SOCIAL SCIENCES & HUMANITIES Phenomenon of Transsexual
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by Universiti Putra Malaysia Institutional Repository Pertanika J. Soc. Sci. & Hum. 21 (S): 109 - 122 (2013) SOCIAL SCIENCES & HUMANITIES Journal homepage: http://www.pertanika.upm.edu.my/ Phenomenon of Transsexual Behaviour Among Youth in Kuala Lumpur: A Case Study Mohd Roslan Rosnon*, Mohamad Naqiuddin Dahamat Azam and Mohd Najmi Daud Faculty of Human Ecology, University Putra Malaysia, 43400 Serdang, Selangor, Malaysia ABSTRACT Understanding the complex lives of transsexual groups is essential in order to resolve this issue in a more intellectual, systematic and effective manner. Thus, this case study was aimed at knowing more about male-to-female transsexuals, especially among youth, by studying their sexual orientation as well as how far a sense of femininity is felt by them. Eight transsexual women were the informants recruited for this study based on snowball sampling technique. Each informant had completed a semi-structured interview at least twice. The basis of the interview was the principle of saturation in which the informants had been interviewed until no new ideas were emerging. The interview was audio-taped, transcribed verbatim and checked for content based on thematic analysis technique. The findings revealed two important themes from the narrative of the informants, namely, their gender identification and sexual orientation. In terms of gender identification, it was found that all the informants identified themselves according to feminine features although the features did not match their own physical features. Meanwhile, in terms of sexual orientation, the results showed that this group of transsexuals preferred to engage in sexual activities. For them, sexual satisfaction was only achievable by engaging in such sexual activities because of their sexual instinct, which was similar to that of women. One implication of this feature would be a potential rise in social problems. Thus, all parties should cooperate to combat this issue aggressively and effectively. Keywords: Transsexual behaviour, transsexual, youth, Kuala Lumpur INTRODUCTION ARTICLE INFO Article history: Due to the evolution and advancement Received: 21 May 2012 Accepted: 18 January 2013 of various aspects of life as well as the E-mail address: challenges of globalisation that continue [email protected] (Mohd Roslan Rosnon) * Corresponding author to advance, the tendency of some youth ISSN: 0128-7702 © Universiti Putra Malaysia Press Mohd Roslan Rosnon, Mohamad Naqiuddin Dahamat Azam and Mohd Najmi Daud in getting caught up in comfort zones has There is a lot of opposition from various caused them to be pulled into self-inflicted quarters on on-going claims made by damage and downfall, leading to their the LGBT group that they were creating getting trapped in perturbing social maladies an environment of sexual freedom in such as drug addiction, alcoholism and this country and that they felt that their hedonism that prevent them from taking action was proper and not against the law. up the responsibilities that await them. In However, in multicultural Malaysia, this more extreme situations, they engage in acts issue is strictly contrary to the values, of crime. Statistics by the Social Welfare morals and culture; furthermore, this does Department of Malaysia show that a total of not only involve Malaysian culture but other 4407 youth aged between 16 and 21 years eastern cultures as well. Clearly, this is an were involved in several types of crime such important issue that needs further and deeper as drug possession, vandalism, gangsterism, analysis in order to provide an adequate rape and others (Social Welfare Department overview and explanation of this social of Malaysia, 2012a). However, the number problem. Hence, this study focusses on one of cases in 2011 showed some increase component of LGBT i.e. the transgender or from the year before with 745 cases (Social transsexual. Welfare Department of Malaysia, 2012b). Essentially, activity among male youth Recently, the phenomenon of alternative transsexuals is known and judged from sexual behaviour, orientation and lifestyle various angles. Some of these are based on the termed lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender characteristics portrayed by the male youth (LGBT) behaviour has become increasingly transsexuals, such as their self-image, the visible among Malaysian youth, raising way they dress, behaviour that is conflicting serious issues related to religion, morality to their gender as well as the way they think, and ethics. The promotion of the LGBT which is inconsistent with the cognitive community through the Seksualiti Merdeka development of a male (Nevid, Rathus & (Sexuality Independence) programme Green, 2008). In Malaysia, men involved in in 2012 became the talk of the town and transsexual activities are popularly referred a hot topic in the newspapers and other to as transsexuals or ‘Mak Nyah’1. Viewed mass media. The National Fatwa Council, through the lens of Malaysian culture, the a prominent Islamic council in Malaysia, activities by these transsexuals are labelled banned the LGBT community and Seksualiti an unhealthy and improper phenomenon in Merdeka programme and declared those Malaysia as they go against the norms of the organisations as illicit (e-Fatwa, 2012), local communities (Teh, 2001). Similarly, while several non-government organisations religious figures and groups view them (NGOs) and a Member of Parliament as acts of sin that violate religious codes suggested that the government categorise 1Mak Nyah: Man who has undergone surgery to remove his genital organs or has undergone a sex- the LGBT activities as illegal in Malaysia change procedure; How transsexuals in Malaysia (Utusan, 2012). address themselves 110 Pertanika J. Soc. Sci. & Hum. 21 (S): 109 - 122 (2013) Phenomenon of Transsexual Behaviour Among Youth in Kuala Lumpur: A Case Study of conduct. However, for most Western personality and character of an individual. societies, the concept and activities of Society considers such a moral crisis a transsexuals are acceptable and tolerable. major setback as morals are the core and The clash between the two cultures with foundation of a human civilization (Mat regards to LBGT behaviour has caused a Saat Baki, 1993). The rise and downfall major impact in judging and determining of a society depends on the morals and whether these transsexual activities conform conduct of its people. Duly, society today to convention or otherwise (Abdul Aziz, does realise the need to resolve this crisis 2002) within the Malaysian context. of transsexual behaviour among male youth In Malaysia, transsexual behaviour or ‘Mak Nyah’. These youth should not be exhibited by male youths received treated like a disregarded minority as they much attention in the early years that are unable to solve the problem themselves. such behaviour became apparent among If the problem is left unresolved, it will give Malaysian youth. It grew into a more rise to a greater moral crisis. serious issue when a significant number of The experience of transsexual transsexuals began to be notice in higher- tendencies within the male population is learning institutes across Malaysia (Suriati, often described in this way: “A woman’s Jabil & Azilah, 2011; Rohana & Zulkifli, mind trapped in a man’s body” (Abdul Aziz, 2001). Extensive coverage and serious 2002; Aminuddin & Johan, 2002; Rohana attention given by various parties have & Zulkifli, 2001; Azam Beruntung, 2001; exposed transsexuals, particularly those Ahmad Amin, 1995; Wan Azmi, 1991; Wan in higher learning institutes, to various Halim, 1987). The expression, ‘a woman’s negative implications. They have repeatedly mind trapped in a man’s body’ implies received negative reactions whether through that transsexuals or Mak Nyah possess the gesture or word by other students who identity, feelings and sexual behaviour of a consider them the cause of various problems, woman. This assumption to some extent has particularly moral issues (Abdul Aziz, caused some uneasiness in the community, 2002). Moreover, these transsexuals are also resulting in feelings of prejudice against pressured by the university authorities with Mak Nyah, and the resulting ill effect is rules and regulations that limit their freedom discrimination against transsexuals, both to express themselves. One of the rules that from the authorities and members of society limit their freedom is the dress code or the itself (Azam Beruntung, 2001). The dilemma freedom to dress on campus (Aminuddin & of transsexuals or any other problems that Johan, 2002). they may face are often ridiculed and According to Aminuddin and Johan made light of; similarly their feelings are (2002), on the issue of transsexuals among toyed with (Mat Saat Baki, 1993). No one male youth, society sees the phenomenon wants to understand or believe what they as a moral setback, as it involves the are experiencing, as if what they were Pertanika J. Soc. Sci. & Hum. 21 (S): 109 - 122 (2013) 111 Mohd Roslan Rosnon, Mohamad Naqiuddin Dahamat Azam and Mohd Najmi Daud experiencing was all fantasy (Wan Azmi, refers to someone who is known to suffer 1991). Society considers this minority group from psychological gender disorders and ‘immoral’ as the behaviour of individuals practices the lifestyle of the opposite sex in the group are deemed inappropriate by after undergoing surgery or hormonal and often upset the majority (Aminuddin & therapy