What to Make of Donald Trump’s Early-Morning ... http://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/donal...
NEWS DESK WHAT TO MAKE OF DONALD TRUMP’S EARLY-MORNING WIRETAP TWEETS
By David Remnick and Evan Osnos 11:22 A.M.
President Trump’s tweets exemplify a fairly basic but often highly effective rhetorical maneuver—the diversionary reverse accusation.
etween six and six-thirty this morning, the President of the B United States, who had returnedreturned to his Mar-a-Lago estate, in Florida, unleashed a series of tweets accusing his predecessor of tapping his phones just before Election Day: “� ��� ���!” “This is Nixon/Watergate. Bad (or sick) guy!” Two hours later, he tweeted again, this time about Arnold Schwarzenegger’s decision to leave “The New Celebrity Apprentice”: “Sad end to great show.”
The �rst meeting Jeff Sessions had with the Russian Amb was set up
1 of 12 03/04/2017 03:38 PM What to Make of Donald Trump’s Early-Morning ... http://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/donal...
by the Obama Administration under education program for 100 Ambs…… — Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) MarchMarch 4,4, 20172017
Terrible! Just found out that Obama had my “wires tapped” in Trump Tower just before the victory. Nothing found. This is McCarthyism! — Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) MarchMarch 4,4, 20172017
Just out: The same Russian Ambassador that met Jeff Sessions
2 of 12 03/04/2017 03:38 PM What to Make of Donald Trump’s Early-Morning ... http://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/donal...
visited the Obama White House 22 times, and 4 times last year alone. — Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) MarchMarch 4,4, 20172017
Is it legal for a sitting President to be “wire tapping” a race for president prior to an election? Turned down by court earlier. A NEW LOW! — Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) MarchMarch 4,4, 20172017
I’d bet a good lawyer could make a great case out of the fact that
3 of 12 03/04/2017 03:38 PM What to Make of Donald Trump’s Early-Morning ... http://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/donal...
President Obama was tapping my phones in October, just prior to Election! — Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) MarchMarch 4,4, 20172017
How low has President Obama gone to tapp my phones during the very sacred election process. This is Nixon/Watergate. Bad (or sick) guy! — Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) MarchMarch 4,4, 20172017
Arnold Schwarzenegger isn’t voluntarily leaving the Apprentice,
4 of 12 03/04/2017 03:38 PM What to Make of Donald Trump’s Early-Morning ... http://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/donal...
he was �red by his bad (pathetic) ratings, not by me. Sad end to great show — Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) MarchMarch 4,4, 20172017
Donald Trump’s early-morning Twitter binge unleashed, as he likely expected it would, a �urry of comments on the same medium, with his partisans echoing his rage at Barack Obama while many others questioned Trump’s motives, his integrity, and his mental stability.
Others pointedpointed toto articlesarticles postedposted onon BreitbartBreitbart as a possible inspiration; it would not be the �rst time that Trump has been moved to action by something published on Breitbart, the former home of his close adviser Steve Bannon. One of the articles is based on Senator Orrin Hatch’s remark about the wiretaps that led to the downfall of Michael Flynn as the national-security adviser. Another is based on Mark Levin, a conservative radio host, who recently accused Obama of “police state” tactics to carry out a “silent coup” against Trump.
One of President Trump’s most consistent rhetorical maneuvers is a fairly basic but often highly effective one—the diversionary reverse accusation. When he is accused of bene�tting from “fake
5 of 12 03/04/2017 03:38 PM What to Make of Donald Trump’s Early-Morning ... http://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/donal...
news,” he �ips the neologism on its head; suddenly CNN, the Times, and the rest are “fake news.” When Democratic politicians such as Chuck Schumer and Nancy Pelosi call for investigations of his campaign’s contacts with Russian officials, Trump posts pictures of those critics meeting publicly with Vladimir Putin and calls for an investigation. This happened on Saturday. He fogs the language and clouds the issue.
The stories on Breitbart appearappear toto bebe relatedrelated to the efforts of American intelligence and law-enforcement officials to investigate potential links between Trump aides and Russian officials. It would seem that Trump, in the same spirit of diversion, has con�ated the work of the courts, law enforcement, and intelligence agencies with “Obama.”
As Benjamin Rhodes, the former deputy national-security adviser under Obama, put it in a tweet on Saturday, the President is not authorized to order a wiretap.
No President can order a wiretap. Those restrictions were put in place to protect citizens from people like you. https://t.cohttps://t.co /lEVscjkzSw/lEVscjkzSw — Ben Rhodes (@brhodes) MarchMarch
6 of 12 03/04/2017 03:38 PM What to Make of Donald Trump’s Early-Morning ... http://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/donal...
4,4, 20172017
Ironically, the Obama Administration, after being informed that the Russian government was likely behind the hack of the Democratic National Committee and that the effort was intended to undermine Hillary Clinton, did not act more forcefully for fear of appearing to favor its own political party.
nd there is other news as well. Trump, who for years has A paid compliments to Putin’s strength and tactics, is expected to appoint as his main adviser on Russia Fiona Hill, a think-tank analyst who has described the Russian President as a gangster. Many members of the foreign-policy community in Washington are stunned. They wonder how Hill could take such a post when the Trump Administration is under scrutiny for its relations with Russian officials.
A dual citizen of the United States and the United Kingdom, Hill is a senior fellow at the Brookings Institution, in Washington, and between 2006 and 2009 served as a Russia analyst on the National Intelligence Council, a kind of intelligence think-tank independent of the C.I.A. Hill is the co-author, with Clifford G. Gaddy, of a political and psychological portrait of the Russian President titled “Mr.Mr. Putin:Putin: OperativeOperative inin thethe KremlinKremlin.” The book describes Putin’s system as a “protection racket” in which he views himself as the “CEO of Russia, Inc.” and is served by “crony oligarchs.” “In reality,” Hill and Gaddy write, “his leadership style is more like that of a ma�a family Don.”
7 of 12 03/04/2017 03:38 PM What to Make of Donald Trump’s Early-Morning ... http://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/donal...
Hill and Gaddy describe in detail Putin’s background as an intelligence officer and the methods used in the Russian secret services to discredit opponents. “Core individuals collect and amass detailed compromising material (kompromat in Russian) that can be used as leverage on every key �gure inside and outside of government,” they write.
A few weeks ago, we spoke with Hill, on the record, for an articlearticle about Russia and the Trump Administration. She in no way gave the impression that she was an admirer of Trump or shared his views on Russia. While Trump himself has derided the intelligence agencies and their conclusion that Putin directed an operation aimed at undermining the 2016 election and Clinton’s candidacy, Hill expressed no such doubt. She added, “They couldn’t have anticipated, whoever is doing this”—Russian military intelligence, Russian foreign intelligence—“whoever, they couldn’t have imagined how lucky they would be and come across the motherlode of information.”
“Are they trying to turn him into the Manchurian Candidate?” Hill went on. “The Russians didn’t invent him, but now they seem to create that impression. It was all intended to discredit Clinton and the electoral and party system. They wanted to amplify someone like Trump because what he says is music to their ears.”
When asked why Trump seemed so admiring of Putin, particularly his “strength,” Hill said, “I don’t want to suggest that Trump is emulating Putin. Trump is his own creation. But Putin, coming from the K.G.B., a lot of his skill set comes out of the K.G.B. playbook. His public messaging is right out of Lenin,
8 of 12 03/04/2017 03:38 PM What to Make of Donald Trump’s Early-Morning ... http://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/donal...
with slogans like ‘Land for the Peasants,’ and calling the Bolsheviks a majority when they were not. This is a skill set that Putin acquired. Trump knows how to play the media all on his own. He creates his own Twitter feed and uses it. He knows how to get the media’s attention without the bene�t of a state- controlled media. He does it all on his own. Trump understands how a free media works.”
Many Russian and American analysts now refer to the current state of U.S.-Russia relations as a kind of new Cold War; Hill gave the current state of affairs an even more alarming tag. “I think we are in a hot war with Russia, not a cold war,” she said. “But we have to be careful about the analogy. It’s a more complex world. There is no set-piece confrontation. This is no holds barred. The Cold War was a more disciplined competition, aside from the near blowups in Berlin and Cuba, where we walked back from the brink. The Kremlin now is willing to jump over the abyss. They want to play for the asymmetry. They see themselves in a period of hot kinetic war. Also, this is not just two-way superpower. There is China, the rising powers. I almost see it as like the great power competition from the time before the Second World War.”
Hill also said that the Russians, partly because they “have” Edward Snowden, in Moscow, possess “a good idea of what the U.S. is capable of knowing. They got all of his information. You can be damn well sure that [Snowden’s] information is theirs.”
In the think-tank and analytical world of Russian specialists in Washington, Hill has a solid reputation. Celeste Wallander, who was Obama’s leading adviser on Russia, said, “Fiona is a respected
9 of 12 03/04/2017 03:38 PM What to Make of Donald Trump’s Early-Morning ... http://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/donal...
analyst in the Washington Russia community, and she has been very tough and really hardheaded about who and what Putin is and about U.S.-Russian policy.”
And yet the general feeling in that same community is that Trump is not an ordinary Republican President—his comments about Putin are extraordinary, and so is the tumult in his Administration, particularly when it comes to its relations with Russia. Michael Flynn lost his job as the national-security adviser in less than a month because of his contacts with the Russian Ambassador, and others in the Trump circle—from Paul Manafort, Trump’s onetime campaign manager, to the Attorney General, Jeff Sessions, to Carter Page, a policy adviser during the race—are also being scrutinized. Some officials and analysts wonder if Hill is deluded in thinking, somehow, that she can play a positive and decisive role in a White House clouded by the prospect of congressional investigations and in�uenced so markedly by ideologues like Steve Bannon.
In late July, Hill wrote a column for VoxVox on why Putin might have wanted to interfere in the election. Her analysis was completely in line with consensus thinking. She concluded that Putin believed that the Obama Administration, and particularly Clinton, as Obama’s Secretary of State, had somehow been responsible for the anti-Kremlin demonstrations in 2011 and 2012 and that he wanted either to prevent Clinton from becoming President or, more likely, to do his best to weaken her. “A US president who is elected amid controversy and recrimination, reviled by a large segment of the electorate, and mired in domestic crises,” Hill wrote, “will be hard-pressed to forge a coherent foreign policy and challenge Russia.”
10 of 12 03/04/2017 03:38 PM What to Make of Donald Trump’s Early-Morning ... http://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/donal...
David Remnick has been editor of The New Yorker since 1998 and a staff writer since 1992.
Evan Osnos joined The New Yorker as a staff writer in 2008, and covers politics and foreign affairs.
MORE: DONALD TRUMP RUSSIA TWITTER VLADIMIR PUTIN JEFF SESSIONS
Sign up for the daily newsletter: The best of The New Yorker every day.
Go
Our bad! It looks like we're experiencing playback issues.
REFRESH
NEWS 1 / 7
The Youngest Elected A Hate Crime at How the Gun Industry
11 of 12 03/04/2017 03:38 PM What to Make of Donald Trump’s Early-Morning ... http://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/donal...
About
Our sites
© 2017 Condé Nast. All rights reserved. Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our user agreement (effective 1/2/2016) and privacy policy (effective 1/2/2016). Your California privacy rights. The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with prior written permission of Condé Nast.
12 of 12 03/04/2017 03:38 PM