Required Chlorination Doses to Fulfill the Credit Value for Disinfection of Enteric Viruses in Water: a Critical Review
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Required chlorination doses to fulfill the credit value for disinfection of enteric viruses in water: A critical review Item Type Article Authors Rachmadi, Andri Taruna; Kitajima, Masaaki; Kato, Tsuyoshi; Kato, Hiroyuki; Okabe, Satoshi; Sano, Daisuke Citation Rachmadi, A. T., Kitajima, M., Kato, T., Kato, H., Okabe, S., & Sano, D. (2020). Required chlorination doses to fulfill the credit value for disinfection of enteric viruses in water: A critical review. Environmental Science & Technology. doi:10.1021/ acs.est.9b01685 Eprint version Publisher's Version/PDF DOI 10.1021/acs.est.9b01685 Publisher American Chemical Society (ACS) Journal Environmental Science & Technology Rights This is an open access article published under an ACS AuthorChoice License, which permits copying and redistribution of the article or any adaptations for non-commercial purposes. Download date 02/10/2021 21:39:20 Item License http://pubs.acs.org/page/policy/authorchoice_termsofuse.html Link to Item http://hdl.handle.net/10754/661375 This is an open access article published under an ACS AuthorChoice License, which permits copying and redistribution of the article or any adaptations for non-commercial purposes. pubs.acs.org/est Critical Review Required Chlorination Doses to Fulfill the Credit Value for Disinfection of Enteric Viruses in Water: A Critical Review Andri Taruna Rachmadi, Masaaki Kitajima, Tsuyoshi Kato, Hiroyuki Kato, Satoshi Okabe, and Daisuke Sano* Cite This: https://dx.doi.org/10.1021/acs.est.9b01685 Read Online ACCESS Metrics & More Article Recommendations *sı Supporting Information ABSTRACT: A credit value of virus inactivation has been assigned to the disinfection step in international and domestic guidelines for wastewater reclamation and reuse. To fulfill the credit value for water disinfection, water engineers need to apply an appropriate disinfection strength, expressed as a CT value (mg × min/L), which is a product of disinfectant concentration and contact time, against enteric viruses in wastewater. In the present study, we extracted published experimental data on enteric virus inactivation using free chlorine and monochloramine and applied the Tobit analysis and simple linear regression analysis to calculate × the range of CT values (mg min/L) needed for 4-log10 inactivation. Data were selected from peer-reviewed papers containing kinetics data of virus infectivity and chlorine residual in water. Coxsackie B virus and echovirus require higher CT values (lower susceptibility) for 4-log10 inactivation than adenovirus and a human norovirus surrogate (murine norovirus) with free chlorine. On the other hand, adenovirus has lower susceptibility to monochloramine compared to murine norovirus, coxsackievirus, and echovirus. The factors that influence the required CT value are virus type, pH, water temperature, and water matrix. This systematic review demonstrates that enteroviruses and adenovirus are appropriate representative enteric viruses to evaluate water disinfection using free chlorine and monochloramine, respectively. 1. INTRODUCTION The WHO guidelines for the safe use of wastewater, excreta, Fresh water is an unevenly distributed and scarce resource due and greywater have recommended the multiple barrier system to several factors, including human population growth in for health risk management in wastewater reclamation and 9 urbanized areas and global climate change.1,2 Wastewater reuse. In the multiple barrier system, unit processes of reclamation and reuse, even for drinking purposes, has been wastewater treatment, such as a primary settlement process, a regarded as a promising practice to mitigate water stress,2,3 biological treatment process, an advanced oxidation process, a although waterborne disease risks caused by pathogens in membrane filtration process, and a disinfection process, are 4 See https://pubs.acs.org/sharingguidelines for options on how to legitimately share published articles. Downloaded via KING ABDULLAH UNIV SCI TECHLGY on February 4, 2020 at 11:48:33 (UTC). ffi wastewater need to be properly managed. Enteric viruses, in combined to obtain a su cient total log10 reduction of particular, warrant special attention as waterborne pathogens 10 5,6 pathogens in water. In order to achieve a health-based target because of their high concentration in untreated wastewater. based on the tolerable loss of disability-adjusted life years Guidelines for drinking water need to be followed when (DALYs) per person per year, a virus reduction of 2- to 3-log reclaimed wastewater is used as a drinking water source, and 10 and 6- to 7-log10 is required in the reclaimed water for some domestic and international guidelines urge drinking 11 water engineers to pay attention to enteric viruses in the restricted and unrestricted irrigation sources, respectively. source. For example, the United States Environmental Another study recommended an additional 2- to 3-log10 Protection Agency (USEPA) has included adenovirus, reduction of viruses in water to ensure the safety of recycled caliciviruses (including norovirus), enterovirus (including water for irrigation of food crops and drinking water polioviruses, coxsackievirus, and echovirus), and hepatitis A purposes.12 virus in the contaminant candidate list 4 (CCL4) in 2016 as 7 common drinking water microbial contaminants. In addition, Received: March 19, 2019 the World Health Organization (WHO) guidelines for Revised: December 22, 2019 drinking water quality (2011) classify astroviruses, hepatitis E Accepted: January 13, 2020 virus, sapovirus, and rotavirus as important pathogens with Published: January 13, 2020 some evidence for high health risks.8 © XXXX American Chemical Society https://dx.doi.org/10.1021/acs.est.9b01685 A Environ. Sci. Technol. XXXX, XXX, XXX−XXX Environmental Science & Technology pubs.acs.org/est Critical Review The final barrier in water and wastewater treatment used were “chlorine” + “disinfectant” + “kinetics” and the name processes is usually disinfection. Sodium hypochlorite, ozone, of virus type, including “human norovirus” (HuNoV), and peracetic acid are frequently used as disinfection agents in “adenovirus” (AdV), “echovirus” (EV), or “coxsackie B virus” water and wastewater treatment plants in developed (CVB). Murine norovirus (MNV) was included as a surrogate countries.13 Among available disinfection agents, free chlorine for human norovirus due to the unavailability of robust cell (in sodium hypochlorite form) and monochloramine are still lines for human norovirus infectivity assay.21 Data were the most widely used disinfectants due to their low cost and extracted from the articles by a single reviewer (ATR) and efficacy for the inactivation of microbes, despite their limited verified by another reviewer (DS). The extracted data included surface contact area in the event that aggregates of enteric CT values, LRVs, tested virus strain, and experimental viruses are formed and there are disinfectant scavengers in conditions of water matrices (pH, temperature, turbidity). water such as organic matter.14,15 The biocide effect of a After obtaining the initial screening results, each paper’s title disinfectant is expressed as a CT value, which is a product of and abstract were cross-checked to ensure the paper fulfilled all disinfectant concentration and exposure time. In disinfection the requirements mentioned above. Duplicates found in both step of the multiple barrier system, the CT values (mg × min/ databases were also eliminated in the final results. L) required to inactivate enteric viruses by a certain level (for Three methods were employed to extract the CT values and example, a 2-log10 reduction or 99% inactivation) need to be LRVs. First, when CT values calculated using the EFH determined prior to the operation of a wastewater treatment model19,20 were provided in the selected paper, those CT system.10 The USEPA guidance manual for compliance with values specified in the manuscript were directly used. Second, the filtration and disinfection requirements for public water when all the EFH model parameter values were available in the systems using surface water sources has shown that CT values manuscript, including Supporting Information (SI), a manual of 3, 4, and 6 mg × min/L are required to get a 2-,3-, and 4- calculation was conducted to obtain the CT values needed for ° − log10 virus reduction in water at 10 C and pH 6.0 9.0 by free 2,3 and 4 LRVs using the EFH model described in the chlorine.16 The USEPA project summary has indicated the CT following formula:19 values of 1.1−2.5 and 0.01−0.05 mg × min/L needed for a 2- CC=−exp( kt* ) (2.1) log10 reduction of poliovirus and rotavirus using free chlorine t 0 and 768−3740 and 3806−6476 mg × min/L with monochlor- 17 −nk* t amine, respectively. WHO drinking water guidelines state nm1exp()− m * m ln(NNo / ) =− kCt ′0 [ ()nk t ] that a CT value range from 2 to 30 mg × min/L is needed to m (2.2) obtain a 2-log reduction of viruses at 0−10 °C and pH 7−9.8 fi 10 where Ct is the chlorine concentration at speci c sampling However, there is yet to be any detailed sets of guideline CT times, ln N/N0 is the natural log of the survival ratio (number values for each enteric virus listed as a water contaminant by of viruses remaining at time t divided by the number at initial USEPA and WHO. * time), C0 is the initial concentration of chlorine, k is the This study aimed to estimate the CT values necessary to chlorine decay rate (min−1), m is the unity constant, n is the ffi obtain su cient log10 reduction of enteric viruses using free coefficient of dilution (dimensionless), and k’ is the viral chlorine and monochloramine. The CT values for a 4-log10 reduction rate (dimensionless). Third, when all data of fi reduction were derived to ful ll the minimum requirement of infectivity reduction kinetics and chlorine decay were available disinfectant process in drinking water regulation based on only in graphs, we extracted the CT and log10 points using published data sets from various studies using a Tobit-censored ImageJ software. or standard linear regression model. The extracted CT values and LRVs from selected articles were combined together within the same virus species.