File for Brad
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
REPRESENTATION, EQUITY & ENVIRONMENT Working Paper Series Working Paper 24 Institutional Choice and Recognition: Effects on the Formation and Consolidation of Local Democracy Minutes of a Comparative Policy Research Workshop Bradley L. Kinder, Nathaniel Gerhart and Anjali Bhat December 2006 The Representation, Equity and Environment Working Paper Series This series is a continuation of WRI’s ‘Environmental Accountability in Africa’ working paper series (Working Papers number 1 through 22). The series was renamed to reflect the Equity Poverty and Environment team’s broadening, mostly through comparative research, to include research and analysis worldwide. This periodic working paper series presents new research on democratic decentralization and legislative representation concerning the management, control and use of natural resources. The series will present research and analysis on the effects of policies on the distribution of profits and other benefits within natural resource commodity chains and the distribution of government revenues from natural resource exploitation and trade. The objective of this working paper series is to provide researchers working at the intersection of governance and natural resource management with a forum in which to present their findings and receive feedback from scholars and practitioners around the world. Your comments can be sent to the series editor at WRI or to the authors at the contact information listed at the back of each working paper. Cover Image Artist: Mor Gueye Mor Gueye is an internationally renowned Senegalese artist. At over 80 years of age, Mor Gueye is considered the ‘dean’ of Senegal’s reverse glass painters. This technique, where he paints on one side of a glass pane to be viewed from the other, is popular in urban Senegal. The reverse glass paintings on the cover were photographed by Franklin Pierre Khoury, the art photographer of the Museum of African Art at the Smithsonian Institute in Washington, DC. ii REPRESENTATION, EQUITY AND ENVIRONMENT WORKING PAPER 24 Institutional Choice and Recognition: Effects on the Formation and Consolidation of Local Democracy Minutes of a Comparative Policy Research Workshop Rapporteurs: Bradley L. Kinder, Nathaniel Gerhart, and Anjali Bhat December 2006 Series editor: Institutions and Governance Program Jesse RIBOT 10 G Street, N.E., Suite 800 Washington, D.C. 20002 USA www.wri.org TABLE OF CONTENTS Preface ..........................................................................................................................................................1 Thursday, 15 June 2006 ................................................................................................................................2 Opening Session............................................................................................................................................2 Objectives and Agenda by Tomila Lankina and Parakh Hoon.....................................................................4 Theme I: Politics of Institutional Choice—who is chosen & why?..............................................................6 Session 1: Politics of Institutional Choice ....................................................................................................6 Case 1: Solange Bandiaky ............................................................................................................................6 Case 2: Fabiano Toni .................................................................................................................................10 Case 3 – Tomila Lankina ............................................................................................................................14 Case 4 – Bréhima Kassibo..........................................................................................................................18 Plenary and Group Discussions .................................................................................................................21 Friday, 16 June 2006...................................................................................................................................24 Theme II: Politics of Recognition – Representation, Citizenship/Belonging, and Public Domain ............24 Overview and Discussion of Politics of Recognition by Jesse Ribot ..........................................................24 Session 2 – Representation .........................................................................................................................26 Case 1 – Papa Faye ....................................................................................................................................26 Case 2 – Ashwini Chhatre...........................................................................................................................29 Case 3 – Marja Spierenburg.......................................................................................................................32 Case 4 – Mafaniso Hara.............................................................................................................................36 Plenary Session on Themes: Representation, Belonging/Citizenship, and Public Domain........................40 Saturday, 17 June 2006...............................................................................................................................46 Report back on Group Break out sessions from Friday, June 16. ..............................................................46 Session 3 – Belonging/Citizenship .............................................................................................................52 Case 1: Anne Larson...................................................................................................................................52 Case 2: Roch Mongbo.................................................................................................................................55 Case 3: Peter Hochet..................................................................................................................................59 Case 4: Parakh Hoon..................................................................................................................................62 Session 4: Public Domain ...........................................................................................................................66 Case 1 – Euclides Goncalves......................................................................................................................66 Case 2: Po Garden, Louis Lebel, Fasai Viseskul, Nathan Badenoch, Charunee Chirangworapat, and Manogh Prompanyo....................................................................................................................................69 Plenary – Emerging Themes by Fumi Saito ...............................................................................................72 Sunday, 18 June 2006 .................................................................................................................................75 Theme III: Comparative Analysis and Findings.........................................................................................75 Plenary: Comparative Research Results – Emerging patterns....................................................................75 Plenary: Comparative Research Approach and Methods—how to proceed? .............................................83 Plenary: Policy Lessons—policy implications ...........................................................................................90 Plenary: Where to go from here? ................................................................................................................95 Appendix A: Participant List ......................................................................................................................98 Appendix B: Meeting Agenda ....................................................................................................................99 Appendix C: Concept Note.......................................................................................................................105 Appendix D: Representation, Equity and Environment Working Paper List ...........................................105 5 PREFACE The text that follows is taken directly from notes typed by the rapporteurs during oral presentations at the WRI workshop “Institutional Choice and Recognition: Effects on the Formation and Consolidation of Local Democracy” in Ubud, Bali in June 2006. These minutes are not all accurate. Typing while listening is a difficult task. For some of the participants, English is not their first language. Participants come to the meeting with different accents and pronunciations. Some participants speak faster than others—something to which the rapporteurs will attest. To assure that the intended message of the authors comes across in this text, we have given all of the authors the opportunity to correct their contributions to the dialogue. We asked them to clarify only—not to change what they said. Those participants who did give us comments respected this request. The articles written for this conference are being revised as working papers and articles for publication during the course of 2007. Many people contributed to the success of this meeting. First and foremost Bradley Kinder organized the logistics of this meeting from the identification of the site to the getting everyone