Hans Urs Von Balthasar and Kenosis: the Pathway to Human Agency

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Hans Urs Von Balthasar and Kenosis: the Pathway to Human Agency Loyola University Chicago Loyola eCommons Dissertations Theses and Dissertations 2013 Hans Urs Von Balthasar and Kenosis: The Pathway to Human Agency Timothy J. Yoder Loyola University Chicago Follow this and additional works at: https://ecommons.luc.edu/luc_diss Part of the Religious Thought, Theology and Philosophy of Religion Commons Recommended Citation Yoder, Timothy J., "Hans Urs Von Balthasar and Kenosis: The Pathway to Human Agency" (2013). Dissertations. 918. https://ecommons.luc.edu/luc_diss/918 This Dissertation is brought to you for free and open access by the Theses and Dissertations at Loyola eCommons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Dissertations by an authorized administrator of Loyola eCommons. For more information, please contact [email protected]. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 License. Copyright © 2013 Timothy J Yoder LOYOLA UNIVERSITY CHICAGO HANS URS VON BALTHASAR AND KENOSIS: THE PATHWAY TO HUMAN AGENCY A DISSERTATION SUBMITTED TO THE FACULTY OF THE GRADUATE SCHOOL IN CANDIDACY FOR THE DEGREE OF DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY PROGRAM IN THEOLOGY BY TIMOTHY J. YODER CHICAGO, IL MAY 2014 Copyright by Timothy J. Yoder, 2014 All rights reserved. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS First I want to thank my dissertation committee at Loyola University of Chicago. I want to thank my director, Mark Bosco for steering me through the ups and downs of the dissertation process with patience and wisdom. I would like to thank the rest of my committee, Mark McIntosh of Durham University and Andrew Radde-Gallwitz of Loyola University Chicago for their support as well. My first introduction to the thought of Hans Urs von Balthasar came through Dr. McIntosh’s book on Balthasar’s Christology. His personal guidance during the early stages of this project was invaluable to me. I would also like to thank Andrew Radde-Gallwitz for his thoughtful questions and suggestions on this project. In addition to my committee I had several colleagues and friends who shared their time and wisdom with me. To Tim Squier and Ethan Worthington, who read the entire text at various stages, I am especially grateful. I would also like to thank Dina Berger, Brock Bingaman, Melissa Browning, Courtney Friesen, Ron and Lisa Geiger, Kristina Grob, Andrea Hollingsworth, Jessica Horowitz, Jason Kolkey, Hannah Kushnick, Jay Miiller, Silas Morgan, Cyril O’Regan, Ethan Schrum, Andrea Stapleton, Kris Squier, Elisabeth Vasko, and Catherine Wolf. Each of these people had a special role supporting me through this dissertation. The completion of this project would not have been possible without the encouragement, support, and sacrifice of my family. My parents, Sheldon and Letha, iii provided childcare on countless occasions to provide me time to write and research. Their constant support is an example of the nature of self-sacrificial love. I would also like to thank my mother-in-law, Valois Lantz for her support. My wife Katie and my two sons Samuel and Elijah sacrificed a lot of weekends and evenings with me while I worked to complete this project. Katie believed in my success even when I doubted it, and I am deeply grateful for her love and support. To Katie, Samuel, and Elijah TABLE OF CONTENTS ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ............................................................................................... iii ABSTRACT ..................................................................................................................... viii CHAPTER ONE: INTRODUCTION ................................................................................. 1 The Problem ..................................................................................................................... 2 The Argument .................................................................................................................. 5 The Context ...................................................................................................................... 9 The Fruit of Original Sin: Absorption and Autonomy................................................... 13 Conclusion ..................................................................................................................... 22 CHAPTER TWO: KENOSIS, INCARNATION AND SALVATION ............................ 25 Balthasar’s Approach to the Incarnation and the History of Kenosis ............................ 28 The Five Biblical Motifs of Salvation ........................................................................... 36 Conclusion ..................................................................................................................... 47 CHAPTER THREE: SUPER-KENOSIS AND THE TRINITARIAN LIFE ................... 49 Secondary Literature and the Context of Trinitarian Discourse .................................... 51 The Analogy of Being .................................................................................................... 54 Negative Theology ......................................................................................................... 56 Christological and Trinitarian Kenosis .......................................................................... 60 Adrienne Von Speyr and the Theology of Saints .......................................................... 62 Super-Kenosis and Trinitarian Persons .......................................................................... 64 Trinity as an Event of Love ........................................................................................... 72 Ontological Difference................................................................................................... 74 Conclusion ..................................................................................................................... 77 CHAPTER FOUR: THE SAINTS AND KENOSIS ........................................................ 78 Why the Saints? ............................................................................................................. 78 “The Faith of the Simple Ones”: Main Themes for Interpretation ................................ 80 John of the Cross and the “Scream of the Vivisected Soul” .......................................... 86 Thérèse of Lisieux and the Little Way ........................................................................... 89 Elizabeth “the Vanishing” .............................................................................................. 93 Conclusion ..................................................................................................................... 95 CHAPTER FIVE: KENOSIS AND THE SPIRITUAL PATHWAY TO AGENCY ....... 98 The Relationship between Theology and Spirituality .................................................... 98 Gospel as Norm............................................................................................................ 100 Philosophical Difference and the Spirituality of Kenosis ............................................ 102 The Scandal of the Gospel over Intellectual System ................................................... 107 Mission and Human Agency ........................................................................................ 115 Discernment ................................................................................................................. 122 Conclusion ................................................................................................................... 129 vi BIBLIOGRAPHY ........................................................................................................... 143 VITA ............................................................................................................................... 151 vii ABSTRACT The purpose of this dissertation is to examine the kenotic motif in the theology of Hans Urs von Balthasar, particularly in light of his concern to protect human agency. This dissertation argues that Balthasar views kenotic spiritual practice as the pathway to achieve true human agency. This kenotic pathway to agency is placed in contrast to Balthasar’s concept of original sin as an attempt by humanity to achieve agency on their own terms. The narrative of original sin results in two possible outcomes for Balthasar: a spiritual pathway toward the absorption of the self, which results in the annihilation of the self or, the autonomy of the self is emphasized to the degree that self-actualization becomes the goal of the spiritual journey and other humans are seen as obstacles to self- realization. This project explores the themes of kenosis within the doctrine of the Incarnation and Trinity as the solution to understanding human agency and as the answer to original sin in and through the Incarnation. The Christological and Trinitarian shape of sainthood and spirituality are explored in the final two chapters. Balthasar’s treatment of St. John of the Cross, St. Thérèse of Lisieux, and Elisabeth of the Trinity are examples of how the kenotic motif is revealed in the lives of the saints. The final chapter looks at Balthasar’s spirituality as thoroughly kenotic and that this kenotic activity cannot be systematized into a universal ethical or spiritual model; rather, it is enacted through discernment. This discernment is based on the norm of the gospel as “hard sayings” and as “good news.” Each individual human being is invited to take on a unique mission, viii which forms them into a theological person, those providing a deep and real sense of human agency. The dissertation
Recommended publications
  • Christ and Analogy the Christocentric Metaphysics of Hans Urs Von Balthasar by Junius Johnson
    Christ and Analogy The Christocentric Metaphysics of Hans Urs von Balthasar by Junius Johnson This in-depth study of Hans Urs von Balthasar’s metaphysics attempts to reproduce the core philosophical commitments of the Balthasarian system as necessary for a deep understanding of von Balthasar’s theology. Focusing on the God-world relation, the author examines von Balthasar’s reasons for rejecting all views that consider this relation in terms of either identity or pure difference, and makes clear what is at stake in these fundamentally theological choices. The author then details von Balthasar’s understanding of the accepted way of parsing this relationship, analogy. The philosophical dimensions of analogy are explored in such philosophical topics as the Trinity and Christology, though these topics may be treated only in a preliminary way in a study focused on metaphysics. “Crisp writing, clear thought, insightful reflection on a seminal and influential thinker's take on one of the most fundamental themes of theology–what more would you want from a book in theology? This is in fact what you get with Johnson's Christ and Analogy. Whether you are interested in von Balthasar, in theological method, or in relationship between metaphysics and theology you should read this book.” --Miroslav Volf, Yale Divinity School Junius Johnson is a lecturer at Yale Divinity School and a research fellow at the Rivendell Institute at Yale University. Johnson earned a Ph.D. in theology at Yale University. Table of Contents Chapter 1: Introduction I. Theology’s Handmaid: Scope of the Project A. What is Metaphysics? B.
    [Show full text]
  • Bonaventure's Metaphysics of the Good
    Theological Studies 60 (1999) BONAVENTURE'S METAPHYSICS OF THE GOOD ILIA DELIO, O.S.F. [Bonaventure offers new insight on the role of God the Father vis-à-vis the created world and the role of the Incarnate Word as metaphysical center of all reality. The kenosis of the Father through the self-diffusion of the good inverts the notion of patriarchy and underscores the humility of God in the world. By locating universals on the level of the singular and personal, Bonaventure transforms the Neoplatonic philosophical quest into a Christian metaphysics. The author then considers the ramifications of this for the contem­ porary world.] HE HIGH MIDDLE AGES were a time of change and transition, marked by T the religious discovery of the universe and a new awareness of the position of the human person in the universe. In the 12th century, a Dio- nysian awakening coupled with the rediscovery of Plato's Timaeus gave rise to a new view of the cosmos.1 Louis Dupré has described the Platonic revival of that century as the turn to a "new self-consciousness."2 In view of the new awakening of the 12th century, the question of metaphysical principles that supported created reality, traditionally the quest of the philosophers, began to be challenged by Christian writers. Of course it was not as if any one writer set out to overturn classical metaphysics; however, the significance of the Incarnation posed a major challenge. It may seem odd that a barely educated young man could upset an established philo­ sophical tradition, but Francis of Assisi succeeded in doing so.
    [Show full text]
  • ABSTRACT Love Itself Is Understanding: Balthasar, Truth, and the Saints Matthew A. Moser, Ph.D. Mentor: Peter M. Candler, Jr., P
    ABSTRACT Love Itself is Understanding: Balthasar, Truth, and the Saints Matthew A. Moser, Ph.D. Mentor: Peter M. Candler, Jr., Ph.D. This study examines the thought of Hans Urs von Balthasar on the post-Scholastic separation between dogmatic theology and the spirituality of Church, which he describes as the loss of the saints. Balthasar conceives of this separation as a shattering of truth — the “living exposition of theory in practice and of knowledge carried into action.” The consequence of this shattering is the impoverishment of both divine and creaturely truth. This dissertation identifies Balthasar’s attempt to overcome this divorce between theology and spirituality as a driving theme of his Theo-Logic by arguing that the “truth of Being” — divine and creaturely — is most fundamentally the love revealed by Jesus Christ, and is therefore best known by the saints. Balthasar’s attempted re-integration of speculative theology and spirituality through his theology of the saints serves as his critical response to the metaphysics of German Idealism that elevated thought over love, and, by so doing, lost the transcendental properties of Being: beauty, goodness, and truth. Balthasar constructively responds to this problem by re-appropriating the ancient and medieval spiritual tradition of the saints, as interpreted through his own theological master, Ignatius of Loyola, to develop a trinitarian and Christological ontology and a corresponding pneumatological epistemology, as expressed through the lives, and especially the prayers, of the saints. This project will follow the structure and rhythm of Balthasar’s Theo-Logic in elaborating the initiatory movement of his account of truth: phenomenological, Christological, and pneumatological.
    [Show full text]
  • Beauty As a Transcendental in the Thought of Joseph Ratzinger
    The University of Notre Dame Australia ResearchOnline@ND Theses 2015 Beauty as a transcendental in the thought of Joseph Ratzinger John Jang University of Notre Dame Australia Follow this and additional works at: https://researchonline.nd.edu.au/theses Part of the Philosophy Commons COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA Copyright Regulations 1969 WARNING The material in this communication may be subject to copyright under the Act. Any further copying or communication of this material by you may be the subject of copyright protection under the Act. Do not remove this notice. Publication Details Jang, J. (2015). Beauty as a transcendental in the thought of Joseph Ratzinger (Master of Philosophy (School of Philosophy and Theology)). University of Notre Dame Australia. https://researchonline.nd.edu.au/theses/112 This dissertation/thesis is brought to you by ResearchOnline@ND. It has been accepted for inclusion in Theses by an authorized administrator of ResearchOnline@ND. For more information, please contact [email protected]. School of Philosophy and Theology Sydney Beauty as a Transcendental in the Thought of Joseph Ratzinger Submitted by John Jang A thesis in partial fulfilment of the requirements of the degree of Master of Philosophy Supervised by Dr. Renée Köhler-Ryan July 2015 © John Jang 2015 Table of Contents Abstract v Declaration of Authorship vi Acknowledgements vii Introduction 1 Structure 3 Method 5 PART I - Metaphysical Beauty 7 1.1.1 The Integration of Philosophy and Theology 8 1.1.2 Ratzinger’s Response 11 1.2.1 Transcendental Participation 14 1.2.2 Transcendental Convertibility 18 1.2.3 Analogy of Being 25 PART II - Reason and Experience 28 2.
    [Show full text]
  • Understanding Von Balthasar's Trilogy*
    doi: 10.11144/javeriana.tx67-184.uvbt Understanding Comprensión de la trilogía de Hans Urs Von Balthasar Von Balthasar’s Resumen: El artículo expone la estruc- Trilogy∗ tura de pensamiento de Hans Urs Von Balthasar a partir de la síntesis que este logró en su “Trilogía teológica”: “Estética Rodrigo Polanco∗∗ teológica”, “Teo-dramática” y “Teo- lógica”. Debido a que la Trilogía está basada en los tres trascendentales del ser (belleza, bondad y verdad), este estudio, RECIBIDO: 24-12-16. APROBADO: 08-03-17 luego de revisar las fuentes e influencias que recibió Von Balthasar a lo largo de su vida, describe su comprensión de la Abstract: The article presents the structure relación entre filosofía y teología y ex- of Hans Urs Von Balthasar’s thought from the pli ca cómo toda la revelación trinitaria synthesis he achieved in his “Theological Trilogy”: se puede expresar muy bien a partir de “Theological Aesthetics,” “Theo-Drama,” and la manifestación (belleza), donación “Theo-Logic”. Because the Trilogy is based on the (bondad) y comprensión (verdad) de Dios. three transcendentals of Being (beauty, goodness, Palabras clave: Hans Urs Von Balthasar, and truth), this study—after reviewing Balthasar’s trilogía teológica, influencias de Von influences throughout his life—describes his Balthasar, pensamiento de Von Balthasar, understanding of the relationship between teología de Von Balthasar. philosophy and theology and explains how the trinitarian revelation can be aptly expressed through God’s manifestation (beauty), bestowal (goodness), para citar este artículo: and comprehension (truth). Polanco, Rodrigo. “Understanding Von Key words: Hans Urs Von Balthasar, Theological Balthasar’s Trilogy”. Theologica Xa veriana Trilogy, Balthasar’s Influences, Balthasar’s Thought, 184 (2017): 411-430.
    [Show full text]
  • The Christological Function of Divine Impassibility: Cyril of Alexandria and Contemporary Debate
    The Christological Function of Divine Impassibility: Cyril of Alexandria and Contemporary Debate by David Andrew Graham A thesis submitted to the Faculty of Wycliffe College and the Theological Department of the Toronto School of Theology in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts in Theology awarded by the University of St. Michael's College © Copyright by David Andrew Graham 2013 The Christological Function of Divine Impassibility: Cyril of Alexandria and Contemporary Debate David Andrew Graham Master of Arts in Theology University of St. Michael’s College 2013 Abstract This thesis contributes to the debate over the meaning and function of the doctrine of divine impassibility in theological and especially christological discourse. Seeking to establish the coherence and utility of the paradoxical language characteristic of the received christological tradition (e.g. the impassible Word became passible flesh and suffered impassibly), it argues that the doctrine of divine apatheia illuminates the apocalyptic and soteriological dimension of the incarnate Son’s passible life more effectively than recent reactions against it. The first chapter explores the Christology of Cyril of Alexandria and the meaning and place of apatheia within it. In light of the christological tradition which Cyril epitomized, the second chapter engages contemporary critiques and re-appropriations of impassibility, focusing on the particular contributions of Jürgen Moltmann, Robert W. Jenson, Bruce L. McCormack and David Bentley Hart. ii Acknowledgments If this thesis communicates any truth, beauty and goodness, credit belongs to all those who have shaped my life up to this point. In particular, I would like to thank the Toronto School of Theology and Wycliffe College for providing space to do theology from within the catholic church.
    [Show full text]
  • From the Garden of Eden to the New Creation in Christ : a Theological Investigation Into the Significance and Function of the Ol
    The University of Notre Dame Australia ResearchOnline@ND Theses 2017 From the Garden of Eden to the new creation in Christ : A theological investigation into the significance and function of the Old estamentT imagery of Eden within the New Testament James Cregan The University of Notre Dame Australia Follow this and additional works at: https://researchonline.nd.edu.au/theses Part of the Religion Commons COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA Copyright Regulations 1969 WARNING The material in this communication may be subject to copyright under the Act. Any further copying or communication of this material by you may be the subject of copyright protection under the Act. Do not remove this notice. Publication Details Cregan, J. (2017). From the Garden of Eden to the new creation in Christ : A theological investigation into the significance and function of the Old Testament imagery of Eden within the New Testament (Doctor of Philosophy (College of Philosophy and Theology)). University of Notre Dame Australia. https://researchonline.nd.edu.au/theses/181 This dissertation/thesis is brought to you by ResearchOnline@ND. It has been accepted for inclusion in Theses by an authorized administrator of ResearchOnline@ND. For more information, please contact [email protected]. FROM THE GARDEN OF EDEN TO THE NEW CREATION IN CHRIST: A THEOLOGICAL INVESTIGATION INTO THE SIGNIFICANCE AND FUNCTION OF OLD TESTAMENT IMAGERY OF EDEN WITHIN THE NEW TESTAMENT. James M. Cregan A thesis submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy at the University of Notre Dame, Australia. School of Philosophy and Theology, Fremantle. November 2017 “It is thus that the bridge of eternity does its spanning for us: from the starry heaven of the promise which arches over that moment of revelation whence sprang the river of our eternal life, into the limitless sands of the promise washed by the sea into which that river empties, the sea out of which will rise the Star of Redemption when once the earth froths over, like its flood tides, with the knowledge of the Lord.
    [Show full text]
  • Monasticism Old And
    Study Guides for Monasticism Old and New These guides integrate Bible study, prayer, and worship to explore how monastic communities, classic and new, provide a powerful critique of mainstream culture and offer transforming possibilities Christian Reflection for our discipleship. Use them individually or in a series. You may A Series in Faith and Ethics reproduce them for personal or group use. A Vision So Old It Looks New 2 It is hard to be a Christian in America today. But that can be good news, the new monastics are discovering. If the cost of discipleship pushes us to go back and listen to Jesus again, it may open us to costly grace and the transformative power of resurrection life. In every era God has raised up new monas- tics to remind the Church of its true vocation. The Finkenwalde Project 4 Dietrich Bonhoeffer’s project at Finkenwalde Seminary to recover for congregations the deep Christian tradition is a prominent model for young twenty-first-century Christians. Weary of the false dichotomy between right belief and right practice, they seek the wholeness of discipleship in what Bonhoeffer called “a kind of new monasticism.” Evangelicals and Monastics 6 Could any two groups of Christians—evangelicals and monastics—be more different? But the New Monasticism movement has opened a new chapter in the relations of these previously estranged groups. Nothing is more characteristic of monastics and evangelicals than their unshakable belief that one cannot be truly spiritual without putting one’s faith into practice, and one cannot sustain Christian discipleship without a prayerful spirituality.
    [Show full text]
  • Von Balthasar's Ideal Theology
    APPENDIX VON BALTHASAR'S IDEAL THEOLOGY It is well known that von Balthasar spent the early years of his theological career studying the patristic period of Christianity. I When one considers the dominant view in that period of what an ideal theology, as well as what an ideal theologian, should consist in, it soon becomes apparent how great is the patristic influence on his thought. Certainly, both his ideal theology and his conception of what a Christian theologian should be clearly show the influence that the patristic period had on him. In this appendix, I first draw out some of the features of the dominant view held within the patristic period2 of an ideal theology and an ideal theologian-a view which had such a marked effect on von Balthasar. I then discuss his proposals for the way forward in theology-proposals which incorporate the specific ideal which he draws from the patristic period. Thus, in this appendix, I shed further light on von Balthasar's appeal for a return to a more integrated approach to theology. (a) The Early Centuries If we are to gain any further insight into von Balthasar's conception of what both theology and theologians ought to be, then we must take into considera­ tion what, for him, was the definitive period of Christian theology-namely, the early centuries of Christianity. The most relevant feature of this period, 1 Indeed, von Balthasar's ·fIrst significant theological pUblications were in Patristics. See Hans Urs von Balthasar, Kosmische Liturgie. Hohe und Krise des griechischen Weltbilds bei Maximus Confessor (Freiburg: Herder, 1941); Hans Urs von Balthasar, Die Gnost­ ischen Centurien des Maximus Confessor (Freiburg: Herder, 1941); and Hans Urs von Balthasar, Presence et Pensee.
    [Show full text]
  • Kenosis and the Nature of the Persons in the Trinity
    Kenosis and the nature of the Persons in the Trinity David T. Williams Department of Historical and Contextual Theology University of Fort Hare ALICE E-mail: [email protected] Abstract Kenosis and the nature of the Persons in the Trinity Philippians 2:7 describes the kenosis of Christ, that is Christ’s free choice to limit himself for the sake of human salvation. Although the idea of Christ’s kenosis as an explanation of the incarnation has generated considerable controversy and has largely been rejected in its original form, it is clear that in this process Christ did humble himself. This view is consistent with some contemporary perspectives on God’s self-limitation; in particular as this view provides a justification for human freedom of choice. As kenosis implies a freely chosen action of God, and not an inherent and temporary limitation, kenosis is consistent with an affirmation of God’s sovereignty. This view is particularly true if Christ’s kenosis is seen as a limitation of action and not of his attributes. Such an idea does not present problems concerning the doctrine of the Trinity, specifically regarding the relation between the economic and the immanent nature of the Trinity. The Trinitarian doctrine, on the contrary, indeed complements this idea – specifically the concept of perichoresis (the inter- relatedness among the Persons of the Triniy and the relation between the two natures of Christ). Opsomming Kenosis en die aard van die Persone in die Drie-eenheid Filippense 2:7 beskryf die kenosis van Christus – sy vrye keuse om homself te ontledig ter wille van die mens se verlossing.
    [Show full text]
  • Mysticism and Mystical Experiences
    1 Mysticism and Mystical Experiences The first issue is simply to identify what mysti cism is. The term derives from the Latin word “mysticus” and ultimately from the Greek “mustikos.”1 The Greek root muo“ ” means “to close or conceal” and hence “hidden.”2 The word came to mean “silent” or “secret,” i.e., doctrines and rituals that should not be revealed to the uninitiated. The adjec tive “mystical” entered the Christian lexicon in the second century when it was adapted by theolo- gians to refer, not to inexpressible experiences of God, but to the mystery of “the divine” in liturgical matters, such as the invisible God being present in sacraments and to the hidden meaning of scriptural passages, i.e., how Christ was actually being referred to in Old Testament passages ostensibly about other things. Thus, theologians spoke of mystical theology and the mystical meaning of the Bible. But at least after the third-century Egyptian theolo- gian Origen, “mystical” could also refer to a contemplative, direct appre- hension of God. The nouns “mystic” and “mysticism” were only invented in the seven teenth century when spirituality was becoming separated from general theology.3 In the modern era, mystical inter pretations of the Bible dropped away in favor of literal readings. At that time, modernity’s focus on the individual also arose. Religion began to become privatized in terms of the primacy of individuals, their beliefs, and their experiences rather than being seen in terms of rituals and institutions. “Religious experiences” also became a distinct category as scholars beginning in Germany tried, in light of science, to find a distinct experi ential element to religion.
    [Show full text]
  • 1A2ae.10.2.Responsio 2
    THE TRINITARIAN GIFT UNFOLDED: SACRIFICE, RESURRECTION, COMMUNION JOHN MARK AINSLEY GRIFFITHS, BSC., MSC., MA Thesis submitted to the University of Nottingham for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy July 2015 Abstract Contentious unresolved philosophical and anthropological questions beset contemporary gift theories. What is the gift? Does it expect, or even preclude, some counter-gift? Should the gift ever be anticipated, celebrated or remembered? Can giver, gift and recipient appear concurrently? Must the gift involve some tangible ‘thing’, or is the best gift objectless? Is actual gift-giving so tainted that the pure gift vaporises into nothing more than a remote ontology, causing unbridgeable separation between the gift-as-practised and the gift-as-it-ought-to- be? In short, is the gift even possible? Such issues pervade scholarly treatments across a wide intellectual landscape, often generating fertile inter-disciplinary crossovers whilst remaining philosophically aporetic. Arguing largely against philosophers Jacques Derrida and Jean-Luc Marion and partially against the empirical gift observations of anthropologist Marcel Mauss, I contend in this thesis that only a theological – specifically trinitarian – reading liberates the gift from the stubborn impasses which non-theological approaches impose. That much has been argued eloquently by theologians already, most eminently John Milbank, yet largely with a philosophical slant. I develop the field by demonstrating that the Scriptures, in dialogue with the wider Christian dogmatic tradition, enrich discussions of the gift, showing how creation, which emerges ex nihilo in Christ, finds its completion in him as creatures observe and receive his own perfect, communicable gift alignment. In the ‘gift-object’ of human flesh, believers rejoicingly discern Christ receiving-in-order-to-give and giving-in- order-to-receive, the very reciprocal giftedness that Adamic humanity spurned.
    [Show full text]