OF RECORD Sc CASE #2019-1433 CA CASE #2019-CA0047
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
COURT OF APPEALS FOR GREENE COUNTY, OHIO INDEX OF RECORD sc CASE #2019-1433 CA CASE #2019-CA0047 1. GREENE COUNTY COURT OF APPEALS CASE Z019-CA-0047 NUMBERED 1 -34. IN TESTIMONY WHEREOF, I HAVE HERE UNTO SUBSCRIBED MY NAME AS CLERK OF COURT OF APPEALS FOR GREENE COUNTY, OHIO AND AFFIXED THE SEAL OF THE COURT, ON THIS 30”‘ DAY OF OCTOBER, 2019. CLERK OF THE COURT OF APPEALS IN AND FOR GREENE COUNTY, OHIO. Date: 10/30/2019 09:51:01.0 Docket Sheet Page: 1 CRTR5925 Detail Case Number status Judge 2019 CA 0047 Open In The Matter of Action BELLEROOK-SUGARCREEK LOCAL SCHOOLS et a1 VS. STATE OF OHIO EX MANDAMUS ACTION 6102 REL et E1 IN COURT OF APPEALS 130 Party Attorneys 09 gyms EELLEROOK-SUGARCREEK LOCAL SCHOOLS APL JUSTICE, TAEITHA D 3757 UPPER EELLEROOK ROAD SUEASHI & WILDERMUTH BELLEROOK. OH 45305 THE GREENE TOWN CENTER W 50 CHESTNUT STREET SUITE 230 :0! DAYTON, OH 45440 03 STATE OF OHIO EX REL APP HOLLON, CHRISTOPHER C CAELE NEWS NETWORK INC FARUKI IRELAND COX RINEHART & ONE CNN CENTER DUSING PLL ATLANTA. GA 30303 110 NORTH MAIN STREET SUITE 1600 DAYTON, OH 45402 CABLE NEWS NETWORK INC RHINEHART, ERIN E FARUKI PLL 110 NORTH MAIN STREET SUITE 1600 DAYTON, OH 45402 SUPERINTENDENT OF APL JUSTICE. TABITHA D EELLEROOX-SUGARCREEK LOCAL SCHLS DOUGLAS A COZAD PHD SUBASHI S: WILDERMUTH 3757 UPPER EELLEROOK ROAD THE GREENE TOWN CENTER EELLEROOK. OH 45305 50 CHESTNUT STREET SUITE 230 DAYTON, OH 45440 COZAD PHD, DOUGLAS A COX MEDIA GROUP OHIO INC APP HOLLON, CHRISTOPHER C DEA DAYTON DAILY NEWS AND WHIO-TV FARUKI IRELAND COX RINEHART & CHANNEL 7 DUSING PLL 1611 SOUTH MAIN STREET 110 NORTH MAIN STREET SUITE 1600 DAYTON, OH 45409 DAYTON, OH 45402 DAYTON DAILY NEWS DBA RHINEHART, ERIN E FARUKI PLL 110 NORTH MAIN STREET SUITE 1600 DAYTON, OH 45402 WHIO-TV CHANNEL 7 DBA WDTN-TV2 APP STORAR. ANDREW C 4595 SOUTH DIXIE DRIVE 2700 KETTERING TOWER DAYTON: OH 45439 DAYTON, OH 45423 SCRIPPS MEDIA INC APP HOLLON. CHRISTOPHER C DBA WCPO-TV PARUKI IRELAND COX RINEHART & 213 WALNUT STREET DUSING PLL COLUMBUS, OH 43215 110 NORTH MAIN STREET SUITE 1600 DAYTON. OH 45402 WCPO-TV DEA RHINBHART. ERIN E FARUKI PLL 110 NORTH MAIN STREET SUITE 1600 DAYTON, OH 45402 THE CINCINNATI ENQUIRER APP HOLLONy CHRISTOPHER C A DIVISION OF CP MEDIA INC FARUKI IRELAND COX RINEHART & 213 ELM STREET DUSING PLL CINCINNATI, OH 45202 110 NORTH MAIN STREET SUITE 1600 Date: ‘10/30/2019 09:51:01.1 Docket sheet Page: 2 CRTR5925 Detail 2019 CA 0047 ' BELLEROOK~SUGARCREEK LOCAL SCHOOLS et 31 VS. STATE OF OHIO EX REL et al DAYTON, OH 45402 GP MEDIA INC AN RHINEHART, ERIN E PARUKI PLL 110 NORTH MAIN STREET SUITE 1600 DAYTON, OH 45402 THE NEW YORK TIMES COMPANY APP HOLLON, CHRISTOPHER DEA C THE NEW YORK TIMES FARUKI IRELAND COX RINEHART 5: 620 3TH AVE DUSING PLL NEW YORK, NY 10018 110 NORTH MAIN STREET SUITE 1600 DAYTON, OH 45402 THE NEW YORK TIMES DEA RHINEHART, ERIN E FARUKI PLL 110 NORTH MAIN STREET SUITE 1600 DAYTON, OH 45402 AMERICAN BROADCASTING COMPANIES INC APP HOLLON, CHRISTOPHER DEA AEC NEWS C PARUKI IRELAND COX RINEHART & 77 WEST 66TH STREET DUSING PLL APO NEW YORK, NY 10023 110 NORTH MAIN STREET SUITE 1600 DAYTON, OH 45402 ABC NEWS DEA RHINEHART, ERIN E FARUKI PLL 110 NORTH MAIN STREET SUITE 1600 DAYTON, OH 45402 THE ASSOCIATED PRESS APP HOLLON. CHRISTOPHER C 200 LIBERTY STREET FARUKI IRELAND COX RINEHART & NEW YORK, NY 10281 DUSING PLL 110 NORTH MAIN STREET SUITE 1600 DAYTON, OH 45402 RHINEHART, ERIN E FARUKI PLL 110 NORTH MAIN STREET SUITE 1600 DAYTON, OH 45402 OHIO ATTORNEY GENERAL OT ALTIER, MARK 1»: OFFICE OF THE OHIO ATTORNEY GENERAL 30 E BROAD STREET 16TH FLOOR COLUMBUS, OH 43215 Opened Disposed Case 08/09/2019 Type Undisposed COURT OF APPEALS Comments: No. Date of Pleadings Filed, orders and Decrees Amount Dwed/ Balance Due / Journal EOok~Page-Nbr Ref Nbr Amount Dismissed J 1 W 08/09/19 ORIGINAL ACTION IN MANDAMUS FILED 25.00 Receipt: 346960 Date: 08/09/2019 0.00 2 08/09/19 CLERKS COMPUTER SERVICE FEE Receipt: 20.00 346960 Date: 08/09/2019 0.00 3 08/09/19 OTHER COMPUTER SERVICE FEES Receipt: 3.00 346960 Date: 08/09/2019 0.00 Date: ‘10/30/2019 09:51.01.2 Docket sheet Page: 3 CRTR5925 Detail 2019 CA 0047 EELLEROOK~SUGARCREEK LOCAL SCHOOLS et 31 VS. STATE OF OHIO EX REL et al No. Date of Fleadings Filed, Orders and Decrees Amount 0wed/ Balance Due Journal Eook—Page~Nbr Ref Nbr Amount Dismissed 4 08/09/19 DEPOSIT Receipt: 346960 Date: 49.00 09/09/2019 0.00 5 05/05/19 SPECIAL PROJECTS FEE SECOND DISTRICT 25.00 COURT OF APPEALS FILED Receipt: 0.00 346960 Date: 08/09/2019 ~ 09/09/19 MoTIoN FOR EXPEDITED cAsE SCHEDULE AND 0.00 FOR ORAL ARGUMENT FILED; 0.00 ERIN E RHINEHART (Attorney) on behalf of STATE OF ox-no Ex REL (Appenee) 7 08/12/19 SUMMONS ON MANDAMUS ISSUED BY 3.00 CERTIFIED MAIL. Receipt: 346960 Date: 0.00 05/09/2019 9 09/12/19 sUMMoNs FEE 6.00 9 IQ‘ 09/12/19 Issue Date: 08/12/2019 20.00 service: CV Summons on Complaint 20.00 Method: 1 Certified Mail Cost Per: $10.00 EELLBROOK>SUGARCREEK LOCAL SCHOOLS 3757 UPPER BELLBROOK ROAD BELLBROOK, OH 45305 Tracking No: 9590926699042143308409 SUPRRINTENDENT OF EELLBROOK-SUGARCREEK LOCAL SCHLS DOUGLAS A COZAD PHD 3757 UPPER EELLBROOK ROAD BELLEROOK, OH 45305 Tracking No: 9590926699042l43308416 10 09/12/19 JOINT NOTICE OF RESPONDEN‘l‘5' WAIVER 017 0.00 SERVICE AND DEcIsIoN NOT TO OPPOSE 0.00 MoTIoN FOR EXPEDITED cAsE SCHEDULE AND FOR oRA1. ARGUMENT FILED. Attorney: RHINEEART. ERIN E (0079299) Attorney: JUSTICE, TAEITHA D (0075440) ‘ 11 09/12/19 MIS 1 0.00 12 06/12/19 MIS 2 0.00 Date: 10/30/2019 05:51:01.2 Docket Sheet Page : 4 CRTR5925 Detail 2019 CA 0047 BELLBROOK-SUGARCREEK LOCAL SCHOOLS et al VS. STATE OF OHIO EX REL et al Date of Pleadings Filed, Orders and Decrees Amount 0wed/ Journal Balance Due Book-Page-Nbr Ref Nb: Amount Di amissed 13 /Q‘ 08/13/19 DECISION AND ENTRY SCHEDULING ORDER FILED: THE PARTIES PROPOSE AN AGREED EXPEDITED CASE SCHEDULE. WE SUSTAIN THE MOTION TO EXPEDITE AND TAKE THE MOTION FOR ORAL ARGUMENT UNDER ADVISEMENT. THE FOLLOWING SCHEDULE IS ADOPTED: RESPONDENTS SHALL FILE AN ANSWER BY THURSDAY, 8/15/19. THE PARTIES SHALL PRESENT EVIDENCE, IN THE FORM REQUIRED BY LOC.APP.R. 8(E)1 BY MONDAY, 8/19/19. RELATORS SHALL FILE A MERIT BRIEF BY THURSDAY, E/22/19. RESPONDENTS SHALL FILE A MERIT BRIEF BY THURSDAY, 8/29/19. RELATORS SHALL FILE A REPLY BRIEF BY THURSDAY, 8/5/19. ORAL ARGUMENT WILL BE ORDERED BY THE COURT AT A LATER DATE. THE PARTIES SHALL FILE WITH THE CLERK OF THIS COURT AND SHALL ADDITIONAL SUPPLY AN ELECTRONIC COPY OF THEIR FILINGS TO OPPOSING COUNSEL AND TO THIS COURT‘S ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICE BY EMAIL. 19-08-1894/1896 .. 03/13/19 FAX /,3 FEE DUE FROM Receipt: 347057 21.00 Date: 08/13/2019 15 03/15/19 ANSWER OF RESPONDENTS TO RELATORS' COMPLAINT FILED? 0.00 TAEITHA D JUSTICE (Attorney) on behalf of BELLBROOK-SUGARCREEK LOCAL SCHOOLS, SUPERINTENDENT OF BELLBROOK-SUGARCREEK LOCAL SCHL5 (Appellee) ' 16 I 08/15/19 MOTION Eli TO CONSOLIDATE FILED - (WITH 0.00 CASE NUMBER 2019 CA 0049,‘ - COPY TO COA Attorney: LITTLE JR, MARION H (0042679) 17 ~ 05/16/19 NOTICE OF WITHDRAWAL OF MOTION TO CONSOLIDATE FILED. - COPY TO COA 0.00 Attorney: LITTLE JR, MARION H (0042679) 1a\/ IQ 08/19/19 SUCCESSFUL SERVICE Method : 1 Certified Mail ‘ Issued ; 08/12/2019 service CV Summons on Complaint Served 08/15/2019 Return ~ 08/19/2019 On : SUFERINTENDENT OF .BELLBROOK- SUC-ARCREEK LOCAL SCHLS Signed By SHEILA R WOODY "Reason : successful Comment : Tracking H : 959D926S990421433084l6 Date: 10/30/2019 09:51:01.2 Docket sheet Page: 5 cRTR5§25 Detail _ 2019 CA 0047 BELLBROOK-SUGARCREEK LOCAL SCHOOLS et a1 VS. STATE OF OHIO EX REL et al No. Date of Pleadings Filed, Orders and Decrees Amount Owed/ Journal Eook-Page-Nbr Balance Due Ref Nbr Amount Dismissed I9‘/Q‘ 0a/19/19 SUCCESSFUL SERVICE Method 0.00 : 1 Certified Mail Issued 0.00 2 08/12/2019 Service : CV summons on Complaint Served t 08/15/2019 Return : 03/15/2019 On : BELLBROOK-SUGARCREEK LOCAL SCHOOLS Signed By ; sHEILA R wOoDY Reason : Successful Comment Tracking $1 : 9590926699042143308409 03/19/19 JOINT NOTICE ' OF COMPLETION OF 0.00 DISCOVERY, STIPULATIONS, AND AGREED 0.00 STATEMENT OF FACTS FILED. - COPY TO COA 21 ‘Ag’ 08/22/19 MOTION OF DAVE YOsT, OHIO ATTORNEY 0.00 GENERAL, FOR LEAVE OF COURT TO FILE AN 0.00 AMICUS CURIAE BRIEF HEREIN WITH SUCH BRIEF APPENDED HERETO, AND CONDITIONALLY FILED WITH THIS MOTION FILED; Attorney: ALTIER, MARK W (O017BE2) 22 §‘\ 08/22/19 AMICUS CURIAE BRIEF OF ATTORNEY 1.00 GENERAL DAVE YDST CONDITIONALLY 1.00 SUBMITTED WITH MOTION TO FILE SUCH BRIEF FILED - COPY TO COA Attorney: ALTIER, MARK W (0017832) 23 03/22/19 MERIT BRIEF OF RELATORS - FILED COPY 1 00 TO COA . 1 0 0 Attorney: RHINEHART, ERIN E (0075293) . / Attorney: STORAR, ANDREW C (0018302) 24 03/29/19 BRIEF OF — I RESPONDENTS FILED COPY TO COA 1.00 1.00 TABITHA D JUSTICE (Attorney) on behalf of BELLBROOK—SUGARCREEK LOCAL scHOoLs, SUPERINTENDENT OF EELLERoo1<—suOARcREEx< LOCAL scans (Appellee) 25 .