Roho Churches of Western Kenya in the Era of Globalization
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Spirit, Desire and the World: Roho Churches of Western Kenya in the Era of Globalization by Timothy John Padwick A thesis submitted to The University of Birmingham for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy Department of Theology School of Historical Studies The University of Birmingham March 2003 University of Birmingham Research Archive e-theses repository This unpublished thesis/dissertation is copyright of the author and/or third parties. The intellectual property rights of the author or third parties in respect of this work are as defined by The Copyright Designs and Patents Act 1988 or as modified by any successor legislation. Any use made of information contained in this thesis/dissertation must be in accordance with that legislation and must be properly acknowledged. Further distribution or reproduction in any format is prohibited without the permission of the copyright holder. 1st of 3 files Introductory material and chapter 1 The remaining chapters and the appendices are in two additional files Abstract This thesis is a study of the Roho churches of Vihiga District, Western Kenya, from their beginnings in 1927 to the present. After an initial historical overview of this group of African Independent Churches, it examines their creation of a vernacular theology – the founders’ vision. This was characterized by a strong pneumatology, in which the Holy Spirit acts as guardian of the community. The thesis locates this vision, and its rejection of modernist, western, and capitalist modes of development, in the articulation of the traditional communal mode of production in contradistinction to the European industrial capitalism characteristic of Kenya in the 1930s. It examines the desire of Roho leaders to play a role in the public sphere and recounts their attempt to influence national political life through an indigenous conciliar movement at the time of political independence. Finally, it examines the process of re-envisioning undertaken by Roho leaders and members to meet the dual challenges of pauperization and modernization at the present day. Dedicated to the Bishops and Archbishops of the Roho churches of Vihiga, who first introduced me to Roho Christianity, and who continue to encourage me to enter more deeply into that faith Acknowledgements This work has its roots in my life and work in Kenya over the past thirty years, and I am unable to name all those who have contributed in one way or another. Thanks to all the people of Kenya who have made me feel at home. In particular I would like to thank the leaders of Kenya United Independent Churches for their support, friendship, and encouragement, especially Archbishop Moses Aseri, one of my sponsors in Vihiga; Archbishop James Kisibo, a good guide to Roho church life and a spiritual father; Archbishop Christopher Ondolo, for his faith, perseverance, and humility; Archbishop Elijah Joji for his enthusiastic advocacy of Roho traditions; the late Archbishop Eliakimu Keverenge for his grace and spiritual wisdom; Archbishop James Chabuga for his unshakenness and good sense; Bishop Willington Esikuri for his grace and humility; Archbishop Richard Ong’anda for his practical wisdom; and Archbishop Philip Bulimu whose tenor of life continues to remind me of the seriousness of it all. In addition to these elders, I would like to thank especially my age-mates, the late Rev. Ayub Kenyan Kedogo, and Mrs. Gladys Kedogo, of African Holy Zionist Church, who invited me into their home in 1987, and to whom I have been a brother; and Archbishop Manoah Keverenge, whose energy and networking is always challenging. Archbishop John Kivuli II of African Israel Church Nineveh, my chairman at Kenya United Independent Churches, was a good if sometimes exacting employer and has been a supportive friend. Kennedy Mbayagi has been a good companion and guide on difficult journeys. The people of Holy Spirit Church of East Africa, Bukoyani, have welcomed, supported, and taught me much about the Roho faith. I hope I have captured in this work a little of the vision of the church’s founders and martyrs. Special thanks to Archbishop Joel Sande, General Secretary Rev. Joseph Zare, and National Treasurer Rev. Dishon Osore. There are many others in the church too numerous to mention. Some of their names occur in the text of the thesis itself. Bishop Antonious Markos, Organizing Secretary of OAIC, first gave me the opportunity to meet AIC leaders of great power and vision, including the late Rev. (Ntate) Samuel Mohono, OAIC General Secretary, 1982-6. Rev. Agustin and Rev. Dr. Rosario Batlle challenged me with their commitment to build the theological capacity of AICs while respecting their integrity. More recently, without the continued support of the current OAIC General Secretary, Archbishop Njeru Wambugu, this work would have never been re-started, nor reached completion. His constantly re-iterated challenge that AICs should become conscious of their heritage and engage effectively with the problems and strengths of the African continent has forced me (and everyone at OAIC) to ask radical questions about the goals, values, and methods of theology and ‘development’ in Africa. In this task, I have benefited immensely from a continuous and continuing critical dialogue with my colleagues Nicta Lubaale, and the late Maurice Onyango. Pastor Elisha Otieno has continued to support me in the task of articulating Roho theology. Rev. Lawford Imunde gave me the encouragement I needed to begin this thesis, and his own costly dedication to the continent of Africa remains an inspiration. My colleagues at OAIC, Rev. Fr. Michael Ng’ong’a, Rev. John Gichimu and Rev. Emmanuel Simwa have always been ready with wise advice and friendship during times of uncertainty and confusion. I thank especially Teresa Ntarara, Jane Nkrumah, Rose Onyango, Samson Koinange, Ernest Nyaudha, and Arthur Wekesa, without whose support and hard work I could never have completed this work. Finally I thank the OAIC International Chairman, Baba Aladura Dr. G.I.M. Otubu, for encouragement and support. I am grateful to all my colleagues at the Church Mission Society for supporting and encouraging me in a life-project that must often have seemed risky or quixotic. In particular I would like to mention here Christopher Carey, Tim Dakin, Zak Niringiye, Peter Kenworthy and Tim Sanders. I trust that their vision and generosity has been adequately rewarded. My supporting churches in the UK, especially St. Martin’s Morden, St. Martin’s Epsom, Christchurch Aughton, Cottage Lane Mission Ormskirk, and St. Giles Bredon, have helped practically, and with fellowship and support, when I needed them most. In the academic field, David B. Barrett and Harold W. Turner first introduced me to the positive and sympathetic study of AICs. Jack Thompson, Stan Nussbaum, Ralph Woodhall, Allan Anderson, Philomena Mwaura, and Esther Mombo have continued the task, giving encouragement, sympathy, advice and support from their respective bases at the former Selly Oak Colleges, the University of Birmingham, the Network on AICs, and Kenyatta University, and St Paul’s University College, Limuru. In particular Allan Anderson has seen this thesis through to completion. To have attempted this thesis without the co-operation and commitment of my research assistants would have been impossible. Raphael Otakwa has kept me and my material organized, and has assisted in more ways than I can list. Rev. Albert Obede has been a wise and perceptive interpreter of Roho spirituality and politics. Lauden Kedogo, Stephen Muguga, and Rosemary Osore shared with me in conducting interviews and did much arduous work in transcribing and translating. Rev. Albert Obede, Rev. Francis King’anga, and Rev. Daniel Oguso have for many years been sharing with me their views and ideas; they also helped by reading part of the text and offering suggestions. I thank my father, Tim Padwick, for proofreading the text; Jim Harries also assisted. Rev. John Gichimu helped with the Swahili. Last but not least, Jackson Lwoyero has been a constant support to me for over a decade; he has made for me a home and a base which has made all this has possible. Table of Contents Table of Illustrations....................................................................................... i Glossary of common Swahili words............................................................... ii List of Abbreviations and Acronyms.............................................................. v Maps...................................................................................................... Following p. vi Chapter One. Articulating ‘local’ values and visions Part One. Introduction ♦ Spirit or flesh?……………………………………………………………. 1 ♦ African Independent Churches …………………………………………... 5 ♦ A personal journey……………………………………………………….. 8 Part Two. Theoretical considerations……………………………………… 13 ♦ Globalization, modernity, & modernization ……………………………… 13 ♦ Articulation of modes of production theory…………………………………. 19 ♦ Theological assumptions…………………………………………………. 26 Part Three. Local realities and global pressure…………………………… 28 ♦ Development theory and practice………………………………………… 29 ♦ Vernacular theologies and local churches ………………………………... 32 ♦ The founders’ visions…………………………………………………….. 35 Part Four. Methodological issues………………………………………….. 37 ♦ Ethnography and the interpretation of symbols…………………………. 37 ♦ Oral history as social construction……………………………………….. 40 Part Five. Living, working, and researching at the grassroots ♦ ‘Uppers’ and ‘Lowers’: bridging the