DOCSLIB.ORG

Proportional Representation in Western Australia Its Principles

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Proportional Representation in Western Australia Its Principles Proportional Representation in Western Australia Its Principles, History, Outcomes and Education Harry C.J. Phillips WESTERN AUSTRALIAN Electoral Commission Table of Contents FOREWORD ........................................................................................................................................... iii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS.................................................................................................................... v CHAPTER 1 VOTING SYSTEMS, ELECTORAL LAW AND REPRESENTATION ............... 1 1.1 Representation.............................................................................................................................. 1 1.2 Electoral law (Its components)..................................................................................................... 2 1.3 Types of Proportional Representation.......................................................................................... 3 (a) The list system...................................................................................................................... 4 (b) The Single Transferable Vote (STV) Form of PR................................................................ 4 CHAPTER 2 THE BEGINNINGS OF THE PROPORTIONAL REPRESENTATION QUEST IN AUSTRALIA............................................................................................. 7 2.1 Letter to the Inquirer (1870) ........................................................................................................ 7 2.2 The idealists in the Colonies ........................................................................................................ 9 (a) Catherine Helen Spence ....................................................................................................... 10 (b) Edward Nanson .................................................................................................................... 10 (c) Thomas and Henry Ashworth............................................................................................... 11 (d) Andrew Inglis Clark ............................................................................................................. 11 2.3 Proportional representation in the Commonwealth...................................................................... 11 CHAPTER 3 MOTIONS FOR PROPORTIONAL REPRESENATION IN WESTERN AUSTRALIA................................................................................................................. 15 3.1 Preferential Voting in 1907.......................................................................................................... 15 3.2 The 1912 Gawler Proportional Representation Motion and Bill.................................................. 17 (a) The advocacy deficit ............................................................................................................ 19 (b) A PR Machinery Bill............................................................................................................ 21 CHAPTER 4 THE SLOW PUSH FOR PROPORTIONAL REPRESENTATION....................... 23 4.1 The Proportional Representation Winding Track......................................................................... 23 4.2 Edith Cowan and Proportional Representation ............................................................................ 24 4.3 The 1923 Proportional Representation Amendment Proposal ..................................................... 25 4.4 T.R. Ashworth and the Peden Royal Commission on the Constitution of the Commonwealth ............................................................................................................................ 26 4.5 Senate PR from 1949 ................................................................................................................... 29 CHAPTER 5 PRESSURE FOR PROPORTIONAL REPRESENTATION IN WESTERN AUSTRALIA................................................................................................................. 31 5.1 The Claughton Proportional Representation and Other Electoral Matters Proposal .................... 31 5.2 The Hetherington Labor Party Proportional Representation Bill................................................. 32 5.3 The Jamieson Labor Proportional Representation Bill................................................................. 33 5.4 Stephens’ Initial Quest for Proportional Representation.............................................................. 34 5.5 Stephens and Proportional Representation in 1984...................................................................... 37 CHAPTER 6 ARTHUR TONKIN AND OTHERS ON PROPORTIONAL REPRESENTATION IN BURKE’S FIRST TERM (1983–1985) ............................ 39 6.1 The 1983 Quest for Proportional Representation in the Legislative Council............................... 39 (a) Practical considerations........................................................................................................ 41 (b) Regional considerations ....................................................................................................... 42 (c) Concerns about complexity .................................................................................................. 43 6.2 The 1984 Fair Representation Bill ............................................................................................... 45 CHAPTER 7 THE ADOPTION OF PROPORTIONAL REPRESENTATION FOR THE WESTERN AUSTRALIAN LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL......................................... 49 7.1 Mal Bryce replaces Arthur Tonkin as Electoral Reform Minister ............................................... 49 7.2 The Labor Government’s Legislation and Perspective ................................................................ 50 7.3 The Liberal Party Perspective(s) .................................................................................................. 53 7.4 The National Party Perspective .................................................................................................... 55 i CHAPTER 8 THE ‘WA INC’ ROYAL COMMISSION AND THE COMMISSION ON GOVERNMENT PERSPECTIVES............................................................................ 59 8.1 The WA Inc Royal Commission Perspective............................................................................... 59 8.2 The Commission on Government and the PR Question............................................................... 60 8.3 Robson Rotation........................................................................................................................... 62 CHAPTER 9 RETENSION AND MODIFICATION OF PROPORTIONAL REPRESENTATION ................................................................................................... 65 9.1 The 2001 Mining and Pastoral Region and Agricultural Region Result ...................................... 65 9.2 The Miragliotta Monograph......................................................................................................... 66 (a) Inclusive Gregory Method.................................................................................................... 68 (b) The Weighted Inclusive Gregory Method............................................................................ 69 (c) Other Fractional Methods..................................................................................................... 70 9.3 Weighted Inclusive Gregory Method for the Legislative Council and Local Government (2007 only) .............................................................................................................................. 70 9.4 The 2005 One Vote One Value Legislation and Regional PR Modifications .............................. 72 CHAPTER 10 KEY CONSIDERATIONS OF PR IN WESTERN AUSTRALIA........................... 75 10.1 An intelligent electorate ............................................................................................................... 75 10.2 Representation of diverse interests in the Western Australian Legislative Council..................... 78 (a) 1989 – Legislative Council Election .................................................................................... 78 (b) 1993 – Legislative Council Election .................................................................................... 79 (c) 1996 – Legislative Council Election .................................................................................... 80 (d) 2001 – Legislative Council Election .................................................................................... 81 (e) 2005 – Legislative Council Election .................................................................................... 82 (f) 2008 – Legislative Council Election .................................................................................... 83 10.3 Candidate Centred Voting System ............................................................................................... 84 10.4 PR and Women ............................................................................................................................ 87 CHAPTER 11 CONCLUDING OBSERVATIONS ............................................................................ 91 TABLES Table 1: Proposed Composition of Legislative Council Regions – 1986 .................................................. 52 Table 2: Proposed Composition of Legislative Council Regions – 1987 .................................................. 57 Table 3: Thresholds of Representation for
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Notable Australians Historical Figures Portrayed on Australian Banknotes
    NOTABLE AUSTRALIANS HISTORICAL FIGURES PORTRAYED ON AUSTRALIAN BANKNOTES X X I NOTABLE AUSTRALIANS HISTORICAL FIGURES PORTRAYED ON AUSTRALIAN BANKNOTES Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander readers are respectfully advised that this book includes the names and images of people who are now deceased. Cover: Detail from Caroline Chisholm's portrait by Angelo Collen Hayter, oil on canvas, 1852, Dixson Galleries, State Library of NSW (DG 459). Notable Australians Historical Figures Portrayed on Australian Banknotes © Reserve Bank of Australia 2016 E-book ISBN 978-0-6480470-0-1 Compiled by: John Murphy Designed by: Rachel Williams Edited by: Russell Thomson and Katherine Fitzpatrick For enquiries, contact the Reserve Bank of Australia Museum, 65 Martin Place, Sydney NSW 2000 <museum.rba.gov.au> CONTENTS Introduction VI Portraits from the present series Portraits from pre-decimal of banknotes banknotes Banjo Paterson (1993: $10) 1 Matthew Flinders (1954: 10 shillings) 45 Dame Mary Gilmore (1993: $10) 3 Charles Sturt (1953: £1) 47 Mary Reibey (1994: $20) 5 Hamilton Hume (1953: £1) 49 The Reverend John Flynn (1994: $20) 7 Sir John Franklin (1954: £5) 51 David Unaipon (1995: $50) 9 Arthur Phillip (1954: £10) 53 Edith Cowan (1995: $50) 11 James Cook (1923: £1) 55 Dame Nellie Melba (1996: $100) 13 Sir John Monash (1996: $100) 15 Portraits of monarchs on Australian banknotes Portraits from the centenary Queen Elizabeth II of Federation banknote (2016: $5; 1992: $5; 1966: $1; 1953: £1) 57 Sir Henry Parkes (2001: $5) 17 King George VI Catherine Helen
    [Show full text]
  • Compulsory Voting in Australian National Elections
    Parliament of Australia Department of Parliamentary Services Parliamentary Library RESEARCH BRIEF Information analysis and advice for the Parliament 31 October 2005, no. 6, 2005–06, ISSN 1832-2883 Compulsory voting in Australian national elections Compulsory voting has been part of Australia’s national elections since 1924. Renewed Liberal Party interest and a recommendation by the Joint Standing Committee on Electoral Matters that voluntary and compulsory voting be the subject of future investigation, suggest that this may well be an important issue at the next election. This research brief refers to the origins of compulsory voting in Australia, describes its use in Commonwealth elections, outlines the arguments for and against compulsion, discusses the political impact of compulsory voting and refers to suggested reforms. Scott Bennett Politics and Public Administration Section Contents Executive summary ................................................... 3 Introduction ........................................................ 4 The emergence of compulsory voting in Australia ............................. 5 Compulsory voting elsewhere ........................................... 8 Administration of compulsory voting in Australian national elections ............... 8 To retain or reject compulsory voting? ..................................... 9 Opposition to compulsory voting ......................................... 9 Support for compulsory voting .......................................... 11 The political impact of compulsory voting
    [Show full text]
  • 1 Exhausted Votes
    Committee Secretary Timothy McCarthy Joint Standing Committee on Electoral Matters Dear committee, I am a software engineer living in Melbourne. Over the last few months, I have developed a tool for analysing Senate ballot papers, using raw data made available by the AEC on their website. In this submission, I will present some of my results in the hope that they might be of use to the committee, particularly in evaluating the success of changes to the recent changes to the Electoral Act. The key results are as follows: • Of the 1,042,132 exhausted votes, 917,379 (88%) were from ballots whose first preference was for a minor party or independent candidate. • 25% of the total primary vote for minor parties exhausted, compared to just 1.22% for major parties. • Nationally, donkey votes made up only 0.15% of the vote. The Division of Lingiari had an unusually high number of donkey votes (2.32%), mainly from the remote mobile teams in that division. • Despite the changes to above-the-line voting, 290,758 ballots still marked a single '1' above the line. • 1,046,837 ballots (7.56% of formal ballots) were saved from informality by savings provi- sions in the Act. 1 Exhausted votes Changes in the Electoral Act prior to the election introduced optional preferential voting both above and below the line. These changes introduced the possibility of ballots exhausting, something that was exceedingly rare under the previous rules. At the 2016 Federal election, there were just over 1 million exhausted votes, about 7.5% of the total.
    [Show full text]
  • From Track to Tarmac
    Federation Faces and Introduction A guided walk around the streets and laneways Places of North Sydney focusing on our Federation connections, including the former residences of A walking tour of Federation Sir Joseph Palmer Abbott, Sir Edmund Barton faces and places in North and Dugald Thomson. Along the walk, view the Sydney changes in the North Sydney landscape since th Federation and the turn of the 20 century. Distance: 6 Km Approximate time: 4 hours At the turn of the year 1900 to 1901 the city of Grading: medium to high Sydney went mad with joy. For a few days hope ran so high that poets and prophets declared Australia to be on the threshold of a golden age… from early morning on the first of January 1901 trams, trains and ferry boats carried thousands of people into the city for the greatest day of their history: the inauguration of the Commonwealth of Australia. It was to be a people‟s festival. Manning Clark, Historian It was also a people‟s movement and 1901 was the culmination of many years of discussions, community activism, heated public debates, vibrant speeches and consolidated actions. In 1890 the Australasian Federal Conference was held in Melbourne and the following year in Sydney. In 1893 a meeting of the various federation groups, including the Australian Native Association was held at Corowa. A plan was developed for the election of delegates to a convention. In the mid to late 1890s it was very much a peoples‟ movement gathering groundswell support. In 1896 a People‟s Convention with 220 delegates and invited guests from all of the colonies took place at Bathurst - an important link in the Federation chain.
    [Show full text]
  • The Effects of Physical and Social Environments on the Health and Wellbeing of Children and Young People
    THE EFFECTS OF PHYSICAL AND SOCIAL ENVIRONMENTS ON THE HEALTH AND WELLBEING OF CHILDREN AND YOUNG PEOPLE Prepared for the W.A Commissioner for Children and Young People by Dr Carmen Lawrence, June 2019 Contents Section 1: Introduction…………………………………………………………….3 Section 2: Social determinants………………………………………………..4 Section 3: The spatial dimensions of children’s lives in WA…..5 3.1: Population profile..…………………………….……………………5 3.2: Social profile…………………………………………………………….6 3.3: Children’s health and wellbeing……………………………..6 3.3.1: Definitions and measurement of health and wellbeing…………………………………………………………….6 3.3.2: Children’s health and wellbeing data sets………7 3.4: Summary………………………………………………………………14 Section 4: Why place matters……………………………………………….15 4.1: Locational disadvantage……………………………………….17 4.2: Regional and remote areas…………………………………..17 4.3: Green space, backyards and public open space….18 4.4: Transport………………………………………………………………19 Section 5: The important attributes of place……………………….20 5.1: Socio-economic status and neighbourhood disadvantage……………………………………………………………...20 5.2: Pollution…………………………………………………………………24 5.3: Noise……………………………………………………………………….28 5.4: Community safety and violence……………………………29 5.5: Social capital………………………………………………………….31 1 5.6: The natural environment – Exposure to nature/greeness…………………………………..………………...33 5.6.1: Population studies………………………………………….35 5.6.2: Physical health…….…………………………………..........36 5.6.3: Mental health and psychological wellbeing……………………………………………………………………39 5.6.4: Cognitive benefits………………………………………….42 5.6.5:
    [Show full text]
  • MP362 Gardiner J P.PDF
    House to House An MP Goes Breathing Space for In all respects the period from the 1910 debate, with all the absurdity that that episode unearthed, right through to the mid-1930s, was one of marking time for Parliament House in Western Australia. Ten governments had come and gone in a twenty-six year period, six of them conservative administrations and four led by Labor premiers with a smooth transition from one Labor Premier to another in 1936. It is true that, at times, there were periods of peace and plenty, and prior to 1914 a variety of economic indices-railway expansion, wheat and flour production and population growth to name some-showed impressive if not spectacular advances for the people of the small state. Yet if economic progress was unspectacular the State and its Parliament were but a short step away from an extraordinary incident in 1915 that was ever a reminder that in a parliamentary democracy human frailty was rarely far from lofty issues of state. The incident came in the form of the downfall and reported disappearance that year of the sitting member for Roebourne, J.P. (Joe) Gardiner, a young Labor MP, union secretary and hotel manager, who had been elected only four years before when he was all of twenty-five. The disappearance was to end Gardiner's personal political career but it was to have even more serious consequences for the Scaddan Labor Government of which he was a part. For within ten months of Gardiner's seat being declared vacant on 30 September 1915 for non­ attendance, Scaddan's government was to fall by vote of the House rather than the vote of the people.
    [Show full text]
  • Women in the Federal Parliament
    PAPERS ON PARLIAMENT Number 17 September 1992 Trust the Women Women in the Federal Parliament Published and Printed by the Department of the Senate Parliament House, Canberra ISSN 1031-976X Papers on Parliament is edited and managed by the Research Section, Senate Department. All inquiries should be made to: The Director of Research Procedure Office Senate Department Parliament House CANBERRA ACT 2600 Telephone: (06) 277 3061 The Department of the Senate acknowledges the assistance of the Department of the Parliamentary Reporting Staff. First published 1992 Reprinted 1993 Cover design: Conroy + Donovan, Canberra Note This issue of Papers on Parliament brings together a collection of papers given during the first half of 1992 as part of the Senate Department's Occasional Lecture series and in conjunction with an exhibition on the history of women in the federal Parliament, entitled, Trust the Women. Also included in this issue is the address given by Senator Patricia Giles at the opening of the Trust the Women exhibition which took place on 27 February 1992. The exhibition was held in the public area at Parliament House, Canberra and will remain in place until the end of June 1993. Senator Patricia Giles has represented the Australian Labor Party for Western Australia since 1980 having served on numerous Senate committees as well as having been an inaugural member of the World Women Parliamentarians for Peace and, at one time, its President. Dr Marian Sawer is Senior Lecturer in Political Science at the University of Canberra, and has written widely on women in Australian society, including, with Marian Simms, A Woman's Place: Women and Politics in Australia.
    [Show full text]
  • Full-Fee Paying International Students at Murdoch University 1985 - 1991: a Policy Case Study
    FULL-FEE PAYING INTERNATIONAL STUDENTS AT MURDOCH UNIVERSITY 1985 - 1991: A POLICY CASE STUDY. Colin Trestrail B.A., B. Ed., Grad.Dip.Admin., M.Ed. FACEL. This dissertation is presented as fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy, 2005. DECLARATION I declare that this dissertation is my own account of my research and contains as its main content work which has not been submitted previously for a degree at any tertiary institution. Signed: Colin Trestrail ii ABSTRACT In 1985 the Australian Government announced a momentous policy initiative allowing Australian universities to enrol full-fee paying international students for the first time. This case study is an analysis of the policy development that ensued at Murdoch University between 1985 and 1991as it responded to this opportunity to alleviate problems, with finance and low student numbers, that were threatening its very existence as an independent university. In particular, it examines the factors that had placed Murdoch in such a parlous situation, and the reasons why it was able to respond quickly and effectively so as to implement a highly successful and comprehensive program for the recruitment, enrolment and support of full-fee paying international students. The case study format allowed for the use of a wide range of data sources. Sources of documentary evidence included: formal written works about the events and concepts under investigation, newspapers and other media items, letters, memoranda, agendas and minutes of meetings, and other internal Murdoch University documents. In addition, archival materials such as annual reports, budgets and financial records were consulted. Verification and extension of the documentary and archival evidence was gained from interviews with past and present staff and students of Murdoch University who had been involved with the program.
    [Show full text]
  • Western Australia State Election 2017
    RESEARCH PAPER SERIES, 2017–18 18 SEPTEMBER 2017 Western Australia state election 2017 Rob Lundie Politics and Public Administration Section Contents Introduction ................................................................................................ 2 Background ................................................................................................. 2 Electoral changes ................................................................................................ 2 2013 election ...................................................................................................... 2 Party leaders ....................................................................................................... 3 Aftermath for the WA Liberal Party ................................................................... 5 The campaign .............................................................................................. 5 Economic issues .................................................................................................. 5 Liberal/Nationals differences ............................................................................. 6 Transport ............................................................................................................ 7 Federal issues ..................................................................................................... 7 Party campaign launches .................................................................................... 7 Leaders debate ..................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • 1 Heat Treatment This Is a List of Greenhouse Gas Emitting
    Heat treatment This is a list of greenhouse gas emitting companies and peak industry bodies and the firms they employ to lobby government. It is based on data from the federal and state lobbying registers.* Client Industry Lobby Company AGL Energy Oil and Gas Enhance Corporate Lobbyists registered with Enhance Lobbyist Background Limited Pty Ltd Corporate Pty Ltd* James (Jim) Peter Elder Former Labor Deputy Premier and Minister for State Development and Trade (Queensland) Kirsten Wishart - Michael Todd Former adviser to Queensland Premier Peter Beattie Mike Smith Policy adviser to the Queensland Minister for Natural Resources, Mines and Energy, LHMU industrial officer, state secretary to the NT Labor party. Nicholas James Park Former staffer to Federal Coalition MPs and Senators in the portfolios of: Energy and Resources, Land and Property Development, IT and Telecommunications, Gaming and Tourism. Samuel Sydney Doumany Former Queensland Liberal Attorney General and Minister for Justice Terence John Kempnich Former political adviser in the Queensland Labor and ACT Governments AGL Energy Oil and Gas Government Relations Lobbyists registered with Government Lobbyist Background Limited Australia advisory Pty Relations Australia advisory Pty Ltd* Ltd Damian Francis O’Connor Former assistant General Secretary within the NSW Australian Labor Party Elizabeth Waterland Ian Armstrong - Jacqueline Pace - * All lobbyists registered with individual firms do not necessarily work for all of that firm’s clients. Lobby lists are updated regularly. This
    [Show full text]
  • 30 May 1990]19 L391 Hallahan Is in the House Because I Will Quote from Correspondence She Wrote When She Was Minister for Local Government
    1387 IL4gtetaftiu (flnunzii Wednesday, 30 May_ 1990 T HE PRES IDE NT (Hon Clive Griffiths) took the Chair at 2.30 pm, and read prayers. STATEMENT -BY THE PRESIWENT Supply Blockade Vote -Incorrect Newspaper Report THE PRESIDENT :I read with some interest in this morning's The West Australian that 15 Liberal and three National Party Legislative Councillors had decided to deny the Government Supply. I believe that the impression created by the article needs correction. This Chamber has 33 voting members - 16 Labor, three National and 14 Liberal. To increase the Liberal vote from 14 to 15 means that there is a phantom member of the House or, more credibly, that I have been included in the calculation. I am a member of the Liberal Party, but as President my parry affiliation must, and does, give way to the conventions supporting that office. Although I attend the formal business of party meetings I am not present when tactics or House business are discussed; that is, I do not participate in the political decisions made by the Liberal members of the Council. When it comes to voting, the Constitution disfranchises the President - it deprives him of a deliberative vote. The only time that the President votes is when the result is tied. In that situation, the President votes to break the tie. Without such a casting vote, the question, as it does in Committee of the Whole, would pass in the negative. How a Presiding Officer uses a casting vote is not really a matter of choice. Traditions developed in the House of Commons and applied in this House provide guidance in most situations.
    [Show full text]
  • A. I. Clark Papers
    A. I. CLARK PAPERS PAPERS OF r-. i - ANDREW INGLIS CLARK AND HIS FAMILY DEPOSITED IN THE UNIVERSITY OF TASMANIA ARCHIVES REF:C4 - II 1_ .1 ~ ) ) AI.CLARK INDEXOF NAMES NAME AGE DESCN DATE TOPIC REF Allen,J.H. lelter C4/C9,10 Allen,Mary W. letter C4/C11,12 AspinallL,AH. 1897 Clark's resign.fr.Braddon ministry C4/C390 Barton,Edmund 1849-1920 poltn.judge,GCMG.KC 1898 federation C4/C15 Bayles,J.E. 1885 Index": Tom Paine C4/H6 Berechree c.1905 Berechree v Phoenix Assurance Cc C4/D12 Bird,Bolton Stafford 1840-1924 1885 Brighton ejection C4/C16 Blolto,Luigi of Italy 1873-4 Pacific & USA voyage C4/C17,18 Bowden 1904-6? taxation appeal C4/D10 Braddon,Edward Nicholas Coventry 1829-1904 politn.KCMG 1897 Clark's resign. C4/C390 Brown,Nicholas John MHA Tas. 1887 Clark & Moore C4/C19 Burn,William 1887 Altny Gen.appt. C4/C20 Butler,Charles lawyer 1903 solicitor to Mrs Clark C4/C21 Butler,Gilbert E. 1897 Clark's resign. .­C4/C390 Camm,AB 1883 visit to AIClark C4/C22-24 Clark & Simmons lawyers 1887,1909-18 C4/D1-17,K.4,L16 Clark,Alexander Inglis 1879-1931 sAl.C.engineer 1916,21-26 letters C4/L52-58,L Clark,Alexander Russell 1809-1894 engineer 1842-6,58-63 letter book etc. C4/A1-2 Clark,Andrew Inglis 1848-1907 jUdge 1870-1907 papers C4/C-J Clark,Andrew Inglis 1848-1907 judge 1901 Acting Govnr.appt. C4/E9 Clark,Andrew Inglis 1848·1907 jUdge 1907-32 estate of C4/K7,L281 Clark,Andrew Inglis 1848-1907 judge 1958 biog.
    [Show full text]