CD_20130311page1_BASIC.qxp 3/8/2013 5:04 PM Page 1
®
www.crainsdetroit.com Vol. 29, No. 10 MARCH 11 – 17, 2013 $2 a copy; $59 a year
©Entire contents copyright 2013 by Crain Communications Inc. All rights reserved
Page 3
Who will eventually replace ‘The Captain’ at Penske? CRAIN’S MICHIGAN BUSINESS At West Michigan’s marinas, low water raises concerns, Page 9 Bonus State of funding Michigan is seeing more venture capital and private equity KEVIN FOWLER money. Read all about it in The New Michigan Deal, a 40-page special edition delivered with this issue. Shinola all wound up for online sales Report’s tip This Just In Watch, bike to tighten Report: Michigan hospitals show financial improvement company to skills gap: A report from the Michigan Health and Hospital Association points to improved financial add workers performance by Michigan Cooperation hospitals. BY SHERRI WELCH CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS The state’s 134 community BY DUSTIN WALSH hospitals increased average In many ways, assembly of the CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS operating margins in 2011 to tiny “engines,” or movements, 3.3 percent from 2.8 percent in that will power Shinola watches The Southeast Michigan jobs 2010 primarily by reducing couldn’t be more different than market is rebounding, but an ag- costs, improving quality and manufacturing automotive parts. ARA HOWRANI ing workforce and skills gap con- recording a 9 percent reduc- Where automotive parts manu- Bedrock Manufacturing Co. CEO Heath Carr says it matters that Shinola tinue to plague employers in need, watches and bicycles are assembled in Detroit. “The history that’s here, that tion in uncompensated care, facturing and assembly is often according to a report released means something,” he said. according to the report re- all about brawn, with clanging Monday by the Workforce Intelli- leased today. presses and expansive plant floor to the OEM’s just-in-time manu- gence Network. MHA Senior Vice President plans, Shinola/Detroit LLC’s watch facturing approach — albeit with The Detroit-based coalition, Peter Schonfeld attributed movement assembly in Detroit is much smaller tools and far fewer which works with eight local com- lower costs to quality and delicate, quiet and much like a employees. munity colleges, seven Michigan- safety initiatives, such as re- clean room with its temperature, “Made in Detroit and the histo- Works agencies and economic de- ducing catheter-associated humidity and dust controls. ry that’s here, that means some- velopment agencies, is urging urinary tract infection rates But Shinola is latching onto the thing,” said Heath Carr, CEO of employers and agencies to work and improving newborn same work ethic and creative en- Dallas-based Bedrock Manufactur- together to rectify the shortfall. health. See crainsdetroit.com ergy that built Detroit’s automo- ing Co., the privately held compa- In 2012, key growth employment for a full story on the report. tive industry for its mass produc- sectors struggled to fill jobs, ac- — Jay Greene tion of watch movements, down See Shinola, Page 25 See Skills gap, Page 21
Crain’s is seeking nominations for entrepreneurs Nominees will be judged for their innovation, problem-solving ability or sheer relentlessness. Additional categories include social entrepreneurs and entrepreneurial spirit. Deadline: March 18 | www.crainsdetroit.com/nominate NEWSPAPER 20130311-NEWS--0001-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 3/8/2013 5:14 PM Page 1
® Cwww.crainsdetroit.comRAIN Vol. 29, No. 10 ’SDETROITMARCH 2013 BUSINESS$2 a copy; $59 a year ©Entire contents copyright 2013 by Crain Communications Inc. All rights reserved
Inside Michigan
At West Michigan’s marinas, low water raises concerns, Page 9
In test ‘neighborhood,’ it’s about keeping up with the Jones’ energy efficiency, Page 11
Bonus State of funding Michigan is seeing more venture capital and private equity KEVIN FOWLER money. Read all about it in The New Michigan Deal, a 40-page special edition delivered with this issue. Shinola all wound up for online sales Report’s tip This Just In Watch, bike to tighten Report: Michigan hospitals show financial improvement company to skills gap: A report from the Michigan Health and Hospital Association points to improved financial add workers performance by Michigan Cooperation hospitals. BY SHERRI WELCH CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS The state’s 134 community BY DUSTIN WALSH hospitals increased average In many ways, assembly of the CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS operating margins in 2011 to tiny “engines,” or movements, 3.3 percent from 2.8 percent in that will power Shinola watches The Southeast Michigan jobs 2010 primarily by reducing couldn’t be more different than market is rebounding, but an ag- costs, improving quality and manufacturing automotive parts. ARA HOWRANI ing workforce and skills gap con- recording a 9 percent reduc- Where automotive parts manu- Bedrock Manufacturing Co. CEO Heath Carr says it matters that Shinola tinue to plague employers in need, watches and bicycles are assembled in Detroit. “The history that’s here, that tion in uncompensated care, facturing and assembly is often according to a report released means something,” he said. according to the report re- all about brawn, with clanging Monday by the Workforce Intelli- leased today. presses and expansive plant floor to the OEM’s just-in-time manu- gence Network. MHA Senior Vice President plans, Shinola/Detroit LLC’s watch facturing approach — albeit with The Detroit-based coalition, Peter Schonfeld attributed movement assembly in Detroit is much smaller tools and far fewer which works with eight local com- lower costs to quality and delicate, quiet and much like a employees. munity colleges, seven Michigan- safety initiatives, such as re- clean room with its temperature, “Made in Detroit and the histo- Works agencies and economic de- ducing catheter-associated humidity and dust controls. ry that’s here, that means some- velopment agencies, is urging urinary tract infection rates But Shinola is latching onto the thing,” said Heath Carr, CEO of employers and agencies to work and improving newborn same work ethic and creative en- Dallas-based Bedrock Manufactur- together to rectify the shortfall. health. See crainsdetroit.com ergy that built Detroit’s automo- ing Co., the privately held compa- In 2012, key growth employment for a full story on the report. tive industry for its mass produc- sectors struggled to fill jobs, ac- — Jay Greene tion of watch movements, down See Shinola, Page 25 See Skills gap, Page 21
1 Crain’s is seeking nominations for entrepreneurs Nominees will be judged for their innovation, problem-solving ability or sheer relentlessness. Additional categories include social entrepreneurs and entrepreneurial spirit. Deadline: March 18 | www.crainsdetroit.com/nominate NEWSPAPER 71486 02858 0 20130311-NEWS--0002-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 3/8/2013 4:11 PM Page 1
Page 2 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS March 11, 2013
MICHIGAN BRIEFS Lansing developer plans to revive Conn., and Pittsburgh ranked higher, while Detroit and Lansing historic building in Toledo Downtown Grand Rapids hungers for grocery stores were lower. A Lansing developer plans to put apartments and retail into a his- If you think Detroiters were happy in 2011 when Clements should know. In recent years, Trader MICH-CELLANEOUS toric but vacant building in down- Austin, Texas-based Whole Foods Market announced Joe’s hired him to find a prime location, he said. But town Toledo as part of a $20 million it was coming to Detroit — the Midtown store is ex- the company was never satisfied with its options. Ⅲ The Lansing-based Thomas M. investment, The Blade newspaper pected to open in June — the media in Grand Clements and local developers such as Jonathan Cooley Law School says that in Sep- reported last week. Rapids, to quote our reporting friends at MiBiz, Bradford, president and CEO of the Grand Rapids- tember it will start offering a mas- Kevin Prater said last week that “went bonkers” over a report that Whole Foods and based nonprofit Inner City Christian Federation, have ter’s degree in homeland security he hoped to close on a deal to buy California-based Trader Joe’s, along with the Swedish tried to convince potential greengrocers that down- and national security law. the Berdan Building by the end of department store chain H&M, would open stores in town Grand Rapids is a solid investment, despite Ⅲ MLive.com reported that the the week. His firm already has re- the Grand Rapids area. One problem, MiBiz noted: decades of flight to the suburbs. At one point, both Baltimore-based Sinclair Broadcast developed a nearby upscale apart- Trader Joe’s and Whole Foods say “they have no Meijer Inc. and Spartan Stores Inc. flirted with small Group has entered into a definitive ment building, the Toledo newspa- plans to enter the market anytime soon.” H&M did- concept ideas but eventually passed, Clements said. agreement to buy the broadcast as- per reported. Past development n’t respond to requests for comment. Bradford said grocery store companies are rooted sets of 18 television stations owned deals have failed. The five-story A few days before this excitement, MiBiz wrote in strong suburban operations and carry certain as- by Barrington Broadcasting Group Berdan Building, completed in about the difficulty in persuading grocers to locate sumptions that can’t be applied to urban life. “It’s LLC, including WEYI and WBSF in 1902, is listed on the National Regis- in downtown Grand Rapids. (Sound familiar, Detroi- not tough to understand why they aren’t here yet,” the Flint-Saginaw-Bay City-Mid- ter of Historic places. ters?) A store like Trader Joe’s likely would test the he said. “They need some education, and we need to land market. The Federal Communi- waters first in suburban Grand Rapids, said Earl go to them and stick their faces in the opportunity cations Commission must approve Clements, retail principal with Colliers International. and the reality.” the $370 million deal. Charter school’s curriculum would Ⅲ Kalamazoo-based Stryker Corp. include extracurricular activities MLive reported, citing a report by County were occupied last year. planned to buy $250 million of its Upon doing math, Calvin College common stock from public share- Guess you can add a fourth “R” to the college. Hope College in Hol- The hotels maintained an aver- finds $115M in long-term debt land, a school similar in size to age room rate of $92.94 a night, holders Friday, MLive.com report- this school: rink. MLive.com report- ed. ed last week that a charter school Calvin College in Grand Rapids Calvin, has $64.3 million in long- said Doug Small, CEO of the Experi- being proposed for the Kalamazoo- has $115 million in long-term debt term debt, MLive said. Former ence Grand Rapids visitors bureau. Find business news from Battle Creek area would cater to and, MLive.com reported, not President Gaylen Byker, who re- The room rate was higher than the around the state at crainsdetroit teenage elite athletes in hockey, soc- enough money to cover it. In a let- tired at the end of the 2011-12 acad- state average of $83.44 but lower .com/crainsmichiganbusiness. cer and figure skating. Legacy Acade- ter posted on Calvin’s website, emic year, could not be reached for than the national average of $106 Sign up for Crain's Michigan my would serve grades 7-12, accord- board of trustees Chairman Scott comment, MLive said. per night. Grand Rapids’ room Business e-newsletter at crains ing to a grant application filed with Spoelhof wrote that the board just rate was third highest among detroit.com/emailsignup. the Michigan Department of Education. became aware of the shortfall in Hotels doing better in GR, too cities in its peer group. Hartford, It would be the first such school recent months. in Michigan, modeled on a school Long-term debt at Calvin grew Crain’s reported in its last issue CORRECTION for tennis players in Las Vegas, as investments meant to pay it on the improving hotel market in said Heather Montei, spokes- down earned smaller-than-expect- Southeast Michigan. Last week, Ⅲ A brief on Page 1 of the March 4 issue had an incorrect spelling of De- woman for the school’s organizers. ed returns, and the college spent MLive.com reported similar news troit Building Authority Director Beth DunCombe’s last name. The earliest the school would open more money than it had on con- from Grand Rapids, where 60.6 is fall 2014, Montei said. struction projects and real estate, percent of the 7,000 rooms in Kent
The firm worth Today, more than ever, global competition, new technologies, and corporate listening to streamlining require innovative thinking is the firm that and leaderships abilities. Continuing SM your education can be key to your listens to you. success. From biomedical and robotics engineering to health IT management Talk to Foley. We’re listening.SM and chemical biology, Lawrence Technological University can prepare you for the jobs of the future. When our Detroit clients needed a national law firm that provides trusted local advisors with top-tier legal 2013 2013 2013 skills, Foley delivered. That’s why our attorneys and BEST COLLEGES MILITARY NATION’S BEST FRIENDLY UNDERGRAD ONLINE in the Midwest STUDENT ENGAGEMENT practices are consistently recognized for excellence S C H O O L Princeton U.S.1 News & Review® G.I. Jobs® World Report® by our clients and industry experts.*
Learn more about how Foley can add value to your business. Contact Possible is everything. Detroit Office Managing Partner Daljit S. Doogal at [email protected]. Foley.com Explore over 100 undergraduate, master’s, and doctoral programs in Colleges of Architecture and Design, Arts and Sciences, Engineering, and Management.
Waive your application fee at www.ltu.edu/applyfree
*Chambers USA: America’s Leading Business LawyersBOE64/FXTo#FTU-BXZFST®
Lawrence Technological University | 21000 West Ten Mile Road, Southfield, MI 48075-1058 #0450/t#3644&-4t$)*$"(0t%&530*5t+"$,40/7*--&t-04"/(&-&4 800.225.5588 | [email protected] | www.ltu.edu ."%*40/t.*".*t.*-8"6,&&t/&8:03,t03-"/%0t4"$3".&/50 4"/%*&(0t4"/%*&(0%&-."3t4"/'3"/$*4$0t4)"/()"*t4*-*$0/7"--&: 5"--")"44&&t5".1"t50,:0t8"4)*/(50/ %$
ª'PMFZ-BSEOFS--1t"UUPSOFZ"EWFSUJTFNFOUt1SJPSSFTVMUTEPOPUHVBSBOUFFBTJNJMBSPVUDPNF /$MBSL4USFFU 4VJUF $IJDBHP *-tt 20130311-NEWS--0003-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 3/8/2013 4:58 PM Page 1
March 11, 2013 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS Page 3 Mortgage firm Health Care to grow into ex-Borders HQ Gold Star plans to hire hundreds
BY KIRK PINHO CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS Dan Milstein, founder and CEO Eye surgeons refocus of Gold Star Mortgage Financial Group Corp., is moving his company to a after recession, Page 15 higher-profile address in Ann Arbor as the ex- panding mort- Company index gage company gets ready to These companies have significant mention in this hire hundreds of week’s Crain’s Detroit Business: employees. LAT PHOTOGRAPHIC Beaumont Health System ...... 17, 22 The move into “Things happen,” says Roger Penske of Penske Corp., “but we have a good management structure with our companies, Beitman Laser Eye Institute ...... 15 key leadership people who know the business and help build it. … I just hope I can be a part of that for a long time.” at least 70,000 Beyond Interactive ...... 13 square feet of Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan ...... 23 Milstein space at the for- Center for Automotive Research ...... 24 mer Borders Group Inc. headquar- CMS Energy ...... 22 ters in Ann Arbor is a big mile- Coburn-Kleinfeldt Eye Clinic ...... 16 stone for Milstein, an immigrant College for Creative Studies ...... 25 from Urkaine who founded Gold Compuware ...... 13 Next at the wheel Core Partners ...... 23 Star in 2000 at age 24. The company has grown signifi- Creative Breakthroughs ...... 22 cantly from its humble begin- Roger Penske would like to rule forever, Dawn Food Products ...... 13 nings, starting out of “a space that Detroit Metro Convention & Visitors Bureau ...... 12 was previously used as a closet” at Dow Building Solutions ...... 11 a AAA insurance building on Stadi- but who will eventually be the next Captain? Dow Chemical ...... 13 um Boulevard. FEV ...... 24 Milstein, 37, plans to expand his Flint Group ...... 13 the throng standing below a tele- elusive NASCAR title being workforce by up to 250 loan offi- BY BRANT JAMES General Motors ...... 13 CRAIN NEWS SERVICE vision stage at the start/finish Penske’s holy grail — the ques- cers, underwriters and other em- Gold Star Mortgage Financial Group ...... 3 line. tion must be asked: When is the ployees in the next 12 months as it Grand Valley State University ...... 10 Nearly three hours had passed One hour earlier, Penske had pursuit of victory enough? moves. HealthPlus of Michigan ...... 16 since Brad Keselowski captured completed his last post-race inter- As he pushed through a glass The Henry Ford ...... 12 See Gold Star, Page 23 team owner Roger Penske’s first view of the 2012 NASCAR season door, passed a mound of empty piz- Henry Ford Health System ...... 15 NASCAR Sprint Cup Series champi- with print media and choked za boxes and turned toward the IAC Group ...... 13 onship on Nov. 18, bringing the down a slice of congealing pizza second-floor hallway where anoth- IAV Automotive Engineering ...... 3 boss down from the spotter’s stand before another series of radio and er radio interview awaited, Penske Inteva Products ...... 13 at Homestead-Miami Speedway. television interviews. He then turned to one of his sons, Greg. John S. and James L. Knight Foundation ...... 5 Penske climbed the steps of his pit trudged back downstairs for more The latter had been within arm’s Kelly Services ...... 13 box, where he hugged and kissed sponsor and NASCAR commit- distance most of the night, from Livonia Outpatient Surgery Center ...... 16 his wife and lucky charm, Kathy. ments. the spotter’s stand to victory cir- Mac-Mold ...... 21 Two hours earlier, the reserved Does it take much to suggest cle. His father confided for the first Masco ...... 13 white-haired billionaire reveled that even a goal-oriented baron of time that he was finally tiring. Metis Sports Management ...... 7 as instigator, handing Keselow- industry would grow weary even- When it comes to Penske — COSTAR GROUP Michigan Health and Hospital Association ...... 1 ski fresh cans of sponsor brew tually? There are mountains to who turned 76 on Feb. 20 — Gold Star Mortgage Financial Group Michigan Outpatient Surgery Center ...... 16 Miller Lite to refill a monstrous climb, finish lines to cross, cham- “tired” is a relative term, but it is Corp. is moving into the former Michigan State University ...... 10, 12 pilsner glass from which he inter- pionships to win. And when you Borders Group Inc. headquarters in Michigan Travel Commission ...... 12 Ann Arbor. mittently imbibed or slung over have done it all — the long- See Penske, Page 24 MSX International ...... 13 PCA Bombo ...... 7 Penske ...... 3 Plante Moran ...... 22 Ross Mortgage ...... 23 As standards tighten for fuel, emissions, Shinola/Detroit ...... 1, 25 Thetford ...... 13 Tower Marina ...... 9 Wayne State University ...... 21 growing IAV takes answers for test drive Whitehall Landing ...... 9 Workforce Intelligence Network ...... 1 BY DUSTIN WALSH technology is testing the emissions in Ann Arbor in 1998 before un- CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS and fuel efficiency of the diesel en- veiling the development center in gine for an agricultural machine Northville in 2008, with a total cur- Department index The groan of a combine engine manufacturer. In the next, identi- rent investment of $33 million. slows inside a climate-controlled cal room, it’s a turbo-boosted en- The U.S. subsidiary grew state- BANKRUPTCIES ...... 4 test chamber the size of a dorm gine for an automaker. And so on. side on the backs of its German BUSINESS DIARY ...... 19 room, and the faint smell of diesel As manufacturers, automakers owners. Volkswagen AG owns 50 CALENDAR ...... 18 fuel remains as more than $1 mil- and suppliers work toward meet- percent of IAV, Continental AG CAPITOL BRIEFINGS...... 4 lion worth of equipment runs ana- ing stricter fuel and emissions holds 20 percent and Schaeffler CLASSIFIED ADS ...... 21 lytical tests on the performance of standards in the U.S., IAV is creat- Technologies AG & Co. KG 10 percent. JOB FRONT ...... 20 the next-generation engine. ing and testing some of the indus- The less than 5-year-old U.S. arm Here in this room, one of four at COURTESY OF IAV AUTOMOTIVE ENGINEERING INC. KEITH CRAIN...... 6 try’s best ideas — and it shows on of Germany’s IAV GmbH quadrupled IAV President Andy Ridgway said the Northville Township-based IAV Au- the books. company is growing in response to LETTERS...... 6 tomotive Engineering Inc., the latest IAV opened a small sales office See IAV, Page 24 increased government regulations. MARY KRAMER ...... 9 OPINION ...... 6 Crain’s Michigan Business Business events OTHER VOICES ...... 6 THIS WEEK @ Sign up for the roundup of statewide During any given week, useful business events are PEOPLE ...... 20 news delivered to email inboxes every held throughout the region. See what’s coming up at WWW.CRAINSDETROIT.COM Wednesday: crainsdetroit.com/getemail. crainsdetroit.com/section/events. RUMBLINGS ...... 26 WEEK ON THE WEB ...... 26 20130311-NEWS--0004-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 3/8/2013 4:11 PM Page 1
Page 4 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS March 11, 2013 Roads funding down road from May
The May 7 ballot will tween the two, and some was when legislative leaders kept not include any request Republicans in the Sen- members in the Capitol until to raise taxes or change Capitol ate are willing to go about 5 a.m. before leaving for the the way they are dis- Briefings there, but the House Re- Fourth of July break. bursed to pay for in- publican caucus made If they did that, lawmakers creased transportation that law’s repeal part of could still choose to give an option funding, but it doesn’t its action plan for this to voters as well in a special elec- mean it still couldn’t legislative session. tion. However, the cost for a spe- happen this year. Sen. Roger Kahn, R- cial election could be as much as Last Thursday, the Saginaw, chair of the $10 million, Kahn said. Senate adjourned with- Senate Appropriations It would have been less expen- out taking a vote to re- Committee, and the In- sive for the state if it had put quest such a plan be Chris Gautz frastructure Moderniza- something on the May 7 ballot, be- placed on the May ballot, tion Committee, which is cause many cities and counties al- thereby missing the 60-day dead- where any transportation funding ready have elections planned that line to do so. bills would go, said he wasn’t sur- day. The state would have just Word was there was no agree- prised to see the Senate miss its had to reimburse those jurisdic- ment on exactly what to ask the self-imposed deadline. tions that would have had to have voters for, or how much, and how “It was a very ambitious ask to a vote solely for the purpose of the that would fit into or be a separate get it done in that time frame to vote on transportation funding. option for voters to consider how start with,” Kahn said. So now any decision to put best to fund the roads. He didn’t broadcast that belief something on the ballot before the Of course, there’s also the pesky because he wanted to try to next statewide election in August task of getting bipartisan support accomplish it, the same way the 2014 will cost the state money it for such a request, as it takes a past two years the Legislature has otherwise hadn’t planned on two-thirds vote in both chambers said it would get the state budget spending. to put it before the voters. done by June 1, even though it House Speaker Jase Bolger, R- Even before last year’s signing technically has until the end of Marshall, does not have a prefer- of the right-to-work law, getting September. ence for either going to the ballot two-thirds of either chamber to With the May 7 ballot question in a special election or having agree on anything significant was plan now off the table, Kahn said the Legislature vote on a final a tough task, and now it’s just even he likes the idea that Senate Ma- plan, his press secretary Ari Adler more so — if not impossible. jority Leader Randy Richardville, said. Also, I’m told Democrats were R-Monroe, has to get it done by the “He has not committed to nor re- pushing for a firm guarantee that Fourth of July. buffed any idea. He is listening to if they were to go along with a plan “It would be patriotic to have all ideas right now,” Adler said. for increased transportation fund- our roads start to be fixed on “He’s trying to make sure that ing that any vote or push to repeal July Fourth,” he said with a everybody keeps talking and keeps the state’s prevailing wage law chuckle. coming up with ideas. He’s afraid would be taken off the table. If history is any guide, the last that if we start saying ‘yes’ or ‘no’ They want clear linkage be- time the state raised the gas tax to certain things, then people will stop doing that.” What many in the Legislature seem to have said “no” to, though, is Gov. Rick Snyder’s plan to raise the 19 cent gasoline tax and 15 cent diesel tax to a flat 33 cents per gal- lon. When the spark of Snyder spokesman Kurt Weiss said in an email that there are dif- imagination meets up with ferent ideas and plans being re- viewed right now. the talent to harness its The administration is still confi- dent the right solution will be found for road funding. potential, the possibilities “Inaction is not an option, and everyone understands that,” are endless. Weiss said. There does remain confidence in the halls of the Capitol that something will get done this year. The move, or lack thereof, last week by the Senate should not be seen as a step back, “just one more step along the way,” Adler said. Chris Gautz: (517) 403-4403, [email protected]. Twitter: @chrisgautz
When you’re serious about intellectual property law… BANKRUPTCIES That’s why companies that are serious about innovation select Brinks. The following businesses filed for Chapter 11 or Chapter 7 protection in In intellectual property, having a trusted partner is important … a partner U.S. Bankruptcy Court in Detroit March with unparalleled skill in IP law, litigation and protection. At Brinks, 1-7. Under Chapter 11, a company files for reorganization. Chapter 7 involves we’re as serious about your success as you are in achieving it. From total liquidation. Ⅲ Grand Summit Pointe II LLC, 6632 inspiration to innovation, small sparks to big successes, you need a 866.222.0112 Telegraph Road, Suite 350, Bloomfield Hills, voluntary Chapter 11. Assets team committed to guiding you onward and upward. usebrinks.com and liabilities not available. Ⅲ R.T.R. Building Co. Inc., 5153 Clarendon Crest, Bloomfield Hills, Detroit Office: Suite 1775 | 300 River Place Drive | Detroit, MI 48207 | 313.393.5400 voluntary Chapter 11. Assets and lia- bilities not available. — Ryan Felton 20130311-NEWS--0005-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 3/8/2013 4:10 PM Page 1
March 11, 2013 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS Page 5 Knight Foundation contest looks for creative public art ideas
BY SHERRI WELCH tion or company in the area, and Miami five years ago and Philadel- ty that was in its cultural adoles- to bring the challenge to Detroit. CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS there’s no limit on how many any phia three years ago, Knight has in- cence up until recently ... (and) in “Detroit feels to me like it’s the single person or organization can vested $22.5 million in 180 projects. Philly, while it was very culturally Berlin of America when it comes to Local artists and art supporters submit. But they have to be about Typically, the foundation gets mature, it didn’t have as much in the arts,” Scholl said. “Every day have a big chance to pitch creative art and take place in Detroit or about 1,200 ideas per year per city the way of grass-roots activity,” there is someone coming to Detroit Detroit public art ideas. benefit the city. And projects will and picks an undetermined num- said Dennis Scholl, vice presi- to work on a cultural project.” And the more creative the idea, be required to find matching mon- ber of winners from a finalist pool dent/arts Knight Foundation. Sherri Welch: (313) 446-1694, the better. ey to implement the idea if it wins. of 30-70. Detroit has a mix of both, and [email protected]. Twitter: Organizers of a program funded Since launching the contest in “In Miami, you had a communi- that’s what spurred the foundation @sherriwelch by the John S. and James L. Knight Foundation say people should think big. Thought starters: a poetry slam on the Detroit River, a new Mexican festival in Southwest De- 60$//2)),&(Ř+20(2)),&( troit, the return of vintage movies to a historic Detroit theater, or Michigan’s Best Selection For even something off the wall like Small Professional Office or Home Office images of mud puppies dancing on Free Design Assistance larger-than-life screens. Customization - Sizes & Finishes The Miami-based foundation will open nominations for the Professional Installation three-year, $9 million Knight Arts Contemporary or Traditional Challenge Detroit on March 25. The program will fund what it deems the best arts ideas from De- troit, with a little vetting help from a group of about 10 yet-to-be-picked local “readers.” Proposals of 150 words or less must be submitted via knightarts.org, which also lists the winning ideas in the foundation’s other two arts chal- lenge cities — Miami and Philadel- phia — and will have information FEATURING on meetings planned for Detroit to explain about the program. Nominations for the Detroit challenge close April 22; the win- 6287+),(/'ō752< 129,ō/$.(6,'( ners will be announced Oct. 14. *5$1'5$3,'6 Ideas can come from any indi- www.gormans.com jesper_B vidual, group, cultural organiza-
How a man who never went to medical school is changing health care in America.
He spent his career as an entrepreneur and global consultant in the automotive industry. And then he decided to take that experience and generously share it with us at Beaumont. Serving as a trustee and Board member of our health system for 19 years, Steve Howard’s insight and strategic vision have helped us direct the future. As Board Chair, he embraced a partnership in which Beaumont is the only Michigan health system to join the national High Value Healthcare Collaborative – an organization that is designing a model of high quality and value-based care for the country. Through his leadership, Steve has supported philanthropy that allows us to attract renowned physicians and acquire leading edge technology. And he has been a champion for patient safety and superior outcomes. As a result, Beaumont continues to be rated the most preferred health care provider in the region. Anticipating the challenges of health reform, Steve’s forward thinking has led an initiative that will create an historic merger between Beaumont and Henry Ford health systems. This new organization will be a national model for health care. With a tireless commitment of time, talent and energy, Steve has benefited patients at Beaumont – and around the country – making health care better, and more accessible, for us all. Steve Howard has earned Modern Healthcare’s 2013 Trustee of the Year award. And he reminds us that it doesn’t take a medical degree to change health care. All it takes is a heart.
Steve Howard, chair, Board of Directors, Beaumont Health System, Modern Healthcare’s 2013 Trustee of the Year 20130311-NEWS--0006-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 3/8/2013 4:09 PM Page 1
Page 6 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS March 11, 2013 OPINION OTHER VOICES No public promises Shine light on government It’s your government. ment services. more public access and against vi- And it’s your money Some good public ser- olations of the state Freedom of In- that’s paying for it. vants provide that infor- formation Act and the Open Meet- You deserve to know mation readily. But often ings Act. The coalition will review for private debt how that money is being the search for answers is requests for help and can nomi- spent and if waste, fraud, an uphill battle, because nate them for funding from the Na- he opening of “Oz the Great and Powerful” last week corruption, conflicts of in- other government officials tional Freedom of Information terest or just bad decision- prefer to operate in pri- Coalition. has made many in Michigan nostalgic for the making are getting in the vate so they can do what How is Michigan doing when it T Granholm-era film credits that led to numerous movie way of the results you ex- they want without as comes to public access to informa- star sightings around the area. pect. much oversight. Some- tion? But let’s take a look behind the curtain. Customers every day Charles Hill times it’s because they One measure is the failing grade The movie was filmed in Pontiac at what is now Michigan demand accountability from the have something to hide, some- Michigan received in a State In- people who remodel their houses, times because they think it’s more tegrity Investigation last year by Motion Picture Studios, run by Linden Nelson and backed by serve them food, fix their cars or efficient or easier to operate in se- the Center for Public Integrity, Al Taubman and John Rakolta, among others. The project was sell them a TV or a computer. cret. And they have government Global Integrity and Public Radio vastly ambitious — and vast. The cavernous building was de- Citizens should demand the resources to use, while news orga- International. signed to be able to accommodate all facets of filmmaking, and same accountability — and more nizations and citizens face shrink- Michigan’s overall ranking was director Sam Raimi described it as “the best I’ve ever seen.” — of their government. ing budgets. 44th of 50 states. Individual catego- Are children being educated in a Now, journalists and citizens ry scores included grades of “F” But when Gov. Rick Snyder took office and reduced the way that helps them succeed in life have a new ally: the Michigan for executive accountability, judi- amount of subsidies available, the big-budget projects dried for their own good and the good of Coalition for Open Government. cial accountability, state civil ser- up, and so did the business model for the studio. their fellow citizens? Are the ac- MiCOG is being launched official- vice management, state pension In the end, taxpayers ended up paying $40 million in film cused treated fairly by police and ly this week during Sunshine fund management, state insurance subsidies for the movie, and studio owners started defaulting judges? Are people getting the pub- Week, which is observed each year commissions, political financing, lic safety and other services they to promote open government and legislative accountability, lobby- on bonds sold to help pay for the project, leaving the State of should? Are contracts being freedom of information. ing disclosure, ethics enforcement Michigan Retirement System, which had inexplicably guaran- awarded to those best equipped to MiCOG’s mission is to promote agencies and redistricting. teed them, on the hook for the bill. provide a good service at a reason- and protect transparency and ac- Remember: It’s your govern- The state pension fund is just one example. The city of able price, or to a company that countability in governments at the ment and you deserve to know Allen Park also was left holding the bag after selling $31 mil- costs too much and delivers too lit- local, state and federal levels. Its what it is doing. For more informa- tle but was chosen for improper efforts will include creating educa- tion, see miopengov.org. lion in bonds for a studio project that never materialized. The reasons? Are people who truly tional programs and information Charles Hill is former Michigan debt was a factor leading to the city’s current oversight by an need help getting that help? to help guide citizens interested in Associated Press bureau chief and emergency manager. Journalists work hard to find open government. sits on the MiCOG board of direc- We think it’s good for Michigan to keep a foothold in the answers to those questions and And the coalition also can help tors. Crain’s Executive Editor film industry, but we agree with capping the amount of incen- many more. So do parents. So do get funding for lawsuits by citizens Cindy Goodaker also is a member of people who use and pay for govern- and the media who are fighting for the MiCOG board. tives available on an annual basis — $50 million for fiscal 2013 — and also believe that there should be ongoing cost/benefit evaluation of them. And one thing is for sure: Public pension funds and other bodies should not be in the business of guaranteeing the debt LETTERS of private investors, who should be willing to assume that themselves. Keeping us from hacker harm Center takes wrong direction Editor: Accordingly, I find disconcert- Michigan have not persuaded Internet-related scams and threats have become so common- Over the past two years, resi- ing the recent article in Crain’s Baron to lure those entities to place, it seems we’ve almost become numb to them — even when dents have been told by various that Center for Automotive Re- Michigan. large networks of private information have been breached. leaders that if Michigan was made search President Jay Baron is To say the competition is with Not so the state of Michigan, which has been working with a right-to-work state, onerous busi- working to attract overseas au- Mexico and not the North, mean- ness taxes were repealed and the tomakers and suppliers to South- ing Michigan, is cause for concern. Oakland County, a group of large companies and others to cre- infrastructure were repaired, no- ern states with the suggestion that Baron is also quoted saying the ate an emergency response plan. tably roads and bridges, the state it may include engineering and de- center is not promoting existing As Lansing correspondent Chris Gautz reports on Page 1, and Southeast Michigan would be sign divisions as well (“Local cen- businesses to move South, but he the group has been considering questions such as what the re- able to attract and retain potential ter wants more auto jobs for does not indicate that it would dis- sponse should be in the event of a large breach of security for investors because the climate for South; MEDC not happy,” March courage such activity. such enterprising spirits would be 4). It would appear that all of the ef- Jim Amar the state, a region or multiple large companies. more attractive and competitive. forts done to attract businesses to Plymouth Township The details of the plan won’t be available until later this spring, but this is a laudable example of public-private collabo- Send your letters: Crain’s Detroit Business will consider for publication all signed letters to the editor that do not ration for the benefit of all the state’s citizens. defame individuals or organizations. Letters may be edited for length and clarity. Email [email protected]
KEITH CRAIN: When does the sky stop falling? It’s been more than a week since than money spent by in- ey on. also haven’t heard anyone talk some sort of amendment that re- the deadly sequester began. dividuals — or shall we I guess I just don’t about the interest payments on quires a balanced budget — like And although there have been call them “taxpayers.” agree that the govern- our debt. We owe $16 trillion, an our local and state budgets have. A many predictions that the end of When taxpayers offer ment has a better idea amount I cannot even compre- very sensible and necessary rule. the world was coming, we haven’t up taxes, they give the of how to spend my hend. If we don’t do anything Michigan seems blessed to have seen any severe adjustments yet. money to the govern- money than I do. about our debt, my guess is that an a number of jurisdictions with fi- I am sure that when you take bil- ment to spend. No car, The really big entitle- increasing amount of taxes we pay nancial problems, most notably lions of dollars from government no television or no ments aren’t affected by will go to the Chinese and every- the city of Detroit and Wayne programs, there will be lots of dis- house. sequestration. body else who has bought our debt. County. location from industries that are The sky-is-falling ar- But the federal gov- But I am glad to know that every Luckily, the state has righted its impacted, especially military con- gument seems to sug- ernment is still making penny of every government pro- financial ship, and now our gover- tractors. Some of those cuts may be gest that whatever the $85 billion in cuts this gram, whether it’s city, county, nor is attempting to do the same painful in Southeastern Michigan. government is spending fiscal year. We have to state or federal, is so wisely spent with Detroit, a formidable task. But I still haven’t figured out our taxes on must be more impor- make big cuts if we ever want to that there is no way anyone can Too bad no one seems interested why money spent by government tant to our economy than whatev- get close to a spending plan that re- ever cut a nickel. in righting the Titanic in Washing- is any different to the economy er we might be spending our mon- flects what we take in as revenue. I Someday, perhaps, we’ll have ton. 20130311-NEWS--0007-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 3/8/2013 4:13 PM Page 1
March 11, 2013 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS Page 7 Trio climbs into ring of sports management
BY BILL SHEA cause of the need to spend money your percentage, when he first CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS on athletes while waiting years to signs. You don’t get paid again un- see a return on that investment til he goes to arbitration. That’s Detroit junior middleweight box- and because of the rise of mega- three years if he’s in the majors,” er Tony Harrison — the last fighter agencies in the past decade. he said. “You only get paid when personally trained by Emanuel “It’s getting more difficult to get he gets paid (a new contract).” Steward at Kronk Gym before Stew- into more than ever before,” he In the meantime, agents have to ard died in 2012 — improved his ca- said. “You have to compete with spend money on travel and also reer record to 12-0 with a first-round the big dogs. These guys have so provide gear such as custom bats, knockout Thursday night at Mo- much money and capital behind gloves, shirts, etc. Agents are lim- torCity Casino Hotel’s Sound Board. them. You’re not generating fees, ited to spending $1,500 per year per In the audience watching Harri- so you need capital.” player by Major League Baseball son take down West Michigan’s Agents specialize, he said, and Players Association rules. Thomas Amarro was Grosse many agents are lawyers who con- “I’m laying out $40,000 to $50,000 Pointe attorney Peter Alle. tinue to practice law until the on equipment in spring training,” Harrison is Alle’s first client as an sports agency can earn real money Kirschenbaum said. “It’s a strug- agent with PCA Bombo LLC, a new AL BURGESS — which can take many years. gle. It takes at least five to 10 years Grosse Pointe attorney Peter Alle greets boxer Tony Harrison after Harrison’s sports management firm he runs. “You’re advising a high school (to make money), depending on the knockout win in a match Thursday at MotorCity Casino Hotel in Detroit. Alle is a Partners are lifelong friend KC kid. You get 5 percent, or whatever sport.” partner in new sports management firm PCA Bombo LLC. Crain — of the Crain Communications Inc. family that owns Crain’s Detroit Business — and sports filmmaker Bob Potter. Alle said the company’s goal is simple: “We’re looking to manage FREE WEBINAR SERIES: APRIL – AUGUST 2013 athletes.” Their plan is to seek clients such as boxers, NASCAR drivers and players in the four major leagues. Alle said he’s licensed to man- age Harrison with Michigan’s Un- About the Series armed Combat Commission, which Look forward to 2014 and nobody knows what health care will regulates boxing and mixed mar- look like, but everyone knows things will be different. That’s the tial arts fighting in the state. The player unions for the pro starting point for Health Facts 2014, a project to provide facts sports leagues typically regulate for employers and employees as they make near-term health and license agents, and each have care decisions. their own requirements, Alle said, adding that he’s studying to earn With the combined resources of the Greater Detroit Area Health certification for those leagues. Presented by: Council and Crain’s Detroit Business, this series will present Alle is using space at his father’s useful and informative webinars throughout the year aimed at Grosse Pointe firm, Law Offices of In Partnership with: ™ employers, employees and providers. James Alle, where he works full time as an attorney. Providing the company name is Bob Potter, CEO and managing partner of New York City filmmak- ers Bombo Sports & Entertainment. PCA stands for Potter, Crain To and Alle. All three are investing in the agency, with Crain bringing Exchange About the Webinar his business experience and Potter Receive strategic advice on whether to offer a health plan or to ask bringing his sports industry con- or employees to use the insurance exchange. This webinar is designed nections, Alle said. Notto “I just love the idea of having a for employers considering both options. fighter from Detroit that we can help Exchange create a Detroit boxing brand again, that we lost with the end of Kronk Discover: and Emanuel Steward,” Crain said. Alle and Crain met Potter last Tuesday, April 2 Insight from consultants specializing in health plan design year while he was working on a documentary about Detroit, and 12 – 1P.M. The legal issues: What the Affordable Care Act requires he called Crain in search of a local boxer to include. The HR angle: Advice from a human resources perspective Crain connected Potter to Alle, Reserve your seat: who boxes as a hobby at The World’s crainsdetroit.com/events Best Boxing Gym and has connec- tions to the local fight scene. The three men hit it off, he said, and eventually Potter hatched the idea to work together on managing a boxer. “All of us have a love for Detroit, and we’re all big sports fans,” Alle said. Bombo has done documentaries on mixed martial arts fighting, the Detroit Lions, Philadelphia Eagles, Boston Red Sox, Los Angeles Dodgers, the National Basketball As- sociation and the Manchester United, Chelsea and Liverpool soccer teams of the English Premier League. If and when PCA Bombo pays off as an investment is unknown. “We haven’t developed expecta- tions yet (on revenue). It’s hard to gauge at this stage,” Alle said. Agent Storm Kirschenbaum is owner and president of Birming- ham-based Metis Sports Manage- ment LLC, which represents 70 pro baseball players. He said the sports agent universe is a tough one be- DBpageAD_DBpageAD.qxd 3/7/2013 9:17 AM Page 1 20130311-NEWS--0009,0010-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 3/8/2013 10:58 AM Page 1
March 11, 2013 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS Page 9
PUBLISHER’S NOTEBOOK
Contact Mary Kramer at mkramer @crain.com. CRAIN’S MICHIGAN BUSINESS Mary Kramer Snyder wants earful from biz The stock market is soaring; the Michigan-based auto industry is roaring. But the state’s unemployment rate remains stubbornly at nearly 9 percent. At the same time, many employers complain about not finding enough people to fill specific jobs, including engineers, machinists and technical talent. What gives? That’s what Gov. Rick Snyder hopes to find out March 18-19 when he convenes an economic summit on talent at Cobo Center. The invitation- only event is drawing CEOs, business owners, human resource directors, higher education officials and workforce development leaders. But it’s employers looking for talent whom the governor wants to hear from most in order to shape a message to workforce training and higher education organizations this spring. Snyder will give a kickoff address, followed by a state talent profile by economist Paul Traub from Detroit’s branch of the Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago. Attendees will break out by region and industry to identify challenges and opportunities to meet the talent crunch. T.J. HAMILTON Already, the event has drawn an R.J. Peterson, president of Tower Marina in Douglas and Saugatuck Yacht Services in Saugatuck, estimates that pleasure boating pumps $15 million to impressive list of executives from $20 million into the Saugatuck-Douglas economy each year — and with the right support could bring in much more. auto, health care, law and accounting firms and technology/IT. And there is room for a few more. If you are an employer concerned about filling current or future jobs, go to michiganadvantage.org/governors- economic-summit to request an invitation. Meanwhile, despite the jobless Lake effect rate, a lot of things are going in the right direction in Michigan. Our supplement in this week’s issue, “The New Michigan Deal,” Marina owners face low water levels, high anxiety as boating season nears outlines the surge in investments in state companies from private equity BY MATTHEW GRYCZAN population of 2,700. firms and venture capital funds. This CRAIN’S MICHIGAN BUSINESS If recreational boaters don’t use the 50 special feature — a collaboration municipal slips and the 950 other private between Crain’s and Grand Rapids- The blue water hen the days grow longer and the slips on White Lake, local enterprises such based MiBiz, is being distributed “ weather warms, year-round residents outside Michigan to subscribers of economy is threatened by as the Maple Tree Inn and Harbor View Grille W of the White Lake area north of would land in the doldrums. other Crain publications. Muskegon like to joke that they can’t these lower water levels. ... Tens of thousands of people across So how far have we come? make left-hand turns on their streets any- Michigan are grappling with how they will Reporter Tom Henderson asks more. This is really the be affected by low water levels on the Snyder that question on Page 6 of the Tourists from Chicago and other areas Great Lakes. Nowhere are the conversa- supplement. Before running for flood the roads of the adjacent cities of new normal. tions probably more intense than in com- governor, Snyder was a venture Whitehall and Montague like a summer ” munities along the eastern shore of Lake capitalist. When he launched his first monsoon, ready to recreate on the 6-mile- Alan Steinman, Michigan. Among them, owners of private fund in 1997, he said, only two or Annis Water Resources Institute three funds were active in the state. long lake that has a channel leading to marinas appear to be the most anxious. Today, nearly 30 have Michigan Lake Michigan and adven- Business owners, government officials offices, and nearly 100 VC funds ture. Many of the visiting ed keeping statistics nearly a century ago. and recreational boaters are trying to fig- invest in Michigan companies. powerboaters and sailors Treated as one body of water by the ure out how to react to the low drafts in I have a bias, but what struck me have come to the area for Army Corps, Lake Michigan-Huron ended marinas before the season launches rough- most about Henderson’s interview years, first as children and February at 1 inch above the previous ly in late April, running through mid- with Snyder is to learn that the plans now as parents with kids of record low set in 1964. The “most probable October. for the Renaissance Venture Capital their own. line of the latest forecast shows Michigan- “If a business has to spend $200,000 to Fund — a successful “fund of funds,” This year, Whitehall City Huron remaining 2 to 7 inches above dredge this spring so customers can all where money from leading Manager Scott Huebler record lows through August,” the agency boat, and that comes out to $1,000 a slip, corporations is in turn invested in hopes the area will offer reported last week. would the customers pay that?” said Dan other venture capital firms to grow smooth sailing instead of “If nothing changed, this would be a se- Erwin, general manager of Whitehall Land- Huebler state businesses — was announced “mud bog races,” a result of rious problem for our marina — and our ing, a private marina of 220 slips on White by Snyder during a cruise on the the lowest water level ever recorded on downtown a block away,” said Huebler, Lake. Detroit River sponsored by Crain’s. lakes Michigan and Huron in January who estimated that Whitehall doubles in since the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers start- size during the summer from its normal See Marinas, Page 10 20130311-NEWS--0009,0010-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 3/8/2013 10:58 AM Page 2
Page 10 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS March 11, 2013 Marinas: Lower water levels prompt worry for boating season ■ From Page 9 “Human nature tells me the vast No one knows yet what lake lev- dredging funds to cope with this a result, to a great extent, of silt directly supported an additional 44 majority would say: ‘No, I think I’ll els will be when the season opens, year’s low lake levels, as are 48 oth- from the Jordan River that has jobs from $2.6 million in direct take my boat and go to the other but it’s clear to Erwin that he will be er public harbors and marinas. been made abundantly visible by sales, $834,000 in wages and salaries side of the lake or go down to in trouble if the water in White Lake In Erwin’s case, private marinas low lake levels. and $1.5 million in value added. Muskegon this summer because isn’t high enough to put back in the will be left to fend for themselves But the city of East Jordan is Peterson said his marina is in they don’t need water the sailboats with deep drafts to offer usable slips and access to lucky. It’s one of five municipali- good shape for the upcoming boat- to dredge and that are stored on his premises. channels already dredged with fed- ties on Charlevoix Harbor, a feder- ing season because it performed their rates won’t “A better scenario may be that eral or state money. ally designated deep-draft harbor about $1 million worth of dredg- include that we can get them in the water and Lawmakers and city officials rec- and home to a U.S. Coast Guard sta- ing last spring to allow the S.S. $1,000. When you float them down the aisle, but per- ognize that most pleasure boaters tion. Locals know that any type of Keewatin to leave its decades-old are deep enough haps the slips are too shallow for are served by private marinas, so recreational boat will be able to location there for a new home at again to accom- them,” he said. Then it would just coastal communities can be hurt navigate through the harbor to Port McNicoll, Ontario. The mari- modate me, then be a matter of matching boats with economically if the businesses can’t reach Lake Michigan this summer na operates its own dredges for its I’ll look at that.’” appropriate slips, with some dredg- open. The 29 public harbors and — if the boat can get out of its slip. slips. It’s not a hy- ing as needed. harbors of refuge on Lake Michigan East Jordan is lucky there, too. Dredging the mouths of harbors pothetical prob- that are listed on the DNR’s website The municipal marina that Can- is “something you have to put up Erwin lem for Erwin. Not too low for boats to go reported having a total of 1,386 slips, non operates will be receiving with every year” because the About 60 percent of his customers of which half are reserved for tran- $420,000 in emergency funds from wave action on Lake Michigan are sailors versus powerboaters, To keep things in perspective, a sient boaters. Private marinas in the state to dredge the harbor 6 feet pushes sand to those locations, Pe- and sailboats need drafts any- flotilla of pleasure craft will be the Saugatuck-Douglas area alone deep and create a disposal site for terson said. But the silt that most where from 4½ to 7 feet below the skimming along on Lake Michigan offer well over 600 slips. the silt. marinas deal with comes up- water line to navigate — compared this summer even with record-low State Sen. Goeff Hansen, R-Hart, Private marinas, which can stream from the river itself and with powerboats, which may need levels, thanks to dredging of feder- whose 34th District includes White- range from hundreds of slips to a can be mitigated. only 2 to 3½ feet of draft. al navigational channels by the hall, Montague and other coastal simple fuel dock and fix-it store That’s where the state can help The water in White Lake reced- Army Corps. In addition, the state communities, told attendees of the with a few slips, may need to private marinas — by coordinat- ed so much even late last fall that Senate last week authorized an Small Harbor Coalition, which met re- dredge “on their own dime,” Can- ing the work between the DNR and some sailboats were starting to tip emergency $21 million appropria- cently in Lansing, that he supports non said. “Some are going to be DEQ so underwater structures can because the bottoms of their keels tion to keep public harbors, mari- legislation to offer state-sponsored able to get the dredging done, but be built to reduce siltation, Peter- were resting on sand. nas and boat launches open. The low-interest loans to private mari- there are going to be many that son said. “Some customers who didn’t measure now awaits action in the nas and provide more tools for local just don’t have the capabilities. Experts say other actions may know where some sandbars were state House. financing of dredging. Representa- “We are lucky to be city-owned need to be taken if the record-low in the aisle (between the boat slips The Michigan Department of Natural tives of the DNR and Michigan De- and have the support of our gener- lake levels of Michigan and Huron and docks) got stuck, and we had Resources owns or sponsors 81 mari- partment of Environmental Quality told al fund. If I didn’t have that, our become the new norm. to send people to go out to the bow nas, many of which are “grant in the same group that they have pro- marina wouldn’t be able to stay “The blue water economy is pulpit and bounce up and down aid” facilities such as the White Lake posed changes on procedures to open.” threatened by these lower water until they freed the boat,” Erwin Municipal Marina that are owned and speed permitting and make dredg- The East Jordan Municipal Harbor levels,” said Alan Steinman, direc- said. “It wasn’t so bad that tricks operated by local units of govern- ing less costly. used to be entirely self-sufficient tor of the Annis Water Resources Insti- like that wouldn’t work. But if it’s ment but receive DNR funding. The By luck and design, towns and for maintaining its harbor, but tute at Grand Valley State University. as bad as we expect this coming Whitehall harbor and White Lake cities that dot the eastern shore of that changed in 2008 when the city “The water levels probably will spring, that sort of thing isn’t go- Municipal Marina are slated to get Lake Michigan have encouraged for the first time needed to use gen- come back — whether they come ing to be enough to work.” $182,000 of the state emergency growth of the “blue water econo- eral funds for dredging. back to the long-term mean is an- my,” tied to pleasure boating as an other question. This is really the anchor for their economic lifeblood. new normal with regard to adapta- Marinas.com, a comprehensive list- Marinas: An economic anchor tion to changes associated with cli- ing of public and private marinas The impact of private marinas mate change.” nationwide, indicates that more on a local economy probably isn’t Coastal communities that rely than 130 of the state’s 409 marinas more obvious than in the case of on the blue water economy may have access to Lake Michigan. Tower Marina in Douglas and have to rethink what this means to Many of the marinas have grown Saugatuck Yacht Services in Saug- property values, new develop- up around natural harbors at the atuck, which have about 500 deep- ments, the frequency and funding mouths of rivers that empty into water slips, heated and cold-water of dredging, where docks are situ- Lake Michigan. storage facilities and a year-round ated and new recreational-boat service and parts department on technology, Peterson and Stein- their premises. The Army Corps man said. Boating leaves $636 million in wake considers Saugatuck a harbor of “Many of Michigan’s marinas An executive summary compiled refuge, meaning a designated spot and even access sites were built in by the DNR about six years ago said for boats caught in bad weather on locations where they are particu- recreational boating in Michigan Lake Michigan to moor until condi- larly vulnerable to swings in water generates about 24,000 jobs and re- tions improve. levels,” said Ed Mahoney, director sults in $636 million in income to R.J. Peterson, a special consul- of the Recreational Marine Research business owners. But many com- tant to the Michigan Waterways Com- Center at Michigan State University. munities with harbors have at best mission and president of Tower Ma- “The problem in Michigan contin- only anecdotal evidence of the eco- rina and Saugatuck Yacht Services, ues to be government is getting out nomic impact of recreational boat- estimated that pleasure boating of the business of dredging recre- Working Capital In Action ing. The impact from commercial pumps about $15 million to $20 mil- ational harbors, and boating bud- use of harbors is easier to gauge be- lion annually into the Saugatuck- gets did not anticipate having to cause bulk carriers of coal, lime- Douglas economy. But that figure spend so much on dredging so of- We provide businesses accounts receivable and inventory financing stone and other materials pay ad could rise to more than $50 million ten.” valorem tax on the cargo they carry needed to address growth opportunities and increase cash flow. if the industry were encouraged to Until a sustainable statewide to usually a few large companies in grow further. plan is developed, all eyes are on Our experienced staff and network resources connect an area. An in-depth case study done on the weatherglass. Like farmers, entrepreneurs with the tools they need to succeed and expand. It’s hard to tell whether the cus- Tower Marina and Saugatuck marina managers can opine for tomer of a local restaurant is a Yacht Services in 2004 by the Army hours about where Great Lakes recreational boater for the season Corps gives perhaps the best sense levels are headed. Need Cash to Grow? We Have the Solution. or a passing tourist, said Tom Can- of what a local marina can add to a “I think that the water levels are non, parks and recreation director community. During that season, going to go up dramatically based for the northern Michigan city of boaters spent $2.85 million on lodg- on the precipitation,” said Peter- East Jordan, on the south branch of ing, restaurants, groceries, boat son, the Saugatuck marina opera- Lake Charlevoix. “But we are pret- fuel, marine supplies and shopping tor. “I’m getting that from what I ty confident that over 70 percent of and entertainment. The bulk of read in the papers.” the summer revenues of many area that money was spent by those who In East Jordan, Cannon offered businesses come from boating — owned boats ranging from 21 to 40 another forecast: “There are some and half their income comes in the feet in length. people who think that the lake lev- summer. For Allegan County, that meant els are going to come right back “They generally said that if we direct economic impact of $1.8 mil- up, but I don’t see that. It might go couldn’t get help (with dredging), lion in sales, $661,000 in wages and up a few inches, but it’s going to they wouldn’t be able to open their salaries and $952,000 in value added take more than one hard winter — 248.658.1100 HennesseyCap.com doors.” to the local economy, supporting 37 it takes years.” Cannon said he can walk around jobs, the study states. Matthew Gryczan: (616) 916-8158, areas of the harbor in ankle-deep Annual craft expenses — slip [email protected]. Twitter: water that used to be 6 feet deep — fees, storage, repairs, equipment — @mattgryczan 20130311-NEWS--0011-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 3/8/2013 10:44 AM Page 1
March 11, 2013 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS Page 11 CRAIN’S MICHIGAN BUSINESS Midland homes look like neighborhood, but Dow’s testing efficiency
BY JESSICA HOLBROOK The project will generate compar- CRAIN NEWS SERVICE ative data on home energy efficien- cy based on whole-house insulation, LAS VEGAS — Dow Building Solu- air-sealing systems and real-world tions, a unit of Dow Chemical Corp., living conditions. It also will offer has created a “test community” of data on energy consumption, hu- 12 houses in Dow’s hometown of midity, moisture levels, heat flow Midland, designed to capture com- and temperature, Dow said. parative data on high-perfor- The houses were built by Cobble- mance, energy-efficient homes. stone Homes of Saginaw. The builder The project — dubbed TEETH, purchased the materials for the for Twelve Energy Efficient Test homes through regular retail chan- Homes — consists of a neighbor- nels — though Dow reimbursed hood of houses built uniformly to costs — so Dow also could compare precise standards, like orientation the price of building the homes. to the sun and grade, to make them It’s about a $5,400 difference be- as close to identical as possible. tween a home built at 2006 green The houses are comparable in size, building standards and one built floor plan and other key features. using 2012 standards, Morey said. The only variables are each The homes are also being rent- house’s “envelope” — the outer ed. As part of Dow’s five-year part- walls, doors, windows, floors and nership with Cobblestone, the ceiling — and how the home is company is given access to infor- built, James Morey, residential mation like the tenants’ energy market manager for Dow Building bills, utility costs and electricity Solutions, said in an interview in consumption. January at the International Builders’ Dow also periodically will ques- Show in Las Vegas. tion the residents about the com- The homes are built to one of fort and durability of the house three standards: a baseline model, and each feature, Morey said. a mostly Dow house and one given Dow also will be able to compare “the steroid approach,” Morey the demographics and lifestyles of said. the residents and see the impact of The project will give Dow a “stan- a family with teenagers compared dardized, baseline way” to compare to the impact of a childless couple. data on energy-efficient housing. The tenants will not know what And because the homes are nearly model home they are living in. identical, people won’t be able to They all will pay the same rent. discount the results, he said. From Plastics News
Judge halts Lansing casino work
BY CHAD HALCOM in 1997. It intends to apply to the CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS U.S. Department of the Interior to take the Lansing properties into The Sault Ste. Marie Tribe of trust, a prerequisite for off-reser- Chippewa Indians cannot proceed vation gambling. with the casino it has planned for But a section of the Indian gam- downtown Lansing until it adopts ing act requires that an application a revenue-sharing agreement with to place that land in trust have “a other Michigan tribes, a federal prior written agreement between court judge ruled last week. the tribe and the state’s other feder- Judge Robert Jonker of U.S. Dis- ally recognized Indian tribes that trict Court in Grand Rapids ordered a provides for each of the other tribes preliminary injunction in the Sep- to share in the revenue of the off- Reliable, modernized grid tember lawsuit brought by Michi- reservation gaming facility.” gan Attorney General Bill Schuette The Saginaw Chippewas, who Energy is essential to the way we live, work and play. to stop development of the $245 mil- own Soaring Eagle Casino & Resort lion Lansing Kewadin Casino, citing a near Mt. Pleasant, and the Not- provision of the federal Indian tawaseppi Hurons, who own Fire- ITC operates, builds and maintains the region’s electric Gaming Regulatory Act. Keepers Casino near Battle Creek, The tribe entered into a compre- both contend the Sault haven’t transmission infrastructure. We’re a Michigan-based company hensive development agreement reached such an agreement with with Lansing officials last year to them. working hard to improve electric reliability and increase electric develop an off-reservation casino in In a statement, Sault Tribe the city’s entertainment district. Chairman Aaron Payment sug- transmission capacity throughout the Midwest. But leaders of the Saginaw Chippewa gested an appeal may be coming. Indian Tribe and the Nottawaseppi “The Sault Tribe remains unde- Huron Band of Potawatomi Indians con- terred and steadfastly committed tend the Sault have not reached a to pursuing our legal right to de- revenue-sharing agreement with velop our Lansing casino,” he said. them for Kewadin Lansing. “Anyone who understands tribal The Sault completed a Lansing gaming and the trust land process www.itctransco.com land purchase in November using also understands that this is going income from a trust established to be lengthy process with multi- from funds allocated by Congress ple legal steps along the way.” 20130311-NEWS--0012-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 3/8/2013 11:42 AM Page 1
Page 12 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS March 11, 2013 CRAIN’S MICHIGAN BUSINESS State tourism industry’s plan is pure expansion
BY AMY LANE portation. The plan suggests strate- The plan hits on the industry’s SPECIAL TO CRAIN’S MICHIGAN BUSINESS gies that include taking inventory of need for research and data. It sug- Most of the states that have a tourism current transportation options into gests establishing an online sys- Michigan’s tourism industry “ and throughout the state, identify- tem to capture and share relevant has a new five-year blueprint for office like Travel Michigan have a ing gaps in service and connectivi- industry research, potentially sup- growth. Now members of that in- ty, and investigating solutions. ported by fees on those who use it. dustry will determine what can be marketing plan, but not many (have a) ... The plan’s analysis of the indus- Also in the plan is the idea of the achieved in the coming years and plan that focuses on more than marketing. try’s strengths, weaknesses, oppor- “Pure Michigan promise” and the how to do it. ” tunities and threats identifies Detroit need for the state to “foster a cul- The strategic plan’s goals in- Metropolitan Airport as a major global ture of service excellence” so it can Sarah Nicholls, Michigan State University clude greater collaboration, im- asset and notes other urban oppor- meet visitor expectations raised tunities, such major-league sports by the successful Pure Michigan proved funding and heightened al, said Sarah Nicholls, a Michigan “In many ways, we look at teams and Detroit’s reputation — ad campaign. recognition of the Pure Michigan State University associate professor Toronto like another Chicago,” particularly outside the U.S. — for brand — including the objective to who facilitated the planning under Zimmerman said. An identified weakness: Incon- automotive innovation and music. increase visitor spending more the Travel Commission’s leader- He said the state also would look sistent customer service quality than 21 percent, to $21.5 billion in ship and wrote the final document. to expand its presence in Europe The plan “points out that urban throughout Michigan and a lack of 2017 from $17.7 billion in 2011. “Most of the states that have a and launch tourism marketing in destinations are an important a standard customer service train- The plan — developed with in- tourism office like Travel Michigan Asia, including Japan, South Ko- piece of the pie,” said Michael O’- ing or approach. put from hundreds of members of have a marketing plan, but not rea and China. Callaghan, executive vice presi- Steve Yencich, president and Michigan’s tourism industry, at many of them have an industry- Felicia Fairchild, executive di- dent and COO of the Detroit Metro CEO of the Lodging and Tourism meetings around the state and wide plan that focuses on more rector of the Convention & Visitors Bureau. Association, said the difficulty is through other venues — “is com- than marketing,” Nicholls said. Saugatuck-Dou- O’Callaghan said another signifi- “finding a training program that pletely influenced and written by Already in play is funding that glas Convention & cant element is the plan’s focus on can be used across all industry seg- the industry and for the industry,” would underpin one significant ob- Visitors Bureau, collaboration and bringing together ments” and is affordable to all, he said Patricia Mooradian, presi- jective: Increasing the Pure Michi- said she hoped members of the tourism industry. said. dent of The Henry Ford in Dearborn gan campaign’s presence interna- the beefed-up A current example of the collab- The Pure Michigan promise is a and chairman of the Michigan Trav- tionally. Gov. Rick Snyder’s budget marketing inter- oration that the plan might envi- broad concept, Yencich said. el Commission. proposal to boost Pure Michigan nationally could sion: The Detroit convention bu- “It begins the moment you cross The commission adopted the funding to $29 million from $25 mil- boost an aggres- reau’s quarterly social media the state line and includes the 2012-17 plan in February, and lion by the 2014 fiscal year would sive focus her seminars, previously offered to its roads and bridges you travel on, putting it into action will be dis- own members, now will be avail- give the state money for interna- bureau has on Fairchild includes our initial impressions cussed at a session at the April 14- tional promotion that could in- international able to members of the Michigan as we walk into that restaurant, 16 Pure Michigan Governor’s Confer- clude advertising in Toronto — a visitors, drawn to the character of Lodging and Tourism Association. hotel, golf course … and does not ence on Tourism at the Detroit market where Michigan never has “small-town America” and the wa- Association member properties end with the delivery of customer Marriott Renaissance Center. had a significant presence, said ter. can sign up, watch and ask ques- service excellence,” he said. “It’s The plan reaches beyond promo- George Zimmermann, vice presi- But she and others also said many tions via online access to the semi- the follow-up and follow-through tion to identify other critical issues, dent of Travel Michigan, the state’s international visitors are accus- nars, produced in Troy, beginning to that entire vacation experi- and that makes it somewhat unusu- tourism marketing arm. tomed to traveling via public trans- March 21. ence.” 20130311-NEWS--0013-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 3/8/2013 9:50 AM Page 1
March 11, 2013 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS Page 13
Monthly Netherlands WHERE MICHIGAN DOES BUSINESS
fice services and logistics on a temporary he Netherlands has the fifth-largest Crain’s monthly World Watch report and contract basis. In addition, Kelly pro- economy in the eurozone, even showcases Michigan companies lead- Farmsum vides customers payroll and search and se- T though its 2012 tax revenues Amsterdam, ing the way in international business, Groningen lection services. dropped 9 percent and its GDP contracted. Hoofddorp, as well as those expanding their global Winschoten Top executive: Leif Agnéus is senior vice Its estimated GDP is $770.2 billion, No. Schiphol-Rijk operations. president, Europe, Middle East and Africa 24 in the world, according to the CIA Westknollendam Each World Watch Monthly features and Asia-Pacific regions. Bas Jongen is World Factbook. a different country. If you know of a country general manager for Benelux. In 2011, the U.S. imported $33 billion in Nijkerk Michigan company that exports, manu- goods and services from the Netherlands Arnhem factures abroad or has facilities abroad, NETHERLANDS and exported $47.5 billion. Major indus- Gravenzande Masco Corp. email Jennette Smith, managing editor, Alblasserdam tries include construction, fishing and mi- at [email protected]. Putte Based: Taylor croelectronics. It is also part of the Breda, Etten-Leur Hoek, Operations: Hüppe BV in Alblasserdam and Benelux economic union with Belgium Terneuzen Born Hansgrohe BV in Westknollendam, market- and Luxembourg. COMING UP Steenbergen, ing and sales locations Ⅲ April: Saudi Arabia Ⅲ May: Japan Roosendaal Employees: About 30 GERMANY Products: Bathroom and kitchen products BELGIUM including showers, faucets, toilets and in- Beyond Interactive Inc. bergen stallation systems Employees: 100-150 Top executive: Mark van Leuken, sales Based: Ann Arbor Products: Muffins, cookies, pastry mixes, FRANCE manager, Hüppe BV; Sander Hengeveld, Operations: Mediacom BV in Amsterdam custard powders, dry ingredient mixes and rayon manager, Hansgrohe BV Employees: 27 extruded decorations Products: Sales and marketing organiza- Industries served: The food and bakery in- managing director, Opel Netherlands tion dustry and food service MSX International Inc. Industries served: Online adverting Top executive: Janet Spiering, cluster International Automotive Based: Warren Top executive: Frank Bitter, CEO of Media- leader of Dawn Benelux (Belgium/Nether- Operations: Headquarters are in Nijkerk, com BV lands/Luxembourg), who reports to Serhat Components Group which is also the headquarters for the MSXI Unsal, president of Dawn Foods International Based: Southfield Benelux business unit. Operations: Research and development, Employees: 100 Dow Chemical Co. manufacturing and production facilities in Products: Call centers and retail network Born services, which include customer relation- Based: Midland Employees: Approximately 275 ship management, management of warran- Operations: Headquarters for Dow Benelux Products: Dashboards, instruments, doors ty programs, coaching programs and ser- BV located in Hoek, Terneuzen; manufactur- and bumpers vice and technical training ing, production facilities in Farmsum and Industries served: Automotive Top executives: David Leroi, operation Winschoten Top executive: Rien Segers, senior vice director for Benelux; Johan Kloosterboer, Employees: 2,235 president, engineering and development operation manager, Netherlands; René Products: High-density polyethylene, poly- Europe Derboven, account manager, Belgian busi- ether polyols, and Dow cellosize (polymers ness that are readily soluble in water and are More information: Benelux is part of used in a wide range of agriculture, textiles Inteva Products LLC MSXI’s retail network solutions business and household products) Based: Troy unit. Biggest customers include BMW, Fiat Industries served: Automotive, oil and gas, Operations: Voestalpine Polynorm BV in Bun- Group Automobiles, Ford, General Motors, Huyn- Compuware BV is based in the borough of packaging, building and construction, fur- schoten, main production facility for the dai-Kia, Jaguar Landrover, Renault-Nissan Al- Amsterdam-Zuidoost. niture, wire and cable, large appliances, wa- Northern and Western European customer liance, Mercedes, Peugeot Citroen, Toyota, the ter treatment and agriculture base; Voestalpine Plastics Solutions in Putte Volkswagen Group, Volvo, and also truck busi- Compuware Corp. Top executive: William Huisman, chair- and Roosendaal, plastics manufacturer ness with Iveco. Based: Detroit man of the board of directors of Dow Employees: More than 1,030 Operations: Compuware BV, Amsterdam- Benelux BV Products: Closure systems, interior sys- Zuidoost tems, motors, electronics and roof systems Employees: 86 Flint Group Inc. Industries served: Defense, commercial ve- Products: Performance management ap- hicle, consumer, automotive plications and mainframes; business portfo- Based: Plymouth Township Top executive: Benno Rammelmüller, man- lio software; professional services automa- Operations: Flint Ink Winschoten BV service, aging director and chairman, Voestalpine tion software; Covisint cloud engagement manufacturing and production center in Polynorm Metals Group software; Uniface application development Winschoten; marketing and sales office in platforms Winschoten; manufacturing and production Top executive: Philippe Llorens, senior facility in Gravenzande; headquarters in Kelly Services Inc. vice president, Europe, Middle East, Africa Luxembourg Based: Troy Employees: 204 Operations: Kelly Services has had a pres- MSX International is headquartered in Nijkerk, Products: Print ink and coating, press- ence in the Netherlands since 1990. Current along with the MSXI Benelux business unit. Dawn Food Products Inc. room chemicals, printing blankets and operations are located in Hoofddorp, Arn- Based: Jackson sleeves, pigments, and additives hem and an on-site customer location in Operations: Breda, Groningen and Steen- Industries served: Packaging and printing Schiphol-Rijk. Thetford Corp. Top executive: Charles Knott, Employees: 20 permanent employees Based: Ann Arbor chairman of Flint Group Inc., is Products: Kelly provides employees Operations: Thetford BV headquarters for based in Amsterdam. skilled in the areas of finance, science, of- Europe research, development, marketing, sales, manufacturing, and production in Et- General Motors Co. ten-Leur Employees: 450 Based: Detroit Products: Permanent and portable toilets, Operations: Breda, sales and chemicals, cleaners, refrigerators marketing organizations of Opel Top executive: Stéphane Cordeille, manag- and Chevrolet Netherlands ing director, Thetford BV Employees: Approximately 150 More information: Thetford’s European Products: Sales and marketing headquarters was established in 1971. organization — Ryan Felton Industries served: Delivers prod- ucts (mainly Opel and Chevrolet) to private and business cus- Sources: Crain’s research, CIA World Fact- tomers in fleet, lease and rental book, Netherlands Foreign Investment Janet Spiering is cluster leader of Dawn Benelux. Top executive: Karl Howkins, General Motors has a building in Breda. Agency, Economicties.org 20130311-NEWS--0014-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 3/8/2013 9:48 AM Page 1
Page 14 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS March 11, 2013 CRAIN'S LIST: LARGEST MICHIGAN LOGISTICS 20I3 DETROIT TIGERS COMPANIES Ranked by 2012 revenue SEASON TICKETS Company Revenue Full-time employees Address ($000,000) Percent in Michigan STILL AVAILABLE Rank Phone, website Top local executive(s) 2012/2011 change Jan. 2013 Con-way Inc. Douglas Stotlar $5,580.9 5.5% 897 1. 2211 Old Earhart Road, No. 100, Ann Arbor 48105 president and CEO $5,290.0 (734) 757-1444; www.con-way.com Universal Truckload Services Inc. H.E. "Scott" Wolfe 1,037.0 B 48.2 NA 2. 11355 Stephens Road, Warren 48089 CEO 699.8 (586) 920-0100; www.goutsi.com Express-1 Inc. Joe Stevens 548.0 C 209.6 155 3. 429 Post Road, P.O. Box 210, Buchanan 49107 president 177.0 (269) 695-2700; www.express-1.com TICKET PACKAGES United Road Services Inc. Kathleen McCann 288.0 11.2 317 4. 10701 Middlebelt Road, Romulus 48174 president and CEO 259.0 AS LOW AS $374 (734) 947-7900; unitedroad.com England Logistics SCM Patrick Runk 278.4 8.6 65 5. 33031 Schoolcraft Road, Livonia 48150 managing director 256.3 GREAT BENEFITS (734) 838-9000; www.englandlogistics.com/scm * KC Integrated Services LLC Kenyon Calender 129.6 23.4 NA INCLUDING: 6. 862 Will Carleton Road, Carleton 48117 CEO 105.0 (800) 476-6317; www.kcintegrated.com • Opening Day tickets with plan ProTrans International Inc. Shawn Masters 122.0 D 13.7 100 • Postseason ticket priority 7. 28552 Orchard Lake Road , Farmington Hills 48334 vice president of operations 107.3 D • Season ticket discount (248) 538-6100; www.protrans.com James Group International Inc. John James 110.0 266.7 131 • Complimentary food vouchers 8. 4335 W. Fort St., Detroit 48209 chairman and CEO 30.0 • And more! (313) 841-0070; www.jamesgroupintl.com ■ Biggest increase RSI Logistics Inc. Kelley Minnehan 104.4 5.8 NA *Some restrictions apply. 9. 2419 Science Parkway, Okemos 48864 senior vice president 98.7 (517) 349-7713; www.rsilogistics.com Rush Trucking Corp. Andra Rush 104.0 -9.6 532 #48 Torii Hunter 10. 35160 E. Michigan Ave., Wayne 48184 president and CEO 115.0 (800) 526-7874; www.rushtrucking.com E.L. Hollingsworth & Co. Christopher Shepard 95.2 26.1 275 11. 3039 Airpark Drive N., Flint 48507 president 75.5 (810) 233-7331; www.elhc.net 313.471.BALL (2255) Load One Transportation & Logistics John Elliott 68.8 22.1 415 12. 13221 Inkster, Taylor 48180 president and CEO 56.3 (734) 947-9440; www.load1.com Transcorr National Logistics LLC Brian Jones 50.0 12.4 70 13. 2855 44th St., Suite 300, Grandville 49418 COO 44.5 (888) 778-0773; www.transcorrlogistics.com VSF Transportation Inc. Mont Reed 46.4 5.5 90 14. 1025 Ken-O-Sha Industrial Drive, Grand Rapids 49508 president 44.0 (616) 530-0005; www.vsftransportation.com Landaal Packaging Systems Robert Landaal 40.0 14.3 175 15. 3256 B Iron St., Burton 48529 VP marketing/sales 35.0 (800) 656-6652; www.landaal.com ARC Supply Chain Solutions Inc. Greta Elliott 39.7 66.8 32 16. 13221 Inkster Road, Taylor 48180 president 23.8 (877) 272-3523; www.arc-scs.com Chris Kopp vice president Evans Distribution Systems Inc. John A. Evans 35.8 8.5 503 17. 18765 Seaway Drive, Melvindale 48122 president 33.0 (313) 388-3200; www.evansdist.com John W. Evans CEO Columbian Distribution Services Inc. John Zevalkink 35.0 NA NA 18. 900 Hall St. SW, Grand Rapids 49503 CEO NA (616) 514-6000; www.columbianlogistics.com Bay Logistics Inc. Don Finney 27.0 8.0 135 19. 9450 Buffalo St., Hamtramck 48212 general manager 25.0 (313) 664-4100; www.baylogistics.com Seko Worldwide Detroit Tanya Bartelo 24.9 16.3 20 20. 6800 S. Cypress, Romulus 48174 Michael Bartelo 21.4 (734) 641-2100; www.sekologistics.com/detroit owner, managing directors US Special Delivery Inc. Terry Reed 20.3 4.7 102 21. 821 East Blvd., Kingsford 49802 president 19.3 (906) 774-1931; usspecial.com AIT Worldwide Logistics Lorri Fairchild 18.6 0.7 NA 22. 30255 Beverly Road, Suite 100, Romulus 48174 Detroit franchise owner 18.4 (734) 326-9140; www.aitworldwide.com Three Star Trucking Co. Inc. Denise Rays 15.9 -20.5 59 23. 36860 Van Born Road, Wayne 48184 president and CEO 20.0 (734) 728-5500; www.threestartrucking.com Frontline Logistics Inc. Greg Haigh 13.5 8.0 14 24. 10315 E. Grand River, No. 300, Brighton 48116 vice president 12.5 (734) 449-9474; www.frontlinelogistics.com JMA Logistics LLC Jeanette Abraham 4.2 7.7 7 25. 28401 Schoolcraft Road, Suite 450, Livonia 48150 president/CEO 3.9 (734) 762-4830; www.jmalogistics.com
This list of logistics companies is an approximate compilation of the largest such companies in Michigan. It is not a complete listing but the most comprehensive available. Crain's estimates are based on industry analysis and benchmarks, news reports and a wide range of other sources. Unless otherwise noted, information was provided by the companies. Companies with headquarters elsewhere are listed with the address and top executive of their main Michigan office. Actual revenue figures may vary. NA = not available. B Acquired Linc Logistics Co. July 26, 2012. C Acquired six companies in 2012. D Crain's estimate. LIST RESEARCHED BY BRIANNA REILLY 20130311-NEWS--0015,0016-NAT-CCI-CD_-- 3/8/2013 10:59 AM Page 1
March 11, 2013 CRAIN’S DETROIT BUSINESS Page 15
LEADING THROUGH TOUGH TIMES Longtime Beaumont board trustee tells of the ups and downs, Page 17
People