Congruent Management of Multiple Resources
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
PROCEEDINGS FROM THE WOOD COMPATIBILITY WORKSHOP INITIATIVE RESOURCES: CONGRUENT MANAGEMENT OF MULTIPLE United States Department of Agriculture CONGRUENT MANAGEMENT Forest Service OF MULTIPLE RESOURCES: Pacific Northwest Research Station PROCEEDINGS FROM THE General Technical Report PNW-GTR-563 WOOD COMPATIBILITY November 2002 INITIATIVE WORKSHOP Keynote papers • Aquatic studies • Scale issues • Silviculture studies • Nontimber forest products • Social/economic studies PNW-GTR-563 2002 PNW-GTR-563 EDITORS Adelaide C. Johnson is a hydrologist, Aquatic and Land Interactions Program, PNWResearch Station, Juneau, Alaska 99801; Richard W. Haynes and Robert A. Monserud are research foresters, Human and Natural Resources Interactions Program, PNWResearch Station, Portland, Oregon 97208. Technical editors include Mary Willox, Longmont, Colorado 80501; and Rachael Baker, Juneau, Alaska 99801 Cover design and graphic layout of proceedings: Jenny Beranek, Beaverton, Oregon 97006 Cover graphic/chapter heading graphic: Terry Inokuma, Philomath, Oregon Cover photo credit: Paul Hennon, PNW Research Station, Juneau, Alaska 99801 Papers were provided in camera-ready form for printing by the editors, who are therefore responsible for the content and accuracy. Opinions expressed may not necessarily reflect the position of the U.S. Department of Agriculture. The use of trade or firm names is for information only and does not imply endorsement by the U.S. Department of Agriculture of any product or service. CONGRUENT MANAGEMENT OF MULTIPLE RESOURCES: PROCEEDINGS FROM THE WOOD COMPATIBILITY INITIATIVE WORKSHOP Adelaide C. Johnson, Richard W. Haynes, and Robert A. Monserud, Editors Skamania Lodge Stevenson, Washington December 4-7th 2001 U.S. Department of Agriculture Forest Service Pacific Northwest Research Station Portland, Oregon General Technical Report PNW-GTR-563 November 2002 ABSTRACT Johnson, Adelaide C.; Haynes, Richard W.; Monserud, Robert A. eds. 2002. Congruent management of multiple resources: proceedings from the Wood Compatibility Initiative workshop. Gen. Tech. Rep. PNW-GTR-563. Portland, OR: U.S. Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, Pacific Northwest Research Station. 252 p. The Wood Compatibility Initiative (WCI) addresses options that may increase the compatibility between wood produc- tion and other societal values derived from forestlands. The set of 25 papers included in this proceedings presents the sum- maries of WCI-related research, compiled from a workshop held December 4-7th 2001 at the Skamania Lodge in Stevenson, Washington. The workshop proceedings papers are grouped into six general topics: 1) workshop keynote papers, 2) aquatic- related studies, 3) issues relating to scale, 4) silviculture studies, 5) nontimber forest products related research, and 6) social/ economic studies. These papers set the context for scientific and management inferences as well as illustrate the complex and diverse array of information needed in the development of land management strategies at different spatial scales. KEY WORDS: Forest management, societal values, wood production, tradeoffs, compatibility. ENGLISH/METRIC EQUIVALENTS When you know: Multiply by: To find: Meters (m) 3.28 Feet Square meters (m2) 10.8 Square feet Centimeters (cm) 2.54 Inches Hectares (ha) 2.47 Acres Kilometers (km) .62 Miles Kilogram (kg) 2.205 Pounds Feet (ft) .305 Meters Square feet (ft2) .093 Square meters Inches (in) .394 Centimeters Acres .405 Hectares Mile 1.609 Kilometers Pounds (lbs) .454 Kilograms Proceedings from the Wood Compatibility Initiative Workshop CONTENTS 1. Emergent Results from the Wood Compatibility Initiative Richard W. Haynes, Robert A. Monserud, and Adelaide C. Johnson 1 A. KEYNOTE PAPERS 2. Challenges to Integrating Wood Production Biodiversity, and Other Socioeconomic Values at Broad Scales: an Example from Coastal Oregon 13 Thomas A. Spies, K. Norman Johnson, Pete Bettinger, William C. McComb, Janet L. Ohmann, and Gordon H. Reeves 3. Effects of Streamside Forest Management on the Composition and Abundance of Stream and Riparian Fauna of the Olympic Peninsula 27 Martin G. Raphael, Peter A. Bisson, Lawrence L.C. Jones, and Alex D. Foster 4. Socioeconomic Factors Influencing Land Use and Management Changes in the Pacific Northwest 41 Ralph J. Alig and Jeffrey D. Kline 5. Mixed Alder-Conifer Forests: Managing Upland Ecosystems in Southeast Alaska for Wood Products, Wildlife, and Fish 51 Paul Hennon, Mark Wipfli, Robert Deal, Adelaide Johnson, Toni De Santo, Mark Schultz, Tom Hanley, Ewa Orlikowska, Gomi Takashi, Mason Bryant, and Rick Edwards B. AQUATIC STUDIES 6. Influence of Site and Landscape Features on Vertebrate Assemblages in Small Streams 61 Peter A. Bisson, Martin G. Raphael, Alex D. Foster, and Lawrence L.C. Jones 7. A Survey of Research on Riparian Responses to Silviculture 73 Patrick G. Cunningham 8. Riparian Buffers and Thinning Design in Western Oregon Headwaters Accomplish Multiple Resource Objectives 81 Deanna H. Olson, Samuel S. Chan, and Charles R. Thompson 9. Research on Streamside Issues Through the Wood Compatibility Initiative 93 Susan Bolton and Cara Berman 10. Physical and Chemical Processes in Headwater Channels with Red Alder 101 Adelaide C. Johnson and Richard T. Edwards C. SCALE ISSUES 11. An Evaluation of Tradeoffs Between Wood Production and Ecological Integrity in the Oregon Coast Range 111 Thomas A. Spies, K. Norman Johnson, Gordon Reeves, Pete Bettinger, Michael T. McGrath, Robert Pabst, Kelly Burnett, and Keith Olsen 12. Framing the Discussion of Future Forestry in the Pacific Northwest 121 Fred J. Swanson, John H. Cissel, Deana D. Pennington, and Julia A. Jones 13. Development of Mixed Red Alder-Conifer Stands in Southeast Alaska 127 Robert L. Deal and Ewa H. Orlikowska D. SILVICULTURE STUDIES 14. Do Large Trees Always Have Higher Wood Product Value? 135 R. James Barbour, David D. Marshall, Dean L. Parry, and Glenn Christensen 15. Stem Characteristics and Wood Properties: Essential Considerations in Sustainable Multipurpose Forestry Regimes 145 David D. Marshall and Dean S. DeBell 16. How Adaptable are Forest Growth Models For Simulating Alternative Silvicultures in the Northwest? 151 Robert A. Monserud and Andrew P. Robinson 17. Factors Influencing Growth and Flowering of Understory Plants in Conifer Stands in Western Washington 159 Constance A. Harrington, Karl R. Buermeyer, Leslie Chandler Brodie, and Bryan W. Wender 18. Compatibility of Breeding for Increased Wood Production and Long-term Sustainability: the Genetic Variation of Seed Orchard Seed and Associated Risks 169 Randy Johnson and Sara Lipow E. NONTIMBER FOREST PRODUCTS 19. Assessment of Western Oregon Forest Inventory for Evaluating Commercially Important Understory Plants 183 Nan Vance, Andrew Gray, and Bob Haberman 20. Assessing Commercial Understory Species: Quantity, Quality, Supply and Demand 191 Becky K. Kerns, Susan J. Alexander, David Pilz, and Leon H. Liegel 21. Silvishrooms: Predicting Edible Ectomycorrhizal Mushroom Productivity 199 David Pilz, Randy Molina, Eric Danell, Richard Waring, Catherine Rose, Susan Alexander, Daniel Luoma, Kermit Cromack, and Charles Lefevre 22. Involving Stakeholder Communities in Research on Nontimber Forest Products 209 Roger D. Fight, Ellen M. Donoghue, and Harriet H. Christensen F. SOCIAL/ECONOMIC STUDIES 23. Logic Models as Frameworks for Thinking about Compatibility 215 Keith M. Reynolds 24. Compatibility of Timber and Conservation: Tracing the Tradeoff Frontier 225 Claire A. Montgomery 25. Assessing Temporal Trends in Forest Inventory and Analysis Data: Applications to Criteria and Indicators 233 Joseph A. Donnegan 26. Social Acceptability of Natural Resource Decision-making Processes 245 Keith M. Reynolds Proceedings from the Wood Compatibility Initiative Workshop, number 1. EMERGENT RESULTS FROM THE WOOD COMPATIBILITY INITIATIVE Richard W. Haynes1, Robert A. Monserud2, and Adelaide Johnson3 ABSTRACT The Wood Compatibility Initiative (WCI) was stimulated by the public debate over forest management, which often por- trayed management choices as involving tradeoffs between biophysical and socioeconomic components of ecosystems. Its purpose is to expand information on the options that may increase the compatibility between wood production and other societal values derived from forestlands. The WCI addresses two aspects of the compatibility issue. First, how can various forest management practices be related to an array of associated goods and services? Second, how can the effects of differ- ent approaches to forest management be derived across relatively large and complex ecosystems? The goal is to enable a richer public dialogue about the ability of land management options to produce timber, nontimber forest products, fish, and wildlife. KEY WORDS: Forest management, forest production, tradeoffs, compatibility. INTRODUCTION Considered in aggregate at the regional scale, compatible wood production increases the overall level of some forest The Pacific Northwest (PNW) Research Station has a value(s) without decreasing others. The goal is to remove 75-year tradition of discovery in forest and range research forest management from the divisive arena of either or (see Duncan 2000 for details). Since 1998, scientists at the choices. PNW Research Station have been engaged in an effort called the Wood Compatibility Initiative (WCI) to develop The WCI addresses two aspects of the compatibility a greater understanding of potential compatibility among issue. First, how can various forest management