About the Best Kindof Settlers Inotherwise Serene Southwestern
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Inthe late eighteenth century, deep divisions about the best kindof Bradford's legacy is not spierre of the occasion." The Pitts- government and who DAVIDwellknown today, but during burgh Gazette later claimed that a the Whiskey Insurrection in 1794, "nod" from Bradford could have wouldlead itseparated President George Washington want- meant the destruction ofone's prop- ed Bradford arrested "byHook, or erty. And when he finally fled down settlers inotherwise by Crook."' Pittsburgh author and the Ohio River, militiaofficers mis- serene southwestern attorney HughHenry Brackenridge, takenly thought that they were ex- describing one event of the "rebel- pected to killhim rather than allow Pennsylvania. lion," called Bradford "the Robe- him to escape. 2 Bradford's part in James P. McClure, whose dissertation at the University ofMichigan dealt with Western Pennsylvania history of the late eighteenth century, is senior associate editor withthe Salmon P. Chase Papers, a documentary publication project at the Department of History, Claremont Graduate School, Claremont, California. Above: 'On the Monongahela,' by William Wall,1860, (original in oil). 72 'Let Us Be Independent* the Whiskey Insurrection was so had Bradford as itsprimary focus. As range of strongly held opinions notorious, according to Bracken- a result, what his case tells us about about them. 11 ridge, that he became identified with the region in 1794 has been ne- The population increase in the a Philistine deity of the Old Testa- glected. years preceding the Whiskey Insur- ment: when the people ofWashing- David Bradford was born in rection brought tensions over the ton County learned that Bradford Maryland about 1760 and probably breaking off of new counties, in- had finally advised submission to moved to Washington County, cluding part of Allegheny, from the government's terms, "The pop- Pennsylvania, about 1781, the year Washington County. 12 Another at- ular language, withrespect to him, itwas created from part ofWestmo- tempt to reduce the county's size, was, that 'Dagon was fallen.'" 3 reland County. The following year instigated by residents ofthe south- The Whiskey Insurrection was a he— became deputy attorney general— ernportion ofthe county, began by series ofincidents that originated in the state's district attorney for 1792. One of the discontented opposition to a federal excise tax on Washington County, a position southerners decried "the Aristocrat- distilled spirits. Itlost its momen- which he still held in 1794. 5 He ical nest of Washington" with its tum even before thousands ofmili- builtan imposing stone house inthe "juridical &legal grandees." 13 In tiamen marched intoWestern Penn- town of Washington and owned a February 1794, a satirical piece in sylvania inthe fall of1794 to ensure gristmill and sawmill. In 1792 he the Pittsburgh Gazette mocked the compliance with the law.4 David was elected to the Pennsylvania town of Washington as a self-styled Bradford didnotinstigate the excise House ofRepresentatives, where he "Athens of the western world," crisis, but he didmuch to give itthe served asingle term without seeking whose residents looked down on appearance of an insurrection. Itis re-election. 6 One of his contempo- the ignorant "boobies" ofthe coun- unlikely that there wouldhave been raries stated that Bradford favored ty's southern reaches. 14 Washing- —amilitiamuster at Braddock's Field efforts to create a new state in the ton town's "grandees" also feltpres- the largest gathering— ofthe Whis- region in the 1780s but was a "zeal- sures from John Canon's town of key Insurrection without him. ous" supporter ofthe federal consti- Canonsburg to the north. In the He came the closest of any public tution at the time ofits ratification. 7 early 1790s, Canonsburg competed figure to advocating a course of In attempting to explain the with Washington as the county's revolutionary action. He was the Whiskey Insurrection, Judge Alex- center of activity.15 , only leader toresist openly the gov- ander Addison stated that the "nat- In the 1780s a group of Wash- ernment's original plan for the re- uraluntamedness oftemper" offron- ington County residents, including gion's submission to law. tier settlements "was increased by David Bradford, attempted to cre- Many residents of Washington the peculiar circumstances of this ate a structure to contend withsome County and the neighboring region country." 8 By "this country," Add- of their frustration. At the January in the years before 1794 were dis- ison meant Western Pennsylvania, 1787 term of the county's courts, contented, frustrated, and uncer- and the "peculiar circumstances" "the magistrates, sheriff,prothono- tain. Those tensions fed the resis- included a boundary controversy and tary, attornies, and a number of tance to the tax on the product of conflicting claims that began in1774 reputable inhabitants" agreed to the region's many stills. Bradford, between Pennsylvania and Virginia. form an association against the pur- for his part, was one ofa number of The two states reached agreement chase or use ofany liquors imported would-be chieftans ina competitive on the issue in 1780, but it was the into the region from east of the political environment. There is lim- middle of the decade before the Allegheny Mountains. 16 Bradford ited information about him, so we boundaries were formally marked. represented the town of Washing- cannot know for certain ifhe acted Washington County's early years ton when acounty committee, call- solely from personal ambition, or were marked by tension over land ing itself "a general Patriotic Con- because he meant to represent oth- titles,disputes over the allocation of vention," met to promote this ob- ers frustrated by the political situa- county offices, and resistance to tax ject. The "convention" expanded tion. For whichever reason, the collection and militia enrollments. the list of concerns. Its delegates Whiskey Insurrection presented him There was agitation for the creation complained about several issues, withan opportunity to gainground of a new state in the region.9 The including an "exceeding burden- politicallyand he took advantage of effects ofthese conflicts were feltfor some" tax collection system, the it.His actions relate more to local years. 10 Warfare with Native Amer- allocation of the county's election power, ambition, and the society icans continued in the 1780s and districts, and a potential "abridge- and politics of Western Pennsylva- early 1790s. Theregion's white pop- ment of our common rights" nia in the 1790s than to the excise ulation swelled after the Revolu- through restrictions on navigation tax. He did not create the Whiskey tion, and opportunities for land- of the Mississippi River. Although Insurrection, but itis important to ownership declined. Cash was scarce only 11 official delegates attended account for his role init.And while and commercial prospects uncer- the meeting, representing fewer than much has been written about the tain. Troubled by all these issues, halfof the county's townships, they insurrection, nohistorical study has Western Pennsylvanians displayed a claimed the power to review bills 73 Pittsburgh History, Summer 1991 it confidence in the integrity and wisdom ofany set ofmen living."23 Within this setting David Brad- ford was a striver working tomake a place for himself. Early inhis career inWashington County, he was clerk for a special commission investigat- ing a dispute involving James Marshel, John Canon, and Dorsey Pentecost, prominent contenders for county leadership in the 1780s. 24 Heplayed anactive role inthe Wash- ington County "convention" of 1787. He sat for a term in the assembly. InFebruary 1789 he was one of the founding members, and also one of two "Counsellors," of the "Washington Society for the Relief of Free Negroes and others, unlawfully held inBondage." 25 He was secretary to the trustees of the Washington Academy. In1793 the governor appointed him a commis- sioner to oversee the sale in Wash- ington oflots inthe town ofBeaver, recently laid out on the Ohio Riv- er. 26 And inMarch of 1794, at the under consideration by the state ofPennsylvania to settlement, con- first meeting of "the Democratic legislature, and "infuture our deci- tinuing conflicts with Indians, offi- Society of Pennsylvania, in Wash- sion thereon shall be considered as cial salaries, and the new require - ington County," he was elected the instructions to our representa- ments for county judges. 20 West- group's vice president. This group tives." 17 moreland County politician Willi- was the county's version ofthe Dem- Bradford was one of two dele- am Findley observed that in some ocratic-Republican societies which gates appointed "toprepare an in- quarters "every discription of op- had begun to form inopposition tc strument of association," but the pression that theyhave heard named the policies of the Washington Ad- group did not sustain itself. 18 The is brought into the account." 21 ministration.27 convention illustrates theissues that Six years before the Whiskey In- Yet despite his energy, Bradford concerned the inhabitants of the surrection, "AWashington County was frustrated in his attempts to western counties. Itwasperhaps the Farmer," writing in a Pittsburgh distinguish himself in Washington first attempt to create a standing newspaper, predicted the approach County. His position as deputy at- association in the region based on ofa political crisis: "The period will torney general carried far less polit- township representation. In 1793 shortly arrive, when on our prudent ical weight than judgeships or the and early 1794 there were roughly exertions willdepend the well being offices of prothonotary, clerk of similar meetings in Washington, of these fractured counties; a time courts, sheriff, or recorder ofdeeds Fayette, and Westmoreland coun- which must give birth to petty op- and register of wills. He did not ties. Delegates at those gatherings pressions, or rise in a growth of parlay any of his offices into a sus- complained of an increase in state happiness under an envied democ- tained climb to a position ofsignif- legislators'pay, and ofa new system racy." 22 In 1793 William Littellof icant power.