Journal of Critical Reviews

ISSN- 2394-5125 Vol 7, Issue 12, 2020

PHONETIC FEATURES OF THE KALMYK AND OIRAT OF WEST

1S.M. Trofimova, 2T.M. Kekeeva, 3T.Z. Kekeeva, 4L.A. Nikitina, 5D.N. Ovraeva

Kalmyk State University named after B.B. Gorodovikov, , E-mail: [email protected]

Received: 10.03.2020 Revised: 11.04.2020 Accepted: 12.05.2020

Abstract The purpose of the article. By comparing the elements of phonetic systems of the modern Kalmyk and the of West Mongolia, the authors aim to identify in these languages the pan-Oirat areal features, the specific phonetic characteristics that were formed during the hundreds of years of independent development in the Kalmyk language and the Oirat language of West Mongolia and preserved through the historical development. The solution to this task may provide the research basis for the future development of issues of historical grammar. Scientific novelty. The comparison of language contacts of in West Mongolia and living in Russia. The expansion of Oirats over large areas and continuous language contacts must have led to the development of differences in the languages of Oirats in West Mongolia and Kalmyks in . There are new opportunities to compare the identical variants in different contact situations, which allows one to assess the importance of such factors as the structural similarity on the phonetic level of the contacting languages. As a result, the prerequisites will be formed for the creation of historical grammar of the Mongolian protolanguage. This research topic is unique in global Mongolian studies. Results. The study of the Kalmyk language and the Oirat language of West Mongolia has indicated that during the four centuries of independent development, the Kalmyk language has remained practically unchanged within one of its main levels – phonetic and is almost similar to the Oirat language area formed in the ancient times. Conclusions. The phonetic structure of the modern Kalmyk language has remained practically unchanged and retains the features of the Oirat language area.

Keywords: phonetic interference, Kalmyk language, language of West Mongolia Oirats, old , long vowels, vowel fracture.

© 2020 by Advance Scientific Research. This is an open-access article under the CC BY license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.31838/jcr.07.12.94

INTRODUCTION Thus, the Oirats are currently divided into four groups that are There are no languages that have not experienced the in contact with different languages. influence of other languages during their historical development. The ancestors of the Kalmyk and Mongolian Among the linguistic contacts of the Oirats, the most ancient Oirat native speakers form the northwestern area of Mongolic are contacts with the and the most languages and, localizing in , blend with the Turkic significant for the modern condition are with Russian (for tribes that used to live there, forming the group of the proto- Kalmyk) and Khalkha-Mongol (for Oirats of Western Mongolic tribes. Historians named this group of tribes shiwei Mongolia). To establish how deep the influence of the Russian and it was subsequently divided into three large ethnic groups language on the modern Kalmyk language is and to – Oirats, and Khalkhas. By the time when Genghis understand how it differs in structure from the Oirat language 's empire was formed, Oirats had not yet become a nation of Western Mongolia, it is necessary to compare the results of and were part of different tribes. However, every Oirat tribe the development of the modern Kalmyk language with the had its own language, which had specific and pan-Oirat features of the Oirat language of Western Mongolia developing characteristics. After the fall of the Yuan empire, Oirats were under Khalkha-Mongolian influence. In this case, it will be temporarily united within the Dzungar . Defeated by possible to confirm which features appeared as a result of the Manchus, they were partially destroyed and partially contact influences (and distinguish the Kalmyk language from scattered across the territories of different states. Some of the other Oirat languages) and which are part of the internal Oirats migrated from the region of East to the development of the system. These results are important for steppes, forming the , which included comparative historical linguistics in general and the theory of Dörbets, , and some other Oirat tribes. linguistic changes. There they subsequently took Russian citizenship and became The article involves the analysis of language contacts of the part of the . For over 400 years, Kalmyks have Kalmyk language and the Oirat language of Mongolia on the experienced an increasing influence from the phonetic level if they occur. By comparing the elements of the and culture on their language and ethnic culture. Another part phonetic structure of the modern Kalmyk of the Oirats, consisting of the same Dörbets, Torghuts, and the Oirat language of West Mongolia, we will attempt to Khoshuts, as well as Myangads, Olots, Baits, Zakhchins and identify the pan-Oirat areal features and the specific phonetic other tribes, continued to remain in the territory of characteristics in the modern Kalmyk language in the process northwestern Mongolia and was strongly influenced by the of its historical development, as well as to define the Khalkha language and culture. distinctive features of the Kalmyk language and its features Some of the Oirats were moved to where they that were formed in its development. According to L.V. experienced a strong influence of the language and culture of Shcherba's fair observation, "the world that has been given to the local Turks, and , as well as the Chinese. A us in our direct experience, while remaining the same small part of the Oirats who lived in Xinjiang converted to everywhere, is cognized differently in different languages, and was forced to to the region of Issyk-Kul including those spoken by peoples that form a unity from the Lake where they still live. These Oirats, called Sart Kalmyks, cultural point of view" [1, p. 49]. This article was based on the can now be said to have lost their language and culture and particular materials from the modern Kalmyk language, the have become completely Kyrgyz, switching to their language. Oirat language of West Mongolia, the data from the old Mongolian language was also used. All this is because the Oirat language of West Mongolia and the Kalmyk language have the

Journal of critical reviews 519

PHONETIC FEATURES OF THE KALMYK AND OIRAT LANGUAGES OF WEST MONGOLIA

same proto-language – the language of the Shiwei-, shanaga from the old Mong. ǯinaγ-а "ladle", Kalm. махн makhn, according to V.I. Rassadin, "the common northwestern branch Oir. махн makhn from the old Mong. miqan "meat", Kalm. of old Mongolian languages which separated from the зурhан zurqan, Oir. зургаан zurqaan from the old Mong. northeastern and southern branches quite early" [2, p. 5]. ǯirγuγan "six". METHODS To achieve the goal set in the article, one must The short vowel *о (о) of the non-palatalized row remains in comprehensively use the following well-proven scientific its initial form in most cases, for example, Kalm. ботхн botkhn, methods and approaches: description, interpretation, Oir. ботхан botkhan from the old Mong. botuγun "young integration, the comparative-contrastive method and the giraffe", Kalm. orn орн, Oir. орон oron from the old Mong. orun comparative-historical method. As are not "bed", Kalm. товч tovch, Oir. тобчи tobchi from the old Mong. equally well explored and described and some of them are still tobči "button", Kalm. толhа tolqa, Oir. толгаа tolqaa from the almost unknown to science, the descriptive method of old Mong. toluγai "head" or due to the vowel fracture of *ï,for studying Mongolic languages remains relevant. The need for example, Kalm. җола jola, Oir. jolaa from the old Mong. ǯiluγ-a descriptive studies does not subside within Mongolic studies. "reins", Kalm., Oir. Чон chon from the old Mong. činua "wolf". At the same time, it is important to note that the old The short vowel *у (и) of the non-palatalized row also Mongolian, Buryat and Kalmyk languages have already been preserves its initial form. For example, Kalm. утцн utzn, Oir. described relatively thoroughly which will make it possible to утсан utsan from the old Mong. utasun "thread", Kalm. урл url, start the comparative-historical studies of linguistic elements Oir. урул urul from the old Mong. uruγul "reins", Kalm. хумсн and prepare the basis for the creation of historical grammars khumsn, Oir. хумсун khumsun from the old Mong. qumsun of these languages. "nail". The vowel а appeared in the first syllable instead of *i The Kalmyk language materials used were the published due to the vowel fracture. For example, Kalm. утх utq, Oir. dictionaries [3], grammars [4, 5], monographs [6, 7, 8], утга utga from the old Mong. qituγ-a "knife", Kalm. нурhн research articles studying the phonetic structure of the nurqn, Oir. нургн nurgn from the old Mong. niruγun "back", modern Kalmyk language [9, 10], as well as our personal Kalm. цусн tsusn, Oir. цусн tsusn from the old Mong. čisun. observations of the colloquial Kalmyk speech. The Oirat The vowel *ы (ï) of the non-palatalized row in the first syllable materials were taken from the Oirat dictionary in the modern Kalmyk language and the Oirat language of compiled by Zh. Tsoloo [11], dialectological notes, prepared by West Mongolia, according to V.I. Rassadin, "was not preserved Professor V.I. Rassadin in 2007 and 2009 during the trips to and was transformed either into other vowels of the non- West Mongolia, as well as personal observations. palatalized row due to vowel fracture <…> or became the palatalized front i which often occurs in the Kalmyk and Oirat RESULTS AND DISCUSSION languages. Words of the non-palatalized row often become The study of the system of sounds of the modern Kalmyk palatalized in this case" [2, p. 10]. For example, Kalm. ширдг language and phonetic structure of the Oirat language of West shirdg, Oir. ширдг shirdg from the old Mong. širdeg, Kalm. Mongolia yielded the following results. First, one should note шивр shivr, Oir. шивр from the old Mong. šiberi, Kalm. чикн that there are no phonetic differences between these chikn, Oir. чикн chikn from the old Mong. čikin, Kalm. шил shil, languages and, according to V.I. Rassadin, "the modern Kalmyk Oir. шил shil from the old Mong. šil, Kalm. шин shin, Oir. шин language and the Oirat of West Mongolia preserve shin from the old Mong. šin-e. similar phonetic traits, although the native speakers of these languages have been separated by vast spaces for 400 years" In the modern Kalmyk language and the Oirat language of [2, p. 7; 12-15]. West Mongolia, short vowels such as е, æ, ö, ü, i are used in the words of the palatalized row with full articulation. There are three types of vowel sounds in the Kalmyk language and the Oirat language of West Mongolia according to It is worth noting that the vowel æ is not present in proto- pronunciation: short vowels а, о, ö, e, æ, u, ü, ï, i, long vowels Mongolic, Khalkha and Buryat. This is a specific vowel that is аа, оо, uu, ee, ææ, öö, üü, ii, diphthongs – ïi, ii, ai, oi, ui, üi. Short typical only of the vowel system of the Kalmyk language and vowels are represented by single letters (а, о, u, e, etc.), long the Oirat language of West Mongolia. According to V.I. vowels are represented by two letters (аа, оо, uu, etc.) and Rassadin, "it (æ) developed in the Oirat language area in place diphthongs are represented by two different letters (ïi, ii, ai, oi, of the vowel *а from the non-palatalized row under the ui, üi). Short vowels are pronounced quickly, abruptly. Long influence of the vowel *i<*ï in the second syllable of proto- vowels are pronounced in a drawn-out manner, smoothly. Mongolic words due to assimilative processes <…> The Diphthongs are pronounced with two different sounds joined presence of the vowel æ is the distinctive feature of the vowel into one. The distinction between long and short vowels is one system of the Kalmyk and Oirat languages. For example, Kalm., of the essential principles of the phonetics of the Kalmyk Oir. bærkh, kh.-Mong. barikh "grab, catch" (< old Mong. bariqu language. This principle runs through the entire language. id.); Kalm., Oir. khærkh, kh.-Mong. kharih "come home (< old Mong. qariqu id)" [2, p. 11]. Examples: Kalm. khæ:sн, Oir. It is worth noting that short vowels *а (а), *о (о), *у (и), *ы (ï) khæ:sн from the old Mong. qaysun "cauldron", Kalm. khæ:сh, have been partially preserved and partially changed both in Oir. khæ:сh from the old Mong. qayuči "scissors", Kalm. khæ:ng, the Kalmyk language and the Oirat language of Mongolia. Oir. khæ:nag from the old Mong. qayunuγ "hybrid of yak and The vowel *а (а) of the non-palatalized row remains in the cow". first syllables of most words. For example, Kalmyk батhн In the modern Kalmyk language and the Oirat language of batkhn, Oirat батhан batkhan, from the old Mongolian West Mongolia, as well as in other Mongolian languages, the *bataγana "fly", Kalm., Oir. амн amn from the old Mong. *aman vowel *ö is similar to the old Mongolian *е and *i due to "mouth", Kalm., Oir. хавр khavr from the old Mong. *qabar assimilation. For example, Kalm. örgn , Oir. örgün from the old "spring", Kalm., Oir. хамр khamr from the old Mong. *qamar Mong. eregüü "chin", Kalm. övsn, Oir. övsün from the old Mong. "nose", Kalm., Oir. хавр khavr from the old Mong. *qabar ebüsün, Kalm. övr, Oir. övür from the old Mong. ebür "cavity", "spring", Kalm., Oir. амн amn from the old Mong. *aman Kalm. övl, Oir. övül from the old Mong. ebül, Kalm. övgn, Oir. "mouth", Kalm., Oir. сахл sakhl from the old Mong. *saqal övgön from the old Mong. ebügen, Kalm. övdg, Oir. övdeg from "beard", Kalm. хаша khasha, Oir. хаша khasha from the old the old Mong. ebüdeg, Kalm. шөвг Oir. from the old Mong. Mong. qašiy-a "fence, hedge". In some cases, due to the vowel šibüge "awl". fracture of *ï, the vowel а or уappears in the first syllable. This process occurred in all Mongolian languages. For example, In the modern Kalmyk language and the Oirat language of Kalm. заhсн zaqsn, Oir. загсан zaqsan from the old Mong. West Mongolia the front-row palatalized vowel *ü, according ǯiγasun "fish", Kalm. яман yaman, Oir. ямаан yamaan from the to V.I. Rassadin, "usually inherits the proto-Mongolic vowel * ü old Mong. *imaγan "goat", Kalm. шанh shanq, Oir. шанага in this position. For example, Kalm., Oir. kürkh, kh.-Mong.

Journal of critical reviews 520

PHONETIC FEATURES OF THE KALMYK AND OIRAT LANGUAGES OF WEST MONGOLIA

kürekh (< proto-Mong. *kürekü) "achieve"; Kalm., Oir. küsl, kh.- dictionary]. In four volumes. Vol. I. А–Г. Moscow: Mong. küsel (< proto-Mong. * küsel) "desire"; Kalm., Oir. üsn, Academia; 2001. p. 486. kh.-Mong. süü // süün (< proto-Mong. *üsün) "milk" [2, p. 12]. 13. Pyurbeev GTs (Ed.). Bolshoi akademicheskii mongolsko- Examples: Kalm., Oir. nüdün from the old Mong. nidüge, Kalm., russkii slovar [Large academic Mongolian-Russian Oir. shüdün from the old Mong. šidüge. dictionary]. In four volumes. Vol. II. Д–О. Moscow: Academia; 2001. p. 507. CONCLUSION 14. Pyurbeev GTs (Ed.). Bolshoi akademicheskii mongolsko- Therefore, the comparison of the phonetic systems of the russkii slovar [Large academic Mongolian-Russian modern Kalmyk language and the Oirat language of West dictionary]. In four volumes. Vol. III. Ө-Ф. Moscow: Mongolia indicates that the linguistic historical processes in Academia; 2001. p. 438. these languages are the same and the languages possess the 15. Pyurbeev GTs (Ed.).Bolshoi akademicheskii mongolsko- same phonetic characteristics, although native speakers of russkii slovar [Large academic Mongolian-Russian these languages have been separated in space and time for dictionary]. In four volumes. Vol. IV. Х-Я. Moscow: several thousand years. Academia; 2002. p. 506.

ACKNOWLEDGMENT The study was carried out with the financial support of the Russian Foundation for Basic Research and the Mongolian Ministry for Education, Culture and Science, project No. 19- 512-44006.

REFERENCES 1. Shcherba LV. Yazykovaya sistema i rechevaya deyatelnost [Language system and speech activity]. Leningrad: Nauka; 1974. p. 428. 2. Rassadin VI, Trofimova SM, Shagdarsuren Ts, Bold L, Davaasuren B.. Istoricheskaya svyaz kalmytskogo yazyka s yazykom oiratov Mongolii [The historical connection between the Kalmyk language and the Oirat language of Mongolia]. Elista: izd-vo Kalm. un-ta; 2010. p. 182. 3. Muniev BD (Ed.). Kalmytsko-russkii slovar [Kalmyk- Russian dictionary]. Moscow: Russkii yazyk; 1977. 4. Sanzheev GD. Sravnitelnaya grammatika mongolskikh yazykov [Comparative grammar of Mongolian languages]. Vol. I. Moscow: izd-vo AN SSSR; 1953. p. 240. 5. Bitkeev PC, Doraeva RP, Pavlov DA, Pyurbeev GC.Grammatika kalmytskogo yazyka. Fonetika i morfologiya [Grammar of the Kalmyk language. Phonetics and ]. Elista: Kalm. kn. izd-vo; 1983. 6. V.I. Rassadin Ocherki po istoricheskoi fonetike buryatskogo yazyka [Essays on the historical phonetics of the ]. Moscow: Nauka; 1982. p. 200. 7. Ubushaev NN. Dialektnaya sistema kalmytskogo yazyka [Dialect system of the Kalmyk language]. Elista: AOr NPP "Dzhangar "; 2006. p. 256. 8. Rassadin VI, Trofimova SM. Kratkaya prakticheskaya grammatika sovremennogo kalmytskogo yazyka [Concise practical grammar of the modern Kalmyk language]. Elista: izd-vo "Dzhangar "; 2018. p. 120. 9. Rassadin VI, Trofimova SM. O nedostatkakh deistvuyushchei kalmytskoi orfografii [On the disadvantages of the current Kalmyk orthography].In: Khisamitdinova FG, Bagautdinova KhI, Nafikov ShV, Sirazitdinov ZA, Suleimanova RA, editors. Aktualnye problemy dialektologii yazykov narodov Rossii. Proceedings of the XIII international conference. Ufa: Izd-vo “Gilem”; 2013. p. 131-132. 10. Rassadin VI, Trofimova SM. Ob osnovnykh printsipakh obucheniya kalmytskomu yazyku kak inostrannomu [On the main principles of teaching Kalmyk as a foreign language].In: Salaev BK, editor-in-chief. Aktualnye problemy sovremennogo mongolovedeniya i altaistiki: proceedings of the International scientific conference in honor of Professor V.I. Rassadin's 75th birthday and the 55th anniversary of teaching and academic work (10-13 Nov. 2014). Elista: ZAOr "NPP "Dzhangar";2014. p. 316- 318. 11. Tsoloo Zh.BNMAU Dakh Mongol Helniy Nutgyin Ayalguun Tol Bichig. II. Ayrd ayalguu [Dictionary of Mongolian dialects in the People's Republic of Mongolia. II. Oirat dialect]. ; 1988. p. 943. 12. Pyurbeev GTs (Ed.). Bolshoi akademicheskii mongolsko- russkii slovar [Large academic Mongolian-Russian

Journal of critical reviews 521