Histories of Land Politicization, Property and Belonging in Molo, Kenya Kolben Waaranperä, Ulrika
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Histories of land Politicization, property and belonging in Molo, Kenya Kolben Waaranperä, Ulrika 2018 Document Version: Publisher's PDF, also known as Version of record Link to publication Citation for published version (APA): Kolben Waaranperä, U. (2018). Histories of land: Politicization, property and belonging in Molo, Kenya. Lund University. Total number of authors: 1 General rights Unless other specific re-use rights are stated the following general rights apply: Copyright and moral rights for the publications made accessible in the public portal are retained by the authors and/or other copyright owners and it is a condition of accessing publications that users recognise and abide by the legal requirements associated with these rights. • Users may download and print one copy of any publication from the public portal for the purpose of private study or research. • You may not further distribute the material or use it for any profit-making activity or commercial gain • You may freely distribute the URL identifying the publication in the public portal Read more about Creative commons licenses: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/ Take down policy If you believe that this document breaches copyright please contact us providing details, and we will remove access to the work immediately and investigate your claim. LUND UNIVERSITY PO Box 117 221 00 Lund +46 46-222 00 00 ULRIKA WAARANPERÄ LUND UNIVERSITY & MALMÖ UNIVERSITY Histories of land Politicization, property and belonging in Molo, Kenya Ulrika Waaranperä DOCTORAL DISSERTATION by due permission of the Faculty of Social Science, Lund University, Sweden. To be defended at Niagara, auditorium NI:C0E11, Nordenskiöldsgatan 1, Malmö. 19 April 2018, 10.15 AM Faculty opponent Research Professor Morten Bøås Norwegian Institute of International Affairs Organization Document name LUND UNIVERSITY DOCTORAL DISSERTATION Date of issue 23 March 2018 Sponsoring organization Author(s) Lund University & Malmö University Ulrika Waaranperä Title and subtitle Histories of land. Politicization, property and belonging in Molo, Kenya Abstract This thesis aims to explore the politicization of land in a local setting in Kenya. The purpose is to study how access to land is justified through histories about relational property and belonging. The notion of deep politics is used in order to suggest that these histories of property and belonging not only transform the meanings of land but also the meanings of politics. The empirical chapters describe how the ordeals of the high politics of the state—such as the creation of settlement schemes, the provision of landed resources, or the alteration of constituency boundaries—have given rise to local histories about how property and belonging are constituted. The findings of the thesis build on extensive fieldwork. The main empirical material consists of qualitative interviews with 129 persons, undertaken primarily in Molo. The interviews are complemented with ethnographic observations and archival sources. In policy and theory alike, land is usually treated as a purely economic resource, subject to property rights regulations of a technical, universal and decontextualized nature. Such assumptions have underwritten many large-scale land privatization reforms in the Global South. In contrast to such assumptions, this dissertation contributes to the literature on access to land in Africa by suggesting that even when property rights to land are generally accepted, they are also backed up by other claims, such as various histories of belonging. The idea that property rights, decades after titling-reforms, are both accepted and complemented with other notions of what constitutes legitimate access to land is an original finding of the thesis. This adds further complexity to the notion of property as inherently relational and potentially eligible for politicization. Additional light is hereby cast on why conflicts over land might not be solved but instead reinforced by land reforms. Key words: Property, belonging, politicization, land, histories, deep politics, Kenya Classification system and/or index termes (if any): Supplementary bibliographical information: Language English ISSN and key title: ISBN 0460-0037 Histories of land. 978-91-7753-567-6 Recipient’s notes Number of pages Price 266 Security classification I, the undersigned, being the copyright owner of the abstract of the above-mentioned dissertation, hereby grant to all reference sources permission to publish and disseminate the abstract of the above-mentioned dissertation. Signature:__________________________________ Date: 23-03-2018 Histories of land Cover art by Johanna Fjaestad Camino Primitivo I & Camino Primitivo Blanco, oil on canvas © Ulrika Waaranperä Malmö University, Department of Global Political Studies Lund University, Department of Political Science ISBN 978-91-7753-567-6 (print) ISBN 978-91-7753-568-3 (pdf) ISSN 0460-0037 Printed in Sweden by All Media Öresund Malmö 2018 Paul Auster writes that every book is the result of somebody’s solitude. These pages took solitude to happen. But the support, insight and sometimes hard work of others was necessary in order to allow me to sit in solitude and write them. First, I need to thank the Moloites. In these pages, they figure as a collective or under pseudonyms, made necessary by the volatile times under which I insisted on discussing matters of land, politics and history with them. Yet, every one of them has contributed crucially to this thesis. For this, I am ever grateful; asanteni sana, nĩ ngatho mũno, koonkoy miising'. With patience, friendship and language skills, Scholar Waititu, Grara Jepleting, Begotty Chepkorir and Lilian Jerono all greatly facilitated my fieldwork by acting as research assistants. As a translator, cultural broker, co-analyst and discussion-partner, Lucy Njeri has been invaluable. Her initiated knowledge of Kenyan politics and her interest in Kenyan histories has greatly challenged and inspired my thinking. These pages would not have been the same without her. Dr Akaranga, Dr Ndhovu and Silvia Sitawa at the Department of Philosophy and Religious Studies at Nairobi University assisted me with both formal and informal matters. The Government of Kenya and The National Commission for Science, Technology and Innovation kindly granted a research permit for this study. The Nordic Africa Institute, Lars Hiertas minnesfond, Stiftelsen Karl Staaffs fond and Per Westlings minnesfond generously funded parts of the research. Åke Uthas and employees at the Ministry of Lands in Nairobi patiently took time to provide me with material, which I have not been able to make full use of in this text. Staff at the Kenya Land Alliance, National Council of Churches in Kenya, and at the National Network for IDPs and Internal Displacement Policy and Advocacy Centre (IDPAC) generously shared their detailed knowledge about matters of land, politics and history. Malena Kjellstrand taught me how to make maps. Johanna Fjaestad kindly granted me permission to use her paintings for the cover. Heather Stacey assisted with editing. All the institutions and individuals named above deserve my thanks. Colleagues and students at two institutions, Global Political Studies, Malmö University and Political Science Department, Lund University, have been crucial for the coming into being of this thesis. I would especially like to mention Sandra Engstrand, Josef Chaib, Emil Persson, Ioana Bunescu, Linn Ehde, Ivan Gusic, Jacob Lind, Mats Fred and Linda Åhäll, with whom I have periodically shared office spaces and the everyday pains and pleasures of writing. Annika Björkdahl, Maja Povrzanović Frykman, Catia Gregoratti, Fabio Cristiano and Ivan Gusic carefully read and offered insightful comments on an earlier draft of this thesis. Klas Nilsson, Johan Lundin and Ann-Charlotte Ek kindly did the same on separate chapters. Special thanks also to my supervisors: Patrik Hall for always stepping in at the right moment to advise me on what to do or to explain what I was already doing. We often speak of persons as ‘understanding’, but as my co- supervisor, Kristina Jönsson has impersonated this word. Her understanding of the journey doctoral studies entails has been invaluable. My second co-supervisor, Anders Sjögren, has not only been a meticulous reader, but his never-resting interest for matters Kenyan has been ever inspiring. To be able to read, write and think, we need numerous other things, some of which were provided to me by the always-helpful librarians at Orkanen library and the forthcoming staff at IT and facility services, including the friendly cleaning staff at level 10. Last for my loved ones. Friends and extended families; you know who you are. Thank you! My mum Inger and dad Bertil for your endless support (even though my interests were always different). Gull-Britt and Bengt for being such dedicated grandparents to our children. Heikki and Amina; you are still small children but very potent teachers of the things in life which are important. Jonas, the love of my life, for companionship—and for understanding solitude: sat nam! Lillasäte, March 2018 Contents 1. INTRODUCTION 1 Histories of land 1 Aim 3 Location of the study 7 Land and politics 11 Overview 19 2. METHODOLOGY 23 The local point of view 23 Seeing from somewhere 25 Being in and making a field 34 Interpretation and representation 45 Methodological contributions 51 3. KENYAN HISTORIES 53 Travelling histories of land 53 Episode 1. Colonial rule 55 Episode 2. Uprising 63 Episode 3. Independence