Ethical Record
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
The ISSN 0014-1690 Ethical Record Vol. 95 NO. 7 JULY/AUGUST 1990 Editorial Clearly, in the age of perestroika, Gorbachev and (possibly) Yeltsin, little is PERSPECTIVES ON THE SOVIET to be learnt from those left-wing intellec- UNION AND BRITAIN tuals in the West who cling to inter- pretations of Soviet history which are THE "VIEWPOINTS" SECTION in list now being abandoned by many leading month's edition of The Record was brief Soviet minds. A full appreciation of the but stimulating. S. E. Parker's comments changes currently taking place in the on the history of the Soviet Union in the Soviet Union, and the Eastern bloc in inter-war years, and Julian Ross's cri- general, depends on our being as ready to ticism of the hereditary principle as it reject outmoded orthodoxies as are the relates to the Monarchy and the House of people .who are bringing these changes Lords, imply two very important lines about. of thought From alterations in Soviet society to Parker, writing about Stuart Munro's those in British: Julian Ross's opposition recent talk at South Place on Ralph Fox, to the hereditary principle was expressed rightly criticises the naive view of Stalin in connection with Martin Green's arti- held by Fox and endorsed by Munro. cle "Towards a Republic" in the April This naivety was shared by several of issue of The Record. Ross is certainly Fox's contemporaries, including such right in arguing that Republicanism, eminent figures as the Webbs and H. G. which is antithetical to the hereditary Wells. It is, unfortunately, still found principle in political life, should be part today, despite the adverse comments on of any radical programme in British Stalin which have emerged from within politics. South Place is making a con- the Soviet Union itself (explicitly by tribution in that it has been providing a Khrushchev in 1956, implicitly by Gor- forum for Republican thought; in addi- bachev since 1985) as well as from the tion to Martin Green's talk, we have had detailed analyses of historians in the lectures on Tom Paine and Richard Lee. West Munro's belief in the still-surviving Hopefully, this provision will continue. myth that the Soviet Union rescued A Republican system, if it ever is Europe during World War II is cogently established, will not of course bring - attacked by Parker when he draws atten- Utopie, but it will remove a large amount tion to Stalin's aggression in Eastern of the privilege-based authority which Europe in 1939 (following the non- 'has for so lona gone unquestioned aggression pact with Hitler) and to his in this country. British society is still too refusal to challenge Nazism till the deferential,- still too uncritical of German invasion of 1941. tradition. CONTENTS Page Coming to Conway Hall . 22 The Unsung Heroes of the First Austrian Republic—Gertrude Elias 3 Moliere: The Throne and the Altar-1. Good . 14 Namibia: Aspects of Democracy—Michael Wolfers 16 The views expressed in this journal are not necessarily those of the Society Published by the South Place Ethical Society, Conway Hall, Red Lion Square, London SOUTH PLACE ETHICAL SOCIETY The Humanist Centre, Conway Hall 25 Red Lion Square, London WCIR 4RL. Telephone: 071-831 7723 Hall Lettings: 071-242 8032. Lobby: 071-405 4125 Appointed Lecturers: Harold Blackham. T. F. Evans, Peter Heales, Richard Scorer, Barbara Smoker, Harry Stopes-Roe, Nicolas Walter. Trustees: Christine Bondi, Louise Booker, John Brown. Anthony Chapman, Peter Heales, Don Liversedge, Ray Lovecy, Ian MacKillop. Victor Rose, Barbara Smoker, Harry Stopes-Roe. Honorary Representative: Norman Bacrac. Chairman General Committee: Diane Murray. Deputy Chairman: David Williams. Honorary Registrar: Ann Wood. Honorary Treasurer: Don Liversedge. Secretary: Nicholas Hyman. Hall Manager Geoffrey Austin. Honorary Librarian: Edwina Palmer. Editor, The Ethical Record: Tom Rubens. Concerts Committee Chairman: Lionel Elton. General Committee: The Officers and Jean Bayliss, Cynthia Blezard, Lesley Dawson, Govind N. Deodhekar, Brian Haynes, Ellis Hillman, Martin Harris, Naomi Lewis, Lisa Monks, Terry Mullins, Lydia Vernet, Nicolas Walter. Finance Committee: Chair: Don Liversedge. Development Committee: Convenor: Nicolas Walter. Policy and Programme Committee: Chair: Cynthia Blezard. Bookstall: Chair: Edwina Palmer, Library Committee: Chair: Edwina Palmer. NIETZSCHE SOCIETY FORMED A Nietzsche Society was formed at a one-day Conference on Saturday. April 28 at the University of Essex. To coincide with the conference, a panel discussion on Nietzsche took place at the Joethe Institute, London, on Monday, April 30. Over 100 people have already joined the Society. The registration fee is £2. Those interested in joining should contact: Dr. Keith AnseII-Pearson, Department of Politics, Queen Mary-Westfield College, Mile End Road, London El 4N5 The Ethical Record is posted free to members. The annual charge to Subscribers is £6. Matter for publication should reach the Editor, Tom Rubens, Conway Hall, 25 Red Lion Square, London WC IR 4RL (071-831 7723) no later than the FIRST OF THE MONTH for publication in the following month's issue. 2 Ethical Record. July/August 1990 THE UNSUNG HEROES OF THE FIRST AUSTRIAN REPUBLIC Text of a Lecture given to SPES on November 12, 1989 - by GERTRUDE ELIAS THE FIRST AUSTRIAN REPUBLICwh ich emerged out of the rubble of World War One las- ted only 15 years—from November 12, 1918, when the troops—famished and in rags, returned from the battlefields, until March 1933—when the clerical fascists declared martial law and abolished parliamentary democracy— paving the way for the Nazi occupation of Austria in 1938 It is naive to assume that the West didn't care for what was happening in Central Europe. They cared very much. That's why the Americans had planted their most pro- mising secret agent Allen Dulles, who later became the head of the CIA, into Vienna during the first world war. British television programmes are the very opposite of well-documented informa- tion. Whenever they produce a programme about Austria they concentrate on the days of the Austro-Hungarian monarchy, when the autocratic emperor would wave his white-gloved hand to his loyal subjects, and the waltz king Johann Strauss pretended that the Danube is blue. From these good old days we are taken straight to Hitler's "triumphal march into Vienna", unaltered as they found it in the Nazi film archives, and culminating in the horror of the holocaust, because for reasons of their own, they had made Austria the whipping boy for most Nazi crimes. This unsavoury subject must always be dealt with by a rabbi—though most Vien- nese Jews were uncompromising apostates; the post-Hitler era seems to demand it in this way, and so we have to listen to legends about the unalterable forces of history, which have made the Jews, and the Jews only, carry the cross of persecution since the days when the Almighty had evicted Adam and Eve on a trumped up charge from the Garden of Eden. The Austrian labour movement which had fought heroically against fascism since the 'twenties received little credit from emigre writers in post-war literature. Famous Austrian writers like Stefan Zweig or Franz Werfel expressed no sympathy with the workers who had been fighting in the suburbs of Vienna to stop the onslaught of fascism. The very opposite was the wrathful voice of indignation of Karl Kraus, humanist, pacifist, satirist, the true political conscience of the time. An indefatigable fighter against hypocrisy and corruption, he published his own journal Die Fackel (from 1899 until 1935) in which he wrote everything the papers were trying to hush up. My father was born in Vienna in 1870, and was brought up by his widowed mother, a seamstress by trade who sewed up the elaborate underwear worn by the luscious full- bosomed ladies of the Hapsburg Empire. She was a maniac for cleanliness and her service to humanity was to grab unwashed little street urchins, immerse them in an old barrel which had originally served to hold pickled gherkins, scrub and delouse them, give them a chunk of whatever food she had in the house and send them home. Ethical Record, July/August 1990 3 There were many who regarded her as a saint, but others were outraged when she gave in to her innate radicalism and, without authorisation of the family, cut off little girls' locks, when non-violent means to exterminate the vermin seemed to her inadequate. My father started work at 10.delivering rolls for his uncle's bakery at six every morn- ing before going to school. At 18 after finishing grammar school, he won first prize as Austria's fastest shorthand writer, a feat which landed him a job as a stenographer in Parliament, which enabled him to pay his fees at the University to study law. His work in Parliament wasn't time consuming. Sessions were often suspended for weeks to avoid embarrassing debates about such matters as the shooting of striking workers by the army, which happened not infrequently in the eastern provinces of the monarchy. Leaders of the Social Democratic Party were often kept in prison, particularly when an election was to be held. It was a period of violent class struggles against the autocratic regime, which excluded workers, peasants and the middle class from any influence in government. Only in 1907 was general suffrage won by the people (women were still excluded). In 1914 war broke out, and my father was called up for the army. After messing about reluctantly with rifles and bayonets he was transferred to Bratislava, a small gar- rison town on the Danube, where we joined him. It was in the winter of 1916.