SAPERE AUDE

Freedom and Responsibility

Stockholm, 25-29 April, 2017

Association of Schools of Political Studies of the Council of Europe

venue Skogshem & Wijk Hustegavägen 1 181 90 Lidingö, Sweden in collaboration with SITE (Stockholm Institute of Transition Economics) with support from The Council of Europe The Mott Foundation The Permanent Representation of the Netherlands to the Council of Europe We don’t receive wisdom; we must discover it for ourselves after a journey that no one can take for us or spare us.

Marcel Proust

2 / 3 Tuesday, 25 April

FREEDOM, ECONOMY AND RESPONSIBILITY

10.00–10.30 Opening ceremony: 17.00–18.30 Session: Lena Nemirovskaya Democratic Institutions Today: FOUNDER, MOSCOW SCHOOL OF CIVIC EDUCATION Crisis or Transformation?

Michael Sohlman Tatiana Vorozheikina CHAIRMAN OF THE SWEDISH INSTITUTE FOR FOREIGN POLICY; MEMBER OF THE ROYAL SWEDISH ACADEMY OF SCIENCES 18.30–18.45 Break

10.30–12.00 Session: World After Fact 18.45–19.30 Plenary: John Lloyd Anastasia Gontareva Alexander Shmelev 12.00–12.30 Coffee break Marina Skorikova

12.30–14.00 Session: 19.30 Dinner The European Economy in the age of Brexit and Trump Fredrik Erixon

14.00–15.00 Lunch Two things are important in life – purpose and meaning; however, citizenship and public welfare simply provide the necessary conditions 15.00–16.30 Session: for them. If one thinks about this properly, a modern civic society isn’t The Russian Economy: Challenges and the worst place we can live our lives in, as long as the will to improve Opportunities our way of life has not been extinguished. Torbjörn Becker 16.30–17.00 Coffee break Ralf Dahrendorf

4 / 5 Wednesday, 26 April Thursday, 27 April

THE FOUNDATIONS OF THE MODERN STATE POLITICS AND BEYOND

10.00–11.30 Session: 10.00–11.30 Session: Human rights, Democracy and The Rule of “Post-order” in the Head Law: The Role of the Council of Europe Andrey Kolesnikov Daniel Tarschys 11.30–12.00 Coffee break 11.30–12.00 Coffee break 12.00–13.30 Session: 12.00–13.30 Session: The Russian Word Pravda and its Meanings The Evolution of the Trial by Jury Maxim Trudolyubov Sergei Pashin 13.30–14.30 Lunch 13.30–14.30 Lunch 14.30–16.00 Session: 14.30–16.00 Session: Is a Reasonable Balance Between Democracy Reforms Needs and Nationalism at all Possible? Evgeny Gontmakher Vladislav Inozemtsev 16.00–16.30 Coffee break 16.00–16.30 Coffee break

16.30–18.30 Round table: 16.30–18.00 Session: Civilisation and Culture Populism and Liberalism Alexander Shmelev Charles Gati 19.00 Dinner 18.00–18.30 Coffee break

18.30–20.00 Session: The Russian Orthodox Church and Radical Russian Nationalism Nikolay Mitrokhin 20.00 Dinner

6 / 7 Friday, 28 April Saturday, 29 April

HISTORY FOR THE FUTURE CIVICS WITHOUT BORDERS

10.00–11.30 Session: 09.00–10.30 Session: Global Citizenship The Origins of Civics Elisabeth Eide Andrey Zakharov

11.30–12.00 Coffee break 10.30–11.00 Coffee break

12.00–13.30 Session: 11.00–12.30 Session: Sweden from 1917: The Welfare State and Global Civics Competitive Capitalism Hakan Altinay Gunnar Wetterberg 12.30–13.30 Lunch 13.30–14.30 Lunch 13.30–15.00 Session: 14.30–16.00 Session: Democratic Citizens and Politicians: Disparities 1917: February versus October in Experiences and Expectations Alexey Kara-Murza Lev Shlossberg

16.00–16.30 Coffee break 15.00–15.30 Coffee break 16.30–18.00 Session: 15.30–16.00 Closing Remarks Populism and Elitism: Lessons of Russian Yury Senokossov Revolutions of 1917 Emil Pain 16.00–16.30 Participants’ comments

18.00–18.30 Coffee break 21.00 Dinner

18.30–20.30 Round table: Rule of Law Alexander Shmelev 20.30 Dinner

8 / 9 John Lloyd Contributing Editor, The Financial Times Experts ()

Nikolay Mitrokhin Academic researcher, Research Centre (Russia) for East European Studies, Hakan Altinay Director, European School of Politics; University of Bremen (Turkey) President, Global Civics Academy Elena Nemirovskaya, OBE Founder, Moscow School of Civic Education Torbjörn Becker Director, Stockholm Institute of Transition (Russia) (Sweden) Economics Emil Pain General Director, Center for Elisabeth Eide Professor, Department of Journalism (Russia) Ethnopolitical and Regional Studies (Norway) and Media Studies, Oslo and (CEPRS) Akershus University College Sergei Pashin Professor, National Research University Fredrik Erixon Economist, Author; Director, European (Russia) Higher School of Economics; Member, (Sweden) Centre for International Political Economy Presidential Commission on Human (ECIPE) Rights and Civil Society Charles Gati Senior Research Professor of European Yury Senokossov Founder and Director of Publishing (USA) and Eurasian Studies, Johns Hopkins (Russia) Programmes, School of Civic Education School of Advanced International Studies Lev Shlossberg Chairman, Pskov regional branch; Anastasia Gontareva Project coordinator, Association of Schools (Russia) Member, Federal Political Committee (Russia) of Political Studies of the Council of of the Yabloko Political Party; Deputy, Europe Pskov Regional Assembly; Human Rights Evgeny Gontmakher Deputy Director, Institute of World Activist (Russia) Economy & International Relations, Alexander Shmelev Political Writer, Blogger Russian Academy of Sciences (Russia) Vladislav Inozemtsev Director, Centre for Post-Industrial Marina Skorikova Project Coordinator, Association of (Russia) Studies, Moscow (Russia) Schools of Political Studies of the Council of Alexey Kara-Murza Deputy, Department of Social and Europe (Russia) Political Philosophy, Institute of Michael Sohlman Chairman, Swedish Institute for Foreign Philosophy of the Russian Academy of (Sweden) Policy; Member, Royal Swedish Academy Sciences of Sciences; Executive Director, Nobel Andrey Kolesnikov Senior Associate and Chair, Carnegie Foundation (1992 to 2011) (Russia) Moscow Center’s Russian Domestic Politics and Political Institutions Program

10 / 11 Participants Daniel Tarschys Professor of Political Science, Stockholm (Sweden) University; Secretary General, Council of Europe (1994 - 1999) ARMENIA Maxim Trudolyubov Russia and Eastern Europe (Russia) Correspondent, Columnist, Vedomosti Arpine Asatryan Leading Expert, Finance and Economy Daily; Author and Chief Editor, The Division of the Administration Russia File, Kennan Institute; Department of the Government Columnist, The New York Times of Armenia Tatiana Vorozheikina Political Analyst Lilit Avagyan Leading Expert, Information Technology (Russia) and Special Systems Division of the Administration Department of the Gunnar Wetterberg Social Scientist, Historian, Author (Sweden) Government of Armenia Garegin Nadiryan Senior Expert, Administration Andrey Zakharov Editor, Neprikosnovennyi Zapas: Debates Department of the Government (Russia) on Politics and Culture Magazine of Armenia Margarita Poghosyan Section Head, Monitoring and Evaluation Department, Armenian Ministry for Sports and Youth Issues

BELARUS

Olga Gedranovich Senior Lecturer, Information Technology Chair, Minsk Innovation University Svyatoslav Kurilenko Expert, Liberal Club Non-Profit Organisation Yelena Novikova Manager, Social Weekend Social Project Competition Yunelya Salnikova Manager, Pact International Non-Profit Organisation

12 / 13 BULGARIA POLAND

Ivaylo Tihov Manager, Regional Government Olimpia Bronowicka Polish-Russian Cooperation Expert, The District of the City of Sofia Centre for Polish-Russian Dialogue and Understanding Igor Isayev Editor-in-Chief, PROstir.pl Web Portal GEORGIA for Ukrainians in Poland Olga Dorokhina Programme Manager, Georgian Katarzyna Kołakowska Coordinator, The Centre for Polish- Committee of the Helsinki Civil Russian Dialogue and Understanding Assembly Agnieszka Pikulicka- Editor, New Eastern Europe Wilczewska News Magazine

KAZAKHSTAN

Dmitry Mazorenko Journalist, Vlast.kz Internet Magazine RUSSIAN FEDERATION Sergey Alekseyev Historian, Researcher (Irkutsk Oblast) KYRGYZSTAN Grigory Bailo Chairman of the Board, Naslediye Elita Bakirova Freelance Journalist, Global Voices (Samara Oblast) (Heritage) Foundation Central Asia Non-Profit Project Pavlina Baldovskaya Information Manager, Rostov Association Ulan Usoyun Uulu Director, Kochmon – Nomad Public (Rostov Oblast) of Homeowner Companies Foundation Yulia Barlova Deputy Head, Human Rights (Yaroslavl Oblast) Commissioner Administration Magomed Bekov MONTENEGRO College Member, KavkazPro Expert Club (Ingushetia) Nihad Canovic Associate, Cabinet of the Parliament of Andrey Bystrov Assistant Professor, Theory and History Montenegro (Moscow) of Law Chair, Higher School of Economics Vladislav Dajkovic Activist, DEMOS Political Party Research Institute Ana Rasovic President of the Youth Forum, URA – Victor Dereza Editor, Details Department, Yuga.ru United Reform Action Political Party (Krasnodarsky Krai) Internet Portal

14 / 15 Maria Dubkova Coordinator, Vesna (Spring) Youth Andrey Linev History and Social Sciences Teacher, (St Petersburg) Democratic Movement, St Petersburg (Chelyabinsk Oblast) Secondary General Education School Ksenia Fadeyeva Volunteers Coordinator, Aleksey Navalny Svetlana Lobunova Volunteer, Activists School Project (Tomsk Oblast) Election Headquarters, Tyumen Oblast (Bryansk Oblast) Natalia Gaisak Social Sciences and Law Teacher, Pavel Luzin Senior Lecturer, Perm State National (Permsky Krai) Secondary General Education School No. 2 (Permsky Krai) Research University with In-Depth Humanities Studies Darya Manuylova Journalist, Valentin Manuylov Publishing (Penza Oblast) Sergey Gevorkyan Regional Department Chairman, House (Astrakhan Oblast) Yabloko Political Party Anna Medyukh Chief Expert, Yenisey TV Channel, Yana Goncharova Coordinator, RosUznik Volunteer (Krasnoyarsky Krai) Promotion Department (Rostov Oblast) Project Kira Meshcherina Junior Researcher, RAS Institute for Alexander Gurov Head, EKA-Ryazan Non-Profit (Volgograd Oblast) African Studies; Researcher, Laboratories (Ryazan Oblast) Organisation for the Monitoring of Social and Political Nikita Khabarov Masters Degree Student, Voronezh Destabilization Risks (Voronezh Oblast) State Pedagogical University Igor Mikhailov Practicing Lawyer Larisa Khomaiko Analyst, Siberian Centre, Transparency (Chuvash Republic) (Altaisky Krai) International – R Darya Nazarova Coordinator, Institute for Humanitarian Dmitry Kochetkov Deputy Editor-in-Chief, Karavan+Ya (Moscow) Research and Social Technologies (Tver Oblast) Weekly, Tver Region Non-Profit Organization Sergey Konovalov Journalist, Cameraman, Founder of Dmitry Pashnev Civic Activist (Tomsk Oblast) Independent Video Production Studio (Novosibirsk Oblast) Andrey Krivorotko Chairman, Bureau for Social and Cultural Vladimir Petrakov Director, F. S. Mackenzie Company, (Ryazan Oblast) Projects Non-Profit Organisation (Primorsky Krai) Vladivostok Branch Vasily Kustov Practicing Lawyer Anna Petrenko Journalist, Photo Reporter, Kofe (Tatarstan) (Bryansk Oblast) Ponedelnika (Monday Coffee) Newspaper Yevgeny Kuzmin Head, Kam24 Information Agency Yevgeny Potapov Elections Observer, Golos (Voice) (Kamchatski Krai) (Oryol Oblast) Association Valentina Kuzmina Chief Correspondent, Amur.info Irina Pys Sociologist, Social Projects Agency (Amur Oblast) Information Agency (Moscow Oblast)

16 / 17 Artur Ramazanov General Director, First Kaspian Yulia Tarkovskaya Live Broadcast Announcer, Artvis (Dagestan) TV Channel (Yaroslavl Oblast) Media Management Company Irina Rydanskaya Financial Advisor, Golden Hills Capital Anastasia Titova Chairperson, Party of Progress Political (Oryol Oblast) Investment Company (Krasnodarsky Krai) Party, Regional Branch Ruslan Sabirov Assistant, Prometheus Research Institute Tatiana Tokareva Director, Status Social Education Centre (Tatarstan) (Irkutsk Oblast)

Roman Sadykov Civil Activist Marina Tsurkan Associate Professor, Tver State (Tyumen Oblast) (Tver Oblast) University Ruzilya Sadykova Lawyer, Vasilchenko & Partners Company Dmitry Velikovsky Investigative Journalist, Novaya Gazeta (Tyumen Oblast) (Moscow) (New Gazette) Newspaper Oleg Savilov Individual Entrepreneur Olga Yefimkina Editor, AiF – Bryansk Internet Portal (Khakassia) (Smolensk Oblast)

Alexander Seleznev Managing Partner, Shprits, Seleznev and Idris Yusupov Correspondent, Novoye Delo (New (Yaroslavl Oblast) Partners College of Lawyers (Dagestan) Business) Dagestan General News Weekly Aleksey Shabanov Journalist, Special Correspondent, Yugra Ksenia Zheleznikova Author, Supervisor, Common Future (Khanty-Mansi TV and Radio Company (Volgograd Oblast) Projects Festival Autonomous District – Yugra) Yulia Zmanovskikh Chief Expert, Irkutsk Oblast Culture and Rimma Shabanova Deputy General Director, Telesem (Irkutsk Oblast) Archive Ministry, Department for (Ryazan Oblast) Journal Government Policy, Law, Information and Analysis Support Yevgeny Shprits Managing Partner, Lawyer, Shprits, (Yaroslavl Oblast) Seleznev and Partners College of Lawyers Victor Zyryanov Creator and Editor, Orlets Local History (Oryol Oblast) Social and Political Resource Veronika Shulgina Masters Degree Student, Public (Moscow) Activist, Higher School of Economics Research Institute Marina Smirnova Commissioning Editor, Vid Sboku (Side (Ryazan Oblast) View) Internet Newspaper Yelena Brintseva Associate Professor, Vadim Getman University of National Economy, Pavel Stepanyan Deputy Head, Public Environmental (Stavropolsky Krai) Control of Russia Company, Regional Oleg Derenyuga Editor-in-Chief, NikVesti TV Company Branch

18 / 19 Lesya Leshchenko Correspondent, Department of Politics, UNIAN Information Agency Notes Andrey Lokhmatov Correspondent, Prestupnosti.NET (Crime.NO) Internet Periodical Artem Nikolenko Board Member, Republic Political Party Katerina Sereda Commissioning Editor, NikVesti Newspaper Oksana Shchirba Programme Announcer, Voice of Kyiv Radio Station Roman Shirokikh Acting Director, Ukrainian Interregional Specialized Exchange

20 / 21 22 / 23 Enlightenment is man’s emergence from his self-imposed nonage. Nonage is the inability to use one’s own understanding without another’s guidance. This nonage is self-imposed if its cause lies not in lack of understanding but in indecision and lack of courage to use one’s own mind without another’s guidance. Sapere aude! “Have the courage to use your own understanding”, is therefore the motto of the enlightenment.

Immanuel Kant “Answering the Question: What Is Enlightenment?”