Journal of Asia-Pacific Biodiversity 7 (2014) e1ee5

Contents lists available at ScienceDirect

Journal of Asia-Pacific Biodiversity

journal homepage: http://www.elsevier.com/journals/journal-of-asia-pacific- biodiversity/2287-884x

Original article The remarkable endemism of at White Sands National Monument in New Mexico, USA, with special emphasis on Gelechioidea ()

Eric H. Metzler a,b,c,* a Department of Entomology, Michigan State University, East Lansing, MI 48824, USA b Department of Entomology, USNM Natural History, Washington, DC 20013-7012, USA c Museum of Southwestern Biology, University of New Mexico, Albuquerque, NM 87131, USA article info abstract

Article history: The white sands formation, a snow-white gypsum dunes system, is the world’s largest gypsum dune Received 17 January 2014 field. White Sands National Monument protects about 40% of the dunes; the dunes formation as it is Received in revised form known today was formed ca. 8,000 years BP. Prior to 8,000 years BP, the area covered by the dunes was a 12 February 2014 wet cool forest of the last glacial maximum in North America. The dunes were formed as a result of the Accepted 13 February 2014 hypsithermal, a warming and drying period which followed the most recent glacial maximum. The white Available online 12 March 2014 sands formation is located in south central New Mexico in the Tularosa Basin of southwestern United States. A 10-year study of moths at the dunes was commissioned by the U. S. National Park Service in Keywords: Island biogeography 2006. Almost immediately species new to science were detected. In the period of 6 years, 30 new species Galapagos of North America were discovered in the dunes. Several of the new species are white or very pale in color, and are endemic Gypsum dunes to the dunes. The focus of the 10 year project was modified to emphasize naming the undescribed species Evolution which helps the National Park Service catalog and manage the habitats. The data should encourage other researchers to explore the interactions of the with the plants and the harsh desert environment, to study DNA and evolution, and to study the rapid adaptation which seems to be occurring. Copyright Ó 2014, National Science Museum of Korea (NSMK) and Korea National Arboretum (KNA). Production and hosting by ELSEVIER. All rights reserved.

Introduction maximum in North America. The dunes were formed as a result of the hypsithermal, a warming and drying period which followed the The white sands formation is a snow-white gypsum dunes most recent glacial maximum. The White Sands formation is system which covers 744.6 sq km (Figure 1). It is the world’s largest located in south central New Mexico in the Tularosa Basin of gypsum dune field. White Sands National Monument, encom- southwestern United States. passing the southern portion, protects about 40% of the dunes; the The dunes were created from dissolved gypsum selenite crystals remaining 60% is under the jurisdiction of the White Sands Missile in large playas (Figure 1.) at the southwestern boundary of the dune Range administered by the U. S. Army. The dunes as they are known field. As water evaporates gypsum crystallizes out of solution and today were formed ca. 8,000 years BP. Prior to 8,000 years BP, the forms on the dry surface of the playa. As the crystals disintegrate area covered by the dunes was a wet cool forest of the last glacial sand-sized crystals are formed. Winds, predominately from the southwest, blow the crystals from the dry lake bed onto the dune field. The dunes can be as high as 10 m. Plants and soils are suc- cessively covered and uncovered (Figure 2) as the blowing sand moves the ridge crests from the southwest to the northeast as much as 9 m per year (McKee and Moiola, 1975). Plants respond to the harsh conditions of shifting pure gypsum soils in several ways. They add stem length rapidly to accommodate * þ Tel.: 1 575 443 6250. encroaching dunes, they extend lateral root systems, and they make E-mail address: [email protected]. Peer review under responsibility of National Science Museum of Korea (NSMK) and dense root clusters to hold the sand in place as dunes advance Korea National Arboretum (KNA). across the landscape. Common examples of these plants’ http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.japb.2014.02.001 2287-884X/Copyright Ó 2014, National Science Museum of Korea (NSMK) and Korea National Arboretum (KNA). Production and hosting by ELSEVIER. All rights reserved. e2 EH Metzler / Journal of Asia-Pacific Biodiversity 7 (2014) e1ee5

when found in the field. The New Mexico gypsum flora is often dominated by Tiquilia hispidissima (Torr. & Gray) A. Richards (Bor- aginaceae), Sporobolus nealleyi Vasey (Poaceae), Bouteloua breviseta Vasey (Poaceae), Nerisyrenia linearifolia (S. Watson) Greene (Bras- sicaceae), and Calylophus hartwegii filifolius (Eastw.) Towner & Ra- ven (Onagraceae). Other common, but less abundant, species include Anulocaulis gypsogenus Waterfall (Nyctaginaceae), Selino- carpus lanceolatus Woot. (Nyctaginaceae), Nama carnosum (Woot.) C.L. Hitchc. (Hydrophyllaceae), Dicranocarpus parviflorus Gray (Asteraceae), and Centaurium maryannum B.L. Turner (Gentiana- ceae) (Sivinski, 1994). At first glance much of the gypsum dunes may appear bleak and devoid of life (Figure 3), but a closer look reveals 30 species and seven subspecies of animals that are endemic to the white sands. These taxa are specifically adapted to life in the white dunes by their permanent white color, or apparent lack of color. These are Holbrookia maculata ruthveni Smith, 1943 (Squamata), Sceloporus undulatus cowlesi Lowe and Norris, 1956 (Squamata), Cnemidophrus inornatus gypsi Wright and Lowe, 1993 (Squamata), Perognathus flavescens apache Merriam, 1889 (Rodentia), Neotoma nicropus leucophaea Baird, 1855 (Rodentia), Ammobaenites phrixocnemoides arenicolus (Strohecker, 1947) (Orthoptera), Daihinoides hastiferum larvale (Strohecker, 1947) (Orthoptera), Euxoa lafontainei Metzler and Forbes, 2009a (), Schinia poguei Metzler and Forbes, 2011b (Noctuidae), and Protogygia whitesandsensis Metzler and Forbes, 2009b (Noctuidae). Some species are variable in color, but individuals collected on the white substrate at the Monument are pale, when compared to nearby populations that do not live in the Figure 1. Satellite view of the white sands formation in the Tularosa Basin, Otero Co., dunes. These animals are Spermophilus spilosoma Bennett, 1833 New Mexico, USA. The dark blue represents playas with water. The playas are inter- (Rodentia), Cibolecris parviceps arida (Bruner, 1889) (Orthoptera), mittently flooded depending on local rainfall. (For interpretation of the references to color in this figure legend, the reader is referred to the web version of this article.) Phrynosoma cornutum (Harlan, 1825) (Squamata) (Kain, 2000), Eucosma columbiana (Walsingham, 1879) (Tortricidae), Copa- blepharon serratigrande Lafontaine, 2004 (Noctuidae), and Euxoa pleuritica (Grote, 1876) (Noctuidae). adaptations at the Monument are Yucca elata Engelm. (Agavaceae), Prior to this study there was a dearth of research on the inver- Rhus trilobata Nutt. (Anacardiaceae), Poliomintha incana (Torr.) Gray tebrate fauna in the gypsum dune field in the Tularosa Basin of New (Lamiaceae), and Populus fremontii var. wislizenii Wats. (Salicaceae). Mexico. Highlights of previous research at White Sands National There are several common gypsophilous plants which are very Monument pertinent to were Stroud (1950) who listed 452 faithful to gypsum habitats and will always indicate gypseous soils species of insects and Strohecker (1947) who described 2 species of camel crickets endemic in the gypsum dunes.

Materials and methods

In 2006 the U. S. National Park Service invited me to conduct a long term (ten year) study of the Lepidoptera at White Sands

Figure 2. Dune ridge in White Sands National Monument with typical plant life on the shifting dunes. The dominant plants in this photograph are (1) Rhus trilobata Nutt. (Anacardiaceae), (2) Poliomintha incana (Torr.) Gray (Lamiaceae), and (3) Yucca elata Engelm. (Agavaceae). Figure 3. Open snow-white gypsum dunes in White Sands National Monument. EH Metzler / Journal of Asia-Pacific Biodiversity 7 (2014) e1ee5 e3

National Monument. The Monument encompasses the southern 40% of the white sands formation. The northern 60% is under the control of the U. S. Army. A transect three km long and approximately 300 m wide was established along the south east edge of the dunes within the Monument. Eleven sample sites were selected in four habitat types; open dunes with no vegetation (Figrue 1), interdunal habitat (Figure 2), edge-of-dunes where the dunes abruptly end, and open basin desert habitat (Figure 4). Because vegetation types are markedly different in many of the interdunal habitats, more than one interdunal habitat was selected. Adult moths were collected monthly in bucket-type black-light traps (Figure 5). All moths were sorted to species, identified, and counted. Representatives of each species were mounted on pins, and the wings were spread for permanent storage in research collections. Lepidopteran immatures were collected alive on food plants and reared in laboratory conditions. Representative larvae were preserved in 95% ethanol. Individual rear legs were removed from some pinned adults and z submitted to the Barcode of Life Data System (BOLD) laboratory at Figure 5. The contents of one bucket-type black-light trap. The volume of moths 1 liter. The yellow object is a moistened sponge that is used because of the very low the Biodiversity Institute of Ontario, University of Guelph in humidity (15%) in the desert. (For interpretation of the references to color in this figure Guelph, Ontario, Canada. The resulting “Neighbour Joining Tree” legend, the reader is referred to the web version of this article.) cladograms were used to help delineate species and define some species. Adults were prepared for identification by dissection, mounting genital structures on microscope slides, and photography of adults Results and genital parts. Adults were photographed with a Nikon model D200 camera mounted on a bellows with a Micro-NIKKOR 105 mm The first few samples from the study sites contained several 1:2.8 macro lens. Illumination was provided by an Aristo DA-10 species of moths new to science. Based on my experience studying lightbox manufactured by Aristogrid. Adults were dissected with Noctuidae, I immediately recognized Protogygia whitesandsensis, the aid of a Wild model M5 stereomicroscope, and the genital parts Euxoa lafontainei, and Schinia poguei as new to science. Reassur- were slide mounted following protocols outlined in Hardwick ingly, as predicted by Kain (2000), but not surprisingly, many of the (1950), Pogue (2002), Lafontaine (2004), and Metzler et al. undescribed species are white or very pale in color. (2009). Genital parts were stained with Chlorazol Black and At the end of the first 5 years of the study, ca. 600 species of Safranin O, and mounted on slides in Euparal. Photographs of mi- moths were recorded. Of these, most of the 30 species new to sci- croscope genitalia slides were made with a Nikon model D200 ence are endemic to the white sands formation. Thus the rate of camera mounted on the photo tube of a Zeiss Lumipan Universal endemism is approximately 5%, a figure which seems very high Research Microscope using a Leitz 1x plan objective and bright field considering the relative short time devoted to the study and the transmitted light. Photographs were processed with Microsoft very small study area (The transect is 3 km 100 m.) in the dunes Windows versions of Zerene Stacker and Adobe Photoshop CS6 system. software. In response to the high number of undescribed species, the study was revised by the National Park Service to concentrate on documenting and describing the new species. Seven new species were described Metzler et al. (2009), Metzler and Forbes (2011a, 2011b, 2012), and two papers describing Gelechioidea (Metzler and Lightfoot, in press)(Figure 6)(Metzler, in press)(Figure 7) will be published in 2014. Manuscripts are in preparation for the description of several other species. Primary types were deposited in the Smithsonian Institution in Washington, DC or the Museum of Southwestern Biology, at the University of New Mexico, Albuquerque, NM. All other specimens were deposited in the Museum of Southwestern Biology; the Albert J. Cook Research Collection, Depart- ment of Entomology, Michigan State University; the Arthropod Museum, New Mexico State University; and the McGuire Center for Lepidoptera and Biodiversity, Florida Museum of Natural History. All non-lepidopteran insects (by-catch) were placed in 95% ethanol and deposited at the Museum of Southwestern Biology. Because of the unusual physical and biological qualities of the New Mexico white gypsum dunes, I was especially aware of the possibility of finding undescribed species of moths. The results exceed my expectations. In 1950 Stroud reported 20 species of Lepidoptera from the Monument. In the period 9 February 2007 fi Figure 4. Open basin desert vegetation. The edge of the dunes can be seen on the left through 31 December 2012 I identi ed more than 600 species of of the photograph. Lepidoptera (unpublished data) from the Monument. The study of e4 EH Metzler / Journal of Asia-Pacific Biodiversity 7 (2014) e1ee5

Figure 6. A mated pair of Areniscythris new species () in copula on the surface of the open sand at 0900. The paper to describe this species is in press (Metzler & Lightfoot).

Lepidoptera at White Sands National Monument is projected to last approximately 10 years. Thirty undescribed species of moths in seven families, including Gelechiidae, Coleophoridae, and Scythrididae, were identified. Most specimens of Gelechioidea have yet to be examined by geni- Figure 8. Two undescribed species of Coleophora from White Sands National Monu- ment. These species will be described by Jean-François Landry. talic preparation. Jean-François Landry identified two new species of Coleophora (Figure 8) to be described by him. One new species of Dichomeris (Figure 9) is represented by a single male, and it will be dunes have a different diet than caterpillars eating the same plant described when additional specimens are collected. One species of species outside the dunes. Chionodes, nearly devoid of color (Figure 10), is in manuscript. More Future research on Lepidoptera should attempt to capture Gelechioidea, most are white or very pale in color (Figure 11), gravid females to obtain ova for rearing on plants from within and remain to be diagnosed.

Discussion

The data indicate that the white sands formation is home to more endemic species of Lepidoptera than any other single habitat of similar size in North America. The rate of endemism appears to be about 5%. Numerous species of moths from several families have adults with whitish or paler phenotypes within the dunes. New research (unpublished data) shows the same species of plants in the dunes and outside the dunes have different chemical signatures and different microbes. These results mean that caterpillars in the

Figure 9. Dichomeris new species from White Sands National Monument.

Figure 7. Chionodes new species (Metzler, 2014) from White Sands National Monument. Figure 10. White Chionodes new species from White Sands National Monument. EH Metzler / Journal of Asia-Pacific Biodiversity 7 (2014) e1ee5 e5

Grote AR. 1876. Check List of the Noctuidae of America, North of Mexico, pt 2. Buffalo, NY: Reinecke & Zesch. 50 pp. Hardwick DF. 1950. Preparation of slide mounts of lepidopterous genitalia. The Canadian Entomologist 82:231e235. Harlan R. 1825. Description eof two new species of Agama. Journal of the Academy of Natural Sciences of Philadelphia 4:296e304. Kain SM. 2000. White animals at White Sands. In: An introduction to White Sands National Monument and the Tularosa Basin employee and volunteer orientation handbook. Otero County, NM: White Sands National Monument pp. 48-1e48-18. Lafontaine JD. 2004. The moths of North America including Greenland, fascicle 27.1, Noctuoidea Noctuidae (part). (part Agrotini). Washington, DC: The Wedge Entomological Research Foundation. 385 pp. Lowe CH, Norris KS. 1956. A subspecies of the lizard Sceloporus undulatus from the White Sands of New Mexico. Herpetologica 12:125e127. McKee ED, Moiola RJ. 1975. Geometry and growth of the White Sands Dune field, New Mexico. United States Geological Survey Journal of Research 3:59e66. Metzler EH. in press. The Lepidoptera of White Sands National Monument 7: A new species of Chionodes Hübner, [1825] (Gelechiidae, Gelechiinae) dedicated to Ronald W. Hodges and Elaine R. Snyder Hodges in the year of Ron’s80th birthday, 2014. The Journal of The Lepidopterist’ Society. Metzler EH, Bustos D, Forbes GS. 2009. The Lepidoptera of White Sands National fi Figure 11. Unidenti ed pale yellow Gelechioidea from White Sands National Monu- Monument, Otero County, New Mexico, USA 1. Two new species of Noctuidae fi ment. (For interpretation of the references to color in this gure legend, the reader is (Lepidoptera, Noctuinae, Agrotini). ZooKeys 9:47e62. referred to the web version of this article.) Metzler EH, Forbes GS. 2009a. Euxoa lafontainei Metzler & Forbes, sp. n. In The Lepidoptera of White Sands National Monument, Otero County, New Mexico, USA 1. Two new species of Noctuidae (Lepidoptera, Noctuinae, Agrotini). Zoo- outside the dunes. Attempts should be made to locate larvae on Keys 9:47e62. their natural host plants in the dune field. Metzler EH, Forbes GS. 2009b. Protogygia whitesandsensis Metzler & Forbes, sp. n. In The Lepidoptera occurring in the white sands formation in The Lepidoptera of White Sands National Monument, Otero County, New Mexico, USA 1. Two new species of Noctuidae (Lepidoptera, Noctuinae, Agro- southern New Mexico, provide a rare opportunity to study adap- tini). ZooKeys 9:47e62. tation and evolution in an island habitat that is not surrounded by Metzler EH, Forbes GS. 2011a. The Lepidoptera of White Sands National Monument, water. Otero County, New Mexico, USA 3. A new species of Aleptina Dyar 1902 (Lepi- doptera: Noctuidae: Anphipyrinae, Psaphidini). In: Schmidt BC, Lafontaine JD, editors. Contributions to the systematics of New World macro-moths III, ZooKeys Acknowledgments 149. pp. 125e133. Metzler EH, Forbes GS. 2011b. The Lepidoptera of White Sands National Monument, The following Gelechioidea specialists magnanimously lent Otero County, New Mexico, USA 4. A new species of Schinia Hübner, 1818 (Lepi- doptera: Noctuidae: Heliothinae). In: Schmidt BC, Lafontaine JD, editors. Contri- their time and expertise to help me; Jean-François Landry, David butions to the systematics of New World macro-moths III, ZooKeys 149. pp.135e144. Adamski, Sangmi Lee, and Ronald W. Hodges. Other specialists Metzler EH, Forbes GS. 2012. The Lepidoptera of White Sands National Monument determined, described or offered assistance to me in working 5: Two new species cochylini (Lepidoptera, Tortricidae, Tortricinae). Zootaxa 3444:51e60. on other families; J. Donald Lafontaine, B. Christian Schmidt, Metzler EH, Lightfoot DC. in press. The Lepidoptera of White Sands National Donald J. Wright, Michael G. Pogue, Donald R. Davis, James S. Monument, Otero County, New Mexico, USA 6. A new species of the Miller,JohnW.Brown,RichardS.Peigler,RichardL.Brown,and Areniscythris (Scythrididae), a recently discovered iconic species from the Monument. The Journal of The Lepidopterist' Society Charles V. Covell, Jr. Special thanks goes to David Bustos, Natural Pogue MG. 2002. A world revision of the genus Spodoptera Guenée (Lepidoptera: Resources Protection Manager at White Sands National Monu- Noctuidae). Memoires of the Americn Entomological Society 43:1e202. ment for permitting and helping with my research, and The Sivinski RC. 1994. Flora Neomexicana: Gypsophilous plants. Native Plant Soc New Mexico Newslett 19:1e3. Western National Parks Association (Grant Reference # 08-17(1)) Smith HM. 1943. The White Sands earless lizard,InZoological series, 24. Field for funding some of my travel in the first three years of the Museum of Natural History. p. 342. study. Richard L. Brown and Sangmi Lee provided useful com- Strohecker HF. 1947. Some southwestern Gryllacrididae. Ann Entomol Soc Am 40: 241e246. ments on earlier drafts of the manuscript. Stroud CP. 1950. A survey of the insects of White Sands National Monument, Tularosa Basin, New Mexico. Am Midland Natural 44:659e677. References Walsingham TdG. 1879. Illustrations of typical specimens of Lepidoptera heterocera in the collection of The British Museum. Part IV. - North-American Tortricidae. London England: British Museum of Natural History. 84 pp. Bennett ET. 1833. Characters of new species of mammalia from California. Pro- Wright JW, Lowe CH. 1993. Synopsis of the subspecies of the little striped whiptail ceedings of the Zoological Society of London 1833:39e42. lizard, Cnemidophorus inornatus Baird. Journal of the Arizona-Nevada Academy of Bruner L. 1889. New North American Acrididae found north of the Mexican border. Science 27:129e157. Proceedings of the U.S. National. Museum 12:47e82.