The Economic Importance of Organophosphates in California Agriculture
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
The Economic Importance of Organophosphates in California Agriculture by: Mark Metcalfe*, Bruce McWilliams*, Brent Hueth*, Robert Van Steenwyk**, David Sunding*, and David Zilberman* *Department of Agricultural and Resource Economics **Department of E.S.P.M. Cooperative Extension Entomologist University of California, Berkeley With assistance from: William Chaney, Richard Coviello, Larry Godfrey, Pete Goodell, Elizabeth Grafton-Cardwell, Eric Natwick, Carolyn Pickel, Nick Toscano, Lucia Varela and Frank Zalom University of California Cooperative Extension APPENDIX August, 2002 This study was funded by the California Department of Food and Agriculture. The opinions expressed are those of the authors. Table of Contents APPENDIX A: UC SPECIALIST REPORTS ........................................................................3 INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................................ 3 ALFALFA HAY ............................................................................................................................. 4 Current Pest Management Program ....................................................................................... 6 OP Free – Pest Management Program with Available Technology....................................... 8 OP Free – Pest Management Program with Emerging Technology ...................................... 8 ALMONDS .................................................................................................................................. 16 Current Pest Management Program ..................................................................................... 19 OP Free – Pest Management Program with Available Technology......................................... 21 OP Free – Pest Management Program with Emerging Technology .................................... 24 Addendum ............................................................................................................................. 27 BROCCOLI .................................................................................................................................. 43 Current Pest Management Program ..................................................................................... 46 OP Free – Pest Management Program with Available Technology..................................... 48 OP Free – Pest Management Program with Emerging Technology .................................... 49 Addendum ............................................................................................................................. 50 CARROTS ................................................................................................................................... 63 Current Pest Management Program ..................................................................................... 66 OP Free – Pest Management Program with Available Technology..................................... 67 OP Free – Pest Management Program with Emerging Technology .................................... 68 COTTON ..................................................................................................................................... 75 Current Pest Management Program ..................................................................................... 78 OP Free-Pest Management with Available Technology ....................................................... 80 OP Free – Pest Management Program with Emerging Technology .................................... 81 Addendum ............................................................................................................................. 84 GRAPES ...................................................................................................................................... 97 Current - Pest Management Program ................................................................................ 103 OP Free – Pest Management Program with Available Technology................................... 105 OP Free – Pest Management Program with Emerging Technology .................................. 107 Addendum ........................................................................................................................... 109 LETTUCE (HEAD AND LEAF) .................................................................................................... 119 Current Pest Management Program ................................................................................... 123 OP Free – Pest Management Program with Available Technology................................... 125 OP Free – Pest Management Program with Emerging Technology .................................. 127 Addendum – Lettuce ............................................................................................................ 129 ORANGES ................................................................................................................................. 151 Current Pest Management Program ................................................................................... 156 OP Free – Pest Management Program with Available Technology................................... 157 OP Free – Pest Management Program with Emerging Technology .................................. 159 Addendum ........................................................................................................................... 160 1 PEACHES AND NECTARINES ..................................................................................................... 169 Current Pest Management Program ................................................................................... 173 OP Free – Pest Management Program with Available Technology................................... 175 OP Free – Pest Management Program with Emerging Technology .................................. 176 Addendum ........................................................................................................................... 178 STRAWBERRIES ........................................................................................................................ 187 Current - Pest Management Program ................................................................................ 189 OP Free – Pest Management Program with Available Technology................................... 191 OP Free – Pest Management Program with Emerging Technology .................................. 192 Addendum ........................................................................................................................... 193 TOMATOES (FRESH AND PROCESSED) ...................................................................................... 200 Current Pest Management Program ................................................................................... 205 OP Free – Pest Management Program with Available Technology................................... 209 OP Free – Pest Management Program with Emerging Technology .................................. 212 Addendum ........................................................................................................................... 214 WALNUTS ................................................................................................................................ 227 Current - Pest Management Program ................................................................................ 231 OP Free – Pest Management Program with Available Technology................................... 232 OP Free – Pest Management Program with Emerging Technology .................................. 234 Addendum ........................................................................................................................... 236 APPENDIX B: MATHEMATICAL MODEL .....................................................................249 2 Appendix A: UC Specialist Reports INTRODUCTION Entomologically sound pest management programs are a necessary foundation for an economic analysis of the importance of organophosphate (OP) insecticides to California agriculture. OP free insect pest management programs must be unbiased and constructed with clearly understandable parameters and objectives. The economic analysis in this report relied on OP free insect pest management programs constructed by University of California Cooperative Extension (UCCE) entomologists. UCCE entomologists have intimate knowledge of existing programs while at the same time are knowledgeable of new pest management tools that will become available in the near future. In fact, UCCE entomologists are often in the forefront of the development of new pest management tools. For this analysis, UCCE entomologists developed a “typical” insect pest management program for a commodity or commodities in which they have expertise. The OP free insect pest management programs are constructed for immediate implementation without consideration of the cost of the program or consequence of insecticide resistance. The programs take into account any secondary or occasional pests that may require additional control measures. Also, the UCCE entomologists estimated any increased damage or yield loss above current levels that would result from their OP free insect pest management program. The UCCE entomologists also developed a more ecologically sound OP free insect pest management program using currently available pest management practices and those emerging technologies that are anticipated to be registered within the next