The Birds of San Clemente Island
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
THE BIRDS OF SAN CLEMENTE ISLAND PAUL D. JORGENSEN, Wildlife and Natural ResourcesOffice, Staff Civil Engineer, Code 1843, NAS North Island, Bldg. 3, San Diego, California 92135 (present ad- dress:California Department of Parks and Recreation,3990 Old Town Ave., Suite 300-C, San Diego,CA 92110) HOWARD L. FERGUSON, 7009 Weller St., San Diego, CA 92122 Presentedhere is the firstcompilation of publishedand unpublishedinfor- mation on the birds of San Clemente Island since Howelrs 1917 account of the birds of the CaliforniaChannel Islands.The absenceof any published synthesisof recordssince that time clearlyinvites this update. The majorityof observationshave been made over the past 10 years by numerousre- searchers who visited the Island. The classicreasons for listingisland bird faunas have been amply explained by Jehl (1977) and DeSanteand Ainley (1980). But, San ClementeIsland presentsa specialcase because the statusof manybird species is expectedto changerapidly as feral animalsare removed.The Navy'scurrent attempts to removeall goats,pigs, cats and deer, if successful,will assuredlybring about drasticchanges to the Islandby reversingmore than a centurylong trend of habitat devastation. The information presented here will be helpful in measuringthe changes in the avifaunal and ecologicalconditions of the Island.We only wishthere were more data on conditionsprior to the arrival of exotic animals. ISLAND DESCRIPTION San Clemente Island (SCI) is the southernmostof the California Channel Islands,its center lying at about 32ø50'N latitude, 118ø30'W longitude (Figure 1). It is 103 km west-northwestof San Diego and 80 km south- southwestof San Pedro, the nearestmainland point. Santa Catalina Island, the closestland, is 34 km to the north. San Clemente Island is 34 km long, rangingfrom 2.4 km wide near the north end, to 6.4 km wide near the south end; its long axis runs approx- imatelynorthwest. The total land area of the Islandis approximately 150 km2 and its high point, called Mount Thirst, reaches599 m and lies near the centerof the Island.For conveniencethe steepnortheast side of the Islandis hereinreferred to as the "east"side and the gentlersloping southwest side as the "west" side. Most of the San Clemente Island coastlineis rugged and precipitous, especiallyon the eastside and at Seal Cove on the westside. Sandy beaches are few, the largestoccurring at the southern end of the Island at China Cove, Horse Beach Cove, and Pyramid Cove. Two large offshorerocks at the northern end of the Island are also of significanceto birds. Other smaller rock isletsare locatedalong the westernshore of the Islandparticularly be- tween Eel Point and Lost Point. Geologically,San ClementeIsland is describedas the upperpart of a tilted and gentlyarched block with a steepeast slope and a more gentlewest slope (Olinstead1958). It is principallycomposed of volcanicrocks of Miocene Western Birds 15:111-130, 1984 111 BIRDS OF SAN CLEMENTE ISLAND age.The 20 distinctwavecut terraces on the westside extend up to a levelof 450 m. The Islandis everywheredissected by deep, geologicallyyoung can- yons,those on the eastside dropping precipitously over 500 m to the sea. Apparently,the Islandhas never been connected to the mainland. San Clemente Island has a distinct maritime climate with cool summers and mild winters. Based on weather records since the 1940s, the mean an- nual temperatureis 16 ø C, with mean summertemperatures of 18 ø C, and mean wintertemperatures of I4 ø C. The averagedaily temperaturerange is approximately5 ø C. Freezingtemperatures are very rare. Occasionally, when SantaAna conditionsprevail in Augustthrough October, temperatures exceeding38 ø C havebeen recorded. Gale forcewinds are frequentin the higherregions of the Island,whereas at the northernairfield, the average wind speedfor all monthsis under 10 knots.The predominantwind direc- tion is from the west with short periods of northerly to easterly winds associatedwith Santa Ana conditions.Annual precipitationranges between 13 and 20 cm. The wettestmonths are November through March and the driestmonths from June through September. CURRENT VEGETATION Vegetationand floral accountsof San ClementeIsland and other Califor- nia Channel Islandshave been reviewed and discussedin severalpublica- tions (Dunkle 1950, Raven 1963, Axelrod 1967, Philbrick 1967, Thorne 1969, Philbrickand Hailer 1977, Ferguson1979, Brumbaugh1980, Power 1980, Sward and Cohen 1980). All authors mention the substantial deleteriouseffects that fetal animals,particularly sheep or goats,have had on the distribution,abundance, and conditionof the nativeplants. Virtually no reproductionof woody specieshas occurredin this centurybecause of fetal animal depredationupon their fruit and seeds. Bunchgrass,prickly-pear, cholla, and the lesscommon velvet-cactus are dominantnative species. In addition,much of the Islandis denselycovered by introduced Mediterranean annual grasses, e.g., Arena, Bromus, Hordeurn, Vuipia. Native shrubsand trees are essentiallyrestricted to the precipitouseastern canyons and cliffs,but may alsobe foundless frequently in most of the large westerncanyons. When comparedto the shrubcom- munitiesfound on the northernChannel Islands,San Clemente'sshrub com- munitiesare relativelydepauperate. San Clemente Island is unique among the CaliforniaChannel Islands becauseit harborsthe highestnumber of endemic plants--a total of 15 distinctivetaxa. In addition, 41 Channel Island endemicsare found there and the total known flora for San ClementeIsland is 331 taxa (Fergusonunpubl. ms.). At leastthree specieshave been extirpatedeither by man or introduced herbivores. Seven plant communitiesare found on San ClementeIsland. Dominant speciesoccurring in each communityare Avena barbata,Bromus sp., $tipa puichra (Grasslands);Lycium cali.•ornicum, Bergerocactus emoryii, Opuntia sp. (Maritime Desert Scrub); Quercus tomenteila, Lyonothamnusfloribun- dus (IslandWoodland); Malua ieprosa,$aisola iberica (Disturbed);Abronia sp., Ambrosiachamissonis, Astragalus miguelensis (Coastal Strand/Dunes); 112 BIRDS OF SAN CLEMENTE ISLAND Castle Rock VicinityMap •,•North HeadRock Active Air Field V•LosAngeles Wilson Cove / West Cove NOTS Pier SantaCatalina Old Air Field sanIsland,_C,l_e_m•ente SanDiego yon ? Eel Point Lemon Tank SealCove -•'• Mt. Thirst MailPoint Canyon Bryce Canyon N uito Cove ! China Canyon Lost Point 1 mile i Scale Pyramid China Point HorseBeach PyramidCove Canyon(Smugglers Cove) Figure1. Map of San ClementeIsland showing place names and the locationof the Islandon the California coast. 113 BIRDS OF SAN CLEMENTE ISLAND Artemisia nesiotica, A. cali}•ornica,Opuntia sp. (Maritime Sage Scrub); $alicornia subterminalis,Frankenia grandifolia, Distichlis spicata (Salt Marsh). The Grasslandcommunity, being the largest,covers approximately 45 % of the Island. Maritime Desert Scrub, Island Woodland and "Disturbed" areas are next in size covering approximately 35%, 7% and 5% of the Island, respectively.Coastal Strand/Dunes, Maritime Sage Scrub, and Salt Marsh cover 4%, 3%, and 0.2% of the Island (Fergusonunpubl. notes). MAN AND HIS IMPACT ON SCI VEGETATION Man modifiedthe Islandvegetation before botanists had visitedthe Island. We can thereforeonly speculateon the historicalor pristinecondition of the Islandflora. Unfortunately,goats were introducedto San ClementeIsland in the 1800s (Johnson1975). By 1883, there were 10,000 sheepon the Island (Doran 1980). Britton; in 1897, also noted the presenceof cattle on the Island (Doran 1980). Sheep grazingcontinued until 1934 when the San ClementeIsland Sheep and Wool Companylost its leaseand the Islandwas transferredto the Navy. Apparentlyall of the sheep were removed at that time, but the goats remained on the Island, their population unchecked. Their numbersincreased to a peak of 12,000 in the early 1970s. In 1972, the Navyinitiated a feralanimal removal program. By 1983 therewere fewer than 1000 goatsleft and it is hopedthat they willbe removedsoon. Deer and fetal pigswere introducedonto the Islandin the early 1950s for the sakeof sporthunting. Most, if not all, of theseanimals have alsobeen removed. Naval use has had various environmental effects on the Island. Numerous roadsand rifle rangeshave been constructed,a new airfieldwas built on the northern end of the Island in the early 1950s, and ship to shoregunnery practicedirectly impacts about 2% of the Island. Some idea of the Island'svegetation prior to the introductionof feral animalsmay be gainedfrom the notesof early botanists.William Lyon, who visitedthe south end of San Clemente Island in 1885, noted great dead masses of Dudleya (virens) which had formerly covered the ground throughout the entire Island (Raven 1963). Today Dudleya virens is restrictedto steep canyon walls and the lowest western terrace near Eel Point. Another report from about 1883 statesthat Lavatera assurgentifiora (California Tree-Mallow) "constitutedan unbroken forest, extending for milesupon the high plateaus"(Raven 1963). Today there are only a few Lavatera remaining. The drasticreduction of these two speciesserves as a powerful reminder of what the Island once looked like. The reductionof Lavatera probablyparallels that of many other plants, particularlywoody speciesfavored by goats,that were not adaptedto life on the cliffs--the one area out of reach of the exoticanimals. At leastthree Islandendemic plants have alreadybecome extinct. HISTORICAL REVIEW OF SAN CLEMENTE ISLAND AVlFAUNA Early accountsof the birdsof San Clemente Island beganwhen Cooper (1870)