“The Jazz Problem”: How U.S. Composers Grappled with the Sounds of Blackness, 1917—1925 Stephanie Doktor Cumming, Georgia
“The Jazz Problem”: How U.S. Composers Grappled with the Sounds of Blackness, 1917—1925 Stephanie Doktor Cumming, Georgia Bachelor of Arts, Vocal Performance, University of North Georgia, 2003 Master of Arts, Musicology, University of Georgia, 2008 Master’s Certificate, Women’s Studies, University of Georgia, 2008 A Dissertation presented to the Graduate Faculty of the University of Virginia in Candidacy for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy Department of Music University of Virginia December, 2016 iv © Copyright by Stephanie DeLane Doktor All Rights Reserved December 2016 v For Hillary Clinton and Terry Allen, who both lost the race but the fight still rages on vi ABSTRACT My dissertation tracks the development of jazz-based classical music from 1917, when jazz began to circulate as a term, to 1925, when U.S. modernism was in full swing and jazz had become synonymous with America. I examine the music of four composers who used black popular music regularly: Edmund Jenkins, John Powell, William Grant Still, and Georgia Antheil. For each composer, whose collections I consulted, I analyze at least one of their jazz-based compositions, consider its reception, and put it in dialogue with writings about U.S. concert music after World War I. Taken together, these compositions contributed to what I call the Symphonic Jazz Era, and this music was integral to the formation of American modernism. I examine how these four composers grappled with the sounds of blackness during this time period, and I use “the Jazz Problem” as an analytic to do so. This phrase began to circulate in periodicals around 1923, and it captured anxieties about both the rise of mass entertainment and its rootedness in black cultural sounds in the Jim Crow era.
[Show full text]