Reconsidering Expressivity in Music for Robotic Instruments
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
NIME ProceedingsMechatronic Template Expression: for LaTeX Reconsidering Expressivity in Music for Robotic Ben Trovato⇤ InstrumentsG.K.M. Tobin† Lars Thørväld‡ Institute for Clarity in Institute for Clarity in The Thørväld Group Documentation Documentation 1 Thørväld Circle 1932 Wallamaloo Lane P.O. Box 1212 Hekla, Iceland Wallamaloo,Steven New Kemper Zealand Dublin, Ohio 43017-6221 larst@affiliation.orgScott Barton [email protected] Gross School of the Arts webmaster@marysville- Worcester Polytechnic Institute Rutgers University ohio.com Worcester, MA, USA LawrenceNew Brunswick, P. Leipuner NJ, USA Sean Fogarty [email protected] Nymous [email protected] Brookhaven Laboratories NASA Ames Research Center Redacted Brookhaven National Lab Moffett Field 8600 Datapoint Drive P.O. Box 5000 California 94035 San Antonio, Texas 78229 [email protected] [email protected] that refining [email protected] parameters will lead to a more expressive Robotic instrument designers tend to focus on the number of sound instrument. controlABSTRACT parameters and their resolution when trying to develop PleaseEquating read greater the commentscontrol over insonic the nuance nime-template.tex with “expression” resonates with mainstream contemporary understandings of musical expressivityThis paper in provides their instruments. a sample These of aparameters LAT X document afford greater for thesonic file to see how to create the CCS Concept Classifi- E expression. From this perspective, with its roots in Romantic-era nuanceNIME related conference to elements series. of It music conforms, that are somewhat traditionally loosely, associated to cations! withthe formattingexpressive human guidelines performances for ACM including SIG Proceedings. articulation, It timbre, is an aesthetics, a performer is able to transmit the meaning of a piece of dynamics,alternate andstyle phrasing. which Equating produces the a tighter-lookingcapacity for sonicpaper nuance and and 1.music, INTRODUCTION often thought of as emotion, to the listener through subtle musicalwas designed expression in response stems from to concerns the “transitive” expressed, perspective by authors, that variations of articulation, timbre, dynamics, and phrasing. This Theperspectiveproceedings is referredare the to recordsas “transitive” of a conference. in that meaning ACM or emotion seeks is musicalover page-budgets. expression is Itan complements act of emotio thenal documentcommunicationAuthor’s from to give these conference by-products a uniform, high-quality performer(Alternate) to listener. Guide However, to Preparing this perspective ACM SIG is Proceedings problematic in Us- the appearance.considered to To be transmi do this,tted ACM from hasthe performer some rigid to the requirements listener [25, 32]. caseing LAofT EroboticX2✏ and instruments BibTEX. Thissince sourcewe do filenot has typically been writtenconsider forScruton the format summarizes of the this proceedings position and its documents: prevalence in there contemporary is a A machineswith the to intentionbe capable of expressing being compiled emotion. under Contemporary LTEX2 ✏theoriesand specifieddiscourse, format “…despite (balanced all the double skepticism columns), that has a specifiedbeen heaped set on ofBibTeX. musical expression focus on an “intransitive” perspective, where ofRomantic fonts (Arial aesthetics, or Helvetica the popular and view Times remains Roman) essentially in certain that of musicalTo make meaning best useis ofgenerated this sample as document,an embodied run itexperience. through specifiedRousseau sizes and (forDiderot: instance, music 9 evokes point foremotion body because copy). it expresses LAT X and BibTeX, and compare this source code with your UnderstandingE expressivity from this perspective allows listeners to emotion.The good Music news is is, the with middle only aterm handful in an of act manual of emotional set- compiled PDF file. A compiled PDF version is available to 1 interpret performances by robotic instruments as possessing their own tings,communication…”the LATEX document [32]. class file handles all of this for help you with the ‘look and feel.’ The paper submit- you. The transitive concept of musical expression is problematic in the expressiveted to the meaning, NIME even conference though the performer must be is a stored machine. in It analso enables musicians working with robotic instruments to develop their caseThe of remainder robotic instruments. of this document How can is a concernedmachine be with expressive show- if it A4-sized PDF file, so North Americans should take A own unique vocabulary of expressive gestures unique to mechanical ing,cannot in the feel context that which of an can “actual” be expressed? document, Concerns the LoverTE Xcom-expressivity care not to inadvertently generate letter paper-sized mandsin mechanical specifically music available date back for denotingto the musical the structure automata of of a the instruments.PDF files. ThisThis paper paper explores template these shouldissues of prevent musical that expression, from proceedingseighteenth paper,and nineteenth ratherthan centuries. with givingIn 1752, rigorous Quantz descrip- described introhappeningducing the if theconceptpdflatex of mechatronicprogram expression is used toas a generate compositional the tions or explanations of such commands. andPDF design file. strategy that highlights the musical and performative Vaucanson’s mechanical flute player as a technically proficient capabilitiesThe abstract unique shouldto robotic preferably instruments. be between 100 and 200 musician but claimed that it was devoid of human expression: “With words. 2.skill THE a musicalBODY machineOF [i.e. THE Vaucanson’s PAPER flute-player] could be Typically,constructed the that body would of aplay paper certain is organizedpieces with into a quickness a hierar- and Author Keywords chicalexactitude structure, so remarkable with numbered that no human or unnumbered being could headingsequal it either MusicalAuthor robotics, Keywords expression, music for robotic instruments forwith sections, his fingers subsections, or with sub-subsections, his tongue. Indeed and evenit would smaller excite NIME, proceedings, LATEX, template sections.astonishment, The commandbut it would\section never movethat you” precedes [29, emphasis this para-added]. In 2 A CCS Concepts graphthis isquote, part ofQuantz such aacknowledges hierarchy. LTtheEX technical handles theprecision num- of bering and placement of these headings for you, when you AppliedCCS Concepts computing~Sound and music computing; Vaucanson’s automaton, but considers the instrument to be incapable useof thestirring appropriate an emotional heading response commands in the listener. around the titles of Applied computing Sound and music comput- the In headings. 1818 a critic If you from want the London a sub-subsection times described or smallera performance part by 1.ing;• INTRODUCTIONPerforming arts; !Information systems Music to be unnumbered in your output, simply append an aster- Designers of robotic instruments• 1 place a great deal of emphasis! on the Johann Maelzel’s Automaton Trumpeter as technically precise, but retrieval; isklacking to the in command expression, name. “Nothing Examples can exceed of both the accuracy numbered and andneatness capability of their instruments to be “expressive” [14, 23, 30, 34]. unnumbered headings will appear throughout the balance of the execution, or the steadiness of the tone: in the rapidity with While⇤Dr. Trovatorobotic instruments insisted his are name typically be adept first. at performing complex of this sample document. sequences of pitches and rhythms with technical precision, the sonic which the same note may be repeated in succession, and in some †The secretary disavows any knowledge of this author’s ac- Because the entire article is contained in the document nuancetions. traditionally associated with expressive human performance, environment,passages of a you similar can nature, indicate it thesurpasses start ofthe a powers new paragraph of any living trumpeter; it fails only in expression, and in the swell of the note, a including‡This author articulation, is the onetimbre, who dynamics, did all the and really phr hardasing, work.is more with a blank line in your input file; that is why this sentence difficult to model, requiring complex hardware and software design. formsdefect a which separate is common paragraph. to all music produced by mechanism” [4]. Again, we find mechanical performance set apart from human Much of the current research on robotic instruments highlights 1 Twoperformance, of these, with thethe former\numberofauthors less expressive thanand the\alignau- latter. capabilities for sonic nuance as a function of the number of sound thor commands, you have already used; another, \bal- Contemporary robotic instrument designers continue to be inspired control parameters and their resolution [e.g. 33]. This research ancecolumns, will be used in your very last run of LATEX toby ensure the concerns balanced over column expressivity heights in onmusical the last automata page. in order to Licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 2Thisincrease is the parametric second footnote. capabilities Itof startstheir instruments. a series ofFor three example, 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0). Copyright footnotesMaes et al. that state, add “…sounds nothing could informational, be programmed but justto go give on or an off at remains with the author(s).