Amendment, Municipal Jury Amendment Act (Bill 46) Amendment and Consequential Amendments RIA 5491 Act (Bill 45) labour Relations Amendment Act (Bill 85) RIA 2494 RIA 5492 Consumer Protection Amendment Act (Bill 61) law Enforcement Review Amendment Act RIA 5491 (Bill 87) Dangerous Goods Handling and Transportation RIA 5492 Amendment Act (Bill 53) law Reform (Miscellaneous Amendments) Act RIA 5491 (Bill 72) Dental Association Amendment Act (Bill 80) RIA 5492 RIA 5492 law Society Amendment Act (Bill 74) Denturists Amendment Act (Bill 6) RIA 5492 RIA 5491 liquor Control Amendment Act (2) (Bill 91 ) Economic Innovation and Technology Council RIA 5492 Act (Bill 9) loan Act, 1992 (Bill 1 02) RIA 5491 RIA 5493 Environment Amendment Act (Bill 49) Manitoba Advisory Council on the Status of RIA 5491 Women Amendment Act (Bill 5) Family Maintenance Amendment Act (Bill 89) RIA 5491 RIA 5492 Manitoba Evidence Amendment Act (Bill 38) Farm Income Assurance Plans Amendment Act RIA 5491 (Bill 43) Manitoba Hydro Amendment Act (Bill 1 0) RIA 5491 RIA 5491 Farm Practices Protection and Consequential Manitoba Multiculturalism Act (Bill 98) Amendments Act (Bill 82) RIA 5492 RIA 5492 Mental Health Amendment Act (Bill 93) Garnishment Amendment Act (Bill 8) RIA5492 RIA 5491 Milk Prices Review Amendment Act (Bill 44) Health Care Directives and Consequential RIA 5491 Amendments Act (Bill 73) Municipal Assessment Amendment Act (Bill 20) RIA 5492 RIA5491 Health Services Insurance Amendment and Optometry Amendment Act (Bill 81 ) Consequential Amendments Act (Bill 75) RIA 5492 RIA 5492 Pension Benefits Amendment Act (Bill 76) Highway TrafficAmendment Act (Bill 15) RIA 5492 RIA5491 Pension Plan Acts Amendment Act (Bill 1 00)

102 Hansard Index

Johnson, Hon. George - Cont. Johnson, Hon. George - Cont. RIA 5492 Winnipeg Bible College and Theological Personal Property Security Amendment Act Seminary Incorporation Amendment Act (Bill 97) (Bill 48) RIA5492 RIA 5491 Throne Speech Petty Trespasses Amendment Act (Bill 47) Aboriginal self-government 9-1 0 RIA 5491 Economic challenges 2-3 Provincial Auditor's AmendmentAct (Bill 92) Economicgrowth 3-7 RIA 5492 National unity 9 Provincial Police Amendment and Consequential Social services 7-9 AmendmentsAct (Bill 86) RIA 5492 Judicial system Public Trustee Amendment, Trustee Amendment and Child and Family ServicesAmendment Act Aboriginal participation (Bill 68) Lathlin 225; McCrae 225 RIA 5492 Bail reviews Real PropertyAmendment Act (Bill 7) Chomiak 2879; McCrae 2879 RIA 5491 Charging directive Residential Tenancies Amendment Act (2) Chomiak 3531 -2; Manness 3532 (Bi11 84) Circuit court RIA 5492 McCrae 1469; Storie 1469 Retirement Plan Beneficiaries Act (Bill 71) Courttranscription service RIA5492 Edwards 1656-7; McCrae 1656-7, 1714 Salvation Army Grace General Hospital Correspondence (T.P. 39) Incorporation Amendment Act (Bill 39) Edwards 1656 RIA 5491 GodsRiver, Manitoba Seven Oaks General Hospital Incorporation Lathlin 554; McCrae 554 Amendment Act (Bill 90) Public defender system RIA 5492 Chomiak 1779; McCrae 1779-80 Social Allowances Amendment and Two-tiered system Consequential Amendments Act (Bill 70) Chomiak 1780; McCrae 1780 RIA 5492 Special Operating Agencies Financing Authority JuryAmendment Act (Bill 46) Act (Bill 96) 1 r McCrae 596; 2r Ashton 646-7; RIA 5492 Chomiak 647; Edwards 647-8; McCrae 646; Statute Law Amendment Act, 1 992 (Bill 1 01) referredto Standing Committee on Law RIA 5493 Amendments; RIS Manness 3962; 3r 5221 ; Statute Law Amendment (Taxation) Act, 1992 RIA 5491 (Bill 94) RIA 5492 SurveysAmendment Act (Bill 34) Justice, Department of RIA 5491 Policy, Planning and Special Projects branch Tax Appeals Commission Act (Bill 95) Major projects (T.P. 154) RIA 5492 McCrae 41 30 The Pas Health Complex Incorporation Supplementary information Amendment Act (Bill 52) 1992-93 Estimates (T.P. 152) RIA 5491 McCrae 4095

103 Hansard Index

Justice, Departmentof (Supply) Justice (Supply) - Cont. Administration and Finance Salaries Human Resource Services Chomiak 41 33-6, 4140-3; Edwards 41 37-40; Edwards 41 32; McCrae 41 32 McCrae 4133-43 Minister's salary Provincial Policing Edwards4259-61 ; Lathlin 4249-58; Chomiak 4147-8; Edwards 4144-7; McCrae 4250-60 McCrae 4145-8 Policy, Planning and Special Projects Keystone Agrlcuhural Producers Chomiak 41 30-2; Edwards 41 30-1 ; McCrae 41 30-2 Correspondence (T.P. 121) Public Inquiry into the Administration of Carstairs 3862 Justice and Aboriginal People LERA Chomiak 41 33; Edwards 41 33; McCrae 41 33 See Law Enforcement Review Agency Corrections Administration Labour adjustment program Chomiak 4240; McCrae 4240 Federal/provincial co-ordination Adult Corrections Doer 5108-1 0; Filmon 5109-1 1 Edwards 4240-2 ; McCrae 4240-3 Funding Courts Filmon 1325; Lamoureux 1325 CourtServices Edwards 4243-6; McCrae 4243-6 Labour College of Canada Regional Courts Scholarship Edwards 4247; McCrae 4247 Ashton 341 6-7; Praznik341 7 Justice Civil Legal Services Labour, Departmentof Chomiak 4237; McCrae 4237 Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 43) Constitutional Law Praznik 551 Edwards 4239-40; McCrae 4239-40 Apprenticeshipand Training branch Family Law Staffing Edwards 4238-9; McCrae 4238-9 Praznik 1715-6; Reid 1715 Manitoba Law Reform Commission Employment standards guide (T.P. 163) Edwards 4237-8; McCrae 4238 Praznik 4228 Opening remarks Supplementary information McCrae 4126-9 1992-93 Estimates (T.P. 155) Response Praznik 41 61 Chomiak 41 29; Edwards 4129 Work stoppages (T.P. 162) Protection of Individual and Property Rights Praznik 42 18 Public Trustee Worker Advisor Office OtherExpenditures Statistics (T.P. 161) Edwards 4248; McCrae 4248 Praznik 4226 Salaries Edwards 4247-8; McCrae 4247-8 Labour, Departmentof (Supply) Public Prosecutions Administration and Finance Board of Review Minister's salary Salaries Lamoureux 4237 Chomiak 4143; Edwards 4143-4; Labour Programs McCrae 4143-4; Storie 41 44 Apprenticeshipand Training

104 Hansard Index

Labour (Supply) - Cont. Labour Relations Amendment Act (8111 85) Ashton 4214-8; Lamoureux 4232, 4235; 1 r Praznik 31 37; 2r Ashton 5149-57; Praznik 421 4-8, 4232, 4235 Cerilli 5023-5; Lamoureux 5157-61 ; Conciliation and Mediation Maloway 5146-8; Martindale47 51-4; Ashton 4218-23; Praznik 421 8-32 Praznik 3326-33; Santos 501 8-23; Employment Standards Storie 4754-61 ; Wowchuk51 48-9; Ashton 4227-8; Lamoureux 4231-2, 4236; referred to Standing Committee on Praznik 4227, 4231-2 Industrial Relations; R/S Praznik 5334; Fire Prevention 3r Ashton 5459-67; Lamoureux 5458-9; Lamoureux 4234-5; Praznik 4234 Praznik 5470-1 ; Reid 5467-70; Storie 5455-8; Labour adjustment RIA5492 Ashton 4228-30; Lamoureux 4235; Praznik 4228-9, 4235 Lake Winnipegosis Mechanical and Engineering Cormorant population control Lamoureux 4233-4; Praznik 4233 Enns 341 6; Wowchuk 341 6 Worker Advisor Office Trap net policy Ashton 4226-7; Lamoureux 4235-6; Enns 1164; Wowchuk 1164 Praznik 4226, 4236 Workplace Safety and Health Lakes and rivers Ashton 4223-5; Praznik 4223-6 Opening remarks Copper sulphate buildup Praznik 4209-1 0 Cerilli 2016-7; Cummings 2017 Response Ashton 421 0-2; Lamoureux 4212-3 LAMOUREUX, Kevin (Inkster, LIB) Amusements Amendment Act (Bill 42) Labour disputes 2r 745-6 CKND Television Beverage Container Act (Bill 50) Proposal regarding union activities (T.P. 35) 2r 1741-2 Ashton 1610 Budget debate 1342-8 Labour Force Development Agreement Child and Family ServicesAmendment Act (2) Governmentparti cipation (Bill 66) Friesen 5169; Vodrey51 69-70 2r 3834-5 National standards City of Winnipeg Amendment, Municipal Carstairs 5170; Vodrey 51 70 Amendment andConsequential Amendments Act (Bill 45) Labour force development boards 2r 994-6 Announcement Civil Service Commission (Supply) Friesen 4886; Vodrey 4886 4322-33 Opening remarks Labour laws Response 4312 Worker protection Consumer and Corporate Affairs, Department of Ashton 3270; Praznik 3270-1 (Supply) Administration and Finance Labour, Minister of Minister's salary 4622-3 Meeting request Consumer Affairs Maloway 2255;Pra znik 2255 Consumers' Bureau 4609-10

105 Hansard Index

Lamoureux, Kevin - Cont. Lamoureux, Kevin - Cont. Culture, Heritage and Citizenship, Departmentof Sponsorship transfer (Supply) Lamoureux 468 Administration Immigration Consultants Registry Act (Bill 32) Executive Support 4679-80, 4684-5, 4692-5 1 r 397; 2r 3942-4 Human Resource Services4695-7 Interim Appropriation Act, 1992 (Bill 67) Minister's salary 5050-1 2r 1635-41 , 1664;C/W 1670-8, 1734-40, 1762-4 Citizenship labour, Departmentof (Supply) Immigration Policy and Planning Administration and Finance 481 6-7, 4941 -9 Minister's salary 4237 Culture, Heritage and Recreation Programs labour Programs Arts Branch 4809-1 0 Apprenticeshipand Training 4232, 4235 Executive Administration 4700 Employment Standards 4231-2, 4236 Grants to Cultural Organizations 4802-3 Fire Prevention 4234-5 Historic Resources 4814 labour adjustment 4235 Public Library Services481 0-2 Mechanical and Engineering 4233-4 Regional Services 481 5 Worker Advisor Office 4235-6 Multiculturalism Opening remarks Multicultural Secretariat 5030-9 Response 4212-3 Opening remarks labour Relations Amendment Act (Bill 85) Response 4667-8 2r 5157-61 ; 3r 5458-9 Decentralization (Supply) legislative Assembly (Supply) Decentralization 4785, 4791 -3 Elections Manitoba 5053-4 Opening remarks Manitoba Advisory Council on the Status of Women Response 4784-5 Amendment Act (Bill 5) Education and Training, Department of (Supply) 2r 650-4, 662-3 Post-Secondary, Adult and Continuing Education Manitoba Multiculturalism Act (Bill 98) and Training 2r 4521-32, 4n9-80, 51 63-4; RIS 5398; Red River Community College 3719-21 3r 5431-4, 5448-50 Family Services, Departmentof (Supply) Ministerial statements Income Security and Regional Operations Education, multicultural Income Supplement Programs 1956-7 Policy for the 1990s Garnishment Amendment Act (Bill 8) Response 3164 2r 538 Immigrant Credentials,Working Group on Grievance, Matter of Executive Summary Women's Directorate Response 1252 Civil service investigation 1922-8 Rural EconomicDevelopment Initiative Health, Departmentof (Supply) Response 2203 Administration and Finance Nonpolitical statements Executive support 2039-44 Citizenship awards 1974-5 Minister's salary 3292-6, 3389 Earth Day 2468 Health Services Insurance Amendment Act (Bill 51 ) International Day for the Elimination of 2r 1011-2, 1 146 Racial Discrimination Homesteads, Marital Property Amendment and 1473 Consequential Amendments Act (Bill 88) McColm, Ken 2r 4585-6 Cross Canada walk 1717 House Business National Day of Mourning 2693-4 Constitutional Referendum Act (Bill 26) Philippine Heritage Week 4308

106 Hansard Index

Lamoureux, Kevin - Cont. Lamoureux, Kevin - Cont. Seniors' Month 3991 Hiring process 3986 Sisler High School Investigation 3987 Youth parliament 362 Multicultural legislation Tartan Day 1781-2 Introduction 2994, 3092-3, 3897 Oral questions Manitoba Grants Advisory Council 4603 Antiracism co-ordinator Manitoba Intercultural Council 4603 Hiring process 1612 Multicultural Secretariat CRISP program Hiring policy 127-8, 925 Funding 1324 Taxicab industry Civil Service Commission luxury cab proposal 876-7 Bulletins Women's Directorate Term positions 3986 Assistant Deputy Minister Political interference 55-6, 58 Competition 1972 Crystal Casino Hiring process924 -5, 1 053-4, 1918 Expansion 3957 Pension Plan Acts Amendment Act (Bill 1 00) Culture, Heritage and Citizenship, Minister of 2r 501 1 Hiring authority 1 054 Petitions Decentralization Foreign Domestic Workers' program Brandon, Manitoba 692 1752; ruled in order 1 no-1 Education and Training, Minister of Manitoba Heritage Federation Resignation request57 Granting authority Foreign domestic workers 3264; ruled out of order 3313-4 Deportation intervention 3897 3313; ruled in order 3574 Foreign DomesticWorkers' Program 3360; ruled in order 3670 Governmentposition 1160-1 3405; ruled in order 4160 Minister's correspondence 3274, 3897 3529; ruled in order (Dacquay)4272 Hay Commission Report 3643; ruled in order 4497-8 Government response 1053 4093; Health, Department of 4198; External agencies funding 1325 4426; Heritage community Points ofOrder Granting process 2576, 2693 P/0 by &b!Qnres pectingdealing with matter labour adjustment program raised 223; Lamoureux 223; Praznik 223; Funding 1325 Members cautioned 223 Manitoba Heritage Federation P/0 by Mtmm.respecting closing debate 2346-7; Funding decisions 1418 Lamoureux 2348; Manness 2347; Reid 2347-8; Granting authority 1372, 2575-6 taken under advisement 2348; Minister's support4281 Speaker's ruling 4495-6 Role 1418 P/0 by laurendeau respecting relevancy of Volunteer role 1372 debate (Edwards) 3062; Lamoureux 3062; Manitoba Intercultural Council Martindale3062; Antiracism recommendations 2994 ruled out of order (Dacquay) 3062 Government's intention 4504-5 P/0 by Mannessrespecting imputation of motives Manitoba legislative Assembly (Cheema) 1260; Ashton 1260-1 ; Cross-culturaltraining 1611-2 Lamoureux 1260; Manitoba lotteries Foundation ruled out of order 1261 Casino plans 3957 P/0 by Mitchelson respecting line of questioning

107 Hansard Index

Lamoureux, Kevin - Cont. Lamoureux, Kevin - Cont. (Supply) 4681 ; Rlmon 4682-3; RIS 541 8; 3r 541 8 Lamoureux 4681-3;Praznik 4682 ; Statute Law Amendment Act, 1992 (Bill 1 01 ) ruled in order (Rose) 4682-3 2r 51 78 P/0 by fmdrespec ting sub-judice Tabled papers convention 747; L. Evans 747; Manitoba Women's Directorate Lamoureux 747-8; Correspondence (T.P. 21) 925 taken under advisement (Dacquay) 748; The Pas Health Complex Incorporation Amendment Speaker's ruling 2007-8 Act (Bill 52) Private Members' Business 2r 3832 Resolutions Throne speech debate Aboriginal Justice Commission 1562-3 201 -7 Bail review provisions, changes to 3946-7 University of Manitoba Amendment Act (Bill 25) CN Rail jobs 1831-3 2r 2066 Constitutional referendum for Canada 291 1-2 Urgent Public Importance, Matters of Crime Prevention Council 864-5 Domestic violence 28 Education, distance 4662-3 Economic crisis 41 1-2, 448-50 Fire Safety Safari 2409-1 1 Manitoba Heritage Federation Governmentcontracts , issuing of 3837-9 Granting authority 2581 -3, 2586-7 Inner city housing upgrade 4262 Vacation With Pay Amendment Act (Bill 33) Medicare, preservation of 3727-8 1r467 North American Free Trade Agreement Winnipeg Bible College and Theological Seminary 507-9, 588 Incorporation Amendment Act (Bill 97) Open Skies 3358 2r 5028 Postal rate increase, rural newspapers 657 Seniors' rights21 60-1 LATHLIN, Oscar (The Pas, NDP) Ukraine, Independenceof 3198-9 Aboriginal JusticeInitiatives (Supply) Video lottery terminals 2647-9 5178-87 Violence, education against 1151-3 Budget debate Women, violence against 4032-6 1355-9 Workforce 2000 914-5 Economic Innovation andTechnology Council Act Privilege, Matters of (Bill 9) Legislative Building security 4437-8 2r 693-7 Quorum counts4565-6 Justice, Department of (Supply) Real Property Amendment Act (Bill 7) Administration and Rnance 2r 536-7 Minister'ssalary 4249-58 Residential Tenancies Amendment Act (2) (Bill 84) Ministerial statements 2r 4581-5 Aboriginal issues Resolutions National meeting Domestic violence-free zone, Manitoba Response 91 8-9 1097-1 102, 2281 -5, 38n-B NorthernAffairs, Departmentof (Supply) Retirement Plan Beneficiaries Act (Bill 71 ) Administration and Rnance 2r4745 Executive Support4048 Salvation Army Grace General Hospital Expenditures Related to Capital Incorporation Amendment Act (Bill 39) Northern Communities 41 05-8 2r 1644-5; 3r38 31-2 Local Government Development Seven Oaks General Hospital Incorporation Programs and Operational Support Amendment Act (Bill 90) Emergency Response Program 4050-1

108 Hansard Index

Lath/In, Oscar- Cont. Lath/In, Oscar - Cont. Recreational Director's Program 4051-3 Aboriginal participation 225 Selkirk Region 4053-4 Gods River, Manitoba 554 The Pas Region 4053 NorthernManitoba Native Affairs Secretariat Employment opportunities 2691 Aboriginal Development Programs FederaVProvincial agreements 24 4066-9,4073-4 Norway House Fishermen's Co-op Other Expenditures 4066 Compensation 2877 Northern Development and Co-ordination Repap Manitoba Inc. NorthernFlood Agreement Employment creation strategy 752 Northern Aood Program 4058-61 Employment protection 752 NorthernManitoba Economic Development Renegotiations 3045 Commission Treaty land entitlements 1113 Other Expenditures 4064-5 The Pas, Manitoba Salaries 4055 Civil service positions 3045 Opening remarks Employment decline 2690-1 Response 4042-6 Employment opportunities24, 2876 Oral questions Petitions ACCESS programs Abinochi Preschool Program Funding-Federal 686 1965; ruled in order 2245 Governmentcomm itment 687 Aboriginal Justice System Aboriginal Justice Inquiry 917; ruled in order 1108 Report recommendations 20, 224-5 1155; ruled in order 1248 Aboriginal justice system 1248; ruled in order 1317 Governmentposition 553 1316; ruled in order 1965 Budget 2296; ruled in order 2588 Impact 41 60; ruled in order 41 99 The Pas, Manitoba 752 4198; ruled in order 4426 Child abuse allegations 4426; ruled in order 4498 Justice Department investigation 554 The Pas Health Complex Clearwater Lake, Manitoba 396; ruled in order 462 Government nursery closure 23, 923, 3983 Private Members'Business ERDA agreements Address for Papers Status report686 Public Health Amendment Act Free Trade Agreement Legal opinion 4188-9 Lumber tariff 1113 Resolutions Grand Rapids, Manitoba Canadian National Rail jobs 1827-8 Environmental monitoring 41 67 Resolutions Grand Rapids Generating Station Domestic violence-free zone, Manitoba 1 093-7 Environmental concerns 3318-9 The Pas Health Complex Incorporation Amendment Oil spill 1161 Act (Bill 52) Stability 41 67 1 r 514; 2r 1962; RISLa thlin 4487 Turbine inspections 1161 Urgent Public Importance,Matter of Highways and Transportation, Department of Economic crisis 445-6 District 1 0 headquarters 2876 Interpretation Act LAURENDEAU,Marcel (St. Norbert, PC) Amendments 21 Budget debate Judicial system 141 0-4, 1425-6

109 Hansard Index

Laurendeau, Marcel - Cont. Laurendeau, Marcel - Cont. Child and Family ServicesAmendment Act (2) P/0 by Manness respecting references to persons (Bill 66) outside the Legislature (Maloway) 3549; 2r 3835-7 Members cautioned (Laurendeau) 3549 Health Services Insurance Amendment Act (Bill 51) P/0 by Martindale respecting word "stupid" 1r 3309-12 (Ernst) 4396; Highway Traffic Amendment Act (3) (Bill 83) withdrawal requested (Laurendeau) 4396; 1r3137; 2r 41 59 withdrawn 4396 Nonpolitical statements P/0 by McCrae respecting imputation of motives Fort Richmond Centurions (Wasylycia-Leis) 1795; Manitoba high school hockey champions 1057 withdrawn 1795 Great-West Life Assurance Company P/0 by Wasy!ycja-Lejs respecting imputation of 1 OOth birthday251 5 motives (Orchard) 1784; Hohl, David ruled out of order (Laurendeau) 1784; Olympic wrestling team member 2598 Members cautioned 1784 International Assembly of French-language P/0 by Wasylycia-Lejsrespecti ng word "hypocrites" Parliamentarians (Orchard) 1785; Cheema 1785; 3175 taken under advisement (Laurendeau) 1795 Winnipeg Police Department, gratitude to 4438 withdrawal requested 2022; Oral questions withdrawn (Orchard) 2022 Manitoba Hazardous Waste Management Corp. Private Members' Business Negotiations-R.M. of Montcalm 926 Address for Papers Points ofOrder Public Health Amendment Act P/0 by Am1Qn respecting admissibility of Legal opinion 1692 amendment 1830-1 ; Resolutions taken under advisement (Laurendeau) 1831 ; Constitutional task force 41 90-1 P/0 by Laurendeau respecting relevancy of Manitoba/Russiaagreement 3076-7 debate 369; PTH 101 safety 1087-9 Members cautioned (Dacquay)369 Voters' list, permanent 2785-7 P/0 by Laurendeau respecting words "Premier Public Utilities and Natural Resources, Moonbeam" (Maloway) 884; Standing Committee on withdrawn 884 5th Report 41 61 P/0 by Laurendeau respecting relevancy of Throne speech debate debate 1 027; 207-12 Members cautioned (Dacquay) 1027 Workers Compensation Amendment Act (2) (Bill 55) P/0 by Laurendeau respecting word "fabrication" 2r 2345-6 (Wasylycia-Leis) 2029; withdrawn 2029 LawAmendments, Standing Committee on P/0 by Laurendeau respecting words "false 1st Report information" (Ashton) 3017; Dacquay 1042-4 ruling challenged 301 8; 2nd Report sustained 3034 Dacquay 3405-6 P/0 by Laurendeau respecting relevancy of 3rd Report debate (Edwards) 3062; Lamoureux 3062; Reimer 4273 Martindale 3062; 4th Report ruled out of order (Dacquay) 3062 Dacquay 5107-8 P/0 by Laurendeau respecting dress code 3540; 5th Report ruled out oforder 3540 Penner 5258-60

110 Hansard Index

LswAmendments - Cont. Legal Aid Services - Cont. 6th Report Funding Reimer 5322-5 Chomiak 1232; McCrae 1232 7th Report Labour dispute Penner 5391 -3 Chomiak 1495-6; McCrae 1495-6 Minister's intention Law Enforcement Review Agency Edwards 1711 ; McCrae 1711-2 Annua1 Report, 1990 (S.P. 84) Private bar McCrae 2102 Edwards 1712, 1714; McCrae 1712, 1714 Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 124) McCrae 4274 Legislative Assembly (Supply) Elections Manitoba Law Enforcement Review Agency Doer 5053; Lamoureux 5053-4; McCrae 5053-4 Civilian participation Chomiak 4985-6; McCrae 4985-6 Legislative Building Racism investigations See Privilege, Matters of Chomiak 2307-8; McCrae 2307-8 Ucensed Practical Nurses Law Enforcement Review Amendment Act Educational opportunities (BIII 87) Cheema 3898; Orchard 3898 1 r Manness 3145; 2r Ashton 4748; Governmentsu pport Chomiak 4748-50; Edwards 5000; McCrae 4174; Cheema 625-6, 874-5; Orchard 625-6, 875, referred to Standing Committee on Law 877-8, 2745; Wasylycia-Leis 877-8, 2745 Amendments; RIS McCrae 5393; Red River Community College 3r Chomiak 5414-6; RIA 5492 Orchard 2745; Wasylycia-Leis 2745

Law Reform Commission Undenvlew Residence Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 37) Funding decrease McCrae 513 Barrett4099 ; Gilleshammer 4099, 4169; Orchard 41 70; Wasylycia-Leis 4170 Law Reform (Miscellaneous Amendments) Act (Bill 72) Unnet Graphics (International) 1 r McCrae 1717; 2r Barrett 3340-5; See Ministerial statements Chomiak 3156-61 , 3333-5; Edwards 2276-7; McCrae 2086-7; Santos 3335-40; referred to Uquor Control Act Standing Committee on Law Amendments; Confiscated liquor R!SMcCrae 5219; 3r 5232; RIA5492 McCrae 798-9; Storie 798-9

Law Society Amendment Act (Bill 74) Uquor Control Amendment Act (Bill 77) 1 r McCrae 2075; 2r Ashton 4184; 1 r Hickes 21 02; 2r Hickes 2569-70, 3638; Chomiak 4184-5; Edwards 2863-4; Storie 2731-3 McCrae 2468-9; Storie 2857-62; referred to Standing Committee on Law Liquor Control Amendment Act (2) (Bill 91) Amendments; RIS McCrae 5220; RIA 5492 1 r Mcintosh 331 5; 2r Ashton 3855-8; Carstairs 3859-61 ; Hickes 3858-9; LegalAid Services Society of Manitoba Mcintosh 3854-5; referred to Standing Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 36) Committee on Law Amendments; McCrae 513 RIS Manness5220; 3r Hickes 5234-5; RIA 5492

111 Hansard Index

Loan Act, 1992 (Bill 1 02) Maloway, Jim - Cont. 1 r Manness 5476; 2r 5476; C/W 5477; Consumer Protection Amendment Act (2) (Bill 57) RIS Manness 5477; 3r 5477; RIA 5493 1r792 Consumer Protection Amendment Act (4) (Bill 61 ) Lodge Operators and Outfitters Licensing 2r 3538-44 and ConsequentialAmendm ents Act Economic Innovation and Technology Council Act (Bill 22) (Bill 9) 1r Enns 171; 2r Ashton 771-6; Barrett 997-1002; 2r 881 -7 Edwards 852-4; Enns 639-40; C. Evans 3147-52; Franchises Act (Bill 18) Hickes 768-71 ; 1 r 870; 2r 1 003-6 Interim Appropriation Act, 1992 (Bill 67) Long Plain Indian Reserve 2r 1624-8 Tree-growing contract Labour Relations Amendment Act (Bill 85) Connery 1114; Enns 1114-5 2r 5146-8 Manitoba Hydro Act (Bill 1 0) Lyme disease 2r 30 67-72 Status report (T.P. 66) Oral questions Orchard 2664 Business PracticesAct Restitution 626, 692 MacLeod Stedman Consumer Protection Amendment Act Employment opportunities Government support626 Doer 16; Filmon 16 Furnace inspections Funding justification Carbon monoxide levels 251 1-2 Stefanson 54; Storie 54 Condemning authority 21 09-1 0, 2254 Head office location Faulty heat exchangers 2512 Doer 17; Filmon 17 Mandatory 2254 Secured creditors Gas utilities Stefanson 54-5; Storie 53 Monthly fixed charge 227-8 Gimli Motorsport Park MALOWAY, Jim (Elmwood, NDP) Lease renewal, Minister's role in 51 72 Business Practices Amendment Act (Bill 27) Labour, Minister of 2r 4153-5 Meeting request 2255 Business PracticesAmendment Act (2) (Bill 62) Odometertampering 2r 3544-50 Consumer warning 626, 691 -2, 755-6 City of Winnipeg Amendment Act (2) (Bill 35) Minister's opinion 3042 3r 368-70 RCMP report3042 City of Winnipeg Amendment, Municipal Public utilities Amendment and Consequential Amendments Customer refunds 2994 Act (Bill 45) Lock-off statistics 2993 2r 1989-95 Points of Order Consumer and Corporate Affairs, Department of P/0 by .ErmUrespecting words "has no guts" (Supply) (Maloway) 1628; Administration and Finance Member cautioned (Dacquay) 1628 Research and Planning 4443-7 P/0 by Laurendeau respecting words "Premier Opening remarks Moonbeam" (Maloway) 884; Response 4441 -2 withdrawn 884 Consumer Protection Amendment Act (Bill 54) P/0 by Manness respecting references to persons 1r 1223; 2r 1647-9 outside the Legislature (Maloway) 3549;

112 Hansard Index

Maloway, Jim - Cont. Manitoba Association for Childbirth and Members cautioned (laurendeau) 3549 Family Education Private Members'Business Funding elimination Address for Papers Orchard 2577; Wasylycia-leis 2576-7 Public Health Amendment Act legal opinion 4923-4 Manitoba Blue Cross Social Allowances Amendment and Consequential Tax increase Amendments Act (Bill 70) Manness 4170, 4208; Santos 41 70, 4208 2r491 8-20 Manitoba Centennial Centre Corporation Special Operating Agencies Financing Authority Act (Bill 96) Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 9) 2r 5009 Mitchelson 169 Statute law Amendment (Taxation) Act, 1992 Manitoba Centrefor Health Polley and (Bi11 94) Evaluation 2r 5002 Health care studies (T.P. 11) Tax Appeals Commission Act (Bi11 95) Orchard 463 2r 5004-5 Hospital funding report (T.P. 83) Manitoba Advisory Council on the Status Orchard 3084 of Women Maternal Demographic Risk Factors and the Incidence of low Birth weight, Manitoba Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 10) (T.P. 119) Mitchelson 169 Orchard 3844 Supplementary information See also Ministerial statements 1992-93 Estimates (T.P. 164) Mitchelson 4273 Manitoba Civil ServiceCommission Employee Benefits Manitoba Advisory Council on the Status of Women Amendment Act (Bill 5) Supplementary information 1992-93 Estimates 1r Mitchelson 170; 2r Ashton 560-7; Praznik 4199 Barrett 576-82; Carstairs525; Edwards 582; Lamoureux 650-4, 662-3; Manitoba Civil ServiceSuperannuation Mcintosh 663-7; Mitchelson 523-5, 667; Board Reimer 567-70; Wasylycia-leis 570-6; referred Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 107) to Standing Committeeon law Amendments; Praznik 331 5 RIS Manness3961 ; 3r Barrett531 9-21; RIA 5491 Manitoba Crop Insurance Corporation Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 121) Manitoba Agricultural Credit Corporation Findlay 4200 Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 96) Correspondence(T.P. 1 14) Findlay 2790 Findlay 3731 Interest rates Review Findlay 1262 ; Plohman 1262 Johnson 5 See also Agriculture, Departmentof (Supply) Manitoba ArtsCouncil Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 57) Manitoba Data Services Mitchelson 819 See Pro vincial Auditor's Report

113 Hansard Index

Manitoba Developmental Centre Manitoba Health Research Council

See Fam ily Services, Department of (Supply) • Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 92) Rehabilita tion and Community Living; Nonpolitical Orchard 2685 statements Manitoba Heritage Federation Manitoba Economic Innovation and Technology Council Correspondence request Friesen 4990; Mitchelson 4990 Creation Funding decisions Johnson 3 Lamoureux 1418; Mitchelson 1418 Granting authority Manitoba Evidence Amendment Act Friesen 3584; Lamoureux 1372, 2575-6; (BIII 38) Mitchelson 1372 , 2576, 3584 1 r McCrae 262; 2r Chomiak 743-5; Information tabling request Edwards 800-1 ; McCrae 498-9; referred to Friesen 3584; Mitchelson 3584 Standing Committee on Law Amendments; Meeting cancellations R/S Manness 3962; 3r 5221 ; RIA 5491 Friesen 2580; Mitchelson 2580 Meeting requests Manitoba Exploration Incentive Program Friesen 2355; Mitchelson 2355 See En ergy andMi nes, Department of (Supply) Minister's support Lamoureux 4281 ; Mitchelson 4281 Manitoba Farm Mediation Board Peer review Friesen 2356; Mitchelson 2356 Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 15) Political interference Findlay 261 Friesen 2580; Mitchelson 2580 See also Agriculture, Department of (Supply) Role Lamoureux 1418; Mitchelson 141 8-9 Manitoba Film Classification Board Volunteer role See Culture, Heritage and Citizenship, Friesen 2580; Lamoureux 1372 ; Department of (Supply)-Administration Mitchelson 1372, 2580 See also Pe titions; Urgent Public Importance, Manitoba Grants AdvisoryCouncil Mattersof Review Cerilli 4601 ; Mitchelson 4601 Manitoba Housing Authority See also Multicultural legisla tion Clarification Ernst 3900; Wowchuk 3900 Manitoba Habitat Heritage Corporation Employees' status Annual Report, 1991 (S .P. 101) Ernst 2854; Plohman 2853-4 Enns 2985 Internal audit Ernst 3789-90; Martindale3789-90 Manitoba Hazardous Waste Management Layoffs Corporation Ernst 796; Martindale 796 Annual Report, 1991 (S.P. 100) Parkland district Cummings 2846 Ernst 797-8; Wowchuk 797-8 Negotiations-A.M. of Montcalm Selkirk office Cummings 926;Laurendeau 926 Dewar 1423; Ernst 1423 PCB storage site Seniors' services Cummings 2081 -2 ; Edwards2081 -2 Ernst 3896-7;Wowc huk 3896

114 Hansard Index

Msn/tobs Housing Authority - Cont. Manitoba Labour Board Service contracting Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 74) Ernst796; Martindale 796 Praznik 1490 Staffing Ernst 3896;Wow chuk 3896 Manitoba Labour Management Review Staffing-Dauphin, Manitoba Committee Ducharme 3144;Filmon 3145; Plohman 3144-5 Annua1 Reports, 1988, 1989 (S.P. 62) Praznik 1013 Manitoba Housing and Renewal Corporation Manitoba Law Reform Commission Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 81) See Justice, Department of (Supply)--Justice Ernst 1771 See also Housing, Department of (Supply)-Transfer payments Manitoba Legislative Assembly Cross-culturaltraining Manitoba Hydro Lamoureux 1611-2; Mitchelson 1611-2 Conawapa pamphlet (T.P. 153) Edwards 41 00 Manitoba Liquor Control Commission See also Ministerial statements Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 110) Manitoba Hydro Amendment Act (BIII 1 0) Mcintosh 3785 Quarterly Reports, 1991 (S.P. 26, 27) 1 r Neufeld (Downey) 170; 2r Alcock 992-4; Manness 352 Ashton 674-82; Carstairs 3550-6; Quarterly Report, Nine Months, 1991 (S.P. 71) Downey 482-3,3560-2; Edwards 3061-7; Manness 1464 Hickes 667-74; Maloway 3067-72; Resignation request-Chairperson Martindale 935-9; Storie 928-35; Mcintosh 176; Storie 176 Sveinson 3345-7; referred to Standing Sales techniques Committee on Public Utilities and Natural Mcintosh 2354-5; Storie 2354 Resources; RIS Downey 5218; 3r Storie 5222-5; Senior s�ary levels RIA5491 Ashton 474; Mcintosh 175-6, 474; Storie 175-6 Manitoba Hydro-Electric Board Annu� Report, 1991 (S.P. 103) Manitoba Lotteries Foundation Downey 3084 Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 7) Quarterly Report, 1991 (S.P. 42) Mitchelson 169 Manness 551 Casino plans Lamoureux 3957; Mitchelson 3957 Manitoba Intercultural Council Crystal Casino Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 111) Expansion Mitchelson 3844 Lamoureux 3957; Mitchelson 3957 Antiracism recommendations Hiring process Downey 2994; Lamoureux 2994 Lamoureux 3986-7;Mitchelson 3986-7; Government's intention Praznik 3987 Lamoureux 4504-5; Mitchelson 4505 Quarterly Reports, 1991 (S.P. 28, 29) Review Manness 352 Cerilli 4577; Mitchelson 4577-8 Quarterly Report, 1991 (S.P. 52) See also Multicultural legislation Manness 750

115 Hansard Index

Manitoba Mineral Resources Ltd. Manitoba-Russia agreement Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 85) See Private Members ' Business-Resolutions Downey 2350 Manitoba School for the Deaf Manitoba Multiculturalism Act (Bill 98) See Education and Training, Department of 1 r Mitchelson 4298; 2r Carstairs 4514-21 ; (Supply)-Program Development and Support Services Cerilll 5164-5; Lamoureux 4521-32, 4779-80, 5163-4; Mitchelson 4510-14; referred Manitoba Securities Commission to Standing Committee on Municipal Affairs; See Consumer and Corporate Affa irs, RIS Cerilli 5397-8; Cheema 5398-9; Department of (Supply)-Corporate Affairs Lamoureux 5398; Mitchelson 5397, 5399-5400; 3r Cerilli 5429-31 ; Lamoureux 5431 -4, 5448-50 ; Manitoba Tax Assistance Office Santos 5434, 5446-7; RIA 5492 Closure Barrett620-1 ; Doer 620; Manness 620-1 Manitoba Pollee Commission Funding restoration Annual Report, 1991 (S.P. 38) Ducharme 1711 ; Santos 1711 McCrae 513 Manitoba Telephone Amendment Act Manitoba Pork est. (6111 41) Annual Report, 1991 (T.P. 160) 1r Cerilli 353 Findlay 4200 Manitoba Telephone System Manitoba Potash Project 1st Quarterly Report, 1992 (S.P. 112) See En ergy andMi nes, Department of (Supply) Manness 3951 2nd Quarterly Report, 1991 (S.P. 2) Manitoba, Province of Manness 12 Quarterly Financial Report, 1991 (S.P. 60) 3rd Quarterly Report, 1991 (S.P. 3) Manness 91 9 Manness 12 Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 97) Manitoba Public Insurance Corporation Findlay 2790 1st Quarterly Report, 1992 (S.P. 69) Billing contract Manness 1250 Dewar 1018; Findlay 1018 2nd Quarterly Report, 1992 (S.P. 113) Call Management System Manness 3951 Barrett270; Findlay 270 3rd Quarterly Report, 1991 (S.P. 47) Directory contract Manness 61 8 Dewar 1613; Findlay 1613 4th Quarterly Report, 1991 (S.P. 18) Long-distance competition Manness 286 Dewar 1612; Findlay 1612-3 Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 59) Rate structure Cummings 91 9 Dewar 1 01 8; Findlay 1 018-9 Impaired driving Staff layoffs-Portage Ia Prairie Third-partybenefits Dewar 1158; Findlay 1158 Cummings 3792-3; Edwards 3792-3 Telecommunications bill-Federal Government position Manitoba Research Council Dewar 1158; Findlay 1159 Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 89) Telephone director contract Stefanson 2589 Dewar 1019; Findlay 1019

116 Hansard Index

Manitoba-u.s. snowmobile trail Msnness, Hon. Clayton - Cont. See Nonpolitical statements RIS 2469 Community Support Programs (Supply) Manitoba-u.s. trade deficit Lotteries Funded Programs 5059 Governmentstrat egy Crown Corporations Council Doer 1 049; Filmon 1049-50 Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 119) 41 62 Education and Training, Departmentof (Supply) Manitoba Water Services Board Post-Secondary, Adult and Continuing Education Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 88) and Training Derkach 2515 Program Analysis, Co-ordinationand Support 3459-61 3496-8 ' Manitoba Women's Directorate Emergency Expenditures (Supply) Annual Report, 1991 (S.P. 79) 5059 Mitchelson 1754 Family Maintenance Amendment Act (Bill 89) Assistant Deputy Minister 1 r 3265; Competition Finance, Department of Lamoureux 1972 ; Mitchelson 1972 Annua1 Report, 1991 (S. P. 35) 466 Correspondence (T.P. 21) Revenue Estimates, 1992-93 (T.P. 193) 5108 Lamoureux 925 Special audit-Taxation Division (T.P. 1) 122 Hiring process Finance, Departmentof (Supply) Lamoureux 924-5, 1 053-4, 1918; 5195-5210 Mitchelson 924-5, 1 054, 1918 Administration and Finance See also Grievance, Ma tters of Minister'ssalary 5211-3 Opening remarks51 91-3 MANNESS, Hon. Clayton (Morris, PC) Financial Administration Act (Minister of Finance) Return under Section 56(3) (S.P. 20) 286 (Minister responslbfe for the administration of Garnishment Amendment Act (Bill 8) The Crown Corporation Accountability Act) RIS 3961 Address for Papers Health Care Directives and Consequential Public Health Amendment Act Amendments Act (Bill 73) Legal opinion RIS5308 Wasylycia-Leis 732; not accepted 732; Health Services Insurance Amendment and transferredto Private Members' Business Consequential AmendmentsAct (Bill 75) Adjournment motion RIS 5308 5493 Health, Departmentof (Supply) Allowance for Lossesand Expenditures Incurred Administration and Finance by Crown Corporations and other Provincial Minister's salary 3280-5 Entities (Supply) Health Services Insurance Amendment Act (Bill 51) 5056-8 2r 2340-2 Appropriation Act, 1992 (Bill 1 03) Homesteads, Marital PropertyAmendment and 1 r 5476; RIS 5477 Consequential Amendments Act (Bill 88) Budget address 1r 3265; 1166-73 House Business Budget debate Manitoba Hydro Amendment Act (Bill 1 0) 1439-45 Sponsorship transfer 479 City of Winnipeg Amendment, Municipal Municipal Assessment Amendment Act (Bill 20) Amendment and Consequential Amendments Sponsorship transfer 479 Act (Bill 45) Interim Appropriation Act, 1992 (Bill 67)

117 Hansard Index

Manness, Hon. Clayton - Cont. Manness, Hon. Clayton - Cont. C/W 171 8-22, 1734-40, 1766-7; R!S 1768 Municipal Assessment Amendment Act (Bill 20) Internal Reform, Workforce Adjustment and RIS 5394 General Salary Increases (Supply) Oral questions 5061 Agricultural industry Law Enforcement Review Amendment Act (Bill 87) Net farm income 3894 1r3145; Budget Liquor Control Amendment Act (2) (Bill 91 ) Construction industry 1326 RIS 5220 Crop insurance 924 Manitoba Advisory Council on the Status of Women Economic growth 921 Amendment Act (Bill 5) Education, post-secondary 1109 RIS 3961 Education/training 920 Manitoba Evidence Amendment Act (Bill 38) Employment creation strategy RIS 3962 402, 920, 92 1-2, 1325-6 Manitoba Hydro-Electric Board Employment retraining programs 406 Quarterly Report, 1991 (S.P. 42) 551 Fiscal Stabilization Fund 1178 Manitoba Liquor Control Commission Impact Quarterly Reports, 1991 (S.P. 26, 27) 352 The Pas, Manitoba 752 Quarterly Report, Nine Months, 1991 (S.P. 71 ) Revenue sources 921 1464 Unemployment rate forecast 920 Manitoba Lotteries Foundation Budget-Federal Quarterly Report, 1991 (S.P. 28, 29) 352 Finance Minister's position 726-7 Quarterly Report, 1991 (S.P. 52) 750 CareerStartprogram Manitoba, Province of Funding 973, 2107 Quarterly Financial Report, 1991 (S.P. 60) 91 9 Child Guidance Clinic Manitoba Public Insurance Corporation Governmentposition 3897-8 1st Quarterly Report, 1992 (S.P. 69) 1250 Civil service 2nd Quarterly Report, 1992 (S.P. 113) 3951 Staff layoffs 1115-6 3rd Quarterly Report, 1991 (S.P. 47) 61 8 Clean Environment Commission 4th Quarterly Report, 1991 (S.P. 18) 286 Provincial park land usage 970-1 Manitoba Telephone System Community-based health care system 1st Quarterly Report, 1992 (S.P. 112) 3951 Tax relief program 4431 2nd Quarterly Report, 1991 (S.P. 2) 12 Community colleges 3rd Quarterly Report, 1991 (S.P. 3) 12 Applied Sciencescourses 1110 Messages Enrolment 406 Bill 86 (S.P. 1 05) 31 37 Conawapa dam project Bill 88 (S.P. 1 06) 3265 Public Utilities Board Bill 94 (S.P. 116) 4095 Referral 872 Bill 95 (S.P. 115) 3981 Economic growth Bill 96 (S.P. 120) 41 62 Building permits 2795-6 Capital Expenditures Consumer confidence 3898-9 Revised estimates (S.P. 131) 5271 Employment creation strategy Capital Supply (S.P. 64) 1173 56, 131,174, 400-1 ,1228 Main Supply (S.P. 65) 1173 Employment statistics 3788-9 Ministerial statements Forecast justification 1178-9 Linnet Graphics (International) agreement Government policy 1757 Computer mapping system 510-1 Governmentpolicy performance2690, 5406 Manitoba Hydro Savings Bonds 2571 -2, 4427 Government strategy 1229, 1966-8,3787-8

118 Hansard Index

Manness, Hon. Clayton - Cont. Manness, Hon. Clayton - Cont. Housing starts 2747 Fiscal Stabilization Fund 288-9 Interprovincial migration 1757 Manitoba Data Services288 Municipal public works program 3787 Provincial deficit Manufacturing industry 3899-900 Clarification 687 National average statistics 1175-6 Increase 687, 922 Population statistics 5406-7 Provincial revenues Provincial comparisons 57, 331 8 Additional sources 622 Retail trade sector 2594-5 Clarification 625 Education and Training, Departmentof Repap Manitoba Inc. Underspending 922 Aboriginal land claims 751 Education, post-secondary Benefits to Manitoba 753 Funding 1182 Cuttingarea 751 , 825 Employment creation strategy Employment creation strategy Northern programs 1328 752, 754-5, 757, 1017-8 Employment retraining programs Employment protection 752 Funding 622 Expenditures 756 Federal Trade Tribunal Financial status 1017 Manitoba cabinetmakers 41 02 Renegotiations 750, 753-4, 3045 Free Trade Agreement Swan River area 2580-1 Abrogation 3644 Treaty land entitlements 1113 Employment creation statistics 3644, 3646-7 Woodlands division Government support3583 Job security 1328 Impact industrial production 3583-4 Retail sales tax Labour adjustment strategy 3647-8 Statistics 3789 Softwood lumber duty 1178 Retail trade sector Goods and services tax Employment statistics 131 Harmonization 131, 399-400, 402-3 Sales decline 1497-8 Impact manufacturing industry 400 Statistics discrepancy 5265-6 Government - Federal Social assistance Untendered contracts 2302 Abuse rate 174 Gross Revenue Insurance Plan Employment creation strategy 21 07-8 Coverage levels-Riskarea 12 2471-2 Student Temporary Employment Program Judicial system Funding restoration 974 Charging directives 3532 The Pas, Manitoba Manitoba Blue Cross Civil service positions3045-6 Tax increase 4170, 4208 Wang Canada Manitoba Tax Assistance Office Government involvement 3649 Closure 620-1 Untendered contract 3650 NorthAmerican Free Trade Agreement Orders for Return Justification 3645 Vision Fund (No. 2) Northern Youth Corps Job Program Alcock 478; accepted 478 Funding restoration 973-4 Personal Property Security Amendment Act Pedlar Commission (Bill 48) Recommendations 3532 RIS 3962 Poverty rate Points ofOrder Manitoba statistics331 7-8 P/0 by � respecting words "I am going to Provincial Auditor's Report recommend rabies shots" (Orchard) 1775;

119 Hansard Index

Manness, Hon. Clayton - Cont. Manness, Hon. Clayton - Cont. Manness 1775; ruled out of order 1775; Private Members' Business Members cautioned 1775 Resolutions P/0 by MfllQn respecting closing debate 2346-7; Bail review provisions, changes to 3948-9 Lamoureux 2348; Manness 2347; Reid 2347-8; Government contracts, issuing of 3839-40 taken under advisement 2348; Postal rate increase, rural newspapers 660-1 Speaker's ruling 4495-6 Privilege, Matter of P/0 by � respecting imputation of motives Quorum counts 4566 (Filmon) 3038; Manness 3039; Provincial Auditor taken under advisement 3039; Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 22) 286 ruled out of order 4436; Special Audit Members cautioned 4436 Taxation Division-Departmentof Finance 122 P/0 by Carstajrs respecting words wcompletely Provincial Auditor's Amendment Act (Bill 92) honestw (Manness) 754; 1 r 3891 ; 2r 41 71-2; RIS 5308 Members' cautioned (Dacquay) 754 Provincial Police Amendment and Consequential P/0 by Manness respecting supplementary Amendments Act (Bill 86) questions 125; Carstairs 125; Martindale 125; 1r3145; Members cautioned 125 Public Accounts P/0 by Manness respecting supplementary Fiscal year ending March 31 , 1991 (S.P. 19, 34) questions 405; 286, 466 Members cautioned 405 Public Officers Act P/0 by Manness respecting words wmaster of Return under Section 20 (S.P. 21 ) 286 obfuscationw (Wasylycia-Leis) 877; Public Trustee Amendment, Trustee Amendment withdrawn 877 and Child and Family ServicesAmendment Act P/0 by Manness respecting withdrawal being (Bill 68) conditional (Storie) 1225; Doer 1225; RIS 3962 ruled out oforder 1225 Real PropertyAmendment Act (Bill 7) P/0 by Manness respecting imputation of motives RIS 3961 (Cheema) 1260; Ashton 1260-1 ; Retirement Plan Beneficiaries Act (Bill 71 ) Lamoureux 1260; 2r 3145-6; RIS 5307-8 ruled out of order 1261 Special Operating Agencies Financing P/0 by Manness respecting preambles to Oral Authority Act (Bill 96) Questions (Cerilli) 2463; 1 r 4162; 2r 4743-4;C/W 5256; RIS 5395 Members cautioned2463 Statute Law Amendment (Taxation) Act, 1992 P/0 by Manness respecting more than one person (Bill 94) from a partyspeaking on Matter of Urgent 1 r 4095; 2r 4508-9; C/W 5236-54; RIS 5308 Public Importance 2585; Supply, Capital taken under advisement 2585; Supply, Committee of 5272 Speaker's ruling 2882 SurveysAmendment Act (Bill 34) P/0 by Manness respecting previously asked RIS 5394 questions 2992; Alcock2992 ; Ashton 2992; Tax Appeals Commission Act (Bill 95) ruled out of order 2992 1 r 3981 ; 2r 4509-10;C/W 5255-6; P/0 by Manness respecting question anticipating RIS 5309 debate (Carstairs) 3043; Ashton 3043-4; Urgent Public Importance, Matters of question rephrased 3044 Domestic violence 28-9 P/0 by Manness respecting references to persons Economic crisis 412-3, 438-9 outside the Legislature (Maloway) 3549; Economic crisis 2883-4 Members cautioned (Laurendeau) 3549 Goods and servicestax

120 Hansard Index

Manness, Hon. Clayton - Cont. Martindale, Doug - Cont. Harmonization 409 Response 4368-9 Manitoba Heritage Federation Program Development and Support Granting authority 2583 Client Services4394-8 Rural Deve lopment, Minister of Grants and Subsidies 4398 School board interference4553-4 ProjectManagement 4393-4 Research and Planning 4383-5, 4387-92 Manufacturing Industry Transfer Paymentsto Manitoba Housing and Employment creation strategy Renewal Corporation Filmon 1322; Storie 1322 4402-3 Employment statistics Interim Appropriation Act, 1992 (Bill 67) L. Evans 406-7; Filmon 2078; C/W 1685-9 Stefanson 406-7; Storie 2078 Labour Relations Amendment Act (Bill 85) Shipment statistics 2r 4751-4 Doer 2193; L. Evans 3958-9; Manitoba Hydro Amendment Act (Bill 1 0) Filmon 2194; Stefanson 3958-9 2r 935-9 Nonpolitical statements MARTINDALE, Doug (Burrows, NDP) Festival of Vaisakh 21 11-2 Budget debate Hanukkah 27 1433-9 Sisters Servants of Mary Immaculate City of Winnipeg Amendment, Municipal 1 00 years of service 4309 Amendment and Consequential Amendments Tartan Day 1781 Act (Bill 45) Oral questions 2r 1027-33 Bill 70 Consumer and Corporate Affairs, Department of Amendments 2799, 3674 (Supply) Justification 41 03 Administration and Finance Constitutional issues Minister's salary 4622 Housing responsibility 1375 Consumer Affairs Consumer protection legislation Consumer's Bureau 4459-62 Governmentsupport 977 Corporate Affairs Dutch elm disease program Manitoba Securities Commission 4621 Funding restoration 2080 Economic Innovation andTech nology Council Act Employment creation programs (Bill 9) Hiring priority 2851 2r 705-1 3 Food banks Grievance, Matterof Increased use 263 Poverty level Housing, co-operative Martindale 3382-8 Federal program 1374, 2581 , 2597-8 Health Care Directives and Consequential Housing, Minister of AmendmentsAct (Bill 73) Apology request 4881-2 3r 531 6-7 Housing, nonprofit Health Services Insurance Amendment Act (Bill 51) Government strategy 126 2r 4267-9 Housing, public-Pembina Highway Housing, Departmentof (Supply) Playground structure 4882 Administration and Finance Human Resources OpportunityCentre Executive Support 4370-2 Funding restoration 2080 Finance and Operations 4375-8, 4379-80 Inner-city recreation programs Opening remarks Governmentsu pport 2851

121 Hansard Index

Martindale, Doug - Cont. Martindale, Doug - Cont. Manitoba Housing Authority 1 1 08; ruled in order 1156 Internal audit 3789-90 2074; ruled in order 21 02 Layoffs 796 Rotary Pines Project Service contrac ting 796 Funding withdrawal North American Free Trade agreement 12; ruled in order 48 Withdrawal 4306 48; withdrawn 122 Poverty rate Points of Order Prevention program co-ordination 3369 P/0 by Laurendeau respecting relevancy of Recreation centre-Fife Street debate (Edwards) 3062; Lamoureux 3062; Roof repairs 2597 Martindale 3062; Rent Regulation Bureau ruled out of order (Dacquay) 3062 Director'sstatus 2879 P/0 by Manness respecting supplementary Rent regulations questions 125; Carstairs 125; Martindale 125; Rollbacks 827, 875-6, 976-7 Members cautioned 125 Residential Tenancies Amendment Act P/0 by Martindale respecting word "stupid" Proclamation 472, 2879 (Ernst) 4396; Rotary Pines Project withdrawal requested (Laurendeau) 4396; Funding reallocation 126 withdrawn 4396 SAFER program Private Members' Business Eligibility statistics 4578 Address for Papers Public awareness 4578, 4881 Public Health Amendment Act SARC report Legal opinion 963-4, 1690-1 Recommendations 3675 Resolutions Seniors RentaiStart Inner city housing upgrade 4257-60,4262-3 Applications 1 26 Voters' list, permanent 2783-5 Social assistance Privilege, Mattersof Benefit cap 1256 Quorum counts 4566 CRISP benefits 1256 Residential Tenancies Amendment Act (Bill 65) Common law regulation 1776 1r2193; Discrimination 1776 Residential Tenancies Amendment Act (2) (Bill 84) Employment creation strategy 2r 4581 -5 1255, 2079, 3370 Resolutions Food allowance 41 02 Riel, Louis Off-reserve Status Indians 2798 Role in development of Manitoba 3667-8 Rate increase 264 Social Allowances Amendment and Consequential Rent appeal intervention4989 Amendments Act (Bill 70) Social assistance-students 2r 3865-8; 3r5451 � Common law regulation 1710 Throne speech debate Increase 171 0 101-8 Summer Challenge program University of Manitoba Amendment Act (Bill 25) Elimination 2851 2r 3635-7 Winnipeg International Airport Urban Affairs, Department of (Supply) Protection 201 9 Expenditures Related to Capital Petitions Riverbank Development 4356 Criminal Code amendments 1909; ruled in order 2012 Matas, David Fight Back Against Child Abuse campaign See Nonpolitical statements

122 Hansard Index

Matter of Grievance McCrae, Hon. James C. - Cont. See Grievence, Matters of Aboriginal Justice Initiatives (Supply) 5178-90 Matterof Privilege Canada/Manitoba Enabling Vote (Supply) See Privilege, Matters of 5055-6 Condolence, Motions of Matters of Urgent Public Importance Hillhouse, Thomas Paterson 61 0 See Urgent Public Importance, Matters of Family Maintenance Amendment Act (Bill 89) 2r 4283-4; RIS 5220 McALPINE, Gerry (Sturgeon Creek, PC) Fatality Inquiries Act Budget debate Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 75) 1654 1263-70 Garnishment Amendment Act (Bill 8) Nonpolitical statements 1r170; 2r 482 Dupuis, Patrice Health Care Directives and Consequential Youth Science Foundation award recipient Amendments Act (Bill 73) 3279 1 r 2075; 2854-5 Manitoba student achievements 4170-1 Homesteads, Marital Property Amendment and Silver Heights Collegiate Consequential Amendments Act (Bill 88) Reach for the Top team 2800 2r 4282-3; RIS 5220 Sturgeon Creek High School Human Rights Commission Provincial handball champions 3175, 4889 Annua1 Report, 1990 (S.P. 39) 513 Tartan Day 1717-8, 1780-1 Jury Amendment Act (Bill 46) Vimy Ridge anniversary 2065 1 r 596; 2r 646 Petitions Justice, Department of Salvation Army Grace General Hospital Policy, Planning and Special Projects branch 122; ruled in order 168 Major projects (T.P. 154) 4130 Private Members'Business Supplementary information Address for Papers 1992-93 Estimates (T.P. 152) 4095 Public Health Amendment Act Justice, Department of (Supply) Legal opinion 1700, 2002-3 Administration and Finance Resolutions Human Resource Services 41 32 Environmental Youth Corps 4363-5 Minister's salary 4250-60 Seniors' rights 2153-6 Policy, Planning and Special Projects 4130-2 Salvation Army Grace General Hospital Public Inquiry into the Administration of Incorporation Amendment Act (Bill 39) Justiceand Aboriginal People 1r220; 2r 1641; RIS 3831 ; 3r 3832 4133 Throne speech debate Corrections 247-53 Administration 4240 Urgent Public Importance, Matters of Adult Corrections 4240-3 Economic crisis 456-8 Courts CourtServices 4243-6 McColm, Ken Regional Services 4247 See Nonpolitical statements Justice Civil Legal Services 4237 McCRAE, Hon. James C. Constitutional Law 4329-40 (Brandon West, PC) Family Law 4238-9 (Minister of Justiceand AttorneyGeneral) (Keeperof the GreatSeal) Manitoba Law Reform Commission 4328 (Minister responsible for Constitutional Affairs) Opening remarks 4126-9

123 Hansard Index

McCrae, Hon. James C. - Cont. McCrae, Hon. James C. - Cont. Protectionof Individual and Property Rights Aboriginal justicesystem Public Trustee Government position 553-4 Other Expenditures4248 Advertising, misleading Salaries 4247-8 Consumer protection 126 Public Prosecutions Bill 86/87 Board of Review Adjudication process 5269 Salaries 41 33-43 Consultations 5269-70 Provincial Policing 4145-8 Withdrawal 5266-7 Law Enforcement Review Agency Board of Review Annua1 Report, 1990 (S.P. 84) 21 02 Chaulk, Robert624 Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 124) 4274 Government representation 625 Law Enforcement Review Amendment Act (Bill 87) Child abuse allegations 2r 4174; RIS 5393 Justice Department investigation 554 Law Reform Commission Constitutional issues Annual Report, 1991 (S.P. 37) 513 Aboriginal representation 873 Law Reform (Miscellaneous Amendments) Act Areas of agreement 4277 (Bill 72) Bilateral negotiation�uebec 872-3 1 r 1717; 2r 2086-7; RIS 52 19 Delegation of powers 4203 Law Society Amendment Act (Bill 74) Government position 4738-9 1 r 2075; 2r 2468-9; RIS 5220 National standards4600-1 Legal Aid Services Society of Manitoba News briefing request 4278 Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 36) 513 Notwithstanding clause 41 64-6 Legislative Assembly (Supply) Referendum4203 Elections Manitoba 5053-4 Senate reform 4202 Manitoba Police Commission Courtof Queen's Bench Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 38) 513 Appeal screening court292-3 Manitoba Evidence AmendmentAct (Bill 38) Crime prevention programs 1 r 262; 2r 498-9 Funding 4168-9 Ministerial statements Dakota Ojibway Tribal Council Constitutional meeting Police force Multilateral discussions Funding 4602-3 2246-7 2842-3, 3361 -2, 3978-9, 4594-5 Domestic violence ' Constitutional process proposal 1221 Bail conditions 974 Defence Infrastructure, Advisory Group on Rehabilitation programs 974-5 Manitoba presentation 1317-8 Headingley Correctional Institute Domestic Violence Community Advisory Psychiatric care facilities 1496-7 Committee Impaired driving 14-5 Stayed charges review 2878-9 Impaired drivers, victims of 286 Indian Birch Reserve Municipal Assessment Amendment Act (Bill 20) Child Welfare worker ban 1055 24 497-8 Interpretation Act Nonpolitical statements Amendments21 International Human Rights Day 132-3 Judicial system Oral questions Aboriginal participation225 Aboriginal Justice Inquiry Report Bail reviews 2879 Courtservices, Northern 1368-9 Circuit court 1469 Recommendations 20-1 , 224-5, 552-3 Court transcription service 1656-7, 1714

124 Hansard Index

McCrae, Hon. James C. - Cont. McCrae, Hon. James C. - Cont. Gods River, Manitoba 554 Constitutional referendum for Canada 2905-8 Public defender system 1778-9 Crime Prevention Council 857-60 Two-tiered system 1780 Women, violence against 4029-32 Law Enforcement Review Agency Provincial Police Amendment and Consequential Civilian participation4985-6 Amendments Act (Bill 86) Racism investigations2307-8 2r 4173-4; RIS 5393 Legal Aid Services Society of Manitoba Public Trustee Funding 1232 Annu� Report, 1990 (S.P. 122) 4274 Labour dispute 1495-6 Annu� Report, 1991 (S.P. 123) 4274 Minister's intention 1711 Public Trustee Amendment, Trustee Amendment Private bar 1712, 1714 and Child and Family ServicesAmendment Act Liquor Control Act (Bill 68) Confiscated liquor 798-9 1 r 1654;2r 2084-6 Pedlar Commission Real Property Amendment Act (Bill 7) Recommendations 18-9, 625, 1762 1 r 170; 2r 479-81 Policing servicesagreement Regulations Act Fee-for-servicescosts Regulation Nos. 43/91 to 246191 (S.P. 1) 12 4205-6, 4278-9, 4737-8, 5174 Resolutions RCMP services Domestic violence-free zone, Manitoba 1058-68 Falcon Beach detachment 2357 Retirement Plan BeneficiariesAct (Bill 71) Restraining orders, enforcement of 1r1 654 Departmental co-ordination 2353 Statute Law Amendment Act, 1992 (Bill 1 01 ) Personal Property Security Amendment Act 1r4596; 2r 5122; RIS 5393 (Bill 48) Throne speech debate 1 r 61 8-9; 2r 828-9 327-36 PettyTrespasses Amendment Act (Bill 47) Victims Assistance Committee 1 r 596; 2r 648-9; RIS 5219 Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 118)4161 Points of Order P/0 by � respecting unparliamentary MciNTOSH, Hon. Linda (Asslnlbola, PC) language (McCrae) 333; �lnlster of Consumer and Cor orate Affairs) withdrawn 333 lnlster charged with the admc nlstratlon of P/0 by McCrae respecting introduction of e Liquor Control Act) Bills 792; Budget debate Members cautioned (Dacquay) 792 1299-1 305 P/0 by McCrae respecting imputation of motives Business Practices Amendment Act (2) (Bill 62) (Wasylycia-Leis) 1795; 1 r 1174-5; 2r 1975-6; RIS 5307 withdrawn 1795 Consumer and Corporate Affairs, Department of P/0 by McCrae respecting word "cowardly" Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 109) 3643 (Barrett) 2287; Supplementary information ruled out of order (Dacquay) 2287; 1992-93 Estimates (T.P. 157) 4199 Members cautioned 2288 Consumer and Corporate Affairs, Department of Private Members' Business (Supply) Address for Papers Administration and Finance Public Health Amendment Act Minister's salary 4622 Legal opinion 961 -3 Research and Planning 4443-8 Resolutions Consumer Affairs Aboriginal JusticeCommis sion 1556-9 Consumer's Bureau 4459-62, 4607-20

125 Hansard Index

Mcintosh, Hon. Linda - Cont. Mcintosh, Hon. Linda - Cont. Corporate Affairs Director's status 2879-80 Manitoba Securities Commission 4621 Rent regulations Regulations462 1 -2 Enforcement 1659 Opening remarks 4439-41 Legal opinion request 1659 Consumer Protection Amendment Act (4) (Bill 61 ) Rollbacks 827, 876, 977 1 r 1175; 2r 1975; RIS 5307 Residential Tenancies Amendment Act Insurance Act Proclamation 472-3, 2879 Annua1 Report, 1992 (S.P. 56) 792 Points of Order Interim Appropriation Act, 1992 (Bill 67) P/0 by Mcintosh respecting relevancy of C/W 1688-9 debate 1991 ; Liquor Control Amendment Act (2) (Bill 91 ) Members cautioned (Dacquay) 1991 1 r 3315; 2r 2854-5 Public Utilities Board Manitoba Advisory Council on the Status of Women Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 104) 31 36 Amendment Act (Bill 5) Rent Regulation Program 2r 663-7 Report on the administration, 1991 (S.P. 117) Manitoba Liquor Control Commission 4161 Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 110) 3785 Residential Tenancies Amendment Act (2) (Bi11 84) Nonpolitical statements 1 r 3672; 2r 41 75-6; RIS 5308 Assiniboine Memorial Curling Club Resolutions Junior men's curling champions 827 Riel, Louis Oral questions Role in development ofManitoba 3666-7 Advertising, misleading Trade Practices Inquiry Act Consumer protection 125 Annua1 Report, 1992 (S.P. 55) 791 Business PracticesAct Restitution 626, 692 Mcleod,Allan Chinese cooking wine See Nonpolitical statements Sale restrictions 1971 , 2082-3 Consumer ProtectionAme ndment Act Mcleod, Robert Government support627 See Nonpolitical statements Consumer protection legislation Government support977 Medicare,five principles of Gas utilities See Private Members'Busi ness-Resolutions Monthly fixed charge 227-8 Manitoba Liquor Control Commission Mental Health Amendment Act (Bill 93) Fetal alcohol syndrome warnings 3044 1 r Orchard 3844;2r Cheema 4889; Resignation request-Chairperson 176 Orchard 41 72-3; Wasylycia-Leis 4898-4901; Sales techniques 2354-5 referred to Standing Committee on Municipal Senior salary levels 175-6, 474 Affairs; R!SOrchard 5395; RIA5492 Odometertampering Consumer warning 626, 691-2, 755-6 Mental health carefacil ities RCMP report 3042 Bed closures Public utilities Filmon 4984;Orchard 3167, 4304-5; Customer refunds 2994 Wasylycia-Leis 3166-7, 4304, 4983-4 Lock-off statistics 2993 RCMP Mental health care system Confiscated liquor disposal 798 Bed closures Rent Regulation Bureau Cheema 4742; Orchard 4742, 51 12;

126 Hansard Index

Mental health care system - Cont. Messages - Cont. Wasylycia-Leis 51 12 Manness 3265 Community-based services Bi11 94 (S.P. 116) Cheema 4742; Orchard 4742 Manness 4095 Correspondence (T.P. 69) Bi11.95 (S.P. 115) Cheema 2809 Manness 3981 Reform Bill 96 (S.P. 120) Brandon, Manitoba Manness 41 62 Cheema 4307; Orchard 4307 Bi11 98 (S.P. 125) Co-ordination Mitchelson 4398 Orchard 51 11-2; Wasylycia-Leis 51 11 Bi11 100 (S.P. 126) Governmentstrategy Praznik 4569 Orchard 4200-1 ; Wasylycia-Leis 4200-1 Capital Expenditures See also Misericordia Hospital; Urban Hospital Revised Estimates (S.P. 131) Council Manness 5271 Capital Supply (S.P. 64) Messages Manness 1173 Bill 9 (S.P. 12) Main Supply (S.P. 65) Filmon 169 Manness 1173 Bill 10 (S.P. 13) Neufeld 169 Midwifery Bill 20 (S.P. 129) Governmentini tiatives Derkach 5000 Carstairs 2687-8; Orchard 2687-8 Bill 35 (S.P. 16) Ernst 261 Milk Prices Review Amendment Act (8111 44) Bill 43 (S.P. 44) 1 r Findlay 596; 2r Findlay 734-6; Findlay 596 Gaudry 2260-1 ; Hickes 2258-60; Bill 44 (S.P. 45) Plohman 953-5; referred to Standing Committee Findlay 596 on Agriculture; RIS Findlay 5219; 3r 5232; Bill 49 (S.P. 46) RIA5491 Cummings 596 Bill 53 (S.P. 48) Milk Prices Review Commission Cummings 619 Annu� Report, 1991 (S.P. 4) Bill 64 (S.P. 70) Findlay 122 Gilleshammer 1320 Bill 70 (S.P. 76) Mining communities Gilleshammer 1654 Employment retraining program Bill 75 (S.P. 83) Downey 2990; Storie2990 Orchard 2075 Equity insurance Bill 78 (S.P. 86) Downey 2990-1 ; Storie 2990 Ernst 2350 Exploration Bill 79 (S.P. 91 ) Downey 2988; Storie 2988 Driedger 2589 Governmentini tiatives Bill 82 (S.P. 102) Downey 2987-8; Storie 2987 Findlay 3036 Bi11 86 (S.P. 105) Mining Community Reserve Fund Manness 31 37 Snow Lake, Manitoba Bill 88 (S.P. 106) Filmon 2989-90; Storie 2989

127 Hansard Index

Mining operations Ministerial statements - Cont. Dust control Manitoba presentation Cummings 4991 ; Storie 4990-1 McCrae 131 7-8 Response Ministerial statements L. Evans 1318-9; Gaudry 1319 Aboriginal issues DomesticViolence Community Advisory National meeting Committee Downey 917-8 McCrae 14-5 Response Response Carstairs 91 9; Lathlin 91 8-9 Barrett 15; Edwards 15 Air ambulance service Education, multicultural Driedger 218 Policy for the 1990s (T.P. 88) Response Vodrey 3162-3 Ashton 218-9; Gaudry 219 Response Alco Rural Development Bond Corporation Chomiak 3163-4; Lamoureux 31 64 Downey 48-9 First Ministers' meeting Response Filmon 1702-4 Gaudry 49; Wowchuk 49 Response Breast Cancer Screening Carstairs 1705-6; Doer 1704-5 Reportof the Working Group Immigrant Credentials, Working Group on Orchard 965-7 Executive Summary Response Mitchelson 1251-2 Cheema 968-9; Wasylycia-Leis 967-8 Response CT Scanning Committee Report (T.P. 55) Cerilli 1252; Lamoureux 1252 Orchard 2298-2300 Impaired drivers, victimsof Response McCrae 286 Cheema 2301 ; Wasylycia-Leis 2300-1 Response Canadian Men's Curling Championship Chomiak 286-7; Edwards 287 Stefanson 1249-50 InternationalWomen's Day Response Mitchelson 1 044-6 Cheema 1250; C. Evans 1250 Response Canadian Women's Curling Championship Barrett 1 046; Carstairs 1046-7 Stefanson 1047 Linnet Graphics (International) agreement Response Computer mapping system Alcock 1048; L. Evans 1047-8 Manness 510-1 Constitutional meeting Response Multilateral discussions Carstairs 512-3; Doer 512 McCrae 2246-7, 2842-3, 3361-2, 3978-9, Manitoba Centre for Health Policy and 4594-5 Evaluation Response Orchard 463-4 Carstairs 2248-9, 2844-5, 3362-3, 4595-6; Response Doer 2247-8, 2843-4, 3979-80, 4595; Cheema 465-6; Wasylycia-Leis 465 Edwards 3980-1 ; Friesen 3362 Manitoba Hydro Savings Bonds Constitutional process proposal Manness 2571 -2, 4427 McCrae 1221 Response Response Alcock 2572, 4427-8; Doer 2572, 4427 Carstairs 1222-3; Doer 1221-2 National Forest Week Defence Infrastructure, Advisory Group on Enns 2869-70

128 Hansard Index

Ministerial statements - Cont. Ministerialsta tements - Cont. Response Western Premiers' Conference Edwards 2870-1; L. Evans 3870 Filmon 3406-7 Natural Lands and Special Places Workbook Response Enns 3843 Carstairs 3409-10; Doer 3407-9 Response World Curling championships Carstairs 3844; C. Evans 3843-4 Stefanson 1 n1 Northern Central Hydro Electrification Agreement Response Downey 1252-3 Alcock 1n1; C. Evans 1n1 Response Women, violence against Edwards 1254; Harper 1253 National day of remembrance Northern Flood Agreement (T.P. 108) Mitchelson 12-3 Downey 2871 , 3574-5 Response Response Carstairs 14; Doer 13 Ashton 2871 -2; Edwards287 2-3, 3576; Harper 3575-6 Misericordia Hospital Portof Churchill Emergency wardclosure Rail line protection Cheema 1969-70; Orchard 1969-70 Driedger 462-3 Emergency ward closure (T.P. 49) Response Cheema 1969 Edwards 463; Reid 463 Funding Post-Secondary Student Support Program Orchard 1n2-3; Wasylycia-Leis 1n2 Status Indians Mental health care Vodrey 4567-8 Cheema 3039; Orchard 3039-40 Response See also Urban Hospital Council Alcock 4569; Friesen 4568-9 Rural Economic Development Initiative Derkach 2201 -2 Missing Children's Week, National Response See Nonpolitical statements Lamoureux 2203; Wowchuk 2202-3 Seniors Month MITCHELSON, Hon. Bonnie Ducharme 5401 �(River East, PC) Response lnlster of Culture, Heritage and Citizenship) Carstairs 5402; Santos 5402 lnlster responsible for Multiculturalism) lnlster charged with the administration of Social assistance e Manitoba LotteriesFoundation Act) Off-reserve Status Indians (Minister responsible for the Status ofWomen) Gilleshammer 3670-1 Budget debate Response 1385-90 Carstairs 3671 ; L. Evans 3671 Centre Culture! Franco-Manitobain Thompson, Manitoba Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 11) Downtown revitalization Mitchelson 169 Derkach 161 3-4 Culture, Heritage and Citizenship, Department of Response . Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 78) 1753 Ashton 1614; Carstairs 1614 Community Places Programs, 1992-93 Western Governors' Association Conference (T.P. 172) Filmon 5260-1 4427 Response Supplementary information Carstairs 5262; Doer 5261-2 1992-93 Estimates (T.P. 171) 4427

129 Hansard Index

Mitchelson, Hon. Bonnie - Cont. Mitchelson, Hon. Bonnie - Cont. Culture, Heritage and Citizenship, Departmentof Ministerial statements (Supply) Immigrant Credenti�s.Working Group on Administration Executive Summary 1251-2; Executive Support4668-80 , 4684-95 International Women's Day 1 044-6 Human Resource Services 4695-8 Women, violence against Manitoba Film Classification Board 4698 National day of remembrance 12-3 Minister's salary 5050-2 Multiculturalism Secretariat Citizenship Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 80) 1754 Immigration Policy and Planning Nonpolitical statements 4816-7, 4857-64, 4926-51 Citizenship awards 1973-4 Culture, Heritage and Recreation Programs Festival of Vaisakh 21 11 Arts Branch4807-1 0 National Citizenship Week 2083-4 Executive Administration 4698-9, 4795-4802 Philippine Heritage Week 4307-8 Grants to Cultural Organizations 4803-6 Immigrant Credenti�s. Working Group on Historic Resources 481 4-5 Executive Summary 1250 Public Library Services481 1-3 Nonpolitical statements Regional Services481 5 International Day for the Elimination of Multiculturalism Racial Discrimination Multicultural Secretariat 5030-49 1474 Opening remarks 4623-8, 4664-5 International Women's Day 1022 Freedom of Information Act Oral questions Annu� Report, 1990 (S.P. 8) 169 Antiracism co-ordinator Immigrant Credentials, Working Groupon Hiring process 1612 Executive Summary (T.P. 29) 1250 Bill 70 Interim Appropriation Act, 1992 (Bill 67) Impact on women 3676 C/W 1673-9 Budget-Fader� Manitoba Advisory Council on the Status of Women Impact cultural programs 799-800 Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 10) 169 Constitutional proposal Supplementary information Cultural programs, devolution of 4506-7 1992-93 Estimates (T.P. 164) 4273 Crystal Casino Manitoba Advisory Council on the Statusof Women Expansion 3957 Amendment Act (Bill 5) Domesticviolence 1 r 170; 2r 523-5, 667 Education/prevention programs 4884 Manitoba Arts Council Governmentprograms 18 Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 5� 81 9 Farm Lands Ownership Board Manitoba Centennial Centre Corporation Reportproduction costs 228, 268 Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 9) 169 Foreign domestic workers Manitoba Intercultural Council Deportation intervention 3897 Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 111)3844 Investigations 2895-6 Manitoba Lotteries Foundation Foreign Domestic Workers' Program Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 7) 169 Government access 3534 Manitoba Multiculturalism Act (Bill 98) Governmentposition 1 022, 1160-1 1 r 4298; 2r 451 0-14; RIS 5397, 5399-5400 Minister's consultations 3534 Manitoba Women's Directorate Minister'scorrespondence 3274, 3897 Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 79) 1754 Heritage community Messages Funding reduction 4989 Bill 98 (S.P. 125) 4398 Granting process 2576

130 Hansard Index

Mitchelson, Hon. Bonnie - Cont. Mitchelson, Hon. Bonnie - Cont. Public consultations 3584 Governmentsupport 4207 Immigration policy Women's Directorate Government recommendations 4879 Assistant Deputy Minister Refugee claimants 4880 Competition 1982 Manitoba Grants Advisory Council Hiring process 924-5, 1 054, 1918 Review 4601 Women's issues Manitoba Heritage Federation Government initiatives 3676-7 Correspondence request 4990 Points of Order Funding decisions 1418 P/0 by Mitchelson respecting line of questioning Granting authority 1372, 2576, 3584 (Supply) 4681 ; Filmon 4682-3; Information tabling request 3584 Lamoureux 4681-3;Praznik 4682 ; Meeting cancellation 2580 ruled in order (Rose) 4682-3 Meeting requests 2356 Resolutions Minister's support4281 Domestic violence-free zone, Manitoba Peer review 2356 1on-8, 1 090-3 Political interference 2580 Status of Women (Supply) Role 141 8-9 Advisory Council on the Status of Women Volunteer role 1372, 2580 4414-20 Manitoba Intercultural Council Opening remarks 4404-6 Government'sintention 4505 Women's Directorate 441 0-4, 4416, 4420-4 Review 4577-8 Manitoba Legislative Assembly Moose Lake Loggers Ltd. Cross-culturaltraining 1611-2 Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 54) Manitoba Lotteries Foundation Downey 791 Casino plans 3957 Hiring process 3986 Mount Carmel Clinic Multicultural legislation Cross-culturalcounselling unit Amendments 4601 Cheema 51 15; Hickes 793-4, 1163; Consultations 4503, 51 16 Orchard 793-4, 1163, 51 15 Introduction 3093, 3897 Justification4504 Mount Manitoba Manitoba Grants Advisory Council 4603 Manitoba Intercultural Council 4603 See Nonpolitical statements Multicultural Resource Centre Closure 124 Multicultural legislation Education resources 124 Affirmative Action, impact on Multicultural Secretariat Cerilli 4429-30; Praznik 4429-30 Activities 3956 Amendments Hiring policy 128, 925 Cerilli 4601; Mitchelson 4601 Political influence 5268 Consultations Report tabling request 3957 Cerilli 4503; Cheema 51 16; Property rights proposal Mitchelson 4503-4, 51 16 Legal opinion request 800 Introduction Race relations policy Downey 2994; Lamoureux 2994, 3092-3, 3897; Education system 1494 Mitchelson 3093, 3897 Programs funding 1495 Justification The Diviners Cerilli 4504; Mitchelson 4504

131 Hansard Index

Multlcu/tursl/eg/slstlon - Cont. Mun/clpsl Assessment-Cont. Manitoba Grants Advisory Council Penner 493-6; Plohman 2768-76; Lamoureux 4603; Mitchelson 4603 Wowchuk 867-9; referred to Standing Manitoba Intercultural Council Committee on Municipal Affairs; Lamoureux 4603; Mitchelson 4603 RIS Manness 5394; 3r Wowchuk 5395-6; RIA5491 Multicultural Resource Centre Closure Municipal Assessment Amendment Act (2) Cerilli 124; Mitchelson 124 (BIII 99) Education resources 1 r Wowchuk 4543; Cerilli 124; Mitchelson 124 Municipal assessments Multiculturalism Secretariat Delays Activities Derkach 4204; Wowchuk 4203-4 Cerilli 3956; Mitchelson 3956 Right to appeal Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. BO) Derkach 4204; Wowchuk 4204 Mitchelson 1754 Hiring policy Municipal Board Cerilli 58; Filmon 58-9; Lamoureux 127-8, 925; Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 67) Mitchelson 128, 925 Derkach 1174 Political Influence Headingley/Winnipeg boundary (T.P. 22) Cerilli 5267-8; Mitchelson 5268 Ernst11 74 Report tabling request Cerilli 3956-7; Mitchelson 3957 Municipal Council Conflict of Interest See also Culture, Heritage and Citizenship, Amendment Act (Bill 29) Deparlnnent of (Supply) 1 r Edwards 467 Municipal Affairs, Standing Committee on Mystery Lake School Division 1st Report Dacquay 352 Funding 2nd Report Ashton 2309; Vodrey 2309 Dacquay 1653 Meeting request 3rd Report Ashton 2309; Vodrey 2309 Dacquay 2296-7 4th Report National unity Dacquay 2349 Government initiatives 5th Report Johnson 9 Rose 5388-91 Native Affairs, Minister responsible for Municipal Amendment Act (Bill 31) Public's confidence 1 r Gaudry397; 2r Gaudry 908-9; Downey 1418; Hickes 1418 Helwer 2069-71 ;Penner 2071-3; Rose 2566-8

Municipal Assessment Amendment Act Native AffairsSecr etariat (BIII 20) See NorthernAffai rs, Departmentof (Supply) 1 r Downey (Derkach) 261 ; 2r Carstairs 3562-3, 3861-3;Derkach491 -3; Dewar 4176-7; Natural Resources, Departmentof L. Evans 4177-81 ; Gaudry 767; McCrae 497-8; Annu& Report, 1991 (S.P. 68)

132 Hansard Index

Natural Resources - Cont. Natural Resources (Supply) - Cont. Enns 1249 Resource Programs Co-Management agreements Fisheries Public forum Administration

Edwards 1326; Enns 1326-7 • Enns 5088-9; C. Evans 5088-9 Working group Forestry Edwards 1327; Enns 1327 Administration Fisheries branch-Brandon Enns 5081-6; Edwards 5081 -6 Closure Forest Protection Enns 4166, 4576; L. Evans 4166; Enns 5087-8; C. Evans 5087 Rose 4575-6 Silviculture Forestry Enns 5086-7; C. Evans 5086 Five Year Report (S.P. 87) Lands Enns 2458 Crown Lands Administration library services Enns 4981 ; Wowchuk 4980-1 Enns 2465-6; C. Evans 2465 Parks and Natural Areas Natural Lands and Special Places Administration Workbook (T.P. 118) Dewar 4971-2; Enns 4972 Enns 3843 Management and Development Supplementary information Enns 4972-4; C. Evans 4972-4 1992-93 Estimates (T.P. 179) Park Operations and Maintenance Enns 4594 Enns 4976; C. Evans 4976; Wowchuk4976 Waste dumping-Winnipeg Floodway Program Services Cummings 4301 ; Gaudry 4301 Enns 4974-5; C. Evans 4974-5 Visitor Services Natural Resources, Departmentof (Supply) Enns 4976-80;C. Evans 4976-80 Administration and Finance Water Resources Administrative Services Administration Edwards 4873-6, 4952; Enns 4872-6, 4952; Enns 4963-6; C. Evans 4965-6; C. Evans 4872-3 Plohman 4963-5 Executive Support Water Licensingand Approvals Enns 4871 ; C. Evans 4870 Enns 4967-8; Wowchuk 4966-7 Minister's salary Water Management C. Evans 5090 Enns 4968-71 ; C. Evans 4968-9; Venture Manitoba Tours Ltd. Plohman 4969-70; Wowchuk 4971 Enns 4871 -2; C. Evans 4871-2 Opening remarks Nelson Mclntrye Collegiate Enns 4865-8 See Nonpolitical statements Response Edwards 4869; C. Evans 4868-9 Net Income Regional Operations Provincial decline Fire Pre-Suppression Program Doer 50-1 ; Filmon 50-1 Enns 4962-3; C. Evans 4962 NEUFELD, Fire Tac Program Hon. Harold (Rossmere, PC) (Minister of Energy and Mines) Enns 4963; C. Evans 4963 (Minister responslble for the Manitoba Hydro HeadquartersOperations Act) Edwards 4952-9, Enns 4952-62; Budget debate C. Evans 4961-2; Wowchuk 4960-1 1359-64,13 75-7

133 Hansard Index

Neufeld, Hon. Harold - Cont. Nonpol/tlcslsta tements - Cont. Manitoba Hydro Amendment Act (Bill 1 0) Wear Your Bear day 1r 170 Cheema 3961 ; Orchard 3960; Messages Wasylycia-Leis 3960-1 Bill 10 (S.P. 13) 169 Citizenship awards Oral questions Cerilli 1974; Lamoureux 1974-5; Conawapa dam project Mitchelson 1974 Contract validity 226 Compton, Jim Expenditures-Manitoba Hydro 130 Canada Award recipient Expenditures-Ontario Hydro 130 Friesen 731 Legal opinion request 267-8 Core Area Initiative Postponement 129 Training program graduates Public Utilities Board Hickes 1232-3 Review 268 Dental Health Month Renegotiation 361 Render 2599 Surplus power 268 Dupuis, Patrice Snow Lake, Manitoba Youth Science Foundation award recipient Labour adjustmentcommittee 294 McAlpine 3279 Mineral exploration 295 Earth Day Private Members' Business Cerilli 2468; Lamoureux 2468; Reimer 2467-8 Resolutions Festival of Vaisakh Ukraine, Independence of 3202-3 Cheema 2111; Martindale 2111-2; Mitchelson 21 11 Nonpolitical statements Friesen,Henry AIDS Candlelight Memorial Medical Research Council of Canada Barrett3371 ; Wasylycia-Leis 3419 Cheema 3046; Friesen 3047; Orchard 3046-7 Allona, Elliana Fort Richmond Centurions Energy of our Resources calendar Manitoba high school hockey champions Manitoba artist Doer 1057; Laurendeau 1057 Downey 477 Glenlawn Collegiate Altona Volunteer Fire Department Achievements 361-2 Penner 4438-9 Girls' varsity team 1499 Assiniboine Memorial Curling Club Great-West Life Assurance Company Junior men's curling champions 1 OOth birthday Mcintosh 827 Laurendeau 2515 Associated CountryWomen of the World Day Greece independence Wowchuk 2751 Ashton 1662-3; Ernst 1663 Basketball championship Hamblin, Lorna and Chris Penner 1663 Outstanding Young Farmers Award recipients Bear, Elsie Penner 2995 Order of the BuffaloHunt recipient Hanukkah Dewar 1023; Downey 1023 Carr 26-7; Filmon 27; Martindale27 Border Crossings magazine Hockey championships Magazine of the year award Derkach 1662 Friesen 4309 Hohl, David Canadian Women's Curling Championship Olympic wrestling team member Dacquay 1056 Laurendeau 2598 Children's Hospital Research Foundation Holocaust Awareness Week

134 Hansard Index

Nonpoliticalstat ements - Cont. Nonpoliticalstat ements - Cont. Cheema 2750; Doer 2749-50; Filmon 2749 Manitou, Manitoba International Day for the Elimination of C. Evans 628; Orchard 628 Racial Discrimination Mount Manitoba climbing team Cerilli 1474; Lamoureux 1473; Alcock 2799-80; Dacquay 2799, 3419; Mitchelson 1474 Doer 2799 International Human Rights Day National Access Awareness Week Carr 132; Cerilli 132; McCrae 132-3 Barrett3990-1 ; Gilleshammer 3991 InternationalWomen 's Day National Citizenship Week Barrett 1022; Edwards 1022; Mitchelson 1022 Mitchelson 2083-4 Inter-Universities North National Day of Mourning 20th anniversary Lamoureux 2693-4; Praznik 2693; Reid 2693 Ashton 1 057-8 National Missing Children's Week International Assembly of French-language Alcock 3794-5; Cerilli 3794; Parliamentarians Gilleshammer 3793-4 Gaudry 3173-4; Laurendeau 3175; National Safe Driving Week Wasylycia-Leis 3174-5 Gaudry 24-5 MAHA Provincial B Atoms Hockey Tournament National Social Work Week Derkach 1057 Alcock 879-80;Barrett 879; Gilleshammer 880 Manitoba athletic achievements Nelson MclntryeCol legiate Barrett 1499 Girls' varsity basketball team Manitoba commemorative coin Gaudry 1499 Dewar 1921 ; Gaudry 1921 ; Reimer 1920-1 New Year's celebrations Manitoba Developmental Centre Reimer 21 1 0-1 Accreditation Olafson, Doug Connery 1424; Doer 1424-5 YTV Youth Achievement award Manitoba student achievements Wasylycia-Leis 731-2 McAlpine 4170-1 Order of Canada recipients Manitoba-U.S. snowmobile trail Doer 2800-1 Penner 880 Partnershipsin Education Manitoba's 122nd birthday Render 1233 Carstairs 3276-7; Dewar 3279; Doer 3275-6; Petr, Jacqueline Filmon 3274-5; Gaudry 32n-9 Olympic competitor, ice dancing Marriage congratulations Carstairs 4n Carstairs 2084 Philippine HeritageWeek Matas, David Cheema 4308-9;Lamoureux 4308; Canadian Council for Refugees Mitchelson 4307-8; Santos 4308 Santos 295-6 Piche, Travis McColm, Ken 2nd place trophy, National Chess competition Cross Canada walk Dacquay 3900-1 Lamoureux 1717 Pockar, Brian McLeod, Allan Canadian figure skating champion, death of Victoria Cross recipient Carstairs2801 Helwer 3046 R.D. Parker Collegiate McLeod, Robert Knotts Berry Farm Heritage Music Festival Rh Award recipient Ashton 2598 Dacquay 1425 Radio communautaire du Manitoba Mixed curling bonspiel Gaudry 59-60

135 Hansard Index

Nonpo/lt/cs/sta tements - Cont. Nonpol/tlcs/sta tements - Cont. Rae, Don Praznik 3176-7; Storie 3176 Order of the Buffalo Hunt recipient Winkler Ayers hockey team Connery 3681 Anavet Cup recipients Riel, Louis Orchard 2599 Federal recognition Winnipeg Hawks Triple ftAft Bantam hockey team Dewar 1117; Downey 1118-9; Enns 1117-8; Western Canadian Bantam Champions Gaudry 1118 Cheema 5410 Roblin, Senator Duff Winnipeg Police Department, gratitude to Retirement Laurendeau 4438 Carstairs 4887-8; Doer 4887; Enns 4888; Winnipeg Thunder Almon 4886-7 World Basketball League Saint Patrick's Day C. Evans 3372 Carstairs 1329; Doer 1329; Almon 1328 Winter Olympics Seniors Month Manitoba participants Ducharme 3991 ; Lamoureux 3991 ; Santos Cheema 627-8; C. Evans 628 3991 World Health Day Silver Heights Collegiate Wasylycia-Leis 1921-2 Reach for the Top team Wright, Amanda McAlpine 2800 Winter fun poster contest winner Sisler High School Connery 731 Youth parliament Yes, I Can Awards Lamoureux 362 Chomiak 758; Reid 758-9 Sisters Servantsof Mary Immaculate 1 00 years of service Nonprofit housing Martindale 4309 See Housing, nonprofit Sturgeon Creek High School Provincial handball champions Noplmlng Park-Forestry McAlpine 3175, 4889 Swan River Metis FriendshipCentre Environmental mediator First Annual Square Dance Competition Cummings 2199; Edwards 2199 Wowchuk 3372 Land division Tartan Day Cummings 2200; Edwards 2199-2200 Lamoureux 1781-2; Martindale 1781 ; Negotiations McAlpine 1717-8, 1 780-1 Cummings 2199; Edwards 2199 Ukraine independence Wildernesssta tus Carstairs 26; Chomiak 25; Filmon 25-6 Carstairs972 ; Enns 972-3 University of Winnipeg Wesmen GPAC basketball men's championship North American Free Trade Agreement Filmon 1058 Agricultural industry Vimy Ridge anniversary Connery 1373; Downey 1660-1 ; Andlay 1373; Alcock 1920; Doer 191 9-20; Filmon 1919; Plohman 1660-1 McAlpine 2065 Clarification Westminster United Church Doer 4603; Almon 4604 1 OOth anniversary Crown corporations Friesen 3373 Doer 1491 ; Stefanson 1491-2 Westray, Nova Scotia mine accident Cultural industries Ashton 3176; Carstairs 3324; Downey 3324; Alcock 1913-4; Stefanson 1914

136 Hansard Index

North American Free Trade Agreement - Cont. North American Free Trade Agreement-Cont. Deadline Cummings 2791 ; Doer 1706, 2194-5, 2790-1, Cummings 1605; Doer 1605 3037-8; Filmon 1706, 2195, 3037-8 Departmental review Sanitary standard Stefanson 1913; Storie 1913 Plohman 1779; Stefanson 1779 Tabling request Sectoral briefing Alcock 1914; Stefanson 191 3-4; Storie 1913 Doer 2194;Filmon 2194 Election call Supply management Downey 1656; Storie 1656 Doer 1606, 4982-3; Downey 1606; Garment industry Findlay 1778-9; Plohman 1778-9; Stefanson 3319-20;Storie 3319-20 Stefanson 4982-3 Government action Water exports Downey 1655; Storie 1655 Alcock 1775-6, 2877-8; Governmentposition Stefanson 1775-6, 2878 Cummings 1605; Doer 1366-7, 1490, 1605, Withdrawal 1706-7; Downey 1490; Film on 1323; Martindale4306; Filmon 1323, 1367-8, 1706-7; Storie 1323 Stefanson 3320; Storie 1323, 3320 Governmentstrategy See a/so Priva te Members'Busi ness-Resolutions Filmon 2853; Storie 2853 Government study NorthMain Development Corporation Tabling request Funding Doer 1368;Stef anson 1368 Ernst 51 14; Hickes 51 14 Government withdrawal Doer 4597-8; Stefanson 4597-8 North Portage Development Corporation Impact labour force Doer 4877-9; Stefanson 4878-9 Annual Report, 1991 (T.P. 15) Impact Manitoba Ernst 618 Doer 2574; Filmon 2574; Stefanson 971-2; Storie 971 -2 NorthWest Company Information tabling request Employment creation strategy Downey 1662; Filmon 2077-8; Stefanson 2579-80;Storie 2578-9 Stefanson 1913; Storie 1662, 1913, 2077 Justification Northern Affairs, Department of Manness 3645; Storie 3645 Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 66) Labour adjustment strategy Downey 1174 Doer 1491 ; Filmon 1491 Supplementary information Labour standards 1992-93 Estimates(T.P. 110) Alcock 1716; Filmon 1716 Downey 3643 Manitoba conditions Doer 1706-8; Filmon 1706-7; Northern Affairs, Departmentof (Supply) Stefanson 403-4; Storie 403-4 Administrationand Finance Manitoba opposition Executive Support Stefanson 971 ; Storie 971 Downey 4047-9; Gaudry 4047-8; Premier's position Harper 4048-9;La thlin 4048 Doer 4604; Filmon 4604 Communities Economic Development Fund Provincial jurisdiction Downey 4050; Gaudry 4050; Harper 4050 Downey 1656;Storie 1656 NorthernAffairs Fund Public hearings Downey 4049-50; Harper 4049-50

137 Hansard Index

Northern Affairs (Supply) - Cont. Northern Affairs (Supply) - Cont. Expenditures Related to Capital Opening remarks NorthernCommu nities Downey 4037-42 Downey 41 05-8; Gaudry 41 05, 41 08; Response Lathlin 41 05-8 Gaudry 4047; Lathlin 4042-6 Local Government Development Programs andOperational Support Northern Central Hydro Electrification Community Training agreement Downey 4051 ; Gaudry 4051 See Ministerial statements Emergency Response Program Downey 4050-1; Lathlin 4050-1 Northern Flood Agreement Grants South Indian Lake Downey 4051 ; Gaudry 4051 Legal expenses Recreational Director's Program Doer 2742-3; Filmon 2742-4 Downey 4051-3; Harper 4053; See also Northern Affairs, Department of (Supply) Lathlin 4051 -3 -Northern Development and Co-ordination; Regional Services Ministerial statements Downey 4051 ; Gaudry 4051 Selkirk Region Northern Manitoba Downey 4054; Gaudry 4054; Harper 4054; Lathlin 4053-4 Employment creation strategy The Pas Region Ashton 5409-10; Filmon5409 -10 Downey 4053; Lathlin 4053 Employment opportunities Native Affairs Secretariat Derkach 2691 ; Lathlin 2691 Aboriginal Development Programs FederaVProvincial agreements Downey 4066-74, 41 05; Gaudry 4072; Downey 24; Lathlin 24 Harper 4069-73, 41 05; Lathlin 4066-9,4073-4 Other Expenditures NorthernMan itoba Economic Development Downey 4066; Lathlin 4066 Commission NorthernDev elopment and Co-ordination See Northam Affairs, Department of (Supply) NorthernFlood Agreement -Northam Development and Co-ordination Economic Development Corporate Projects NorthernTe lecom-Layoffs Downey 4062; Gaudry 4062 Governmentaction Salaries Doer 4543-4; Stefanson 4543-5 Downey 4061 -2; Gaudry 4061 -2; Harper 4062 Northern Youth Corps Job Program Northern Flood Program Funding restoration Downey 4055-61; Gaudry 4055-6, 4060; L. Evans 973; Manness 973-4 Harper 4055-61 ; Lathlin 4058-61 Northern Manitoba Economic Development Norway House Fisherman's Co-op Commission Compensation OtherExpenditures Downey 28n; Lathlin 2877 Downey 4062-5; Harper 4064-5; Lathlin 4064-5 Nursing Education, Ministerial Council on Salaries Status Downey 4055; Lathlin 4055 Orchard 2594; Wasylycia-Leis 2593-4

138 Hansard Index

Oak Hammock Marsh development OptometryAmendment Act - Cont. Ducks Unlimited complex Amendments; RIS Orchard 5220; 3r 5233; Cerilli 2080-1; Cummings 1912-3, 2080-1 ; RIA 5492 Doer 1911-2, 3673; Filmon 1911-2, 3673 Environmental assessments ORCHARD, Hon. Donald (Pembina, PC) Cerilli 269; Almon 269 (Minister of Health) Government credibility Alcoholism Foundation of Manitoba Cerilli 269; Almon 269-70 Annuru Report, 1991 (S.P. 93) 2685 Governmentwithdrawal Supplementary information Cerilli 4275-6; Enns 4275-6 1992-93 Estimates (T.P. 75) 2871 Impact on tourism Budget debate Doer 4275; Stefanson 4275 1218-20, 1233-7 Sewage treatment Condolence, Motions of Cerilli 1914-5; Cummings 1914-5 Einarson, Henry John 613-4 See also Ducks Unlimited Dental Association Amendment Act (Bill 80) 1 r 2846;2r 3054-5, 3963; RIS 5220 Odometer tampering Denturists Amendment Act (Bill 6) Consumer warning 1 r 170; 2r 628-9; RIS 3961 Maloway 626, 691-2, 755-6; Health, Departmentof Mcintosh 626, 691-2, 755-6 Annuru Report, 1990 (S.P. 94) 2685 Highways and Transportation, Minister of Capital Program, 1992/93 (T.P. 197) 5278 Opinion Hospital insurance and health care plans Driedger 3042; Maloway 3042 (T.P. 78) Royal Canadian Mounted Police report 2913 Driedger 3042-3; Maloway 3042; Regulation506/ 88R Mcintosh 3042 Response to questions (T.P. 62) 2523 See also Business Practices Act-Restitution; Staff year vacancy report (T.P. 48) 1932 Consumer Protection Amendment Health, Department of(Supply) Act-Governmentsup port Administration and Finance Olafson, Doug Evaluation and Audit Secretariat 2178, 2204-26, 231 1-26, 2359-84,241 3-27 See Nonpolitical statements Executive support15 25-6, 1564-83, Older Worker Adjustment, Program for 1784-1805, 1 839-78, 1 928-46,2025-46, Status report 21 14-35, 2162-n Connery 1161-2; Praznik 1161-2 Health Information Systems 2430-3 Minister's salary 3236, 3246-7 3287-8, 3390-1 3422-3 Ombudsman ' ' Annuru Report, 1990 (S.P. 58) Alcoholism Foundation of Manitoba 3230-3 Rocan 819 Continuing Care Programs Administration 2665-83, 2694-6 Open Skies policy Health Services See Priva te Members'Business-Resolutions Administration 2815-23, 2886-95, 291 3-58, 2996-3007 ' Optometry Amendment Act (BIII 81) 3010-7, 3094-3101, 3105-1 7, 31n 1 r Orchard 2846;2r Barrett3876-7; Capital Construction321 5-7 Cheema 3963-4; Orchard 3055-6, 3963; Emergency Health and Ambulance Services referred to Standing Committee on Law 321 3-4

139 Hansard Index

Orchsrd, Hon. Donsld - Cont. Orchsrd, Hon. Donsld - Cont. Hospital and Community Health Services Friesen, Henry 3178-86 Medical Research Council of Canada 3046-7 Laboratory and Imaging Services 3204-13 Mixed Curling Bonspiel Health Services Insurance Fund 3229-30 Manitou, Manitoba 628 Healthy Public Policy Winkler Ayers hockey team Administration2437-9 Anavet Cup recipients 2599 Health Promotion, Protection and Disease Optometry AmendmentAct (Bill 81) Prevention 1 r 2846;2r 3055-6, 3963; RIS5220 2516-38, 2601 -9 Oral questions Healthy Child Development 261 9-23, 2650-65 AIDS education projects Insured Benefits Funding 4598-9 Salaries 321 7-28 AIDS prevention programs Lotteries Funded Programs Street LINKS funding 3648-9 Health Policy Evaluation and Research At-risk pregnancies Initiative Prevention programs 4169-70 3233-5 Brandon General Hospital Opening remarks 1500-1 1 , 1524 Budget reduction 602-3 Provincial Mental Health Services Funding 1774, 3088-9 Administration 2696-2715, 2801-15 Labour adjustment strategy 1775 Health Services Insurance Amendment and Palliative care unit 1165 Consequential Amendments Act (Bill 75) Service reduction 560, 603, 3089 1 r 2075; 2r 3853-4 Brandon Mental Health Centre Interim Appropriation Act, 1992 (Bill 67) Replacement facility 341 5-6 C/W 1764-5, 1768 Brandon School of Psychiatric Nursing Manitoba Centre for Health Policy and Evaluation Closure 1758 Health care studies (T.P. 11) 463 Breast cancer Hospital funding report (T.P. 83) 3084 Governmentinitiatives 291 Maternal Demographic Risk Factors and the Canada Health Act Incidence of Low Birthweight, Manitoba Tray-fee regulations 2255-6 (T.P. 119) 3844 Child Guidance Clinic Manitoba Health Research Council Audiology program 3172-3 Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 92) 2685 Children's Dental Health Program Mental Health Amendment Act (Bill 93) Service reduction 2850 1r3844; 2r 4172-3; 3r 5395 Community-based health care system Messages Governmentini tiatives 1471 Bill 75 (S.P. 83)2075 Deer LodgeHospital Ministerial statements Bed closures 3322-3 Breast Cancer Screening Depo-Provera Reportof the Working Group 965-7 Licenceapproval 291 CT Scanning Committee Report(T.P. 55) Drug patent law-Federal 2298-2300 Governmentposition 2590-1 Manitoba Centre for Health Policy and Governmentstrate gy 2592 Evaluation Impact on drug costs 2591 463-4 Eating disorders Nonpolitical statements Treatment programs 5171-2 Children's Hospital Research Foundation Furnace inspections Wear Your Bear day 3960 Carbon monoxide levels 2512

140 Hansard Index

Orchard, Hon. Donald - Cont. Orchard, Hon. Donald - Cont. Health AdvisoryNetwork Public awareness campaign 51 12-3 Home care program 3414 St. John's Ambulancefunding 3680 Reportrelease 3413 Speciality treatments23 Health care facilities U.S. residents, servicesto 20, 21-2, 557-8 Bed closures 878, 1111-2, 1466, 1492-3, Waiting lists review 3533 1772-3, 2017-8, 3087, 3041 -2 Spending decisions 1110-1 Funding 1181 Surgery waiting lists17 6-7 Operating budgets 3166 Underspending1 180-1 Health care system Health care system, Northern Anesthetist manpower review 1968-9,2201 Mammography/chemotherapy services3580-1 Anesthetist shortage 177 Mortality rate 3090 CT scanners Transportationfee 878-9, 3090-1 Fundraising 2303-4 Health, Department of Cataract surgery 826, 1661-2 Employee morale 975-6 Deinsurance 251 0-1 Regional operations Diagnostic services St. Boniface 1916 Privatization 4741 Underspending922 Fee schedule reform 3678 Health Sciences Centre Forensic services4306 Bed closures 1226-7, 191 6-7 Health SmartCard 3579-80 Knee/hipreplacement surgery 796-7 Hip/knee replacementsurgery 826 Operating budget 1181 , 1467 Out-of-province patients 2304-5 Operating room closure 1226 Multicultural policy 51 15-6 Schoolof Nursing closure 4552 Public accountability21 06-7 Hearing disorder screening Reform Program funding 2575 Audiology services3680 Home care program Bed closures 3323, 3370, 4572-3 Accessibility 1762 Bridge funding 3368, 3371 Advisory committee 623 Community-based services3365 Advocacyoffice 624 Consultations 1492, 3167, 3365, 4741 Alternative service556-7, 3172 Continuing care 4430-1 Decision-making process 1421 Co-ordination 3091-2 Employee conflictof interest 141 9-20 Bridge funding 3368 Employee intimidation 1420-1 De insurance 22-3 Funding 3414 Government agenda 3041-2 Governmentcommitment 475-6 Health, Minister of Licensed Practical Nurses' role 3898 Awareness 22 Privatization 1657 Home care program 3370-1 , 3534-5, 4431-2 Service reduction Hospital closure 23 556, 141 9, 1420, 1657-8, 1659-60, 3171 Impact employment 3366 Servicereduction-Parkland region 1420 Implementation 19, 3364, 3366, 4987 Services,list of317 2 Information release 19 Whiteway, Nancy 623 Meeting request 3167-B Licensed PracticalNur ses Monitoring process Educational opportunities 3898 3367, 3412-3, 3532-3, 4987 Governmentsupport 625-6, 875, 877-8, 2745 Patient protection 3364 Red River Community College 2745 Professional training co-ordination 4551 Lindenview Residence

141 Hansard Index

Orchard, Hon. Donald - Cont. Orchard, Hon. Donald - Cont. Funding 41 70 Proclamation 1972, 2083 Manitoba Association for Childbirthand Family Thompson General Hospital Education Regional facility 3581 Funding elimination 25n Urban aboriginal medical program Mental health care facilities Funding reduction 4571 Bed closures 3167, 4304-5 Urban Hospital Council Mental health care system Budget reduction proposal 821 -2 Bed closures 4742, 51 12 Mental health care Community-based services4742 Recommendations 3040 Reform Misericordia Hospital review 473 Co-ordination 51 11-2 Recommendations 22 Governmentstrategy 4200-1 Report request 557 Midwifery Speciality nursing Government initiatives 2687-8 Recommendations 3041 Misericordia Hospital Points ofOrder Emergency ward closure 1969-70 P/0 by � respecting word "coward" Funding 1 n2-3 (Orchard) 1467; Mental health care 3039-40 withdrawn 1467 Mount Carmel Clinic P/0 by &blQn respecting words "I am going to Cross-cultural counselling unit recommend rabies shots" (Orchard) 1775; 793-4, 1163, 51 15 Manness 1775; ruled out of order1 n5; Nursing Education,Mi nisterial Council on Members cautioned 1775 Status 2594 P/0 by � respecting words "an obligation Pharmacare to tell the truth" (Orchard) 3089; Calcium supplements 5409 ruled out oforder 3089 Clarythromycinexclusion 520-1, 926-7, 2256-7 P/0 by A§blQorespecting words "false information" Cyclosporine exclusion 927 (Orchard) 31 06; Deductible increase 520 Members cautioned (Reimer) 3106 Exclusions51 76 P/0 by Wasylycja-Lejsrespecti ng imputation of Poverty rate motives (Orchard) 1784; Prevention programco-ordination 3369 ruledout of order (Laurendeau) 1784; St. Boniface Hospital Members cautioned 1784 Bed closures 3086-7, 4280, 4304 P/0 by Wasylycja-Lejsrespecti ng word "hypocrites" School of Licensed Practical Nurses 822, 2745 (Orchard) 1785; Cheema 1785; St. John's Ambulance taken under advisement (Laurendeau) 1795 Funding 2881 -2 withdrawal requested 2022; Selkirk Mental Health Centre withdrawn (Orchard) 2022 Forensic unit 294, 558-9 P/0 by Wasylycja-Lejs respecting word "fabricate" Selkirk School of Psychiatric Nursing (Orchard) 2033; Closure postponement 1758, 4306 withdrawal requested (Rose) 2933; Reopening 294 withdrawn (Orchard) 2033 Seven Oaks General Hospital Private Members' Business Operating budget 2195-6 Resolutions Social assistance Crime Prevention Council 865 Employment creation programs 3370 Medicare, five principles of5362-4 Food allowance 3043 Medicare, preservation of 3724-6 Solvent abuse legislation Reproductive health 201 0

142 Hansard Index

Orchard, Hon. Donald - Cont. Patient Records Access and Selkirk Psychiatric School of Nursing Confidentiality Act (8111 17) 2291-3 1 r Cheema 398-9 Salvation Army Grace General Hospital Incorporation Amendment Act (Bill 39) Pedlar Commission report 2r 1645-6 Recommendations Supply, Capital Barrett 18, 1761 -2; Chomiak 625, 3532; Supply, Committee of Manness 3532; McCrae 18-9, 625, 1762 5276-80, 4282-90, 5295-6, 5298-5305, 5337-41 See also Domestic violence Tabled papers Health care system reform Pembina Valley Water Co-operative Correspondence (T.P. 94) 31 84 Assiniboine River Diversion report Hospital bed statistics (T.P. 47) 1928 Driedger 925; C. Evans 925 Lyme disease Status report (T.P. 66) 2664 PENNER, Jack (Emerson, PC) Urgent Public Importance, Matter of Agriculture, Department of (Supply) Economic crisis 421-3 Agricultural Development and Marketing Division Marketing Branch 3921-3 Order of Canada Budget debate 1400-6 See Nonpolitical statements Law Amendment, Standing Committee on 5th Report5258-60 Orders for Return 7th Report 5391-3 Vision Fund (No. 2) Municipal Amendment Act (Bill 31) Alcock 478; accepted Manness 478 2r 2071 -3 Municipal Assessment Amendment Act (Bill 20) Ozone Depleting Substances Act 2r 493-6 Nonpolitical statements Enforcement 795 Altona Volunteer Fire Department 4438-9 Basketball championship 1663 PR 340 grading Hamblin, Lorne and Chris Project completion Outstanding Young Farmers Award recipients Driedger 3852; Rose 3852 2995 Manitoba-U.S. snowmobile trail 880 PTH 101 safety Petitions See Priva te Members'Busi ness-Resolutions Winnipeg Bible College and Theological Seminary Incorporation Act Paddlewheel Riverboats 3990; ruled in order 4093 Lower Fort Garry trip Points ofOrder Dewar 191 8-9; Stefanson 1918-9 P/0 by Penner respecting comments in regards to Dutch elm disease 839; Partnerswith Youth taken under advisement (Sveinson) 839; ruled out of order 978 See Fa mily Services, Department of (Supply) -Rehabilita tton and Community Uving; Private Members' Business Resolutions Partnerships In Education Bail review provisions, changes to 3949 See Nonpolitical statements Grow Bonds 3565-7, 3570-1

143 Hansard Index

P•nn•r, Jsck - Cont. P•tltlons - Cont. Public Utilities and Natural Resources, Hickes 1701 ; ruled in order 1753 Standing Committee on Lathlin 1965; ruled in order 2245 1 st Report2790 Aboriginal Justice System 2nd Report 2842 Ashton 1 174; ruled in order 1316 6th Report4499 Harper 1415; ruled in order 1604 7th Report4566-7 Harper 31 62; ruled in order 3264-5 Throne speech debate Harper 3978; ruled in order 4093-4 195-201 Hickes 1770; ruled in order 1910-1 Urgent Public Importance, Matter of Hickes 21 92; ruled in order 2246 Economic crisis 431 -3 Lathlin 917; ruled in order 1108 Winnipeg Bible College and Theological Seminary Lathlin 1155; ruled in order 1248 Incorporation Amendment Act (Bill 97) Lathlin 1248; ruled in order 1317 1 r 4200; 2r 4489 Lathlin 1316; ruled in order 1965 Pension Benefits Amendment Act (Bill 76) Lathlin 2296; ruled in order 2588 Lathlin 4160; ruled in order 4199 1 r Praznik 2193; 2r Ashton 5015-7; Lathlin 41 98; ruled in order 4426 Barrett 5012-5; Carstairs474 7-8; Lathlin 4426; ruled in order 4498 Praznik 3048-51 ; referred to Standing Brandon General Hospital Committee on Industrial Relations; L. Evans 2684; ruled in order 2740 RIS Praznik 5333; 3r Ashton 5420-2; L. Evans 2789; ruled in order 2869 Barrett5386-8; Praznik 5422; RIA 5492 L. Evans 2868; ruled in order 2984-5 Pension Plan Acts Amendment Act L. Evans 3360; ruled in order 3405 (BIII 100) L. Evans 3785; ruled in order 3842 L. Evans 3842; ruled in order 3891 1 r Praznik 4569; 2r Ashton 501 1 ; L. Evans 3891 ; ruled in order 3950 Lamoureux 501 1; Praznik 5009-1 1 ; referred to L. Evans 3950; ruled in order 3978 Standing Committee on Industrial Relations; L. Evans 3978; ruled in order 4093 RIS Praznik 5334; 3r 5335; RIA 5492 L. Evans 4198; ruled in order 4297 Personal PropertySecu rity Amendment L. Evans 4297; ruled in order 4497 Act (Bill 48) L. Evans 4497; ruled in order 5107 1 r McCrae 618-9; 2r Chomiak 2855-7; L. Evans 51 07; ruled in order 51 67 Edwards 829; McCrae 828-9; referred to L. Evans 5401 ; Standing Committee on Law Amendments; Children's Advocate RIS Manness 3962; 3r 5221 ; RIA 5491 Carstairs 2684; ruled in order 2789 Carstairs 2789; ruled in order 2841 Pesticide usage Carstairs 2841; ruled in order 2868 Biological alternatives Carstairs 2984;ruled in order 3035 Cerilli 4987-8; Cummings 4988 Carstairs 3264; ruled in order 3313 Environmental licensing Carstairs 331 3; ruled in order 3360 Cerilli 4987; Cummings 4987 Carstairs 3529; ruled in order 3574 Malathion Carstairs 3842; ruled in order 3950-1 Cerilli 4988; Cummings 4988 Carstairs 41 60; ruled in order 41 98 Carstairs 4272; ruled in order 4297-8 Petitions Carstairs 4297; ruled in order 4426-7 Abinochi Preschool Program Carstairs 4426; ruled in order 4497 Friesen 1701 ; ruled in order 1753 Carstairs 5401 ;

144 Hansard Index

Petitions - Cont. Petitions - Cont. Criminal Code amendments Fight Back Against Child Abuse campaign Barrett 1489; ruled in order 1652 Ashton 1701 ; ruled in order 1909 Cerilli 1248; ruled in order 1317 Barrett462; ruled in order 510 Cerilli 1365; ruled in order 1416 Barrett551 ; ruled in order 595 Cerilli 1770; ruled in order 1909 Barrett594; ruled in order (Dacquay) 617 Cerilli 1965; ruled in order 2012-3 Barrett684; ruled in order(Dacquay) 722 Cerllli 2349; ruled in order 2457 Barrett 722;ruled in order (Dacquay) 749 Chomiak 1221 ; ruled in order 1249 Barrett 791 ; ruled inorder 818 Chomiak 1316; ruled in order 1366 Barrett870; ruled in order 965 Chomiak 1701 ; ruled in order 1752 Barrett965; ruled in order 1013 Dewar 1248; ruled in order 1365 Barrett 1 013; ruled in order 1041 -2 C. Evans 1221 ; ruled in order 1249 Barrett11 08; ruled in order 1155 Friesen 1909; ruled in order 1965-6 Barrett1316 ; ruled in order 1365 Martindale 1909; ruled in order 2012 Barrett 1365; ruled in order 1415 Reid 1155; ruled in order 1174 Barrett16 04; ruled in order 1653 Reid 1221 ; ruled in order 1249 Barrett 1701 ; ruled in order 1752 Reid 1248;ruled in order 1317 Barrett 1770; ruled in order 1909-1 0 Reid 1316; ruled in order 1366 Barrett201 2; ruled in order 21 01 Reid 1415; ruled in order 1489 Barrett21 92; ruled in order 2245 Reid 1652; ruled in order 1701-2 Barrett2868; ruled in order 2984 Reid 1770; ruled in order 1910 Barrett31 62; ruled in order 3265 Reid 1965; ruled in order 2012 Barrett33 13; ruled in order 3360 Reid 2245; ruled in order 2296 Barrett 3842; ruled in order 3891 Reid 2349;ruled in order 2457-8 Barrett3950; ruled in order 3978 Reid 4093; ruled in order 4160-1 Barrett416 0; ruled in order 4199 Santos 1770; ruled in order 1910 Cerilli 1108; ruled in order 1156 Wasylycia-Leis 2012; ruled in order 2074 Cerilli 1604; ruled in order 1653 Wasylycia-Leis 21 01 ; ruled in order 21 92 Chomiak 462; ruled in order 510 Domestic violence Chomiak 551 ; ruled in order 595 Safe shelter-Length of stay Chomiak 594; ruled in order (Dacquay) 617 Reid 3313; ruled in order 3405 Chomiak 684; ruled in order (Dacquay) 723 Dutch elm disease program funding Chomiak 722 ; ruled in order (Dacquay) 749 Carstairs 791 ; ruled in order 819 Chomiak 791 ; ruled in order 818 Cerilli 2192; ruled in order 2296 Chomiak 870; ruled in order 917 Friesen 791 ; ruled in order 81 9 Chomiak 917; ruled in order 965 Friesen 2074; ruled in order 2192-3 Chomiak 1 013; ruled in order 1042 Friesen 2349; ruled in order 2457 Dewar 1108; ruled in order 1156 Friesen 2457; ruled in order 2505 Dewar 1415; ruled in order 1489 Friesen 2571 ; ruled in order 2589 Dewar 1652; ruled in order 1702 Friesen 2868; ruled in order 2984 Friesen 1489; ruled in order 1652-3 Friesen 3842;ruled in order 41 61 Hickes 1365; ruled in order 1415 Friesen 4160; ruled in order 4198-9 Hickes 1652; ruled in order 1701 Friesen 4272; ruled in order 4298 Martindale 11 08; ruled in order 1156 Friesen 4426; ruled in order 4498-9 Martindale 2074; ruled in order 21 02 Friesen 4566; ruled in order 4594 Reid 617; ruled in order (Dacquay) 684 Friesen 4735; ruled in order 4877 Reid 722; ruled in order (Dacquay)749 Friesen 5401 ; Reid 791 ; ruled in order 818

145 Hansard Index

Petitions - Cont. Petitions - Cont. Reid 870; ruled in order 91 7 Lamoureux 4426; Reid 1108; ruled in order 1155 Rotary Pines Project Santos 1701 ; ruled in order 1753 Funding withdrawal Santos 2012; ruled in order 2074 Martindale 12; ruled in order 48 Storie 1652; ruled in order 1702 Martindale 48; withdrawn 122 Wasylycia-Leis 462; ruled in order 510 Salvation Army Grace General Hospital Wasylycia-Leis 551 ; ruled in order 595 McAlpine 122; ruled in order 168 Wasylycia-Leis 595; ruled in order (Dacquay) Seven Oaks General Hospital 617-8 Helwer 3313; ruled in order 341 8-9 Wasylycia-Leis 684; ruled in orde r (Dacquay) The Pas Health Complex 722 Lathlin 396; ruled in order 462 Wasylycia-Leis 1464;ruled in order 1490 Winnipeg Bible College and Theological Foreign DomesticWorkers' Program Seminary Incorporation Act Lamoureux 1752; ruled in order 1770-1 Penner 3990; ruled in order 4093 Housing authorities Volunteer boards Petr, Jacqueline C. Evans 1909; ruled in order 2101 Wowchuk 1155; ruled in order 1174 See Nonpolitical statements Wowchuk 1604; ruled in order 1653 Wowchuk 1701 ; ruled in order 1770 Petty TrespassesAmend ment Act (Bill 47) Wowchuk 2074; ruled in order 21 01-2 1 r McCrae 596;2r Chomiak 4183-4; Human Resources OpportunityCentre Edwards 649-50; McCrae 648-9;referred to Moratorium on closure Standing Committee on Law Amendments; Dewar 2192;ruled in order 2245-6 RIS McCrae 5219; 3r 5232; RIA 5491 Dewar 2296; ruled in order 2505 Dewar 2505; ruled in order 2571 Pharmacare Dewar 2571 ; ruled in order 2588 Calcium supplements Dewar 2588; ruled in order 2684 Orchard 5409; Santos 5409 Dewar 2684; ruled in order 2740 Clarythromycin exclusion Dewar 2789; ruled in order 2841-2 Orchard 520-1 , 926-7, 2256-7; Dewar 2841 ; ruled in order 2868-9 Wasylycia-Leis 520-1 , 926-7, 2256-7 Dewar 2984; ruled in order 3035 Correspondence (T.P. 79) Dewar 3035; ruled in order 3084 Dewar 3162; ruled in order 3264 Cheema 2996 Dewar 3785; ruled in order 3842-3 Cyclosporine exclusion Dewar 3950; ruled in order 4094 Orchard 927 ; Wasylycia-Leis 927 Manitoba Heritage Federation Deductible increase Granting authority Orchard 520; Wasylycia-Leis 519-20 Lamoureux 3264; ruled out of order 331 3-4 Exclusions Lamoureux 3313; ruled in order 3574 L. Evans 5176; Orchard 51 76 Lamoureux 3360; ruled in order 3670 Lamoureux 3405; ruled in order 41 60 Pharmaceutical costs Lamoureux 3529; ruled in order (Dacquay) Impact on seniors 4272 Ducharme 3371 , 3988-9; Santos 3371 , 3988-9 Lamoureux 3643; ruled in order 4497-8 Lamoureux 4093; Philippine Heritage Week Lamoureux 4198; See Nonpolitical statements

146 Hansard Index

Piche, Travis Plohmsn, John S. - Cont. See Nonpolitical statements Animal HusbandryAmendment Act (Bill 12) 2r 2488-93, 3869-70; 3r 5227-9 Piney Area Seniors'Group Bee-Keepers Repeal Act (Bill 11) 2r 7.1 3-20 Co-ordinator Ducharme 1160; Santos 1159-60 Economic Innovation and Technology Council Act (Bill 9) Piper Aircraft Corporation 2r 802-8 Family Services, Department of (Supply) Manitoba relocation Child and Family Services Stefanson 1157; Storie 1157 Child and Family Support 2384-5 Farm Income Assurance Plans Amendment Act PLOHMAN, John S. (Dauphin, NDP) (Bill 43) Agriculture, Department of (Supply) 2r 2262-9; 3r 5229-31 Administration and Finance Farm Practices Protection and Consequential Executive Support 3592-3 Amendments Act (Bill 82) Minister's salary 4013 2r 4893-8; 3r 541 1 Agricultural Development and Marketing Division Health, Departmentof (Supply) Animal Industry Branch 3751-4, 3757 Health Services Marketing Branch 3914-9 Administration 2924-35 Soils and Crops Branch 3804-10, 3901 -6 Highways and Transportation, Departmentof Technical Servicesand Training Branch (Supply) Agricultural Societies 391 3-4 Administration and Rnance Salaries 3913 Computer Services4472-3 Veterinary Services Branch 3795-3804 Milk Prices Review Amendment Act (Bill 44) FederaVProvincial Agreement 2r 953-5 Soil Conservation Agreement 4009-10 Municipal Assessment Amendment Act (Bill 20) Income Insurance and SupportPrograms 2r 2768-76 Administration 401 0-2 Natural Resources, Department of (Supply) Net Income Stabilization Account 4012 Resource Programs Manitoba Agricultural Credit Corporation Water Resources Administration 3740-8 Administration 4963-5 Allowance for Doubtful Accounts 3750 Water Management 4969-70 Manitoba Crop InsuranceCorporation Oral questions Administration Agricultural industry 3593-361 1 ' 3681 -93, 3700-5, 3731-7 Rnancial assistance 54-5 Gross Revenue Insurance Plan 3738 Net farm income 3893-4 Opening remarks Agricultural land Response 3589-91 Taxation levels 2305 Policy and Economic Division Agricultural Ministers' meeting Administration 4000-7 Agenda 3894 Agricultural Research Agriculture, Departmentof University of Manitoba grant 4007-8 Laboratories, privatization of 3985 Manitoba Farm Mediation Board 4009 Bill 82 Regional Agricultural Services Division Environmental guidelines 4604-5 Agricultural Crown Lands Branch 3994-4000 Mandate 3680 Central Region 3993 Budget Northwest Region 3992-3 Crop insurance 923-4

147 Hansard Index

Plohmsn, John S. - Cont. Plohmsn, John S. - Cont. Civil service Processing potato producers Staff layoffs 1116 Marketing board 3537 Crop insurance Pur-A-Tone Hog Operation Crop adjuster salaries 227 Environmental concerns 3679 Crow benefit Soils Testing Laboratory Government position 360-1 Privatization results 3986 Payment plan 3268, 3578-9 Veterinary Drug Centre Public hearings 361 Privatization results 3986 Dauphin Lake Advisory Committee Western Premiers' Conference Funding 3793 Agricultural issues 341 4-5 Decentralization Crow benefit 3268 Status report 1117 Wild Kingdom Zoo-Dauphin Family Services, Department of Inhumane treatment of animals 4882-3 Custodydispute-Dau phin 4434-5 Points of Order Farming industry P/0 by Plohman respecting responses to Financial assistance 728-9 questions (Supply) 3431 ; Alcock3431 ; GATT negotiations Ashton 3431-2; Downey 3431 ; Praznik 3432; Supply management proposal 404-5, 627 ruled out of order (Dacquay) 3432 Grain exports-U.S. P/0 by Plohman respecting relevancy of debate Licensing process 2593, 3536-7 (Cummings) 3505; Gross Revenue Insurance Program ruled in order (Dacquay) 3505 Contractvalidity 1324 Private Members' Business Coverage levels Address for Papers Lentils2793-4 Public Health Amendment Act Risk areas 27 41 -2 Legal opinion 1697-1700 Southwest Manitoba 4279 Resolutions Governmentposition 226 PTH 101 safety 1081-3 Legal opinion request 1471 -2 Ukraine, Independenceof 3196-8 Notification deadline 1471 Provincial Park Lands Amendment Act (Bill 21) Objectives 4279 2r 947-51 Premium levels 226-7, 1262-3, 1323, 1472 Social Allowances Amendment and Consequential Home Care Program Amendments Act (Bill 70) Employee conflict of interest 1419 2r 4909-1 5 Servicereduction 1419 Statute Law Amendment (Taxation) Act, 1992 Service reduction-Parkland region 1420 (Bill 94) Manitoba Agricultural Credit Corporation C/W 5246-7 Interest rates 1262 Supply, Capital Manitoba Housing Authority Supply, Committee of 5352-7 Employees' status 2853-4 Tabled papers Staffing-Dauphin, Manitoba 3144-5 Supply management programs (T.P. 1 0) 404 North American Free Trade Agreement Throne speech debate Impact agricultural industry 1660-1 113-21 Sanitary standards 1779 Urgent Public Importance, Matterof Supply management 1778-9 Economic crisis 429-31 Portof Churchill Efficiency2020-1 Pockar, Brian Rail line protection 1020-1 See Nonpolitical statements

148 Hansard Index

Points of Order Points of Order - Cont. P/0 by � respecting brevity ofquestions Members cautioned 1708 and answers 51 ; P/0 by Ashton respecting words "I am going to Members cautioned 51 recommend rabies shots" (Orchard) 1775; P/0 by MblQn respecting dealing with matter Manness 1775; ruled out of order17 75; raised 51 ; Members cautioned 1775 Members cautioned 51 P/0 by MblQnrespecting admissibility of P/0 by � respecting dealing with matter amendment 1830-1 ; raised 59; taken under advisement (Laurendeau) 1831 ; Members cautioned 59 P/0 by � respecting closing debate 2346-7; Lamoureux 2348; Manness 2347; Reid 2347-8; P/0 by � respecting dealing with matter taken under advisement 2348; raised 223; Lamoureux 223; Praznik 223; Speaker's ruling 4495-6 Members cautioned 223 P/0 by � respecting words "space cadet" P/0 by � respecting brevity of questions (Filmon) 2460; and answers 270; ruled out of order 2460; Members cautioned 270 Members cautioned 2460 P/0 by MblQn respecting brevity of questions P/0 by Ashton respecting imputation of motives and answers 290; (Filmon) 3038; Manness 3039; Members cautioned 290 taken under advisement 3039; P/0 by MblQnrespecting unparliamentary ruled out of order 4436; language (McCrae) 333; Members cautioned 4436 withdrawn 333 P/0 by M.blQnrespecti ng words "an obligation P/0 by Mb1Qorespecti ng words "Reverend to tell the truth" (Orchard) 3089; Blackjack from Burrows" (Connery) 452; ruled out of order 3089 withdrawn 452 P/0 by MblQnrespecting words "false information" P/0 by AmtQnrespecti ng brevity of questions (Orchard) 31 06; and answers 688; Members cautioned (Reimer) 3106 Members cautioned (Dacquay)688 P/0 by M.b12nrespecti ng brevity ofquestions P/0 by A§bl!mrespecting brevity ofquestions and answers 3323; and answers 757; Members cautioned 3323 Members cautioned (Dacquay)757 P/0 by M.b12nrespecti ng members reading from P/0 by � respecting Chair's assumption prepared text 3437; Enns 3437-8; Member had risen on a point of order 531 ; ruled out of order (Dacquay) 3438 taken under advisement (Dacquay) 531 ; Ruling challenged 3438; ruled in order 827 sustained 3438 P/0 by Mb1Qo respectingrelevancy of P/0 by &b1QQrespec ting brevity of questions and debate 1 066; Praznik 1 066; answers 4433; Members cautioned (Dacquay) 1066 Members cautioned 4433 P/0 by MblQnrespecti ng word "honesty" 1181 ; P/0 by Carstairs respecting words "completely Members cautioned 1181 honest" (Manness) 754; P/0 by AmtQn respecting relevancy of Members' cautioned (Dacquay) 754 debate (Filmon) 1466; P/0 by Carstajrs respecting past precedent 2585; Member cautioned 1466 taken under advisement 2585; P/0 by MblQn respecting word "coward" Speaker's ruling 2882 (Orchard) 1467; withdrawn 1467 P/0 by Connery respecting words "we are having P/0 by Aib!Qnrespecting brevity of questions biased chairing in this House" 1993; and answers 1708; taken under advisement (Dacquay) 1993;

149 Hansard Index

Points of Order - Cont. Points of Order - Cont. ruled out oforder 2514 Members cautioned 405 P/0 by .QQ§[respecti ng word wcroniesw P/0 by Manness respecting words wmaster of (Filmon) 1479; obfuscationw (Wasylycia-Leis) 877; Members cautioned 1479 withdrawn 877 P/0 by � respecting words wmy honourable P/0 by Manness respecting withdrawal being friend for Burrows has a learning disabilityw conditional(Storie) 1225; Doer 1225; (Ernst) 4578; ruled out of order 1225 ruled out of order 4578 P/0 by Mannessrespecti ng imputation of motives P/0 by � respecting relevancy of (Cheema) 1260; Ashton 1260-1 ; debate 530-1 ; Lamoureux 1260; Members cautioned (Dacquay) 531 ruled out oforder 1261 P/0 by .EI:ll§1respec ting relevancy of P/0 by Mannessrespecting preambles to Oral debate 370; questions(Cerilli) 2463; Members cautioned (Dacquay)370 Members cautioned 2463 P/0 by .Em§!respecting relevancy of P/0 by Manness respecting more than one person debate 1032; Doer 1032; from a party speaking on Matter of Urgent Members cautioned (Dacquay) 1032 Public Importance 2585; P/0 by .E!:m1respecti ng words whas no gutsw taken under advisement 2585; (Maloway) 1628; Speaker's ruling 2882 Member cautioned (Dacquay) 1628 P/0 by Manness respecting previously asked P/0 by Laurendeau respecting relevancy of questions 2992; Alcock2992; Ashton 2992; debate 369; ruled out of order 2992 Members cautioned (Dacquay) 369 P/0 by Manness respecting question anticipating P/0 by Laurendeau respecting words wPremier debate (Carstairs) 3043; Ashton 3043-4; Moonbeamw (Maloway) 884; questionrephrased 3044 withdrawn 884 P/0 by Manness respecting references to persons P/0 by Laurendeau respecting relevancy of outsidethe Legislature (Maloway) 3549; debate 1027; Members cautioned (Laurendeau) 3549 Members cautioned (Dacquay) 1027 P/0 by Martindale respecting word wstupidw P/0 by Laurendeau respecting word wfabricationw (Ernst) 4396; (Wasylycia-Leis) 2029; withdrawal requested (Laurendeau) 4396; withdrawn 2029 withdrawn 4396 P/0 by Laurendeau respectingwords wfalse P/0 by McCrae respecting introduction of informationw (Ashton) 301 7; Bills 792; ruling challenged 301 8; Members cautioned(Dacquay) 792 sustained 3034 P/0 by McCrae respecting imputation of motives P/0 by Laurendeau respecting relevancy of (Wasylycia-Leis) 1795; debate (Edwards) 3062; Lamoureux 3062; withdrawn 1795 Martindale 3062; P/0 by McCrae respecting word wcowardlyw ruled out of order(Dacquay) 3062 (Barrett) 2287; P/0 by Laurendeau respecting dress code 3540; ruled out of order (Dacquay) 2287; ruled out oforder 3540 Members cautioned 2288 P/0 by Mannessrespecting supplementary P/0 by Mcintosh respecting relevancy of questions 125; Carstairs 125; Martindale 125; debate 1991 ; Members cautioned 125 Members cautioned (Dacquay) 1991 P/0 by Mannessrespecti ng supplementary P/0 by Mitchelson respecting line of questioning questions 405; (Supply) 4681 ; Filmon 4682-3;

150 Hansard Index

Points of Order - Cont. Policing servicesag reement Lamoureux 4681 -3; Correspondence (T.P. 183, 184) Praznik 4682; Chomiak 4737 ruled in order (Rose) 4682-3 Fee-for-servicecosts P/0 by f§nnm:respecti ng comments in regards Chomiak 4206, 4278, 4737-8; to Dutch elm disease 839; Derkach 4302, 5174; McCrae 4206, 4278-9, taken under advisement (Sveinson) 839; 4737-8, 5174; Wowchuk4302, 51 74 ruled out of order 978 Municipal costs P/0 by Plohman respecting responses to Derkach 873-4;Wowch uk 873-4 questions (Supply) 3431 ; Alcock3431 ; Ashton 3431-2; Downey 3431 ; Praznik 3432; ruled out of order (Dacquay) 3432 Portof Churchill Plohman P/0 by respecting relevancy of debate All-partycommi ttee (Cummings) 3505; Driedger 224; Harper 224 ruled in order (Dacquay) 3505 Agreement tabling request P/0 by friwlikrespecting supplementary Driedger 4202; Reid 4202 questions269; Ashton 269; Efficiency ruled out of order 269 Driedger 2020-1 ; Plohman 2020-1 P/0 by � respecting sub-judice Federal commitment convention 747; L. Evans 747; Driedger 471 ; Reid 471 Lamoureux 747-8; Future status taken under advisement (Dacquay) 748; Carstairs 4984-5; Driedger 4984-5 Speaker's ruling 2007-8 Government communications P/0 by � respecting relevancy of Driedger 4202; Reid 4201 debate 4526; Members cautioned4526 Government strategy P/0 by �respecting words "at least be Driedger 1263; Reid 1263 honest" (Cheema)23; Grain shipments withdrawal requested 23 Driedger 471 , 4201 , 51 16; Almon 690, 3273; P/0 by � respectingwords "always such Harper 3273; Reid 471 , 690, 4201, 51 16 a phony" (Filmon) 1225; Grain shipments-Russian Republic ruled out oforder 1225 Doer 3893; Almon 3893 P/0 by � respecting responses to Manitoba representation questions(Supply) 3432; Driedger 472; Reid 472 ruled out of order (Dacquay) 3432 Promotion P/0 by Wasylycja-Lels respecting imputation of Filmon 3273-4; Harper 3273 motives (Orchard) 1784; Rail line protection ruled out of order (Laurendeau) 1784; Almon 690; Andlay 1020; Plohman 1020-1 ; Members cautioned 1784 Reid 690 P/0 by Wasylycja-Lels respecting word "hypocrites" Rail line upgrading (Orchard) 1785; Cheema 1785; Driedger 51 16; Reid 51 16 taken under advisement (Laurendeau) 1795; Rail line usage withdrawal requested 2022; Driedger 3893; Doer3892-3 withdrawn (Orchard) 2022 Shipment statistics P/0 by Wasylycja-Lejs respecting word "fabricate" Carstairs 4984; Doer 3892; Driedger 4984; (Orchard) 2033; Almon 3892 withdrawal requested (Rose) 2933; See a/so Ministerial statements; We stern Premiers ' withdrawn (Orchard) 2033 Conference

151 Hansard Index

Portage Ia Prairie, Manitoba Prsznlk, Hon. Darren - Cont. Bridge inspection Condolence, Motions of Connery 3678-9; Driedger 3679 Hillhouse, Thomas Paterson 608-1 0 Bridge replacement Educationand Training, Department of (Supply) Connery 3679; Driedger 3679 Post-Secondary, Adult and Continuing Education and Training Post-Adoption RegistryAct (Bill 24) Program Analysis, Co-ordination and Support 1 r Carstairs 397 3509-13 Internal Reform, Workforce Adjustment and Post-SecondaryStudent Support Program General Salary Increases (Supply) See Ministerial statements 5060-1 Labour, Departmentof Postal rates Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 43) 551 See Private Members'Busi ness-Resolutions Employment standards guide (T.P. 163) 4228 Supplementary information Povertylevels 1992-93 Estimates (T.P. 155) 4161 Manitoba statistics Work stoppages (T.P. 162) 42 18 Alcock 3317-8; Manness 331 7-8 Worker Advisor Office Prevention program co-ordination Statistics (T.P. 161) 4226 Martindale 3369; Orchard 3369 Labour, Departmentof (Supply) See also Grievance, Ma tters of Labour Programs Apprenticeshipand Training Prairie Agricultural MachineryIns titute 4214-8, 4232, 4235 Annual Report, 1991 (T.P. 17) Conciliation and Mediation 4218-32 Findlay 694 Employment Standards 4227, 4231 -2 Fire Prevention 4234 PRAZNIK,Hon. Darren (Lac du Bonnet, PC) Labour Adjustment 4228-9,4235 {Minister of Labour) Mechanical and Engineering 4233 (Minister responsible for The Civil Service Act: Worker Advisor Office 4226, 4236 the Civil Service Superannuation Act; The Civil Service SpecialSupplementary WorkplaceSafety and Health 4223-6 Severance Benefit Act; The Public Servants Opening remarks 4209-1 0 Insurance Act) Labour Relations Amendment Act (Bill 85) (Minister responsible for and charged wHhthe administration of The Workers Compensation 1 r 3137; 2r 3326-33; R!S 533; 3r 5470-14 Act) Manitoba Civil Service Commission Employee Amusements Amendment Act (Bill 42) Benefits 1r 595; 2r 641 -3;RIS 5332 Supplementary information City of Winnipeg Amendment Act (3) (Bill 78) 1992-93 Estimates 41 99 3r 5328 Manitoba Civil Service Superannuation Board Civil Service Commission Annual Report, 1991 (S.P. 107) 3315 Affirmative Action Manitoba Labour Board Comparative profile (T.P. 168) 4312 Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 74) 1490 Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 30) 397 Manitoba Labour Management Review Committee Comparative employment (T.P. 169) 4312 Annua1 Reports, 1988, 1989 (S.P. 62) 1013 Supplementary information Messages 1992-93 Estimates (T.P. 156) 41 61 Bill 100 (S.P. 126) 4569 Civil ServiceComm ission (Supply) Nonpolitical statements 4312-33 National Day of Mourning2693 Opening remarks 4310 Westray, NovaScotia mine accident 3176-7

152 Hansard Index

Prsznlk, Hon. Darren - Cont. Prsznlk, Hon. Darren - Cont. Oral questions Government participation 3271 Apprenticeshiptraining Manitoba Lotteries Foundation First-aid certificate, mandatory 1715 Hiring process-Investigation 3987 Budget Multicultural legislation Civil service layoffs 1182-3 Affirmative Action, impact on 4429-30 CKND Television strike Older Worker Adjustment Program Government advertisingpolicy 1 162-3, 161 1 Status report1 161-2 Unfair labour practices 161 1 Unemployed Help Centre Civil servants Funding reinstatement 3417 Senior salary levels 474 Unionization Civil service Governmentcriteria 3270 Staff layoffs 1116 Workers Compensation Board Voluntary incentive program 1115 Family entitlements4502-3, 4549 Civil Service Commission Intimidation 4573-4 AffirmativeActi on co-ordinator 4430 Long-term benefits 292 Bulletins Medical advice 292 Term positions 3986 Medical specialist reports 1 056 Political interference 55-6, 57, 1n-8 Public inquiry 4301 -2, 4432-3,4549 Decentralization Vocational rehabilitation benefits2686-7 Status report 1117 Pension Benefits Amendment Act (Bill 76) Disabled employees 1 r 2193; 2r 3048-51/ RIS 5333; 3r 5422 Rehabilitation/vocational services3988 Pension Plan Acts Amendment Act (Bill 1 00) Economic growth 1 r 4569; 2r 5009-11 ; RIS 5334 Full-timeem ployment 2993 Points of Order Electrical ConstructionJourneymen P/0 by MblQnrespecting dealing with matter Examination standards 4885-6 raised 223; Lamoureux 223; Praznlk 223; Employment Standards Act Members cautioned223 Amendments 3988 P/0 by Mbt2nrespecting relevancy of Foreign Domestic Workers' Program debate 1 066; Praznik 1 066; Labour law coverage 3534 Members cautioned (Dacquay) 1066 Furnace inspections P/0 by Mitchelson respecting line of questioning Condemning authority 21 10, 2254-5 (Supply) 4681 ; Filmon 4682-3; Mandatory 2254 Lamoureux 4681 -3; Hay Commission report Praznik 4682; Government response 1053 ruled in order (Rose) 4682-3 Health care system P/0 by Plohman respecting responses to Essential servicesagreement 3417 questions(Supply) 3431 ; Alcock3431 ; Labour College of Canada Ashton 3431-2; Downey 3431 ; Praznik 3432; Scholarship 341 7 ruled out of order (Dacquay) 3432 Labour, Department of P/0 by fmmikrespecting supplementary Apprenticeship andTr aining branch questions269; Ashton 269; Staffing 1715-6 ruled out of order 269 Labour laws P/0 by fmmikrespecting sub-judice Worker protection 3270-1 convention 747; L. Evans 747; Labour, Minister of Lamoureux 747-8; Meeting request 2255 taken under advisement (Dacquay) 748; Labour movement Speaker's ruling 2007-8

153 Hansard Index

Prsznlk, Hon. Darren - Cont. Prlvsts Msmbsrs' Business - Cont. P/0 by � respecting relevancy of Winnipeg Regional Housing Authority (2) debate 4526; Maintenance contracts, 1990-91 Members cautioned4526 Alcock 41 87; Private Members' Business Orders for Retum Resolutions Winnipeg Regional Housing Authority (1 ) Fire Safety Safari 241 1-2 Maintenance costs, 1990-91 Ukraine, Independenceof 3200-2 Alcock 4187; Resolutions Resolutions Riel, Louis Aboriginal Justice Commission Role in development ofManitoba 3668-9 (Cheema) 1554-6;Hickes 1559-62; Throne speech debate Lamoureux 1562-3; McCrae 1556-9 339-45 Accreditation, Professional and Technical Urgent Public Importance, Matter of Alcock 2503-4; Reimer 2499-2502; Economic crisis 434-6 (Santos) 2497-9, 2502-3 Winnipeg Bible College and Theological Seminary Bail review provisions, changes to Incorporation Amendment Act (Bill 97) Barrett3947-8 ; Lamoureux 3946-7; RIS 5328-9 Manness 3948-9; Penner 3949; (Reid) 3944-6 Workers Compensation Board CN Rail jobs Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 98) 2842 Driedger 1833-5; Lamoureux 1831-3; Five Year Operating Plan (S.P. 99) 2842 (Lathlln) 1827-8; Reid 1835-7; Stefanson 1828-30 Prime Oil Company Child care, rural Barrett 3886-7; Enns 3889-90; Work order extension Gilleshammer 3887-8; (Wowchuk) 3884-6 Cerilli 556; Cummings 556 Constitutional referendum for Canada (Carstairs) 2902-5; Doer 2908-1 1; Private Bills, Standing Committee on Lamoureux 291 1-2; McCrae 2905-8 1st Report Constitutional task force Reimer 3314 Doer 41 92-3; Gaudry 4193-5; 2nd Report (Laurendeau) 4190-1 ; Render 41 95-7 Reimer 4094-5 Core Area Initiative renewal Ducharme 542-5; (Edwards) 539-42; Private Members' Business Friesen 545-7; Reimer 547-9 Address for Papers Core Area Initiative Ill Public Health Amendment Act Alcock 4540-1 ; Dacquay 4538-40; Legal opinion (Friesen) 4535-8, 4541 -2 Ashton 2494-7; Barrett2285 -8; Crime Prevention Council Carstairs 957-8; Cerilli 3564-5; Chomiak 860-2; Connery 862-3; Dewar 3348-50; Doer2004-6 ; (Edwards) 854-7; Lamoureux 864-5; L. Evans 4533-5; Friesen 1692-5; McCrae 857-60; Orchard 865 Gilleshammer 1695-7; Economic Summit Hickes 958-61 ; Lathlin 41 88-9; (Doer)5435-7, 5440-3 ; Filmon 5443-5; Laurendeau 1692 ; Maloway 4923-4; Stefanson 5437-40 Martindale 963-4, 1690-1 ; McAlpine 1700, Education, distance 2002-3; McCrae 961 -3; Plohman 1697-1 700; Ashton 4656-9; Carstairs 4659-61 ; Reid 2n9-82; Santos 4921-3; Storie 3073-5; (Gaudry) 4653-4; Lamoureux 4662-3; (Wasylycia-Leis) 955-7; Wowchuk 3881 -4 Render 4661-2; Vodrey4654-6

154 Hansard Index

Private Members' Business - Cont. Private Members ' Business - Cont. Environmental Youth Corps Wasylycia-Leis 2008-1 0 Barrett4365-6; (McAlpine)4363-5 Selkirk School of Psychiatric Nursing Fire Safety Safari (Dewar) 2288-91 ; Orchard 2291-3; Lamoureux 2409-1 1 ; Praznik 241 1-2; Santos 2293-5 Reid 2407-9; (Render) 2404-7 Seniors' rights Governmentcontracts, issuing of Ducharme 2158-60; Lamoureux 2160-1 ; Ashton 3840; Ducharme 3841 ; (McAlpine) 2153-6; Santos 2156-8 (Lamoureux) 3837-9; Manness 3839-40 Ukraine, Independence of Grow Bonds (Helwer) 3195-6; Lamoureux 3198-9; Enns 3571 -3; (Penner) 3565-7, 3570-1 ; Neufeld 3202-3; Plohman 3196-8; Wowchuk 3567-70 Praznik 3200-2; Wowchuk 31 99-200 Housing, inner city Video lotteryterminals Upgrade Downey 2644-7; Lamoureux 2647-9; Ernst 4360-2;Lamoureux 4362; (Rose)2639-42 ; Sveinson 2649; (Martindale)4357-60 , 4362-3; Wowchuk 2642-4 Manitoba/Russiaagreement Violence, education against Alcock 3082; Ashton 3077-80; Barrett 1149-51 ; Chomiak 1153-4; Enns 3080-2; Ernst 3082-3; (Dacquay) 1147-9; Lamoureux 1151-3 (Laurendeau) 3076-7; Voters' list, permanent Medicare, five principles of (Carstairs) 2782-3; Laurendeau 2785-7; Cheema 5358-62; Orchard 5362-4; Martindale2783-5 Wasylycia-Leis 5364-6 Women, violence against Medicare, preservation of (Barrett)4027-9 ; Lamoureux 4032-6; Ashton 3728-30; Lamoureux 3727-8; McCrae 4029-32; Wowchuk 4036 Orchard 3724-6; (Wasylycia-Leis) 3721· 4 Workforce 2000 NorthAmer ican Free Trade Agreement Hickes 912-4; Lamoureux 914-5; (Alcock) 499-501 ; Lamoureux 507-9; Stefanson 502-4; Storie 504-7 (Reimer) 909-12; North American Free Trade Agreement PrivateTr aining Accountability Act (8111 23) (Hickes) 583-5; Lamoureux 588; Stefanson 585-8; Storie 588-93 1 r Carstairs 398 Open Skies Privilege, Matters of Driedger 3353-6; Lamoureux 3358; (Reid) 3350-3, 3357-8; Render 3358 Legislative Building security PTH 1 01 safety (Ashton) 4437; Ducharme 4438; Edwards 1 086-7; Connery 1 083-5; Lamoureux 4437-8; (Helwer) 1 078-81 ; Laurendeau 1 087-9; taken under advisement; Plohman 1 081 -3 Speaker's ruling 4605 Postal rate increases, rural newspapers Quorum counts Ashton 659-60; Cummings 658-9; Doer 657-8; (Lamoureux) 4565-6; Manness 4566; Downey 661 ; C. Evans 656-7; Lamoureux 657; Martindale4566; Manness 660-1 ; (Rose) 654-6 taken under advisement 4566; Reproductive health Speaker's ruling 5176 (Wasylycia-Leis) 746-7; Wellington, Member for debate suspended pending ruling on Misrepresentation of facts point of order 747-8; Carstairs 594; Barrett2010-1 ; Orchard 201 0; remarks withdrawn (Barrett) 594

155 Hansard Index

Privileges and Elections, Standing Provincial Park Lands Amendment Act Committee on (BIII 21) 1st Report 1 r Enns 171 ; 2r Edwards 851 -2; Enns 638-9; Render 4567 C. Evans 41 82; Plohman 947-51 ; Storie 2755-9 2nd Report Chomiak 5474; Render 5472-3 Provincial Pollee Amendment and ConsequentialAmend ments Act (Bill 86) Processing potato producers 1r Manness 3145; 2r Chomiak 4745-7; Edwards 4997-5000; McCrae 4173-4; referred to Marketing board Standing Committee on Law Amendments; Rndlay 3537; Plohman 3537 RIS McCrae5393; 3r Edwards 5413-4; RIA 5492

Provincial Auditor Public Accounts Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 22) Fiscal year ending March 31 , 1991 (S.P. 19, 34) Manness 286 Manness 286, 466 Rscal Stabilization Fund Doer 288; Manness 288-9 Public Accounts, Standing Committee on Manitoba Data Services 1st Report Doer 287-8; Manness 288 L. Evans 168-9 Special Audit 2nd Report Taxation Division-Departmentof Rnance L. Evans 396-7 Manness 122 Public Health Amendment Act See Priva te Members'Busi ness-Address for Provincial Auditor's Amendment Act Papers (BIII 92) 1 r Manness 3891 ; 2r Alcock 5162; Public Health Amendment Act (2) (Bill 56) L. Evans 5162-3; Manness 4171-2; 1rWasylycia-Leis 1048; C/W L. Evans 5235; RIS Manness 5308; 2r Wasylycia-Leis 2738-9 3r 5317; RIA 5492 Public health organizations Provincial deficit Funding Cheema 1259-60; Almon 1260 Clarification Alcock 687; Manness 687 Public Officers Act Increase Return under Section 20 (S.P. 21) Alcock 687; Carstairs 922 ; Manness 687, 922 Manness 286 Provincial revenues Public Schools Finance Board Additional sources Annual Report, 1991 (S.P. 108) Carstairs 622; Manness 622 Vodrey 3576 Clarification Manness 625 Public Trustee Provincial parks Annua1 Report, 1990 (S.P. 122) McCrae 4274 See Clean Environment Commission; Natural Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 123) Resources, Department of (Supply)-Resources Programs; specific parks McCrae 4274

156 Hansard Index

Public Trustee - Cont. R.D. Parker Collegiate See also Justice, Department of See Nonpolitical statements (Supply)-Protection of Individual Rights and Property Rights RCMP SeeRoyal Canadian Mounted Police Public TrusteeAmendm ent, Trustee Amendment and Child and Family Services Race relations policy Amendment Act (Bill 68) Education system 1 r McCrae 1654; 2r Chomiak 2865-7; Cerilli 1494; Mitchelson 1494 Edwards 22n-9; McCrae 2084-6;referred to Programs funding Standing Committee on Law Amendments; Cerilli 1495; Mitchelson 1495 RIS Manness 3962; 3r 5221 ; RIA 5492 Racial Discrimination, International Day for Public utilities the Elimination of Customer refunds See Nonpolitical statements Maloway 2994; Mcintosh 2994 Lock-off statistics Racism Investigations Maloway 2993; Mcintosh2993 Policing services Chomiak 2991 , 3038; Filmon 2991 , 3038 Public Utilities and Natural Resources, Standing Committeeon Radio communautalre du Manitoba 1st Report See Nonpolitical statements Penner 2790 2nd Report Rae, Don Penner 2842 See Nonpolitical statements 3rd Report Rose 3036 Rafferty-Alameda dam project 4th Report Environment, Minister of Rose 3136 Involvement 5th Report Cummings 3272-3; Edwards 3272-3 Laurendeau 41 61 Renegotiation 6th Report Cummings 3272; Edwards 3272 Penner 4499 7th Report Real PropertyAmend ment Act (Bill 7) Penner 4566-7 1 r McCrae 170; 2r Ashton 529-35; Chomiak 535-6; Lamoureux 536-7; Public Utilities Board McCrae 479-81;referred to Standing Committee Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 104) on Law Amendments; RIS Manness 3961 ; Mcintosh 31 36 3r 5221 ; RIA 5491 See also Conawapa dam project Recycling, glass Pur-A-Tone Hog Operation Cerilli 795; Cummings 795 Environmental concerns Contractaward criteria Cummings 3679; Plohman 3679 Doer 2691 ; Driedger 2691-2 See also Bi/1 82; Dauphin Lake Contractconsult ations Cerilli 2746; Cummings 2746 Quorum counts Government initiatives See Privilege, Matters of Doer 2692; Driedger 2692

157 Hansard Index

Recycling, newspaper Reid, Daryl - Cont. Cerilli 795; Cummings 795 Executive support2044-5 Health Services Recycling programs Capital Construction 321 5-7 Distributor's costs Health ServicesInsur ance Amendment Act (Bill 51) Cummings 4207; Edwards 4207 2r 4270-1 Waste oil disposal Highway Traffic Amendment Act (Bill 15) Cerilli 4349-50; Cummings 4550 2r 3872-6; 3r 5226-7 Highway Traffic Amendment Act (2) (Bill 63) Red River Community College 1r1156-7 Course start dates (T.P. 46) Highways and Transportation Department Friesen 1755 Amendment Act (Bill 14) Funding 2r 897-904 Filmon 1707; Friesen 1707 Highways and Transportation, Departmentof Nursing curriculum (Supply) Carstairs 1601 ; Vodrey 1610 Administration and Finance See also Licensed PracticalNurses Administrative Services4468 Computer Services 4470-1 Red Sucker Lake, Manitoba Minister's salary 4719 Schoolclosure Occupational Health and Safety 4473-4 Downey 4743; Harper 4742-3; Vodrey 4743 Personnel Services4468-70 Boards and Committees Regional development corporations Motor Transportation Board 4712-4 Funding Driver andVehicle Licensing Derkach 1472-3, 3582, 3851 ; Filmon 3850; Management Services4707-9 Wowchuk 1472, 3582, 3850-1 Engineering and Technical Services Government Air and Radio Services4647-8 Regulations Act Mechanical Equipment Services 4643-4 Regulation Nos. 43/91 to 246/91 (S.P. 1) NorthernAirports 4645 McCrae 12 Traffic Engineering 4646 Expenditures Related to Capital REID, Daryl (Transcona, NDP) Construction/Upgradingof Provincial Trunk City of Winnipeg Amendment Act (2) (Bill 35) Highways 3r 366-8 471 8 City of Winnipeg Amendment Act (3) (Bill 78) Opening remarks 2r 5140-1 Response 4466 City of Winnipeg Amendment, Municipal Operations and Maintenance Amendment and Consequential Amendments Bridges and Structures Act (Bi11 45) Salaries 4628-9 2r 1131-7 Maintenance Program 4474-8 Economic Innovation and TechnologyCouncil Act Operations and Contracts 4486 (Bill 9) Transport Compliance4632-6 2r 81 6-7, 833-7 Winter Roads Franchises Act (Bill 18) 1 00 percent Provincial 4482-5 2r 3632-5 Planning and Design and Land Surveys Health, Departmentof (Supply) Land Surveys 4642-3 Administration and Finance Planning and Design 4642 Evaluation and Audit Secretariat 2322-6 Transportation Policy and Research

158 Hansard Index

Reid, Daryl - Cont. Reid, Daryl - Cont. 4649-52,4700-4 Long-term benefits 292 Highways Protection and Consequential Medical advice 292 Amendments Act (Bill 79) Medical specialist reports 1 056 2r 4992-7 Public inquiry 4301 -2, 4432-3,4549 Labour Relations Amendment Act (Bill 85) Vocational rehabilitation benefits 2686-7 3r 5467-70 Petitions Ministerial statements Criminal Codeamendmen ts Portof Churchill 1155; ruled in order 1174 Rail line protection 1221 ; ruled in order 1249 Response 463 1248; ruled in order 1317 Nonpolitical statements 1316; ruled in order 3405 National Day ofMourning 2693 1415; ruled in order 1489 Yes, I Can Awards 758-9 1652; ruled in order 1701-2 Oral questions 1770; ruled in order 1910 Apprenticeshiptraining 1965; ruled in order 2012 First-aid certificate, mandatory 1714 2245; ruled in order 2296 CN Rail 2349; ruled in order 2457-8 Job relocations 51 4092; ruled in order 4160-1 Layoffs 52, 2460-1 Domestic violence Canadian Airlines International Safe shelter-Length of stay Centralization 2577 331 3; Employment creation strategy 2577-8 Fight Back Against Child Abuse campaign Reservationoffice 61 7; ruled in order (Dacquay) 684 Layoffs 2577 722; ruled in order (Dacquay) 749 Gemini Reservation System 791 ; ruled in order 818 Merger 1018 870; ruled in order 91 7 Labour, Departmentof 1108; ruled in order 1155 Apprenticeshipand Training branch Pointsof Order Staffing 1715 P/0 by A§tmmrespecting closing debate 2346-7; Portof Churchill Lamoureux 2348; Manness 2347; Reid 2347-8; Agreement tabling request 4202 taken under advisement 2348; Federal commitment 471 Speaker's ruling 4495-6 Government communications 4201 Private Members' Business Government strategy 1263 Address for Papers Grain shipments 471 , 690, 4201 Public Health Amendment Act Manitoba representation 472 Legal opinion 2779-82 Rail line protection 690 Resolutions Transportation issues Bail review provisions, changes to 3944-6 Premier's involvement 52 CN Rail jobs 1835-7 Trucking industry Fire Safety Safari 2407-9 All-partytask force 41 64 Open Skies 3350-3, 3357-8 Employment creation strategy 41 64 Tabled papers Employment protection 41 63 Apprenticeshiptraining Operating authority 3789 Correspondence (T.P. 44,45 ) 1715 Workers Compensation Board Throne speech debate Family entitlements4502 -3, 4549 188-95 Intimidation 4573-4 Urban Affairs, Departmentof (Supply)

159 Hansard Index

Reid, Daryl - Cont. Render, Shirley - Cont. Financial Assistance to the City of Winnipeg Dental Health Month 2599 4339-42 Glenlawn Collegiate Workers CompensationAmendm ent Act (2) (Bill 55) Achievements 361 -2 1r 61 8; 2r 1744-7 Girls' varsity team Render 1499 REIMER, Jack (Niakwa, PC) Partnerships in Education 1233 Budget debate Oral questions 1192-8 Indian Birch Reserve Business PracticesAmendment Act (Bill 27) Child Welfare worker ban 1055 2r 2067-9 The Diviners Economic Development, Standing Committee on Government support 4206 4th Report 2789 Private Members' Business 6th Report 31 36 Resolutions 7th Report 3643 Constitutional task force 41 95-7 8th Report 5258 Domestic violence-free zone, Manitoba 1102-6 Franchises Act (Bill 18) Education, distance 4661-2 2r 1962-4 Fire Safety Safari 2404-7 Law Amendments,Sta nding Committee on Open Skies 3358 3rd Report 4273 Privileges and Elections, Standing Committee on 6th Report 5322-5 1st Report4567 Manitoba Advisory Council on the Status of Women 2nd Report 5472-3 Amendment Act (Bill 5) Throne speech debate 2r 567-70 232-6 Nonpolitical statements University of Manitoba Amendment Act (Bill 25) Earth Day 2467-8 2r2561 -3 Manitoba commemorative coin 1920-1 Urgent Public Importance, Matter of New Years' celebrations 21 10-1 Economic crisis 442-3 Points of Order P/0 by � respecting words "false information" Rent Regulation Bureau (Orchard) 31 06; Director'sstatu s Members cautioned (Reimer) 31 06 Martindale2879; Mcintosh 2879-80 Private Bills, Standing Committeeon Report on the Administration, 1991 (S.P. 117) 1st Report 3314 Mcintosh 41 61 2nd Report4094-5 Private Members' Business Rent regulations Resolutions Enforcement Accreditation, Professional and Technical Cheema 1659; Mcintosh 1659 2499-2502 Legal opinion request Core Area Initiative renewal 547-9 Cheema 1659; Mcintosh 1659 Workforce 2000 909-12 Rollbacks Throne speech debate Martindale 827, 875-6, 976-7; 38-43 Mcintosh 827,876, 977

RENDER, Shirley (St. VItal, PC) Repap Manitoba Inc. Industrial Relations, Standing Committee on Aboriginal land claims 1 st Report 5329-32 Doer 750-1 ; Manness 751 Nonpolitical statements Benefits to Manitoba

160 Hansard Index

Repap Manitoba Inc. - Cont. Residential Tenancies Amendment Act (2) Carstairs 752-3; Manness 753 (8111 84) Bunker tank relocation 1 r Mcintosh 3672; 2r Cheema 4751 ; Carstairs 794; Cummings 794-5 Lamoureux 4581 -5; Martindale4580-1 ; Contractual obligations Mcintosh41 75-6; referred to Standing Filmon 267; Wowchuk 267 Committee on Economic Development; Cutting area R/S Mcintosh 5308; 3r 5317; RIA5492 Doer 751 ; Manness 751 , 825; Wowchuk 825 Employment creation strategy Resignations Ashton 754-5; Carstairs 757, 1 017; Filmon 267; Carr, James Gordon {Crescentwood) (T.P. 9) Lathlin 752; Manness 752, 754-5, 757, 1017-8; Rocan 397 Wowchuk 266-7 Connery, Edward James {Portage Ia Prairie) Employment protection (T.P. 199) Lathlin 752; Manness 752 Rocan 5401 Employment statistics Doer 122-3; Filmon 123 Resolutions Environmental assessment Domestic violence-free zone, Manitoba Filmon 267; Wowchuk 267 Barrett 1071-7, 3878; Carstairs 1068-71 ; Environmental inspection Cerilli 1106-7, 3878; Gilleshammer 3878-80; Carstairs 794; Cummings 794 Lamoureux 1097-1 102, 2281 -5, 3877-8; Expenditures Lathlin 1093-7; {McCrae) 1058-68; Carstairs 756; Manness 756 Mitchelson 1 077-8, 1 090-3; Render 1102-6 Financial status Riel, Louis Carstairs 1016-7; Manness 1017 Role in development of Manitoba Globe andMail article (T.P. 24) Carstairs 3654-6; Cheema 3667; Carstairs 1017 {Downey) 3652-4; Ducharme 3661 ; Renegotiations Enns 3656-8; Friesen 3658-61; Carstairs 753-4; Doer 750; Lathlin 3045; Gaudry 3661 -4; Martindale3667 -8; Manness 750, 753-4, 3045 Mcintosh 3666-7; Praznik 3668-9; Statement of claim-Oueen's Bench (T.P. 20) Storie 3664-6 Carstairs 794 See also Priva te Members ' Business Swan River area Manness 2580-1 ; Wowchuk 2580-1 Restraining orders Technological change Departmental co-ordination Doer 123; Filmon 123-4 Carstairs 2353; McCrae 2353 Treaty land entitlements See also Child day care centres Lathlin 1113; Manness 1113 Woodlands division Job security Retail sales tax Ashton 1327-8; Manness 1328 Statistics Alcock 3789; Manness 3789 Reproductive health See Priva te Members'Busi ness-Resolutions Retail trade sector Employment statistics Residential Tenancies Amendment Act L. Evans 131; Manness 131 (8111 65) Sales decline 1r Martindale 2193; L. Evans 1497-8; Manness 1497-8

161 Hansard Index

Retsil trade sector - Cont. Rocan, Hon. Denis - Cont. Sales information, Statistics Canada (T.P. 195) Angus McKay School, Grade 5 Alcock 5265 (Elmwood) 262 Statisticsdiscrepancy Arborg Collegiate, Grade 9 Alcock 5265-6; Manness 5265-6; (Interlake) 171 Stefanson 5265 Archwood School, Grade 6 Sunday shopping (St. Boniface) 2350 Ashton 3852-3; Filmon 3853 Atlantic High School Band See also Economic growth (Iowa) 5167 Baizley, Obie Retirement Plan Beneficiaries Act (Bill 71) Former MLA (Osborne) 2301 1 r McCrae 1654;2r Chomiak 3963-5; Banman, Bob Lamoureux 4745; Manness 3145-6; referred Former MLA(La Verendrye) 3371 to Standing Committee on Law Amendments; Bayne, Nicholas R!S Manness 5307-8; 3r 5316; RIA 5492 High Commissioner of Great Britain 4543 Bemidji State University students 2741 Riel, Louis BernieWolfe School, Grades 5-6 (Radisson) 41 62 Draft resolution (T.P. 26) Bertram E. Glavin School, Grades 5-6 Dewar 1117 (Concordia) 4569 See also Nonpolitical statements; Resolutions Blake, Dave Roblin, Senator Duff Former MLA (Minnedosa) 3872 Brown, Arnold See Nonpolitical statements Former MLA (Rhineland) 1165, 3844 ROCAN, Hon. Denis (Gladstone, PC) Calvin Christian School, Grade 9 (River East) 132 Chief Electoral Officer Canadian Forces Language School Statutory Report, 1990 (S.P. 130) 5260 (Sturgeon Creek) 4162 Commonwealth Day message Carter, David 1041 Speaker (Alberta Legislative Assembly) 4095 Elections Finances Act Century High School Patriot Jazz Ensemble Annua1 Report, 1990 (S.P. 32) 397 Bismarck, North Dakota 596 Freedom of Information Act Crestview School, Grade 5 Annua1 Report, 1990 (S.P. 63) 1156 (Assiniboia) 1490, 1605 House Business DakotaColle giate Pages 11 Japanese exchange students 2249 Votes and Proceedings Darwin School, Grade 9 Printing/perusal 11 (Riel) 353 Introductionof Guests Driedger, Herold 4-H Ambassadors' Program Former MLA (Niakwa) 296 3672 Ecole Glenwood, Grade 6 Acadia Junior High School, Grade 9 (St. Vital) 4596 (St. Norbert) 551 , 2985 Elmwood High School, English Language Adult ESL Winnipeg School Division No. 1 Students 1157 (Concordia) 1754 Allon, EIIiana Elmwood High School, Grade 9 Energy of our Resources calendar (Concordia) 1320 Manitoba artist468 Elmwood High School, Grade 12

162 Hansard Index

Rocan, Hon. Denis - Cont. Rocan, Hon. Denis - Cont. (Concordia) 4162 John Pritchard School, Grade 9 Elwick Community School, Grade 5 (River East) 3164 (The Maples) 596 Joseph Wolinsky School, Grade 12 Fall, Sir Brian (St. Johns) 2684 High Commissioner of Great Britain 468 Kildonan East Regional Secondary School Garden City Collegiate, Grade 9 Grades 11-12 (Concordia)220 (Kildonan) 2249, 2458 Kilian, Andre Garden City Collegiate, Grade 11 Ambassador of the Republic of South Africa (Kildonan) 2985 3529 Garden Grove School, Grade 5 Kirkness Adult Learning Centre (Inkster) 4499 (Broadway) 2589, 3529, 51 08 George McDowell School, Grade 9 Klassen, John (Seine River) 514 Honourary Consul of Austria 3981 Gnadenthal School, Grades 1-8 Kleefeld School,Gr ade 8 (Emerson) 3363 (Steinbach) 3951 Grandview School, Grades 11-12 Kleefeld School, Grades 5-9 (Dauphin) 3891 -2 (Steinbach) 4095 Grant Park High School, Grade 9 Lakehead Separate School Board Band (Crescentwood) 220, 1605, 21 02 Thunder Bay, Ontario 3981 Green, Sid Landmark School, Grade 5 Former MLA (Inkster) 5410 (La Verendrye) 3084 Greenway School, Grade 5 Leaf Rapids Education Centre, Grade 8 (St. James) 49 (Ain Aon) 4095 Gross Isle School, Grade 6 Linden Meadows School, Grade 9 (Lakeside) 1108-9 (Tuxedo) 287 H.S. Paul School, Grade 9 Mahugu, Njuguna (Seine River) 3981 High commissioner of Kenya to Canada 1966 Harapiak, Harry Mandrake, Ed Former MLA(The Pas) 299 Former MLA (Assiniboia) 2350 Harapiak, Leonard Manitoba Association for Schooling at Home 171 Former MLA (Swan River) 299 Manitoba Government Employees'Association Hedges Junior High School, Grades 8-9 Women's Committee2572 (Assiniboia) 1490 Maples Collegiate Herndl, Dr. Kurt (Maples) 1175 Ambassador of Austria to Canada 3981 Margaret Park School, Grades 4-5 Heyes School, Grade 6 (Kildonan) 2790 (Swan River) 4569 Mary PorterScho ol, Grade 5 Immaculate Heart of Mary, Grade 5 (Rupertsland)3643 (Burrows) 4298 Maxwell, Colin Johnston, J. Frank Canadian Wildlife Federation 1966 Former MLA (Sturgeon Creek) 1165 Metis Senate, membersof 3265-6 James Nisbet School, Grade 5 Miami Elementary School, Grades 5-6 (Maples) 3164 (Morris) 468 Jefferson Junior High School, Grades 7-8 Minenko, Mark (Kildonan) 5262 Former MLA (Seven Oaks) 1232 John De Graff, Grades 5-6 Morden Collegiate, Grade 9 (Rossmere)2846 (Pembina) 4428

163 Hansard Index

Rocan, Hon. Denis - Cont. Rocan, Hon. Denis - Cont. Morden Collegiate, Grade 11 (Interlake) 4200 (Pembina) 4298 Riverview School, Grade 5 Mount Manitoba climbing team 2790 (Osborne) 4543 Murphy, Rod Robert H. Smith School, Grade 5 MP (Churchill) 15 (Selkirk) Native Business Management Skills Program Rocan 4298 (Wellington) 1966 Robert H. SmithSchool , Grades 5-6 Nellie McClung Collegiate, Grade 11 (Selkirk) 3844 (Pembina) 3576 Roseau Valley School, Grades 9 and 11 Notre Dame de Lourdes, Grade 6 (Emerson) 399 St. Basil, Portneuf, Quebec41 55 Rosenort School, Grade 9 Oakenwald School, Grade 5 (Morris) 3844 (Fort Garry) 1416 Rossburn Elementary School,Grade 8 Park La Salle School, Grade 5 (Roblin-Russell) 4877 (St. Norbert) 3410 Royal School, Grade 5 Parkdale School, Grades 5-6 (Tuxedo) 2741 (Ain Aon) 41 62 St. Andrews Society of Winnipeg 1771 Onanole Elementary School, Grades 5-6 St. George School, Grade 9 (Minnedosa) 4569 (St. Vital) 49, 171 Paradis, Judy St. Gerard School. Grade 5 AIPLF Conference delegate (Maine) 3084 (Concordia) 41 62 Pawley, Howard St. John's-Ravenscourt, Grade 9 Former Premier (Manitoba) 596 (FortGarry) 969, 3672 Perry, Tom Ste . Anne School Minister of Advanced Education, Training (La Verendrye) 1464 and Technology (BritishColum bia) 5476 Sargent Park School, Grade 9 Provencher School, Grade 9 (Wellington) 1366 (St. Boniface) 2790 Sandy Bay School, Grade 9 Queen Elizabeth School, Grades 8-9 (Ste. Rose) 514 (St. Boniface) 2075 Shott, Kevin R.B. Russell Vocational School, Grade 12 RCMP constable 3981 (Point Douglas) 171 Searle, Newell Ralph Maybank School, Grade 5 Department of Agriculture(Minn esota) 1108 (Fort Garry) 2193 Silver Heights Collegiate Red River Community College Reach for the Top winners English Language Students(Point Douglas) (Sturgeon Creek) 3363 3137 Silver Heights Collegiate Journalism st udents 3266, 341 0 Student Council Richfield High School Choir (Sturgeon Creek) 2985 (Minnesota) 1048 Sisler High School River HeightsSchool , Grade 9 English Language Students 3266 (Brandon West) 4735 Souris Elementary School, Grade 5 River West Park School, Grade 9 (Turtle Mountain) 4543 (Charleswood)219 3 Southwood Elementary School, Grades 7-8 Riverside School, Grades 7-9 (Pembina) 51 08 (La Verendrye) 870 Southwood School, Grade 5 Riverton School, Grades 4-5 (Steinbach) 4499

164 Hansard Index

Rocsn, Hon. Denis - Cont. Rocsn, Hon. Denis - Cont. Stewart, Fred Harper 3162; ruled in order 3264-5 Minister of Technology, Telecommunications Harper 3978; ruled in order 4093-4 and Research (Alberta) 5476 Hickes 1770; ruled in order 1910-1 Sun Valley Elementary School, Grade 5 Hickes21 92; ruled in order 2246 (River East) 2572 Lathlin 91 7; ruled in order 1108 Teulon Collegiate, Grade 9 Lathlin 1155; ruled in order 1248 (Gimli) 2301 Lathlin 1248; ruled in order 1317 Teulon Collegiate, Grade 11 Lathlin1316 ; ruled in order 1965 (Gimli) 262 Lathlin 2296; ruled in order 2588 Teulon Elementary School, Grade 4 Lath lin 41 60; ruled in order 4199 (Gimli) 2013 Lathlin 41 98; ruled in order 4426 Treheme School, Grade 7 Lathlin 4426; ruled in order 4498 (Gladstone) 3643 Brandon General Hospital Tyndall Park School, Grade 4 L. Evans 2684; ruled in order 2740 (Inkster) 4982 L. Evans 2789; ruled in order 2869 University of Manitoba, Student Parliament L. Evans 2868; ruled in order2984-5 (FortGarry) 51 08 L. Evans 3360; ruled In order 3405 University of Winnipeg, Enrichment program L. Evans 3785; ruled in order 3842 (Wolseley) 3084 L. Evans 3842;ruled in order 3891 University of Winnipeg, Sociology students L. Evans 3891 ; ruled in order 3950 (Wolseley) 1175 L. Evans 3950; ruled in order 3978 Victor Wyatt School, Grade 4 L. Evans 3978; ruled in order 4093 (Seine River) 1366 L. Evans 4198; ruled in order 4297 Villeneuve, Noble L. Evans 4297; ruled in order 4497 MPP (Stormont, Dunas, Glengarry) 3137 L. Evans 4497; ruled in order 5107 Viscount Alexander School, Grade 9 L. Evans51 07; ruled in order 5167 (Fort Garry) 2458, 2505, 2740-1 Children's Advocate Voyageur '92 students 4162, 4543 Carstairs2684; ruled in order 2789 W.B. Lewis School, Grade 5 Carstairs 2789; ruled in order 2841 (Lac du Bonnet) 15 Carstairs 2841 ; ruled in order 2868 Warren Collegiate, Grade 11 Carstairs 2984; ruled in order 3035 (Lakeside) 3529 Carstairs3264; ruledin order 3313 West Branch High School Band Carstairs 3313; ruled in order 3360 (Iowa) 3036 Carstairs 3529; ruled in order 3574 Winkler Elementary School, Grade 5 Carstairs 3842;ruled in order 3950-1 (Pembina) 4596 Carstairs 41 60; ruled in order 4198 Ombudsman Carstairs 4272; ruled in order 4297-8 Annua1 Report, 1990 (S.P. 58) Carstairs 4297; ruled in order 4426-7 Rocan 819 Carstairs 4426; ruled in order 4497 Petitions Criminal Code amendments Abinochi Preschool Program Barrett 1489; ruled in order 1652 Friesen 1701 ; ruled in order 1753 Cerilli 1248; ruled in order 1317 Hickes 1701 ; ruled in order 1753 Cerilli 1365; ruled in order 1416 Lathlin 1965; ruled in order 2245 Cerilli 1770; ruled in order 1909 Aboriginal Justice System Cerilli 1965; ruled in order 2012-3 Ashton 1174; ruled in order 1316 Cerilli 2349; ruled in order 2457 Harper 1415; ruled in order 1604 Chomiak 1221 ; ruled in order 1249

165 Hansard Index

Rocsn, Hon. Danis - Cont. Rocsn, Hon. Denis - Cont. Chomiak 1316; ruled in order 1366 Barrett 1316; ruled in order 1365 Chomiak 1701 ; ruled in order 1752 Barrett 1365; ruled in order 1415 Dewar 1248; ruled in order 1365 Barrett16 04; ruled in order 1653 C. Evans 1221 ; ruled in order 1249 Barrett 1701 ; ruled in order 1752 Friesen 1909; ruled in order 1965-6 Barrett 1770; ruled in order 1909-1 0 Martindale 1909; ruled in order20 12 Barrett20 12; ruled in order 2101 Reid 1155; ruled in order 1174 Barrett21 92; ruled in order 2245 Reid 1221 ; ruled in order 1249 Barrett 2868; ruled in order 2984 Reid 1248;ruled in order 1317 Barrett 3162; ruled in order 3265 Reid 1316; ruled in order 1366 Barrett331 3; ruled in order 3360 Reid 1415; ruled in order 1489 Barrett 3842; ruled in order 3891 Reid 1652; ruled in order 1701-2 Barrett 3950; ruled in order 3978 Reid 1770; ruled in order 1910 Barrett41 60; ruled in order 41 99 Reid 1965; ruled in order 2012 Cerilli 1108; ruled in order 1156 Reid 2245; ruled in order 2296 Cerilli 1604; ruled in order 1653 Reid 2349; ruled in order 2457-8 Chomiak 462; ruled in order 510 Reid 4092; ruled in order41 60-1 Chomiak 551 ; ruled in order 595 Santos 1770; ruled in order 1910 Chomiak 594; ruled in order (Dacquay) 617 Wasylycia-Leis 2012; ruled in order 2074 Chomiak 791 ; ruled in order 81 8 Wasylycia-Leis 2101 ; ruled in order 21 92 Chomiak 870; ruled in order 91 7 Domestic violence Chomiak 91 7; ruled in order 965 Safe shelter-length of stay Chomiak 1013; ruled in order 1042 Reid 3313; Dewar 1108; ruled in order 1156 Dutch elm disease program funding Dewar 1415; ruled in order 1489 Carstairs 791 ; ruled in order 81 9 Dewar 1652; ruled in order 1702 Cerilli 2192; ruled in order 2296 Friesen 1489; ruled in order 1652-3 Friesen 791 ; ruled in order 81 9 Hickes 1365; ruled in order 1415 Friesen 207 4; ruled in order 2192-3 Hickes 1652; ruled in order 1701 Friesen 2349; ruled in order 2457 Martindale 1108; ruled in order 1156 Friesen 2457; ruledin order 2505 Martindale2074 ; ruled in order 21 02 Friesen 2571 ; ruled in order 2589 Reid 791 ; ruled in order 81 8 Friesen 2868; ruled in order 2984 Reid 870; ruled in order 917 Friesen 3842; ruled in order 41 61 Reid 1108; ruled in order 1155 Friesen 4160; ruled in order 4198-9 Santos 1701 ; ruled in order 1753 Friesen 4272; ruled in order 4298 Santos 2012; ruled in order 2074 Friesen 4426; ruled in order 4498-9 Storie 1652; ruled in order 1702 Friesen 4566; ruled in order 4594 Wasylycia-Leis 462; ruled in order 51 0 Friesen 4735; ruled in order 4877 Wasylycia-Leis 551 ; ruled in order 595 Fight Back Against Child Abuse campaign Wasylycia-Leis 595; ruled in order (Dacquay) Ashton 1701 ; ruled in order 1909 61 7-8 Barrett462; ruled in order 510 Wasylycia-Leis 1464;ruled in order 1490 Barrett 551 ; ruled in order 595 Foreign DomesticWorkers' Program Barrett 594; ruled in order (Dacquay) 61 7 Lamoureux 1752; ruled in order 1770 Barrett 791 ; ruled in order 81 8 Housing authorities Barrett870; ruled in order 965 Volunteer boards Barrett 101 3; ruled in order 1041-2 C. Evans 1909; ruled in order 2101 Barrett 1108; ruled in order 1155 Wowchuk 1155; ruled in order 1174

166 Hansard Index

Rocan, Hon. Denis - Cont. Rocan, Hon. Denis - Cont. Wowchuk 1604; ruled in order 1653 Members cautioned 59 Wowchuk 1701 ; ruled in order 1770 P/0 by 8§blQn respecting dealing with matter Wowchuk 2074; ruled in order 2101-2 raised 223; Lamoureux 223; Praznik 223; Human Resources OpportunityCentre Me01berscautioned 223 Moratorium on closure P/0 by Mb1Qnrespecting brevity ofquestions Dewar 2192;ruled in order 2245-6 and answers 270; Dewar 2296; ruled in order 2505 Members cautioned270 Dewar 2505; ruled in order 2571 P/0 by Mb1Qnrespecti ng brevity of questions Dewar 2571 ; ruled in order 2588 and answers 290; Dewar 2588; ruled in order 2684 Members cautioned 290 Dewar 2684; ruled in order 2740 P/0 by Mbm.nrespecting unparliamentary Dewar 2789; ruled in order 2841-2 language (McCrae) 333; Dewar 2841 ; ruled in order 2868-9 withdrawn 333 Dewar 2984; ruled in order 3035 P/0 by Ashton respecting words "Reverend Dewar 3035; ruled in order 3084 Blackjack from Burrows" (Connery) 452; Dewar 3162; ruled in order 3264 withdrawn 452 Dewar 3785; ruled in order 3842-3 P/0 by A§b!2orespecting Chair's assumption Dewar 3950; ruled in order 4094 Member had risen on a pointof order531 ; Manitoba Heritage Federation taken under advisement (Dacquay) 531 ; Granting authority ruled in order 827 Lamoureux 3264; ruled out of order 3313-4 P/0 by MlJ!Qnrespecti ng word "honesty" 1181 ; Lamoureux 3313; ruled in order 3574 Members cautioned 1181 Lamoureux 3360; ruled in order 3670 P/0 by &tmmrespecting relevancy of Lamoureux 3405; ruled in order 41 60 debate (Almon) 1466; Lamoureux 3643; ruled in order 4497-8 Member cautioned 1466 Rotary Pines Project P/0 by &tmm respecting word "coward" Funding withdrawal (Orchard) 1467; Martindale 12; ruled in order 48 withdrawn 1467 Martindale 48; withdrawn 122 P/0 by M.blQn respecting brevity ofquestions Salvation Army Grace General Hospital and answers 1708; McAlpine 122; ruled in order 168 Members cautioned 1708 Seven Oaks General Hospital P/0 by &btQnrespecting words "I am going to Helwer 3313; ruled in order 341 8-9 recommend rabies shots" (Orchard) 1775; The Pas Health Complex Manness177 5; ruled out of order 1775; Lathlin 396; ruled in order 462 Members cautioned 1775 Winnipeg Bible College and Theological P/0 by &m1Qore specting closing debate 2346-7; Seminary Incorporation Act Lamoureux 2348; Manness 2347; Reid 2347-8; Penner 3990; ruled in order 4093 takenunder advisement 2348; Points ofOrder Speaker's ruling 4495-6 P/0 by � respecting brevity of questions P/0 by &IJlQn respecting words "space cadet" and answers 51 ; (Filmon) 2460; Members cautioned 51 ruled out of order 2460; P/0 by Mb1Qnrespec ting dealing with matter Members cautioned2460 raised 51 ; P/0 by A§b!2orespecting imputation of motives Members cautioned 51 (Filmon) 3038; Manness 3039; P/0 by Mb!Qnrespecting dealing with matter taken under advisement 3039; raised 59; ruled out of order 4436;

167 Hansard Index

Rocsn, Hon. Denis - Cont. Rocsn, Hon. Denis - Cont. Members cautioned 4436 P/0 by Manness respecting imputation of motives P/0 by � respecting words wan obligation (Cheema) 1260; Ashton 1260-1 ; to tell the truthw (Orchard) 3089; Lamoureux 1260; ruled out oforder 3089 ruled out of order 1261 P/0 by MIJlQn respecting brevity of questions P/0 by Mannessrespecti ng preambles to Oral and answers 3323; Questions (Cerilli) 2463; Members cautioned 3323 Members cautioned2463 P/0 by A§blQn respecting brevity of questions and P/0 by Manness respecting more than one person answers 4433; from a party speaking on Matter of Urgent Members cautioned 4433 Public Importance 2585; P/0 by Carstajrs respecting past precedent 2585; taken under advisement 2585; taken under advisement 2585; Speaker's ruling 2882 Speaker's ruling 2882 P/0 by &mom:respecting comments in regards P/0 by 02tirespecti ng words wmy honourable to Dutch elm disease 839; friend for Burrows has a learning disabilityw taken under advisement (Sveinson) 839; (Ernst) 4578; ruled out of order 978 ruled out of order 4578 P/0 by .Er5wlik respecting supplementary P/0 by Manness respecting previously asked questions 269; Ashton 269; questions 2992; Alcock2992 ; Ashton 2992; ruled out of order 269 ruled out of order 2992 P/0 by � respecting sub-judice P/0 by Manness respecting question anticipating convention 747; L. Evans 747; debate (Carstairs) 3043; Ashton 3043-4; Lamoureux 747-8; question rephrased 3044 taken under advisement (Dacquay) 748; P/0 by Connery respecting words wwe are having Speaker's ruling 2007-8 biased chairing in this House" 1993; P/0 by friwl.ikrespecting relevancy of taken under advisement (Dacquay) 1993; debate 4526; ruled out of order 2514 Members cautioned 4526 P/0 by QQ§rrespecti ng word wcroniesft P/0 by .8QQm}respec ting words wat least be (Filmon) 1479; honest" (Cheema) 23; Members cautioned 1479 withdrawal requested 23 P/0 by Laurendeau respecting words wPremier P/0 by Storje respectingwords walways such Moonbeamw (Maloway) 884; a phont (Filmon) 1225; withdrawn 884 ruled out oforder 1225 P/0 by Laurendeau respecting dress code 3540; Privilege, Matters of ruled out of order 3540 Legislative Building security P/0 by Manness respecting supplementary (Ashton) 4437;Ducharme 4438; questions12 5; Carstairs 125; Martindale 125; Lamoureux 4437-8; Members cautioned 125 taken under advisement; P/0 by Manness respecting supplementary Speaker's ruling 4605 questions 405; Quorum counts Members cautioned 405 (Lamoureux) 4565-6; Manness 4566; P/0 by Manness respecting words "master of Martindale 4566; obfuscationw (Wasylycia-Leis) 877; taken under advisement 4566; withdrawn 877 Speaker's ruling 51 76 P/0 by Manness respecting withdrawal being Wellington, Member for conditional (Storie) 1225; Doer 1225; Misrepresentation of facts ruled out of order 1225 Carstairs 594;

168 Hansard Index

Rocsn, Hon. D•nls - Cont. Ros•, Bob - Cont. remarks withdrawn (Barrett) 594 Natural Resources, Departmentof Resignations Fisheries branc�randon Carr, James Gordon Closure 4575-6 (Crescentwood) (T.P. 9) 397 PR.340 grading Connery, Edward James Project completion 3852 (Portage Ia Prairie) (T.P. 199) 5401 Points ofOrder Speaker's statements P/0 by Mitchelson respecting line of questioning Christmas message 395 (Supply) 4681 ; Filmon 4682-3; Lamoureux Manitoba Legislative Internship Program 122 4681 -3; Praznik 4682; Urgent Public Importance, Matters of ruledin order (Rose) 4682-3 Domestic violence P/0 by Wasylycia-lejs respecting word "fabricate" Speaker's ruling 29; (Orchard) 2033; Economic crisis withdrawal requested (Rose) 2933; Speaker's ruling 2884; withdrawn (Orchard) 2033 challenged 2884; Private Members' Business sustained 2885 Resolutions Goods and services tax Postal rate increase, rural newspapers 654-6 Harmonization Video lottery terminals 2639-42 Speaker's ruling 409-1 0 Public Utilities and Natural Resources, Manitoba Heritage Federation Standing Committeeon Granting authority 3rd Report3036 Speaker's ruling 2585 4th Report 31 36 Rural Development, Minister of Throne speech debate School board interference 283-5, 302-5 Speaker's ruling 4554; challenged 4554; RotaryPines Project sustained 4555 Funding reallocation Emst 126; Martindale 126 ROSE, Bob (Turtle Mountain, PC) See also Petitions Agriculture, Standing Committee on 1st Report4272-3 Royal Canadian MountedPollee Budget debate Confiscated liquor disposal 1289-93 Mcintosh 798; Storie 798 Decentralization (Supply) Falcon Beach detachment Decentralization 4795 Carstairs 2357; McCrae 2357 Economic Development, Standing Committee on Municipal costs 1 st Report 791 Ashton 2357; Downey 2357 2nd Report2349 Shooting 3rd Report2458 Independent investigation 5th Report2842 Chomiak 3039; Filmon 3039 Municipal Affairs, Standing Committee on Uniform 5th Report5388-9 1 Government position Municipal Amendment Act (Bill 31) Carstairs 1568; Filmon 1468 2r 2566-8 Oral questions Rural Development, Department of Faith Community Baptist Church Annum Report, 1991 (S.P. 95) Building relocation 3852 Derkach 2740

169 Hansard Index

Rural Development- Cont. Rural Development (Supply) - Cont. Restructuring Wowchuk 3491 -3 Johnson 4 Partners with Youth Supplementary information Derkach 3496; Gaudry 3496 1992-3 Estimates Rural Economic Development Initiatives Derkach 2740 Derkach 3494-5; Wowchuk 3494-5 Municipal Board Rural Development, Department Derkach 3448-9;Wowc huk 3448-9 of (Supply) Opening remarks Administration and Finance Derkach 3423-8 Brandon Office Response Connery 3447; Derkach 3445; Gaudry 3446; Gaudry 3443-4;Wo wchuk 3428-9, 3441 -3 Wowchuk 3445-6 Provincial Planning Executive support Derkach 3449-50,346 2-6; Gaudry 3463-6; Other expenditures Wowchuk 3449-50, 3462-5 Derkach 3444;Gaudry 3444 Rural Economic Development Division Salaries Community Development Derkach 3444;Wowc huk 3444 Other expenditures Finance and Administrative Services Derkach 3491 ; Gaudry 3491 Derkach 3448; Wowchuk 3448 Salaries Human Resource Management Derkach 3490; Gaudry 3490; Derkach 3447;Wowc huk 3447 Wowchuk 3490 Expenditures Related to Capital Economic Development Services Downtown Revitalization Grants Derkach 3491 ; Gaudry 3491 Connery 3488-9; Derkach 3488-9; Drought Proofing Gaudry 3488 Derkach 3491 ; Gaudry 3491 Salaries Local Government Services Division Connery 3482-8;Derkach 3481 -8; Executive Administration Gaudry 3481, 3488; Wowchuk 3482 Derkach 3466-72; Gaudry 3472; Executive Administration Wowchuk 3466-72 Municipal Advisory and Financial Services Derkach 3480; Gaudry 3480 Grants to Municipalities in Lieu of Taxes Infrastructure Derkach 3475; Gaudry 3475; Connery 3480-1 ; Derkach 3480-1 ; Wowchuk 3475 Wowchuk 3481 Police ServicesGrants Rural Development, Minister of Derkach 3477; Gaudry 3478; Wowchuk 3478 Schoolboard interference Research and Systems Carstairs 4546-8; Derkach 4545, 4547-8; Derkach 3479-80; Gaudry3479-80 Filmon 4546-8; Wowchuk 4545-6 Salaries School division interference Derkach 3473-5; Wowchuk 3473-5 Correspondence(T. P. 175) Transit Grants Filmon 4547 Derkach 3476-7; Gaudry 3476; See also Grievance, Matters of; Urgent Public Wowchuk 3476-7 Importance, Matters of Lotteries Funded Programs Grow Bonds Program Rural Economic Development Initiative Derkach 3492-4; Gaudry3494; See Ministerial statements

170 Hansard Index

Russell,Manit oba Salvation Army Grace General Hospital Dissolution Incorporation Amendment Act (Bill 39) Derkach 5175-6; Gaudry 51 75 1 r McAlpine; 2r Ashton 1641-4; Plebiscite Barrett 1961 ; Lamoureux 1644-5; Derkach 5176; Gaudry 51 76 McAlpine 1641 ; Orchard 1645-6; referred to Standing Committee on Private Bills 3831 ; SAFER program R!SMcAlpine 3831 ; 3r Ashton 3831 ; Eligibility statistics Lamoureux 3831-2; McAlpine 3832; RIA5491 Ernst 4578; Martindale 4578 Public awareness Saint Patrick's Day Ernst 4578, 4881 ; Martindale 4578, 4881 See Nonpolitical statements

SARC report SANTOS, Conrad (Broadway, NDP) Recommendations Bee-Keepers Repeal Act (Bill 11) Gilleshammer 3675; Martindale3675 2r 847-8 Budget debate STEP program 1426-31 See Student Temporary Employment Program City of Winnipeg Amendment, Municipal Amendment and Consequential Amendments St. Boniface Hospital Act (Bill 45) Bed closures 2r 2088-92 Cheema 4280; Orchard 3086-7, 4280, 4304; Labour Relations Amendment Act (Bill 85) Wasylycia-Leis 3086, 4304 2r 501 8-23 School of Licensed Practical Nurses Law Reform (Miscellaneous Amendments) Act Cheema 3851 ; Orchard 822, 2745, 3851 ; (Bill 72) Wasylycia-Leis 822, 2745 2r 3335-40 Manitoba Multiculturalism Act (Bill 98) St. Boniface School Division 3r 5434, 5446-7 Admission policy (T.P. 8) Ministerial statements Harper 357 Seniors' Month Response 5402 St. James Seniors' Group Nonpolitical statements Governmentassistance Matas, David Ducharme 1159; Edwards 1159 Canadian Council for Refugees 295-6 Philippine Heritage Week 4308 St. John's Ambulance Seniors Month 3991 Funding Oral questions Orchard 2881-2; Wasylycia-Leis 2881 55 Plus program Funding restoration 1258, 171 1 St. VItal School Division Indexing 3989 Funding formula Canada Pension Plan Chomiak 792-3; Vodrey 793 Benefit increase 171 1 Home care program Safe Driving Week, National Accessibility 1762 See Nonpolitical statements Immigrant credentials Working group 360 Salvation Army Grace General Hospital Manitoba Blue Cross See Petitions Percentage increase 4170

171 Hansard Index

Ssntos, Conrsd - Cont. School division boundsryrevi ew - Cont. Manitoba Tax Assistance Office Commitment Funding restoration 1711 Carstairs 2592-3; Vodrey2593 Pharmacare Correspondence(T.P. 65) Calcium supplements 5409 Vodrey2637 Pharmaceutical costs Impact Francophone Schools Governance Impact on seniors 3371 , 3988-9 Carstairs 1370; Vodrey 1370 Piney Area Seniors' Group Co-ordinator 1 159-60 School divisions Seniors programs Annual Division Action Plan (T.P. 81) Funding 1258 Governmentcomm itment 1160, 1258 Vodrey 3033 Petitions Electionpostpo nement Criminal Code amendments Chomiak 600; Vodrey 600 1770; ruled in order 1910 French language division Fight Back Against Child Abuse campaign Chomiak 600; Vodrey600 1701 ; ruled in order 1753 Funding formula 2012; ruled in order 2074 Carstairs 1164-5; Vodrey 1 164-5 Private Members' Business Information delivery Address for Papers Carstairs 3675-6; Vodrey 3675-6 Public Health Amendment Act See also specific divisons Legal opinion 4921-3 Resolutions Schools, Independent Accreditation, Professional and Technical Agreement tabling request 2497-9, 2502-3 Chomiak 1422; Vodrey 1422 Selkirk Psychiatric School of Nursing Correspondence(T.P. 30) 2291-3 Chomiak 1422 Seniors' day 2156-8 Funding (T.P. 70) Social Allowances Amendment and Consequential Vodrey 2823 Amendments Act (Bill 70) Funding formula 2r4766-74 Chomiak 1112, 1422, 1469-70, 1760; Throne speech debate Vodrey 1112, 1422-3, 1470, 1760 236-41 List of registered schools(T.P. 99) University of Manitoba AmendmentAct (Bill 25) Vodrey 3304 2r 784-6 Urgent Public Importance, Matter of See also specific schools Economic crisis 458-9 Workers Compensation Amendment Act (2) (Bill 55) Schools, public 2r 1747-9 Enrollment decline Chomiak 2021 ; Vodrey 2021 School boards See a/so specific schools Political interference Filmon 4501 ; Vodrey4501 ; Wowchuk 4501 Seafood Enterprises Association School division boundaryreview Agreement Cancellation Connery 757; Stefanson 757, 1157-8; Carstairs 1369-70; Filmon 1369-70 Storie 1157

172 Hansard Index

Selkirk Mental Health Centre Seven Oaks General Hospital Forensic unit Operating budget Dewar 294,558-9; Orchard 294,558-9 Orchard 2195-6; Wasylycia-Leis 2195-6 Correspondence (T.P. 14) See also Petitions Dewar 559 Seven Oaks General Hospital Incorporation Selkirk School of Psychiatric Nursing Amendment Act (Bill 90) Closure postponement 1 r Helwer 3529; 2r Cheema 3880-1 ; Dewar 1758, 4306; Orchard 1758, 4306 referred to StandingComm ittee on Private Reopening Bills; RIS Lamoureux 5418; 3r Lamoureux 541 8; Dewar 294; Orchard 294 RIA 5492 See also Private Members'Busi ness-Resolutions

SenateTransportation Comm ittee Seven Oaks Youth Centre Manitoba representation Closure Driedger 1 019; Edwards 1019 Alcock 1227; Carstairs 1256; Gilleshammer 1227-8, 1256-7 Seniors' Directorate Length of stay Annu� Report, 1991 (S.P. 33) Carstairs 4303-4; Gilleshammer 4303-4 Ducharme 466 See also Fa mily Services, Department of Supplementary Information (Supply)--Child andFa mily Services 1992-93 Estimates (T.P. 60) Ducharme 2458 Sewage lagoon-OakPoint Environmental concerns Seniors' housing Cerilli 2796-7;Cumm ings 2797 See Housing, seniors Environmental impact assessment Cerilli 2797; Cummings 2797 Seniors' Month Licensing process See Ministerial statements; Nonpolitical Cummings 2798; Edwards2797-8 statements; Public hearings Seniors 'programs Cerilli 2797; Cummings 2797-8; Edwards 2798 Funding Shoal Lake, protection of Ducharme 1258; Santos 1258 Government commitment Environmental review process Ducharme 1160, 1258; Santos 1160, 1258 Doer 2506-7; Filmon2507 Manitoba regulations Seniors' RentaiStart Cummings 21 05-6; Doer 2105 Applications Minister's communications Ernst 126; Martindale 126 Cummings 21 04-5; Doer 2104-5 Negotiations-Ontario Seniors' rights Cummings 2506; Doer 2506

See Private Members' Business-Resolutions Premier's discussions Doer 2506; Filmon 2506 Service de Conselller Funding Sliver Heights Collegiate Barrett3957-8; Gilleshammer 3958 See Nonpolitical statements

173 Hansard Index

Slmplot-Brandon plant Social assistance Governmentassistance Abuse rate L. Evans 3959; Stefanson 3959 Carstairs 174; Manness 174 Modernization Alternative L. Evans 691 ; Stefanson 691 L. Evans 356; Filmon 356 Benefrt cap Single-Industrytowns Gilleshammer 1256; Martindale 1256 Equity insurance CRISP benefits Downey 1613, 2253-4; Storie 1613, 2253-4 Gilleshammer 1256; Martindale 1256 Common law regulation Sisler High School Gilleshammer 1776; Martindale 1776 See Nonpolitical statements Discrimination Gilleshammer 1776; Martindale 1776 Sisters Servants of Mary Immaculate Employment creation strategy See Nonpolitical statements L. Evans 2107-8, 2251 -2; Gilleshammer 1255, 2251 -2; Small business Filmon 2079-1 0; Manness 21 07-8; Government initiatives Martindale 1255, 2079, 3370; Orchard 3370 Stefanson 1229; Storie 1229 Employment training programs Carstairs 174; Gilleshammer 174 Small School Rural Workshops Food allowance Cancellation Carstairs 2988-9, 3043;Gil leshammer 2988-9, Chomiak 469-70; Vodrey 470 4102-3; Martindale410 2; Orchard 3043 Correspondence (T.P. 12) Government priorities Chomiak 470 Gllleshammer 730; Martindale 730 Head of household regulation Snow Lake, Manitoba Gilleshammer 5175; Martindale 51 75 Labour adjustment committee Off-reservestat us indians Neufeld 294;Storie 294 Ashton 2596; Downey 2596; Mineral exploration L. Evans 2357-8, 2466-7, 3142-3; Neufeld 295; Storie 295 Gilleshammer 2358, 2467, 2596, 2798-9, 3142-3; Martindale 2798 Social Allowances Amendment and Off-reserveStatus Indians Consequential Amendments Act (Bill 70) Correspondence(T.P. 87) 1 r Gilleshammer 1654; 2r Alcock 4774-9; L. Evans 3142 Ashton 4901 -9; Barrett 5134-7; Provincial tax credit Carstairs 3863-5; C. Evans 5025-7; Carstairs 356-7; Gilleshammer 356-7 L. Evans 5127-34; Gilleshammer 1979-81 ; Rate increase Hickes 4766-74; Maloway 491 8-20; Gilleshammer 264; Martindale 264 Martindale3865-8; Plohman 4909-15; Rent appeal intervention Santos 4761-6; Storie 4284-7; Gilleshammer 4989; Martindale 4989 Wowchuk 4915-8;referred to Standing Special needs Committee on Industrial Relations; Carstairs 357; Giiieshammer 357 RIS Gilleshammer 5333; 3r Ashton 5379-82; See also Ministerial statements Carstairs 5378-9; Doer 5375-8; L. Evans 5382-6; Gilleshammer 5454; Martindale5451 -5; Social assistance-students RIA 5492 Categorization

174 Hansard Index

Social ssslstsncs - Cont. Status of Women (Supply) - Cont. Carstairs 1755-6; Gilleshammer 1756 Response Common law regulation Barrett4406-8 ; Carstairs 4408-10 Gilleshammer 171 0; Martindale 1710 Women's Directorate Increase Barrett441 0-4, 4420-1 ; Carstairs 441 6-20, Gilleshammer 1710; Martindale 1710 4423-4; Mitchelson 4410-4, 4416, 4420-4 Reductions Derkach 179; Hickes 178-9; Gilleshammer 179 Statute LawAmendment Act, 1992 (BIII 1 01) Regulationchanges 1 r McCrae 4596; 2r L. Evans 5178; Carstairs 1756; Gilleshammer 1756 Lamoureux 5178; McCrae 5122; referred to Standing Committee on Law Amendments; Social Work Week, National RIS McCrae 5393; 3r Chomiak 5416-7; RIA 5493 See Nonpolitical statements Statute Law Amendment (Taxation) Act, Soli Testing Laboratory 1992 (Bill 94) Privatization results 1 r Manness 4095; 2r Alcock 5003-4; Findlay 3986; Plohman 3986 Maloway 5002; Manness 4508-9;Storie 5002-3; C/WAlcock 5238, 5248-9; Doer 5244-5; Solvent abuse legislation Edwards 5252-3; L. Evans 5236-7, 5239-44, Proclamation 5246-51 ; Manness 5236-54; Plohman 5246-7; Hickes 1971-2, 2083; Orchard 1972, 2083 RIS Manness 5308; 3r Doer 5318-9; L. Evans 531 8; RIA 5492 Speaker'sstate ments Christmas message STEFANSON, Hon. Eric (Kirkfleld Park, PC) Rocan 395 (Minister of Industry, Trade and Tourism) (Minister responsiblefor The Development Manitoba Legislative Internship Program CorporationAct ; Sport) Rocan 122 (Minister charged with the administration of the Boxing and Wrestling Commission Act, The Fitness and Amateur Sport Act) Special Operating Agencies Financing Budget debate Authority Act (Bill 96) 1455-60 1 r Manness 4162; 2r Alcock 5008-9; Co-operative Loans and Loans Guarantee Board Maloway 5009; Manness 4743-4; Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 128) 4877 Storie 5005-8; C/W L. Evans 5256; Co-operative Promotion Board Manness 5256; referred to Standing Committee Annual Report, 1991 (S.P. 127) 4877 on Municipal Affairs; RIS Manness 5395; Economic Innovation andTechnology Council Act 3r L. Evans 5412; Storie 5412;RIA 5492 (Bill 9) 3r 531 1-3 Status of Women Fitness and Sport (Supply) See Manitoba Advisory Council on the Status of 5214-7 Women Industry, Trade and Tourism, Departmentof Annu� Report, 1991 (S.P. 90) 2589 Status of Women (S�pply) Economic indicators (T.P. 185) 4825 Advisory Council on the Status of Women Supplementary information Barrett441 4, 4419-20; Carstairs 4414-9; 1992-93 Estimates (T.P. 166) 4273 Mitchelson 441 4-20 Industry,Trade and Tourism (Supply) Opening remarks Administration and Finance Mitchelson 4404-6 Executive Support4823

175 Hansard Index

Stefsnson, Hon. Eric - Cont. Stefsnson, Hon. Eric - Cont. Grant Assistance-Faculty of Management Governmentpolicy performance2991 -2 4832-5 Prairie provinces' co-operation 2018-9 Strategic Planning 4823-32 Research and development 3983-4 Industry and Trade Division Wage levels 1 054-5 Business Resource Centre 4849-50 Free Trade Agreement Rnancial Programs4847-9 Impact food processing industry 1777 Industry Impact Manitoba 2573 Sectoral development 4836-46 Impact on manufacturing industry 4597 Opening remarks 481 8-20 Labour adjustment strategy 1777, 2573-4 Strategic Development Initiative Division Softwood lumber duty 1113, 1177 Administration 4850-2 Government, Federal Health Industry Development Initiative 4852-3 Untendered contracts 2350-1 Interim AppropriationAct, 1992 (Bill 67) Hudson's Bay DistributionCentre C/W 1723-8 Employment security 2685-6 Manitoba Research Council MacleodSt edman Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 89) 2589 Funding justification 54 Ministerialstate ments Secured creditors 53-4 Canadian Men's Curling Championship 1249-50 Manufacturing industry Canadian Women's Curling Championship 1047 Employment statistics406-7 World Curling championships 1771 Shipment statistics 3958-9 Oral questions North American Free Trade Agreement ACCESS programs Cultural industries 1914 Funding-Federal 686-7 Departmental review 1913 Government commitment687 Tabling request 191 3-4 Assiniboia Downs Governmentconditions 403-4 Status 130-1 Governmentopposition 971 Winter harnessracing 130 Governmentstudy Borden Company Ltd. Tabling request 1368 Closure 1055 Governmentwithdrawal 4597-8 Labour adjustment strategy 1776-7 Impact Crown corporations 1491-2 CFB Shilo Impact garment industry 3320 Continuation 691 Impact labour force 4878-9 Communications initiative Impact Manitoba 971 -2 Research and development funding 3894 Impact supply management 4982-3 Cross-border shopping Information tabling request 1913 Government Services, Department of Sanitary standards 1779 U.S. purchase policy 5264 Water sales 1775-6, 2878 Government strategy 1 016, 5264 Withdrawal 3320, 4306 Industry, Trade andTourism, Departmentof North West Company 1016 Employment creation strategy2579-80 Drug patent law-Federal NorthernTelecom -Layoffs Impact on labour force 2591 Government action 4543-4 ERDA agreements Oak Hammock Marsh development Status 686 Impact on tourism 4275 Economic growth Paddlewheel Riverboats Employment creation strategy 4274-5 Lower Fort Garry trip 191 8-9 Full-time employment decline2578 Piper AircraftCorporation

176 Hansard Index

Stefsnson, Hon. Eric - Cont. Storie, Jerry - Cont. Relocation 1157 Energy and Mines, Department of(Supply) Retail trade sector Administration and Finance Statisticsdiscrepancy 5265 Executive Office47 21-5 Seafood Enterprises Associates HeaiU'lCare Directives Act (Bill 16) Agreement 757, 1157 2r4148-51 Simplot-Brandon plant Industry,Trade and Tourism (Supply) Governmentassistance 3959 Administration and Finance Modernization 691 Executive Support4823 Small business Grant Assistance-Facultyof Management Governmentini tiatives 1229 4832-4 Telecommunications laboratory Minister's salary 4854-5 Government discussions 3895 Strategic Planning 4823-8, 4831 -2 Tourism Industry and Trade Division Government initiatives 3985 Business Resource Centre 4849-50 Promotion campaign Financial Programs4847-9 Government strategy 3317 Industry Statistics Sectoral development4835-7, 4842-5 Decline 141 6-7 Opening remarks Overnightvisitors 3984-5 Response 4820-2 U.S. visitors 3315-6 Strategic Development Initiative Division Unemployment rate, youth Health Industry Development Initiative4852-3 Government strategy 470-1 Tourism Division Private Members' Business Administration 4853 Resolutions Labour Relations Amendment Act (Bill 85) CN Rail jobs 1828-30 2r 4754-61 ; 3r 5455-8 Economic Summit 5437-40 Law Society Amendment Act (Bill 74) North American Free Trade Agreement 2r2857-62 502-4, 585-8 Liquor Control Amendment Act (Bill 77) Urgent Public Importance, Mattersof 2r 2731-3 Economic crisis 415-7 Manitoba Hydro Amendment Act (Bill 1 0) 2r 928-35; 3r 5222-5 Stephenfleld reservoir Nonpolitical statements Irrigation licensing Westray, NovaScotia mine accident 3176 Edwards 601-2; Enns 601-2 Oral questions Abitibi-Price-Pine Falls STORIE, Jerry (FIIn Flon, NDP) Feasibility study 2200 Budget debate Budget 1460-3, 1475-7 Economic growth 921 Condolence, Motions of Employment creation strategy 921 Witney, Charles H. 605 Revenue sources921 Economic Innovation andTechnology Council Act Business relocations (Bill 9) Government discussions 3849 2r 631-6; RIS 5307 Canada-U.S. trade deficit Education and Training, Department of (Supply) Impact labour force 1177 Expenditures Related to Capital Communications industry Acquisitions/Construction of Physical Assets Employment statistics 4097 4086-90 Cross-border shopping

177 Hansard Index

Storie, Jerry - Cont. Storie, Jerry - Cont. Government Services, Department of Tabling request 1913 U.S. purchase policy 5264 Election call 1656 Government strategy 1 015, 5264-5 Governmentaction 1655 Industry, Trade andTourism, Department of . Government conditions403-4 1016 Governmentopposition 971 Drug patent law-Federal Governmentposition 1323 Government strategy 2591-2 Governmentstrate gy 2853 Impact on drug costs 2591 Impact garment industry 3319-20 Impact on labour force 2591 Impact on Manitoba 971 -2 Economic growth Information tabling request 1662, 1913, 2077 Employment creation strategy Justification 3644-5 1228, 3849, 4097 Provincial jurisdiction 1656 Governmentstrategy 1228 Withdrawal 1323, 3320 Employment creation strategy NorthWest Company Governmentcomm itment 1158 Employment creation strategy 2578-9 Free Trade Agreement Piper Aircraft Corporation Abrogation 403, 3643-4 Relocation 1157 Employment creation statistics 3644 RCMP Softwood lumber duty 1177-8 Confiscated liquor disposal 798 Health care system, Northern Seafood Enterprises Associates Mortalityrate 3090 Agreement 1157 Transportation fee3090 Single-industry towns Judicial system Equity insurance 1613, 2253-4 Circuit court 1469 Small business Liquor Control Act Governmentini tiatives 1229 Confiscated liquor 798-9 Snow Lake, Manitoba Macleod Stedman Labour adjustment committee294 Funding justification 54 Mineralexploration 295 Secured creditors 53 Tantalum Mining Corporation Manitoba Liquor Control Commission Contract negotiations 3139 Resignation request-chairperson 176 Employment protection 3139-40 Sales techniques 2354 Tourism Senior salary levels 175-6 Governmentini tiatives 3985, 4097 Manufacturing industry Statistics Employment creation strategy 1322 Overnightvisitors 3984 Employment statistics2078 Wang Canada Mining communities Agreement status 3649 Employment retraining programs 2990 Governmentinvolvement 3649 Equity insurance 2990 Untendered contract 3650 Exploration 2988 Petitions Government initiatives 2987 Fight Back Against Child Abuse campaign Mining Community Reserve Fund 1652; ruled in order 1702 Snow Lake, Manitoba 2989 Points of Order Mining operations P/0 by � respecting words "always such Dust control 4990-1 a phony" (Filmon) 1225; North American Free Trade Agreement ruled out oforder 1225 Departmental review 1913 P/0 by � respecting responses to

178 Hansard Index

Storie, Jerry - Cont. Stony Mountain - Cont. questions (Supply) 3432; Funding ruled out of order (Dacquay) 3432 Cummings 690; Edwards 690 Private Members' Business Funding-Federal Address for Papers Cummings 689; Edwards689 Public Health Amendment Act Legal opinion 3073-5 Student aid Resolutions Appeal process NorthAmerican Free Trade Agreement 504-7, Carstairs 2876; Vodrey 2876 588-93 Application statistics Provincial Park Lands Amendment Act (Bill 21) Carstairs 2875; Vodrey 2875 2r 2755-9 Clarification Resolutions Riel, Louis Vodrey 977 Role in development of Manitoba 3664-6 Emergency assistance Social Allowances Amendment and Consequential Carstairs 2462; Vodrey 2462 Amendments Act (Bill 70) Funding 2r4284-7 Carstairs 2875; Vodrey2875 Special Operating Agencies Rnancing Authority Act (Bill 96) Sturgeon Creek High School 2r 5005-8; 3r 5412 See Nonpolitical statements Statute Law Amendment (Taxation) Act, 1992 (Bill 94) Suche report 2r 5002-3 SurveysAmendment Act (Bill 34) Government response 2r 777-8 Barrett3989; Gilleshammer 3989-90 Tabled papers Recommendations Cross-bordershopping Barrett2880; Gilleshammer 2880 Industry, Trade and Tourism, Department of Working committee (T.P. 23) 1016 Barrett2880 ; Gilleshammer 2880 Throne speech debate 383-6 Summer Challenge program University of Manitoba AmendmentAct (Bill 25) Elimination 2r 786-9 Gilleshammer 2851 ; Martindale 2851 Urgent Public Importance, Matter of Economic crisis 41 0-1 , 413-5 Workers Compensation Amendment Act (2) (Bill 55) Supply, Capital 2r 1749-51, 2343-4 Supply, Committee of Ashton 5350-1 ; Cheema 5280-91 , 5336-9; Student Temporary Employment Program Enns 5342-58; C. Evans 5341-6, 5351-2; Funding restoration L. Evans 5296-8; Manness 5272; L. Evans 974; Manness 974 Orchard 5276-80, 5282-90, 5295-6, 5298-5305, 5337-41 ; Plohman 5352-7; Storie 5292-6; Stony Mountain, Manitoba Wasylycia-Leis 5272-6, 5300-6; Environmental concerns Wowchuk 5347-50, 5357-8 Cummings 476-7, 689; Edwards 476, 689 Ways and Means, Committeeof Correspondence(T.P. 18) Capital Supply 5475-6 Edwards 689 Main Supply 5475-6

179 Hansard Index

Supply, Interim Tax Appeals Commission Act (Bill 95) Supply, Committee of 1 r Manness 3981 ; 2r Alcock 5005; 1615 Maloway 5004-5; Manness 4509-10; Ways and Means, Committee of C/WAlcock 5255; L. Evans 5255-6; 1616 Manness 5255-6; RISManness 5309; RIA 5492 Surveys Amendment Act (Bill 34) Taxicab Industry 1 r Enns 220; 2r Edwards 640-1 ; Enns 640; Luxury cab proposal C. Evans 4287-9; Storie 777-8; Wowchuk 741 -3; Driedger 876-7; Lamoureux 876-7 referred to Standing Committee on Municipal Affairs; RIS Manness 5394; RIA 5491 Tender process Sustainable development Review Governmentcom mitment Cerilli 2746; Cummings 2746 Cummings 1231 ; Edwards 1231 See also Agricultural land; Forestryindustry The Diviners Governmentsupport SVEINSON, Ben (LaVerendr ye, PC) Mitchelson 4207; Render 4206 Business PracticesAmendment Act (Bill 27) 2r 2564-5 The Forks Renewal Corporation Manitoba Hydro Amendment Act (Bill 1 0) Annual Report, 1991 (T.P. 19) 2r 3345-7 Ernst 723 Pointsof Order P/0 by E!nDErespecti ng comments in regards The Pas Health Complex to Dutch elm disease 839; taken under advisement (Sveinson) 839; See Petitions ruled out of order978 Private Members' Business The Pas Health Complex Incorporation Resolutions Amendment Act (Bill 52) Video lotteryterminals 2649 1 r Lathlin 514; 2r Ashton 3832; Lamoureux 3832; Throne speech debate Lathlin 1962;referred to StandingComm ittee 316-20 on Private Bills; RIS Lathlin 4487; 3r Doer 5417; RIA 5491 Swan River Metis Friendship Centre See Nonpolitical statements The Pas, Manitoba Swan Valley School Division Civil servicepositions Lathlin 3045; Manness 3045-6 Distance Education Program Employment decline Vodrey 2688-9; Wowchuk 2688-9 Derkach 2691 ; Lathlin 2690-1 Tantalum Mining Corporation Employment opportunities Downey 24, 2876; Lathlin 24, 2876 Contractnegotiations Downey 3139; Storie 3139 Employment protection Thicket Portage, Manitoba Downey 3139-40; Storie 3139-40 All-weather road Ashton 4305; Driedger 4305 Tartan Day Train derailment report See Nonpolitical statements Ashton 4305; Driedger 4305

180 Hansard Index

Thompson General Hospital Tourism - Cont. Mammography/chemotherapy services Tender process Ashton 41 03-4; Downey 4103-4 Alcock 2849-50;Filmon 2849-50 Regional facility Statistics Orchard 3581 ; Wasylycia-Leis 3581 Decline Doer 1416-7; Stefanson 141 6-7 Thompson, Manitoba Overnightvisitors See Ministerial statements Stefanson 3984-5; Storie 3984 U.S. visitors Throne Speech Doer 331 5; Stefanson 3315-6 Aboriginal self-government Johnson 9-1 0 Trade Practices InquiryAct Economic challenges Annua1 Report, 1992 (S.P. 55) Johnson 2-3 Mcintosh 791 Economic growth Johnson 3-7 Transportation Industry National unity Rail line jurisdiction Johnson 9 Driedger 1 019-20;Edwards 101 9-20 Social services See also Trucking industry Johnson 7-9 Transportation Issues Throne Speech Debate Premier's involvement Alcock 241-7; Ashton 212-7, 229-32; Driedger 52; Reid 52 Barrett90-6; Carr 379-83; Carstairs 133-43; Cerilli 151-7; Chomiak 345-50; Connery 180-8; Treaty land entitlements Dacquay 157-60; Dewar 336-9; Doer 60-83; See Repap Manitoba Inc. Driedger 143-51 ; Edwards 31 1-6; Enns 271 -8; Ernst 1 08-1 3; L. Evans 253-9; Filmon 386-94; Trucking Industry Friesen 160-7; Gilleshammer 83-90; All-partytask force Helwer43-7; Hickes 320-7; Lamoureux 201 -7; Downey 4164;Reid 41 64 Laurendeau 207-12; Martindale 101-8; Employment creation strategy McAlpine 247-53; McCrae 327-36; Driedger 4164;Reid 4164 Penner 195-201 ; Plohman 113-21 ; Employment protection Praznik 339-45; Reid 188-95; Reimer 38-43; Driedger 4163-4; Reid 4163 Render 232-6; Rose 283-5, 302-5; Operating authority Santos 236-41 ; Storie 383-6; Sveinson 316-20; Driedger 3789; Reid 3789 Vodrey 95-101 ; Wasylycia-Leis 278-83; Wowchuk 305-1 1 Ukraine Independence See Nonpolitical statements Tourism Government initiatives Unemployed Help Centre Downey 4097-8; Stefanson 3985; Funding reinstatement Storie 3985, 4097 Ashton 3417; Praznik 341 7 Marketing programs Johnson 6 Unemployment rate, youth Promotion campaign Governmentstra tegy Government strategy Ashton 4507; Carstairs 470-1, 2078, 2196-7, Doer 3316; Stefanson 3316 2252; Downey 3368-9; L. Evans 2251 , 3368-9;

181 Hansard Index

Unemployment rate, youth - Cont. University of Winnipeg Filmon 2078-9, 4507; Gilleshammer 2196-7, Annual Financial Report, 1991 (S.P. 24) 2251-2; Stefanson 470-1 Derkach 352 Programs funding See also Nonpolitical statements Ashton 51 14-5; Filmon 51 15; Gilleshammer 5114-5 University Education Review Commission Implementation Unity Committee Report Friesen 2689; Vodrey 2689 Legal opinion request Doer 820; Filmon 820 Urban aboriginal medical program Funding reduction UnlversHies Friesen 4571 ; Orchard 4571 Departmental review Friesen 2463; Vodrey 2463 Urban Aboriginal Strategy Funding formula Governmentacti on Derkach 173-4; Friesen 173 Rlmon 4571 ; Friesen 4571 Levels ofinstruction Government commitment Friesen 2463; Vodrey 2463 Downey 1608-9; Friesen 1608 Review Release Friesen 5407; Vodrey 5407 Filmon 341 8; Hickes 3418 Tuition fees Friesen 2462; Vodrey 2462 Urban Affairs, Departmentof Tuition fees (T.P. 61) Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 17) Friesen 2462 Ernst 286 See also specific universities Supplementary information 1992-93 Estimates (T.P. 74) Universities Grants Commission Ernst 2869 Annua1 Repo rt, 1991 (S.P. 82) Vodrey 2074 Urban Affairs, Department of (Supply) See also Education and Tra ining, Department of Administrationand Finance (Supply) Administration and Rnancial Services Edwards 4338; Ernst 4338-9 University of Manitoba Executive Support Agricultural research Ernst 4337-8; Friesen 4337-8 Findlay 1424; Gaudry 1423-4 Expenditures Related to Capital Annual Financial Report, 1991 (S.P. 25) Rnancial Assistance to The City of Winnipeg Derkach 352 Ernst4354 -5; Friesen 4354-5 Student food bank Riverbank Development Alcock 975; Vodrey 975 Edwards 4355; Ernst 4355-6; Martindale 4356 Student safety Financial Assistance to The City of Winnipeg Barrett 1761-2; Vodrey 1761-2 Unconditional Current Programs Grant Ernst 4339-42; Friesen 4339; Reid 4339-42 University of Manitoba Amendment Act Opening remarks (8111 25) Ernst 4334-5 1 r Alcock 466-7; 2r Alcock 780-1 ; Response Ashton 789-90, 906-7;Friesen 781-4; Edwards 4336-7; Friesen 4335-6 Lamoureux 2066; Martindale 3635-7; Urban Policy and Agreement Management Render 2561 -3; Santos 784-6;Sto rie 786-9 Core Area Renewed Agreement

182 Hansard Index

Urbsn Affslrs (Supply) - Cont. Urgent Public Importance, Matters of - Cont. Edwards 4348-50; Ernst 4348-53; Economic crisis Friesen 4350-3 Alcock 2884;(L. Evans) 2882-3; Salaries Manness 2883-4 Ernst 4342-8; Friesen 4342-7 ruledout of order 2884; challenged 2884; Urban Hospital Council sustained 2885 Budget reduction proposal Goodsand servicestax Orchard 821-2; Wasylycia-Leis 821-2 Harmonization Mental health care Ashton 408-9; (Carstairs) 408; Manness 409; Recommendations Speaker's ruling 409-1 0 Cheema 3040; Orchard 3040 Manitoba Heritage Federation Misericordia Hospital review Granting authority Cheema 473; Orchard 473 Friesen 2583-4; (Lamoureux) 2581 -3; Public participation Manness 2583; Almon 127; Wasylycia-Leis 126-7 ruled out of order 2585; Recommendations ruling overturned2585; Orchard 22; Wasylycia-Leis 22 Lamoureux 2586-7 Reportrequest Rural Development, Minister of Cheema 557; Filmon 127; Orchard 557; School board interference Wasylycia-Leis 127 Ashton 4552-3; (Carstairs) 4552; Specialty nursing Manness4553-4 ; Recommendations ruled out of order 4554; Orchard 3041 ; Wasylycia-Leis 3041 challenged 4554; sustained 4555 Urgent Public Importance, Matters of Domestic violence Vacation With Pay Amendment Act (BIII 33) (Barrett) 27-8; Lamoureux 28; Manness 28-9; 1 r Lamoureux 467 Speaker's ruling 29; Barrett29-31 ; Carstairs33-4; Vegetable producing Industry Chomiak 35-7; Edwards 37-8; Almon 31-3; Day haul worker program, Federal Vodrey 34-5 Connery 1373; Andlay 1373 Economic crisis U.S. inspections Lamoureux 41 1-2; Manness 412-3; Connery 1373; Andlay 1373 (Storie) 410-1 ; Speaker's ruling 413; Venture Manitoba Tours Ltd. Alcock 417-9; Carstairs 423-5; Auditor's Report, 1991 (S.P. 61 ) Cheema 454-6; Chomiak 452-4; Enns 1013 Connery 450-2; Derkach 459-61 ; Doer 419-21 ; See also Natural Resources, Department of Downey 447-8; Edwards 444-5; Enns 427-9; (Supply) L. Evans 425-7; Gaudry 433-4; Hickes 436-7; Lamoureux 448-50; Lathlin 445-6; Veterinary Drug Centre Manness 438-9; McAlpine 456-8; Privatization results Orchard 421-3; Penner 431-3; Findlay 3986; Plohman 3986 Plohman 429-31 ; Praznik 434-6; Render 442-3; Santos 458-9; VIctims Assistance Committee Stefanson 415-7; Storie 413-5; Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 118) Wowchuk 439-42 McCrae 4161

183 Hansard Index

VIdeo lottery terminals Vodrey, Hon. Rosemary - Cont. Green Team program Schooltax statistics (T.P. 71) 2823 Derkach 5267; Wowchuk 5267 Schoolsfunding, 1992/93 (T.P. 77) 2896 See also Private Members' Business-Resolutions Special opportunity loans (T.P. 123) 3923 Staffing requirements (T.P. 63) 2623 Vlmy Ridge Student Supportbranch (T.P. 92) 3186 See Nonpolitical statements Students, high-risk (T.P. 86) 3127 SupplementaryInformation VIolence,education against 1992-93 Estimates (T.P. 52) 2102 See Priva te Members'Business-Resolutions Educationand Training, Department of (Supply) Administration and Finance VODREY, Hon. Rosemary (FortGarry, PC) Administration and Professional Certification (Minister of Education and Training) 2721-8 Educationand Training, Department of Executive Support2553-61 ACCESS programs (T.P. 145) 3939 Financial Services271 8-9 Annu� Report, 1991 (S.P. 50) 684 Management Information Services271 9-21 Budgets-executive support(T.P. 64) 2623 Personnel Services2638-9, 2715-7 Bursary and loan debts (T.P. 125) 3923 Planning, Research and Policy Co-ordination Canada student loans (T.P. 126) 3924 2624-38 Canada student loans, part-time (T.P. 127) 3924 Bureau de I'education francaise Canada student loans, repayment schedule Division Administration31 32-5 (T.P. 128) Expenditures Related to Capital 3924 Acquisition/Construction of Physical Assets Child Care and Development branch 4085-90 Staffingsummary (T.P. 82) 3033 Capital Grants Community college governance Universities 4090-1 Inter-departmental conversionteam (T.P. 97) Financial Support-schools 3299 Phase-InSupport 2964 Education, distance School Grants and Other Assistance First year university (T.P. 90) 3186 2729-30,2823-36, 2896-2902,2958-63 Eligible enrolment (T.P. 76) 2896 Teachers' Retirement Allowances2964-5 French-language education Opening remarks 2538-45 Funding (T.P. 93) 3186 Post-Secondary,Adult and Continuing Education Manitoba Student Assistance Program and Training Average awards (T.P. 132) 3925 Assiniboine Community College 3768-74 Length of eligibility (T.P. 150) 4013 Education and Training Assistance 381 6-9 Out-of-province applicants (T.P. 151)40 13 Executive Administration Recipients(T.P. 124) 3923 3187-95, 3248-62, 3297-3301 Occupations, high demand (T.P. 98) 3302 Grants 4014 Post-secondary campus list (T.P. 115) 3813 Keewatin Community College 3777-84, 3814-6 Private vocational schools Literacy Office401 5-7 Course offerings (T.P. 139) 3925 Post-Secondary Career Development Enrolment statistics(T .P. 140) 3925 3939-41' 4013-4 Foundation Learning Centre (T.P. 138) 3925 Program Analysis, Co-ordinationand Support Instructor qualifications (T.P. 136) 3925 3302-8, 3398-3404, 3430-41 , 3514-28, Truck driver training (T.P. 135) 3925 3615-31 ' 3705-12 Schoolgrants and other assistance (T.P. 85) Red River Community College 3127 3712-20, 3757-68

184 Hansard Index

Vodrey, Hon. Rosemary - Cont. Vodrey, Hon. Rosemary - Cont. Special Skills Training 401 7-20 Post-secondary accessibility 600-1 Student Financial Assistance Education and Training, Departmentof 381 9-30, 3923-37 Deputy Minister Student Financial Assistance Appeal Board Salary increase 2509 3938-9 Executive Support Workforce 2000 4020-3 Salary increase 2509 Program Development and Support Services Underspending975 Child Care and Development 3118-24 Education, post-secondary Curriculum Services2967-77 Accessibility 874, 2462, 5407 Distance Education and Technology 3124-7 Funding 1050 Division Administration2966-7 Tuition fee increases 1182 Manitoba Schoolfor the Deaf 3032-4 Education Reform, Panel on Native Education 2978-83, 3018-32 Reportrelease 3990 Student Support Program 3127-32 Education system Universities Grants Commission Administrative costs 2793 4023-6, 4074-85 Child Guidance Clinic 4577 Interim Appropriation Act, 1992 (Bill 67) Curriculum development 2793 C/W 1689-90, 1762-4 Dropout rate 2352, 2358, 2792, 3322 Ministerial statements Exceptional student programs funding3848 Education, multicultural Funding formula 792-3, 1 020, 1112-3 Policy for the 1990s (T.P. 88) 3162-3 Grade 1 0 curriculum changes 4572, 4576 Post-Secondary Student Support Program School closures Status Indians 4567-8 Guideline review 2592 Oral questions School year length 2359 ACCESS programs Special needs funding 876 Funding reductions 3169-70 Student achievement levels 3849 Budget Transportation policy review 2592 Student aid 975 Vocational programs funding3848 Budget-Federal Educational facilities Student aid 730 St. James Seniors Group usage 1159 Child Guidance Clinic Employment retraining programs Funding formula 4307 Governmentcommi tment 2461-2 Government position 3959-60, 4307 Governmentinitiatives 727-8 Service replacement 1261-2 Employment training programs Community colleges Governmentstrategy 4300 Accessibility 601 , 2852 Family life education Alternatives 1755 Compulsory curriculum 3321 Employment training initiatives 2079 Labour Force Development Agreement Enrolment 2852 Government participation51 69-70 Funding 601 , 1050, 1755 National standards 5170 Funding restoration 874 Labour force developmentboards Student appeal process 559-60 Announcement 4886 Core Area Initiative Mystery Lake School Division Education programs 1230 Funding 2309 Domestic violence Meeting request 2309 Pedlar Report recommendations 4885 Red River Community College Education, aboriginal Nursing curriculum 161 0

185 Hansard Index

Vodrey, Hon. Rosemary - Cont. Vodrey, Hon. Rosemary - Cont. Red Sucker Lake, Manitoba Throne speech debate School closure 4743 95-1 01 St. Vital School Division Private Members'Busine ss Funding formula 793 Resolutions School boards Education,dis tance 4654-6 Political interference4501 Tabled papers School Division Boundary Review School boundaryreview Commitment 2593 Correspondence (T .P. 65) 2637 Impact Francophone Schools Governance Schooldivisions 1370 Annual Division Action Plan (T.P. 81) 3033 Schooldivisions Schools, independent Election postponement 600 Funding (T.P. 70) 2823 French language division 600 List of registered schools(T.P. 99) 3304 Funding formula 1164-5 Universities Grants Commission Information delivery 3675-6 Annu� Report, 1991 (S.P. 82) 2074 Schools, independent Urgent Public Importance, Matter of Agreement tabling request 1422 Domesticviolence 34-5 Funding formula 1112, 1422-3, 1470, 1760 Schools, public Voters' list, permanent Enrolment decline 2021 See Private Members'Busi ness-Resolutions Small School Rural Workshops Cancellation 470 Wang Canada Student aid Agreement status Appeal process 2876 Downey 3649;Storie 3649 Application statistics 2875 Governmentinvolvement Clarification 977 Downey 3649; Manness 3649 Emergency assistance 2462 Untendered contract Funding 2875 Manness 3650; Storie 3649-50 Swan Valley School Division Distance Education Program 2688-9 Waste on disposal Universities Reporttabling request Departmentalreview 2463 Cerilli 4550; Cummings 4550 Levels of instruction 2463 Soil contamination Review 5407 Cerilli 4550; Cummings 4550 Tuition fees 2462 University of Manitoba WASYLYCIA·LEIS, Judy (St. Johns, NDP) Student food bank 975 Address for Papers Student safety 1761-2 Public Health Amendment Act University Education Review Commission Legal opinion Implementation 2689 732; not accepted Manness 732; Public Schools FinanceBoard transferred to Private Members' Business Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 1 08) 3576 Budget debate Tabled papers 1212-8 Education system Denturists Amendment Act (Bill 6) Special needs students 2r 831 -3 Policy and procedural guidelines (T.P. 96) Health Care Records Act (Bill 36) 3297 1 r 1 048; 2r 2734-5

186 Hansard Index

Wasylycla-Lals, Judy - Cont. Wasylycla-Lals, Judy - Cont. Health, Departmentof (Supply) Reportof the Working Group Administration and Finance Response 967-8 Evaluation and Audit Secretariat CT Scanning Committee Report 2204-9, 2219-26, 2310-3, 2374-83, 241 9-20, Response 2300-1 2423-7 Manitoba Centrefor Health Policy and Executive support15 24-5, 1564-74, 1782-9, Evaluation 1794-6, 1 799-1805, 1855-65, 1874-8, Response 465 1933-43,2025-9, 2031-7, 2113-9, 2129-36, Nonpolitical statements 2162-9, 2174-7 AIDS Candlelight Memorial 3419 Health Information Systems 2427-30 Children's Hospital Research Foundation Minister's salary 3235-7, 3288-92, 3393-7 Wear Your Bear day 3960-1 Alcoholism Foundation of Manitoba 3230-3 InternationalAssembly of French-language ContinuingCare Programs Parliamentarians 3174-5 Administration 2665-8, 2679-83, 2694-5 Olafson, Doug Health Services YTV Youth Achievement award 731-2 Administration World Health Day 1921-2 2886-96,2935-42 , 2945-58, 2997-3005, Oral questions 3108-16, 31n-8 AIDS education projects Capital Construction 3216-7 Funding 4598-9 Hospital and Community Health Services AIDS prevention programs 3182-5 Street LINKS funding 3648-9 Laboratory and Imaging Services 3210-3 At-risk pregnancies Healthy Public Policy Prevention programs 41 69 Administration 2434-6, 2439 Bill C-20 Health Promotion, Protection and Disease Governmentposition 221 -2 Prevention Legal opinion 222 2515-8, 2521-8, 2534-7, 2600-11 Breast cancer Healthy Child Development Government initiatives291 2619-23,2650-5, 2660-2 Children's Dental Health Program Insured Benefits Service reduction 2850 Salaries 3222-8 Deer Lodge Hospital Opening remarks Bed closures 3322 Response 1511-7 Depo-Provera Provincial Mental Health Services Licence approval291 Administration 2704-1 0, 2714-5, 2801-8 Eating disorders Health ServicesInsur ance Amendment Act (Bill 51) Treatment programs 5170-1 2r 4263-5 Goods and servicestax Health Services Insurance Amendment and Harmonization 598-9 Consequential Amendments Act (Bill 75) Health AdvisoryNetwork 2r4591-3 Home care program 3414 Manitoba Advisory Council on the Status of Women Reportrelease 3413 Amendment Act (Bill 5) Health care facilities 2r 570-6 Bed closures 878, 1466, 1492-3, 1 n2-3, Mental Health Amendment Act (Bill 93) 2017-8, 3087, 3141-2 2r 4898-4901 Funding 1181 Ministerialstate ments Operating budget 3166 Breast CancerScreening Health care system

187 Hansard Index

Ws sylycls-Lels, Judy - Cont. Ws sylycls-Lels, Judy - Cont. Anesthetist manpower review 1968-9 Bed closures 3166-7, 4304, 4983-4 CT scanners Mental health care system Fundraising 2303-4 Bed closures 51 12 Deinsurance 2509-1 0 Reform Reform Co-ordination 51 11 Audiology services3680 Governmentstrategy 4200-1 Bed closures 3323, 4572-3 Misericordia Hospital Community-based services3365 Funding 1772 Consultations 1492, 3167, 3365 Nursing Education, Ministerial Council on Government agenda 3040-1 Status 2593-4 Health, Minister of Pharmacare Awareness 22 Clarythromycin exclusion 520-1, 926-7, 2256-7 Home care program 3534-5, 4431-2 Cyclosporine exclusion 927 Impact on employment 3365-6 Deductibleincrease 519-20 Implementation 3363-4,3366 St. Boniface Hospital Patient protection 3364 Bed closures 3086, 4304 Revenue-raising proposals 127 School of Licensed Practical Nurses 822, 2745 St. John's Ambulance funding 2680 St. John's Ambulance U.S. residents, servicesto 21 Funding 2881 Spending decisions 1110-1 Seven Oaks General Hospital Underspending 1180 Operating budget 2195-6 User fees 598 Thompson General Hospital Health care system, Northern Regional facility 3581 Mammography/chemotherapy services3580 Urban Hospital Council Health, Department of Budget reduction proposal 821-2 Employee morale 975-6 Public participation 126-7 Health SciencesCentre Recommendations 22 Bed closures 1226-7, 1916-7 Reportrequest 127 Operating budget 1181 , 1467 Specialty nursing Operating room closure 1226 Recommendations 3041 School of Nursing closure 4551-2 Petitions Home care program Criminal Codeamendme nts Advisory committee 623 2012; ruled in order 2074 Advocacy office 624 21 01 ; ruled in order 21 92 Funding 341 4 Rght Back Against Child Abuse campaign Government commitment 474-5 462; ruled in order 51 0 Service reduction 1659-60 551 ; ruled in order 595 Whiteway, Nancy 622-3 595; ruled in order (Dacquay) 617-8 Licensed Practical Nurses 684; ruled in order (Dacquay) 722 Governmentsupport 87 7-8, 2745 1464;ruled in order 1490 Red River Community College 2745 Points of Order Lindenview Residence P/0 by Laurendeau respecting word "fabrication" Funding 4170 (Wasylycia-Leis) 2029; Manitoba Association for Childbirthand Family withdrawn 2029 Education P/0 by Manness respecting words "master of Funding elimination 2576-7 obfuscation" (Wasylycia-Leis) 877; Mental health care facilities withdrawn 877

188 Hansard Index

Wasylycla-Lels, Judy - Cont. Water rights P/0 by McCrae respecting imputation of motives Priorities (Wasylycia-Leis) 1795; Connery 604; Enns 604 withdrawn 1795 P/0 by Wasylycja-Lejs respecting imputation of Western Canadian Wildlife Services motives (Orchard) 1784; Oak Hammock Marsh Report ruled out of order (Laurendeau) 1784; Cerilli 268; Enns 269 Members cautioned 1784 P/0 by Wasylycja-Lejs respecting word "hypocrites" Western Governors' Association (Orchard) 1785; Cheema 1785; Conference taken under advisement (Laurendeau) 1795; See Ministerial statements withdrawal requested 2022; withdrawn (Orchard) 2022 Western Premiers' Conference P/0 by Wasylycja-Lejs respecting word "fabricate" Agricultural issues (Orchard) 2033; Filmon 341 4-5; Plohman 3414-5 withdrawal requested (Rose) 2933; Crowbenefit withdrawn (Orchard) 2033 Findlay 3269; Plohman 3269 Private Members' Business Port of Churchill Address for Papers Fiimon 3273; Harper 3273 Public Health Amendment Act Regional development program Legal opinion 961 -3 Doer 3266-7; Filmon 3266-8 Resolutions See also Ministerial statements Medicare, five principles of5364-6 Medicare, preservation of 3721-4 Westminster United Church Reproductive health 746-7, 2008-1 0 See Nonpolitical statements Public Health Amendment Act (2) (Bill 56) 1 r 1 048; 2r 2738-9 Westray, Nova Scotia Supply, Capital See Nonpolitical statements Supply, Committee of 5272-6, 5300-6 Wife abuse Tabled papers See Domestic violence Health care system Bed closures Wild Kingdom Zoo-Dauphin Correspondence (T.P. 31) 1466 Inhumane treatment of animals Home care program Findlay 4882-3; Plohman 4882-3 Statistics (T.P. 107) 3535 Throne speech debate Wildlife protection 278-83 Poaching Enns 2692-3;Helwer 2692 Water and waste water management Certificate program Winkler Flyers

Cerilli 3044-5; Cummings 3045 See Nonpolitical statements

Water and Waste Water School Winnipeg Bible College and Theological Government support Seminary Cerilli 2994, 3044; Cummings 2995, 3044 See Petitions

189 Hansard Index

Winnipeg Bible College and Theological Reid 1744-7;Santos 1747-9; SeminaryIncor poration Amendment Act Storie 1749-51 , 2343-4 (BIII 97) Workers Compensation Board 1 r Penner 4200; 2r Ashton 5028; Lamoureux 5028; Penner 4489-90;referred to• Annua1 Report, 1991 (S.P. 98) Standing Committee on Law Amendments; Praznik 2842 RISPraznik 5328-9; RIA 5492 Family entitlements Praznik 4502-3, 4549; Reid 4502-3, 4549 Winnipeg Hawks Five Year Operating Plan (S.P. 99) See Nonpolitical statements Praznik 2842 Intimidation Winnipeg InternationalAir port Praznik 4573-4; Reid 4573-4 Protection Long-term benefits Driedger 2019; Martindale201 9 Praznik 292; Reid 292 Medical advice Winnipeg Pollee Department Praznik 292; Reid 292 See Nonpolitical statements Medical specialist reports Praznik 1056; Reid 1056 Winnipeg Regional Housing Authority Public inquiry See Private Members' Business-Address for Praznik 4301-2, 4432-3,4549 ; Papers, Orders for Return Reid 4301 -2, 4432-3,4549 Vocational rehabilitation benefits Winnipeg Thunder Praznik 2686-7; Reid 2686-7 See Nonpolitical statements Workforce2000 Winnipeg Wards Boundaries Commission See Priva te Members ' Business-Resolutions Supplementary Report (T.P. 43) Emst 1706 women's Day, International Witney, Charles H. See Ministerial statements See Condolence, Motions of World Health Day Women, violence against See Nonpolitical statements See Ministerial statements; Priva te Members' WOWCHUK, Rosann (Swan River, NDP) Business-Resolutions Agriculture, Departmentof (Supply) Women's Day, International Agricultural Development and Marketing Division See Nonpolitical statements Animal Industry Branch 3755-7 Soils and Crops Branch 3812-3 Women's Directorate Manitoba Crop Insurance Corporation See Manitoba Wom en's Directorate Big Game Damage Compensation 3739-40 Animal HusbandryAmendment Act (Bill 12) Women's Issues 2r 3557-60 Government initiatives Bee-Keepers Repeal Act (Bill 11) Barrett3676 ; Mitchelson 3676-7 2r 845-7 Decentralization (Supply) Workers Compensation Amendment Act Decentralization 4795-91 (2) (Bill 55) Opening remarks 1 r Reid 618; 2r Laurendeau 2345-6; Response 4785-91 , 4794

190 Hansard Index

Wo wchuk, Rossnn - Cont. Wowchuk, Rossnn - Cont. Dental Association Amendment Act (Bill 80) Oral questions 2r 3876 Agricultural industry Economic Innovation and Technology Council Act Diversification 4990 (Bill 9) Agr;icultural land 2r 837-9 Education supportlevy 2306 Education, Department of (Supply) Taxation 2306 Post-Secondary, Adult and Continuing Education Education support levy 2354 and Training Reassessments 2353-4 Program Analysis, Co-ordination and Support Right of appeal 2353 3618-23 Bill 82 Farm PracticesProtection and Consequential Game farming 4990 Amendments Act (Bill 82) CN Rail 2r 4185-7, 4891 -2 Producer car drop off 2257 Health, Departmentof (Supply) Childs Lake Continuing Care Programs Water level 2466 Administration 2674-9 Crop insurance Housing, Departmentof (Supply) Big game/waterfowl damage 41 01-2 Transfer Payments to Manitoba Housing and Decentralization Renewal Corporation Relocation statistics3850 4400-2 Status report3582 Labour Relations Amendment Act (Bill 85) Duck Mountain 2r 5148-9 Co-Management agreements 2466 Ministerial statements Economicgrowth, rural Alco Rural Development Bond Corporation Employment creation strategy 3581 Response 49 Education system Rural EconomicDevelopment Initiative Curriculum development 179 Response 2202-3 Funding formula-rural schools 179 Municipal Assessment Amendment Act (Bill 20) Electrical ConstructionJourneymen 2r 867-9; 3r 5395-6 Examinationstandards 4885-6 Municipal Assessment Amendment Act (2) (Bill 99) Fisheries industry 1r4543; Rough fish market 1163-4 Natural Resources, Department of (Supply) GrossRevenue Insurance Program Regional Operations Coverage levels Headquarters Operations 4960-1 Risk areas 2795 Resource Programs Highway maintenance Lands Responsibility 1472 CrownLands Administration 4980-1 Highway map, provincial Parks and Natural Areas Exclusions21 97-8 Park Operations and Maintenance4976 Home care program Water Resources Alternative services556-7, 3172 Water Licensing and Approvals 4966-7 Decision-making process 1421 Water Management 4971 Employee intimidation 1420 Nonpolitical statements Privatization 1657 Associated Country Women of theWorld Day Service reduction 556, 1420, 1657-8, 3171 2751 Services, listof 3171-2 Swan River Metis FriendshipCentre Infrastructures-Rural First Annual Square Dance Competition 3372 Responsibility 688-9

191 Hansard Index

Wowchuk, Rossnn - Cont. Wo wchuk, Rossnn - Cont. Lake Winnipegosis Daycare, rural 3884-6 Cormorant population control 3416 Grow Bonds 3567-70 Trap net policy 1164 Ukraine, independence of 3199-200 Manitoba Housing Authority Video lottery terminals 2642-4 Clarification 3900 Women, violence against 4036 Parkland district 797-8 Rural Development, Departmentof (Supply) Seniors' services 3896 Administration and Finance Staffing 3896 Brandon Office 3445-6 Municipal assessments Executive support Delays 4203-4 Salaries 3444 Right to appeal 4204 Finance and AdministrativeServices 3448 Policing servicesagreement Human Resource Management 3447 Fee-for-servicecosts 4302 Local GovernmentServices Division Impact on Rural Manitoba 4302, 51 74 Executive Administration 3466-72 Municipal costs 873-4 Municipal Advisory and Rnancial Services Regional development corporations Grants to Municipalities in Lieu of Taxes Funding 1472, 3582, 3850-1 Salaries 3473-5 Repap Manitoba Inc. Police Services Grants 3477-8 Contractual obligations 267 TransitGrants 3476-7 Cuttingarea 825 Lotteries Funded Programs Employment creation 266-7 Grow Bonds Program 3491-3 Environmental assessment 267 Rural Economic Development Initiatives 3494-5 Swan River area 2580-1 Municipal Board 3448-9 Rural economicdevelopment Opening remarks Government initiatives 1473 Response 3428-9, 3441 -3 Minister's commitment 5404 Provincial Planning Video lottery revenues 5404 Salaries 3449-50, 3462-5 Rural Development, Minister of Rural Economic Development Division School board interference 4545-6 Community Development School boards Salaries 3490 Political interference 4501 Economic Development Services Swan Valley School Division Salaries 3482 Distance EducationProgram 2688-9 Infrastructure 3481 Video lotteryreve nues Social Allowances Amendment and Consequential Green Team program 5267 Amendments Act (Bill 70) Petitions 2r 491 5-8 Housing authorities Supply, Capital Volunteer boards Supply, Committee of 5347-50, 5357-8 1155; ruled in order 1174 SurveysAmendment Act (Bill 34) 1604; ruled in order 1653 2r 741-3 1701 ; ruled in order 1770 Tabled papers 2074; ruled in order 2101-2 Decentralization Private Members' Business Rural civil service statistics (T.P. 120) 3851 Address for Papers Home care program Public Health Amendment Act Correspondence (T.P. 38) 1657 Legal opinion 3882-4 Throne speech debate Resolutions 305-1 1

192 Hansard Index

Wo wchuk, Rossnn - Cont. Wright, Amanda Urgent Public Importance, Matter of See Nonpolitical statements Economic crisis 439-42 Yes, I Can Awards See Nonpolitical statements

193 Appendices

APPENDIX A Oral Questions

Agriculture, Departmentof Agriculture , Department of- Cont. Agricultural industry Downey 2593; Findlay 3537; Diversification Plohman 2593, 3536-7 Findlay 1424, 4990; Gaudry 1424; Gross Revenue Insurance Program Wowchuk 4990 Contractvalidity Financial assistance Findlay 1324; Plohman 1324 Findlay 54-5, 728-9; Plohman 54-5, 728-9 Coverage levels Net farm income Lentils Manness 3894; Plohman 3893-4 Findlay 2794; Plohman 2793-4 Agricultural laboratories Risk area 12 Privatization Findlay 2741-2, 2744, 2795; Gaudry 2744; Findlay 3985-6; Plohman 3985 Manness 2741-2; Plohman 2741-2: Agricultural land Wowchuk 2795 Conservation methods Southwest Manitoba Findlay 2307; Gaudry 2306-7 Findlay 4279-80; Plohman 4279 Sustainable development Government position Findlay 2:307;Gaudry 2307 Findlay 226; Plohman 226 Agricultural Ministers' Meeting Legal opinion request Agenda Findlay 1472; Plohman 1471-2 Findlay 3894; Plohman 3894 Marketing boards Crop insurance Carstairs 295; Findlay 295 Big game/waterfowl damage Notification deadline Findlay 41 01-2; Wowchuk 41 01-2 Findlay 1471 ; Plohman 1471 Crop adjuster salaries Objectives Findlay 227; Plohman 227 Findlay 4279;Plohman 4279 Crow benefit Premium levels Governmentposition Findlay 227, 1262-3, 1323-4, 1472; Findlay 360-1; Plohman 360-1 Plohman 226-7, 1262-3, 1323, 1472 Payment plan Manitoba Agricultural Credit Corporation Findlay 3268-9, 3578-9; Plohman 3268, 3578-9 Interest rates Public hearings Findlay 1262; Plohman 1262 Findlay 361 ; Plohman 361 North American Free Trade Agreement Farm practices legislation Agricultural industry Environmental guidelines Connery 1373; Findlay 1373 Findlay 4604-5; Plohman 4604-5 Supply management Game farming Findlay 1778-9; Plohman 1778-9 Findlay 4990; Wowchuk 4990 Portof Churchill General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade Rail line protection Supply management proposal Findlay 1020; Plohman 1020-1 Doer 597-8; Findlay 404-5, 597-8, 627; Processing potato producers Plohman 404-5, 627 Marketing board Grain exports-U.S. Findlay 3537; Plohman 3537 Licensing process Soil Testing Laboratory

194 Appendices

Agriculture , Department of - Cont. Civil Service Commission - Cont. Privatization results Education and Training, Departmentof Findlay 3986; Plohman 3986 Hiring authority Soils and Crops branch Ashton 178; Filmon 178 Budget Government ministers Findlay 1423; Gaudry 1423 Hiring authority University of Manitoba Doer 468-9; Downey 469 Agricultural research Hay Commission Report Findlay 1424; Gaudry 1423-4 Governmentresponse Vegetable producing industry Lamoureux 1053; Praznik 1053 Day haul worker program-Federal Manitoba Lotteries Foundation Connery 1373; Findlay 1373 Hiring process-investigation U.S. inspections Lamoureux 3987; Praznik 3987 Connery 1373; Findlay 1373 Multicultural legislation Veterinary Drug Centre Affirmative Action, impact on Privatization results Cerilli 4429-30; Praznik 4429-30 Findlay 3986; Plohman 3986 Political interference Western Premiers' Conference Ashton 57, 177-8; Filmon 57, 58; Agricultural issues Lamoureux 55-6, 58; Praznik 55-6, 57, 177-8 Filmon 3414-5; Plohman 3414-5 Voluntary incentive program Crow benefit Alcock 1115; Praznik 1115 Findlay 3269; Plohman 3269 Wild Kingdom Zoo-Dauphin Inhumane treatment of animals Constitutional Affairs Findlay 4882-3; Plohman 4882-3 Constitutional proposal Aboriginal representation Carstairs 873; McCrae 873 Civil Service Commission All-partycomm ittee Affirmative Action Doer 819, 3085-6; Filmon 819, 3085-6 Co-ordinator Areas of agreement Cerilli 4430; Praznik 4430 Carstairs 4276-7; McCrae 4277 Budget Bilateral negotiations-Quebec Civil service layoffs Carstairs 872-3; McCrae 872-3 Ashton 1182-3; Praznik 1182-3 Cultural programs, devolution of Bulletins Friesen 4506-7; Mitchelson 4506-7 Term positions Delegation of powers Lamoureux 3986; Praznik 3986 Carstairs 4203; Doer 4095-6; Downey 4095-6; Civil servants McCrae 4203 Layoffs Governmentposition Alcock 1115-6; Manness 1115-6; Carstairs 4738-9; McCrae 4738-9 Plohman 1116; Praznik 1116 Legal opinion request Senior salary levels Doer 3084-5; Filmon 3085 Ashton 473-4;Pra znik 474 Multiculturalism Westman region positions Carstairs 5405-6; Film on 5406 Downey 3645; L. Evans 3645 Multilateral discussions Decentralization Carstairs 822-3; Filmon 823 Status report National programs, protection of Plohman 1117; Praznik 1117 Doer 4735-7; Filmon 4735-7

195 Appendices

ConstitutionalAff airs - Cont. Consumerand CorporatflAffairs - Cont. National standards Maloway 3042; Mcintosh 3042 Carstairs 4599-600; McCrae 4600-1 Public utilities News briefing request Customer refunds Carstairs 4277-8; McCrae 4278 Maloway2994 ; Mcintosh 2994 Notwithstanding clause Lock-offst atistics Carstairs 4164-5; McCrae 4164-6 Maloway 2993; Mcintosh2993 Public hearings Rent Regulation Bureau Carstairs 4739, 5405; Doer 3982; Director's status Downey 3982-3; Filmon4739, 5405 Martindale2879; Mcintosh 2879-80 Referendum Rent regulations Carstairs 823, 3088, 4098-9, 4203; Enforcement Doer 820-1 , 4499-500;Do wney 4098-9; Cheema 1659; Mcintosh 1659 Filmon 821 , 823-4, 3088, 4499-500; Legal opinion request McCrae 4203 Cheema 1659; Mcintosh 1659 Renegotiation Rollbacks Carstairs 4883-4; Filmon4883-4 Martindale827, 875-6, 976-7; Senate reform Mcintosh 827,876, 977 Carstairs 3087-8, 4202; Filmon 3087-8; Residential Tenancies Amendment Act McCrae 4202 Proclamation Spending powers Martindale 472, 2879; Mcintosh 472-3, 2879 Carstairs 5405; Filmon 5404 Royal Canadian Mounted Police Timetable Confiscated liquor disposal Doer 4500; Filmon 4501 Mcintosh 798; Storie 798 Unity Committee Report Legal opinion request Doer 820; Filmon 820 Culture, Heritage and Citizenship, Departmentof Consumer and Corporate Affairs, Budget-Federal Departmentof Impact cultural programs Advertising, misleading Friesen 799-800; Mitchelson 799-800 Consumer protection Culture, Heritage and Citizenship, Minister of Edwards 124-5; Mcintosh 125 Hiring authority Business PracticesAct Filmon 1054; Lamoureux 1054 Restitution Farm Lands Ownership Board Maloway 626, 692; Mcintosh 626, 692 Report production costs Consumer protection Edwards 228; Mitchelson 228, 268 Legislation Foreign domestic workers Maloway 626; Martindale 977; Deportationintervention Mcintosh 626, 977 Lamoureux 3897; Mitchelson 3897 Gas utilities Investigations Monthly fixed charge Cerilli 3895-6; Mitchelson 3895-6 Maloway 227-8; Mcintosh 227-8 Foreign Domestic Workers' Program Odometertampering Governmentaccess Consumer warning Cerilli 3534; Mitchelson 3534 Maloway 626, 691-2, 755-6; Government position Mcintosh 626, 691-2, 755-6 Cerilli 1021-2; Lamoureux 1160-1 ; Royal Canadian Mounted Police Mitchelson 1 022, 1160-1

196 Appendices

Culture, Heritage and Citizenship - Cont. Culture, Heritage and Citizenship - Cont. Minister's consultations Government support Cerilli 3534; Mitchelson 3534 Mitchelson 4207; Render 4206 Minister's correspondence Lamoureux 3274, 3897; Mitchelson 3274, 3897 Heritage community Education and Training, Departmentof Funding reduction ACCESS programs Friesen 4989; Mitchelson4989 Funding reductions Granting process Friesen 3169; Voclrey31 69-70 Filmon 2693; Lamoureux 2576, 2693; Governmentaction Mitchelson 2576 Doer 4570; Filmon 4570-1 Public consultations Premier's discussions Friesen 3584; Mitchelson 3584 Doer 4569-70; Filmon 4570 Immigration policy Budget Government recommendations Education, post-secondary Cerilli 4879; Mitchelson 4879 Doer 1109; Filmon 1109; Manness 1109 Refugee claimants Student aid Cerilli 4880; Mitchelson 4880 Alcock 975; Voclrey 975 Manitoba Heritage Federation Child Guidance Clinic Correspondencerequest Funding formula Friesen 4990; Mitchelson 4990 Chomiak 4306; Voclrey4307 Funding decisions Government position Lamoureux 1418; Mitchelson 1418 Chomiak 3897, 3959, 4307; Manness 3897-8; Granting authority Voclrey3959-60, 4307 Friesen 3584; Lamoureux 1372, 2575-6; Service replacement Mitchelson 1372, 2576, 3584 Chomiak 1261-2; Voclrey12 61-2 Information tabling request College Louis Riel Friesen 3584;Mitchelson 3584 Admission policy Meeting cancellations Derkach 357-8; Harper 357-8 Friesen 2580; Mitchelson 2580 Community colleges Meeting requests Accessibility Friesen 2355; Mitchelson 2355 Carstairs 2852; Friesen 601 ; Voclrey 601 , 2852 Minister's support Alternatives Lamoureux 4281 ; Mitchelson 4281 Friesen 1755; Voclrey 1755 Peer review Applied Sciences courses Friesen 2356; Mitchelson 2356 Doer 1109-10; Manness 1110 Political interference Employment training initiatives Friesen 2580; Mitchelson 2580 Carstairs 2079; Voclrey2079 Role Enrolment Lamoureux 1418; Mitchelson 141 8-9 Carstairs 2851-2; Vodrey2852 Volunteer role Funding Friesen 2580; Lamoureux 1372; Filmon 1708; Friesen 601 , 1050, 1708, 1755; Mitchelson 1372, 2580 Voclrey 601 , 1050, 1755 Property rights proposal Funding restoration Legal opinion request Friesen 874; Voclrey 874 Friesen 800; Mitchelson 800 Student appeal process The Diviners Carstairs 559; Voclrey 559-60

197 Appendices

EducaUon and Training - Cont. EducaUon and Training - Cont. Core Area Initiative Derkach 179-80; Wowchuk 179 Education program Grade 10 curriculum changes Friesen 1230; Vodrey 1230 Carstairs 4571 -2; Chomiak 4576; Domestic violence Vodrey 4572, 4576 Pedlar Reportrec ommendations Program reductions Barrett4884-5; Vodrey 4884-5 Chomiak 174-5; Derkach 174-5 Education, aboriginal School closures Post-secondary accessibility Guideline review Friesen 600; Vodrey 600-1 Carstairs 2592; Vodrey 2592 Education and Training, Departmentof School year length Underspending Chomiak 2358; Vodrey 2359 Alcock 975; Vodrey 975 Special needs funding Education and Training, Deputy Minister of Chomiak 876; Vodrey 876 Salary increase Student achievement levels Chomiak 2509; Vodrey 2509 Carstairs 3848-9; Vodrey 3849 Education and Training, Minister of Taxation level Resignation request Chomiak 175; Derkach 175 Filmon 57-8; Lamoureux 57 Transportation policy review Education, post-secondary Carstairs 2592; Vodrey 2592 Accessibility Vocational training Carstairs 2462; Friesen 874, 5407; Carstairs 3848; Vodrey 3848 Vodrey 874, 2462, 5407 Educational facilities Funding restoration St. James Seniors' Group usage Friesen 1050; Vodrey 1050 Edwards 1159; Vodrey 1159 Tuition fee increases Employment retraining programs Alcock 1182; Vodrey 1182 Governmentcommitment Education Reform, Panel on Carstairs 2461 ; Vodrey 2461-2 Reportrelease Governmentinitiatives Chomiak 3990; Vodrey 3990 Friesen 727-8; Vodrey 727-8 Education system Governmentstrat egy Administrative costs Friesen 4300; Vodrey4300 Carstairs 2793; Vodrey 2793 Executive support Child Guidance Clinic Salary increases Chomiak 4576; Vodrey 4577 Chomiak 2509; Vodrey 2509 Curriculum development Family life education Carstairs 2792-3; Derkach 179; Compulsory curriculum Vodrey 2793; Wowchuk17 9 Carstairs 3321 ; Vodrey 3321 Dropout rate Francophone Schools Governance Chomiak 2352, 2358, 2792, 3321-2; Legal opinion request Vodrey 2352, 2358, 2792, 3322 Filmon 1759; Gaudry 1758-9 Exceptional student programs funding Immigrant credentials Carstairs 3848;Vodrey 3848 Working group Funding formula Derkach 360; Santos 360 Chomiak 792-3, 1020, 1112-3; Doer 171-2; Labour Force Development Agreement Filmon 171-!:l; Government participation Vodrey792-3 , 1020, 1112-3 Friesen 5169; Vodrey 5169-70 Funding formula-ruralschools National standards

198 Appendices

Education and Training - Cont. Education and Training - Cont. Carstairs 5170; Vodrey51 70 Chomiak 2021 ; Vodrey 2021 Labour forcedevelopment boards Small School Rural Workshops Announcement Cancellation Friesen 4886;Vodrey 4886 Chomiak 469-70; Vodrey470 Mystery Lake School Division Social assistance-students Funding Reductions Ashton 2309; Vodrey2309 Derkach 179; Hickes 178-9 Meeting request Student aid Ashton 2309; Vodrey 2309 Appeal process Red River Community College Carstairs 2876; Vodrey 2876 Funding Application statistics Filmon 1707; Friesen 1707 Carstairs 2875; Vodrey 2875 Nursing curriculum Clarification Carstairs 1601 ; Vodrey 161 0 Vodrey 977 Red Sucker Lake, Manitoba Emergency assistance School closure Carstairs 2462; Vodrey2462 Harper 4742-3; Vodrey4743 Funding St. Vital School Division Carstairs 2875; Vodrey2875 Funding formula Swan Valley School Division Chomiak 792-3; Vodrey793 Distance Education Program School boards Vodrey2688-9; Wo wchuk 2688-9 Political interference Universities Filmon 4501 ; Vodrey45 01; Wowchuk 4501 Departmental review School Division Boundary Review Friesen2463; Vodrey 2463 Cancellation Funding formula Carstairs 1369-70; Filmon 1369-70 Derkach 173-4;Friesen 173 Commitment Levels of instruction Carstairs 2592-3; Vodrey2593 Friesen 2463 ; Vodrey 2463 Impact Francophone School Governance Review Carstairs 1370; Vodrey 1370 Friesen 5407; Vodrey 5407 School divisions Tuition fees Election postponement Friesen 2462; Vodrey 2462 Chomiak 600;Vodrey 600 University of Manitoba French language division Student food bank Chomiak 600; Vodrey600 Alcock 975; Vodrey 975 Funding formula Student safety Carstairs 1164-5; Vodrey 1164-5 Barrett 1761-2; Vodrey 1761-2 Information delivery University Education Review Commission Carstairs 3675-6; Vodrey3675-6 Implementation Schools, independent Friesen 2689;Vodrey 2689 Agreement tabling request Chomiak 1422; Vodrey 1422 Energy and Mines, Department of Funding formula Energy conservation Chomiak 1112, 1422, 1469-70, 1760; Funding Vodrey 1112, 1422-3, 1470, 1760 Downey 1231 ; Hickes 1231 Schools, public Governmentstra tegy Enrolment decline Downey 1231 ; Hickes 1231

199 Appendices

Energy end Mines - Cont. Environment- Cont. Mining communities FederaVProvincial review Employment retraining program Cummings 926; C. Evans 926 Downey 2990; Storie2990 Jurisdiction Equity insurance Cerilli 2464; Cummings 2464 Downey 2990-1; Storie 2990 Treaty land entitlements Exploration Cerilli 2464;Cumm ings 2464 Downey 2988;Storie 2988 Associationfor a Clean Rural Environment Government initiatives Environment Act violation Downey 2987-8;Storie 2987 Cummings 1778; Gaudry 1778 Mining Community Reserve Fund Pesticide container disposal Snow Lake, Manitoba Cummings 1778; Gaudry 1777-8 Filmon 2989-90; Storie 2989 Review Single-industrytowns Cummings 1778; Gaudry 1778 Equity insurance BFI Waste Systems Downey 1613, 2253-4; Storie 1613, 2253-4 Landfill site Snow Lake, Manitoba Cummings 1114; Edwards 1113-4 Labour adjustment committee Beer industry Neufeld 294;Storie 294 U.S. aluminum containers Mineral exploration Cerilli 1115; Cummings 1115 Neufeld 295; Storie 295 Beverage containers Tantalum Mining Corporation Deposit system Contract negotiations Carstairs 1421-1 ; Filmon 1421-2 Downey 3139; Storie 3139 Bristol Aerospace Ltd. Employment protection Chemical burning Downey 3139-40; Storie 3139-40 Cummings 824; Dewar 824 Environmental concerns Environment, Departmentof Cummings 824; Dewar 824 Abitibi-Price-Pine Falls Cleanup costs De-inking plant Cummings 4281 ; Dewar 4281 Cummings 4207-8; Edwards 4207 Pipeline Licensing process Boundary review Carstairs 3954-5; Cummings 3955 Cummings 4281 ; Dewar 4281 Mediation process Environmental concerns Carstairs 3954; Cummings 3954 Cummings 4281 ; Dewar 4281 Ashern, Manitoba Waste rocket fuel burning Alternate water source Cummings 1607; Edwards 1607 Cummings 4986-7; C. Evans 4986 Waste rocket fuel disposal Environmental concerns Cummings 1608; Edwards 1607-8 Cummings 4986; C. Evans 4986 Clean Environment Commission Ground water contamination Funding Cummings 2877; C. Evans 2877 Cummings 1230-1 ; Edwards 1230-1 Soil/water testing Jurisdiction C. Evans 4986; Cummings 4986 Cummings 3951-2; Doer 3951 -2 Assiniboine River Diversion Provincial park land usage Environmental assessment-federal Cummings 969-70; Doer969- 70; Cerilli 24n3-4; Cummings 2464; Manness 970-1 Doer 3577-8; Downey 3577-8 Conawapa dam project

200 Appendices

Environment- Cont. En vironment- Cont. Economic viability Grand Rapids, Manitoba Cummings 359; Edwards 359 Environmental monitoring Environmental delay Cummings 41 67; Lathlin 4167 Cummings 359; Edwards 359 Grand Rapids Generating Station Environmental panel Environmental concerns Jurisdiction Cummings 3319; Lathlin 3318-9 Cummings3952-3; Doer3952-3; Oil spill Filmon 3953-4 Cummings 1161 ; Lathlin 1161 Report Stability Cummings 4574-5; Edwards 4574-5 Cummings 4167; Lathlin 4167 Intervenerfunding Hazardous waste Cummings 4575; Edwards 4575 Contaminated soil Public Utilities Board Cummings 4435-6;Edwards 4435-6 Referral Pesticide container classification Cerilli 872; Cummings 872 Cummings 2355; Gaudry 2355 Dauphin Lake Lakes and rivers Environmental concerns Copper sulphate buildup Cerilli 3651 ; Cummings 3651 Cerilli 2016-7; Cummings 2017 Domtar site Manitoba Hazardous Waste Management Corp. Cleanup Negotiations-R.M. of Montcalm Cerilli 293-4;Cummings 293-4 Cummings 926; Laurendeau 926 Soil testing costs PCB storage site Cerilli 4204-5; Cummings 4204-5 Cummings20 81 -2; Edwards 2081 -2 Earth Summit Mining operations Communicationswith the Premier Dust control Cerilli 4276; Cummings 4276 Cummings 4991 ; Storie 4990-1 Governmentagenda Natural Resources, Department of Doer 3672; Filmon 3672-3 Waste dumping-Winnipeg Aoodway Manitoba delegation Cummings 4301 ; Gaudry 4301 Doer 3673-4; Filmon3674 Nopiming Park-Forestry Endangered spaces Environmental mediator Tall grass prairie program Cummings 2199; Edwards 2199 Cerilli 1658; Cummings 1658 Land division Environmental legislation Cummings 2200; Edwards21 99-2200 Government strategy Negotiations Cummings 3650-1 ; Edwards 3650-1 Cummings 2199; Edwards 2199 Justification Oak Hammock Marsh Cummings 3650; Edwards 3650 Ducks Unlimited complex Environmentalists Cerilli 2080-1 ; Cummings 1912-3, 2080-1 ; Minister's position Doer 1911-2, 3673; Filmon 1911-2, 3673 Cummings 359; Edwards 359 Sewage treatment Farm practices legislation Cerilli 1914-5; Cummings 191 4-5 Mandate Ozone Depleting Substances Act Cummings 3680;Plohman 3680 Enforcement795 Government reports Pesticide usage Environment friendly products Biologicalalternatives Cummings 228;Edwards 228 Cerilli 4987-8; Cummings 4988

201 Appendices

Environment- Cont. En vironment- Cont. Environmental licensing Manitoba regulations Cerilli 4987; Cummings 4987 Cummings 21 05-6; Doer 21 05 Malathion Minister's communications Cerilli 4988; Cummings 4988 C�mmings 21 04-5; Doer 2104-5 Prime Oil Company Negotiations-Ontario Work order extension Cummings 2506; Doer 2506 Cerilli 556; Cummings 556 Premier's discussions Pur-A-Tone Hog Operation Doer 2506; Filmon 2506 Environmental concerns Stony Mountain, Manitoba Cummings 3679; Plohman 3679 Environmental concerns Rafferty-Alameda dam project Cummings 476-7, 689; Edwards476, 689 Environment, Minister of Funding Involvement Cummings 690; Edwards 690 Cummings 3272-3; Edwards 3272-3 Funding-Federal Renegotiation Cummings 689; Edwards689 Cummings 3272; Edwards 3272 Sustainable development Recycling, glass Governmentcommitment Cerilli 795; Cummings 795 Cummings 1231; Edwards 1231 Contractconsu ltations Tender process Cerilli 2746; Cummings 2746 Review Recycling, newspaper Cerilli 2746; Cummings 2746 Cerilli 795; Cummings 795 Waste oil disposal Recycling programs Reporttabling request Distributor's costs Cummings 4207; Edwards 4207 Cerilli 4550; Cummings 4550 Waste oil disposal Soil contamination Cerilli 4349-50; Cummings 4550 Cerilli 4550; Cummings 4550 Repap Manitoba Inc. Water and waste water management Bunker tank relocation Certificate program Carstairs 794; Cummings 794-5 Cerilli 3044-5; Cummings 3045 Environmentalinspection Water and Waste Water School Carstairs 794; Cummings 794 Government support Round Table on the Environment Cerilli2994, 3044; Cummings 2995, 3044 Projectreview process Work order enforcement Doer 514-6; Filmon 515-7 Cerilli 556; Cummings 556 Sewage lagoon-Oak Point Environmental concerns ExecutiveCouncil Cerilli2796-7; Cumm ings 2797 FirstMinis ters' Conference Environmental impact assessment Education and training initiative Cerilli 2797; Cummings 2797 Carstairs 290, 1494; Filmon 290-1 , 1494 Licensing process Employment creation strategy Cummings 2798; Edwards 2797-8 L. Evans 355-6; Filmon 355-6 Public hearings Goodsand servicestax elimination Cerilli 2797; Cummings 2797-8; Edwards 2798 L. Evans 1498; Filmon 1498 Shoal Lake, protection of Governmentagenda Environmental review process Alcock 264-5;Carstairs 290, 1493; Doer 2506-7; Filmon2507 Filmon 264-5, 290,14 93-4

202 Appendices

Family Services, Departmentof Family Services - Cont. Aboriginal Child and Family Services Resources Independent review Barrett20 15; Gilleshammer 201 5 Barrett4740 ; Gilleshammer 4740 Response time Internal review Barrett20 14; Gilleshammer 2014-5 Barrett4739- 40; Gilleshammer 4740 Child day care Public inquiry Centre licensing Carstairs 3790-1 ; Gilleshammer 3790-1 Barrett358; Gilleshammer 358 Anishinaabe Child and Family Services Fee schedule Funding formula Barrett16 07; Gilleshammer 1607 Carstairs 52-3 ; Gilleshammer 52-3 Funding - Federal Bill 70 Barrett 359; Gilleshammer 359 Amendments Funding formula Gilleshammer 2799, 3674; Barrett358; Gilleshammer 358 Martindale 2799, 3674 Governmentpolicy Cost savings Barrett 1606; Gilleshammer 1606 National strategy Carstairs 21 08-9;Gilleshammer 2109 Government support Financial impact study request Barrett725- 6; Filmon 725-6 Doer 4298-9; Downey 4300; Special needs children Gilleshammer 4299 Carstairs 4988; Gilleshammer 4988-9 Justification Child day care centres Gilleshammer 41 03; Martindale41 03 Funding formula Broadway House Carstairs 1050; Gilleshammer 1050-1 Alternate facility Private centres Barrett 1374; Gilleshammer 137 4 Governmentsupport Closure Barrett 2597;Gilleshammer 2597 Barrett13 74; Gilleshammer 1374 Restraining order enforcement Employees' status Carstairs 2352-3; Gilleshammer 2352-3 Barrett 1374; Gilleshammer 1374 Staff layoffs CRISP program Carstairs 1051 ; Gilleshammer 1051 Funding Subsidized space allocation Filmon 1324-5; Lamoureux 1324 Carstairs 1051 ; Gilleshammer 1051 CareerStartprogram Child daycare workers Centralized administration Salary enhancement grants L. Evans 1180; Gilleshammer 1180 Barrett2596-7 ; Gilleshammer 2597 Funding Child development initiative L. Evans 1180, 2107, 2874; Per capita policy Gilleshammer 1180, 2874; Manness 21 07 Barrett 3170-1 ; Gilleshammer 3171 Funding restoration Child poverty L. Evans 1326; Gilleshammer 1326 Federal Minister's statements Status report Barrett 3170; Gilleshammer 3170 L. Evans 2875; Gilleshammer 2875 Governmentinitiatives Child and Family Services Doer 262-3; Filmon 262-3 Accountability Children's Advocate Carstairs 3269; Filmon 3269 Mandate Communication process Barrett2880; Gilleshammer 2880 Carstairs 2015-6; Gilleshammer 2015-6 Reporting process

203 Appendices

Family Services - Cont. Family Services - Cont. Alcock 1228; Carstairs 1257, 2016, 3270; Independent Living Program Gilleshammer 1228, 1257, 2016, 3270 Accommodation selection Children's residential facilities Barrett4505; Gilleshammer 4505 Curriculum uommittee -- Case review Barrett3900; Gilleshammer 3900 Barrett 4505-6; Gilleshammer 4506 Custodydispute Cost effectiveness Dauphin, Manitoba Carstairs 4502; Gilleshammer 4502 Gilleshammer 4435; Plohman4434-5 Statistics Decentralization Carstairs 4501 ; Gilleshammer 4501 Brandon, Manitoba Inner-city recreation programs L Evans 1053; Gilleshammer 1053 Governmentsupport Disabled employees Gilleshammer 2851 ; Martindale2851 Employment standards Lindenview Residence Ashton 3988; Gilleshammer 3988 Funding decrease Employability Enhancement Programs Barrett4099; Gilleshammer 4099, 4169 Funding Review Barrett2250 ; Carstairs 2252-3; Aboriginal agencies, relations with Gilleshammer 2250-1 , 2252-3 Carstairs 4880-1 ; Gilleshammer 4880-1 Employment programs SARC report Hiring priority Recommendations Gilleshammer 2851 ; Martindale 2851 Gilleshammer 3675; Martindale 3675 Employment programs, youth Service de Conseiller NorthernManitoba Funding L Evans 2875; Gilleshammer 2875 Barrett3957-8 ; Gilleshammer 3958 Employment Resources Regional Offices Seven Oaks Centre for Youth Closure Closure L Evans 1052-3, 1179; Alcock 1227; Carstairs 1256; Gilleshammer 1053, 1179 Gilleshammer 1227-8, 1256-7 Family Services, Departmentof Lengthof stay Internal review Carstairs 4303-4; Gilleshammer 4303-4 Carstairs3270 ; Filmon 3270 Social assistance Food banks Alternative Increased use L Evans 356; Filmon 356 Gilleshammer 263-4; Martindale263 Benefit cap Foster care Gilleshammer 1256; Martindale 1256 Parental training program CRISP benefits Carstairs 3143-4; Gilleshammer 3143-4 Gilleshammer 1256; Martindale 1256 Standards review Common law regulation Carstairs 3144;Gilleshammer 3144 Gilleshammer 1776; Martindale 1776 Human Resources Opportunity Centre Discrimination Closure Gilleshammer 1776; Martindale 1776 Dewar 1371-2, 1972-3, 21 08, 3091 ; Employment creation strategy Gilleshammer 1371-2, 1972-3, 2108, 3092 L Evans 2107-8, 2251 -2; Funding restoration Gilleshammer 1255, 2251 -2; Filmon 2080; Martindale 2080 Filmon 2079-10; Manness21 07-8; Serviceexpansion Martindale 1255, 2079 Dewar 1371 ; Gilleshammer 1371-2 Employment training programs

204 Appendices

Family Services - Cont. Family Services - Cont. Carstairs 174; Gilleshammer 174 Ashton 51 14-5; Filmon 5115; Food allowance Gilleshammer 51 14-5 Carstairs 2988-9; Gilleshammer 2988-9, 41 02-3; Martindale 4102 Finance, Departmentof Governmentpriorities Budget Gilleshammer 730; Martindale730 Construction industry Head of household regulation L. Evans 1326; Manness 1326 Gilleshammer 5175; Martindale 51 75 Crop insurance Off-reserve status indians Downey 924; Manness 924; Plohman 923-4 Ashton 2596; Downey 2596; Economic growth L. Evans 2357-8, 2466-7, 3142-3; Manness 921 ; Storie 921 Gilleshammer 2358, 2467, 2596, 2798-9, Education and training 3142-3; Martindale 2798 Doer 920; Manness 920 Provincial tax credit Employment creation strategy Carstairs 356-7;Gill eshammer 356-7 Doer 401, 91 9-20, 1 013-4; L. Evans 1325; Rate increase Filmon 1014-5; Gilleshammer 264; Martindale264 Manness 402, 920, 921 -2, 1325-6; Rent appeal intervention Storie 921 Gilleshammer 4989; Martindale 4989 Employment retraining programs Special needs Alcock 405-6; Man ness 406 Carstairs 357; Gilleshammer 357 Fiscal Stabilization Fund Social assistance-students Carstairs 1178; Manness 1178 Categorization Impact Carstairs 1755-6;Gilleshammer 1756 The Pas, Manitoba Common law regulation Lathlin 752; Manness 752 Gilleshammer 1710; Martindale 1710 Introduction date Increase Doer 354; Filmon 354 Gilleshammer 171 0; Martindale 1710 Revenue sources Reductions Manness 921 ; Storie 921 Hickes 179; Gilleshammer 179 Unemployment rate forecast Regulation changes Doer 920; Manness 920 Carstairs 1756; Gilleshammer 1756 Budget-Federal Suche Report Education, post-secondary Governmentresponse Alcock 729; Manness 729-30 Barrett3989; Gilleshammer 3989-90 Employment creation strategy Recommendations Doer 723; Filmon 723 Barrett2880; Gilleshammer 2880 Finance Minister's position Working committee Carstairs 726-7; Manness 726-7 Barrett 2880; Gilleshammer 2880 National Science Council Summer Challenge program Alcock 730; Filmon 730 Elimination Student aid Gilleshammer 2851 ; Martindale2851 Alcock 730; Vodrey730 Unemployment rate, youth Business relocations Governmentstrate gy Government discussions Carstairs 2196-7, 2252; L. Evans 2251 ; Filmon 3849;Storie 3849 Gilleshammer 2196-7, 2251 , 2252 Canada-U.S. trade deficit Programs funding Impact labour force

205 Appendices

Finance - Cont. Finance - Cont. Manness 1177; Storie 1177 Alcock 2690, 2849;Doer 2846-8, 3845-6; Canadian Centre for Disease Control L. Evans 5406; Filmon 2846-8, 2849,3845-7; Start date Manness 2690, 5406 Doer 724-5; Almon 724-5 Governmentpriorities Career Start Doer 220; Almon 220 Funding restoration Governmentstrategy L. Evans 973; Manness 973 Carstairs 289; Doer 16-7, 1966-7, 2013; Community colleges Downey 2013; Almon 17, 289; Enrolment L. Evans 3787-8; Manness 1229, 1966-8, Alcock 406; Manness 406 3787-8; Storie 1228 Conawapa dam project Government strategy-federal Public Utilities Board Doer 3529-30; Almon 3530 Referral Housing starts Cerilli 872; Manness 872 Alcock 2747; Manness 2747 Economic growth Interprovincial migration All-party task force L. Evans 1757; Manness 1757 Doer 1464-5; Almon 1464-6 Investment decline Anti-recession task force Alcock 265; Doer 2848-9; Almon 265, 2848-9 L. Evans 266; Almon 266 Manufacturing industry Average weekly incomes Doer 2986; L. Evans 3899; Almon 2986; Doer 3785-6; Filmon 3785-7 Manness 3899-900 Building permits Municipal public works program Alcock 2795-6; Manness 2795-6 L. Evans 3787; Manness 2787 Consumer confidence National average statistics L. Evans 3898-9; Manness 3898-9 Doer 1175-6; Manness 1175-6 Employment creation strategy Out-migration statistics Carstairs 174, 727; Doer 353, 400-1, 2014, Doer 2013-4; Downey 2014 2075-7, 3531, 3847; Downey20 14, 4097; Population statistics L. Evans 56, 131, 265; L. Evans 5406-7; Manness 5406-7 Filmon 265-6, 353-4, 727, 2075-7, 3531 , 3848, Private sector investment 3849-50;Manness 56, 131, 174, 400-1 , 1228; Alcock 3417-8; Doer 2985; Almon 2985, 3418 Storie 1228, 3849, 4097 Provincial comparisons Employment creation strategy-Federal Alcock 3318; L. Evans 56; Manness 57, 3318 Doer 3530; Almon 3530-1 Public consultations Employment statistics Doer 354-5;Almon 355 Alcock 3140-1, 3788; Doer 3137-9, 3786, 3846; Retail trade sector Almon 3137-9, 3140-1, 3786, 3846; Alcock 2594-5;Manness 2594-5 Manness 2788-9 Summit formation Forecast justification Doer 5402-3; Almon 5402-4 Carstairs 1178-9; Manness 1178-9 Economic summit Government forecast Implementation Doer 2874; Filmon 2874 Doer 2986-7; Almon 2987 Governmentinitiatives Education and Training, Department of Doer 2873-4; Almon 2873-4 Underspending Governmentpolicy Carstairs 922; Manness 922 L. Evans 1756-7; Manness 1757 Education, post-secondary Government policy performance Funding

206 Appendices

Finance - Cont. Finance - Cont. Alcock 1182; Manness 1182 Health care system, community-based Employment creation strategy Tax relief program Government commitment Carstairs 4431 ; Manness 4431 Filmon 1158; Storie 1158 Manitoba Blue Cross Governmentpriorities Tax increase Doer 1015; Filmon 1015 Manness 4170, 4208; Santos 4170, 4208 Northernprograms Manitoba Tax Assistance Office Ashton 1328; Manness 1328 Closure Employment retraining programs Barrett620-1 ; Doer 620; Manness 620-1 Funding Net income Carstairs 621-2; Manness 622 Provincial decline Federal Trade Tribunal Doer 50-1 ; Filmon 50-1 Manitoba cabinetmakers NorthAmerican Free Trade Agreement Alcock 41 02; Manness 4102 Justification Finance Ministers' meeting Manness 3645;Storie 3645 Government agenda NorthernYouth Corps Job Program Doer 220-1 ; Filmon 221 Funding restoration Labour adjustment strategy L. Evans 973; Manness 973-4 Carstairs 222; Filmon 222-3 Poverty rate Social programs Manitoba statistics Carstairs 222-3; Filmon222-3 Alcock 3317-8; Manness 3317-8 Free Trade Agreement Provincial Auditor's Report Abrogation Fiscal Stabilization Fund Manness3644; Storie 3643-4 Doer 288; Manness 288-9 Employment creation statistics Manitoba Data Services Alcock 3646;Manness 3644, 3646-7; Doer 287-8; Manness 288 Storie 3644 Provincial deficit Governmentsupport Clarification Alcock 3582-3; Manness3583-4 Alcock 687; Manness 687 Impact industrial production Increase Alcock 3583; Manness 3583 Alcock687; Carstairs 922; Manness 687, 922 Labour adjustment strategy Provincial revenues Alcock 3647; Manness 3647-8 Additional sources Goodsand Services Tax Carstairs 622; Manness 622 Harmonization Clarification Carstairs 402, 599; Doer 399; Downey 402; Manness 625 L. Evans 131; Filmon 599; Public capital investment Manness 131, 393-4, 402-3; Decline Wasylycia-Leis 598-9 Doer 1176; Filmon 1176-7 Impact manufacturing industry Recession Doer 400; Manness400 Social programs Reporttabling request Doer 619; Filmon 619-20 Carstairs 599-600; Filmon 599-600 Repap Manitoba Inc. Governmentof Canada Aboriginal land claims Untendered contracts Doer 750-1 ; Manness 751 Doer 2301-3; Downey 2392-3; Benefits to Manitoba Manness 2302 Carstairs 752-3; Manness 753

207 Appendices

Finance - Cont. Finance - Cont. Cuttingarea Manness 3650; Storie 3649-50 Doer 751 ; Manness 751 , 825; Wowchuk825 Western Premiers' Conference Employment creation strategy Regional development program Ashton 754-5; Carstairs 757, 1017; Lathlin 752; Doer 3266-7; Almon 3266-8 Manness 752, 754-5,757, 1017-8 Employment protection Government services, Department of Lathlin 752; Manness 752 Gimli Motorsport Park Expenditures Lease renewal, Minister's role in Carstairs 756; Manness 756 Ducharme 5172; Maloway 51 72 Anancial status Leasing Branch Carstairs 1016-7; Manness 1017 Consulting firm Renegotiations Doer 1320; Ducharme 1320 Carstairs 753-4; Doer 750; Lathlin 3045; Director dismissal Manness 750, 753-4, 3045 Doer 341 0; Ducharme 3410 Swan River area Information tabling request Manness 2580-1 ; Wowchuk 2580-1 Carstairs 1321-2; Ducharme 1322 Treaty land entitlements Internalaudit Lathlin 1113; Manness 1113 Doer 1255, 1655; Ducharme 1255; Woodlands division Ernst 1655 Job security RCMP investigation Ashton 1327-8; Manness 1328 Doer 1254-5, 1654-5; Ducharme 1254-5; Retail sales tax Ernst 1655 Statistics Report release Alcock 3789; Manness 3789 Doer 3410-1 ; Ducharme 3410 Retail trade sector Employment statistics Health, Departmentof L. Evans 131; Manness 131 AIDS education projects Sales decline Funding L. Evans 1497-8; Manness 1497-8 Orchard 4598-9; Wasylycia-Leis 4598-9 Statisticsdiscrepancy AIDS prevention programs Alcock 5265-6; Manness 5265-6 Street LINKS funding Small business Orchard 3648-9;Wa sylycia-Leis 3648-9 Government initiatives At-risk pregnancies Stefanson 1229; Storie 1229 Prevention programs Social assistance Orchard 4169-70; Wasylycia-Leis 4169 Abuse rate Bill C-20 Carstairs 174; Manness 174 Extension Student Temporary Employment Program Doer 685-6; Almon685-6 Funding restoration Government position L. Evans 974; Manness 974 Filmon 221-2; Wasylycia-Leis 221-2 The Pas, Manitoba Legal opinion Civil service positions Almon 222; Wasylycia-Leis 222 Lathlin 3045; Manness 3045-6 Bill C-22 Wang Canada Extension Government involvement Doer 5262-3; Almon 5262-4 Downey 3649;Manness 3649 Brandon General Hospital Untendered contract Budget reduction

208 Appendices

Health - Cont. Health - Cont. L. Evans 602; Orchard 602-3 Orchard 5171 -2; Wasylycia-Leis 5170-1 Funding Furnace inspections L. Evans 1773-4, 3088-9; Orchard 1774, Carbon monoxide levels 3088-9 Maloway 251 1-2; Orchard 2512 Labour adjustment strategy Health Advisory Network L. Evans 1774; Orchard 1775 Home care program Palliative care unit Orchard 3413; Wasylycia-Leis 3414 L. Evans 1165; Orchard 1165 Reportrelease Service reduction Orchard 3413; Wasylycia-Leis 341 3 L. Evans 560, 603, 3089; Orchard 560, 603, Health care facilities 3089 Bed closures Brandon Mental Health Centre Cheema 1111-2, 1470; Replacement facility Orchard 878, 1111-2, 1466, 1470, 1492-3, Cheema 341 5; Orchard 341 5-6 1772-3, 2017-8, 3087, 3141-2; Brandon School of Psychiatric Nursing Wasylycia-Leis 878, 1492-3, 1772-3, 2017-8, Closure 3087, 3141 -2 Dewar 1758; Orchard 1758 Funding Breast cancer Orchard 1181; Wasylycia-Leis 1181 Government initiatives Operating budgets Orchard 291 ; Wasylycia-Leis 291 Orchard 3166; Wasylycia-Leis 3166 Canada Health Act Health care system Tray fee regulation Anesthetist manpower review Cheema 2255-6; Orchard 2255-6 Cheema 2201 ; Orchard 1968-9, 2201 ; Child Guidance Clinic Wasylycia-Leis 1968-9 Audiology program Anesthetist shortage Chomiak 3172-3; Orchard 3172-3 Cheema 177; Orchard 177 Children's Dental Health Program CT scanners Service reduction Fundraising Orchard 2850; Wasylycia-Leis 2850 Orchard 2303-4; Wasylycia-Leis 2303-4 Deer Lodge Hospital Cataractsurgery Bed closures Cheema 826; L. Evans 1661-2; Orchard 826, Orchard 3322-3; Wasylycia-Leis 3322 1661-2 Depo-Provera De insurance Licence approval Cheema 2510-1 ; Orchard 2510-1 ; Orchard 291 ; Wasylycia-Leis 291 Wasylycia-Leis 2509-10 Diagnostic services Fee schedule reform Privatization Cheema 3677-8; Orchard 3678 Ashton 4740-1 ; Orchard 4741 Forensic services Drug patent law - Federal Dewar 4306; Orchard 4306 Government position Health Smart Card Doer 2589-90; Orchard 2590-1 Carstairs 3579-80;Orchard 3579-80 Governmentstrategy Hip/knee replacement surgery Orchard 2592; Storie 2591 -2 Cheema 826; Orchard 826 Impact on drug costs Labour adjustment strategy Orchard 2591 ; Storie 2591 Cheema 1471 ; Orchard 1471 Eating disorders Multicultural policy Treatment programs Cheema 51 15; Orchard 51 15-6 209 Appendices

Health - Cont. Health - Cont. Out-of-province patients Co-ordination Cheema 2304; Orchard 2304-5 Cheema 3091-2; Orchard 3091 -2 Public accountability De insurance Cheema 2106-7;Orcharcl 2106-7 Cbeema 22; Orchard 22-3 Spending decision Government agenda Orchard 1110-1 ; Wasylycia-Leis 1110-1 Orchard 3041 -2; Wasylycia-Leis 3040-1 Staff layoffs Release Doer 1223-5; Filmon 1223-6 Doer 3164-6; Almon 3165-6 Surgery waiting lists Health, Minister of Cheema 176-7;Orchard 176-7 Awareness Underspending Orchard 22; Wasylycia-Leis 22 Orchard 1180-1 ; Wasylycia-Leis 1180 Home care program User fees Cheema 3370; Orchard 3370-1 , 3534-5, Almon 598; Wasylycia-Leis 598 4431-2; Wasylycia-Leis 3534-5, 4431-2 Health care system, community-based Hospital closure Government initiatives Cheema 23; Orchard 23 Cheema 1471 ; Orchard 1471 Impact employment Governmentpolicy Orchard 3366; Wasylycia-Leis 3365-6 Cheema 1259; Almon 1259 Implementation Government priorities Carstairs 19; Cheema 4987; Cheema 1260-1 ; Almon 1261 Orchard 19, 3364, 3366,4987; Licensed Practical Nurses' role Wasylycia-Leis 3363-4, 3366 Cheema 3852; Orchard 3852 Information release Health care system, Northern Carstairs 19; Orchard 19 Mammography/chemotherapy services Meeting request Orchard 3580-1 ; Wasylycia-Leis 3580 Cheema 3167-8; Orchard 3167-8 Mortality rate Monitoring process Orchard3090; Storie 3090 Carstairs 3366-7, 3412-3, 3532-3; Transportationfee Cheema 4987; Orchard 3367, 3412-3, 3532-3, Ashton 878; Orchard 878-9, 3090-1 ; 4987 Storie 3090 Nursing education Health care system, reform Cheema 3851 ; Orchard 3851 Audiology services Patient protection Orchard 3680; Wasylycia-Leis 3680 Orchard 3364; Wasylycia-Leis 3364 Bed closures Professional training co-ordination Cheema 3370; Orchard 3323, 3370, 4572-3; Cheema 4550-1 ; Orchard 4551 Wasylycia-Leis 3323, 4572-3 Public awareness campaign Bridge funding Carstairs 51 12-3; Orchard 51 12-3 Carstairs 3367-8; Cheema 3371 ; Revenue-raising proposals Orchard 3368, 3371 Rlmon 127; Wasylycia-Leis 127 Community-based services St. John's Ambulance funding Orchard 3365; Wasylycia-Leis 3365 Orchard 3680; Wasylycia-Leis 3680 Consultations Specialty treatments Ashton 4741 ; Orchard 1492, 3167, 3365, 4741 Cheema 23; Orchard 23 Wasylycia-Leis 1492, 3167, 3365 U.S. residents, services to Continuing care Carstairs 19-20; Cheema 557-8; Carstairs 4430-1 ; Orchard 4430-1 Orchard 20, 21-2, 557-8;

210 Appendices

Health - Cont. Health - Cont. Wasylycia-Leis 21 Privatization Waiting lists review Orchard 1657; Wowchuk 1657 Carstairs 3533; Orchard 3533 Service reduction Health, Department of Orchard 556, 1419, 1420, 1657-8, 1659-60, Employee morale 3171 ; Plohman 1419; Orchard 975-6; Wasylycia-Leis 975-6 Wasylycia-Leis 1659-60; External agencies Wowchuk 556, 1420, 1657-8, 3171 Filmon 1325; Lamoureux 1325 Service reduction-Parkland region Underspending Orchard 1420; Plohman 1420 Carstairs 922; Orchard 922 Services, list of Health SciencesCentre Orchard 3172; Wowchuk 3171-2 Bed closures Whiteway, Nancy Orchard 1226-7, 1916-7; Orchard 623; Wasylycia-Leis 622-3 Wasylycia-Leis 1226-7, 191 6-7 Licensed Practical Nurses Knee/hip replacement surgery Educational opportunities Cheema 796-7;Orchard 796-7 Cheema 3898; Orchard 3898 Operating budget Governmentsupport Orchard 1181 , 1467; Wasylycia-Leis 1181 , Cheema 625-6, 874-5; Orchard 625-6, 875, 1467 877-8, 2745; Wasylycia-Leis 877-8, 2745 Operating room closure Red River Community College Orchard 1226; Wasylycia-Leis 1226 Orchard 2745; Wasylycia-Leis 2745 School of Nursing closure Lindenview Residence Orchard 4552; Wasylycia-Leis 4551 -2 Funding Hearing disorder screening Orchard 4170; Wasylycia-Leis 4170 Program funding Manitoba Association for Childbirth and Family Chomiak 2575; Orchard 2575 Education Home care program Funding elimination Accessibility Orchard 2577; Wasylycia-Leis 2576-7 Orchard 1762; Santos 1762 Mental health care facilities Advisory committee Bed closures Orchard 623; Wasylycia-Leis 623 Filmon 4984;Orchard 3167, 4304-5; Advocacy office Wasylycia-Leis 3166-7,4304, 4983-4 Orchard 624; Wasylycia-Leis 624 Mental health care system Alternative services Bed closures Orchard 556-7,31 72; Wowchuk 556-7, 3172 Cheema 4742; Orchard 4742, 51 12; Decision-making process Wasylycia-Leis 51 12 Orchard 1421; Wowchuk 1421 Community-based services Employee conflictof interest Cheema 4742; Orchard 4742 Orchard 1419-20; Plohman 1419 Reform Employee intimidation Brandon, Manitoba Orchard 1420-1 ; Wowchuk 1420 Cheema 4307; Orchard 4307 Funding Co-ordination Orchard 3414; Wasylycia-Leis 3414 Orchard 5111-2; Wasylycia-Leis 51 11 Government commitment Government strategy Orchard 475-6; Wasylycia-Leis 474-5 Orchard 4200-1 ; Wasylycia-Leis 4200-1 Licensed Practical Nurses role Midwifery Cheema 3898; Orchard 3898 Government initiatives

21 1 Appendices

Health - Cont. Health - Cont. Carstairs 2687-8; Orchard 2687-8 Selkirk Mental Health Centre Misericordia Hospital Forensic unit Emergency ward closure Dewar 294, 558-9; Orchard 294, 558-9 Cheema 1969-70; Orchard 1969-70 SelkirkSchool of Psychiatric Nursing Funding Closure postponement Orchard 1772-3; Wasylycia-Leis 1772 Dewar 1758,4306; Orchard 1758, 4306 Mental health care Reopening Cheema 3039; Orchard 3039-40 Dewar 294; Orchard 294 Mount Carmel Clinic Seven Oaks General Hospital Cross-culturalcounselling unit Operating budget Cheema 5115; Hickes 793-4, 1163; Orchard 2195-6; Wasylycia-Leis 2195-6 Orchard 793-4, 1163, 51 15 Social assistance Nursing Education, Ministerial Council on Employment creation programs Status Martindale 3370; Orchard 3370 Orchard 2594; Wasylycia-Leis 2593-4 Food allowance Pharmacare Carstairs 3043; Orchard 3043 Calcium supplements Solvent abuse legislation Orchard 5409; Santos 5409 Proclamation Clarythromycin exclusion Hickes 1971-2, 2083; Orchard 1972, 2083 Orchard 520-1 , 926-7, 2256-7; Thompson General Hospital Wasylycia-Leis 520-1 , 926-7, 2256-7 Regional facility Orchard 3581 ; Wasylycia-Leis 3581 Cyclosporine exclusion Urban aboriginal medical program Orchard 927; Wasylycia-Leis 927 Funding reduction Deductible increase Friesen 4571 ; Orchard4571 Orchard 520; Wasylycia-Leis 519-20 Urban Hospital Council Exclusions Budget reduction proposal L. Evans 5176; Orchard 51 76 Orchard 821-2; Wasylycia-Leis 821-2 Poverty rate Mental healthcare Prevention program co-ordination Recommendations Martindale 3369; Orchard 3369 Cheema 3040; Orchard 3040 Public health organizations Misericordia Hospital review Funding Cheema 473; Orchard 473 Cheema 1259-60; Filmon 1260 Public participation Regional operations Filmon 127; Wasylycia-Leis 126-7 St. Boniface Recommendations Gaudry 1916; Orchard 1916 Orchard 22; Wasylycia-Leis 22 St. Boniface Hospital Reportrequest Bed closures Cheema 557; Filmon 127; Orchard 557; Cheema 4280; Orchard 3086-7, 4280, 4304; Wasylycia-Leis 127 Wasylycia-Leis 3086, 4304 Specialty nursing School of Licensed Practical Nurses Recommendations Cheema 3851 ; Orchard 822, 2745, 3851 ; Orchard 3041 ; Wasylycia-Leis 3041 Wasylycia-Leis 822, 2745 St. John's Ambulance Highways and Transportation, Funding Department of Orchard 2881-2; Wasylycia-Leis 2881 CN Rail

212 Appendices

Highways and Transportation - Cont. Highways and Transportation - Cont. Bayline upgrade Driedger 3852; Rose 3852 Ashton 4305; Driedger 4305 Portof Churchill Job relocations All-partycomm ittee Driedger 51 ; Reid 51 Driedger 224; Harper 224 Layoffs Agreement tabling request Doer 2458-60; Driedger 52; Filmon 2459-61 ; Driedger 4202; Reid 4202 Reid 52, 2460-1 Efficiency Producer car drop off Driedger 2020-1 ; Plohman 2020-1 Driedger 2257; Wowchuk 2257 Federal commitment Canadian Airlines International Driedger 471 ; Reid 471 Centralization Future status Driedger 2577; Reid 2577 Carstairs 4984-5; Driedger 4984-5 Employment creation strategy Government communications Driedger 2578; Reid 2577-8 Driedger 4202; Reid 4201 Reservationoffice Governmentstrategy Layoffs Driedger 1263; Reid 1263 Driedger 2577; Reid 2577 Grain shipments Crow benefit Driedger 471 , 4201 , 51 16; Filmon 690, 3273; Payment plan Harper 3273; Reid 471 , 690, 4201, 51 16 Driedger 3268; Plohman 3268 Grain shipments-Russian Republic Decentralization Doer 3893; Filmon 3893 Selkirk, Manitoba Manitoba representation Dewar 2514; Driedger 2514 Driedger 472; Reid 472 Faith CommunityBaptist Church Promotion Building relocation Filmon 3273-4; Harper 3273 Driedger 3852; Rose 3852 Rail line protection Gemini ReservationSystem Filmon 690; Reid 690 Merger Rail line upgrading Driedger 1018; Reid 1018 Driedger 51 16; Reid 51 16 Highway construction program,National Rail line usage Funding commitment - Federal Driedger 3893; Doer3892-3 Carstairs 1708-9; Filmon 1709 Shipment statistics Funding commitment - Provincial Carstairs 4984; Doer 3892; Driedger 4984; Carstairs 1709; Filmon 1709 Filmon 3892 Highway maintenance Portage Ia Prairie, Manitoba Responsibility Bridge inspection Driedger 1472; Wowchuk 1472 Connery 3678-9; Driedger 3679 Highway map, provincial Bridge replacement Exclusions Connery 3679; Driedger 3679 Driedger 2197-8; Wowchuk 2197-8 Recycling, glass Odometertampering Contractaward criteria Minister's opinion Doer 2691 ; Driedger 2691-2 Driedger 3042; Maloway 3042 Governmentinitiatives RCMP report Doer 2692; Driedger 2692 Driedger 3042-3; Maloway 3042 Senate TransportationComm ittee PR 340 grading Manitoba representation Project completion Driedger 1019; Edwards 1019

213 Appendices

Highways and Transportation - Cont. Housing - Cont. Taxicab industry Ernst 4882; Martindale488 1-2 Luxury cab proposal Housing, nonprofit Driedger 876-7; Lamoureux 876-7 Governmentstrategy Thicket Portage, Manitoba EFnst 126; Martindale 126 All-weather road Housing, public-PembinaHighway Ashton 4305; Driedger 4305 Playground structure Train derailment report Ernst4882; Martindale 4882 Ashton 4305; Driedger 4305 Housing, seniors Transportation industry Lounge repair-145 Powers Street Rail line jurisdiction Ernst251 3; Hickes 251 3 Driedger 1019-20; Edwards 101 9-20 Manitoba Housing Authority Transportation issues Clarification Premier's involvement Ernst 3900; Wowchuk 3900 Driedger 52; Reid 52 Employees' status Trucking industry Ernst 2854;Plohman 2853-4 All-partytask force Internal audit Downey 4164; Reid 41 64 Ernst 3789-90; Martindale 3789-90 Employment creation strategy Layoffs Driedger 4164;Reid 4164 Ernst 796; Martindale 796 Employment protection Parkland district Driedger 4163-4; Reid 41 63 Ernst 797-8; Wowchuk 797-8 Operating authority Selkirk office Driedger 3789; Reid 3789 Dewar 1423; Ernst 1423 Western Premiers' Conference Seniors' services Portof Churchill Ernst3896-7; Wo wchuk 3896 Filmon 3273; Harper 3273 Servicecontracti ng Winnipeg International Airport Protection Ernst 796; Martindale796 Driedger 2019; Martindale 201 9 Staffing Ernst 3896;Wow chuk 3896 Staffing-Dauphin, Manitoba Housing, Department of Ducharme 3144; Filmon 3145; Alfred Block-selkirk Plohman 3144-5 Inspection Recreation centre-FifeStreet Dewar 1423; Ernst 1423 Roof repairs Brandon, Manitoba Ernst2597; Martindale 2597 Layoffs Rotary Pines Project Ernst 3646; L. Evans 3646 Funding reallocation Constitutional issues Ernst 126; Martindale 126 Housing responsibility SAFER program Ernst 1375; Martindale 1375 Eligibility statistics Housing, co-operative Ernst 4578; Martindale 4578 Federal program Public awareness Ernst 1375, 2581 , 2598; Ernst4578, 4881 ; Martindale 4578, 4881 Martindale 1375, 2581 , 2597-8 Seniors' RentaiStart Housing, Minister of Applications Apology request Ernst 126; Martindale 126

214 Appendices

Industry, Trade and Tourism, Industry, Trade and Tourism - Cont. Departmentof Stefanson 2591 ; Storie 2591 ACCESS programs Economic and Regional Development Agreement Funding-Federal Status report Lathlin 686;St efanson 686-7 Lathlin 686; Stefanson 686 Government commitment Economic growth Lathlin 687; Stefanson 687 Employment creation strategy Abitibi-Price-Pine Falls Doer 4274; Stefanson 4274-5 Employee-owned proposal Full-time employment decline Doer 1754;Rlmon 1754 Alcock 2578; Stefanson 2578 Feasibility study Governmentpolicy performance Doer 1754-5, 21 03-4;Downey 2200-1 ; Alcock 2991 ; Stefanson 2991 -2 ' Rlmon 1754-5, 21 03-4; Storie 2200 Prairie provinces co-operation Rnancial status Alcock 201 8-9; Stefanson 2018-9 Doer 21 02-3; Rlmon 2103 Research and development Alcock 3983-4; Stefanson 3983-4 Assiniboia Downs Wage levels Status Ashton 1 054-5; Stefanson 1 054 C. Evans 130; Stefanson 130-1 Federal Trade Tribunal Winter harness racing Manitoba cabinetmakers C. Evans 130; Stefanson 130 Alcock 2512-3, 3170; Ernst251 2; Borden Company Ltd. Filmon 2512, 3170 Closure Free Trade Agreement Ashton 1 055; Stefanson 1 055 Abrogation Labour adjustment strategy Downey 403; Storie 403 Hickes 1776; Stefanson 1776-7 Employment creation statistics CFB Shilo Doer 3036-7; Rlmon 3037 Continuation Impact on food processing industry L. Evans 691 ; Stefanson 691 Hickes 1777; Stefanson 1777 Communications industry Impact on Manitoba Employment statistics Doer 2573; Stefanson 2573 Ernst4097; Storie 4097 Impact on Manufacturing industry Communications initiative Doer 4596-7; Stefanson 4597 Research and development funding Labour adjustment strategy Alcock 3894;Stefanson 3894 Doer 2573; Hickes 1777; Cross-bordershopping Stefanson 1777, 2573-4 Government actions Softwoodlumber duty Doer 1048-9;Rlmon 1049 Lathlin 1113; Manness 1178; Government Services, Departmentof Stefanson 1113, 1177; Storie 1177 U.S. purchase policy Government - Federal Stefanson 5264;Storie 5264 Untendered contracts Government strategy Doer 2350-1 ; Rlmon 2351-2; Filmon 5265; Stefanson 1 016, 5264; Stefanson2350-1 Storie 1 015, 5264-5 Hudson's Bay Distribution Centre Industry, Trade and Tourism, Department of Employment security Stefanson 1016; Storie 1016 Doer 2685-6; Stefanson 2685-6 Drug Patent Law - Federal MacleodSt edman Impact on labour force Employment opportunities

215 Appendices

Industry, Trade and Tourism - Cont. Industry, Trade and Tourism - Cont. Doer 16; Filmon 16 Government study Funding justification Tabling request Stefanson 54; Storie 54 Doer 1368;Stefanson 1368 Head office location Governmentwithdrawal Doer 17; Filmon 17 Doer 4597-8; Stefanson 4597-8 Secured creditors Impact labour force Stefanson 54-5; Storie 53 Doer 48n-9; Stefanson4878-9 Manitoba-U.S. trade deficit Impact Manitoba Governmentstrategy Doer 2574; Filmon 2574; Doer 1 049; Filmon 1 049-50 Stefanson 971 -2; Storie 971 -2 Manufacturing industry Information tabling request Employment creation strategy Downey 1662 ; Filmon 20n-8; Filmon 1322; Storie 1322 Stefanson 1913; Storie 1662, 1913, 2077 Employment statistics Labour adjustment strategy L. Evans406-7; Filmon 2078; Doer 1491 ; Filmon 1491 Stefanson 406-7; Storie 2078 Labour standards Shipment statistics Alcock 1716; Filmon 1716 Doer 2193; L. Evans 3958-9; Manitoba conditions Filmon 2194;Stef anson 3958-9 Doer 1706-8; Filmon 1706-7; Stefanson 403-4; Storie 403-4 NorthAmerican Free Trade Agreement Agricultural industry Manitoba opposition Stefanson 971 ; Storie 971 Downey 1660-1 ; Plohman 1660-1 Premier's position Clarification Doer 4604; Filmon 4604 Doer4603; Filmon 4604 Provincial jurisdiction Crowncorporati ons Downey 1656; Storie 1656 Doer 1491 ; Stefanson 1491-2 Public hearings Cultural industries Cummings 2791 ; Doer 1706, 2194-5, 2790-1, Alcock 1913-4; Stefanson 1914 3037-8; Filmon 1706, 2195, 3037-8 Deadline Sanitary standard Cummings 1605; Doer 1605 Plohman 1 n9; Stefanson 1779 Departmental review Sectoral briefing Stefanson 1913; Storie 1913 Doer 2194;Filmon 2194 Tabling request Supply management Alcock 1914; Stefanson 191 3-4; Storie 1913 Doer 1606, 4982-3; Downey 1606; Election call Stefanson 4982-3 Downey 1656; Storie 1656 Water exports Garment industry Alcock 1775-6, 28n-8; Stefanson 3319-20;Storie 3319-20 Stefanson 1775-6, 2878 Government action Withdrawal Downey 1655; Storie 1655 Filmon 1323; Martindale4306; Government position Stefanson 3320; Storie 1323, 3320 Cummings 1605; Doer 1366-7, 1490, 1605, NorthWest Company 1706-7;Downey 1490; Filmon 1323, 1367-8, Employment creation strategy 1706-7; Storie 1323 Stefanson 2579-80; Storie 2578-9 Government strategy NorthernTelecom-Layoffs Filmon 2853; Storie 2853 Governmentact ion

216 Appendices

Industry, Trade and Tourism - Cont. Industry, Tra de and Tourism - Cont. Doer 4543-4; Stefanson4543-5 Doer 3316; Stefan son 331 6 Oak Hammock Marsh development Tender process Impact on tourism Alcock 2849-50; Film on 2849-50 Doer 4275; Stefanson 4275 Statistics Paddlewheel Riverboats Decline Lower Fort Garry trip Doer 141 6-7; Stefanson 141 6-7 Dewar 1918-9; Stefanson 1918-9 Overnight visitors Piper Aircraft Corporation Stefanson 3984-5; Storie 3984 Manitoba relocation U.S. visitors Stefanson 1157; Storie 1157 Doer 331 5; Stefanson 3315-6 Repap Manitoba Inc. Unemployment rate, youth Contractual obligations Government strategy Filmon 267; Wowchuk 267 Ashton 4507; Carstairs 470-1, 2078; Employment creation Downey 3368-9; L. Evans 3368-9; Filmon 267; Wowchuk 266-7 Filmon 2078-9, 4507; Stefanson 470-1 Employment statistics Wang Canada Doer 122-3; Filmon 123 Agreement status Environmental assessment Downey 3649;Storie 3649 Filmon 267; Wowchuk 267 Technological change Justice, Departmentof Doer 123; Filmon 123-4 Aboriginal Justice Inquiry Report Retail trade sector Courtservices, Northern Statisticsdiscrepancy Harper 1368-9; McCrae 1368-9 Alcock 5265; Stefanson 5265 Recommendations Sunday shopping Chomiak 3039; Doer552-3 , 5167-9; Ashton 3852-3; Filmon 3853 Downey 553, 5168-9; Filmon 3039; Seafood Enterprises Association Lathlin 20, 224-5; McCrae 20-1, 224-5, 552-3 Agreement Aboriginal justice system Connery 757; Stefanson 757, 1157-8; Governmentposition Storie 1157 Lathlin 553; McCrae 553-4 Simplot-Brandon plant Advertising, misleading Governmentassistance Consumer protection L. Evans 3959; Stefanson 3959 Edwards 125-6; McCrae 126 Modernization Bills 86/87 L. Evans 691 ; Stefanson 691 Adjudication process Small business Edwards5269; McCrae 5269 Government initiatives Consultations Stefanson 1229; Storie 1229 Edwards 5268-9; McCrae 5269-70 Telecommunications laboratory Withdrawal Government discussions Chomiak 5266-7; McCrae 5266-7 Alcock 3894-5;Stefanson 3895 Board of Review Tourism Chaulk, Robert Governmentinitiatives Chomiak 624; McCrae 624 Downey 4097-8; Stefanson 3985; Governmentrepresentation Storie 3985, 4097 Chomiak 624; McCrae 624 Promotion campaign Charterof Rights and Freedoms Governmentstrategy Government support 217 Appendices

Justice - Cont. Justice - Cont. Carstairs 1468-9; Rlmon 1468-9 Public defendersystem Child abuse allegations Chomiak 1779; McCrae 1779-80 Justice Department investigation Two-tiered system Lathlin 554; McCrae 554 Cbomiak 1780; McCrae 1780 Court of Queen's Bench Law EnforcementReview Agency Appeal screening court Civilian participation Edwards 292-3; McCrae 292-3 Chomiak 4985-6; McCrae 4985-6 Crime prevention programs Racism investigations Funding Chomiak 2307-8; McCrae 2307-8 Edwards 4168; McCrae 4168-9 Legal Aid ServicesSociety of Manitoba Dakota Oj ibway Tribal Council Funding Policeforce Chomiak 1232; McCrae 1232 Funding Labour dispute Harper 4602; McCrae 4602-3 Chomiak 1495-6; McCrae 1495-6 Domestic violence Minister's intention Bail conditions Edwards 1711; McCrae 171 1-2 Chomiak 974; McCrae 974 Private bar Rehabilitation programs Edwards 1712, 1714; McCrae 1712, 1714 Chomiak 974; McCrae 974-5 Liquor Control Act Headingley Correctional Institute Confiscated liquor Psychiatric care facilities McCrae 798-9; Storie 798-9 Edwards 1496-7; McCrae 1496-7 Pedlar Commission Human rights case Recommendations Governmentinvolvement Barrett 18, 1761-2; Chomiak 625, 3532; Cheema 4205-6; Downey4205-6 Manness3532; McCrae 18-9, 625, 1762 Impaired driving Policing servicesagreement Stayed charges review Fee-for-servicecosts Chomiak 2878; McCrae 2878-9 Chomiak 4206, 4278, 4737-8; McCrae 4206, Indian Birch Reserve 4278-9, 4737-8, 5174; Wowchuk 51 74 Child welfare worker ban Pornography McCrae 1055; Render 1055 Governmentpolicy Interpretation Act Chomiak 341 1-2; Rlmon 341 1-2 Amendments Racism investigations Lathlin 21 ; McCrae 21 Policing services Judicial system Chomiak 2991, 3038; Rlmon 2991 , 3038 Aboriginal participation Restraining orders, enforcement Lathlin 225; McCrae 225 Departmentalco-ordination Bail reviews Carstairs 2353; McCrae 2353 Chomiak 2879; McCrae 2879 Royal Canadian Mounted Police Charging directive Falcon Beach detachment Chomiak 3531-2; Manness 3532 Carstairs2357; McCrae 2357 Circuit court Shooting McCrae 1469; Storie 1469 Independent investigation Court transcriptionservice Chomiak 3039; Rlmon 3039 Edwards 1656-7; McCrae 1656-7, 1714 Uniform Gods River, Manitoba Governmentposition Lathlin554; McCrae 554 Carstairs 1568; Rlmon 1468

218 Appendices

Labour, Departmentof Labour - Cont. Apprenticeshipand Training branch Worker protection Staffing Ashton 3270; Praznik 3270-1 Praznik 171 5-6; Reid 1715 Labour, Minister of Apprenticeship training Meeting request First-aid certificate, mandatory Maloway 2255; Praznik 2255 Praznik 1715; Reid 1714 Labour movement CKND Television strike Government participation Government advertising policy Ashton 3271 ; Praznik 3271 Ashton 1162-3, 1611; Film on 1163; Older Worker Adjustment, Program for Praznik 1162-3, 1611 Status report Unfair labour practices Connery 1161-2; Praznik 1161-2 Ashton 1610-1 ; Praznik 1611 Unemployed Help Centre Disabled employees Funding reinstatement Rehabilitation/vocational services Ashton 3417; Praznik 341 7 Ashton 3988; Praznik 3988 Unionization Economic growth Government criteria Full-time employment Ashton 3270; Praznik 3270 Alcock 2992-3; Praznik 2993 Electrical Construction Journeymen Manitoba Hydro Examination standards Conawapa dam project Praznik 4885-6; Wowchuk 4885-6 Contractvalidity Employment Standards Act Carr 225-6; Neufeld 226 Amendments Cost projections Ashton 3988; Praznik 3988 Downey 521 ; Edwards 521 Foreign Domestic Workers' Program Delays, Impact of Labour Jaw coverage Doer 4428; Filmon 4428 Cerilli 3533; Praznik 3534 Expenditures-ManitobaHydro Furnace inspections Carr 130; Neufeld 130 Faulty heat exchangers Expenditures-Ontario Hydro Cummings 251 2; Maloway251 2 Carr 129-30; Neufeld 130 Condemning authority Government position Maloway 2109-10, 2254; Praznik 21 10, 2254 Downey 2464-5; Edwards 2464 Mandatory Justification Maloway 2254; Praznik 2254 Carstairs 2508; Filmon 2508 Health care system Legal opinion request Essential servicesagreement Carr 267; Carstairs 51 8; Downey 518; Ashton 3417; Praznik 341 7 Neufeld 267-8 Labour adjustment program Liberal opinion FederaVProvincial co-ordination Government response Doer 5108-1 0; Filmon51 09-1 1 Downey 2464; Edwards 2464 Funding Pamphlet review Filmon 1325; Lamoureux 1325 Downey 41 00-1 ; Edwards 41 00-1 Labour College of Canada Penalty clauses Scholarship Doer 2507; Filmon 2507 Ashton 341 6-7; Praznik34 17 Renegotiation Labour Jaws Doer 4428-9; Filmon4429

21 9 Appendices

Manitoba Hydro - Cont. Manitoba Lotteries Foundation Postponement Casino plans Carr 129; Neufeld 129 Lamoureux 3957; Mitchelson 3957 Power projections Crystal Casino Doer 4162; Downey 41 62 Expansion Premier's discussions Lamoureux 3957; Mitchelson3957 Doer 2507 -8; Almon 2507-8 Hiring process Public Utilities Board Lamoureux 3986; Mitchelson 3986-7 Review Carr 268; Carstairs 518, 2508-9; Manitoba Public Insurance Corporation Downey 517-9, 2465; Edwards 2465; Impaired driving Filmon 2509; Hickes 517-8; Neufeld 268 Third-partybenefits Renegotiation Cummings 3792-3; Edwards 3792-3 Carr 361 ; Carstairs 794; Downey 555, 794; Edwards 554-5; Neufeld 361 Manitoba Telephone System Surplus power Billing contract Carr 268; Neufeld 268 Dewar 1018; Findlay 1018 Sustainable development Call Management System Doer 4162-3; Downey 4163 Barrett270; Findlay 270 Winnipeg Chamber of Commerce position Directory contract Edwards 521-2; Filmon 522 Dewar 1613; Findlay 1613 Grand Rapids Generating Station Long-distance competition Environmental concerns Dewar 1612; Findlay 1612-3 Downey 3318; Lathlin 3318 Rate structure Turbine inspections Dewar 1 018; Findlay 1 018-9 Downey 1161 ; Lathlin 1161 Staff layoffs-Portage Ia Prairie Northern Flood Agreements Dewar 1158; Findlay 1158 South Indian Lake Telecommunicationsbil l-Federal Legal expenses Government position Doer 2742-3; Filmon 2742-4 Dewar 1158; Findlay 1159 Norway House Fishermen's Co-op Telephone director contract Compensation Dewar 1019; Findlay 1019 Downey 2877; Lathlin 2877 Multiculturalism Manitoba Liquor Control Commission Anti-racism co-ordinator Chinese cooking wine Hiring process Sale restrictions Lamoureux 1612; Mitchelson 1612 Hickes 1971 , 2082-3; Mcintosh 1971 , 2082-3 Manitoba Grants Advisory Council Fetal Alcohol Syndrome Review Warnings Cerilli 4601; Mitchelson 4601 Carstairs 3043-4; Mcintosh 3044 Manitoba Intercultural Council Resignation request, Chairperson Antiracism recommendations Mcintosh 176; Storie 176 Downey 2994; Lamoureux 2994 Sales techniques Government's intention Mcintosh 2354-5; Storie 2354 Lamoureux 4504-5; Mitchelson 4505 Senior salary levels Review Ashton 474; Mcintosh 175-6, 474; Storie 175-6 Cerilli 4577; Mitchelson4577-8

220 Appendices

Multiculturalism - Cont. NaturalResources - Cont. Manitoba Legislative Assembly Irrigation purposes Cross-cultural training Cerilli 3168-9; Enns 3168-9 Lamoureux 1611-2; Mitchelson 1611-2 Report status Multicultural legislation Cerilli 3271-2; Enns 3271 -2 AffirmativeAc tion, impact on Childs Lake Cerilli 4429-30; Praznik 4429-30 Water level Amendments Enns 2466; Wowchuk 2466 Cerilli 4601 ; Mitchelson 4601 ClearwaterLake, Manitoba Consultations Government nurseryclosure Cerilli 4503; Cheema 51 16; Enns 23, 3983; Lathlin 23, 3983 Mitchelson 4503-4, 51 16 Co-Management agreements Introduction Public forum Downey 2994; Lamoureux 2994, 3092-3, 3897; Edwards 1326; Enns 1326-7 Mitchelson 3093, 3897 Working group Justification Edwards 1327; Enns 1327 Cerilli 4504; Mitchelson 4504 Crown Lands Act Manitoba Grants Advisory Council Wildlife baiting regulations Lamoureux 4603; Mitchelson 4603 Edwards 2308-9; Enns 2308-9 Manitoba Intercultural Council Dauphin Lake AdvisoryComm ittee Lamoureux 4603; Mitchelson 4603 Funding Multicultural Resource Centre Enns 3793; Plohman 3793 Closure Duck Mountain Cerilli 124; Mitchelson 124 Co-Management agreements Education resources Enns 2466; Wowchuk 2466 Cerilli 124; Mitchelson 124 Ducks Unlimited headquarters Multicultural Secretariat Environmental assessment-Federal Activities Cummings 871 ; Doer871 Cerilli 3956; Mitchelson 3956 Funding withdrawal Hiring policy Cummings 871 ; Doer 871 Cerilli 58; Filmon 58-9; Lamoureux 127-8, 925; Impact tourism Mitchelson 128, 925 Cummings 871 ; Doer 870-1 Political influence Dutch elm disease program Cerilli 5267 -8; Mitchelson 5268 Funding, provincial Reporttabling request Enns 1970-1 , 2748-9; Friesen 1970-1 , 2748 Cerilli 3956-7; Mitchelson 3957 Funding restoration Race relations policy Enns 1320-1 , 2080; Friesen 1320-1 ; Education system Martindale 2080 Cerilli 1494; Mitchelson 1494 Multiyear planning Programs funding Enns 1321 ; Friesen 1321 Cerilli 1495; Mitchelson 1495 Replacement tree allocation Enns 3677; Friesen 3677 Natural Resources, Departmentof Research and development funding Assiniboine River Diversion Carstairs 5408; Enns 5408 Employment creation Review Cerilli 3169; Enns 3169 Enns 3677; Friesen 3677 FederaVProvincial review Scientific opinion tabling request Driedger 926; C. Evans 926 Enns 1915-6, 2080; Friesen 191 5-6

221 Appendices

Nstursl Resources - Cont. NsturslResources - Cont. Two-percent loss limit Driedger 925;C. Evans 925 Enns 2852-3; Friesen 2852-3 Stephenfield reservoir Endangered spaces Irrigation licensing Site selection criteria E&wards 601-2; Enns 601-2 Cerilli 3987; Enns 3987 Waste disposal Tall grass prairie program Winnipeg Roodway Cerilli 1658, 3987; Enns 1658, 3987 Enns 4434; Gaudry 4433-4 Fisheries branch-Brandon Water rights Closure Priorities Enns 4166, 4576; L. Evans 4166; Connery 604; Enns 604 Rose 4575-6 Western Canadian Wildlife Services Fisheries industry Oak HammockMarsh report Rough fish marketing Cerilli 268; Enns 269 Enns 1163-4; Wowchuk 1163 Wildlife protection Forestry industry Poaching Sustainable development Enns 2692-3; Helwer 2692 Carstairs 972-3; Enns 972-3 Garrison Diversion Project Native Affairs Environmental impact assessment Abinochi Preschool Program Edwards 5173; Enns 51 73 Manitoba interests Closure Edwards 51 72-3; Enns 51 73 Downey 1498; Hickes 1498 Habitat Enhancement Program Funding Little Saskatchewan River Downey 1417-8, 1609, 1761 ; Enns 4166; L. Evans 4166 Hickes 141 7-8, 1609, 1761 Lake Winnipegosis Meeting request Cormorant population control Downey 1761 ; Filmon 341 8; Enns 341 6; Wowchuk 3416 Hickes 1761 , 3418 Trap net policy Aboriginal Centre Enns 1 164; Wowchuk 1164 Funding Library services Downey 1609, 3956; Hickes 1609, 3956 Enns 2465-6; C. Evans 2465 Government commitment Long Plain Indian Reserve Downey 3316-7; Hickes331 6-7 Tree-growing contract Aboriginal issues Connery 1114; Enns 1114-5 Government commitment Nopiming Provincial Park Downey 3955; Hickes 3955 Wildernessstatus Aboriginal women Carstairs 972; Enns 972-3 ACCESS program Oak Hammock Marsh development Barrett 1052; Downey 1052 Environmental assessments Program accessibility Cerilli 269; Filmon 269 Barrett10 51-2; Downey 1052 Governmentcredibil ity Native Affairs, Minister responsible for Cerilli 269; Filmon 269-70 Public's confidence Government withdrawal Downey 1418; Hickes 1418 Cerllli 4275-6; Enns 4275-6 Red Sucker Lake, Manitoba Pembina Valley Water Co-operative School closure Assiniboine River Diversion report Downey 4743; Harper 4742-3

222 Appendices

Native Affairs - Cont. Rural Development-Cont. Urban Aboriginal Strategy Taxation Governmentaction Derkach 2305-6; Plohman 2305; Film on 4571 ; Friesen 4571 VVowchuk 2306 Governmentcom mitment Clarification Downey 1608-9; Friesen 1608 Derkach 2466 Release Reassessments Filmon 341 8; Hickes 3418 Downey 2354;VVowchuk 2353-4 Right of appeal Northern Affairs, Departmentof Downey 2353; VVowchuk 2353 Aboriginal Justice Inquiry Report Decentralization Court services, Northern Brandon, Manitoba Downey 1369; Harper 1369 Filmon 692-3; Lamoureux 692 Clearwater Lake, Manitoba Government action Government nursery closure Dewar 3323; Downey 3323 Downey 923, 925; Lathlin 923 Relocation statistics Economic growth L Evans 3645; Downey 3646, 3850-1; Northernprograms VVowchuk 3850 Ashton 407; Downey 407 Selkirk, Manitoba Health care system, Northern Derkach 2513-4, 2746; Dewar 2513-4 Transportationfee Status report Ashton 2356; Downey 2356 Derkach 3582; VVowchuk 3582 Highway construction program Economic growth,rural Northern Manitoba Employment creation strategy Ashton 41 04; Downey 41 04 Derkach 3581-2; VVowchuk 3581 Highways andTransportati on, Departmentof Governmentinitiatives District 1 0 headquarters Derkach 1473; VVowchuk 1473 Downey 2876; Lathlin 2876 Minister's commitment Northern Manitoba Derkach 5404; VVowchuk 5404-5 Employment creation strategy Video lotteryre venues Ashton 5409-10; Filmon5409 -10 Derkach 5404; VVowchuk 5404 Federal-Provincial agreements Green Team program Downey 24; Lathlin 24 Justification Royal Canadian Mounted Police Carstairs 5270; Derkach 5270 Municipal costs Infrastructures, rural Ashton 2357; Downey 2357 Responsibility The Pas, Manitoba Filmon 688-9;VVowch uk 688-9 Employment opportunities Municipal assessments Downey 24, 2876; Lathlin 24, 2876 Delays Thompson General Hospital Derkach 4204; VVowchuk 4203-4 Mammography/chemotherapy services Right to appeal Ashton 41 03-4; Downey41 03-4 Derkach 4204; VVowchuk 4204 Northern Manitoba Rural Development, Departmentof Employment opportunities Agricultural land Derkach 2691 ; Lathlin 2691 Education support levy Policing servicesagreement Derkach 2306; Downey 2354; Fee-for-servicecosts VVowchuk2306, 2354 Derkach 4302, 517 4; VVowchuk 4302, 51 74

223 Appendices

Rursl Development-Cont. Seniors - Cont. Impact on Rural Manitoba Ducharme 3371 , 3988-9; Santos 3371, 3988-9 Derkach 4302-3; Wowchuk 4302 Piney Area Seniors' Group Municipal costs Co-ordinator Derkach 873-4; Wowchuk 873-4 Dwcharme 1160; Santos 1159-60 Regional development corporations St. James Seniors' Group Funding Government assistance Derkach 1472-3, 3582, 3851 ; Filmon 3850; Ducharme 1159; Edwards 1159 Wowchuk 1472, 3582, 3850-1 Seniors programs Rural Development, Minister of Funding Schoolboard interference Ducharme 1258; Santos 1258 Carstairs 4546-8; Derkach 4545,454 7-8; Government commitment Filmon 4546-8; Wowchuk 4545-6 Ducharme 1160, 1258; Santos 1160, 1258 Russell, Manitoba Dissolution Status of Women Derkach 5175-6; Gaudry 5175 Bill 70 Plebiscite Impact on women Derkach 5176; Gaudry 51 76 Barrett3676; Mitchelson 3676 The Pas, Manitoba Domestic violence Employment decline Bail conditions Derkach 2691 ; Lathlin 2690-1 Chomiak 974; McCrae 974 Video lottery revenues Child abuse allegations Green Team program Justice Department investigation Derkach 5267; Wowchuk 5267 Lathlin 554; McCrae 554 Education and prevention programs Seniors Barrett4884; Mitchelson 4884 55 Plus program Governmentprograms Funding restoration Barrett18 ; Mitchelson 18 Ducharme 1258, 1711; Santos 1258, 171 1 Manitoba Women's Directorate Indexing Assistant Deputy Minister Ducharme 2020, 3989; Gaudry 2020; Competition Santos 3989 Lamoureux 1972; Mitchelson 1972 Canada Pension Plan Hiring process Benefit increase Lamoureux 924-5, 1053-4, 1918; Ducharme 1711 ; Santos 171 1 Mitchelson 924-5, 1 054, 1918 Health care system Women's issues De insurance Governmentinitiatives Ducharme 251 0; Wasylycia-Leis 2510 Barrett3676 ; Mitchelson 3676-7 Housing, seniors Lounge repair-1 45 Powers Street Urban Affairs, Department of Ducharme 251 3; Hickes 2513 Aboriginal issues Security systems Education/training opportunities Ducharme 2513; Hickes 251 3 Ernst 4571 ; Friesen 4571 Manitoba Tax Assistance Office Bill 45 Funding restoration City of Winnipeg resolution Ducharme 1711; Santos 1711 Ernst 2198; Friesen 2198 Pharmaceutical costs Minister's authority Impact on seniors Ernst 2198; Friesen 2198

224 Appendices

Urban Affairs - Cont. Urban Affairs - Cont. Secession referendum Ernst 2595-6; Friesen 2595 Ernst21 98;Friesen 2198 Governmentcommitment City of Winnipeg Act Ernst 1229; Friesen 1229 Community Committee role Government support Chomiak 4099-41 00; Ernst41 00 Ernst 51 14; Hickes 51 14 Core Area Initiative Minister's position Education programs Ernst51 13; Hickes 51 13 Ernst12 30; Friesen 1230 NorthMain Development Corporation Inner City Foundation Funding Ernst 129; Friesen 129 Ernst 51 14; Hickes 51 14 Proposed projects Ernst 129; Friesen 128 Workers Compensation Board Public consultations Family entitlements Ernst 228, 3792; Friesen 228, 3792 Praznik 4502-3, 4549; Reid 4502-3, 4549 Renewal Intimidation Ernst 1370-1 ; Friesen 1370-1 Praznik 4573-4; Reid 4573-4 Replacement Long-term benefits Ernst 128, 3792; Friesen 128, 3791 -2 Praznik 292; Reid 292 Dutch elm disease Medical advice Funding restoration Praznik 292; Reid 292 Ernst 519; Friesen 51 9 Medical specialist reports Governmentposition Praznik 1056; Reid 1056 Carstairs 799; Filmon 799 Public inquiry Handi-Transit Praznik 4301-2, 4432-3,4549 ; Cost-sharing agreement Reid 4301-2, 4432-3, 4549 Ernst 1258-9; Friesen 1258-9 Vocational rehabilitation benefits Inner cityrenewal programs Praznik 2686-7; Reid 2686-7 Funding impact

225 Appendices

APPENDIX B Members of the Executive Council (as at Prorogation)

Premier President of the Executive Council Minister of Federal/Provincial Relations Ministerrespon sible for French Language Services...... Hon. Gary A. Almon

Minister of Natural Resources Minister responsible for The Manitoba Natural Resources Development Act (exceptwith respect to Channel Area Loggers ltd. and Moose Lake

Loggers Ltd.) ...... ••••...... ••••.••...... •.•.•...... ••.•...... Hon. Harry J. Enns

Deputy Premier Minister of NorthernAffairs Minister of Energy and Mines Minister responsible for Native Affairs, The Manitoba Natural Resources Development Act (with respect to Channel Area Loggers Ltd. and Moose Lake Loggers Ltd.) A.E. McKenzie Co. ltd. Minister responsible for the Manitoba Hydro Act Minister responsible for and charged with the administration of The Communities Economic Development Fund Act Minister charged with the administration of the

Fisheries Act (PartIll) ...•••••...... •...... ••••••••••.•...... ••.....••••Hon. James E. Downey

Minister of Health ...... •...•..••••....•..•...... •....••...... •.•••...•...•...... Hon. Donald W. Orchard

Minister of Highways and Transportation••••..•...•••••...... •.•..••....••••• .Hon. AlbertDriedger

Minister of Finance Government House Leader Minister responsible for the administration of The Crown Corporations Public Review and

Accountability Act...... •.•...... •...... •...... Hon. Clayton S. Manness

Minister of Environment Minister charged with the administration of

The Manitoba Public Insurance Corporation Act •.•...... •.•••...... ••Hon. Glen Cummings

Minister of Justice and Attorney General Keeper of The Great Seal

Minister responsible for Constitutional Affairs...... •••...•...... •..•...•...... •...... Hon. James C. McCrae

226 Appendices

Minister of Urban Affairs

Ministerof Housing ...... •...... ••.•...•.•...... •••••.•••...... •••...... Hon. James A. Ernst

Minister of Agriculture Minister responsible for the administration of

The Manitoba Telephone Act ...... •...... ••••.•.•...� ...... ••..•.•...... ••.•.•...... •...... J-Ion. Glen M. Findlay

Minister of Rural Development ...... •.•.•...... •••••..•.....•...... •••.•....•..•.•••••...•.••••.. J-Ion. Leonard Derkach

Minister of Government Services Minister responsible for Seniors ...... J-Ion. Gerald Ducharme

Ministerof Culture, Heritage andCitizenship Minister responsible for Multiculturalism Minister charged with the administration of The Manitoba Lotteries Foundation Act

Minister responsible for Status of Women •.•...•...... ••..•.••...... ••...••..•..Hon. Bonnie E. Mitchelson

Minister of Family Services...... •...... ••••.....••••.•.•.•...... •••••.... Hon. Harold Gilleshammer

Minister of Labour Minister responsible for The Civil Service Act, The Civil Service Superannuation Act, The Civil Service Special Supplementary Severance Benefit Act, The Public Servants Insurance Act Minister responsible for and charged with the

administration of The Workers Compensation Act ...... •...... ••...... •...• Hon. Darren T. Praznik

Minister of Industry, Trade andTou rism Minister responsiblefor The Development Corporation Act; Sport Minister responsible for and charged with the administration of The Boxing and Wrestling Commission Act, The Fi tness

and Amateur SportAct ...... •..••••.•.•••...... •••••..•.••••.•.••••...... Hon. Eric Stefanson

Minister of Consumer and Corporate Affairs Minister charged with the administration of

The Liquor Control Act...... ••...... •...... •••...... Hon. Linda Mcintosh

Minister of Education and Training ...... ••.•...... ••..••...... Hon.

227 Appendices

APPENDIX C Standing and Special Committees

Standing Committee Chairperson

Agriculture Mr. Bob Rose Economic Development Mr. Bob Rose Mr. Jack Reimer Industrial Relations Mrs. Louise Dacquay Mrs. Shirley Render Law Amendments Mrs. Louise Dacquay Mr. Jack Penner

Municipal Affairs Mrs. Louise Dacquay Mr. Bob Rose Private Bills Mr. Jack Reimer Privileges and Elections Mrs. Shirley Render Public Accounts Mr. Leonard Evans

Public Utilities and Natural Resources Mr. Jack Penner .

Mr. Bob Rose

Mr. Marcel Laurendeau Mr. Jack Reimer

228