Brian Greene on Music and String Theory

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Brian Greene on Music and String Theory OPINION NATURE|Vol 465|27 May 2010 Q&A: Brian Greene on music and string theory Brian Greene, author of best-selling books The Elegant Universe and The Fabric of the Cosmos, is a theoretical physicist at Columbia University, New York. As an orchestral work based on his 2008 children’s book, Icarus at the Edge of Time, premieres next week, Greene discusses black holes and how music might portray the physics of warped space-time. How have you reworked the Greek myth universes. At Columbia we are studying of Icarus? ‘quantum tunnellings’, which may punch Instead of donning wax wings and flying to through a barrier from one universe to TO/EYEVINE the Sun, in this story a boy builds his own another. We’re studying the ways that AS spaceship and, against his father’s warning, quantum mechanics can generate multiple flies close to a black hole. Black holes have universes. I’m writing a popular book about CONTR a reputation for reaching out and sucking these, which asks the essential question: things in, but they’re not like vacuum when we talk about universes beyond our cleaners — if you stay outside the black hole’s own, is it science? boundary, or event horizon, you can pull away. The boy does just that, but as Albert Has string theory helped us to understand Einstein taught us, black holes affect one’s black holes? passage through time. When the boy returns String theory has given us insights into black from his journey, it is 10,000 years later. The holes that could not have been obtained life he knew is gone. His father is gone. solely through Einstein’s theory of general relativity. In 1974, Stephen Hawking asserted Isn’t that rather grim for a children’s that black holes are not completely black; they story? radiate quantum mechanically, which means It is dark from one perspective but brighter they have entropy, a measure of disorder. from another. At first I didn’t want to force For more than 20 years, no one could figure the book on my five year old. Only recently out where the disorder was stored. Then did my wife read it to him, and he cried at in 1996, physicists Andrew Strominger the end. Since then, he asks me questions and Cumrun Vafa at Harvard University almost daily, such as if the black hole was resolved that problem using string theory. smaller, might less time have passed so the It was a profound discovery. The fact that father would still be alive? Time dilation and string theory could articulate something so general relativity now matter to my five year fundamental convinced many of us that it had old. That’s unusual, and shows what such the capacity to describe physics as we know it. an undertaking can do. It can make science really matter. What do you make of those who are What was it like to work with Philip Glass, sceptical of string theory? Why were you attracted to the myth? the composer of operas about physicists String theory is an attempt to study some It struck me as odd, troublesome even; Johannes Kepler and Einstein? of the deepest questions that we have the original Icarus pays for his courage His interest in science goes deep. When ever studied scientifically. All of us agree with his life, but that is not the way things The Elegant Universe came out in 1999, he that the theory has yet to be established should work. As scientists, we know that called me to discuss some of the chapters. experimentally. We’re still trying to you must push the boundaries. You go into After he agreed to compose the music for understand it well enough to make contact the darkness, not knowing how it will turn Icarus at the Edge of Time, I would explain with experiment. That we haven’t yet reached out, but being willing to grapple with the the physics of warped space and time, and he that point is not a failure of the theory. It’s a consequences. We have seen that during would struggle to represent it musically. For challenge we’re trying to rise to. ■ the atomic age and, more recently, with the instance, as the boy got near the black hole, Jascha Hoffman is a journalist based in human genome, where we are still struggling would you want two lines of music playing San Francisco, California. to come to terms with our new-found power. against each other, one for his time frame and e-mail: [email protected] one for the rest of the Universe? Should you How is your story adapted to the stage? represent gravitational redshift with changes Icarus at the Edge of Time It has a narrator and orchestra, and a film is in frequency? He has tried, in an artful and Narration adapted by Brian Greene and projected behind it. Philip Glass composed poetic way, to capture some of the physics. David Henry Hwang. Music by Philip Glass. the score. David Henry Hwang, who wrote Film created and directed by Al and Al. the 1988 play M. Butterfly, helped me to Meanwhile, what of your research? At the World Science Festival: adapt the text. The visual artists Al and Al Many string theorists are asking whether 6 June, NYU Skirball Center, New York are creating the film, which attempts in an the evolution of the Universe over time At the Royal Society’s See Further festival: impressionistic way to suggest what it is like could give us an insight into how likely our 3–4 July, Royal Festival Hall, London to travel near the edge of a black hole. Universe is to exist among many possible 426 © 2010 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved.
Recommended publications
  • Stephen Hawking (1942–2018) World-Renowned Physicist Who Defied the Odds
    COMMENT OBITUARY Stephen Hawking (1942–2018) World-renowned physicist who defied the odds. hen Stephen Hawking was speech synthesizer processed his words and diagnosed with motor-neuron generated the androidal accent that became disease at the age of 21, it wasn’t his trademark. In this way, he completed his Wclear that he would finish his PhD. Against best-selling book A Brief History of Time all expectations, he lived on for 55 years, (Bantam, 1988), which propelled him to becoming one of the world’s most celebrated celebrity status. IAN BERRY/MAGNUM scientists. Had Hawking achieved equal distinction Hawking, who died on 14 March 2018, was in any other branch of science besides cos- born in Oxford, UK, in 1942 to a medical- mology, it probably would not have had the researcher father and a philosophy-graduate same resonance with a worldwide public. As mother. After attending St Albans School I put it in The Telegraph newspaper in 2007, near London, he earned a first-class degree “the concept of an imprisoned mind roaming in physics from the University of Oxford. He the cosmos” grabbed people’s imagination. began his research career in 1962, enrolling In 1965, Stephen married Jane Wilde. as a graduate student in a group at the Uni- After 25 years of marriage, and three versity of Cambridge led by one of the fathers children, the strain of Stephen’s illness of modern cosmology, Dennis Sciama. and of sharing their home with a team of The general theory of relativity was at that nurses became too much and they sepa- time undergoing a renaissance, initiated in rated, divorcing in 1995.
    [Show full text]
  • CERN Celebrates Discoveries
    INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF HIGH-ENERGY PHYSICS CERN COURIER VOLUME 43 NUMBER 10 DECEMBER 2003 CERN celebrates discoveries NEW PARTICLES NETWORKS SPAIN Protons make pentaquarks p5 Measuring the digital divide pl7 Particle physics thrives p30 16 KPH impact 113 KPH impact series VISyN High Voltage Power Supplies When the objective is to measure the almost immeasurable, the VISyN-Series is the detector power supply of choice. These multi-output, card based high voltage power supplies are stable, predictable, and versatile. VISyN is now manufactured by Universal High Voltage, a world leader in high voltage power supplies, whose products are in use in every national laboratory. For worldwide sales and service, contact the VISyN product group at Universal High Voltage. Universal High Voltage Your High Voltage Power Partner 57 Commerce Drive, Brookfield CT 06804 USA « (203) 740-8555 • Fax (203) 740-9555 www.universalhv.com Covering current developments in high- energy physics and related fields worldwide CERN Courier (ISSN 0304-288X) is distributed to member state governments, institutes and laboratories affiliated with CERN, and to their personnel. It is published monthly, except for January and August, in English and French editions. The views expressed are CERN not necessarily those of the CERN management. Editor Christine Sutton CERN, 1211 Geneva 23, Switzerland E-mail: [email protected] Fax:+41 (22) 782 1906 Web: cerncourier.com COURIER Advisory Board R Landua (Chairman), P Sphicas, K Potter, E Lillest0l, C Detraz, H Hoffmann, R Bailey
    [Show full text]
  • Supergravity at 40: Reflections and Perspectives(∗)
    RIVISTA DEL NUOVO CIMENTO Vol. 40, N. 6 2017 DOI 10.1393/ncr/i2017-10136-6 ∗ Supergravity at 40: Reflections and perspectives( ) S. Ferrara(1)(2)(3)andA. Sagnotti(4) (1) Theoretical Physics Department, CERN CH - 1211 Geneva 23, Switzerland (2) INFN - Laboratori Nazionali di Frascati - Via Enrico Fermi 40 I-00044 Frascati (RM), Italy (3) Department of Physics and Astronomy, Mani L. Bhaumik Institute for Theoretical Physics U.C.L.A., Los Angeles CA 90095-1547, USA (4) Scuola Normale Superiore e INFN - Piazza dei Cavalieri 7, I-56126 Pisa, Italy received 15 February 2017 Dedicated to John H. Schwarz on the occasion of his 75th birthday Summary. — The fortieth anniversary of the original construction of Supergravity provides an opportunity to combine some reminiscences of its early days with an assessment of its impact on the quest for a quantum theory of gravity. 280 1. Introduction 280 2. The early times 282 3. The golden age 283 4. Supergravity and particle physics 284 5. Supergravity and string theory 286 6. Branes and M-theory 287 7. Supergravity and the AdS/CFT correspondence 288 8. Conclusions and perspectives ∗ ( ) Based in part on the talk delivered by S.F. at the “Special Session of the DISCRETE2016 Symposium and the Leopold Infeld Colloquium”, in Warsaw, on December 1 2016, and on a joint CERN Courier article. c Societ`a Italiana di Fisica 279 280 S. FERRARA and A. SAGNOTTI 1. – Introduction The year 2016 marked the fortieth anniversary of the discovery of Supergravity (SGR) [1], an extension of Einstein’s General Relativity [2] (GR) where Supersymme- try, promoted to a gauge symmetry, accompanies general coordinate transformations.
    [Show full text]
  • The Multiverse: Conjecture, Proof, and Science
    The multiverse: conjecture, proof, and science George Ellis Talk at Nicolai Fest Golm 2012 Does the Multiverse Really Exist ? Scientific American: July 2011 1 The idea The idea of a multiverse -- an ensemble of universes or of universe domains – has received increasing attention in cosmology - separate places [Vilenkin, Linde, Guth] - separate times [Smolin, cyclic universes] - the Everett quantum multi-universe: other branches of the wavefunction [Deutsch] - the cosmic landscape of string theory, imbedded in a chaotic cosmology [Susskind] - totally disjoint [Sciama, Tegmark] 2 Our Cosmic Habitat Martin Rees Rees explores the notion that our universe is just a part of a vast ''multiverse,'' or ensemble of universes, in which most of the other universes are lifeless. What we call the laws of nature would then be no more than local bylaws, imposed in the aftermath of our own Big Bang. In this scenario, our cosmic habitat would be a special, possibly unique universe where the prevailing laws of physics allowed life to emerge. 3 Scientific American May 2003 issue COSMOLOGY “Parallel Universes: Not just a staple of science fiction, other universes are a direct implication of cosmological observations” By Max Tegmark 4 Brian Greene: The Hidden Reality Parallel Universes and The Deep Laws of the Cosmos 5 Varieties of Multiverse Brian Greene (The Hidden Reality) advocates nine different types of multiverse: 1. Invisible parts of our universe 2. Chaotic inflation 3. Brane worlds 4. Cyclic universes 5. Landscape of string theory 6. Branches of the Quantum mechanics wave function 7. Holographic projections 8. Computer simulations 9. All that can exist must exist – “grandest of all multiverses” They can’t all be true! – they conflict with each other.
    [Show full text]
  • Sacred Rhetorical Invention in the String Theory Movement
    University of Nebraska - Lincoln DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln Communication Studies Theses, Dissertations, and Student Research Communication Studies, Department of Spring 4-12-2011 Secular Salvation: Sacred Rhetorical Invention in the String Theory Movement Brent Yergensen University of Nebraska-Lincoln, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.unl.edu/commstuddiss Part of the Speech and Rhetorical Studies Commons Yergensen, Brent, "Secular Salvation: Sacred Rhetorical Invention in the String Theory Movement" (2011). Communication Studies Theses, Dissertations, and Student Research. 6. https://digitalcommons.unl.edu/commstuddiss/6 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Communication Studies, Department of at DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln. It has been accepted for inclusion in Communication Studies Theses, Dissertations, and Student Research by an authorized administrator of DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln. SECULAR SALVATION: SACRED RHETORICAL INVENTION IN THE STRING THEORY MOVEMENT by Brent Yergensen A DISSERTATION Presented to the Faculty of The Graduate College at the University of Nebraska In Partial Fulfillment of Requirements For the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy Major: Communication Studies Under the Supervision of Dr. Ronald Lee Lincoln, Nebraska April, 2011 ii SECULAR SALVATION: SACRED RHETORICAL INVENTION IN THE STRING THEORY MOVEMENT Brent Yergensen, Ph.D. University of Nebraska, 2011 Advisor: Ronald Lee String theory is argued by its proponents to be the Theory of Everything. It achieves this status in physics because it provides unification for contradictory laws of physics, namely quantum mechanics and general relativity. While based on advanced theoretical mathematics, its public discourse is growing in prevalence and its rhetorical power is leading to a scientific revolution, even among the public.
    [Show full text]
  • Is String Theory Holographic? 1 Introduction
    Holography and large-N Dualities Is String Theory Holographic? Lukas Hahn 1 Introduction1 2 Classical Strings and Black Holes2 3 The Strominger-Vafa Construction3 3.1 AdS/CFT for the D1/D5 System......................3 3.2 The Instanton Moduli Space.........................6 3.3 The Elliptic Genus.............................. 10 1 Introduction The holographic principle [1] is based on the idea that there is a limit on information content of spacetime regions. For a given volume V bounded by an area A, the state of maximal entropy corresponds to the largest black hole that can fit inside V . This entropy bound is specified by the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy A S ≤ S = (1.1) BH 4G and the goings-on in the relevant spacetime region are encoded on "holographic screens". The aim of these notes is to discuss one of the many aspects of the question in the title, namely: "Is this feature of the holographic principle realized in string theory (and if so, how)?". In order to adress this question we start with an heuristic account of how string like objects are related to black holes and how to compare their entropies. This second section is exclusively based on [2] and will lead to a key insight, the need to consider BPS states, which allows for a more precise treatment. The most fully understood example is 1 a bound state of D-branes that appeared in the original article on the topic [3]. The third section is an attempt to review this construction from a point of view that highlights the role of AdS/CFT [4,5].
    [Show full text]
  • Soft Hair on Black Holes Arxiv:1601.00921V1 [Hep-Th] 5 Jan
    Soft Hair on Black Holes Stephen W. Hawkingy, Malcolm J. Perryy and Andrew Strominger∗ yDAMTP, Centre for Mathematical Sciences, University of Cambridge, Cambridge, CB3 0WA UK ∗ Center for the Fundamental Laws of Nature, Harvard University, Cambridge, MA 02138, USA Abstract It has recently been shown that BMS supertranslation symmetries imply an infinite number of conservation laws for all gravitational theories in asymptotically Minkowskian spacetimes. These laws require black holes to carry a large amount of soft (i:e: zero- energy) supertranslation hair. The presence of a Maxwell field similarly implies soft electric hair. This paper gives an explicit description of soft hair in terms of soft gravitons or photons on the black hole horizon, and shows that complete information about their quantum state is stored on a holographic plate at the future boundary of the horizon. Charge conservation is used to give an infinite number of exact relations between the evaporation products of black holes which have different soft hair but are otherwise identical. It is further argued that soft hair which is spatially localized to arXiv:1601.00921v1 [hep-th] 5 Jan 2016 much less than a Planck length cannot be excited in a physically realizable process, giving an effective number of soft degrees of freedom proportional to the horizon area in Planck units. Contents 1 Introduction 1 2 Electromagnetic conservation laws and soft symmetries 4 3 Conservation laws in the presence of black holes 7 4 Black hole evaporation 9 5 Quantum hair implants 12 6 Gauge invariance 14 7 Supertranslations 15 8 Conclusion 17 1 Introduction Forty years ago, one of the authors argued [1] that information is destroyed when a black hole is formed and subsequently evaporates [2, 3].
    [Show full text]
  • MATTERS of GRAVITY Contents
    MATTERS OF GRAVITY The newsletter of the Division of Gravitational Physics of the American Physical Society Number 52 December 2018 Contents DGRAV News: we hear that . , by David Garfinkle ..................... 3 APS April Meeting, by David Garfinkle ................... 4 Editor David Garfinkle Department of Physics Oakland University Rochester, MI 48309 Phone: (248) 370-3411 Internet: garfinkl-at-oakland.edu WWW: http://www.oakland.edu/physics/Faculty/david-garfinkle Associate Editor Greg Comer Department of Physics and Center for Fluids at All Scales, St. Louis University, St. Louis, MO 63103 Phone: (314) 977-8432 Internet: comergl-at-slu.edu WWW: http://www.slu.edu/arts-and-sciences/physics/faculty/comer-greg.php ISSN: 1527-3431 DISCLAIMER: The opinions expressed in the articles of this newsletter represent the views of the authors and are not necessarily the views of APS. The articles in this newsletter are not peer reviewed. 1 Editorial The next newsletter is due June 2019. Issues 28-52 are available on the web at https://files.oakland.edu/users/garfinkl/web/mog/ All issues before number 28 are available at http://www.phys.lsu.edu/mog Any ideas for topics that should be covered by the newsletter should be emailed to me, or Greg Comer, or the relevant correspondent. Any comments/questions/complaints about the newsletter should be emailed to me. A hardcopy of the newsletter is distributed free of charge to the members of the APS Division of Gravitational Physics upon request (the default distribution form is via the web) to the secretary of the Division. It is considered a lack of etiquette to ask me to mail you hard copies of the newsletter unless you have exhausted all your resources to get your copy otherwise.
    [Show full text]
  • The Shape of Inner Space: String Theory and the Geometry of the Universe's Hidden Dimensions
    [PDF] The Shape Of Inner Space: String Theory And The Geometry Of The Universe's Hidden Dimensions Shing-Tung Yau, Steve Nadis - download pdf free book The Shape Of Inner Space: String Theory And The Geometry Of The Universe's Hidden Dimensions PDF, The Shape Of Inner Space: String Theory And The Geometry Of The Universe's Hidden Dimensions Download PDF, Read Online The Shape Of Inner Space: String Theory And The Geometry Of The Universe's Hidden Dimensions E-Books, Read The Shape Of Inner Space: String Theory And The Geometry Of The Universe's Hidden Dimensions Full Collection Shing-Tung Yau, Steve Nadis, I Was So Mad The Shape Of Inner Space: String Theory And The Geometry Of The Universe's Hidden Dimensions Shing- Tung Yau, Steve Nadis Ebook Download, PDF The Shape Of Inner Space: String Theory And The Geometry Of The Universe's Hidden Dimensions Free Download, Read Online The Shape Of Inner Space: String Theory And The Geometry Of The Universe's Hidden Dimensions Ebook Popular, online free The Shape Of Inner Space: String Theory And The Geometry Of The Universe's Hidden Dimensions, Download Online The Shape Of Inner Space: String Theory And The Geometry Of The Universe's Hidden Dimensions Book, Download PDF The Shape Of Inner Space: String Theory And The Geometry Of The Universe's Hidden Dimensions, Download pdf The Shape Of Inner Space: String Theory And The Geometry Of The Universe's Hidden Dimensions, Read Best Book Online The Shape Of Inner Space: String Theory And The Geometry Of The Universe's Hidden Dimensions, Read Online The
    [Show full text]
  • Modern Physics 436: Course Outline
    Modern Physics 436: Course Outline 1. The book that I'm going to use for most part of the course will be • Modern Physics: J. Bernstein, P. Fishbane, S. Gasiorowicz (Prentice Hall) (It will be available at the Paragraphe Bookstore) 2. The course generally assumes that you are familiar with basics of integrations, differen- tiations, classical and quantum mechanics. Your pre-requisite are Phys 446, Phys 333. In this course I plan to cover the following topics: • Single particle atom: Basic review of Phys 446 • Multi-particle atoms: Molecules, molecular bondings • Statistical mechanics: Classical and quantum aspects, Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution, Fermi-Dirac distribution, Bose-Einstein distribution, Bose-Einstein condensation • Lasers: Induced radiations, coherent and squeezed states of light • Condensed matter Physics: Band structure, semiconductors, superconductivity, BCS theory, Hall effects (classical and quantum), Laughlin function • Nuclear Physics: Nuclear structure, nuclear interactions, nuclear models • Elementary Particle Physics: Quantum field theory (QFT), virtual particles, Feynman path-integrals, Feynman diagrams, Quantum electrodynamics (QED), particle zoo, weak interactions, leptons, hadrons, Quantum chromodynamics (QCD), quarks Wish-list: • General Relativity and Cosmology: Basic GTR, cosmological inflation, big-bang nucle- osynthesis • Superstring Theory: Very basic ideas, types of string theories, supersymmetry, super- gravity 3. Although I'll try to stick with one book, you're always advised to read other books for more details. A few other important books on the above topics are: • Quantum Mechanics: You may have already been using the book by David Griffiths. Another very good book is by Claude Cohen-Tannoudji, Bernard Diu and Frank Laloe. It comes in two volumes and does everything in full details.
    [Show full text]
  • Dear Brian Greene, When Friends Come to Visit at My House, They See
    Dear Brian Greene, When friends come to visit at my house, they see warning signs on my door saying “High Voltage! Neutron Radiation!” This is because last spring, I took on the task of building a fusion reactor which is now operational and in a research phase. Thanks to the inspiration that I received from reading your book, The Elegant Universe, I have committed my life to a future in nuclear physics. Last year, I was searching for informational books on particle physics since this was an interest of mine; however, I found it difficult to find higher level materials that didn’t require college mathematics knowledge. The solution was your book, which I quickly read and have since been fascinated by the subject. The way that advanced topics are portrayed in a simple to understand and intriguing fashion make the book a brilliant piece of work that any aspiring physicist should read. I vividly recall two nights regarding my fascination with high energy physics. The first of those was the evening that I obtained a copy of The Elegant Universe after it was suggested to me as an excellent resource in string theory and quantum mechanics. I don’t think I ever went to bed that night while I devoured as much literature as I could. Within a week, I had completed the book and realized that my future was in this field. The other event that I recall was when I was searching for a science project online and stumbled upon fusor.net, a research consortium dedicated to amateur nuclear fusion.
    [Show full text]
  • Hawking Radiation and Black Hole Thermodynamics
    HAWKING RADIATION AND BLACK HOLE THERMODYNAMICS ∗ Don N. Page † Institute for Theoretical Physics Department of Physics, University of Alberta Edmonton, Alberta, Canada T6G 2J1 (2004 September 3; additional section added 2004 December 31 ‡) Abstract An inexhaustive review of Hawking radiation and black hole thermody- namics is given, focusing especially upon some of the historical aspects as seen from the biased viewpoint of a minor player in the field on and off for the past thirty years. arXiv:hep-th/0409024v3 31 Dec 2004 ∗Alberta-Thy-18-04, hep-th/0409024, review article solicited for a celebratory Focus Issue on Relativity, “Spacetime 100 Years Later,” to be published in New Journal of Physics. †Internet address: [email protected] ‡On this date the author reached an age which is an integer divisor of the number of references. 1 1 Historical Background Black holes are perhaps the most perfectly thermal objects in the universe, and yet their thermal properties are not fully understood. They are described very accurately by a small number of macroscopic parameters (e.g., mass, angular mo- mentum, and charge), but the microscopic degrees of freedom that lead to their thermal behavior have not yet been adequately identified. Strong hints of the thermal properties of black holes came from the behavior of their macroscopic properties that were formalized in the (classical) four laws of black hole mechanics [1], which have analogues in the corresponding four laws of thermodynamics: The zeroth law of black hole mechanics is that the surface gravity κ of a stationary black hole is constant over its event horizon [2, 1].
    [Show full text]