INSIDE: Training for Mobility p. 20 | A New Jet Trainer? p. 34 | The Rise of Special Tactics p. 40
on my own terms MSGT. ISRAEL DEL TORO says “the SOBs” who injured him don’t determine his future.
He does. p. 26
December 2017 $8
Published by the Air Force Association B:8.375” T:8.125” S:7.375” B:11.125” S:10.125” T:10.875”
BOEING JSTARS WHEN THE STAKES ARE HIGH RISK MUST BE LOW
PROVEN IN COMBAT Critical JSTARS systems are flying today on the P-8, AEW&C, and C-40. Aerial refueling, self-defense, battle management, and power systems are integrated from current, combat-proven commercial derivative platforms, ensuring a low-risk program.
PROVEN RELIABILITY The 737 has a 99.7% mission capability rate. Its worldwide base of over 9,000 aircraft ensures that JSTARS will be there when it’s needed.
PROVEN AFFORDABILITY The 737 is proven as the lowest-cost aircraft in the JSTARS competition to own and operate. Built to perform in high-tempo operations, the 737 has 80% less depot time than the competition, and half the total overall operating cost per flight hour.
boeing.com/jstars
Job Number: 10690258 Client/Brand: Boeing/BDS Date: 8-25-2017 4:20 PM APPROVALS File Name: 10690258_BDS_JSTARS_8x10_r3.indd QC: Steve Jablonoski Bleed: 8.375” x 11.125” Gutter: None Publications: AFA Air Space &Cyber Conference PA: Steve Hutchings PR: Pat Owens Trim: 8.125” x 10.875” Folds: NoneNone Guide RET: Greg Olsen PP: Marybeth Oskin Safety: 7.375” x 10.125” Media/Color Sp: PRINT/4 COLOR Notes: None AB: Kathleen Candelaria TM: Kate Vilt/Deanna Loperena Scale: 1=1 Country: None Vendor: None Actual Size: 8.125x10.875 Language: English Output%: None GCD: Eugene Varnado Colors: Cyan, Magenta, Yellow, Black AD: Sarah Frazer Fonts: Helvetica Neue (55 Roman, 75 Bold, 95 Black; Type 1) CW: Chloe Lebamoff AE: Danielle Wilburn/Erin Heiser ALL CONTENT WITHIN THIS FILE IS FOR OUTPUT ONLY BY END PRINTER/VENDOR. CHANGES, SHARING AND/OR DISTRIBUTING CONTENT IN WHOLE OR IN PART ARE STRICTLY PROHIBITED. LICENSING RIGHTS AND APPROVALS MUST BE REQUESTED AND APPROVED TO/BY FCB CHICAGO. Images: 10690258ct01_r1_JSTARS_8x10.tif (305 ppi; CMYK), Boeing_4C_50mm.eps December 2017. Vol. 100, No. 12 FEATURES STAFF Publisher Larry O. Spencer Editor in Chief Adam J. Hebert Managing Editor Juliette Kelsey Chagnon Editorial Director 20 John A. Tirpak News Editor Amy McCullough Deputy Managing Editor Frances McKenney Senior Designer Betsy Moore Pentagon Editor Brian W. Everstine 26 52 Senior Editor Wilson Brissett 18 Out of Africa 31 Commemorating USAF’s 44 Global Reach, Through Digital Platforms Editor By Jennifer Hlad 100-Year Units Tankers Gideon Grudo USAF teams and the Research by Mike Tsukamoto By Wilson Brissett Production Manager Nigerian armed forces led and Daniel L. Haulman Photos from the collection of Eric Chang Lee an aeromedical evacuation A pullout poster Warren Thompson Photo Editor exercise with African partner commemorating USAF units Aerial refueling gives the Air Mike Tsukamoto nations. that can trace their history Force worldwide reach. back 100 years. Media Research Editor 20 Mobility Guardian 52 They Owned the Night Chequita Wood By Brian W. Everstine 34 Heading To a T-X By Rebecca Grant Contributors This was not AMC’s first by John A. Tirpak The P-61 Black Widow Joseph Burke, John T. Correll, rodeo, but it was the biggest. The T-38 is increasingly o ered a glimpse of modern Robert Dudney, Rebecca ill-suited for training 21st nighttime combat. 26 Like a Phoenix Grant, Daniel L. Haulman, century pilots. By Amy McCullough 58 The Neutron Bomb Jennifer Hlad, Warren Israel Del Toro became the 40 The Rise of AFSOC’s Special By John T. Correll Thompson first airman to ever return Tactics It is almost forgotten today, ADVERTISING: from 100 percent disability. By Wilson Brissett but the enhanced radiation Arthur Bartholomew A handful of incredibly skilled warhead was a blazing 213.596.7239 airmen have proved critical in international issue in the 1970s. the war on terror. Tom Buttrick 917.421.9051 DEPARTMENTS James G. Elliott Co., Inc. [email protected] 2 Editorial: Giving Joint 8 Forward Deployed 30 Books Special: Assignments Their Due By Jennifer Hlad CSAF Professional Reading SUBSCRIBE By Adam J. Hebert List. 9 Verbatim Airmen need to be ready for & SAVE 63 Wingman: 7 Steps to “purple” assignments. 10 Aperture Subscribe to Air Force Retaining Members By John A. Tirpak Magazine and save big o 4 Letters By Joseph Burke the cover price, plus get a 12 Screenshot 4 Index to Advertisers 64 Namesakes: Dyess free membership to the Air 14 Air Force World Force Association. 6 Senior Sta Changes Call 1-800-727-3337
FOLLOW US GET THE ON THE COVER MSgt. Israel Del Toro. See “Like a Phoenix,” p. 26. Photo by facebook.com/ twitter.com/ instagram.com/ Christian Murdock/The Gazette. airforcemag airforcemag airforcemag
Air Force Magazine (ISSN 0730-6784) December 2017 (Vol. 100, No. 12) is published monthly, except for two double issues in April/May and October/November, by the Air Force Association, 1501 Lee Highway, Arlington, VA 22209-1198. Phone (703) 247-5800. Periodical postage paid at Arlington, Va., and additional mailing o ices. Membership Rate: $45 per year; $30 e-Membership; $110 for three-year membership. Life Membership (nonrefundable): $600 single payment, $630 extended payments. Subscription Rate: $45 per year; $29 per year additional for postage to foreign addresses (except Canada and Mexico, which are $10 per year additional). Regular issues $8 each. USAF Almanac issue $18 each. Change of address requires four weeks’ notice. Please include mailing label. POSTMASTER: Send changes of address to Air Force Association, 1501 Lee Highway, Arlington, VA 22209-1198. Publisher assumes no responsibility for unsolicited material. Trademark registered by Air Force Association. Copyright 2017 by Air Force Association.
DECEMBER ★ AIRFORCEMAG.COM Editorial By Adam J. Hebert, Editor in Chief
Giving Joint Assignments Their Due
t is a truism to say the Air Force will not go to war alone. In rebuilding the service’s JTF capabilities. Maj. Gen. Scott J. Zo - all realistic scenarios, USAF will battle alongside Army, Navy, brist, 9th Air Force commander, is working to organize, train, Iand Marine Corps forces. In war zones and on deployments, equip, and certify forces. a joint environment is the norm. In a little over a year, 9th Air Force should have a team “ready Organizationally, however, the Air Force sometimes operates to command and control a JTF or joint operation,” he said in an as if the “purple” world were a mysterious parallel universe. interview, and “handle any mission that is given to us.” In the worst-case scenarios, airmen aren’t educated about or “This is another arrow in the quiver of the joint force,” Zobrist trained for their joint assignments, the service is unprepared said. “Given the importance air operations have played in all to lead multiservice teams, USAF doesn’t know what to do of the operations over the last 20 years, it’s helpful for the US with its joint experience, and airpower winds up marginalized. military leadership … to have a variety of organizational spe - The Air Force is moving to fix this. Gen. David L. Goldfein, cialties and backgrounds do command and control.” Chief of Staff, has made “strengthening joint leaders and teams” The goal is for planners to say, “Ninth Air Force: I know them, one of his three primary focus areas. This includes rebuilding they participated in all these exercises, they’re really good at USAF’s ability to lead joint task forces (JTFs). what they do, they bring this unique capability. … We’re going “If you look around the globe today you can see upwards of to pick them,” Zobrist explained. 20 JTFs, … more if you count the combined joint task forces,” Running parallel with the JTF effort are several personnel Goldfein noted at AFA’s Air, Space & Cyber Conference in management needs. USAF needs airmen ready for joint work September. at every stage of their careers; personnel trained for these USAF typically does not lead these task forces. The Army, assignments; and to reward them with logical follow-on as - which has built JTF leadership into its organization, does. signments and promotions. This leaves the National Command Authority with limited options when a crisis erupts. “Historically, JTFs stand up within Airmen need to be ready for “purple” days or weeks of a crisis with little fanfare or warning,” Gold - fein noted in a 2016 paper on joint leadership. “While intended assignments. to exist only for the duration of the crisis, they often become enduring.” For example, the Air Force should educate airmen on joint When the Army is the entity certified to lead a US response, language and processes beginning in basic training, continuing well, the Army is going to lead the task force. Often this makes throughout their careers, said Maj. Gen. Brian M. Killough, di - sense, but what if an emergency requires an airpower-inten - rector of strategic plans on the Air Staff and head of Goldfein’s sive response? The Army will lead that, too. The Army keeps joint leaders task force. elements of its 82nd Airborne Division prepared to lead JTFs The Air Force’s culture and organizational stovepipes can and is regularly called upon for that purpose. penalize airmen who serve in purple assignments. “In the Goldfein has tasked 9th Air Force at Shaw AFB, S.C., with past, there have been airmen who have gone out into these joint assignments, and their core function has ‘forgotten about them’ or they have been disadvantaged when they came back,” Killough explained in an interview. USAF will begin tracking joint duty more closely and plan - ning lead-in training and follow-on assignments more carefully. Some joint assignments will even be considered equivalent to command positions at promotion time. Goldfein “considers that joint assignment to be such a high priority that he has dedicated one of his top three efforts [to making sure] we train, educate, develop, reward folks” for those assignments, Killough explained. “This is a growth field.” USAF has successful processes in place to prepare general officers for joint leadership positions. Majors and tech sergeants up for a joint posting in Djibouti or South Korea need to know the Air Force will have them ready for the deployment and that such a move will be good for their careers. The Chief has pledged to push this issue for all four years he Airmen and soldiers work together in a command post is in office, which is good because it takes time for a culture shift during an exercise to learn joint task force headquarters to sink in. The Air Force needs to stick with this and strengthen
functions. joint leaders for the long haul. Army Alford/US SSgt.Photo: Matthew
DECEMBER ★ AIRFORCEMAG.COM B:8.375” T:8.125” S:7”
USE THE CREDIT CARD THAT SUPPORTS THE AIR FORCE ASSOCIATION. B:11.125” T:10.875” S:10”
USAA Bank is proud to offer members ways to support organizations like the Air Force Association. You can also benefit from great rewards, competitive rates and USAA’s legendary customer service. Plus, now you can extend your support by redeeming your rewards points for a donation to the Air Force Association.
APPLY TODAY. usaa.com/afavisa or 877-618-2473
USAA means United Services Automobile Association and its affiliates. USAA products are available only in those jurisdictions where USAA is authorized to sell them. Use of the term “member” or “membership” refers to membership in USAA Membership Services and does not convey any legal or ownership rights in USAA. Restrictions apply and are subject to change. The Air Force Association receives financial support from USAA for this sponsorship. This credit card program is issued by USAA Savings Bank, Member FDIC. © 2017 USAA. 233320-0717
This advertisement prepared by Saatchi & Saatchi REVIEW FOR CONTENT ONLY, NOT COLOR. Client: USAA Space: None Creative Director: None Print Production Contact: Product: None Size: 8.1125”x10.875” Copy Writer: None N/A Campaign: None Pubs: Conference Program Art Director: N/A Art Buyer Contact: Job #: 233320-0717 Issue: None Traffic: N/A John/Chris Publication Note: Guideline for general identification only. Do not use as insertion order.
Filename: 233320-0717 AFM BANK AFA Visa 2017.07 AD_01.indd Legal Creative Director Client Location: PDG_Saatchi & Saatchi:USAA:BANKING [007386]:CREDIT CARD:Print:233320-0717 AFM BANK AFA Visa 2017.07DO NOTBleed: 8.375” PRINT x 11.125” Proofreader Art Director Traffic Created: 5-19-2017 11:03 AM Artist: Freelance Studio #: N/A Trim: 8.125” x 10.875” Print Production Account Supervisor Type Director Revised: 5-19-2017 11:03 AM Artist: N/A Spellchecked: No Safety: 7” x 10” Copy Writer Account Executive QC.1 QC.2 Collected: None Artist: N/A Mech Scale: None Round #: 1.1 Flagged Words:None Letters
But What About ... ? USAF 70th shame Mssrs. Tirpak and Tsukamoto “the first (and only) USAF double-sonic We were never more certain that we’d did not include them. Those of us who bomber” made me pause. The FB-111 get bags of mail than when we assembled were in the Air Force during the late Aardvark has often gotten short shrift our “United States Air Force: 70 Years in ’50s and ’60s were and are still very in print. It also was a double-sonic Pictures” feature, September, p. 32. Space proud to have served and kept the bomber as well as the first operational restrictions compelled us to approach this peace during the Cold War. A lot of ink variable geometry wing bomber, pre- pictorial dierently, and not try to illustrate was granted to the Atlas rocket and ceding the B-1. every significant person or system. With ICBM program, but it was the fleets Col. Steve Fish, exactly one image per year there was no of bombers and tankers surrounding USAF (Ret.) way to present a picture of everything im- the Soviet Union that formed the ma - Albuquerque, N.M. portant in Air Force history. We gritted our jor deterrent, especially early in that teeth knowing full well we had no F-100s period. I hope in some future issue The “F” at the beginning of the FB-111’s or B-47s—or Bomarcs or Hound Dogs, or you will honor the crews that flew and designation will forever stoke confusion Hap Arnold or Steve Ritchie. Even 10 pic- maintained these aircraft by publishing and debate—THEEDITORS tures per year would have left things out, an article about their contributions. and, paradoxically, the “omissions” would James O. Gundlach I believe you missed one of the iconic feel more egregious and insulting the big- New Orleans pictures of Air Force lore: the airdrop ger the feature became. We touched on as and subsequent firing of a Minuteman many communities and events as possi- I was glad to see “United States Air missile from a C-5A aircraft in August ble, knowing we could never be compre- Force: 70 Years in Pictures,” but I was 1974. hensive. It was gratifying, though, that so dumbfounded to discover neither word The test program that sprang from many read the article so closely and that nor picture of the B-47 Stratojet. With ideas put forth by Henry Kissing - it stimulated so much discussion. Looking over 2,000 manufactured, it first flew er combined two unique Air Force back at the world’s greatest air force’s in 1947 and provided the core of SAC’s capabilities, intercontinental ballistic achievements over the past 70 years, we deterrent mission through the 1950s missiles and heavy airlift. look forward to finding out what we will and much of the 1960s. Dick Keen be able to add for our 2087 edition.—THE As a visual force, ... it was recognized Big Timber, Mont. EDITORS internationally as we maintained B-47s on continuous alert in locations such First, congratulations on a superb I am disappointedly shocked that not as Spain, Morocco, and England, as September 2017 edition of Air Force one picture of the F-100, the world’s well as Alaska and Guam. Magazine. The 70-year highlights of first supersonic operational fighter, Col. Neil C. Ray, the Air Force are arguably some of the was included! USAF (Ret.) more interesting aspects of our history. Col. James F. Wolff, Montgomery, Ohio I noted a couple of errors as follows: USAF (Ret.) 1. The B-36 had six 4360 cu. in. recips Niceville, Fla. For the year 1947 you could also and four turbojets rather than six have [mentioned]: SAC is currently turboprops. 2. There were 100 B-1s As a former member of SAC’S 310th exploring the entire Arctic with a newly produced, not 104. There were four Bomb Wing, stationed at Schilling AFB, developed grid system of navigation B-1As produced prior to program can- Salina, Kan., I am sorely disappointed and/or [that] a Lt. [Frank O. Klein] in cellation, so that is likely the source of by your omission of the B-47 and KC- SAC’s first operational unit, in an un - confusion. 97. There were many SAC wings flying assigned project, determined that the Lastly, I am a bit surprised that the these magnificent aircraft, and it’s a north magnetic pole, which had not B-2A was not listed as a seminal event moved in over 100 years on Boothia in our history. Though the program was WRITE TO US Peninsula, had in his study moved more than 150 miles to a precise position on Do you have a comment about a current Prince of Wales Island in the Canadian INDEX TO ADVERTIZERS article in the magazine? Write to “Letters,” archipelago. This new position was Air Force Magazine, 1501 Lee Highway, confirmed three months later by a AT&T ...... 17 Arlington, VA 22209-1198 or email us at Canadian ground expedition. (This was Bradford ...... 39 [email protected]. Letters should be concise also reported on Wikipedia.) Boeing ...... Cover II and timely. We cannot acknowledge receipt Col. Frank O. Klein, Mercer...... Cover III of letters. We reserve the right to condense USAF (Ret.) Northrop Grumman ...... Cover IV letters. Letters without name and city/base Sierra Vista, Ariz. USAA ...... 3 and state are not acceptable. Photographs cannot be used or returned. I enjoyed flipping through this histor- Aerospace Education Programs...... 17 —The Editors ical montage of Air Force history. The AFA’s 70 for 70...... 50-51 1960 shot of the B-58 describing it as Go Green ...... 57 DECEMBER ★ WWW.AIRFORCEMAG.COM truncated, the 21 aircraft (now 20) hold mander pulled up in his staff car and first female fighter pilot. This pride at risk every target in the world. What offered him a ride to work one hot and of place on the front cover of your could be more defining of our United humid south Florida morning. magazine puzzles me. Are we now to States Air Force? Col. Bill Malec, believe that the most important event Again, thanks and congrats on a USAF (Ret.) of the last 70 years is the feminization terrific historical vignette! O’Fallon, Ill. of the force? Lt. Col. Richard J. Rose, Pictures are worth a thousand words. USAF (Ret.) I really enjoyed reading your article Col. Mike Sexton, Ocala, Fla. “United States Air Force: 70 Years in USAF (Ret.) Pictures.” However, I was very disap - Albuquerque, N.M. Great issue! Much appreciated by pointed that you failed to include two both Air Force pilots in our family. of the aircraft that were major contrib - We neither said nor implied that “the I noticed on p. 33, under the caption utors to the USAF effort in Vietnam. feminization of the force” was the most for the 1949 B-36, “six turnin’ and four The F-100 flew more combat sorties important event of the last 70 years. Brig. burnin’ ” an error that described those than any other aircraft, and the F-105 Gen. Jeannie Leavitt is, however, one of magnificent P&W 4360 radials as tur- carried the vast majority of ordnance the very few pictured airmen who is still boprops. Had they been, there might delivered by fighter aircraft into the serving, and that influenced our selection never have been a requirement to add heavily defended North. for the cover.—THEEDITORS those gas hungry turbojets to get it off Lt. Col. John W. “Jack” Redmond, the ground. Still, any airplane that has a USAF (Ret.) “Long Time Coming” letters lauded wingspan in excess of the length of the Las Vegas recent attempts to get a handle on the first Wright brothers’ flight brings huge Air Force mission, which a lot of us like smiles about my memories of lying on Cover Issues to call, “Don’t make us come down there” my back in my yard, as a five-year-old, Just a comment regarding your front [“Letters,” September, p. 6]. But the rest watching them fly overhead. cover, September 2017. I think the of the 70th anniversary issue leaves me My wife still laments not being per - “centerfold” should have been a Medal wondering. mitted to have a fighter, though she of Honor winner: A1C John Levitow. The cover looks like there will be a served on the first all-women’s flight Talking about firsts, he was [for years] centerfold section. I know that Second crew at McGuire AFB [N.J.]. I appre - the lowest ranking enlisted troop to Lieutenant Flynn was the first female ciated the acknowledgment that the be awarded the MOH. Being a former selected for fighter pilot training and B-707 and the C-135 were significantly loadmaster, I was disappointed he was that she is standing on the wrong side different airplanes. Flew both. SAM only provided a postage size photo—on to climb into that T-38, but is that the 26000 is a significant draw to visitors at the bottom corner of the cover. central message for the Air Force for the the NMUSAF, and the B-707-300 series CMSgt. Paul A. Castanedo, past 70 years? remains my all-time favorite airplane USAF (Ret.) The [article] says you can’t select the after 46 years of making a living flying Redlands, Calif. “most important “ from any given year, airplanes. but you will illustrate “accomplishments.” Don Brown Airman Levitow appeared for 1969, on That’s fine, but you seem to forget the Air Cincinnati p. 36, in addition to the cover.—THEEDITORS Force warriors in favor of social engineer- ing. You lost interest in the Korea conflict As an Air Force veteran of over 40 The cover of your September issue after two years. There were no F-105s, years on Active Duty, I “lived” many of worries me. F-100s, EB-66s, etc., or any mention of the events highlighted in your photo In 70 years of existence that has pilot Vietnam Medals of Honor during collage. resulted in achievements that no oth- the late 1960s, speed records, launch of That said, the photo of Capt. James er air force can match, you chose to the C-5, and women in ROTC, and the “Jabby” Jabara is the one that really highlight a social first for your 70th Air Force ride to the moon in the early caught my eye and reminded me of anniversary cover: the first woman 1970s. Oh, and then after 1,000 planes got my older brother. Joe enlisted in the fighter pilot. The problem is it’s a dis - shot down in Vietnam, the POWs finally Air Force in 1965 and served under tinction, not an achievement. Worse, it came home in 1973 when airpower was Colonel Jabara when he was the 31st symbolizes that which is most wrong finally used as it should have been in 1967. Tactical Fighter Wing commander at with today’s military: the blurring of Air Force Magazine can be whatever it Homestead AFB, Fla. operational focus by sensitivity issue wants to be. It seem to me it is straying Colonel Jabara had many amazing myopia. further from being a voice for airpower. accomplishments in a career cut short Cmdr. Robert L. Gore, John Conway by his tragic death, along with his USN (Ret.) Jackson, N.J. 16-year-old daughter, in a car crash Texarkana, Texas in November 1966. What my brother My first thought when I saw the cover remembered most was not that Jabara Your September issue of Air Force of the September issue was to imme - was the youngest colonel in the Air Magazine, celebrating the 70th anni- diately cancel my AFA membership, Force at the time, the first American versary of the United States Air Force, which I’ve been enjoying for 36 years. ace in the Korean War, or his 16.5 has on the magazine cover a collage I realize that Air Force Magazine, like enemy aircraft kills across two wars. of photos showing famous and heroic all other professional publications that What my brother Joe always raved men and events surrounding a larger wish to stay in business these days, about was the time that the wing com - photo in the center of the Air Force’s must comply with America’s laws of
DECEMBER ★ WWW.AIRFORCEMAG.COM [email protected]
political correctness. But your selec - more appropriate, especially since the Air Force Association tion of the Air Force’s first female pilot pic of the service’s first lady pilot also 1501 Lee Highway • Arlington, VA 22209-1198 as the centerpiece of this cover’s 70th appears in the main photo spread. anniversary photo collage is taking a My blood pressure went down a afa.org bad thing way too far. This is espe - bit as I thumbed through the related Telephone: 703.247.5800 cially disturbing because two real Air photos inside. I was expecting to see Toll-free: 800.727.3337 Force heroes who also appear on the even more laws of political correctness Fax: 703.247.5853 cover—Chuck Yeager and James Jaba- pictures there, but I must admit that ra—are relegated to the sidelines along the ones you selected do an excellent AFA’s Mission with the lesser-knowns. Why couldn’t job of depicting USAF’s evolution over Our mission is to promote a dominant one of those well known and highly the past seven decades—and without United States Air Force and a strong respected icons have been tapped any PC. national defense and to honor airmen and for the center spot? Even better, why I do wonder, though, why some other our Air Force heritage. not USAF’s first Chief of Staff, Gen. Air Force greats weren’t included—for Carl “Tooey” Spaatz? Any of these instance: the Air Force’s only five-star To accomplish this, we: legendary officers would have been general (“Hap” Arnold); Korean War ■ Educate the public on the critical need for unmatched aerospace power and a technically superior workforce to ensure SENIOR STAFF CHANGES US national security. RETIREMENTS: Maj. Gen. Scott A. Vander Hamm, Maj. Gen. Tommy J. Williams. Brig. Gen. ■ Advocate for aerospace power John A. Cherrey, Brig. Gen. Steven D. Garland, Brig. Gen. Daniel J. Orcutt. and STEM education. NOMINATIONS: To be Lieutenant General: Jacqueline D. Van Ovost. ■ Support the Total Air Force family and promote aerospace education. To be ANG Brigadier General: Jeery D. Aebischer, Shawn N. Bratton, Jerey L. Butler, Contacts Michael E. Callahan, Kevin J. Campbell, Thomas S. Cauthen, Lawrence L. Christensen, Shawn A. Clouthier, Darwin L. Craig, Robert C. Desko, Kevin M. Donovan, Bobbi J. Doorenbos, David CyberPatriot .... [email protected] M. Dziobkowski, Randal K. Eerson, Howard L. Eissler III, Nathan B. Alholinna, Shawn D. Field Services ...... [email protected] Ford, Jed J. French, Daniel E. Gabrielli, Mark P. Gaul, Rainer G. Gomez, Patrick M. Guinee, Government Relations ...... [email protected] Penny D. Hodges-Goetz, Jeremy C. Horn, Cassandra D. Howard, Paul D. Johnson, Boris R. Insurance ...... [email protected] Armstrong, Edward S. Jones, Gary W. Kirk, Heidi L. Kjos, Meaghan Q. LeClerc, Gregor J. Membership...... [email protected] Leist, Suzanne B. Lipcaman, Keith G. MacDonald, Rolf E. Mammen, Gerald E. McDonald, News [email protected] Christopher G. McGraw, Kimberly A. Baumann, Michael R. Morgan, Rebecca L. O’Connor, Duke A. Pirak, Jerey L. Ryan, Jon S. Safstrom, William L. Sparrow, James R. Stevenson, Magazine Jerey D. Storey, Brian J. Te, Edward L. Vaughan IV, Robert L. Bell, April D. Vogel, Charles [email protected] M. Walker, Christopher S. Walker, David A. Weishaar, Wendy B. Wenke, Gregory T. White, Editorial Oices ...... [email protected] Brent W. Wright, William T. Yates, Daniel S. Yenchesky. Letters to Editor [email protected] Wingman ...... [email protected] CHANGES: Brig. Gen. Paul E. Bauman, from Dep. Dir., Future Jt. Force Dev., Jt. Sta, Suolk, Change of Address/Email Va., to Sr. Defense Oicial & Attaché-Pakistan, US Embassy, Islamabad, Pakistan … Brig. Gen. Lance R. Bunch, from Principal Mil. Asst. to SECDEF, OSD, Pentagon, to Dir. CJ35, Future Ops., In an eort to stay connected with AFA and your local chapter, please update your Resolute Spt., CENTCOM, Kabul, Afghanistan … Maj. Gen. Thomas W. Geary, from Asst. DCS, mailing and email addresses. Change of ISR, USAF, Pentagon, to Mil. Dep. to the Dir., DIA, Washington, DC … Brig. Gen. Joel D. Jackson, address requires four weeks’ notice. from Sr. Spec. Asst. to the Cmdr., EUCOM, Mons, Belgium, to Spec. Asst. to the Cmdr., AMC, Scott AFB, Ill. … Brig. Gen. Michael G. Koscheski, from Chief, Strategy Planning Integration To update your contact information: Div., DCS, Strat. Plans, Prgms., & Rqmts., Pentagon, to Dir., Air Crew Crisis Task Force, DCS, ■ Email: [email protected] Ops., USAF, Pentagon … Maj. Gen. Robert D. Labrutta, from Cmdr., 2nd AF, AETC, Keesler AFB, Miss., to Dir., Mil. Force Mgmt. Policy, DCS, Manpower, Personnel, & Svcs., USAF, Pentagon … ■ Visit: The Members Only area Maj. Gen. Timothy J. Leahy, from Cmdr., Curtis E. LeMay Center for Doctrine Dev. & Education, of our website, afa.org to Cmdr., 2nd AF, AETC, Keesler AFB, Miss. … Maj. Gen. Michael D. Rothstein, from Dep. Asst. ■ Call: Our Membership Department Secy. for Plans, Prgms., & Ops., Bureau of Political-Mil. Aairs, Department of State, Washington, at 1-800-727-3337 D.C., to Cmdr., Curtis E. LeMay Center for Doctrine Dev. & Education, Maxwell AFB, Ala. … Maj. Gen. Stephen N. Whiting, from Dir., Integrated Air, Space, & Cyberspace and ISR Ops., ■ Mail your magazine label, including your AFSPC, Peterson AFB, Colo., to Cmdr., 14th AF, AFSPC, Vandenberg AFB, Calif. first and last name, to our Membership Department at 1501 Lee Highway, SENIOR EXECUTIVE SERVICE CHANGES: William S. Castle, to Principal Dep. General Arlington, VA 22209-1198. Counsel, DOD, Pentagon … Colin F. Jackson, to Dep. Asst. SECDEF for Afghanistan, Pakistan, & Central Asia, DOD, Pentagon. DECEMBER ★ WWW.AIRFORCEMAG.COM [email protected] ace-of-aces Capt. Joseph C. McConnell; and/or Desert U S P o s t al S er v ic e S t at em ent o f Ow ner s h ip , Managem ent , and Cir c u l at io n Storm air boss Gen. Chuck Horner. I know photo space 1. P u bl i ca t i o n T i t l e: A i r F o rce M a g a z i n e 2. P u bl i ca t i o n N u mber: 073 0- 6 78 4 was limited, but surely room could have been found 3 . F i l i n g Da t e: O ct . 20, 2017 for one or more of these major figures, even if it meant 4 . I s s u e F req u en cy : M o n t h l y , ex cep t f o r t w o d o u bl e i s s u es , A p ri l /M a y a n d leaving out a few relatively unknown troops. Despite O ct o ber/N o v ember those omissions, I commend Air Force Magazine for your 5 . N o . o f I s s u es P u bl i s h ed A n n u a l l y : 10 well researched, politically benign main photo spread. 6 . A n n u a l S u bs cri p t i o n P ri ce: $ 4 5 . 00 7. Complete Mailing Address of Known Office of Publication (not printer): I may even continue my AFA membership now, on the 15 01 L ee H i g h w a y , A rl i n g t o n , V A 22209 - 119 8 . C o n t a ct P ers o n : E ri c C h a n g L ee. chance that your cover was just a random LPC blip in T el ep h o n e: 703 - 24 7- 5 8 4 9 an otherwise superb magazine. Perhaps we can call it 8. Complete Mailing Address of Headquarters or General Business Office of Publisher (not printer): 1501 Lee Highway, Arlington, VA 22209-1198 an unrealistic, but necessary, sign of our modern times. 9 . F u l l N a mes a n d C o mp l et e M a i l i n g A d d res s es o f P u bl i s h er, E d i t o r, a n d MSgt. James B. Walker, M anaging E ditor: USAF (Ret.) P u bl i s h er: L a rry O . S p en cer, 15 01 L ee H i g h w a y , A rl i n g t o n , V A 22209 - 119 8 ; Dayton, Ohio E d i t o r: A d a m J . H ebert , 15 01 L ee H i g h w a y , A rl i n g t o n , V A 22209 - 119 8 ; M a n a g i n g E d i t o r: J u l i et t e K el s ey , 15 01 L ee H i g h w a y , A rl i n g t o n , V A 22209 - 119 8 No Surprise There 10. O w n er: A i r F o rce A s s o ci a t i o n , 15 01 L ee H i g h w a y , A rl i n g t o n , V A 22209 - 119 8 The Minot Bent Spear incident wasn’t particularly surpris- 11. K n o w n B o n d h o l d ers , M o rt g a g ees , a n d O t h er S ecu ri t y H o l d ers O w n i n g ing when it occurred in 2007 [“Minot’s Bent Spear,” August, o r H o l d i n g 1 P ercen t o r M o re o f T o t a l A mo u n t o f B o n d s , M o rt g a g es , o r O t h er S ecu ri t i es : N o n e p. 35]. Some of us who were members of ACC (Provisional) 12. Tax Status (For completion by nonprofit organizations authorized to expected something similar much sooner. As a member mail at nonprofit rates): Has not changed during preceding 12 months of ACC (Provisional) tasked in 1992 with coordinating 13 . P u bl i ca t i o n T i t l e: A i r F o rce M a g a z i n e merging of dierent SAC and TAC directorates within the 15 . Ex t ent and N at u r e o f Cir c u l at io n Av er age N o . N o . Co p ies o f M o n th ly Jo u rn a l o f th e A ir F o rce A sso cia tio n Co p ies Eac h S ingl e Is s u e new command, we were also tasked to identify overlap of Is s u e D u r ing P u b l is h ed command regulations. A subsequent eort was made at Air P r ec ed ing 1 2 N eares t to Force direction to reduce the number of pages of regula- Mo nt h s Fil ing D at e a. Total Number of Copies (net press run) 8 4 , 020 8 3 , 8 4 0 tions. Admittedly, the combined stack of all the SAC and b. Paid Circulation (by mail and outside the TAC manuals, regulations, and supplements were indeed a mail) formidable pile of paper. However, like aircraft tech orders (1) Mailed outside-county paid subscriptions stated on PS Form 3541 (include paid distri- adding warnings, cautions, and notes as the aircraft and bu t i o n a bo v e n o mi n a l ra t e, a d v ert i s er’ s p ro o f learning curve matures, there were a lot of hard lessons copies, and exchange copies) 75 , 4 4 0 73 , 8 9 0 (2) Mailed in-county paid subscriptions stated learned in those regulations. on PS Form 3541 (include paid distribution As we went through this process, a few of us former a bo v e n o mi n a l ra t e, a d v ert i s er’ s p ro o f co p i es , SAC aircrew types frequently met, comparing notes and and exchange copies) 0 0 (3) Paid distribution outside the mails discussing the potential outcomes with the direction of i n cl u d i n g s a l es t h ro u g h d ea l ers a n d ca rri ers , the old SAC regs. Several of us concluded we needed to s t reet v en d o rs , co u n t er s a l es , a n d o t h er p a i d keep copies in a desk drawer because “we’re going to need d i s t ri bu t i o n o u t s i d e U S P S 6 5 6 6 12 (4) Paid distribution by other classes of mail these again someday.” through the USPS (e.g., first-class mail) 0 0 Furthermore, we thought a few babies were thrown out c. Total Paid Distribution [sum of 15b (1), (2), (3), (4)] 76 , 09 6 74 , 5 02 with the bathwater as we witnessed the diminishing bomber d. Free or Nominal Rate Distribution (by mail force nuclear role. Little did we know it would take until and outside the mail) 2007 for the implications to manifest themselves. Perhaps (1) Free or nominal rate outside-county cop- i es i n cl u d ed o n P S F o rm 3 5 4 1 11 11 enough corporate memory was resident and prevented (2) Free or nominal rate in-county copies such an incident happening sooner. i n cl u d ed o n P S F o rm 3 5 4 1 0 0 When the heads began to roll, I could only think of my (3) Free or nominal rate copies mailed at other classes through the USPS (e.g., first-class mail) 4 8 5 0 time in SAC and the whispered reminder, “To err is human, (4) Free or nominal rate distribution outside to forgive is not SAC policy.” the mail (carriers or other means) 117 117 e. T o t a l F ree o r N o mi n a l R a t e Di s t ri bu t i o n Col. Francis Gibbons, [sum of 15d (1), (2), (3), (4)] 176 178 USAF (Ret.) f. Total Distribution [sum of 15c and 15e] 76 , 272 74 , 6 8 0 Royse City, Texas g . C o p i es N o t Di s t ri bu t ed 7, 74 8 9 , 16 0 h. Total [sum of 15f and g] 8 4 , 020 8 3 , 8 4 0 i. Percent Paid [15c / 15f x 100] 9 9 . 77% 9 9 . 76 % Blue Suit PR 16 . E lectro n ic C o p y C ircu la tio n Regarding letters in Air Force Magazine’s September a . P a i d el ect ro n i c co p i es 0 0 b. Total paid print copies (15c) + paid elec- issue [p. 6] about your editorial “Silent Leadership—At tronic copies (16a) 76 , 09 6 74 , 5 02 a Cost” [July, p. 4]. c. Total print distribution (15f) + paid electron- ic copies (16a) 76 , 272 74 , 6 8 0 Perhaps one reason for the Air Force’s poor public d. Percent paid (both print & electronic cop- profile is the lack of blue-suiters in the White House. ies)(16b / 16c x 100) 9 9 . 77% 9 9 . 76 % President Trump’s chief of staff and defense secretary are 17. P u bl i ca t i o n o f S t a t emen t o f O w n ers h i p retired Marine generals, and his national security advisor I f t h e p u bl i ca t i o n i s a g en era l p u bl i ca t i o n , p u bl i ca t i o n o f t h i s s t a t emen t i s req u i red . W i l l be p ri n t ed i n t h e December 2017 i s s u e o f t h i s p u bl i ca t i o n . is a retired Army general. His former strategic advisor 18 . S i g n a t u re a n d T i t l e o f E d i t o r, P u bl i s h er, B u s i n es s M a n a g er, o r O w n - was an ex-Navy officer. But no one from the Air Force er: Eric Chang Lee (signed), Production Manager. Date: Oct. 20, 2017 works closely to him. Can we change this situation? To I cert i f y t h a t a l l i n f o rma t i o n f u rn i s h ed o n t h i s f o rm i s t ru e a n d co mp l et e. I quote an old real estate adage, “Location is everything.” u n d ers t a n d t h a t a n y o n e w h o f u rn i s h es f a l s e o r mi s l ea d i n g i n f o rma t i o n o n t h i s f o rm o r w h o o mi t s ma t eri a l o r i n f o rma t i o n req u es t ed o n t h e f o rm ma y be Richard Reif subject to criminal sanctions (including fines and imprisonment) and/or civil Flushing, N.Y. sanctions (including civil penalties).
DECEMBER ★ WWW.AIRFORCEMAG.COM Forward Deployed By Jennifer Hlad
AL DHAFRA AB, UNITED ARAB EMIRATES£
ON THE FARM
Operation Inherent Resolve uses a lot of fuel. Not just for the fighter jets dropping bombs on ISIS, but for the aircraft gathering intelligence, surveillance, and reconnaissance, for the generators powering the air-conditioning units cooling the bases, and for all the trucks and other vehicles transporting troops on the ground. About eight million gallons of that fuel is stored here, the largest fuel bladder farm in the Department of Defense. The farm—made up of more than 20 giant dirt pits holding enormous tan bags of fuel—processes roughly 500,000 gallons each day. The fuel bladders range from 50,000 to 210,000 gallons and are checked daily for cuts or leaks. SrA. Dustin Hicks, a fuels lab technician with the 380th Expe- An F-22 refuels from a KC-10 during a mission for Operation ditionary Logistics Readiness Squadron, said his primary focus Inherent Resolve. The fuel came from the farm. is quality assurance. [and] needs the gas, whether it’s an emergency or whether it’s planned,” Sullivan said. The capabilities make it obvious why the KC-10 is called the Extender. “We are able to extend the sortie duration for multiple air- frames, so they can provide cover to troops on the ground, ... can collect intelligence and do reconnaissance missions, [and] ... they can take o and land out of places that are safer, rather than having them be in-country,” Sullivan said. Lieutenant Colonel Shell, commander of the 27th Expedi- A giant fuel bladder at the farm, Al Dhafra AB, United Arab tionary Fighter Squadron, said the squadron’s F-22s “could not Emirates. accomplish” their Operation Inherent Reserve mission without refueling from KC-10s and the KC-135s based elsewhere in the “We just want to make sure these planes have the best fuel,” region. (The Air Force does not release the full names of fighter he said. pilots deployed downrange.) The aircraft fuel is moved to the flight line using a con- “Not possible,” Shell said. stant-pressure hydrant system, which is much faster and more The fuel also powers the base generators, which serve as a eicient than using trucks, said A1C Austin Coe. The equipment backup in case of power loss. In addition to computers and other they use mimics permanent infrastructure in a deployed envi- equipment that rely on power, air-conditioning is “mission critical” ronment, he added. during the sweltering summer months, said Col. Dee Jay Katzer, The fuel keeps the base humming and feeds the aircraft based commander of the 380th Expeditionary Mission Support Group. here, but it also goes to a variety of other American and coalition “We could live without air-conditioning,” he said, noting that “it partner aircraft via midair refueling. would be painful,” but many aircraft maintenance functions can “The fuels airman is not just refueling the KC-10,” explained only be performed at certain temperatures, and the space suit Col. Mark S. Robinson, vice commander of the 380th Air Ex- U-2 pilots wear while flying has to be kept cool, too. peditionary Wing. “It’s not just putting gas in a truck, the truck If the air-conditioning fails in those locations, Katzer said, “that drives to the KC-10, we put gas in the KC-10, and it comes back. mission doesn’t go.” That singular drop of fuel could end up in a number of dierent And even AC in lodging can be mission critical from a crew platforms, flying in a number of dierent locations, and ending rest standpoint, he said. up in a number of dierent coalition jets.” “If it’s 90 degrees in your room, you’re not getting a good A quarter of the Air Force’s KC-10 fleet is based here, and night’s sleep, and now you’re flying a nine-hour mission, 10-hour though the aircraft has more pallet positions than a C-17, the mission, it doesn’t work,” Katzer explained. bulk of what they do is midair refueling, said Capt. Rebecca It’s no wonder the HVAC airmen were, according to operations Sullivan, a KC-10 pilot. superintendent MSgt. Dan Salazar, the busiest of the eight trades As she prepared for an eight-hour flight repeatedly refueling this summer. a pair of F-22s over Iraq, Sullivan explained that the KC-10 has Cooling is also necessary for storing the liquid oxygen that a boom and drogue and can be refueled itself, if necessary. It high-altitude pilots breathe—it’s kept “very, very cold” in special carries around 250,000 pounds of fuel, and some of the planes tanks made so the gas will not boil o into the atmosphere, said also have wing air refueling pods, enabling them to refuel two SSgt. Jason Wood, who works on the storage crew. aircraft at once. “It allows us to have a lot of flexibility in theater, and essen- Jennifer Hlad is a freelance journalist based in the Middle East and a
tially refuel [any] ... of our coalition partners that’s out there former Air Force Magazine senior editor. Photos: Jennifer Hlad
DECEMBER ★ WWW.AIRFORCEMAG.COM Verbatim [email protected] By Robert S. Dudney
Attention-Getter here. They’ve got us.”—Then-White House nuclear weapons and for its groundbreaking “On a nominal basis, you don’t have aide Steve Bannon, remarks to The eorts to achieve a treaty-based prohibition more than single digits of B-2s available American Prospect, Aug. 16. of such weapons. We live in a world where to do anything [immediately]. ... The US Air the risk of nuclear weapons being used is Force is the smallest and least ready it’s ever It Could Happen greater than it has been for a long time. been in history. That should get people’s “We have many military options, and Some states are modernizing their nuclear attention.”—Retired USAF Lt. Gen. David the President wanted a briefing on each arsenals, and there is a real danger that Deptula, militarytimes.com, Aug. 12. of them. ... We are not looking to the total more countries will try to procure nuclear annihilation of a country—namely, North weapons, as exemplified by North Korea. Playing Catchup Korea—but, as I said, we have many op - Nuclear weapons pose a constant threat “[The Air Force] is modernizing across tions to do so.”—Secretary of Defense to humanity and all life on Earth. ... An in- the board. It’s an unusual situation—that James N. Mattis, White House press ternational legal prohibition will not in itself we have so much modernization going on briefing, Sept. 3. eliminate a single nuclear weapon, and ... in the Air Force at one time. ... The Air Force so far neither the states that already have has not been modernizing at the pace that Cherry on Top nuclear weapons nor their closest allies it needs to in order to meet the threat of the “There will be a war with North Korea support the nuclear weapon ban treaty. future and our adversaries are modernizing. over the missile program if they continue to The committee wishes to emphasize that They’re innovating faster than we are, and try to hit America with an ICBM. ... There IS the next steps towards attaining a world if we’re going to be able to protect our vital a military option: ... to destroy North Korea’s free of nuclear weapons must involve the national interest, we need to get beyond the [missile] program and North Korea itself. ... nuclear armed states.”—The Norwegian caps in the Budget Control Act.”—Secretary I prefer the diplomatic approach, but they Nobel Committee, press release, Oct. 6. of the Air Force Heather Wilson, remarks will not be allowed to have a missile to hit at Whiteman AFB, Mo., Sept. 5. America with a nuclear weapon on top.”— Hmmmmmmmmmmmmmm ... Sen. Lindsay Graham (R-S.C.), NBC’s “[Machine intelligence] algorithms will From Russia With Love “Today” program, Aug. 1. be evolved in synthetic, simulated envi- “Artificial intelligence is the future—not ronments and then deployed in the real only for Russia but for all humankind. ... Annals of Diplomacy world. When an inferior foe can field highly Whoever becomes the leader in this sphere “The Kellogg-Briand Pact [which aimed skilled ‘pilots’ that never tire, don’t need will become the ruler of the world.”—Rus- to outlaw war] does not get bad press. It training, and exhibit none of the biological sian President Vladimir Putin, speech to gets no press. That’s because the treaty constraints of a human pilot, what becomes students as reported by Russian news went into eect on July 24, 1929, after which of [the US] training-enabled advantage?” service RT.com, Sept. 1. the following occurred: Japan invaded Amir Husain, author of “The Sentient Manchuria (1931). Italy invaded Ethiopia Machine,” fifthdomain.com, Aug. 7. The Commitment (1935). Japan invaded China (1937). Ger- “While we never asked for this fight [in many invaded Poland (1939). The Soviet Bears in the Woods Afghanistan], we are steadfastly committed Union invaded Finland (1939). Germany “As long as we’re going faster than [rival to seeing it through, and with no more tem- invaded Denmark, Norway, Belgium, the nations] behind us, I don’t want to think porizing. ... We Americans are not made of Netherlands, Luxembourg, and France and about how we fend them o. I just want to cotton candy. We are not seaweed drifting attacked Great Britain (1940). And Japan at- go faster than they can keep up. If there’s in the current. We are not intimidated by tacked the United States (1941), culminating a bear in the woods, you just have to be our enemies, and ... your military does not in a global war that produced the atomic faster than the slowest person.”—Dawn C. scare.”—Secretary of Defense James N. bomb and more than 60 million deaths. Meyerriecks, CIA chief of science and Mattis, 9/11 memorial speech, Sept. 11. A piece of paper signed in Paris does not technology, remarks in Washington, seem to have presented an obstacle to D.C., Sept. 6. Check, Please citizens of one country engaging in the “[The US must] make sure that Kim Jong organized slaughter of the citizens of other In America, Dogs Have It Better Un knows that, if he acts in an aggressive countries.”—From Louis Menand, “What “In North Korea, I lived a dog’s life. Ain’t fashion, the price will be extinction.”—Sen. Happens When You Outlaw War?” in The nobody live good in North Korea. Nothing John McCain (R-Ariz.), CNN’s “State of New Yorker, Sept. 18. to eat. No running water. No electricity. the Union,” Sept. 10. In the wintertime, you freeze. In my Annals of Diplomacy II bedroom, the walls were covered in ice. That’s the Spirit “The Norwegian Nobel Committee has ... You can’t bring your neighbor over for “There’s no military solution [to the North decided to award the Nobel Peace Prize a drink. Why? People start drinking, they Korean threat]. Forget it. Until somebody ... for 2017 to the International Campaign start talking. People disappear.”—Charles shows me that 10 million people in Seoul to Abolish Nuclear Weapons (ICAN). The Robert Jenkins, US Army deserter who don’t die in the first 30 minutes from con- organization is receiving the award for its spent the period 1965-2004 in North ventional weapons, I don’t know what you’re work to draw attention to the catastrophic Korea, interview with military.com, talking about. There’s no military solution humanitarian consequences of any use of Aug. 16.
DECEMBER ★ WWW.AIRFORCEMAG.COM Aperture By John A. Tirpak, Editorial Director
Congress, too, seems more intent on micromanaging the force, the former Chiefs agreed. McPeak, Chief from 1990 to 1994, said he also lived in “a simpler world,” because although he had to deal with a massive post-Cold War drawdown, which took the service from a $110 billion budget to below $70 billion (in roughly 1991 dollars), he had free reign to reorganize it in a way “that made sense.” When it was over—the merging of Tactical and Strategic Air Commands, for example, and a broad reduction in the size of the force of about 30 percent—the Air Force was “smaller and poorer ... but tougher.” Desert Storm was fought on McPeak’s watch, and it was about the most “high intensity” conventional war that could be fought at the time, he said. In that conflict, “we lost an airman about every two days,” he pointed out, which at the time was considered an almost absurdly low rate of losses. Since then— across almost 27 years of nonstop combat—“we lose about one airplane every four years.” That record of success “doesn’t hap - pen by accident,” he said. It happens because “serious people thought a lot about what our real purposes are” as a service and structured the force to focus on those core competencies. He said it was important during the big drawdown to let the troops who were staying in uniform know that “there was a Gen. Merrill McPeak (right), then Chief of Sta, observes future” in the Air Force, and the leadership would do all it could operations beside flight engineer TSgt. Michael Deroggi in to provide them some stability. 1993. McPeak and other former Chiefs were panelists at the 2017 Air, Space & Cyber Conference. CHAIN OF CUSTODY CHIEF CONCERNS Fogleman, Chief from 1994 to 1997, advised younger members No question, the job of Air Force Chief of Staff is tougher now of the audience that it’s pointless to set a goal of becoming than 30 years ago, but the key to doing it right is to focus on Chief—Fogleman noted that getting the job owes as much to the force you’re leaving your successor, former Chiefs advised luck as to good preparation—but urged them to seek out jobs at AFA’s Air, Space & Cyber Conference in September. and experiences outside their comfort zones that will broaden A rare assemblage of former top uniformed leaders of the ser- their knowledge and make them more valuable to the service. vice since the 1980s, including retired generals Larry D. Welch, Even jobs he felt unprepared for and frankly didn’t want, Fogle - Merrill A. McPeak, Ronald R. Fogleman, Michael E. Ryan, and man said—he was a career fighter pilot suddenly in charge of Norton A. Schwartz, offered perspectives in a panel discussion mobility as a four-star—made him a better officer. titled “Leading an Air Force.” They talked about how the job has The late 1990s brought the big surprise, Ryan said. Although evolved since their tour in the top spot and gave suggestions on the “reliable enemy” in the form of the Soviet Union was gone, a how USAF can navigate around some of its thornier problems. multiplicity of brush fire wars in the Balkans and elsewhere put Welch, who led the service from 1986 to 1990—toward the the much-smaller Air Force on a too-busy operating tempo. Ryan end of the Cold War to the eve of Operation Desert Shield— opted to emphasize readiness over modernization at that time said he had it “pretty good” as Chief, because the threat was because of the constant fighting and because “you have to keep well-understood, the Air Force was well-valued by the other the force ready. It’s unconscionable to send a force that isn’t.” services, and “we had the luxury of focusing” on issues the Ryan created the air and space expeditionary force in an uniformed leaders thought were most important. During his attempt to give airmen some predictability about their lives watch, Welch said, there were no major conflicts or surprises and to more fairly spread the duty of constant deployments. like the Cuban Missile Crisis. Schwartz took over the Chief job from Gen. T. Michael Importantly, when it came to portioning out funds for readiness, Moseley, who along with Secretary Michael W. Wynne, was people, and modernization, “we got to choose” where to put em- sacked by Defense Secretary Robert Gates in 2008. Schwartz phasis, and budgets came along regularly and predictably, Welch said simply that he came to the job “most unexpectedly” and observed. During his tour, the Air Force bought the bulk of the had to deal with a force where “confidence in our leaders was force it still flies today, in the form of F-15s, F-16s, and B-1Bs. He not as high” as it should be. Schwartz said rebuilding USAF’s oered the sitting Chief, Gen. David L. Goldfein, his sympathies for credibility was one aspect of his tenure, and sometimes that dealing with the chronic unpredictability of continuing resolutions meant keeping quiet and letting the Air Force’s achievements instead of budgets and a seemingly nonstop demand for combat “speak for themselves.” forces beyond what the service can provide. Schwartz asserted that the nature of deterrence is chang -
DECEMBER ★ AIRFORCEMAG.COM ing, as an increasing number of new states develop nuclear Ryan said he’d get back to Warner later, a response that angered weapons of their own. It may be necessary to introduce or the Senator, who yelled that Ryan “shouldn’t be the Chief” if he reintroduce new theater nuclear weapons, particularly in the didn’t have such answers immediately at hand. And Warner, Ryan Pacific, because of unsteady powers like North Korea that may pointed out, was a family friend. not be deterred with the existing arsenal, Schwartz said. Moreover, It’s crucial to “have that intel on Congress,” Ryan said. “If you mutual assured destruction is not a viable strategy in dealing with don’t, you’re liable to step in quicksand.” such powers, so missile defense, at least in limited form, “is now Welch observed that in his time, the three services were in- a strategic priority.” dividually labeled by Capitol Hill staers as “dumb, defiant, and Systems must be expanded for “eectively defending against a deceptive,” and “the feeling over there” on Capitol Hill “was that determined—but not necessarily massive—first strike,” Schwartz we were the ones who were ‘deceptive.’ ” asserted. He advised USAF to find out what Air Force issue was most important to each member of Congress and make sure that issue was addressed in all dealings with that member, toward finding POLITICS, GENERALLY SPEAKING common ground. One Colorado congressman, he recalled, fought every hardware program but was a ready ally “on every people The panel members were asked if they believe it’s wrong for program.” retired generals like themselves to get involved with politics, as that The Air Force should treat its political capital like a bank account, became a sore spot in the 2016 presidential election. Welch said Schwartz said. “You make deposits, you make withdrawals,” and that while it’s “wrong for me,” he wouldn’t say it’s wrong for others. the former should always outnumber the latter. McPeak confessed feeling that his two forays into poli - Finally, the former Chiefs were asked to suggest how the tics—supporting the presidential bid of former Republican disparate activities of the Air Force can be summed up in three Sen. Bob Dole (Kan.) in 1996 and later as a supporter/advisor letters—CBG (carrier battle group) or MEB (marine expeditionary to the campaign of President Barack Obama, a Democrat, in brigade)—or on a bumper sticker, because the other services 2008—were “a mistake.” seem to be successful distilling their activities in such a way and He signed on with Dole because he knew him and believed in winning support for their programs. him, while he supported and advised Obama because McPeak was “I don’t know how to reduce that to a slogan,” Welch said. The “angry” about George W. Bush’s invasion of Iraq. McPeak said it was Air Force, he said, fights “in three domains and is essential to based on “false claims” that Iraq had weapons of mass destruction. every kind of fight.” Since then he’s “isolated” himself politically, but noted one good Fogleman, too, said such a summary is diicult. Many airmen, outcome of his political involvement: Obama appointed him to head he observed, “don’t know what we do. ... We have to remind them the American Battle Monuments Commission, which had never why we exist.” They also need to know “the role they play” in the before been led by an airman. That job has allowed him to get the grand scheme. US to take responsibility for some American cemeteries overseas, Schwartz, borrowing a slogan USAF used in 2013, answered as well as the Lafayette Escadrille Memorial in France, which had simply, “Vigilance, Reach, Power.” fallen into serious disrepair and has now been rehabilitated. The former Army or Marine Corps oicers preceding him at the ABMC wanted “nothing to do” with those projects, he said. As to his involvement in politics, Fogleman said, “I was never asked, so it was an easy decision,” to laughter and applause. Ryan said without elaboration that he thinks it’s a bad idea to mix the military and politics. Schwartz said “it’s a personal call” for each general’s conscience, but warned that there’s grave danger of allowing an impression that decisions made about the force by serving oicers “might be tainted” by political considerations. That, he said, would be “awful for the republic.”
UP THE HILL TO CARRY WATER
The Chiefs were asked what—if anything—can be done to improve the relationship between the service and Congress—a relationship that has clearly become strained in recent years. Fogleman said the trick is for the Secretary to deal with Congress. “Let the Secretary do most of the heavy lifting” in this regard, he said, because doing so allows the Chief to focus on the tough-enough job of manning, training, and equipping and staying above the political fray. He added that “Secretary 24”—Heather A. Wilson—“has to go work on that,” rebuild confidence in the service, and run interference for her generals. Ryan said it’s essential that the Air Force have a well run and plugged-in legislative liaison oice, keeping its ear out for issues SrA. Amanda Butch, 332nd Expeditionary Maintenance that some members of Congress care deeply about. In one hearing, Squadron, accounts for munitions in Southwest Asia. Ryan said, Sen. John Warner (R-Va.) peppered him with questions Air and space expeditionary forces were created to give
about what it would cost to add six more B-2s to the 20-plane fleet. deploying airmen something resembling predictability. Archives;Photos: Damon Kasberg National SrA. DOD via
DECEMBER ★ AIRFORCEMAG.COM SCREENSHOT
OCTOBER/NOVEMBER ★ WWW.AIRFORCEMAG.COM 10.12.2017
An F-22 Raptor takes o at RAF Lakenheath, UK. F-22s and airmen deployed there to conduct training with other European-based US aircraft and NATO allies. Photo: SrA Malcolm Mayfield Malcolm SrA Photo: Photo:
OCTOBER/NOVEMBER ★ WWW.AIRFORCEMAG.COM Air Force World By Wilson Brissett, Senior Editor