Bedside Assessment of Right Atrial Pressure in Critically Ill Septic Patients Using Tissue Doppler Ultrasonography☆
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Journal of Critical Care 28 (2013) 1112.e1–1112.e5 Contents lists available at ScienceDirect Journal of Critical Care journal homepage: www.jccjournal.org Bedside assessment of right atrial pressure in critically ill septic patients using tissue Doppler ultrasonography☆ John E. Arbo, MD a,⁎, David M. Maslove, MD b, Anne-Sophie Beraud, MD c a Division of Emergency Medicine and Pulmonary Critical Care Medicine, Weill Cornell Medical College, New York Presbyterian Hospital, New York, NY b Department of Medicine, Division of Pulmonary and Critical Care Medicine, Stanford University Medical Center, Stanford, CA 94305 c Department of Medicine, Division of Cardiovascular Medicine, Stanford University Medical Center, Stanford, CA 94305 article info abstract Keywords: Purpose: Right atrial pressure (RAP) is considered a surrogate for right ventricular filling pressure or cardiac Tissue Doppler imaging preload. It is an important parameter for fluid management in patients with septic shock. It is commonly Right atrial pressure approximated by the central venous pressure (CVP) either invasively using a catheter placed in the superior Central venous pressure vena cava or by bedside ultrasound, in which the size and respiratory variations of the inferior vena cava (IVC) Sepsis are measured from the subcostal view. Doppler imaging of the tricuspid valve from the apical 4-chamber view Transthoracic echocardiography has been proposed as an alternative approach for the estimation of RAP. The tricuspid E/Ea ratio is measured, where E is the peak velocity of the early diastolic tricuspid inflow and Ea is the peak velocity of the early diastolic relaxation of the lateral tricuspid annulus. We hypothesized that the tricuspid E/Ea ratio may represent an alternative to IVC metrics, using invasive CVP as the criterion standard, for the assessment of RAP in critically ill septic patients. Materials and methods: A convenience sample of 30 septic patients, both mechanically ventilated and non– mechanically ventilated, was enrolled. Using a portable ultrasound system, maximum velocity of tricuspid E and Ea was measured from the apical 4-chamber view; and IVC diameter and degree of collapse were measured from the subcostal view. Decision tree induction was used to determine the performance of each model compared with invasive CVP. Results: Our results suggest that a tricuspid E/Ea ratio of greater than 4.7 can predict a CVP greater than 10 mm Hg in septic patients with sensitivity greater than 85% and specificity greater than 90%. Conclusions: In this pilot study, Doppler imaging of the tricuspid valve provided a valuable alternative for noninvasive bedside estimation of RAP in septic patients. © 2013 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved. 1. Background CVP in predicting fluid responsiveness, the guidelines suggest that a low CVP can be relied upon as supporting fluid responsiveness [3]. Right atrial pressure (RAP) is considered a surrogate for right Bedside ultrasound can easily be used to estimate CVP [4]. ventricular filling pressure or cardiac preload. It is commonly Noninvasive and repeatable, bedside ultrasound is of particular approximated with a catheter placed in the superior vena cava to value during early patient management, before the placement of a measure central venous pressure (CVP). Although single-point central venous catheter that permits the direct measure of CVP. estimates of CVP have not been shown to reliably correlate with Although central venous catheters are often ultimately required in fluid responsiveness, this measure continues to play a role in the septic patients to facilitate drug administration, bedside ultrasound management of septic patients [1,2]. Central venous pressure targets can minimize the need for early invasive procedures. Ultrasound are recommended in the most recent Surviving Sepsis guidelines for evaluation of the inferior vena cava (IVC) using the subcostal view is both the initial resuscitation of patients with septic shock and the the most common technique for the estimation of RAP [4–7]. In non– subsequent management of patients with sepsis-induced acute mechanically ventilated patients, an IVC diameter of less than 1.2 cm respiratory distress syndrome. While recognizing the limitations of with inspiratory collapse greater than 50% suggests inadequate filling pressures [7]. In some patients, the IVC cannot be visualized because of body ☆ Conflicts of interest: The manuscript is not under consideration elsewhere. None of habitus, recent surgical incisions, or other limitations to the subcostal the document’s contents have been previously published. None of the authors have view. An alternative approach for the estimation of RAP pressures has conflicts of interest relevant to the topic. been proposed using tissue Doppler imaging (TDI) of the tricuspid ⁎ Corresponding author. 455 East 14th #4B New York, NY 10009. – E-mail addresses: [email protected] (J.E. Arbo), [email protected] valve from the apical 4-chamber view [8 11]. Filling pressures are (D.M. Maslove), [email protected] (A.-S. Beraud). estimated using a tricuspid E/Ea ratio, where E is the peak velocity of 0883-9441/$ – see front matter © 2013 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jcrc.2013.08.008 Downloaded for Anonymous User (n/a) at Stanford University from ClinicalKey.com by Elsevier on March 02, 2018. For personal use only. No other uses without permission. Copyright ©2018. Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved. 1112.e2 J.E. Arbo et al. / Journal of Critical Care 28 (2013) 1112.e1–1112.e5 the early diastolic tricuspid inflow measured with pulse Doppler and care medicine fellow (JEA) with training in goal-directed echocardi- Ea is the peak velocity of the early diastolic relaxation of the lateral ography obtained all ultrasound data. With the critical care medicine tricuspid annulus measured using TDI. In early studies, this approach fellow, a cardiologist board-certified in echocardiography (ASB) and was shown to be accurate in both mechanically ventilated and non– blinded to CVP recordings reviewed the quality of all ultrasound mechanically ventilated patients [8,11]. images, verified tissue Doppler and IVC measurements, and semi- The goal of this pilot study was to investigate whether bedside quantitatively assessed right and left ventricular function [7]. echocardiography using the tricuspid E/Ea ratio could be a viable alternative to IVC metrics for the assessment of RAP in critically ill 2.4. Measurements septic patients using invasive CVP as the criterion standard. Tricuspid E and Ea were measured from the apical 4-chamber 2. Methodology view. The maximum velocity of the early tricuspid inflow (E) was measured using pulse Doppler with a 5-mm sample volume placed at 2.1. Inclusion criteria the tips of the tricuspid valve during diastole (Fig. 1). The maximum velocity of the early tricuspid annulus relaxation (Ea) was measured A convenience sample of critically ill septic patients was enrolled, using pulse TDI with a 3-mm sample placed on the lateral tricuspid depending on physician availability. Inclusion criteria were the annulus (Fig. 2). For all measurements, 5 to 10 cardiac cycles were presence of severe sepsis or septic shock, and a preexisting internal recorded using a sweep speed of 100 mm/s. Final values for E and Ea jugular or subclavian vein central venous catheter available for CVP were calculated by taking the average of all measures over 5 to 10 measurements. Sepsis was defined using the standard Surviving Sepsis cardiac cycles, representing at least 1 respiratory cycle. The IVC Campaigncriteria.Bothmechanicallyventilatedandnon–mechanically diameter and respiratory collapsibility were measured 2 to 3 cm ventilatedpatientswere included inthestudy. Theinstitution’s internal proximal to the atriocaval junction from the subcostal window. review board approved the study (Stanford University Medical Center IRB number 18358). Written informed consent was obtained from all 2.5. Statistical analysis patients or their designated representatives for publication of this original research and any accompanying images. We categorized the degree of IVC collapse as “none” (0%), “mild” (b50%), “moderate” (N50%), or “complete” (100%). For the purpose of 2.2. Exclusion criteria labeling the outcome of interest, we classified the CVP measurements as less than 10 mm Hg or at least 10 mm Hg. Patients with atrial dysrhythmias, atrioventricular block, ventric- To maximize the simplicity and interpretability of our model, we ular-paced rhythm, prosthetic tricuspid valves, or severe tricuspid chose to generate a decision tree to classify CVP as either less than 10 regurgitation were excluded from the study. mm Hg or at least 10 mm Hg based on E/Ea ratio. For comparison, we also created a decision tree based on IVC diameter and degree of 2.3. Data acquisition and evaluation collapse. The optimal cutoff values for IVC diameter and E/Ea were determined automatically during the process of decision tree After careful calibration of the central venous catheter pressure induction, in which all possible cutoff values are evaluated transducer, end-expiratory CVP was recorded at the patient’s bedside sequentially and the value providing optimal separation of classes at the time of the ultrasound examination. A portable ultrasound is selected. system (M-Turbo, SonoSite, Inc., Bothell, Wash) with a phased-array To determine the performance of each of these models, we next cardiac transducer was used for ultrasound examinations. A critical ran each of the observations through each of the decision trees and Fig. 1. E = maximum velocity of the early tricuspid inflow in centimeters per second. Downloaded for Anonymous User (n/a) at Stanford University from ClinicalKey.com by Elsevier on March 02, 2018. For personal use only. No other uses without permission. Copyright ©2018. Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved. J.E. Arbo et al. / Journal of Critical Care 28 (2013) 1112.e1–1112.e5 1112.e3 Fig. 2. Ea = maximum velocity of the early tricuspid relaxation in centimeters per second. compared the classification generated by the decision tree to the distributed among mechanically ventilated and non–mechanically actual measured value.