Viking Coastal Trail – Link to Broadstairs Station
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Viking Coastal Trail – Link to Broadstairs Station A report by the Area Manager to the Thanet Joint Transportation Board on 24 June 2003. Introduction 1. This report is a follow up to two previous reports on 13 November 2001 and 19 March 2002, and contains the results of a public consultation on a proposed cycle link between Broadstairs railway station and the Viking Coastal Trail. Background 2. This Board has previously supported an innovative scheme to promote Thanet’s seven railway stations as “Viking Coastal Trail Interchange” points, following an agreement with Sustrans and Connex. This scheme involves distinctive signs on the railway platforms (see Fig. 1 in Appendix A), and signposted routes from the stations to the Viking Coastal Trail. 3. Since it was opened by Olympic athlete Kelly Holmes MBE on 10 June 2001, the Viking Coastal Trail (a 28-mile multi-purpose circular cycle route around Thanet) has been very successful, enjoying very positive national media coverage. Cafes and pubs on the route have reported increased business, and a key objective in the promotion of the route is as a sustainable tourist attraction in its own right (see Appendix B). The links to the stations are an integral part of this strategy. 4. Signposted routes to Westgate, Margate, Dumpton Park, Ramsgate and Minster stations were relatively straightforward to implement, and are now in place. The route to Birchington station initially involved a contraflow cycle lane in Sandles Road, but that was abandoned after consultation with the Parish Council. A new signposted route (involving no alterations to the highway) has subsequently been drawn up and agreed with the Parish Council, and will be implemented in the near future. 5. The link to Broadstairs station is more difficult to achieve. At present there is a temporary signed link that uses the High Street and Albion Street. However, the retention of this route in the longer term is inadvisable, as it is not suitable for an unsupervised 12 year old (which is the criteria required for any National or Regional Cycle Route). 6. On 19 March 2002 this Board considered a proposal for a permanent link, which included a contra-flow cycle lane in Lloyd Road and Lawn Road. Local residents rejected this proposal after public consultation, and therefore this Board took the view to abandon the scheme, and to consider alternatives as a part of the review of the Thanet Cycling Plan. Revised proposals for a permanent link 7. A revised permanent link was designed that attempted to deal with concerns raised in the original public consultation. This scheme is shown on Drawing No. 0004969/Y/1, and incorporates Option 1 for the route through the Vere Road coach and car park. It will cost approximately £40,000 to construct, and funding is currently available from the 2003-04 Thanet Urban Package. 8. A consultation document (attached as Appendix C) was sent out in March 2003 to 170 residents living on or close to the route of the cycle link, together with a questionnaire and an SAE for returning responses. These documents were also sent to local district and county members, as well as to a number of local organisations deemed to have an interest in this matter. In total, 64 completed questionnaires were received, representing a response rate of 34%. 9. Three questions were asked, relating to the three major changes to the route from the previous proposal. The questions were as follows: Question Reason for change from before Q1 Do you support the new footpath A contra-flow cycle lane in Lloyd through the Memorial Recreation Road and Lawn Road resulted in an Ground? unacceptable loss of on-street parking. Q2 Do you support widening the existing A contra-flow cycle lane in Lawn footway on the north side of Lawn Road Road resulted in an unacceptable for shared use by cyclists, between loss of on-street parking. Carlton Avenue and Vere Road? Q3 Do you support widening the existing The path was previously planned to footpath from Vere Road car park to be unsegregated, which lead to Alexandra Road, and segregating it for safety concerns being raised. use by pedestrians and cyclists? The response to these questions was as follows: Yes No Don’t know Q1 36 (56%) 26 (41%) 2 (3%) Q2 33 (52%) 29 (45%) 2 (3%) Q3 35 (55%) 28 (44%) 1 (1%) 1. It can be seen that the new route through the Memorial Recreation Ground has the strongest support amongst residents with 56% of respondents in favour, and is more popular than the contra- flow proposal, which in the previous consultation only attracted 44% support. 2. The new shared use path on the north side of Lawn Road has the least amount of support, with a slim majority of 52% of respondents in favour. It is therefore a slightly more popular option than a contra-flow cycle lane. However, only 30% of residents from Lawn Road who replied favour this shared path option. 3. The views of the public regarding the path through Culmer’s Field (adjacent to the allotments) have not changed a great deal, 55% of respondents now support its conversion to a cycle route, whereas previously 54% were in favour. 4. The following views were also received from non-resident consultees: Consultee Comment (brief summary) Response Broadstairs Recommends that the cycle route uses the High The route cannot use the High and St Peter’s Street. The Town Council has commissioned a Street unless cycle lanes are Town Council transport study by Babtie for the town centre; any introduced, which would result resultant traffic plan could incorporate this in a loss of all on-street parking. proposal. States that an area of land in Vere There is no mention of any Road car park has been earmarked for development for the Vere Road development. car park in the Local Plan. Kent County Not enough detail to give a formal response, Should the scheme proceed to Constabulary although this draft is more suitable than that detailed design, the Police will previously submitted. be consulted in due course. Ramblers Cyclists travelling at speed through the open Cyclists already use the path, Association space may create a hazard for walkers and the segregation is an attempt to should have a separate path. formalise the current situation. Thanet There is room for a short section of contra-flow Contra-flow cycle lanes require Cycling Forum cycle lane in Lawn Road where cyclists enter the protection by a refuge island at Memorial Rec. Rather than a shared use path in their commencement, which Lawn Road, there is room for a 1.5m contra-flow reduces the amount of lane, leaving 2.9m for vehicles. All in all a good carriageway width available. job that will compliment the recent installation of cycle lockers at the station. The Grave concerns over the suggested use of Lawn The terms under which Broadstairs Road and Culmer’s Field. The current temporary Culmer’s Field is administered Society route using the High Street should become needs to be rigorously permanent. examined if the scheme is to proceed. As previously discussed, the existing temporary route cannot remain permanent. Wheelchair These cycle routes have given wheelchair users New cycle paths can also Users Group access to areas that were previously dangerous benefit pedestrians as well as or impossible to get to – keep up the good work. cyclists. 1. Residents who were consulted were also given the opportunity to make specific comments. A summary of those with relevance to the proposals is attached as Appendix D. Conclusion 15. The revised scheme is more popular amongst residents than the previous proposal, however, a significant minority still remain opposed. 16. The scheme does not enjoy the support of either Broadstairs and St Peter’s Town Council or The Broadstairs Society, who would prefer to see the route use the High Street. For reasons previously discussed, this will not be possible without major changes to traffic management in the High Street. 17. The temporary signed route (High Street / Albion Street) is not suitable for an unsupervised 12 year old, which is the criteria required for any National or Regional Cycle Route. The temporary route was not intended to remain in use for the longer term. Therefore, if a permanent link cannot be agreed, the temporary link will have to be removed. This will leave Broadstairs as the only station in Thanet without a link, or the signs that are shown in Appendix A, and the opportunity to involve the town in this innovative tourism initiative will be lost. 18. As a result of the consultation, it has come to light that Culmer’s Field belongs to the Thanet Parochial Charities, who currently lease the land to Broadstairs and St Peter’s Town Council. Therefore, any further progress on the scheme is dependent upon their future co-operation. 19. Subject to the views of this Board, it is proposed to enter into further discussion with Broadstairs and St Peter’s Town Council, and the Thanet Parochial Charities, and then report back to the Board at the earliest opportunity. Accountable Officer – Steve Darling 01227 825362 Background documents : Appendix A: Photo examples of a railway station sign, and a motorcycle barrier that allows wheelchair access. Appendix B: Cycle tourism statistics. Appendix C: Public consultation document. Appendix D: Summary of additional comments of consultees. Drawing No: 0004969/Y/1 (on display). APPENDIX A: PHOTO EXAMPLES OF A RAILWAY STATION SIGN, AND A MOTOR CYCLE BARRIER THAT ALLOWS WHEELCHAIR ACCESS Fig. 1: Digitally created impression of how the platform station signs will appear at each of the Viking Coastal Trail Interchange points Fig.